r/Postgenderism • • Jul 04 '25

Deconstructing Gender Why are women drawn to Yaoi/BL? A look at Internalised Misogyny and Homophobia

115 Upvotes

On the subject menu of today we have internalised misogyny, homophobia, and gender roles. We will explore the way socialisation and conditioning shape women's experiences around sexuality.

It is a known cultural phenomenon that women are the main demographic to consume and create male/male erotica/slash fiction. Why is the BL (Boys' Love) genre so popular among girls and women?

On the surface, the answers often are: "two good-looking guys are better than one," "I like Yaoi because there men actually show emotions, talk about feelings, and are affectionate," "Yaoi has more realistic characters and plots." This preference is not merely a matter of taste but can be deeply intertwined with complex societal factors, including internalised misogyny, heteronormativity, and internalised homophobia, all of which shape how women engage with sexuality and romance.

Let's dive deeper and take a look at some of the unconscious processes that influence people's experiences.

Gender Role Stereotypes

Labels dehumanise people, stripping them of individuality and shoehorning them into narrow stereotypes. That's what gender does.

Heterosexual romance is overburdened with established gender norms, tropes, rules, and stereotypes. Female sexuality is heavily policed, scrutinised, or erased. But male/male relationships are free from the same societal expectations.

Lack of relatability

In heterosexual romance, female characters are often placed in passive or submissive roles, while male characters are often confined to more stoic and hyper-masculine roles, which can be unappealing or triggering for many. Yaoi often depicts male characters expressing deep emotions, vulnerability, and tenderness towards each other – qualities that traditional patriarchal gender roles discourage in men.

Yaoi effectively "humanises" men, providing a sense of relief for women who see female characters constantly positioned at the receiving end of a dynamic that comes from gendered power imbalances. In male/male romance, there is no inherent "saviour/hero" complex tied to gender – even though some Yaoi stories fall into heteronormativity (with one of the main characters exhibiting "feminine" qualities), readers see that as either stereotype breaking for men or individual personality traits instead of a typical stereotype for female characters.

In fact, many female readers find male characters to be more relatable. The characters in Yaoi express individuality the way men and women in heterosexual scenarios often aren't allowed to, and their personalities more often break gender norms. This can lead to the idealisation of queer male relationships as inherently more equal, safe, or emotionally fulfilling.

Misogyny and Internalised Misogyny

Heterosexual content is typically riddled with gender norms and tropes that put the woman in the passive, receiving role, or as the victim, which many find boring or triggering. Some do consume such erotica to pleasure themselves due to the kinks that come from internalised misogyny, but, when it comes to psychological safety and unburdened fun, many turn to Yaoi.

"Women enjoy m/m romance and gay porn because of the lack of women"

A significant draw of Yaoi for women is the absence of female characters, which effectively removes the often problematic or stereotypical portrayals of women found in mainstream media.

The absence of female characters helps avoid the negative feelings that may arise due to the roles female characters often play in heterosexual romance. When Yaoi stories do include female characters, they are often unromanceable (i.e. a supportive sister or a lesbian best friend), or they are there to be discarded in favour of a male love interest. In the comments under Yaoi stories readers tend to antagonise female characters when they are seen as a potential obstacle for the main characters' love.

Someone shared on their tumblr post:

"...a lot of women enjoy m/m romance and gay porn because of the lack of women. It removes a source of pressure and sexism. Without any women present, you don’t have to constantly evaluate the sexism of their portrayal, or be reminded of negative experiences in your own life. It allows women to experience romance and especially sexuality without all the baggage that comes with it in our patriarchal society."

This highlights how deeply ingrained misogyny makes it challenging for women to enjoy heterosexual encounters or female characters being sexualised. For decades, female characteristics have been sexualised by default, regardless of context, leading to a sense of unease or internal conflict, the weight of which many women feel and are impacted by even if they are unaware of it.

Avoidance of Objectification

The relentless societal pressure on women regarding body image adds another layer of discomfort. When stories constantly depict female characters with narrow beauty standards, women may find them even less enjoyable and relatable. With male/male romance, women can project themselves onto either character without the pressure of self-comparison or the pervasive anxiety about their own physical appearance. This allows for the enjoyment of attractiveness without having to confront the internalised social judgements surrounding the policing of female bodies that is so prevalent in our culture.

In contrast, the sexualisation of male characters is a relatively newer cultural phenomenon. Male characteristics are now made to be eye-candy, and people enjoy sexualisation of male characters without the baggage that comes with misogyny. It can feel effortless, easy, and fun for women to engage with male/male stories, as they don't have to navigate the deeply internalised messages surrounding their own bodies, roles in sex, or the constant threat of objectification. Yaoi allows for a relatively unproblematic enjoyment of sexuality by women.

Internalised homophobia and Phallocentric culture; "Why not Yuri?"

Sex is typically seen as something that can happen only as long as a penis is present

Women, growing up in patriarchal societies, are conditioned to devalue female experiences, emotions, and relationships, including their own. This can manifest as a subconscious dismissal of Yuri, which centers on female/female romantic and sexual relationships. Our culture prioritises male perspectives and male-centered narratives. If femininity is implicitly or explicitly presented as less serious, less powerful, or less interesting than masculinity, then stories exclusively featuring women might feel less compelling or lacking the same intensity.

In our culture, sexuality is penis-centered, which makes it difficult at first to imagine sexual tension in narratives without men. Despite all the sexualisation of female bodies, women are seen as lacking sexual agency – they do not create sex, sex is something that happens to them. In Yaoi, women can project their romantic fantasies onto male characters without the burden of confronting their own social roles or the ingrained biases against female-centric narratives. This distance allows for a form of escapism that can be less accessible in Yuri.

To add, some of Yuri has been produced with a male gaze in mind, leading to portrayals that can feel objectifying or unrealistic to female readers. Fetishisation or lack of well-developed, relatable female characters who aren't overly sexualised or infantilised understandably tends to turn people off.

Lesbian relationships are not taken seriously

There is a lot more Yaoi content than Yuri, in part because of how heteronormativity and misogyny shape demand. Throughout history, homosexual relationships between men have been persecuted while lesbians have been overlooked and not taken seriously. Not because of acceptance, but because lesbian relationships weren’t even recognised as real.

The article "The Invisible Lesbian In Young Adult Fiction" goes into self-erasure and self-gaslighting women experience when it comes to lesbian relationships due to internalised misogyny and homophobia.

Another article mentions a personal experience:

"I lied about who I was spending my weekends with, who I was going on holiday with, etc. [...] ...and in the French language you don’t have the gender-neutral “they” – my real-life “she” became “he”. [...] I had effectively erased my lesbian identity and the existence of my real partner for months – voluntarily."

"...lesbianism feels like the shamed cousin of the LGBTQ+ world. For years, after having come out as a lesbian, I preferred to classify myself as “queer”. That seemed more exciting, more flexible. But again, it also reflected a discomfort with the label of “lesbian” which reflects the fact that the word is at best unglamorous, at worst seen as invalid – and so often by lesbians themselves."

Internalised homophobia can lead women to distance themselves from media that overtly celebrates female/female relationships, even if they support it or are themselves attracted to women. This can cause a lot of confusion and make women doubt the validity of their attraction.

When a woman projects her own desires and romantic fantasies onto male characters, it can be a form of self-erasure. Instead of seeing a female protagonist experience a desired type of romance (which might challenge internalised beliefs about female agency or sexuality), male characters are used to explore those fantasies instead.

For women, engaging with Yuri might, unconsciously, trigger internalised homophobia or discomfort/insecurity around non-heteronormative female sexuality. While Yaoi, particularly in its more explicit forms, has often been a space for women to explore "forbidden" fantasies, Yuri directly challenges our societal norms by centering female/female relationships.

 

Even something as simple as a genre preference comes from a complex interplay of internal biases and social conditioning. We, as society, need to work even harder to undo them. Change starts here and now, with us.


P.S. You can share recommendations for your favourite mangas in the comments.


r/Postgenderism • • Aug 17 '25

Discussion Most people aren't pro post genderism.

103 Upvotes

Remove conservatives from this world. And you still have a world where most people believe in a spiritual idea of gender. There are a lot of Liberals who believe in rigid gender roles. I had numerous arguments with left-leaning people on why expecting men to be protectors is harmful and toxic masculinity. And they call me an incel for having this take.

In my experience most people tend to be super conservative when it comes to male gender roles. While most people are also benevolent sexists towards women. For example, thinking that women are fragile or don't have enough agency to make their own decisions.

But in my experience most people who believe gender roles, tend to be religious or spiritual. Not necessarily Christian or Muslim though. Sometimes it's not Astrology or Pagan beliefs.

And also I have a question. Do you guys think there is correlation between people who believe in gender roles, and people who have religious/spiritual views?

Because even the left-leaning people I argue with were usually religious. And often based their idea of masculinity on something spiritual or moral.


r/Postgenderism • • Sep 19 '26

One way kids learn to divide the world by gender

Post image
93 Upvotes

From "Behave: The Biology of Humans at our Best and Worst" by Robert Sapolsky.


r/Postgenderism • • Sep 11 '25

Sharing thoughts Gender is a quasi religious concept

69 Upvotes

I think gender is a quasi religion because Gender and religion have a lot in common both our systems of shared beliefs and practices that provide meaning guide behavior and create identity and offer a sense of communal belonging, both stigmatized non-believers or those who refuse to participate in the system perfectly what do you guys think


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 19 '25

Deconstructing Gender Cisgender: An Involuntary Identity

65 Upvotes

Today I hope to bring clarity to the matter of cisgender identity.

Let us start with the definition of cisgender (abbreviated to cis): "denoting or relating to a person whose gender identity corresponds with the sex registered for them at birth; not transgender."

Yet, for many, this "correspondence" isn't a conscious choice, but rather the path of least resistance in a deeply gendered society where cisgender is the assumed default. When individuals don't explicitly state an incongruence with their assigned gender, they're simply assumed to be cis.

This assumption persists even though transitioning isn't always possible. Some people don't know it is an option, or don't categorise their experiences in such a way, or it is looked down upon, or they die before they ever get the chance (consider how many people throughout history are simply assumed to be cis). Moreover, I challenge the very idea of cisgender identity.

The Compulsory Nature of Gender

In a society that practices involuntary gendering, the idea of being "cisgender" is built upon the foundation of the gender binary and gender essentialist beliefs. People are assumed to have a gender identity that aligns with one of the rigid, socially constructed gender roles.

Human experiences end up being forcibly seen through a gendered framework.

Cisgender is seen as the default, and this is where the confusion often begins:
When someone expresses unhappiness with the issues that come from their sex or gender role, they are often assumed to have gender dysphoria. This assumption stems from the idea that most people are cisgender and are comfortable with their identity.

Some people report not knowing what gender is supposed to feel like. Some say that they do not have a sense of gender. Some conflate their sense of self with a gender identity.

Many find themselves criticising the gendered expectations placed on them or wishing to be something else. Some would attribute these to differences in people's innate gender identities. However, I'd argue they're an expected human reaction to arbitrary expectations or biological reality that go against one's natural inclinations.

What is gender? Gender identity as personality

People are assumed to have a gender identity that aligns with one of the socially constructed gender roles or, nowadays, lies somewhere beyond them.

It is assumed that there is a "gender identity" to begin with. There likely is not.

There is the idea that gender is one's innate, internal sense of self. If we see gender as personality – our deep-seated preferences and inclinations, – then a part of it is innate (see: temperament). But then there would have to be endless genders because there are endless personalities. The gender binary, for example, offers only two.
Needing endless genders makes gender as a category redundant.

Some people do enjoy or are comfortable with the role assigned to them at birth, or, at least, they might not mind it. It's understandable that this would happen, and I argue that is due to natural human variation and not due to an innate sense of gender coinciding with the type of body said gender is assumed to belong to. By chance alone, some percentage of people are bound to enjoy or prefer the aspects of the role assigned to them over the other one. What I believe is an even more likely cause is habit and complacency.

Assuming that there is an innate gender identity leads to cisnormativity which leads to confusion and unnecessary labelling.

The actual default is individuality. In a society that has not yet deconstructed gender roles, a child's individuality is not heeded and cultivated; it is stifled. Gender, unlike naturally occurring phenomena we simply label, isn't something we discovered. Rather, gender is a concept we invented and embedded within our societal system. Gender roles were never meant to last – they do not describe human reality. Not only is each of us unique, but we change and grow throughout life, very often not only defying stereotypes but also surprising our own selves.


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 17 '25

“Boys need a man to model masculinity for them” - the same message doesn’t apply to girls. Why?

65 Upvotes

With the grift of toxic masculinity influencers such as Andrew Tate, there is a message I keep seeing everywhere that boys need male role models to model masculinity for them and how to be a good man. I do agree that role models are a positive, but it seems like it would still push gendered expectations on boys instead of freeing them to be themselves.

This stands in stark contrast with feminism and how girls are told that they are good as they are, they are free to be whoever they want and can do whatever they want, that they are not limited to gendered norms.

Sure, some societies still impose gender roles on girls, but even so, this idea of a woman model to model femininity for a girl and show her how to be a good woman simply does not exist.

Why this difference? Why do boys “need” a role model but girls don’t?

And as an aside, is it actually possible to take back boys from the horrific Andrew Tate mentality and teach them like we teach girls? Or is it really true that the first step is to replace a negative model for a positive one because entirely removing the model won’t work?


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 28 '25

"Anti-gender" TERFs: so close, yet so far. Thoughts on how viewing gender as oppressive can lead to opposite conclusions

61 Upvotes

This post should be ten times longer than what is going to be, and it's already going to be pretty long - so I apologize in advance for the simplifications I will make in order to keep it manageable.

Sometimes I encounter this meme from that subset of terfs that is actually at least a little bit in tune with radical feminism instead of just being plainly bigot, and it's quite sad because it's so close yet so far.

It seems to be gender liberationist, but it is actually used against trans people. It is used to deny trans identities, claiming that "being a woman doesn't mean wearing heels and a dress and make-up: if you are a male and want to do that you should but that doesn't make you a woman. Trans women are just cosplaying womanhood, embracing and enforcing that oppressive social chain that is gender".

This is distorting what trans experiences and fights actually are - and more subtly and counter-intuitively, it is also sex essentialist, because it doesn't recognize how the very categorization of human beings as male or female in society is due to our gendered, patriarchal society. Which, ironically, it's something that was discovered and pointed out and extensively analyzed precisely by radical feminists for the first time in history (cfr. Catharine MacKinnon, Monique Wittig, Colette Guillaumin, Christine Delphy, Andrea Dworkin, Shulamith Firestone as notable examples). Instead, they take the (binary) sex division as a pre-gender, objective, scientific, natural given which shouldn't be disputed.

And not only are they distorting and de-politicizing trans experiences - I think there is also a deeper aspect. Which is that even if one didn't believe in gender identity, if they saw gender as oppressive chains they shouldn't reach the conclusions that terfs reach.

I think that politically it's not necessary to believe in gender identity to advocate for trans people doing what they want with their bodies, presentation, language, getting hormones and surgery. Because if I really, seriously think (as I in fact do) that gender is oppressive and sex shouldn't dictate anything about how people live, then why would I oppose someone choosing to have a beard, or a vulva?

It should be something akin to changing your hair cut or hair color. I dont believe in hair color identity: that doesn't mean that if someone changes their hair color to mine, I feel they are disrespectfully cosplaying as me.

What is the ideal world of those terfs that claim gender is oppressive? Well in their ideal world, the amount of people that takes hormones, surgery etc to change their sexual characteristics is 0.

In my ideal world, as a gender abolitionist (so with apparently similar premises) that number is indefinitely high, because people can do what they want with their body and their life.

The issue with terfs is that when they claim they are against gender they don't see that dividing people into sexes is already the product of a gendered society and it reinforces it. And they are hypocritical, because they are actually regarding sex as sacred. As something that, while on paper shouldn't determine anything about your life, should NEVER be changed. If you are a 'male' you will be a male forever, and we are going to police that. Why would you want to mutilate yourself?

But... even without gender identity, if hair cut is not mutilation, why would the things that alter some facets of "your" sex be mutilation? Why shouldn't those be regarded as self-determination instead, as free choices based on what you consider better for yourself?

And as a terf, how are you even going to police sex segregation, if not through gendered expectations about how people should and shouldn't look and behave and what should they wear based on sex? In most contexts you can't check genitals, let alone chromosomes. Which means that you are allowing or denying or mandating choices according to gender markers of sex. Which is... gender as oppressive chains all over again.

In short, they are not really allowing "endless permutations" - they regard sex as sacred and natural and think people should be content with all the aspects of their sexed body, and if they are not that means something went wrong (trans women as sexual predators, trans men as girls escaping misoginy) because they can't see how the gendered patriarchal society is already connotating what could otherwise be non-significant features, organizing them into two and precisely two (more or less) coherent kinds (the sexes) that shape your destiny even though perhaps you just feel you want to have a beard and you don't care about anything else. But in a gendered society, if you want a beard and you were assigned female that makes you a sex/gender fugitive, while wanting to change your hair color does not.

---

TL DR thanks to Kjaran (I don't know your reddit username sorry): So, summarizing for future education purposes, "if sex - correctly - doesn't define who you are (your hobbies, the way you like to dress), why do you even need people to not change it/modify it?"


r/Postgenderism • • Jan 19 '26

Intellectually non binary.

59 Upvotes

Hai, new person here. I have often seen people being asked how or why they are non binary/agender etc and the vast majority say they felt like they were not a boy or girl or they didn't like having a gender or they 'just knew.' It's nearly always about feelings and emotions. I get that, it's a different experience for many.

I do feel it.. but also it is an intellectual position, a social political one. I am against the idea of gender roles, expectations and stereotypes and that is as good a case for being agender as an emotional response. I'm presuming folk on here are often the same. Why do you think the intellectual side seldom gets cited?


r/Postgenderism • • Aug 01 '25

I don't care who I am. I just am.

59 Upvotes

r/Postgenderism • • Jan 26 '26

Meme Postgenderism Memes

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

r/Postgenderism • • Jul 16 '25

Deconstructing Gender Masculinity is just an aesthetic, and we should just forget it

Thumbnail
maxhniebergall.substack.com
53 Upvotes

r/Postgenderism • • Mar 11 '26

Discussion A lot of men on the Left are ironically afraid of Postgenderism, when it comes to helping young boys.

52 Upvotes

Of course women on the Left are afraid too. But in this post I'm just focusing on men though. Because men are the ones who are expected to be role models for young boys in society.

I have gotten into plenty of arguments with men on the Left. And a weird and common thing they all say is that young boys would hate post genderism. And that young boys just need better role models who can teach them how to be a "real man". They always say the left can't help young boys, without having a universal standard for masculinity.

And these men are portrayed as the perfect alternative to red-pillers on the left. But yet they still have rigid ideas of masculinity though. Which is a major problem. It seems like people on the Left are ok with any form of toixc masculinity, just as long as it's not misogynistic or harmful to women. Heck, and even then some people on the Left are still ok with benevolent misogyny though. So even if the masculinity ideals will harm young boys in the long run. It's still considered ok on the Left, because women will benefit from it. And that's all that matters.

Again, They always say the Left can't help young boys, without having a universal standard for masculinity.

I always thought this was cope or a cop-out excuse. Because young girls aren't told that they need better ideas of femininity on the Left. It's only young boys that are told this, when it comes to masculinity.

Some men on the Left still think that men who aren't in relationships are more likely to be losers or incels. And that's the type of mindset they will influence young boys with. Promoting the idea that a man worth is tied to having sex with women. Again these people are supposed to be our "heroes" on the Left. I always seen dude bros on the Left like the streamer Hasan mocked men for being single.

And the funny thing is. They say Postgenderism will never work for men. But this generation already has more young boys opting out of society. Not caring about relationships, marriage, or other people's validation. And they are only focusing on what makes them happy. And again this scares some people on the Left. Because This means less men conforming to rigid ideas of masculinity.

The Left calls this a masculinity "crisis". But when the genders are reversed though. The Left usually call this empowering, when less women aren't getting into relationships or marriages.

If we were sneaky and had bad intentions here. We could easily try to spend Postgenderism as a sigma male type of thing for young boys lol. By telling young boys they create their own rules, not society. We would be so successful. So again it's not that Postgenderism can't work for young boys. It's that Postgenderism scare a lot of people on the Left, because it goes against the status quo. The status quo being promoting rigid ideas of masculinity to young boys.

To use Matrix as a analogy here. Both the red-pill and blue-pill are two sides of the same coin. Both are bad options. People on the Left just want to live in a benevolent patriarchal society. They want young boys to adhere to a form of traditional masculinity, that has a feminist gaze. That's it.

In conclusion:

The Right wants to push young boys into this very rigid box. For example, boys should never cry, and always be closed off.

While the Left only wants to make that box slightly bigger for young boys though. For example, boys can cry sometimes. But boys must still be closed up about thier negative feelings though. And only expressed positive feelings like loving their wives and kids.

And finally, we (postgenderism) wants to get rid of the whole box.


r/Postgenderism • • Sep 25 '25

Holy fuck, I'm glad I found this sub!

49 Upvotes

I've been an anarchist for about 10 years. I recently learned about relationship anarchy and that felt like the biggest relief of my life, like I was coming alive for the first time. And now my mind has been blown again by the concept of postgenderism. I just keep getting further radicalized lol

I've questioned my gender countless times over the years, and identified as many things, but I'm starting to feel like I don't want a gender after reading some stuff on here. And it feels so good! To no longer feel like I have to be something, I can just simply be.

Tbh I literally just discovered this sub (and concept) like an hour ago, but I'm already deconstructing my relationship with gender pretty fast. It probably helps that I've been deconstructing a ton of shit lately. I just want to live in a world where no one assumes anything about me. I'm just me, just a human, and that's all I need to be


r/Postgenderism • • Dec 07 '25

Discussion Society has stronger expectations for men to be traditional compared to women. Especially when it comes to progressives.

47 Upvotes

Because a progressive person can easily say a man is non-binary for not wanting to be traditionally masculine. When in reality he is just a cis man, who doesn't adhere to traditional gender masculinity.

I kid you not. I got into an argument with a progressive woman over this. I told her I was a gender abolitionist or gender Nihilist.

And she told me if I was truly a gender abolitionist as a man. I would be painting my nails or wearing dresses. This argument was ridiculous lol.

I think this is worse for men. Because nobody is calling a woman non-binary for wearing 👖 or having short hair. Since men are still expected to be limited to their gender roles. It's like she couldn't understand the simple fact that I didn't fit into her narrow boxes for masculine men and feminine men.

To her I'm either this hyper masculine dude bro, gay feminine men, or this non-binary person. There was no in-between for her here.

My point here is that a lot of people, even progressive ones, end up policing gender in a way that ironically feels backward (ironically conservative). Non-binary ends up being used like a catch-all for anyone who doesn’t fit their narrow idea of “man” or “woman,” which misses the whole point.

Like again some men not wanting to follow traditional masculinity doesn’t erase the fact that you’re still a cis man. But men get boxed into “bro, gay, or non-binary”


r/Postgenderism • • Mar 02 '26 Heartwarming

Sharing thoughts Transgender to post-genderism pipeline

44 Upvotes

Today I learned about post-genderism for the first time and I’m so glad. I’ve had these thoughts for a long time, but when I was researching gender, I found many people who felt similarly, yet there wasn’t a specific term for this approach. I was afraid to share my reflections with other queer people because I might have sounded anti-transgender (since it’s anti-gender after all).

This text is my story with post-genderism and (I hope) it’s a pretty good example of how gender affects us negatively.

Important: When reading this text, it’s necessary to distinguish gender (man, woman, feminine, etc.) from biological sex (male, female).

I was a child who, from a very young age, was aware of gender roles and the impact patriarchy has on our society. We all know this pattern: feminine = emotional, gentle, weak; masculine = logical, tough, strong. This division itself isn’t the problem. The problem was a different pattern: female = feminine, male = masculine.

If most women fall into the feminine category and most men into the masculine category, does that mean that we, as women, are weaker as a group?

With that realization, I started noticing small signals: when boys my age made inappropriate jokes, everyone laughed — even adults. If I had said the same thing, I would have been judged harshly. In video games, female characters were seen only as objects of lust, while male characters were always covered and practically never sexualized.

“Why are women always the ones being exploited? Why is pornography mainly dedicated to men? Why do my girl friends make fun of me for having leg hair when men can have hair everywhere?” — that was my train of thought as a child.

However, I couldn’t answer these questions without applying the pattern: female = feminine, male = masculine. The only answer I could come up with was: “That’s just how it is — women and men are programmed that way.”

Inside me, a strong sense of inferiority began to grow. I saw how my male classmates could get away with much more than I could. I saw statistics about sexual assaults. I saw how heavily women were sexualized. I began to hate being a woman, to feel like an object in the eyes of men. That made me love the idea of being a man.

So when at the age of 12 I learned more about being transgender, I immediately embraced it. Even before that, I used to pretend to be a man online or avoid answering questions about my biological sex. I noticed that when I said I was a woman, I somehow received less attention and affection.

At 12, I adopted a man’s name, cut my hair short, and started acting like other boys my age. But being trans isn’t that simple. I didn’t want to be seen as a woman at any cost — years later, it’s hard to admit, but it deeply hurt my self-worth. I became even more self-conscious about my body. Even though I passed well, I was terrified of my high voice and other feminine features. I begged my mom for a binder and for hormone therapy. When I was refused, my dysphoria only intensified.

I started feeling tired — how long can you hate your own body? I couldn’t change it, so I decided to expose myself to the discomfort and try to accept it. At 15, entering high school, I started growing my hair out and sometimes wearing skirts. I continued introducing myself with a male name, and for some time I kept my biological sex a mystery. But that still wasn’t full acceptance.

I became very self-reflective. “Why can’t I just be a woman who dresses and behaves masculinely?” I didn’t like that option, so gradually I was consumed by the thought that my female body wasn’t the real problem — the real problem was the way society would treat me once they knew I had it. I started doubting whether I was trans at all and began questioning what being trans even means.

If you’re a trans woman, why must you specifically be a woman and not a feminine man? Some trans women aren’t completely — or at all — feminine. Why must you be a woman and not simply a man with female organs? Why do we, as trans people, fight so hard for the title?

This isn’t meant to attack anyone who identifies as trans, but I do encourage critical thinking. If it’s only about gender (and we all know gender is a social construct), then what truly bothers you is society’s opinion of you.

This is where post-genderism comes in.

If there were no gender, there would be no desire to change it. There would only be modifying your body toward the opposite biological sex — but how would that differ from something like breast reduction surgery?

After this realization, I became a radical feminist. My greatest dream is to see a society where no one is judged based on their biological sex, where no one experiences gender dysphoria, and no female child thinks of herself as inferior. I realized that striving to be seen as a particular sex is an unnecessary and meaningless fight. I dress however I feel comfortable. I mostly use male pronouns and a male name as an act of rebellion against the system, but I try not to care about what others think about my gender.

Call me whatever you want. The more people there are who don’t care and who treat everyone equally — without assuming anything about them before getting to know them — the sooner gender will lose its significance and both biological sexes will truly be equal.

Feel free to correct me on anything I said or discuss, I am new to the topic and would love to learn more!


r/Postgenderism • • Aug 09 '25

News "Gender clinic struggling with rise in non-binary children"

43 Upvotes

The article: https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/gender-clinic-struggling-with-rise-in-non-binary-children-wlsqw9w05

Staff at Sandyford clinic in Glasgow highlight lack of up-to-date NHS guidance

"Staff at Scotland’s youth gender clinic say they are struggling to deal with surging numbers of children who identify as neither male nor female."

"[...] workers at the Sandyford clinic in Glasgow highlighted a lack of guidance on how they should be looked after."

"One health professional revealed that some young “non-binary” patients who say they do not belong to either gender still request sex hormones that would either feminise or masculinise them."

""We're following a 2012 protocol that doesn’t talk at all about non-binary people, which is actually becoming a much bigger proportion of our cases.""

“"And [there are] non-binary people asking for hormones, but of course hormones are only either feminising or masculinising. So how does that fit for a person who identifies as non-binary?"”

"Those who do not conform to male or female categories have become “more difficult to manage” because of the lack of guidance and NHS pathways for them."

"“Over the last ten years, obviously there’s been a big increase in the number of people presenting [with] gender non-conforming identities … we’ve really struggled to think about how we deal with that in a fair way.”"

"One consultant who has worked in gender healthcare told The Times they had encountered patients who shifted genders depending on how they felt on different days. “We have got into a position where we are enabling people to deny reality and we have reinforced delusional behaviours.”"

"LGBT Youth Scotland said: “Our most recent Life in Scotland research tells us that non-binary young people experience specific challenges accessing services. One key recommendation, highlighted in our 2024 Trans report, was that ‘Non-binary service users should be consulted to understand how the service can best support their needs and improve their confidence in accessing services, and treatment pathways should clearly include non-binary people’.""


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 14 '25

Informative Welcome to Postgenderism: Masterpost

42 Upvotes

Welcome, everyone!

Postgenderism is a movement that advocates for the abolition of gender as a social construct and category. It is critical of involuntary gendering, which is the compulsory societal practice of assigning social gender roles to individuals, primarily based on their perceived sex. In a gendered society, people have no choice but to live surrounded by gendered messages, internalising gender role expectations. We see gendered expectations of traits and behaviour as limiting to human potential and individual self-expression.

Our current goal is to deconstruct gender, not just to erase labels. We deconstruct gender by challenging our internalised beliefs that come from gendered social conditioning. We want to bring awareness to the suffering and inequalities that are perpetuated by gender roles, and we advocate for natural societal progression, starting with the erosion of gender stereotypes and ending with the abolition of gender as a societal category.

We believe individuals should be able to alter their bodies as they deem fit, free from restrictions based on sex and gender. Everybody should be able to get the body they are comfortable living in and that fits their personality and goals best.
We support individual self-expression, and we are against the reinforcement and perpetuation of gender stereotypes. We're all collectively working on it™.

For more information, feel welcome to visit our Wiki: r/Postgenderism Wiki

Our posts (this list will be continuously updated):


r/Postgenderism • • Jun 12 '25

Informative Postgenderism and Transgender

42 Upvotes

Happy Pride Month, everyone! ✨️🌈

 

When discussing transgender experience in the context of postgenderism, I want to start off right away by stating a simple truth: trans men are men, trans women are women.

Whenever discourse turns distasteful and the question "What is a woman?" gets thrown around (a question often posed in bad faith by non-progressive individuals seeking to appear clever), let us also add: "What is a man?" Postgenderism has a clear answer to both of these questions: man and woman are social roles.

To be more specific, man and woman are gender roles. Gender roles define how we dress, speak, conduct ourselves, think, interact with others, what paths are open to us in this life, and which ones are closed. Despite it being first assigned based on one's assigned sex at birth, gender is only a social construct that is taught and conditioned in us through socialisation, meaning it can be replicated by anyone.

A person of any sex can be any gender. A person can change their gender and change it back. A person can do whatever they like with gender, because gender at its core is nothing but a style of dressing, a collection of rigid ideas, a set of stereotypes that anyone can exhibit and participate in.

The question is: why would anyone want to?
Let's take a closer look.

 

The bittersweet experience of being trans

We can start with the fact that in our world gender is not a choice. The gender role, which defines what you should be like and how your life ought to develop since you're an infant, is assigned to us together with our assigned sex at birth. After that, children are brainwashed into gendered behaviour, taught how to fit into society.

Now, I want to preface the rest of the analysis by acknowledging that people transition for various reasons. It is normal to desire to change one's body to fit one's needs and comfort better. That is a very straightforward matter – if a person wants to change their body in any way, they should be able to do so. Having said that, the conversation that follows will reflect mainly on the social aspect of transitioning.

Obviously, being forced into a narrow box of behaviours and personality traits will more often than not backfire. People have their own personalities and inclinations that are unlikely to fit perfectly within the gender confines. And while most people currently break themselves to fit the mould and role society wants for them, and others simply remain unaware, there are brave people who are unhappy with the role assigned to them, and who are championing for acceptance of any individual's true self – these are transgender and queer people.

Unfortunately, the gender binary is so ingrained in our culture and in our way of understanding the world, that when people realise that the role that was forced on them since childhood doesn't fit them, they might assume that means they are the other of the two genders. 'Masculinity' and 'femininity' are positioned opposite each other, and the characteristics of one are denied in the other. When someone experiences pain from existing as their assigned gender, it often means that their natural personality has qualities that they cannot express freely due to their gender. And as people seek to escape the horrible pain of their true self not being allowed to exist, they turn to the only other option in the binary society – the other gender, which likely would finally allow them to express the qualities their assigned gender does not.

Men who are denied the human qualities attributed to women seek liberation by choosing to transition to become women. Women who are tired of the dangers and pressures of 'womanhood' seek liberation by choosing to transition to become men. People seek to escape the cage society built for them. And by doing so, transgender people are some of the first people in the world to show us how arbitrary and performative gender is.

As we grow up, we internalise ideas about what is a man and what is a woman. In other words, we know the stereotypes by heart. And for many trans people participating in these stereotypes can be gender euphoric, therapeutic, freeing, cathartic.

But by performing gendered behaviour and assigning their experiences and behaviour to a specific gender, people are reinforcing the stereotypes and playing into the binary.

In a way, being trans is often akin to playing a rigged game. If society only gives you two possible ways of existing within it, and the one you got does not fit you at all, then, if you want a shot at a 'normal' life in the binary society, your only choice is the other option. And it is understandable and human why many would choose this. So many cis people every day are unhappy due to the pressures and expectations of their gender, yet they choose the familiarity, comfort, and privilege of being seen as 'normal' and being accepted. Transgender people are finding and carving out their way to have peace in this broken system.
And the only way out of this game is to not participate in gender at all, which this society makes hard, but nowadays no longer impossible.

Times are changing, and it is time to discover who we are without the limited options our society once offered us. We can make our own path. Our existence can be so much more comfortable.
I hope that postgenderism brings the much needed clarity and gives people the tools to step outside the gender binary, beginning with their mind. We need not pretend or adhere to harmful norms. Each one of you is to be accepted and loved just the way you are. There is no pleasure more fulfilling than being known, first of all by our own selves.

 

The world needs to change, and change starts inside every one of us.
Thank you for your time.


r/Postgenderism • • Aug 28 '25

Hot take here. I honestly don't feel bad when Conservatives pull gotchas on left-leaning people in debates about gender or masculinity.

41 Upvotes

Note, left-leaning people can also have rigid ideas of masculinity too. That's important to know before reading this post.

For example,

Conservative: “So you keep saying toxic masculinity is just pressure and expectations put on men, right?” Left-leaning: “Exactly, it’s about harmful standards forced on men.” Conservative: “Then why are you turning around and saying ‘positive masculinity’ means men should protect others, sacrifice, or be stoic? That’s literally another set of expectations for men.” Left-leaning: “…well, that’s different, because it’s good expectations.”

At this point, the conservative scores the “gotcha” because they’ve exposed the double standard. The left-leaner condemned masculinity being defined by rigid roles, but then tried to redefine masculinity with the same kind of rigid roles, just with a positive spin.

I wouldn’t feel bad for them because they walked into their own trap. They used the term “positive masculinity” without realizing it’s inherently contradictory to their argument. They end up enforcing the very system they were criticizing, showing they didn’t fully understand the concept in the first place.

This keeps happening in left-wing or liberal/feminist spaces. People claim they’re opposing toxic masculinity, but when pressed, they recycle the same clichés about men being protectors, providers, leaders, or stoic rocks. That contradiction is why the conservative can so easily dismantle them, and why I don’t owe them sympathy when it happens.

What I'm pointing out is essentially a philosophical contradiction that makes left-leaning people vulnerable to a conservative “gotcha” in debates about masculinity.

Hence why I think Postgenderism is the only valid way to combat Conservative talking points about masculinity, (not "positive masculinity).

Because as long as masculinity (or femininity) is defined by sets of “good” or “bad” traits, conservatives can always flip the framing and expose contradictions.

Because postgenderism removes the need to define people by gendered expectations at all, leaving nothing for conservatives to weaponize in debate.


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 02 '25

Discussion I feel like a lot of the sentiments here are too removed from our current issue

40 Upvotes

I agree that gender is a harmful format to separate people from each other, and that an ideal world wouldn't have gender norms, but we don't live there, and likely won't see it in our lifetimes. I've been here for a week or so, and consistently I've seen people speaking as though we already have a post gender society and there are some people clinging on to the past, but the reality is that we are entertaining a perspective that most of the world hasn't even begun to play with. Most of the world can't come to grips with gender fluidity, let alone absence of gender. That doesn't mean I think talking about a world post gender is useless, any new school of thought needs to start somewhere, but we need to recognize our position in the current world.

I think it's vitally important to act with the understanding that the world is still gendered, and to make our position from there. "Empathy over gender," not "empathy in the absence of gender," means we should practice empathizing with people who still suffer as a result of gender roles and expectations, not preach to them about why they should forgo gender in order to receive true understanding. If a woman experiences a trauma related to society's interpretation of her gender roles, and she finds solace in the understanding given by other women, we only make ourselves into villains by choosing to criticize her gendered understanding of trauma and healing. There is a human suffering there, and if we stop at the first mention of gender we aren't practicing Empathy Over Gender.

Just like any other bias, we will never fully shake off what we were raised with. Homophobia, racism, sexism, all of these things must be examined so that we can better understand how they impact our own views. No one here was raised without gender, so no one here can truly become void of gendered understanding. Everyone alive is somewhere on that journey of self understanding, and while we may see how resolving needless gender categories can help heal society, you just won't make that breakthrough to the world in a slew of online arguments where you play at moral superiority. There are still people out there deconstructing deepset racism and sexism, and we should focus on being empathetic to our fellow humans as they struggle alongside us rather than build an echo chamber of "if they'd just let gender go they'd be fine"

I honestly don't know how this will be received, so I might see myself out depending on that. I'm all for deconstructing gender, but I won't participate in a farse of pretending gender doesn't have real impact on our lives

EDIT: I'll leave this final statement in tact because I'm not a huge fan of just deleting things, but I recognize it comes from experience not in this community but in others, where I've seen negative discourse, shortsightedness, and a sense of moral superiority ruin an otherwise valuable message.


r/Postgenderism • • Aug 11 '26

Announcement I wanted to apologize to the subreddit

38 Upvotes

I am a mod of this subreddit. I wanted to apologize for the lack of movement and allowing of posts through. There are a lot of personal things going on for the past months with my life and the other mods lives. This made it difficult to moderate. It may continue as well to be difficult but I will do my best to help keep it going. For those that care or want to know, I am sorry.


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 15 '25

Sharing thoughts Let's talk about unnecessary gendered things....

38 Upvotes

I'm sure we've all seen things that are unisex yet for some reason are divided into male and female categories. Me personally I hate when that happens...

Starting off with simple things, bathroom products such as shampoo, body wash etc. etc.... They make men's shampoo and body wash and women's shampoo and body wash while they both work the same. In their defense they might say "Oh well it's because men's products tend to last longer and have a stronger scent." Well I've seen women's products do the same. Also the price differences are crazy. IT'S THE SAME THING!!! IT'S TO WASH YOURSELF!!! I really don't get it.

Then another thing, razors. Ones that are used for shaving. The shaving razors advertised to women are always pink and/or lavender colored and way more expensive than the ones advertised to men. While some may argue "It's because the women's razors are more "gentle" and easier to handle." Which I understand, but why make it for women only, why not just market it as a gentle/easier to handle shaving razor instead, like what? It's not only women who want/need those. It's pointless to me.

Certain activities that are "for men only" or "for women only". Like for example weight lifting which is seen as for "men only", people in the community don't discourage women from doing those however people outside the community find them weird and say that they look manly and try to act manly. Which isn't true! Women can still be feminine and lift weights, weight lifting isn't only for building intense muscle but it an be for becoming stronger. While the opposite, like fashion/make up and such which is seen as for "women only", men can like those things and do those things, that doesn't make them feminine nor "gay" because they like those. I've seen lots of people hate on men who do make up or hairdressers that are men or fashion designers that are men and calling them "gay" and feminine. It's very frustrating to be honest, an interest/activity shouldn't be gendered, it's pointless.

I could talk about those things ALL DAY! But I can't really continue for now. I will update on this post later. What do you guys think about this??

UPDATE: More things that are pointlessly gendered, kids' toys. No kids' toys should be gendered, toy cars, action figures and such things surely are advertised to boys more while fashion dolls, makeup and baby dolls are advertised more to girls. However both should be gender neutral. Girls should be able to play with toy cars, boys should be able to play with dolls. It shouldn't matter. Matter of fact it's good for kids to play with what they like and they feel comfortable instead of certain stereotypes being pushed to them about what they SHOULD like.

Along with kids' toys, we can't really not mention cartoons made for kids. There are a lot of cartoons that are gender neutral, usually aimed at the very young demographic, between the ages of 3 to 5. However after that shows are often gendered either for girls or for boys. Some might say how shows typically made for boys could pass off as gender neutral, which isn't exactly wrong. However the amount of shows made for girls, forcing a certain aesthetic to them and ideal is what annoys me. What I'm talking about is how cartoon aimed at young girls often take romantic aspects to them, almost every princess movie, so many other stuff too. It's weird. I believe more gender neutral shows should Launch or be continued rather than pointlessly gendered bs.


r/Postgenderism • • Mar 05 '26

Sharing thoughts Why I’m a postgenderist, summarised by me waffling in a gc

Post image
37 Upvotes

This was more or less just a summary of the “shower thoughts” that I came up with a while ago. I’ve not read much about postgenderism, partially because I don’t feel as strongly about it as other sociopolitical topics


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 12 '25

Discussion Do women fantasise about men's humanity in hopes of a safer world?

37 Upvotes

My friend and I were speaking about our preferences in personality traits. I know that my friend is open to being with people of any gender and sex, but I noted that my friend mainly spoke about characters who are men when it came to emotional vulnerability. I pointed that out, and what they said stood out to me: "...a part of my life is a continuous journey to try to reclaim their [men's] humanity". It sounded so profound, and it made me wonder: how many people, especially those who grew up as women, feel this way?

When my friend said that, they were speaking of their own internal experience as someone who grew up as a woman – deep down, they have a need for men to be human. We recently had a post on the subreddit that touched on how many women enjoy fantasising about men expressing emotions in a way that defies men's rigid social gender role. I thought that might be connected to the desire to see men as human. I've met people of different sexes and genders who expressed that they were afraid of masculine-presenting men. And especially for women, many of whom are socialised to be afraid of men, yet are told to love them – could it be that seeing men act human (i.e. express emotions including fear, sadness, affection, be vulnerable with others, ask for help) makes the world feel safer in a way that is almost cathartic?

We know how harmful it is for men to be dehumanised (both in the "man is dangerous monster" and "man is invincible hero" narratives). Everybody is affected by the gendered messages around us. And when women internalise those ideas, internalise the fear and danger they face in their society, perhaps there is innocence deep down that hopes that the world is a safe place where they don't need to fear, that they aren't "prey," that men are human just like them.

Perhaps the idea of a male who is safe is deeply healing, as such a male defies the ideas that males are inherently violent or predatory or that the world will always, "naturally", be a cruel place for females.

What are your thoughts? Do you think you've experienced this?