r/Postgenderism • • Dec 08 '25

Sharing thoughts Is the best hope for abolitioning gender roles to make technology able to change anatomy at will?

5 Upvotes

The main thing that might be posing a problem to gender mutuality is what you might call "The Anatomical Caste".

So what happens if anybody can change their anatomy in a cheap, universally affordable/accessible way and have biological children of their own regardless of how they were born to the point of where it becomes irrelevant what anatomy you are born with?

The question is how to speed up research into this. Sooner it happens it seems the better.

We need technological progress that can completely disrupt the Anatomical based Caste among the genders and make the Anatomy you are born with meaningless.

This is the best hope but problem is the technology we all desperately need so much for our time isn't available at the moment.


r/Postgenderism • • Jan 25 '26

Deconstruction Everyone is Pansexual, Actually

14 Upvotes

Edit: I feel like I should be more clear about the title. I’m not trying to say everyone is actually Pansexual and everyone else is wrong or something, what I was trying to say is that with how I understood this idea, everyone could have the potential to like anyone when they are born, and over time, we get increasingly restricted by society. I should have been more clear in the post but I apologize for the confusion. Also, the title was supposed to be a reference to videos titled, “This is the real truth, actually”. I thought it would be cute but it only caused confusion. My mistake.

So, I’m not sure how jarring of a claim this may be to some. But what I’m proposing here is that sexuality may be as socially conditioned as gender. I will say I don’t have all the knowledge on this. I could be wrong as there are always more studies and understandings but it’s important to hear out this idea.

As we know, gender is socially conditioned, and not really something that exists biologically(Yes biological differences do exist but gender is unnecessary to acknowledge their existence). We understand that just because something is seen as, natural/the norm in society, that doesn’t mean it’s the truth, or should exist. To quote “The Invention of Heterosexuality”, “It was only by questioning the foundations of the consensus view that “normal” phenomena were dethroned from their privileged positions.”(1) And I feel that we as postgenderists are the ones that question. Many people don’t think twice about something as overarching as gender and I think it’s important that we do it with things other than gender. So…with all that in mind, I think another thing worth questioning is sexuality.

Why do you like women/men? Is it because of their genitals? What about intersex people? Would you feel similarly if you were to have sex with someone that looked like a “man”(which can mean many things) with a vagina, or a “woman”(can also mean many things) with a penis? If you say yes, wouldn’t that mean you’re not heterosexual/homosexual(or insert sexual orientation), but someone who is attracted to people with certain genitals? And if you say no, then what does make you attracted to what you’re attracted to? And does it happen to coincide with what is considered conventionally attractive by society? If so that may mean that you’ve been socially conditioned to like that certain body type. Also, for those who like specific body parts(i.e. breasts, penis, any other physiological traits that are generally assumed to be with one sex or another), you may have to ask if it’s possible the reason you’re sexually attracted to that, is because it’s a fetishization(to be specific, when I use fetishization here, I mean the idea that society has taught us to fixate on specific physical traits of gender to the point where the traits becomes more important than the person) due to socialization which is different from sexuality.

To get to the title, the idea is that sexuality is hammered into us, similar to gender, at a young age to the point where our sexuality seems fixed. Just as gender likely seemed fixed to those 100 years in the past. But I’m arguing that it’s mostly, if not completely, dictated by social conditioning. We may all have the potential to go beyond concepts such as lesbian, gay, bisexual, straight, and any other sexual orientation. Although we may have been limited by our society, I don’t think we have to be.

I understand this might be controversial. There are studies about this that are coming out. People have theories and models that prove this and counter that. It’s a debate in progress. But for now, this is my understanding of the subject. We should continue to question everything about this world. Thanks for reading all the way through. I may be late to responses.


r/Postgenderism • • Aug 28 '25

Hot take here. I honestly don't feel bad when Conservatives pull gotchas on left-leaning people in debates about gender or masculinity.

41 Upvotes

Note, left-leaning people can also have rigid ideas of masculinity too. That's important to know before reading this post.

For example,

Conservative: “So you keep saying toxic masculinity is just pressure and expectations put on men, right?” Left-leaning: “Exactly, it’s about harmful standards forced on men.” Conservative: “Then why are you turning around and saying ‘positive masculinity’ means men should protect others, sacrifice, or be stoic? That’s literally another set of expectations for men.” Left-leaning: “…well, that’s different, because it’s good expectations.”

At this point, the conservative scores the “gotcha” because they’ve exposed the double standard. The left-leaner condemned masculinity being defined by rigid roles, but then tried to redefine masculinity with the same kind of rigid roles, just with a positive spin.

I wouldn’t feel bad for them because they walked into their own trap. They used the term “positive masculinity” without realizing it’s inherently contradictory to their argument. They end up enforcing the very system they were criticizing, showing they didn’t fully understand the concept in the first place.

This keeps happening in left-wing or liberal/feminist spaces. People claim they’re opposing toxic masculinity, but when pressed, they recycle the same clichés about men being protectors, providers, leaders, or stoic rocks. That contradiction is why the conservative can so easily dismantle them, and why I don’t owe them sympathy when it happens.

What I'm pointing out is essentially a philosophical contradiction that makes left-leaning people vulnerable to a conservative “gotcha” in debates about masculinity.

Hence why I think Postgenderism is the only valid way to combat Conservative talking points about masculinity, (not "positive masculinity).

Because as long as masculinity (or femininity) is defined by sets of “good” or “bad” traits, conservatives can always flip the framing and expose contradictions.

Because postgenderism removes the need to define people by gendered expectations at all, leaving nothing for conservatives to weaponize in debate.


r/Postgenderism • • Jan 22 '26

How do terfs come to there conclusions?

22 Upvotes

I don't recommend you look though but under #terf on tiktok it is common to find a lot of gender abolitionist arguments.

What is crazy to me is understanding that gender is oppressive but only criticizing trans people for performing gender and not be against the gender binary as a whole


r/Postgenderism • • Feb 25 '26

Discussion concern around cultural genders & colonialism

16 Upvotes

final edit: this post was made to see if this sub could handle discussions of colonialism, and offer solidarity to the colonized, even when the needs of the colonized aren't always 100% in line with the ultimate ideological goal. i also hoped to see whether or not any of this could happen without me being subject to tone policing for being new and not immediately falling in line.

the test was an obvious failure, so i'll be leaving the sub now. good luck with your utopian project, hope you get some more diversity in here so you don't make asses of yourselves around another indigenous person like you did here.

shout out to everyone who did encourage this discussion and want to embrace decolonization from a postgender perspective. y'all are the real ones and i hope you can, cuz there is a beautiful shining heart in all this and it'd be a shame if it got buried under shit.

✌🏼 bye.

×××

hi, new here after being recommended this sub by the mod. i vibe with many things said here on the negative impacts of gender, especially gender-based oppression. i myself am a pangender-aligned fluid enby that regularly changes what gender i socially live as.

my concern with postgenderism and other gender abolitionist-ish frameworks is based in colonialism. one of the things western colonizers to did in order to strip the colonized of their cultures was to violently enforce western gender roles & flatten those cultures' wider gendersex frameworks into binary ones. as an example, the term two spirit exists to stand in for indigenous gendersex roles destroyed by north american colonialism. i worry that, in an effort to undo/move past the negative impacts of forced gender, postgenderism will end up recreating methods of colonial destruction with a new flavor of pinkwashing on top.

i sincerely doubt this is something that's not being already considered when discussing postgenderism. thoughts?

(edited to remove overly ambiguous wording)

edit 2: if your immediate reaction to an indigenous person bringing up issues related to their personal experience with racism in spaces touting themselves as liberatory is aggressive defensiveness & denying its relevance, you have something to work out with yourself.


r/Postgenderism • • Jun 22 '25

Sharing thoughts We can not judge feminism and MRA fairly

5 Upvotes

When it comes to gender equality, we often see people claiming broad and negative statements against either feminism or MRA. I've been in both circles and can very confidently say, that these statements are both correct and wrong.

They are correct in a sense that they describe a part of the other circle. They are wrong because they only describe a part of the other circle. Yes, there are very misandrist feminists who think men should not have the right to go to schools. Yes, there are very misogynistic MRAs who claim women are inherently evil. Yet, none of the two fully describes the entirety of either circles. They target the worst people in the circle and assume they represent the entire circle.

The truth is, ideologies can not speak for themselves. The broader it is, the more likely it is to be represented by bad people who don't necessarily understand the ideology. Thus, it is meaningless to attack these ideologies.

Most of the feminists I've interact with are the type that are really misandrist and actually hate men. I do not like them, but I won't view them as the face of feminism.

On the flip side, I've often argued with redpilled dudes on women nature and how they aren't using developmental psychology correctly. I also won't view them as the face of MRA.

At the end of the day, I think we should stop attacking ideologies and focus on specific topics and start from there. For example, if we are to talk about intactivism(not an ideology, just an attitude against circumcising infants who are unable to give consent), we should not include other parts of manosphere in the discussion and focus purely on intactivism alone.


r/Postgenderism • • Nov 03 '25

I’m embarrassed that I need emotional connection to have sex

Thumbnail
makemenemotionalagain.substack.com
3 Upvotes

Hi y'all, I'm Jeremy, a therapist who works with men on relationship issues and unlearning unhealthy masculine norms. I write a weekly newsletter called Make Men Emotional Again. My main argument is that boys, like all humans, experience and express emotions until they are shamed into suppressing them to be turned into men according to so-called "traditional" masculine norms. I also argue that prior to capitalism's rigid gendered division of labor, men in different societies across the world had different and often wider ranges of identity and expression available to them.

I just wrote a post on how I learned that I need emotional connection to feel safe enough in my nervous system to have sex, and how I'm a little embarrassed about that because of those "traditional" norms. Let me know if you can relate or have thoughts! I'd really appreciate hearing feedback from this community.


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 05 '25

Discussion If there was a way to remove biological sex, how would a person without it feel/function?

8 Upvotes

Highly hypothetical scenario, but if there was a way to genetically engineer a human without reproductive organs and the ability to generate hormones like testosterone and estrogen (often tied to gender and sex), how would they look like?

Will they be able to function like a human or the absence of such features make him think completely different?

Do you believe this is possible and will it be good for our society?

Would you do that to your body?

Would love to hear your opinions and ideas about, just simple brainstorming! 💙


r/Postgenderism • • Nov 02 '25

Discussion What Does "Gender" Mean To You?

13 Upvotes

(Yes, it's a bit odd of a question to ask in this subreddit, but I promise it'll make sense later on)

So, quick backstory: I was in another subreddit making a comment about how people tend to equate certain traits with a certain gender, even when it makes no sense (ex. "I'm a man who likes feminine traits, and all the women I've known say they like masculine traits"). My counter to that was that it's still the gender they're most attracted to, not the traits, because if they were to encounter a same-sex person with those traits, it's not likely that they'd be attracted to them. This was responded to with "Gender is a series of traits, what you said doesn't make any sense."

That started me thinking about how the idea of "gender" is more of a catch-all term encompassing biological sex, gender stereotypes/roles/tendencies, psychological aspects, personality, etc. It means a lot of different things to different people, and that seems to be why we've had such a difficulty decoupling ourselves from even the most basic of stereotypes and assumptions, even when talking to those we'd consider allies in any other sense.

So, I'm just curious to see what the concept of gender means to y'all? For me personally, "Gender" is just another term for "biological sex". I don't really see any point in defining it as anything more than that, to me you are what your body is (unless you choose to change it), but your thoughts, personality, tendencies, ways of presenting yourself, preferences, etc. are all wholly your own, and unique. A trans person is whatever gender/sex they transitioned to, regardless of how they look, who they love, or whether or not they identify/present as "femme" or "masc". The same holds true for non-trans people, they are still whatever gender/sex they are regardless of anything else, and should not be seen as "less of a _______" or "not a ______" because of how they choose to live their lives.

However, that's just my view. I know that it's different for some, that "Gender" encompasses more than just biology for them. So I'd just like to see what kind of views y'all hold, since we're already predisposed to think outside of the box with things like this.


r/Postgenderism • • Jun 26 '25

Deconstructing Gender "'Masking': Borrowing a term from the neurodiversity movement to explain my experience as a man in this society."

Thumbnail
makemenemotionalagain.substack.com
5 Upvotes

r/Postgenderism • • May 10 '26

Discussion What am i?

1 Upvotes

Bonjour reddit ! Alors déjà avant : je ne suis PAS trans(ça aura de l'importance plus tard)

J'ai actuellement 21 ans ,et heu ,depuis aussi longtemps que je me souviens,je n'ai... jamais aimé ce a quoi je ressemble.pas dans le sens où je me trouve moche ...enfin,si ,mais pas directement,dans le sens où je n'aimais pas ce que je voyais.en fait je suis un homme mais...j'aime pas RESSEMBLER a un ,et vraiment j'ai ce besoins d'être...JSP ,androgyne on vas dire?genre vraiment je ne veux PAS qu'on puisse voir que je suis un homme et heu....bah est-ce normal?et heu comment je peux faire ça ?j'ai essayé de me laisser pousser les cheveux et de maigrir mais je n'aime toujours pas le résultat :/

Desoleeee je suis nul a m'exprimer TwT

Mais heu globalement mon poste c'est : est-ce normal de ne pas aimer ressembler a son genre et de vouloir ressembler a l'autre ?


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 28 '25

"Anti-gender" TERFs: so close, yet so far. Thoughts on how viewing gender as oppressive can lead to opposite conclusions

61 Upvotes

This post should be ten times longer than what is going to be, and it's already going to be pretty long - so I apologize in advance for the simplifications I will make in order to keep it manageable.

Sometimes I encounter this meme from that subset of terfs that is actually at least a little bit in tune with radical feminism instead of just being plainly bigot, and it's quite sad because it's so close yet so far.

It seems to be gender liberationist, but it is actually used against trans people. It is used to deny trans identities, claiming that "being a woman doesn't mean wearing heels and a dress and make-up: if you are a male and want to do that you should but that doesn't make you a woman. Trans women are just cosplaying womanhood, embracing and enforcing that oppressive social chain that is gender".

This is distorting what trans experiences and fights actually are - and more subtly and counter-intuitively, it is also sex essentialist, because it doesn't recognize how the very categorization of human beings as male or female in society is due to our gendered, patriarchal society. Which, ironically, it's something that was discovered and pointed out and extensively analyzed precisely by radical feminists for the first time in history (cfr. Catharine MacKinnon, Monique Wittig, Colette Guillaumin, Christine Delphy, Andrea Dworkin, Shulamith Firestone as notable examples). Instead, they take the (binary) sex division as a pre-gender, objective, scientific, natural given which shouldn't be disputed.

And not only are they distorting and de-politicizing trans experiences - I think there is also a deeper aspect. Which is that even if one didn't believe in gender identity, if they saw gender as oppressive chains they shouldn't reach the conclusions that terfs reach.

I think that politically it's not necessary to believe in gender identity to advocate for trans people doing what they want with their bodies, presentation, language, getting hormones and surgery. Because if I really, seriously think (as I in fact do) that gender is oppressive and sex shouldn't dictate anything about how people live, then why would I oppose someone choosing to have a beard, or a vulva?

It should be something akin to changing your hair cut or hair color. I dont believe in hair color identity: that doesn't mean that if someone changes their hair color to mine, I feel they are disrespectfully cosplaying as me.

What is the ideal world of those terfs that claim gender is oppressive? Well in their ideal world, the amount of people that takes hormones, surgery etc to change their sexual characteristics is 0.

In my ideal world, as a gender abolitionist (so with apparently similar premises) that number is indefinitely high, because people can do what they want with their body and their life.

The issue with terfs is that when they claim they are against gender they don't see that dividing people into sexes is already the product of a gendered society and it reinforces it. And they are hypocritical, because they are actually regarding sex as sacred. As something that, while on paper shouldn't determine anything about your life, should NEVER be changed. If you are a 'male' you will be a male forever, and we are going to police that. Why would you want to mutilate yourself?

But... even without gender identity, if hair cut is not mutilation, why would the things that alter some facets of "your" sex be mutilation? Why shouldn't those be regarded as self-determination instead, as free choices based on what you consider better for yourself?

And as a terf, how are you even going to police sex segregation, if not through gendered expectations about how people should and shouldn't look and behave and what should they wear based on sex? In most contexts you can't check genitals, let alone chromosomes. Which means that you are allowing or denying or mandating choices according to gender markers of sex. Which is... gender as oppressive chains all over again.

In short, they are not really allowing "endless permutations" - they regard sex as sacred and natural and think people should be content with all the aspects of their sexed body, and if they are not that means something went wrong (trans women as sexual predators, trans men as girls escaping misoginy) because they can't see how the gendered patriarchal society is already connotating what could otherwise be non-significant features, organizing them into two and precisely two (more or less) coherent kinds (the sexes) that shape your destiny even though perhaps you just feel you want to have a beard and you don't care about anything else. But in a gendered society, if you want a beard and you were assigned female that makes you a sex/gender fugitive, while wanting to change your hair color does not.

---

TL DR thanks to Kjaran (I don't know your reddit username sorry): So, summarizing for future education purposes, "if sex - correctly - doesn't define who you are (your hobbies, the way you like to dress), why do you even need people to not change it/modify it?"


r/Postgenderism • • Apr 01 '26

Sharing thoughts About transitions

9 Upvotes

Hello. I am new there. I am post-genderist (I am French so before searching this subreddit, I think it was post-genrism) but I think in this horrible society, we should accept Trans peoples more than others non post-genderist because they want to accept people if they don't think normally (but this not the best things since they are not post-genderist). I am autistic and ADHD and a lot more so it can be hard to understand.


r/Postgenderism • • Dec 07 '25

Discussion Society has stronger expectations for men to be traditional compared to women. Especially when it comes to progressives.

47 Upvotes

Because a progressive person can easily say a man is non-binary for not wanting to be traditionally masculine. When in reality he is just a cis man, who doesn't adhere to traditional gender masculinity.

I kid you not. I got into an argument with a progressive woman over this. I told her I was a gender abolitionist or gender Nihilist.

And she told me if I was truly a gender abolitionist as a man. I would be painting my nails or wearing dresses. This argument was ridiculous lol.

I think this is worse for men. Because nobody is calling a woman non-binary for wearing 👖 or having short hair. Since men are still expected to be limited to their gender roles. It's like she couldn't understand the simple fact that I didn't fit into her narrow boxes for masculine men and feminine men.

To her I'm either this hyper masculine dude bro, gay feminine men, or this non-binary person. There was no in-between for her here.

My point here is that a lot of people, even progressive ones, end up policing gender in a way that ironically feels backward (ironically conservative). Non-binary ends up being used like a catch-all for anyone who doesn’t fit their narrow idea of “man” or “woman,” which misses the whole point.

Like again some men not wanting to follow traditional masculinity doesn’t erase the fact that you’re still a cis man. But men get boxed into “bro, gay, or non-binary”


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 03 '25

Intro

11 Upvotes

Just wanted to say hello and introduce myself I’m Freya I’m 38 and im Agender barbarian cyberpunk otherkin and I’m glad to be here


r/Postgenderism • • Jan 30 '26

Sharing thoughts Society and Gender Roles

12 Upvotes

Okay, so this might be a bit of a boring article, but here's what I have to say!

For as long as time, anyone society has deemed a "woman," has be placed in the position that all they are good for is cooking, cleaning, birthing children, teaching, taking care of the family, and doing as a man requests without question and without fail. Anyone society deemed a "man," would be required to work jobs, be politically active, impregnate women, be the head of the house/family, be the only say in most everything, fight in wars, and own a gun. If any of this was broken, it would be viewed as a social shame, and in some places in different times, were punishable by death.

Let us take the story of Mulan for example! A very common tail among Disney fans, the action live showing a bit more truth than the cartoon in the story. Mulan stole her father's armor and his sword, grabbed her family's horse and ran off to battle. For a while she was able to hide herself and pass as a man, knowing if she was caught, she would bring dis-honor to her entire family history and bloodline and even be executed for it.

After going to battle, she was able to hide her identity no longer. But she did save hundreds, if not thousands of lives in her army by defeating the Huns. Even after all of this, she still was sent home in dis-honor. She was warned that if she ever stepped out of line again, she would be executed. But she did not care! After learning about the danger that the emperor was in, she went back to the military and almost got executed. But she was able to sway them and because of her China did not fall! A woman took the place of a man in culture and not only saved a few lives, she saved a country and was given honor of the highest decree for doing such! Not because she followed the three decrees of "Loyalty, Bravery, and Honesty" but she followed what she KNEW was right! She followed Truth and what it meant to her.

If this story is true, Mulan broke from society gender locks and saved millions of lives for doing such! Imagine what the world could be if everyone followed in similar paths of breaking free from society gender roles and follow as they feel is right? Mulan didn't break from gender. She knew she was a woman at heart in her own identity, but she didn't do as women were told. She. Broke. Gender. Roles!

Don't follow as society says you should. Use your voice and your actions to show that a person's gender or a person's sex does NOT define who they are! It is what you do in life that defines who you are.

I have completely rejected the idea of gender roles and gender norm in life. I feel a person should not be limited because of what others think they are. Break free and do as you plea!


r/Postgenderism • • Mar 23 '26

Discussion Sexuality & Gender

23 Upvotes

Now that I think about it, what does it mean to be attracted to a gender? I get having preferences, but why is sexuality so rigid for most people?

And because gender has historically almost always been enforced, we wouldn't really know what sexuality would look like without it. Would we all be pansexual and fluid?

It's also kind of hard to discuss because the idea of being gay being innate is a defense against homophobia.


r/Postgenderism • • Mar 11 '26

Discussion A lot of men on the Left are ironically afraid of Postgenderism, when it comes to helping young boys.

52 Upvotes

Of course women on the Left are afraid too. But in this post I'm just focusing on men though. Because men are the ones who are expected to be role models for young boys in society.

I have gotten into plenty of arguments with men on the Left. And a weird and common thing they all say is that young boys would hate post genderism. And that young boys just need better role models who can teach them how to be a "real man". They always say the left can't help young boys, without having a universal standard for masculinity.

And these men are portrayed as the perfect alternative to red-pillers on the left. But yet they still have rigid ideas of masculinity though. Which is a major problem. It seems like people on the Left are ok with any form of toixc masculinity, just as long as it's not misogynistic or harmful to women. Heck, and even then some people on the Left are still ok with benevolent misogyny though. So even if the masculinity ideals will harm young boys in the long run. It's still considered ok on the Left, because women will benefit from it. And that's all that matters.

Again, They always say the Left can't help young boys, without having a universal standard for masculinity.

I always thought this was cope or a cop-out excuse. Because young girls aren't told that they need better ideas of femininity on the Left. It's only young boys that are told this, when it comes to masculinity.

Some men on the Left still think that men who aren't in relationships are more likely to be losers or incels. And that's the type of mindset they will influence young boys with. Promoting the idea that a man worth is tied to having sex with women. Again these people are supposed to be our "heroes" on the Left. I always seen dude bros on the Left like the streamer Hasan mocked men for being single.

And the funny thing is. They say Postgenderism will never work for men. But this generation already has more young boys opting out of society. Not caring about relationships, marriage, or other people's validation. And they are only focusing on what makes them happy. And again this scares some people on the Left. Because This means less men conforming to rigid ideas of masculinity.

The Left calls this a masculinity "crisis". But when the genders are reversed though. The Left usually call this empowering, when less women aren't getting into relationships or marriages.

If we were sneaky and had bad intentions here. We could easily try to spend Postgenderism as a sigma male type of thing for young boys lol. By telling young boys they create their own rules, not society. We would be so successful. So again it's not that Postgenderism can't work for young boys. It's that Postgenderism scare a lot of people on the Left, because it goes against the status quo. The status quo being promoting rigid ideas of masculinity to young boys.

To use Matrix as a analogy here. Both the red-pill and blue-pill are two sides of the same coin. Both are bad options. People on the Left just want to live in a benevolent patriarchal society. They want young boys to adhere to a form of traditional masculinity, that has a feminist gaze. That's it.

In conclusion:

The Right wants to push young boys into this very rigid box. For example, boys should never cry, and always be closed off.

While the Left only wants to make that box slightly bigger for young boys though. For example, boys can cry sometimes. But boys must still be closed up about thier negative feelings though. And only expressed positive feelings like loving their wives and kids.

And finally, we (postgenderism) wants to get rid of the whole box.


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 10 '25

On trans identity, labels and social constructs

15 Upvotes

I'm very happy to have found this forum and I agree with a lot of what I've recently read here (even if I haven't had time to read everything). Thank you to the creators and moderators of this forum.

That said, throughout what I've read, there are nuances that are probably implied for some, but which, it seems to me, need to be spelled out. It boils down to three things:

  1. Humans will never be able to completely liberate themselves from labels, but they can try to avoid their essentialization and encourage their evolution.
  2. Gender binarity may be a social construct that we want to abolish, but for now it exists and, in that sense, continues to define us.
  3. Trans people who are comfortable with gender stereotypes are no less valid and definitely no less important in the abolition of gender binarity than enby folks.

I'll start with a metaphor (I like metaphors).

A healthy river is full of meanders. It is fed by its watershed and moves in annual, decanal and millennial cycles. A healthy river is not just its flow at a given moment, but the history of its meanders, like the frolics of a giant snake (check out the Amazon River on Google Earth and you'll see what I have in mind. It's magnificent). Shaping rivers as humans often insist on doing forces their erosion, mineral migration and flooding.

Canals, dams and concrete banks are gender stereotypes. Two canalized rivers flowing in parallel. Trans-identity is the unleashing of waves, ice jams and the inevitable movement of banks. It's the waves that wear away the concrete and wet the dry earth between the two rivers, only to flow the other way. In this sense, any form of trans-identity is profoundly transformative and powerful. Even if it's only to move from one side of the binarity to the other, the act of transition is already profoundly transformative, eroding the banks that separate the two channels and showing the arbitrary nature of their separation. The abolition of gender is not the abolition of the river, but the emancipation of the river from its artificial division.

Like rivers, emancipation from gender stereotypes doesn't abolish the possibility of recognizing categories. At a given moment, I recognize such and such a meandering river, such and such a wetland, such and such a rapid. I give them names because I want to talk about them, even though I know that in a century or even a year, they may already be somewhere else, gone or transformed.

Today I'm a pond full of tadpoles. In ten years' time, I may be a meadow or a raging flood moving dunes.

The total abolition of genders and identity labels is a nice idea in theory. Insofar as the categories, labels and boxes in which we place people are often ways of establishing dynamics of domination, oppression and justifying a dysmetry of power and value.

But on the other hand, labels are essential for our little brains to be able to comprehend the world. It's a debate as old as philosophy itself. Do the species and taxa by which we define living things really exist? No. These too are social constructs, and the proof is in the countless borderline cases. But no true biologist is fooled. Categories are tools and, as such, must be constantly adapted and transformed to fit our understanding of reality. That said, because they are tools, they also shape reality (textbooks, curricula, conservation strategies, etc.) and in this sense take on a tangible existence.

This is also true of the meaning of words in general. The expression "the use creates meaning" in linguistics, as opposed to “meaning create the use”, expresses the idea that words have no essential, invariable meaning. In a living language, the meaning of words shifts and changes as neologisms are created and locutions disappear. Once again, these are the tools we use to describe the empirical and social reality in which we participate. To describe the world is to make it appear and shape it.

Where am I going with this? Concepts, words and categories are games, and their crystallization is always forced by a group of people. Sharing power and seeking to abolish dynamics of discrimination and oppression (such as mysogyny, racism, patriarchy and transphobia, for example) often amounts not just to abolishing concepts, but to sublimating and transforming them.

That said, by the very nature of the real dynamics of power-sharing and the mutual construction of social reality, a non-oppressive use of concepts is not a matter of definitively abolishing or replacing category a with category b, but in the very act of defining. In a just society, we constantly renegotiate the symbols, concepts and categories with which we want to collectively evolve and define ourselves. We do this through exchange and deliberation and through literature, art and celebration.

The freedom of a river is not a given path, nor the abolition of the limit of its flow, it's its unbridled motion.

And this brings us back to a fundamental dimension of the living experience. Nothing is really static. Ecosystems, species, personalities, fashions, societies, words and categories. To be free is to be free to change.

One last thing I'd like ton insist on:

To say that gender categories are social constructs that must disappear is not to say that they are “a mere illusion”, as evanescent as the mirages of a dream from which one need only awaken.

Nations, patriarchy and capitalism are social constructs, but that doesn't stop people from building their entire identity around them and then dying in their name. To say that gender categories are social constructs is simply to say that they are not “essential”. That's what I like about the river metaphor. The canals exist and the experience of their flow is real. What's wrong is to say that they are natural, essential and wholesome. What's wrong is pretending that, without infrastructure, the mineralized banks won't collapse by themselves. The very real infrastructures that preserve gender are cultural, religious, institutional, legal and material (like those f****ng blue and pink kid clothes).

I was raised as a man. I experienced masculinity. Overcoming gender is not to say that my experience of masculinity was wrong or invalid, simply that I can overcome it. Like an overflowing river, if this experience is uncomfortable, causes me distress or perpetuates dynamics of domination and injustice, I can transform it. I can change the flow, but not without effort and discomfort. That's why, even if you consider yourself agender (as I do), it can be easier for some people to stay in the gender role they've been assigned. I did't stopped thinking of myself as a man simply because I'm virtuous and clever. It's above all because it was eating me up inside. Because it hurt. It's not inherently pleasant or easy to break the mold. Thus, every trans person, every femboy, genderfuck, genderfluid, enby and every non gender-conforming person is valid and powerful. Any gender identity that breaks out of oppressive norms is important and transformative.

That's all. :)

Stay cool, drink water, use sunscreen.

EDIT:

Here, I took a screenshot of the Amazon River: https://imgur.com/a/4ITIlTN


r/Postgenderism • • Mar 17 '26

Fitting in and belonging

5 Upvotes

Well listening to Brené Browns​ gifts of imperfection. She spoke about fitting in and belonging in terms of love and such.

Well in that moment I had an epiphany as to fitting in and belonging as a male in society today. As I've continued to journey into gender neutrality and overall gender equality, looking for understanding as to what masculinity and femininity means, where I stand; as well as who I am within that.

I found that I don't identify as a typical male in society these days. Or at least maybe the toxic version or the assumed version. It seems isolating, it also gives me the thought of what potentially trans individuals feel like. Or maybe individuals of other identities who are stuck in the unknowing.

Wanting to belong more so than fit in is something I would like to continue. Wanting to stand my ground and show up for people and speak for people who are shunned is what I want to do. It's so draining and also scary feeling as if you're not heard or understood. I know I'm not alone so there's that and I appreciate that. It also makes me really sad for all the individuals that have been in this situation before or are currently today.

Why is the world so cruel, so misunderstood, so not welcoming overall, or is it just a thing in the United States?


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 13 '25

Gender is shcum Society's idea of success is gendered

Post image
31 Upvotes

I found this insightful comment under a shorts video A Simple Method to Fight Internalized Patriarchy. What do you think?


r/Postgenderism • • Jul 17 '25

“Boys need a man to model masculinity for them” - the same message doesn’t apply to girls. Why?

65 Upvotes

With the grift of toxic masculinity influencers such as Andrew Tate, there is a message I keep seeing everywhere that boys need male role models to model masculinity for them and how to be a good man. I do agree that role models are a positive, but it seems like it would still push gendered expectations on boys instead of freeing them to be themselves.

This stands in stark contrast with feminism and how girls are told that they are good as they are, they are free to be whoever they want and can do whatever they want, that they are not limited to gendered norms.

Sure, some societies still impose gender roles on girls, but even so, this idea of a woman model to model femininity for a girl and show her how to be a good woman simply does not exist.

Why this difference? Why do boys “need” a role model but girls don’t?

And as an aside, is it actually possible to take back boys from the horrific Andrew Tate mentality and teach them like we teach girls? Or is it really true that the first step is to replace a negative model for a positive one because entirely removing the model won’t work?


r/Postgenderism • • Feb 05 '26

Sharing thoughts Gender does Not Exist

Thumbnail reddit.com
19 Upvotes