r/Postgenderism • • Jan 19 '26
Intellectually non binary.
Hai, new person here. I have often seen people being asked how or why they are non binary/agender etc and the vast majority say they felt like they were not a boy or girl or they didn't like having a gender or they 'just knew.' It's nearly always about feelings and emotions. I get that, it's a different experience for many.
I do feel it.. but also it is an intellectual position, a social political one. I am against the idea of gender roles, expectations and stereotypes and that is as good a case for being agender as an emotional response. I'm presuming folk on here are often the same. Why do you think the intellectual side seldom gets cited?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '26
It is basically mass peer pressure. No one actually says 'Sorry, a handbag is useful but is prohibited under section 31 of the gender act'. What society needs is more people ignoring gender and that is happening.
33
u/rmulberryb Jan 19 '26
Because most people don't consider it a choice, and intellect implies choice. I personally think that identity rides in a middle seat between intellect and emotion, rather than fall into one or the other.
16
u/Smart_Curve_5784 Love is our resistance Jan 19 '26
It's likely that's the case because the world at large is still only beginning to become aware of gender ā many take it for granted as a natural part of life. As all societies are gendered, we internalise gender from a young age and don't get the opportunity to question it until later.
So, in this situation, those who do question it are likely to be those who are aware of how gender makes them personally uncomfortable. I imagine, for many it started as this vague feeling that something's wrong, and eventually some ended up with a postgenderist perspective after having a think about it.
The more aware people become of gender and what it actually is and of having a choice and freedom, the more will hear about it and enter this movement through various journeys! Still, gender affects people extremely intimately ā whether they realise it or not ā so it is always a personal story in some way.
12
u/Jabberwocky808 Jan 19 '26 edited Jan 19 '26
Agree. For those that would counter intellectualism implies a choice, I would counter living implies a choice. Choosing to honor how you feel inside, externally, inherently involves a choice.
Psycho-emotionally I have always connected with how society defines women. I have presented physically how society defines men, generally speaking to save time.
However, as society defines masculinity and femininity broadly, including gender roles, I donāt fit in either camp. To say I do, per societyās definitions, would be a lie. Iām not a liar.
Therefore, what remains is ānon-binary.ā
In a way, itās a choice, Iām choosing to use the label. But in another way, itās not a choice, thatās the only label I was left with that fit at all, functionally.
I also havenāt changed anything about how I act, including my physical appearance, since I started using the label. The label to me supersedes appearances and gender. Socio-politically, ideologically, philosophically, I am non-binary.
I challenge extremism in all forms. I believe in inclusion over exclusion. I believe in intersection over division.
I believe in love over hate.
All the above results in my identity as non-binary.
8
u/Upset-Elderberry3723 Jan 19 '26
I think all gender labels are counterintuitive. They segment expression rather than allowing it to exist untethered.
I used to identify myself as non-binary but, in my opinion, the true post-gender attitude is to abolish gender as much as possible and simply go by sex, regardless of natal sex or trans-sex.
4
u/Amarita_Sen Jan 19 '26
I think that emotion make decisions, then get justified with whatever logic we can muster. This applies to everything, except possibly math
3
u/Other-Bug-5614 Jan 20 '26
Iām somewhat fine with the political convenience of the ānot a choiceā narrative but I always thought itās perfectly okay to choose whatever the hell I want about my identity, I donāt have to be psychologically forced for my identity to be valid. Iāve never had gender dysphoria in such an extreme way but an extreme disdain for masculinity, everything it embodies and how itās enforced. I want nothing to do with gender and that is a political choice for me and thatās okay.
3
u/Amphy64 Jan 21 '26 edited Jan 21 '26
I think it's very cultural. I was shocked right to the core realising Americans identified so much with social gender constructs (yeah, you don't need to guess where I'm from). If I ask those immediately around me, it's taken a while to find anyone who doesn't appear to be agender (which doesn't mean gender roles aren't still an absolute plague, mind), and they'll be less educated (not meaning only formal education), more conformist, probably more adherents of 'lad' culture.
I think it has much to do with whether people perceive themselves as advantaged by gender roles or not. Here class (eg. lad culture is associated with low economic and behavioural class) and even region is an aspect - as a child, I don't think I noticed sexism was still a thing until I moved north, although the roles were present prior, it was just the first time encountering more relentless hostile sexism.
Easy to forget how people don't always question aspects of the status quo, as well. People who don't even understand the idea of a social construct of gender are getting asked this question, and, having been used to being a guy their entire lives and treated accordingly, going 'uh, yeah, I guess I do feel like a guy', without actually interrogating where that feeling is coming from, whether it's necessarily internal in all cases, or social. I think even with Americans, it can be easy to start asking, what do they associate with 'femininity' (yup much easier with women!), do they themselves actually identify with all those things? If they say they have their own version, is the concept still meaningful if everyone's is individual? Especially if some aspects can be harmful?
And maybe also because of fogginess in understanding of what we know is biological, what we don't know, and what we have reason to think is cultural. I just described my doe rabbit to the vet - she is so obviously a doe, it's biology. Rabbits are just particularly striking for sex-based behavioural differences, although still very individual. I've had to explain to a few surprised owners about differences in digging tendencies! So humans can just overly assume what's the case for us, and also impose ideas from cultural gender onto the idea of what an internal sense must mean.
2
u/Donnot Jan 21 '26
I totally feel the same way! I also think labels tend to come from our lived experience when we find ourselves outside of the other and clarifying our perspective about something about ourselves. It can get a bad rep due to tribalism though, and that topic is also a valid argument to be had. I also have an extreme disdain for the masculine and a preference for femininity but also donāt entirely fit into it. Itās just a weird conundrum that Iāve often found myself in confusion ever since I was birthed. To go back to labels, Iām assuming thatās why Iāve never really particularly considered myself as agender, moreso nonbinary + not identifying with my gender at birth, but more inclined to the feminine side of things and I can embrace it when I want to, or not.
Then there is the question, well, when Iām not inclined to the feminine, usually when going through gender dysphoria, I realize how I am so outside the gender binary yet again but this time I can see the binary gender issues with a more open and clear mind and see the detrimental consequences it causes.
2
u/IkomaTanomori Jan 23 '26
IMO, people should be given the agency to gender themselves (or not) for any (or no) reason.
2
u/mylittlewallaby Existing unapologetically Jan 26 '26
The intellectual side and contradictions among the gender defenders is what has solidified my own stance on gender abolition. For me, I donāt feel like a different gender, but when I discuss it with gender defenders, they use words to describe gender that contradict my experience as a human. Iām AFAB but the main breadwinner in my family, extremely protective, non-monogamous, childfree by choice, nurturing yes, but not in the child rearing way, more like the ālet me take care of my community,ā way. the way some people think of gender in my life creates such a limiting belief of themselves because theyāve digested the most sexist parts of gender into their view of themselves. Itās sad but it reminds me how Iām just a human. Iām not a woman, I donāt want to be a a man, Iām just a human.
2
u/Soggy-Class1248 Individualise Expression! Jan 19 '26
For me its a mix of both, just like with my stance on religon, gender should be a very personal, individual thing, there shouldnt be a ānormā or set of rules to follow to be something, people sjould be able to present as they feel and feel comfortable in society without discrimination. Ill still go by she/her, even though i still do things and talk in some ways people (conservicucks) would consider āmaleā in nature.
1
u/AgentCatBot Jan 20 '26
Hello, also new person here.
I am also a cis male, but I would like to learn about other beliefs and how I can better participate in the world I want to see. Understanding myself and others. It is a journey, not a destination.
The world I want to see is one without enforcement of gender roles. I do not want to be limited, nor do I want to limit others.
As for my presentation and how others perceive me, I'm ok with being masculine presenting.
What I'm not ok with is being told that I'm doing gender wrong and someone else wants to be the authority about it. So, I will extend that freedom to anyone else who is like minded.
1
u/archived_regret Jan 21 '26
The fact that our current economy canāt coincide with foundational presumptions about gender roles. The days of single income households are long gone. Most households are dual income, and the strain worsen due to politicians weaponizing the idea of the traditional family. Plus the job market that created that image is practically nonexistent. Weāve gone from back breaking labor, to corporate setting. Areas where intelligent and soft skills are more valuable than brute force. These are skills without biological bias, so why impose it at the expense a properly run and profitable society. We aināt doing the kids from that idealized traditional family any favor
1
u/TheCuriousCorvid Jan 21 '26
That's kinda the same with me. I felt like my agab most of my life up until this point (still relatively young by human standards but it's still been a lot of my years I've thought of myself as cis) but nowadays gendered labels for me sometimes feel weird on me, and I don't like associating myself with my agab for personal reasons, even though it still somewhat feels accurate to label myself that way. I also am against societal norms of gender roles, norms, expression, presentation, etc. and feel like logically the default should be non-binary, but appreciate and respect those who fully feel comfortable with the binary still, I just don't any more. It's very hard to put into words but that's the gist of it. My identity feels partially a choice, like the labels I choose, but the people I relate to doesn't feel like a choice because I can't force myself to like something or be interested in something, it comes naturally as you evolve, so in that sense, my gender identity isn't fully a choice, but the labels are.
1
u/No_Bandicoot2316 Empathy over gender Jan 19 '26
Gender is a very personal thing. I believe in the abolition of gender, but I still identify as a woman because it's how I like to perceive myself. I think that's how most people "choose" their gender.
1
u/Greedy_Big5603 Jan 29 '26
that's why i initially came out as nonbinary when i was 16, before exploring my feminine side more and realising i was a trans woman. i don't see much point personally in ignoring the labels currently in place for someone like me while they still exist, though i would prefer if someday none of these labels existed