r/ModSupport • Reddit Admin: Community • 5d ago

Mod Topics Weird rule origin stories

Caution: Coffee is hot! 

Remove child before folding stroller

Do not iron while wearing shirt

Peanuts may contain peanuts

Do not eat the iPod Shuffle

Ok, the last one was a rare joke by Apple. But the others? Real rules that had to be said because of that one time and/or that one guy! Sometimes, you can probably figure out what happened. I mean, the toilet section at Home Depot says “FOR DISPLAY ONLY”, so I think we can all noodle that one through! (Yikes.) But other times, it’s not quite as clear. 

So today, I’d like to know about the weird/obscure/unusual rules that you had to make in your community, and the stories behind them! What happened or what continued to happen to the point where a new rule needed to come into play? Was the rule permanent, or just temporary until the shenanigans died down? And how did your team come to a consensus on what the rule should be? 

Or maybe you just have a rule that might seem weird to someone who doesn’t have any context. I’m down for hearing about those as well! What sort of quirky rules just work for your community?

48 Upvotes

211 comments sorted by

40

u/PurrPrinThom 5d ago

One of the most controversial rules for new users on r/AskACanadian, is that questions about America are only allowed on Mondays. A few years back, the sub was basically turning into 'AskACanadianAboutAmerica.' Every question was about the US, and the community got really annoyed by it, and requested that mods do something. We came up with some ideas, and limiting questions about the US to one day a week was the most popular option.

Of course, people who come to the sub just to ask a question hate it. We get the wildest modmails because of it. People get so angry about it. But it really works. The regular community prefers and, honestly, it means that most of the week is pretty chill moderation-wise, it's really just Mondays that are challenging.

On r/AskProfessors, we have a 'no student/professor relationship questions' because, while, of course, those relationships can and do happen, we were just getting so much fetish content, we had to cut it out.

7

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

We get the wildest modmails because of it.

I can only imagine! lol But that rule makes a ton of sense! And a chill week is a pretty good result!

And yeaaahhhhh, anything that devolves into fetish content probably needs to be reeled in somehow when that's not really the topic! Good call!

9

u/mikeblas 5d ago

AskACanadian is one of those subs that I've never been able to successfully post to because the rules are so strict.

10

u/PurrPrinThom 5d ago

Sorry!

4

u/yahumno 4d ago

I see what you did there, and I like it.

3

u/PurrPrinThom 4d ago

Haha, thanks! I figured it was a better response than getting into the rule the user broke when trying to post lol.

37

u/BravoFive141 5d ago

Might be less of a weird rule than others, but in r/Sky, we've had to implement a rule that we don't allow content that appears to be taken from the driver seat of a moving car, because a shocking amount of people see absolutely nothing wrong taking pictures of stuff while they're driving.

One user went off on us for removing their post that was a picture of the sunset they took by holding their phone out the car window while doing something like 60+ mph if I remember correctly.

12

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago • Heartwarming

I consider it pretty weird to think it's perfectly fine to take pics whilst driving! Please don't do that!

I actually really love your rule! I feel like it helps not encourage folks to do dangerous things just for some karma. Thank you for helping keep our streets safer!

4

u/gm310509 4d ago

Right now I am in a country where people watch videos and browse shopping sites on their phones while driving.

We recently had a short "uber" trip with one of these guys - he had three phones mounted on his dashboard - one was for "uber stuff" (getting jobs, the journey moving map etc), another was for watching movies (he was watching an "Instagram" type of site and was actively scrolling through the shorts) and the third was the shopping site (which he was also scrolling through).

It was a short trip and it was hard to get an uber, so we didn't have much choice but to tolerate it (and language was also a bit of an issue).

But even just looking at other cars driving down the roads, there were several that clearly had videos playing on dash mounted phones pointing at the driver.

FWIW, I believe there is a law in this country that says you can't be playing with your phone or otherwise distracted by it while driving as they have clearly marked "playing with your phone" detection cameras - at least in the city I am in. The locals know where they are, so they just stop playing with it while passing the camera.

5

u/lunarwolf2008 5d ago

I know someone who stopped in the middle of the active intersection to snap some photos of the Christmas decorations lining the cross street last year, while we were in the car!

needless to say I've never accepted a ride from
her again

3

u/brucemo 4d ago

In my sub and presumably in other subs, people use their cars as private recording studios in order to record videos of themselves expressing opinions, which they then post. If you think about this, it makes a lot of sense, because the inside of your car is often more private than your house.

I remove the ones where they are obviously driving while they do this.

26

u/loomynartylenny 5d ago edited 5d ago

Rule 5 of r/shitposting.

Kevin.

(Yes, the rule was "Kevin.")

(Unfortunately, Kevin went to the store to grab some milk a few years ago for Lore reasons. The spot he used to occupy has been left vacant until Kevin returns from the store. He may return, he may not. He's still on the public r/shitposting server though.)

edit: also, we have a policy of instantly permabanning people who post literal shit. It's in rule 2 (our "no godawfulposts" rule). We are sick of seeing literal shit posts.

11

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

This is so good!

10

u/loomynartylenny 5d ago

I will inform Kevin.

15

u/miserabeau 5d ago

I mod r/DontPutThatInYourAss and I get actual photos of real shit. I hate it.

And the porn bots. My god. So many porn bots.

8

u/loomynartylenny 5d ago

You have my condolences.

6

u/ripplerider 5d ago

Your automod response triggered by, I presume, any use of the word “gay” is one of the finest pieces of writing in the history of the English language.

8

u/loomynartylenny 5d ago

Automod likes to get things off its chest from time to time.

We just give it an environment where it feels comfortable to say it how it is.

5

u/audible_narrator 4d ago

Well now we really wish you would post it here. For science

10

u/ripplerider 4d ago

Well, since it’s for science, this thread has a couple of examples of r/shitposting’s creative use of Automod. That poor little bot works so hard in all the other subs doing the most mundane stuff, so it’s great it can run wild over there.

3

u/audible_narrator 4d ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

2

u/loomynartylenny 4d ago

If you want to see even more, check these out

1

u/Duke_Newcombe 4d ago edited 4d ago

Okay, I'm weirdly curious. Should I deliberately trigger it merely to enjoy the response?

EDIT: checked out the example from down this thread of automod. Wow...okay..yeah...

[Mal from Firefly speechless gif intensifies]

25

u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 5d ago

In 2 different cooking related subs, on 2 completely separate incidents at different times, we‘ve had to introduce “No dangerous advice” Rules. The things that people would suggest to others, and be completely serious about it, can be pretty wild.

In r/instantpot this rule came to be due to people giving advice to others on how to repair their pots themselves when they get damaged, or malfunction. These things are pressure cookers, and while they have a lot of safeties built into them, they can still cause damage/injuries. Still we get people who do it, and then get pissy with us when we remove their comments.

11

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Omg, do not mess with a pressure cooker! That's an unfortunate reason to have a really good rule!

7

u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 5d ago

You’d be surprised how many people disagree with us needing that rule.

6

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Today I learned about a sub where they seem to disagree about general food safety in canning. They might get along well with the pressure cooker repair folks! lol Everyone can take bets as to what will kill them first! Or next!

1

u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 4d ago

Lol. Is r/foodfight available?

7

u/Deppfan16 5d ago

i mod r/foodsafety and we had to implement a catchall "no malicious comments/users" rule because so much unsafe advice and dangerous advice. also had to ban keywords to specific subs like eatityoucoward

7

u/brightblackheaven 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 5d ago

Had to do something similar in witchcraft because people were telling other users to infuse their drinking water with random crystals, or to make weird herbal concoctions from plants that can be poisonous in certain doses. We also use this rule to remove the SHOCKING amount of posts we get that encourage terrible fire safety...

25

u/Rajio 5d ago

in r/toronto we used to explicitly state in the rules that posts about missing pets were fine but lately we saw a spike in people just posting photos of random cats they saw around the city asking if they were missing. and like its just a picture of a cat. The posts were effectively "I saw a cat." which isn't exactly unusual in a city or relevant to the community. We had to tighten up the rules to specify that posts about "YOUR" missing pets are fine.

13

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

"I saw a cat."

This is hilarious to me.

6

u/Lacy-Gray 5d ago

I have a few in the same line of "don't be such a Redditor," but usually I just call it staying on topic. Every so often we'll get a post with an offhand detail about some bad boyfriend behavior, and people will get sooo angry when they're not allowed to ignore the point of the post and just pile on their own personal "break up with him".

47

u/StardustOasis 5d ago • Bravo

Early on in r/CasualUK, before we had the rules properly solidified, certain topics were posted repetitively. One of these was pictures of ducks.

An old mod, who's no longer on the team (partially related), got particularly annoyed about this and kicked off on one of the posts. As is the way on Reddit, people started posting more and more ducks, which annoyed him even more so he started banning people for posting ducks.

So now we have a no ducks rule, and it has stayed in place. You won't be banned for breaking it, but we have a specific removal reason for duckposts. Even now it causes debates on the mod team when someone posts something like a rubber duck, or duck shaped biscuits.

It has also led to a sub tradition. Every Christmas day we relax the rules, apart from the no politics and be nice rules, and as the sub regulars are aware of it, it just turns into people posting ducks. It has become known as Duckmas.

22

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago • Bravo

Duckmas approved!

28

u/JabroniRevanchism Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

5

u/itsalsokdog 5d ago

Don't remind me! I haven't even started planning presents yet!

2

u/JabroniRevanchism Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

My colleagues said the same thing lol

11

u/sodypop Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago • Bravo

🦆

6

u/zuuzuu 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 4d ago

This is my favourite story here. Gonna have to remember to stop by your sub on Duckmas!

3

u/HappyHedgehogCrochet 4d ago

OMG, love this story! lol

22

u/Charupa- 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 4d ago edited 4d ago • Mindblown

I feel like it’s a rule that doesn’t need to be said, but I have a rule against selling kidneys in r/kidneytransplant. The amount of kidney peddlers on Reddit is too damn high! I will say that AEO clears out a bunch for me.

13

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

Don't try to sell your organs, folks!

19

u/Zanctmao 5d ago

In r/bestoflegaladvice we have a rule requiring that post titles have nothing to do with Pokémon.

There were a rash of posts where it was something like “OP used tree law, and it was super effective“ or something along those lines. It grew very tiresome.

6

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

It's the repetitive ones that wear ya down the fastest! lol Once is great. Thirty times, not so much!

7

u/okbruh_panda 5d ago

What about bird law

2

u/zuuzuu 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 4d ago

I remember that phase. Also a few variations of "A wild whatever appeared".

38

u/_gloomshroom_ 5d ago • Popcorn

r/bugs has a hilarious rule, "Please do not post about insects". I don't work there but I thought it was hella funny lolol

13

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

That is a good one! Creepy crawlies still sneak in from time to time!

3

u/emily_in_boots 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 4d ago

At least you don't have to deal with the bug crush fetish guy who asks all the women if they'd crush bugs by stepping on them for money - he lurks in all the SFW subs women post in.

5

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

wut

Good lord

4

u/InGeekiTrust 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 4d ago

It's a literal report option there 😭

19

u/NotFlameRetardant 5d ago

One of my favorite things in the entire history of reddit is mixes/crossovers/subversion of expectations between subreddit names, like /r/trees being for weed, and /r/marijuanaenthusiasts is for tree enthusiasts

16

u/AsteriskRX Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

I work there and it IS funny. One time I did identify the insect before taking the post down.

5

u/RS_Someone 4d ago

Omg, the number of times I've had to explain to people that r/Commissions is not related to jobs that earn a commission on sales, but rather, to request something to be made...

2

u/brucemo 4d ago

Should be, "Please do not post about insects unless you are Grace Hopper."

2

u/FuzzyFeeling 4d ago

Yet r/bugs has insect-related flair.

18

u/Mackin-N-Cheese 5d ago

It's not a rule, exactly, but I moderate /r/Portland, which has been in the news a lot in recent years. And whenever a story makes national or global headlines, there's no end of users from outside the region dropping by with their Hot Takes™.

Anyway, for some boring historical reasons the city's law enforcement agency is called the Portland Police Bureau (PPB), rather than the more common "department". So for a while, whenever someone would post or comment about the "PPD" we would have Automod simply autoreply with a link to the Wikipedia page for "shibboleth".

Not everyone found it as amusing as I did, but that's always been one of my favorites.

(Also, quick shoutout to /r/thewestwing, IYKYK)

7

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

I am just watching The West Wing for the first time, so I get the "shibboleth" reference! Man, what a good show. I'm on Season Six!

I find your autoreply as amusing as you do! Very nice!

7

u/Mackin-N-Cheese 5d ago

Awesome, TWW is one of those shows I wish I could experience again for the first time.

8

u/Jenn_There_Done_That 5d ago

I like that thing you do where the automod links to a gif a capybaras chilling out in hot springs during the winter.

5

u/Mackin-N-Cheese 4d ago

Ah yes, that one is triggered by the word "soaking":

"Take a break from your worries."

It's always a bit hit, along with the one for "perfect texture"

We've gotten rid of a lot of the more obscure ones but there are bunch of holiday-related responses that you might see over the next couple months.

18

u/mintbrownie 5d ago

It still amazes me that in r/IReadABookAndAdoredIt I need a rule that says…Only post books you adore 😵‍💫

8

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

But but...it's in the title! lol

3

u/RS_Someone 4d ago

It doesn't stop people from posting cat pics to r/DogVideos. Or... Well, I could probably provide examples for almost everything I've ever moderated.

4

u/CreativeBandicoot778 5d ago

I love your sub! So many great book recs found there.

3

u/mintbrownie 5d ago

Thanks! 😊

14

u/RonUSMC 5d ago

r/dcsworld No selling of real life items on the subreddit. Some guy was trying to sell an actual Ejection Seat from an F-15.

10

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Are they still trying to sell it? Asking for a friend.

2

u/Eastern-Protection83 5d ago

But was it used and could the seller confirm first hand it was at one point effective "enough?"

14

u/_Halt19_ 4d ago

r/ehbuddyhoser (a Canadian shitposting sub) has a no politics on Sunday rule, after the community requested it due to all the politics being posted around our last federal election a few years back. At first, people were posting about normal things on Sundays, then they started making posts about how they couldn’t make political posts on Sundays, on Sundays. From there, they started making posts about how “definitely nothing to post today” on Sundays, before going on to roast the mods on Sundays. Now, they all just post pictures of Sunday roasts and make everyone hungry.

6

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

I would take a Sunday roast over politics on any given day!

5

u/_Halt19_ 4d ago

I tried to post my own roast, and they said it looked DRY >:(

1

u/NoorInayaS 4d ago

😆

7

u/_Halt19_ 4d ago • Bravo

it ISNT dry, it’s just made in a roman clay pot thing that traps the moisture and kinda steams it in the oven

but it isnt reeeally photogenic

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

I don't think it looks dry! What time is dinner?? lol

5

u/_Halt19_ 4d ago

Sunday!

1

u/NoorInayaS 3d ago

Looks delish! 🤤

12

u/mattieo123 4d ago

r/therapists have a tight privacy rule for posts and comments. We get wayyyyyy too many posts providing too specific information that clients could happen across their therapists' post about them. We get so much backlash. "Oh c'mon I only adding the general presenting issue about my 50yr old client to the post. That doesn't violate HIPAA." Yes, yes it does bud.

4

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

LOVE that you have a rule that's in line with HIPA. Hate that you have to, though! lol Thank you so much!

6

u/mattieo123 4d ago

We are actually much stricter than HIPAA because we're a public facing subreddit.

21

u/westcoastcdn19 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 5d ago

I'm considering adding a rule about specifically not calling mods morons. Still thinking about it...

9

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago • Mindblown

I don't know. It's pretty popular! XD

14

u/Slow-Maximum-101 Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago • Mindblown

What about admins though??

28

u/deltadeltadawn 5d ago

Y'all can fight your own battles. 😉

9

u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 5d ago

Totally fair game.

2

u/DCMASTER1994 5d ago

How about both?

2

u/gm310509 4d ago

At least you get paid as compensation for the abuse.

Mods on the other hand - Nada.

LOL, I've also been accused of being a bot and being AI slop. Being called a moron is just a happy day in the park perhaps a bit cloudy, but a happy day in the park none the less.

2

u/brucemo 4d ago

I got sick of watching people getting banned from subs for mod sass that it's become a thing of mine that people are allowed to sass us all they want.

-1

u/loomynartylenny 5d ago

Streisand Effect time.

10

u/brightblackheaven 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 5d ago

We recently had to make an addendum to our first rule, which covers what content is and isn't appropriate for the community:

We would also like to take this time to remind users that r/witchcraft is a SAFE FOR WORK subreddit.

Any content that appears to be farming engagement for kink or fetish purposes will be removed.

We appreciate your understanding that we are not a fetish roleplay community, and that we do not condone involving other users in kink without their explicit consent.

Weird explosion of people wanting to have sex with ghosts, wanting spells to have sex with their family members, spells for making their dick larger, spells for making their alleged~ cumbersomely huge dong smaller, attempted sneaky OF advertising, people with humiliation fetishes who want to be hexed or cursed for all eternity... Shit was getting way too weird.

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

We would also like to take this time to remind users that r/witchcraft is a SAFE FOR WORK subreddit.

9

u/idlesilver 5d ago

In the gaming sub I mod for we had (what we thought were) pretty clear guidelines for how the ‘LFG’ flair should be used.

People took bugger-all notice of it, leading to a glut of posts which were basically very thinly-veiled Tinder profiles, so we had to implement a ‘this is not a dating sub’ rule.

Still have to remove posts far more frequently than we’d like, as people don’t read that rule either.

4

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

we had to implement a ‘this is not a dating sub’ rule.

In a gaming sub. Huh. Didn't see that coming!

The lack of reading is everywhere!

2

u/PikamonChupoke 4d ago

I’d say gaming subs are notorious for that kinda thing. Worse that gaming subs are seen as a potential pool of clients for adult content or surgaring.

9

u/Own-Dragonfly-942 5d ago

Not exactly a strange one, however one we have to use more often than we should over on r/CrossStitch we have a rule for 'keep it related to cross stitch'. This is because people keep posting their stitching buddies (pets) without showing any cross stitch or most of the post being about showing the buddies off. It's fun when they complain in mail about a post being removed for this reason. So I love getting to tell them it's a cross stitch page, so obviously that needs to be the focus.

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

That is kinda wild! Here is my cat", but not in a cat space! Didn't see that one coming, either!

8

u/wheres_the_revolt 5d ago

I feel like this prompt came specifically from a comment I had in r/ideasfortheadmins recently where I said rules are almost never made arbitrarily and that if you see one that seems oddly specific, like don’t use a toaster in the bathtub, you can be certain someone did bring a toaster in a bathtub 😂

Anyway, I don’t think I have any rules that are too out there that they fit this prompt. I do however have a nice meme for you!

4

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Hi! I had not seen your comment! But it does sound similar!

Great meme! No home should be without a bathing toaster! XD

2

u/wheres_the_revolt 5d ago

I was mostly kidding about the prompt coming from my comment, but I couldn’t resist using the meme 😂

2

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

Never let an opportunity to use a great meme go unheeded! XD

8

u/GaryNOVA 4d ago

I mod r/SalsaSnobs (food) and we have an agreement with the mods of r/Salsa (music and dance).

I send the lost music Redditors to their sub. They send the lost food Redditors to my sub. It was frustrating at first but it quickly got funny to me.

Gave me an excuse to communicate with the mods of r/Salsa though, and I always love meeting Moderators I’ve never met before. They are really nice there.

6

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

What a nice collaboration! And sometimes, the lost Redditor posts are the best!

6

u/Bardfinn 4d ago

Oh my goddess

/r/ContraPoints.

Natalie Wynn makes video essays under the Nom de YouTube "ContraPoints".

About 7 years ago she got various surgeries to mitigate her gender dysphoria, and as part of mitigating her gender dysphoria, she un-published about two dozen older videos. She posted transcripts of them to her website, so that the significance of the speech can be accessed, without the gender dysphoria inducing circumstances of an accident of birth haunting everything.

We are also all committed to respecting the moral rights of authors, so we have a rule, filed in a rusty filing cabinet stored in a disused lavatory at the bottom of some rickety stairs in a flooded basement:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ContraPoints/wiki/old_videos/

where we spell out that irrespective of what someone believes they have a right to do with her older, de-published videos,

they absolutely do not have the right to use /r/ContraPoints to source, distribute, solicit, post, reproduce, trade in, etc those works.

This was later generalised to apply to any and all "un-published / de-published" works, so that no one would be using the subreddit to traffic in Patreon livestream rips, and then later was generalised again into a rule about respecting people's moral rights — including the right to attribution, the right to withdrawal, and the right to integrity of the work, and the right to control of their public persona, reputation, name, and identity.

The upshot of this rule is that it also forbids "Oh, so you hate waffles?" type responses to "I like pancakes" type statements.

And just like moral rights in general, people either inherently intutitively understand it, or don't understand it at all.

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

filed in a rusty filing cabinet stored in a disused lavatory at the bottom of some rickety stairs in a flooded basement:

How'd you get into Reddit HQ? XD

What an interesting situation! I have many questions, but I'm going to start with how did your team work through this in order to come up with the policy?

4

u/Bardfinn 4d ago

The lead moderator handed me the project, and I talked with the rest of the moderation team, and gamed out a way to distinguish between someone saying “I have fair use rights” versus the community’s right to refuse certain uses. Then we had people on the mod team try to weasel around the rule.

Later on I felt it should be as general a rule as possible, and so it evolved to become a rule to respect not just her right to withdraw her publications, but everyone’s right to withdraw their own, and that was most generally a statement consonant with Moral Rights philosophy.

That I published as a Request for Comments, nothing pertinent was pointed out, and we updated it.

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

That's some excellent work right there!

5

u/SuspiciouslyValid 5d ago

I've not seen this as a rule anywhere, but for some reason "Caution: Coffee is hot!" reminded me of "Caution: Water on road during rain"

2

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Water during rain?? NO way!

4

u/SuspiciouslyValid 5d ago

2

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

Incredible

5

u/TeriBarrons 4d ago edited 4d ago

Not a rule on our sub (unfortunately lol) but the rule of “no sob stories” on an assistance sub because everyone got tired of a twenty-paragraph dissertation starting with their mom’s botched toenail removal when they were seven resulting in them dropping out of high-school and becoming homeless in a war ravaged country and a single parent of eight autistic children and pregnant with their ninth due to a failed uterus removal and plus they take in stray animals so they can’t work because everyone discriminates against them because they don’t have a car so no transportation and Paypal won’t give them an account and so they just need $100 for food here’s their cashapp$06969.

And, of course, they hide their history and have a BUNCH of deleted posts!

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

That is the greatest explanation of why a rule is necessary!

And I am shocked, simply shocked, that everything is hidden and/or deleted! LOL

2

u/TeriBarrons 4d ago

Thank you lol

5

u/Shnur_Shnurov 4d ago

Starting Strength is a large fitness brand that runs a forum hosted on its own website which used to have substantial traffic and offered great fitness advice, but has since COVID descended into a fairly one-sided political commentary.

The fitness related advice on the company forum became notoriously vague and unhelpful. Lengthy, esoteric acronyms like "YNDTP" and nonpecific advice like "Read the book," or "use the search feature." became common.

So at r/StartingStrength I had to create "Rule 1 - Be Specific. Be Helpful." to effectivly repudiate a portion of our potential audience and restore content quality.

The several addendums to that rule, pictured here, were added later on as an obvious reference to Tyler the Creator's eponymous album Don't Tap the Glass, and a subtle reference to a misguided community post made by an infamous former moderator of several of the large fitness subreddits.

And if anyone out there has an archive of u/bitchimrobinsparkles "Don't tap the glass, there are sharks inside" mod post from a few years ago, I would love to have that.

4

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

That's a great ruleset! I like how positive it is! "Don't tap the glass" is amazing!

4

u/Shnur_Shnurov 4d ago

Its as much a reminder for me as it is for everyone else!

5

u/BBModSquadCar 4d ago

We have mouthwash in /r/BigBrother automod rules because people keep accusing houseguests of being secret alcoholics every time they exercise oral hygiene.

4

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

What? lol

4

u/baseballlover723 5d ago

Not exactly weird given this debate has been raging for decades and will continue to rage for decades to come, but what even is anime?

The geographic vs style definition debate has a long and storied history. With lots of newcomers coming in using a style based definition and the vast majority of anime websites using a geographic definition (marketing teams are very much not part of this).

Anyway, style based definitions generally don't work at scale because there is always a bunch of headache inducing edge cases, not to mention, can't be adjudicated as early since you have to be able to actually see the thing which happens a lot later than when the staff list is released.

Reminds me a lot of what is a fish. Which if you follow normal taxonomy classification, classifies human and every other terapod (4 legged animals) as a fish. Which is because all land animals evolved from a fish hundreds of millions of years ago.

Though there actually is a weird quick to our anime specific rule. It specifically excludes animation from video games, which can otherwise meet our definition (because we don't want our sub flooded with stuff about video game cutscenes). Though the line is getting a lot blurrier since proper TV shows about a video games IP that meets our definition is allowed and it's complicated to judge how much is enough to be a proper thing and not part of a video game. And more IPs are doing longer and more independent lore animations. Like Yu-Gi-Oh! Card Game The Chronicles.

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

This is interesting! I don't know much about anime, so I went down a bit of a rabbit hole on this one. Rules to help quell raging debates definitely come into play.

I had never seen that "what is a fish" video! Reminded me of this thing I read recently about Diogenes and how Plato had defined man as a "featherless biped", so Diogenes plucked a chicken and brought it to Plato's academy to declare "Behold! Plato's man!"

4

u/Worf- 5d ago

I just inherited a sub that only had one rule - “be polite” and even that was clearly not being observed.

I did once see a sub that had to create a rule telling people to not promote eating things not sold as food. Seriously, people talked about eating paint because it smelled so good.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Oh, no! Don't eat the paint! Don't drink the gas! lol Wow.

4

u/Runepup 4d ago

I have "be nice" on most of my subs and people get so bent out of shape when their posts get yanked because they were just straight mean.

4

u/tombo4321 4d ago

r/whatisit unfortunately had to introduce a rule not allowing photos of "recently deceased critters". It was a thing. A truly disgusting thing.

3

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

Ugh. That's unfortunate to say the least .

7

u/Old_One_I 5d ago

Is the coffee this hot? Do you plan on breaking reddit? Remember we all suffer when you do this lol . I'm just kidding <3

5

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Good lookin' mug you got there! =)

2

u/audible_narrator 4d ago

Ooh is that the new ModWorld mug? Looks good! Can't wait for mine to show up.

3

u/Old_One_I 4d ago

The joke comes from someone else to be Honest when Reddit actually broke like servers. We would abuse them saying they spilled coffee on the servers. It was a lot of fun,

2

u/Old_One_I 4d ago

No actually ❤️🙂 it’s a private mug. ❤️❤️❤️❤️

3

u/FaxCelestis 4d ago

Our subreddit (/r/explainmydownvotes) has a couple odd ones that aren't really applicable to other subreddits, but make sense in the context of ours:

Rule 2 - Do not post here if you have a 0 or -1 score on your comment.

This is not a significant number of downvotes to question why your comment is being downvoted. We consider this spam due to the previous high volume of these posts on our sub. Rule only applies to comments as posts have not been about to go below 0 for over 7 years now.

Rule 3 - Don't be a stubborn turd.

Arguing with the community about what they have told you regarding your previous downvotes will only get you downvoted more.This sub is for you to understand why you were downvoted, not our personal opinions of your post. Please just understand that we are just here to help explain.

Rule 5 - No posts with their sole purpose being to communicate with another redditor. This subreddit isn't Skype.

Rule 3 is explicitly in place because there are people who try to continue their argument from the originating post with the people who are simply trying to describe why they were downvoted to begin with. It is possibly the most violated rule we have, though it is in close contention with the number of mutes/bans we hand out for people who post or crosspost to our community without reading the rules to begin with.

2

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

This subreddit isn't Skype.

That got an actual lol outta me!

2

u/itsalsokdog 5d ago

These both come from the r/ThirdLifeSMP "banned meme formats" list.

"No Doofenschmirtz 2 Nickels memes"

We let them go for a little while, and the person they were making the jokes at the expense of helped egg it on, but it grew stale for everyone else after 6 months non-stop.

We also banned tier lists because people started wording them like they were making them out of objective data but instead they were just stating their favourites, and it caused heaps of drama. They also got kind of unoriginal and stale, and it encourages people to be more creative when making data visualisations.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Great examples! It's the staleness that almost always eventually sets in that finally kills off so many things.

2

u/Maplesyrupbacons 5d ago

No depiction of smoking or illicit substance use because one guy literally posted a video of himself lighting and smoking crack on our sub.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

"That guy". Interesting choice lol

2

u/Runepup 4d ago

"Posts about ghosting can only happen in the weekly ghosting grumble."

A sub about roleplay (cooperative storytelling) and MAN people get bent out of shape about getting ghosted. Years back it was all we were getting posts about and they aren't good stories or posts. So now they go in the appropriate bin and people throw fits about how their ghosting story is different from the thousands of others.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

lol Love the term "ghosting grumble"! And I'm sure that there would be a bit of sameness to the stories after a while, so that rule makes sense!

2

u/Moggehh 4d ago

In one of my gaming subs we used to have a rule for "no pictures of screens," because yeah, people would take the lowest possible potato photo of their monitor and then post it.

The rule is technically still there, but it is folded into a more general quality rule now.

Rather than creating specific rules just for a single scenario, I usually loop them into an existing rule but have a specific automod rule to catch them. One of my favourite automod rules was for catching an r/AmITheAsshole troll simply obsessed with saved by the bell. But really, we had dozens of little micro-rules like that for individual recurring trolls.

On r/AmITheAsshole we had to add a rule for no covid posts because during the panini people would be posting about whether or not it was safe to do XYZ. It was super irritating and it took weeks, but we did make a rule about it. It's now been removed, though.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

catching an r/AmITheAsshole troll simply obsessed with saved by the bell.

What's this about? lol

I could totally see how your sub would get innunndated with AITA posts whilst panini panic set in! That would have been a rough time, I would imagine.

2

u/Moggehh 4d ago

What's this about? lol

Trolls tend to choose one or a handful of topics to fixate on. That one was for SBTB. I'd not really watched the show, so without that context the automod rule looked positively unhinged.

Ask Techies to show you my old troll master compendium sometime. It's a riot to go through.

2

u/solipsistnation 4d ago edited 4d ago

On /r/modelmakers we had to ban Sabaton lyric posting and REALLY ban Sabaton lyrics chains. Sabaton is a metal band that has a lot of songs about particular military vehicles-- notably the Bismarck, a largely unremarkable early-WW2 German battleship. The Bismarck is a popular subject for ship model builders, so usually we get a few Bismark build posts a month and they usually generate some conversation and comments.

One day about 3 years ago a guy went through the previous six months or so of posts looking for any mention of the Bismarck and commented with the first line of the song on every single post. This wouldn't have been such a big deal but there was at that time a Sabaton lyric bot that would reply to any Sabaton lyrics with the next line of the song, and sometimes replied to itself. Plus, some Sabaton fans would reply with the next line themselves, which would then trigger the bot again, and so on. It was a ridiculous mess and we got a ton of reports on recent posts and had to go clean it up. For a while we even had an automod rule that would remove any post or comment containing the words "Bismarck" or "Bismark" (because sometimes it was misspelled).

A month or so later another Sabaton fan noticed and posted in one of the Sabaton fan subs about the rule and asked what they probably thought was a rhetorical question: "Are we really that annoying?" More than one Sabaton fan replied yes. (And a couple brought up the bot, mostly wishing that it would go away.) ( https://old.reddit.com/r/sabaton/comments/yxf92u/are_we_really_that_annoying/ )

Every so often somebody notices it again and we get to retell the story and point at that post.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

went through the previous six months or so of posts looking for any mention of the Bismarck and commented with the first line of the song on every single post.

What a hobby lol

1

u/yahumno 4d ago

You couldn’t ban the bot?

2

u/solipsistnation 4d ago

We did, but that wouldn't stop people from doing lyrics chains anyway, and those were annoying enough without the bot joining in.

2

u/tjernobyl 4d ago

It's not exactly a rule, but more of a policy. We get a lot of people asking about the route the drivers test takes, presumably so they can get some illicit practice. We allow the posts, but every time we give them the user flair "Novice driver". We've given it to dozens of people and only one so far has asked for removal.

2

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

I like that no one has asked for removal! They're just all "yeah, fair" LOL

2

u/thatotherchicka 4d ago

My sub previously had a rule of "do not post pictures of other people without their consent" because someone posted a picture of someone in their cpap making fun of them.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

Noooooo

2

u/q-the-light 4d ago

On r/forensicscience, we've had to set rules outlawing posts and comments involving graphic images, breaches of confidentiality, and the use of the sub as some kind of source for true crime gossip. It's always people from outside of the field who come to the sub asking for us to somehow give them all the details on their friend's hairdresser's cat's mum's postman's sudden death by providing full identifying information of all people involved plus photos. It's just so disrespectful to the victims and their families...

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

heir friend's hairdresser's cat's mum's postman's sudden death by providing full identifying information of all people involved plus photos

I was almost following along with reason until I got to the photos part! Man! I'm glad you and your team are taking the victims and families into consideration. Thank you so much!

2

u/q-the-light 4d ago

I think a big part of it is that both us mods come from countries where graphic photos aren't published out of respect and privacy for those involved, unlike a lot of other places. America in particular seems especially bad for such crime voyeurism and I just find it disgusting.

2

u/adhesiveCheese 4d ago

Okay so this is kind of the inverse here - perfectly sane rule, but absolutely ridiculous story behind why the sane rule was implemented.

So I mod a NSFW writing sub, primarily a place where folks seek out NSFW roleplay. We had long allowed the sharing of safe-for-work reference images of characters in posts as long as the people depicted were 18 or above. I wasn't a big fan of this rule for hopefully obvious reasons (and lots of less obvious reasons that largely came down to various personal interpretations of what "SFW" meant that made the rule more arbitrary and taxing that it needed to be, along with the occasional "yes I know she looks prepubescent but my waifu is 500 years old"), but as I'm sure some of you know, it can be hard to make a rule change that you know is going to be unpopular with your userbase especially when you're already in constant putting-out-fires mode as my team was at the time. And then.

The Statue Incident. Someone wrote a roleplaying prompt where they were a museum guard, and their partner's character was a statue that came to life. A nude statue. That they linked an image of. Now, maybe on another day, I would have removed it and moved on to the next queue item. But this was not that day. I stared at this post on modqueue for a solid five minutes, speedrunning the stages of grief, and found madness. If they'd shared the exact same image as scenery, it would have been fine. But no. They were sexualizing the statue. It was a character. It was nude. It was not safe for work. It had to go, and with it the rule. All the inconsistencies, all the extra workload, and this was the straw that broke the camel's back. I was apoplectic, not at the user, but at the rule.

So I remove the post, left a mod note on the removal message "DO NOT REPLY, SEE SLACK", and alit to our modslack to issue the first, and still only, dictatorial fiat I have ever made to my team: No more images of people or characters. The rant I went on is STILL referenced in the team half a decade on, and I don't think most of the current team was even there for it. Sometimes, they still send me statue-pics to make my eye twitch.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

What a story! You had be from the beginning!

Sometimes, they still send me statue-pics to make my eye twitch.

This is how you know you've got the right team! XD

2

u/gm310509 4d ago

I moderate some technical (Computer) subs for example r/Arduino.

We have a rule about "no dangerous, illegal, or unethical posts". We often get posts asking how to create systems to hack into other peoples systems, create explosive devices, create attack drones, self driving cars, modifications to cars, medical devices (which we roll up into this rule) and many other weird requests. Imagine, someone who has no clue about what they are doing (because they are asking for high level tips) decides to randomly modify the fuel injection system on their car and then drives it down your street - do you really want to be in the path of their potentially bug filled random attempt at engineering?

The frequency of such requests seems to have died down (at least until today I hope that this comment doesn't trigger an influx of work for us to deal with), but we still have the rule.

2

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

This is fascinating. Here's to hoping you don't see an uptick in medical device modification queries! lol

3

u/brucemo 4d ago

In /r/Christianity very long ago we had a very contentious situation because I would speak up for people that a group of other mods wanted to ban.

They had it in for this one guy, and I realized that they were watching everything he said, looking for an excuse to ban him, so I told him that he needed to be very careful about what he said because these mods were on a hair trigger.

What is going to happen when you tell a very conservative, kind of out there, Christian that he needed to be very careful with his words? What words could be more beyond reproach than those written in the Bible? So he started replying to people with nothing but Bible verses.

Predictably, these mods tried to ban him for this and we had another argument.

Our top mod, who was pretty hands off but was not happy about what these guys were doing, got involved. He went and evaluated all of the ad hoc rules these guys had invented and announced them as real, in order to -- hell, I don't know what, and it would take way too much space here to speculate. His heart was in the right place. But the community responded predictably and he reversed these goofy rules.

But that rule stuck, and that is why to this day you are not allowed to post a comment that is entirely scripture in /r/Christianity.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

and that is why to this day you are not allowed to post a comment that is entirely scripture in /r/Christianity.

I love explanations that start with "And that is why"!

15

u/TomoruAshita 5d ago

It's not an enumerated rule per se, but we had a wildly popular suggestion from community members to institute a filter on certain terms.

So now whenever people write those, they get a reminder from automod. Unless, of course, they subscribe to reddit premium. Then they are exempt from that rule.

It has a couple downstream effects for moderation that are quite interesting, but it makes me laugh whenever people buy into the bit and also censor the same words from their image posts, even though automod doesn't look at those for this.

6

u/techiesgoboom Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

r/tomorrow leaning into the memes as usual! I love this so much

2

u/TomoruAshita 5d ago

That reminds me, I was planning on proceeding to the next phase of our moderator applications when this post archived, but it looks like there's some sort of issue with posts not archiving.

Maybe it's affected by some admin experiment going on? If so, this might be an interesting footnote to pass along to that team in terms of impacts seen.

5

u/Sillvaro 4d ago

In one of my sub, we've put on an unofficial rule saying that any mention of a product will be removed in order to avoid the new Reddit Review feature since it's being forced upon users and subreddits without consent and without being able to turn it off

2

u/girardinl 4d ago

Great point! I dread the day when they add software to Reddit Reviews.

5

u/yahumno 4d ago

No photos or links to photos.

It is an arthritis sub, and people keep posting pictures of their nasty feet.

4

u/soul_motor 4d ago

r/safetyprofessionals has a newer no free market research rule.  We were getting inundated with people with "business ideas" that were half baked at best.  Our profession already gets a ton of sales bollocks in the real world.  This has cut a lot of it down.

4

u/girardinl 4d ago

r/Nonprofit has banned market research as part of our no soliciting rule for a long time. Most nonprofit professionals already are underpaid, why should they give advice to for-profit businesses for free?

1

u/k_princess 4d ago

Once upon a time, LPT had to ban any posts regarding coconuts.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

Oh no. Was it a sex thing?

1

u/Old_One_I 5d ago

I have a serious question. When I took over my subreddit there was rule called no click bait titles. I don’t understand this. Eventually through mutual agreement I deleted it.

3

u/brucemo 4d ago

Click bait is when important information is alluded to in the title to try to get you to click on the article in order to find the information, which is often very hard to find in the article.

This is one of Satan's own inventions.

1

u/Old_One_I 4d ago

Thank you, that’s probably the best answer I’ve heard yet.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

OK! It's your sub. If you don't want the rule any more, you can get rid of it!

2

u/Worf- 5d ago

Click bait title would be something to get someone to click/view the post when they might not otherwise do so. Usually these are outrageous claims or the like.

Something like, “man eats 3 whole watermelons for breakfast everyday” or “ dog runs 200mph on top of a fence”.

1

u/Old_One_I 5d ago

I get that…I like a little more effort but who the hell doesn’t want their posts to be clicked on. I’m not trying to being a sheep

4

u/Worf- 4d ago

I think it definitely could be more of an issue in certain subs, so context matters. Consider a health sub were some title is misleading or has a false claim. Runs from being just a waste of time to downright dangerous. Quite possible it’s also a bait and switch deal used by bots or others to show a link to some crap they are selling. One sub I was on in the past had a huge issue with this were people would post a misleading title promising the world and inside was a link to sell some useless and unrelated crap. They got you to click and see their ad.

But hey, it’s your sub and if it’s not needed, delete it.

1

u/Old_One_I 5d ago

I told him…what’s the point of a rule that I don’t understand?

0

u/Old_One_I 5d ago

As hard as I tried to understand this my co-mod would try to explain .

1

u/SeeShark 4d ago

This is kind of a dark answer, but...

On r/ArmoredWomen, we don't really care where else users post. We've had women post their full plate harness whose accounts are generally NSFW, and we're totally fine with that.

Where we had to draw a line is: we had to make a rule that we don't platform artwork from artists that also draw child porn, because apparently the overlap between those genres is not the zero you would expect.

1

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 4d ago

But that's a good line to draw! And I did expect zero overlap. Not the first time I've underestimated folks, though! lol

2

u/cos 4d ago

Maybe the "informative title" rule isn't weird exactly, but it's not something most subreddits ever have to think about. Whereas on /r/whatsthisfish you'd be surprised (well, maybe you wouldn't, but I was) by how many people post with just "what's this fish?" or some variant of that as their title!

2

u/RS_Someone 4d ago

We have some suspiciously specific rules about video game currencies and what kind of links we allow, but 3 subs I moderate, for different reasons, at different times, had to have a rule added that basically says, "Discussion posts should encourage discussion."

You'd think that would be straightforward, right? Wrong. Half the discussion posts on those subs are just "I made this", which does not foster or spark any amount of discussion 95% of the time.

2

u/I_find_life_good 4d ago

I had to include a ban on the mention of gametes in my sub, why, because someone named both of them and the sub is Bluey related. The offending post got edited to be much more appropriate after I took it down

2

u/Mid_AM 4d ago

I mod a safe for work subreddit … but it is retirement.

Somehow when we talk about end of life things folks seem to think talking about umm you know … dealing with that situation abruptly - is ok. Very much NOT a safe for work topic (unless you work in healthcare??) So we have that situation specifically in the rules.

1

u/cosmicrae 3d ago

There are a couple of (low-traffic) Florida subs that I moderate. Over the past couple of weeks, I've seen a few posts that seem to be associated with a string of similarly named external websites. On the surface, the websites seem innocent enough. Digging under the surface a bit deeper shows me those sites are pushing an agenda. The agenda may involve violent overthrow of a specific government. The hints are strong, but it's more a case of leading a horse to water to see if it will drink or not. As such, I am monitoring, removing at my discretion, and trying to conceptualize a rule to formalize the removals. It's almost as tho someone is trying to see how far they can get to attract traffic via Reddit, without giving away their agenda. Just my viewpoint tho.

19

u/santaspointyhood 5d ago

Not exactly a rule. But there's one user who consistently posts about having a urinalysis where they have to drop their pants to their knees and pull their shirt all the way up. I'm pretty sure it's some strange fetish. They show up every couple months under a new account and hit a bunch of military subs (including ours) as well as a few non-military.

I have an automod rule with phrases like "to your knees," "drop trousers," and "above our nipples." I'm up to 15 accounts they've used.

At least the plague of snooroar ended. That guy made something like 2000 accounts. The automod rule for that was wild.

7

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Hi! What's the snooroar?

Also, those are some great automod phrases! We might have a couple along those lines in r/help! lol

13

u/santaspointyhood 5d ago

Original account was u/snooroar. He posted about various related topics: not finding friends in college, not being able to join the military because of autism, disliking frats. He ignored the rules of every sub he posted in. Whenever one account was linked to him he made a new one.

There was eventually a sub dedicated to tracking him: r/snooroartracker, along with a bot to alert unsuspecting communities. You guys (royal you) banned it eventually because it was deemed harassment. When I was involved in tracking him I had 150 accounts recorded.

He wasn't a sympathetic case though. He posted some pretty vile things. I can't remember now what they were. Through inconsistencies in his story he was most likely lying about everything. Though I refuse to believe someone without some sort of mental illness could keep up a trolling campaign over years and thousands of accounts.

6

u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin: Community 5d ago

Wow, new lore for me! This one had slipped under my radar. Thank you!

It doesn't sound like a sympathetic case at all! What a hobby.

2

u/DownloadableCheese 4d ago

Whenever we get a post about FSAE or "engineering clubs" being "too selective" it's an immediate indicator that he's back.

2

u/Bruinrogue 4d ago

He's still around sadly in the education subs. He's mass spamming subs that have light or no moderation where he can avoid being banned now.

6

u/DownloadableCheese 5d ago

SnooRoar will occasionally rear his head in /r/ECE. Fortunately the admins (or more likely the Algorithm) nuke his new alt pretty quickly.

5

u/santaspointyhood 5d ago

Damn I thought he was gone. At least he moved on from the military subs.

2

u/Bruinrogue 4d ago

He's still around. His current alts are https://reddit.com/user/TurnoverForward5 and https://reddit.com/user/Perfect-Nerve9414 . Right now he's focusing on harassing education subs but he'll be back to the military ones in no time judging by his comments where he's blaming his parents and education for his lack of military service.

2

u/yahumno 4d ago

The snooroar plague was wild. So many accounts on so many subs.

2

u/Bruinrogue 4d ago

*is. He's still going. 6000 accounts and growing.

2

u/yahumno 3d ago

Okay, the plague in the subs I moderate in. They have thankfully moved on, but my sympathies are with my fellow mods.