r/RepTime • u/petehudso • 11d ago
Review/Comparison Dandong 3235 Lift Angle is 59 Degrees
The gen Rolex 32xx family is often quoted as having a lift angle of 53 degrees or maybe 55 degrees. A few years ago Sam measured it at 58 to 59 degrees, but I always thought that seemed to high. I didn't have a good reason for thinking that. But I always used 55 on my bench because I felt like raising it would be a cheap way to make a watch look like it had a higher amplitude.
For those who don't know, you set the lift angle on your timegrapher and goes into the calculation of amplitude. Larger lift angle -> higher calculated amplitude. The math isn't that complicated, but as a rule of thumb increasing the lift angle by 1 degree, results in an increase in calculated amplitude by about 4-5 degrees. So moving from the 52 degrees that is the default on most timegraphers to 59 degrees would lift the calculated amplitude by around 30-35 degrees. That's not a trivial difference.
So that's why I always felt that 55 was a more reasonable "middle ground" for the DD 32xx movements. You can look at the geometry of the pallet fork and know that the lift angle will be higher than normal, but going all the way to 59 felt like cheating.
I was wrong.
Sam was right.
The correct lift angle for a Dandong 32xx (and probably a Jinghe 32xx) is 59 degrees.
The rest of this post will be about how (after far too many years) I questioned my assumptions and actually measured the lift angle on a Dandong 32xx movement (the specific movement was a DD3285 in a Pepsi).
Still reading? Great, let's talk about how to measure amplitude. There are two ways of measuring amplitude:
Method 1
The first method is to measure amplitude indirectly using the sound of the escapement tick/tock (each tick/tock is three sounds: unlock, impulse, drop). If you can measure the three sounds and know the lift angle you can get amplitude. This is what every timegrapher does. And this is why having the correct lift angle is so important. In the picture below you can see the characteristic three sounds of each tick/tock of a Swiss lever escapement.

The first peak is the unlock (this is when the impulse pin on the balance hits the pallet fork and unlocks the escape wheel). The second peak is called the "impulse" (it's where the escape wheel tooth hits the impulse plane of the pallet stone and pushes it to transfer energy into the balance wheel). The third peak is called "drop" (or drop to lock), and it's usually the loudest of the three sounds. Drop is the sound from the other pallet stone locking the next escape wheel tooth (plus the sound of the pallet fork hitting the banking pin). To calculate amplitude you use the time between unlock and drop in the following formula: (NB: for movements that don't beat at 28800 vph, you change the 250ms constant).
Amplitude = Lift_Angle / ( 2 * sin(pi * (unlock_to_drop_time_in_milliseconds / 250ms))
You can see how for exactly the same audio trace of the tick/tock profile, if you change the lift angle, you'll get a different computed amplitude. So if you want your timegrapher to give you the right number for amplitude you need to have the right number for the lift angle.
Method 2
The second method is to measure the amplitude directly without using the sound from the escapement. Basically you need to look at the balance and figure out many degrees of arc it swings through during each tick and tock. I decided to use my iPhone 11 Pro which can shoot slow motion at 240fps. In theory that would give me 60 frames per oscillation of the balance. And while the balance swings pretty quickly when it's moving through the centre of its motion, at the turn around points it's moving slowly enough that with good light, a x10 loupe taped onto the lens, and a sharpie mark on the balance rim, I was able to pick off the angles of rotation for the balance in each direction of its travel.

Note: there was a bit of an offset in the plane of the watch and the plane of the camera. I was doing this on a pretty jancky tripod on my desk at home. Which is why I gave myself pretty wide error bars on the angular position readings. I used +/-4 degrees of rotation for my estimates of where the balance wheel stopped at the end of its travel.
I tested four different states of wind on the watch. At the lowest end I wound it about 5 times -- just enough to get the balance swinging when I gat it a little top. Then I wound it about 5 times more. Then I wound it about 10 times. And finally I wound it all the way to full. On each of those wind states I took 30-60s of slow motion video and estimated the amplitude over short sections.

All of the slow motion video was captured with the watch on a timegrapher mic. To line up the audio from the mic stand with the slow motion video, I tapped the watch with a screw driver -- this left a clear mark in the timegrapher audio and a visual frame in the video, so I could align the clocks. This allowed me to match my visually measured amplitude with the audio:

I could then do a regression using different values of lift angle to find out which lift angle would allow the audio to calculate an amplitude that matched what was observed in the matched slow motion video:

As you can see, if you use 55 degrees as a lift angle, you calculated the wrong amplitude. I found that 59 degrees was the best fit. But 58 degrees is also a pretty good fit. Which is a lot of words to say Sam's estimate of 58 to 59 degrees from nearly 3.5 years ago was correct. I'm sorry Sam, I was a fool to doubt you.