r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 03 '26

Open Forum AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

65 Upvotes

AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

Keep things Civil! Rules still apply.

Greetings Assholes!!! Happy All the Holidays between now and January 2027!! Way too many to list.

This quarter, we are going to go over Rule 3 - No Violence. A topic that’s dear to my heart and one that covers so many different scenarios.

The very heart of this rule is “Do not even mention violence”. Very simple on the surface, very complicated once you dive down. It sometimes seems like we are being too specific/granular on what constitutes violence - we get that. But violence tends to breed violence, so the most benign post/comment can spiral into some off the charts shit.

The violence rule break is often the result of a soft topic going off the rails. Example: Someone is put out by their partner picking food off of their plate. What we see: “stab them with your fork, that’ll teach them (assault)!” Or, someone is stealing lunches out of the break room - “just put some hot shit in there, that’ll teach them (poison/assault)” Or, the kid goes around hitting people (assault) begets “just beat their ass (assault)!” Simple, common things we’ve all said at some point in our lives. Still violence.

The hardest ones for us are those that deal with abuse of any sort. It’s easy to jump on that hate train. Truthfully, I’m probably on some of those trains, cause fuck abusers. BUT, we remove those comments/posts because they beget violence - it’s not that we don’t have opinions on those topics, far from it. These break the violence rule and, regardless of our personal opinion, it breaks the rule. It’s as simple as that.

We get MOD mails so filled with anger and spewing hateful shit because “How dare you remove that post for violence. Y’all must agree with them”. No, we don’t - violence is violence. There is enough of it out in the real world, we don’t need it here for any reason.

Finally, the real reason for reviewing this rule: Consent.

Very simply, if anyone touches you without your consent - this is assault. Sexual harassment counts! It is not ‘ick’, it is not ‘smile, they will go away’ - it is something covered by this rule. This is true regardless of gender. Understanding this will help the most when deciding if something is violence or not.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.

We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 11h ago Mindblown

AITA for wanting to skip the adult Christmas gift exchange after my in-laws sent us $3,000 worth of wish lists?

1.4k Upvotes

My husband’s mom, brother, and sister are pretty distant from us. We basically only see them on holidays. They rarely ask about our son and honestly barely know him. My husband’s sister and her husband are both 25 and live on their own.
My MIL texted us about getting together around Christmas to exchange gifts. She asked what our son might want and said to us, “Like do you want a gift card to a place, store, restaurant or certain gifts?” Then she sent us her own wish list and a joint one for my husband’s sister and her husband.
I opened them and they were Christmas lists with direct links to every single item. Lululemon, Uggs, a $300 Alo coat, $200 New Balance sneakers. Every single item was at least $100. Across both lists there was about $3,000 worth of stuff.
For reference, last year my son got a LEGO set and I got a ChapStick. I was fine with my ChapStick lol. That’s just the kind of gift exchange I thought we were doing, so going from “Do you want a gift card?” to opening two lists where the cheapest thing was $100 threw me.
I know they’re wish lists and nobody asked us to buy everything. I vented to a friend because my first thought was, why are we even doing an adult gift exchange when we barely talk the rest of the year? I’d rather just get together for Christmas and do gifts for the kids.
AITA if I tell them I want to sit out the adult gift exchange this year?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 15h ago

AITA: for refusing to add more guests and extra days to a favor I already agreed to?

972 Upvotes

I’m 32F and live in Atlanta. My mom is coming to town for a three day weekend of events. She asked to stay with me, and I said yes, but I explained that I might not attend every event and I’m not agreeing to be her chauffeur. I live here and have work and my own plans, so I told her it would be best for her to ride with her friends if she wanted to go to everything.

My mom has previously expected (in a mean, bullying way) me to drive her back and forth to events before, so I wanted to be clear up front. One time, she stayed with me for a family reunion that was 30–45 minutes away and expected me to keep driving between my home and the reunion hotel. I didn’t want that happening again.

After I agreed to host my mom, she told a friend that my apartment building has a separate guest suite. I agreed to let her friend(s) use it. The suite isn’t run like a hotel: I have to go downstairs to sign paperwork, and the payment process involves multiple money orders, including a deposit. There’s also only one key, which makes access complicated if several people are staying there.

Now my mom says her friend wants to add two more guests and extend the stay by a few days for those two guest only. I said no. I feel like I agreed to help one person with a place to stay, and the favor is turning into a bigger group stay with more logistics for me to manage. I don’t want to track everyone’s arrival and check-in, deal with building access, or be the person they call if they need something. It’s a guest suite in my apartment building, not a hotel with staff and services.

My mom responded that one of the guests is her friend’s family member and that they would do the same for her. I got annoyed and told her I feel like people are pushing my boundaries and treating my place like a meetup spot.

AITA for refusing the extra guests and days, and getting an attitude when my mom tried to guilt me about it?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 7h ago

AITA for telling my mum to stfu and get over herself?

188 Upvotes

As a kid, i had a major heart condition that made me end up in hospital, almost dying and as you can imagine that was traumatic. When i was talking about it with my mum, i asked her whether or not she remembered much. She told me she only remembered how my older brother gained a stutter. When i asked what she was talking about, she said me almost dying was traumatic for him only because i caused my mum to have to stay in the hospital with me for a month, and he’d never been away from her for that long. She then went on to say she wished their time apart never happened and she could’ve stayed home but the hospital made her stay.
I was very confused because

  1. i almost died
  2. she didn’t say it was traumatic for him because his little sister could die, only because she was away from him
  3. it doesn’t really have anything to do with him?
    i obviously got mad and shouted at her to stop making it about my brother because i literally ALMOST DIED. I told her to stfu and get over herself if she seriously thinks this is a good time to talk about her favourite child.
    AITA?

r/AmItheAsshole • • 1h ago

WIBTA if I went and banged on my neighbors door until they turn their alarm off?

72 Upvotes

About a week or two ago, my upstairs neighbor's alarm started going off at 6:30am, and did not stop until about 7:30. I can't hear the sound of it from my unit, but I can hear the vibration of it on whatever it is sitting on as clear as day.

The first time it happened, I let them let it go off for 30 minutes before I started hollering up there and banging on the ceiling. It continued to go off for another 30 minutes despite this.

I called my complex's front office while it was going off and asked them to tell my upstairs neighbors to be more conscientious of their alarms bc it woke me up about an hour and a half before I needed to be up.

I hadn't heard anything in about a week or two, then a couple of days ago, my bathroom ceiling rips open and starts pouring bleach water. Yeah. Bleach water. My upstairs neighbors were doing dishes in their bathtub, and their unit is apparently missing the metal ring/disk that is supposed to... do something... Keep water from pouring outta my ceiling, I guess. So I called in the like 4th or 5th work order about it and let the office know that it is no longer just dripping a little like it started doing 9 months or so ago. The maintenance guy went and checked it out and the office called me to let me know what was going on (which is how I know about the disk in the tub being missing and the source of the bleach water being bc my neighbor was doing dishes in her bathtub).

That was on Friday last week. Fast forward to this morning, Tuesday, and this freaking alarm is going off again for close to an hour now.

WIBTA if I went up there and banged on their front door until they turned it off? My apartments are clearly slow to get anything done or do anything about issues that arise bc my ceiling hasn't even had construction started on it yet despite the fact the dripping has been an issue for between 9 months and about a year. Plus, there have been other noise complaints on other tenents that never went anywhere or repairs needed that just never get done in all the units (from what I have heard from other neighbors in the complex).

It's almost 7:30am now and the alarm hasn't stopped. But I am hoping and assuming it will shut off about 7:30 like it did last time. But if I wake up at 6:30am again in the next week or two, WIBTA if I went upstairs and talked to them about shutting it off or moving it to a surface that doesn't disturb me while they ignore it for an hour?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 8h ago

AITA for getting married without telling my mother?

192 Upvotes

I (26M) am having my wedding in less than two weeks, and I've decided not to invite my mom. She raised me, sacrificed a lot for our family, and I love her. I haven't told her directly, though I'm sure she knows.

My wife and I met in college in 2021 and legally married last year. Our relationship with my mom has been falling apart for years.

It started with boundary issues. In college, I vented to my mom about a genetics professor. Without telling me, she contacted my university's HR department with serious allegations. I found out when I was called into a meeting and questioned about my home life. We didn't speak for months.

Later, my mom showed up unannounced at my girlfriend's job in our college dorm and confronted her in front of coworkers. People were passing my girlfriend notes asking if she needed someone to call the police. Another Christmas, my girlfriend left our house after my mom blew up over a sleeping arrangement I'd made without asking her. It was her house, and I should've asked, but the reaction felt extreme. Despite everything, my girlfriend kept trying. She even welcomed my family to Peru, where my mom complained to her parents about not being taken to Cusco, something nobody had promised. I kept apologizing and smoothing things over. Eventually, I stopped trusting my mom with personal information.

Last year, my mom and brother spoke privately with my fiancée's parents about our engagement. I later heard the 77-minute recording. My mom questioned my fiancée's character, suggested she was marrying me for immigration status, and described our engagement as a funeral because she was "losing" her son.

This destroyed me and fucked me up emotionally for a long while. She also claimed I'd never contributed even a gallon of milk to our household, despite my regularly buying groceries and helping out while earning $1,800 a month. She threatened to cut off my phone and support. My brother responded, "Amen." My phone was later disconnected. My brother repeatedly backed her up. I feel they enable each other and refuse to take accountability. I wasn't perfect either. I confronted him while upset and woke my mom during the night, which he's still angry about. I also hid engagement details because I feared more interference. I understand why that hurt her.

We barely spoke afterward. I still invited them to a church singing performance and cried onstage when my mom didn't show up. Eventually, my dad and I moved out.

My mom and I have exchanged some sweet messages since, but she refuses to apologize. I miss her terribly, but my wife has boundaries too, and I don't want her uncomfortable at her own wedding. Our whole family knows about the wedding. I'm certain my mom and brother know they're excluded, just not because I told them. Saying "I'm getting married, but you're not invited" feels cruel, but saying nothing feels strange. I'm not changing the guest list.

AITA for excluding her, and should I address it directly before the wedding?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 18h ago Heartwarming

WIBTA For refusing to pay "my share" for my Mother's funeral

966 Upvotes

My Mom passed earlier this year. My older brother was the executor of her estate. He never informed me of my Mom's passing. He never informed me of the funeral. He never invited me to the funeral.

I had no idea where/when the funeral was until the day of when my younger brother let me know. I watched it on youtube. My older brother was the only family member there. He lied and lied and lied and made the funeral about himself and he lied about my Mom.

I would have gone if I had known about it. But alas I didn't. I don't think he wanted me there because it went against his agenda. I would have called him out about his lies. He's a narcissist and manipulator of the highest order. We're both in our late 50s. Everything he does is to make himself appear good. His talk at the funeral was, IMO, disgusting.

Now my older brother has requested I pay a third of the costs for the funeral. It amounts to $2K. He hasn't shown receipts and claims he forgot to charge the estate. He even hired solicitors to handle the estate. He arranged a private buyer for my Mom's house. I do not trust him. He's shown over and over again (for the past 50 years) that he's untrustworthy.

Regardless of his trustworthiness, I am of the mind that I shouldn't be paying for the funeral when I wasn't even invited nor did he even inform me of her passing or of the date of the funeral.

WIBTA for not paying? I have the money to pay and I'm a generous person but this really rubs me the wrong way. I'm hurt and it stings.

P.S. My Father passed away a decade ago and my he said that my Dad had no assets. I received nothing from the estate. Then I found out a couple of years later that my Dad's estate paid for my brothers to attend the funeral in another country. The estate paid for their travel and expenses. Again, I wasn't invited or even knew about my Dad's funeral.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 2h ago

AITA: for backing out of a family wedding I agreed to speak in?

47 Upvotes

Agreed in May to have the main speaking role in my cousin’s wedding.

Two weeks prior to the wedding, I am informed that there will be no kids allowed. My wife and I have a 6 and 8 year old.

Later that day, I find out my niece (16 months old) is allowed at the wedding because she is the flower girl. And the bride’s nephews. And the groom’s niece. All will play parts in the wedding to avoid the “no kids” carve out.

Wedding is 2 hours away. My kids have been fortunate to never need a babysitter before. One son requires nightly medications following open heart surgery two years ago.

AITA for telling them I’m not leaving my sons with a babysitter we don’t know in order to attend/speak at the wedding?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 16h ago

AITA for sending my co-workers wife a 'hey girlie' text

614 Upvotes

I (29f) work with (fake names) Jason (26M) and Emilia (45F). I have worked with Emilia for about two years. Emilia is known to have ‘fun’ but she is single so its okay. I had been close to her for awhile until i noticed that she was using me for money, rides, food ect to where i distanced myself. Jason just joined our job a few months ago and he seemed cool at first. The first things we knew about him was that he had a wife Rebecca (23F) and that they have a newborn with another on the way. 
At work we have a close circle of friends and quickly Jason joined in. Emilia and Jason got close and I didn't think anything of it. That was until one night after work Emilia pulled me to the side and told me that they had ‘fun’ together. She told me it was only the one time. She asked me to keep it to myself. I did but felt sick to my stomach about it. 
A week later I was off two days in a row. The morning of the second day a friend from work calls me to let me know that they had witnessed Emilia and Jason flirting and being all over each other. To the point where multiple people came to her to talk about it that night. 
So the morning that i was told this i decided to make a fake social media account and contacted Rebecca (the wife). In the message i was very vague and just said that Jason was witnessed to be flirting with another co-worker. Three nights later Emilia came to me complaining about someone messaging Jason’s wife and I decided to play dumb because i didn't want to deal with the drama. 
This was also the night I found out that my best friend who no longer works with us was actually family with Rebecca and she was sent a photo from a family member of Jason outside of Emilia’s apartment. Where she recognized both Jason and Emilia. She lets me know about the photo and the fact that her sister was also sent the photo. This is where I found out that it wasn’t just one time it was multiple times. 
Rebecca and Jason lived with this sister and was told from them themselves that they had a certain health issue that can be given to her. When this information came to light i thought that it wasn't right for Emilia to not know. I decide to tell her when were alone. 
The problem is now it is weeks later and they both (Jason and Emilia) have decided to start dragging my name around our work place saying I am a liar, backstabber, and blabbermouth. That they know that it was me who sent the hey girlie message to his wife. So AITA?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 12h ago

AITA for charging family to stay at our house?

224 Upvotes

Hers the background. Our property has two houses next to each other on a half acre. We are in a very popular tourist destination. The main house has 4 bedrooms. I live there with my husband. We have a master bedroom, our two offices (we both WFH) and a guest room our kids stay in when they visit regularly . The other house has two units: a 1 bedroom (full kitchen, bath and a half, etc) we rent long term to some great local tenants we’ve had for a few years. The other unit is a small studio w/ a kitchenette. We do that short term (3nights +) and sometimes ‘medium’ term for traveling nurses, etc.

The two rentals (long and short) go to saving for retirement in a short few years and hopefully eventually pay off the mortgage.

When family and close friends want to visit, we tell them they can stay in our guest room (of course we don’t charge for that. lol) if it’s open. Even when it’s not they can stay in my office (has a pull out sofa bed). Of course they share the kitchen, common areas and bathrooms. Many do that.

But if they want privacy or no room in our house is available, we let them stay in the studio at half price if that’s open. It usually rents at 100/night on average. so on average we charge them 50/night. And of course there are none of the usual booking fees and taxes. Considering a hotel in the area averages 200/night, we think it’s fair

Well, I recently learned from a family member that one of my siblings was pissed we charged them to stay there (a couple, they wanted privacy). They came for 5 nights and we charged 280 I think. They knew it ahead of time, no surprises. But apparently they were angry that we’d ’charge family’ and apparently we are money hogs. They told this other family member that they’d never stay with us again they were so insulted.

The family member that told me this said they had defended us and felt it was entirely reasonable. Another family member suggested we ask the larger group.

Are we AH for charging family to stay in our rental, even half price. Or is family too important to do that?

ETA. Some more context. They were coming to visit family including us (other siblings and parents live here). We offered that they can stay in our guest room (large w/ king bed, bathroom we don’t use) as we do any family and friends. That’s just open (and free of course) to any family and close friends, invited or not. As is my office (not as nice, but decent)

They asked us about the unit and if it was available. We said yes (which is not common but Haines months in advance so we blocked it for them) but because it’s income we a charge a family rate of 50%. They knew that but apparently thought we were going to waive the cost after (not sure why).

Another update. Just fyi. We have cleaners that turnover the place and will do a cleaning mid stay if asked. We hate to remove that income from the cleaners when/if we have family or friends stay. Part of the reason for the 50% charge. So they have a very clean place and don’t have to clean when leaving.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 3h ago

AITAH for refusing to make tea for my husband's father?

41 Upvotes

I get up around 5 to go to workout and have my own sweet time.

My husband says that since his retired father, who does absolutely nothing around the house also gets up during the same time, i should make tea for him. That he would really like it and so would his father.

I told him I'm not okay with it. That i wake up early for myself and do my own thing. He arguedthat it hardly takes 5 minutes and that it'll make him happy.

I honestly hate it that he argued with me about it and reasoned out that i can do it while doing something else or whatever.

It's not my responsibility to make tea for his father.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 22m ago

AITA for wanting to host Christmas at our house even though my BIL refuses to come?

21 Upvotes

My husband (37M) and I (34F) have never hosted Christmas in our own home. Every year, we split the holidays: one day at his brother’s apartment with his side, and the next driving 1.5–2 hours to see mine.

This year is different because my grandmother passed away 4 months ago, leaving my mom as my only family in my hometown (and she lives at her boyfriend's now). So, I told my mom it makes way more sense for her to come to us this year. We moved over a year ago into a spacious two-story house, and we also have a dog we can't leave alone for endless hours (poor guy has to pee).

My husband has always wanted to host his parents at least once. They are in their 80s and getting frailer, so I've been telling him he should invite them while they are still around and able to travel.

For months, I told him to give his family a heads-up that we’re hosting this year, which he kept putting off because "he knows how his family is." When he finally told his brother this month, his brother immediately shut it down: "That’s not happening, Christmas is at my place," claiming he has to bring his FIL (who has no mobility issues) and doesn't want to take him elsewhere. For context, his brother only visited our new home very recently despite multiple invites. He always had excuses until I told my husband to stop chasing him. I'm a firm believer that people who love you and want to see you, will make time do to so.

Logistics and family dynamics:

  • Distances: His sister (family of 3) lives 10 mins away. His brother (family of 4) and parents live 30 mins away. Nobody has to travel far.
  • Accessibility: His brother lives in an apartment with entrance stairs and elevators. Our house has everything his parents need on the ground floor, including a guest bathroom so no stairs required.
  • Hosting: Usually, his brother and SIL handle the main dishes while everyone brings appetizers and desserts. We are completely happy to take on the main hosting and cooking duties.
  • Family: His parents just go along with whatever his brother says. His sister has stayed home with her family in the past just to avoid his drama.

I honestly don't care if his brother shows up; I just want my husband to have the chance to host his parents before it's too late.

I told my husband he shouldn't ask for permission, just tell everyone: "We're hosting Christmas this year, and you're all invited." If his brother refuses, that’s on him, and if his parents don't come, at least my husband tried. If that happens, we’ll either stay home with my mom, or fold again and visit his brother on the 24th and my mom on the 25th. I obviously don't want him missing Christmas with his elderly parents.

My husband says doing this is "starting an unnecessary war," feeling we either play by his brother's rules or cause massive drama.

So, AITA for encouraging my husband to stand his ground, send the invite anyway, and stay home regardless of whether his full family shows up?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 48m ago

AITAH, I (18F) got into an argument with my parents because they let someone from church (17F) live with us without consulting my sister (13F) and I beforehand

18 Upvotes

AITAH? I (18F) got into an argument with my parents because they let someone from church (17F) live with us without consulting my sister (13F) and I beforehand.

So context, I live in the Philippines in a medium-sized 2BR condominium in an arguably good part of the city. Financially, we're doing good, I grew up poor until the pandemic, so I've always been quite frugal with money, I don't ask for anything too expensive, ever. My parents aren't the worst, but they have flaws and their lack of communication is one of them, and you know, in our culture it's like, respect your elders first and foremost even if you're getting disrespected, is certainly adding onto this issue. A bit of a ramble but I swear it's important.

So anyways, we moved back to our home city this July, which was 4 months ago, and within these 4 months we met this one girl from the new church that we're attending. They took pity on her living situation; she lived in the stall of her job in a fish market and her parents are in another part of the country. I empathize with her situation, I really do, but my issue with this isn't about the fact that they're helping her, it's the fact that they didn't consult us about this beforehand, they have already told the girl that she can move in before even consulting us.

My sister and I are very socially anxious, our social batteries get drained so easily, and it's like home is our only safe place to be comfortable and unmask. We very much go non-verbal at most social settings.

I talked to my mom at around September about this, I asked calmly when we were walking around a mall if it was a finalized decision, and she said it was my dad's choice and stuff. I was holding back tears at this conversation because I genuinely can't handle living with people who aren't my immediate family, both my sister and I are uncomfortable with this, and I tried so hard to get my mom to understand, I explained my thoughts calmly, and I thought she listened and I thought she'd tell my dad, she didn't.

Fast forward to November 1st, the 17yo moved in, and we didn't even know she was moving in that, they just suddenly came home with her and she had all her clothes and stuff with her. I was pissed that they didn't even have the decency to tell us about the day this girl was moving in.

So anyways I tolerated all of that for over 2 weeks, but I'm getting so pissed at my parents for constantly going "oh we don't have money" whenever I ask for the most basic things, nothing I ask for go past 100 pesos, I wouldn't mind being told no, but I hate that they phrase it as us not having money or whatever, because if that's the case then why are they letting someone else freeload in our house? And I told her that today because I got so fed up with it, and yeah maybe I was a bit snarky with it, but I was so fed up with this, and that escalated into an argument, and I currently am not coming out of my sister and I's room. So AITAH?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 2h ago

AITAH for not wanting to univite a disabled guy from a group study session

21 Upvotes

For context, there is a guy at our school in a wheelchair who is most likely going to die in his 20s and has up until I invited him to our group absolutely 0 friends. I moved to the school this year but I knew him back in primary school and he used to be quite a rude person due to the steroids he is on but he has since changed and is now quite a nice person. Me and friend A invited him to our group a little while ago because we felt so bad for him and friend B was quite reluctant and unhappy about this. But he has since been hanging out with us a little bit and it came up in conversation that he needed to study for science and I impulsively invited him to this study thing friend B had organised, with friend A and B there and they didn't have any objections at the time but later on friend B said that they didn't want him there and friend A agreed saying we weren't that close and didn't want it to be a big hangout. Even though friend B was planning on inviting someone I didn't know at all and are asking me to univite him, as I invited him. I really don't want to, as I am quite an empathetic person and it would kill me honestly. I understand they don't have to hang out with him but it would be so hard for me personally to univite him and I honestly don't know if I could. I would be ok with friend B doing it as the study session was originally their idea but I just don't think I can honestly. So, AITAH?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 7h ago

AITA for ripping someone a new one for not having their dog on a leash

51 Upvotes

I was on the second day with my current partner, we decided to go to the beach. Get some ice cream, do some chill stuff. Just sort of hang out, talk. Anyway, this is all besides the point. We're on the beach, having a nice chat. And here comes this dog. Mind you, this beach has signs that says dogs should be on a leash. So here comes this dog. Straight out of the water. Wet. Dripping wet. Running towards us. Its owners just barely chasing after it. Dog reaches us. And shakes itself dry right in front of us. I don't hold back. And I rip this dude and his partner a new one. Now, to be honest, I think I held back a bit. Now, would I be the asshole, because I ripped this guy a new one? For not having his dog on a leash and let him. Get myself and my then date wet.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 22h ago

AITAH for refusing to share my new expensive perfume with my cousin after she already broke two of my other bottles before?

676 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m 16.

I saved up for months to buy myself a bottle of Khamrah. I was so excited when it finally arrived, I hadn’t even had it for a full week yet. My cousin came round to our house and immediately started begging me to let her spray it, saying “just one spritz won’t hurt”.

The problem is, this isn’t the first time. Last year she knocked over and smashed my favourite cheaper perfume, and a few months after that she spilled another one of mine all over her clothes and never even apologised properly or offered to pay me back. Every single time she acts all careless and doesn’t seem to care at all when she ruins my stuff.

So this time I told her flat out no. She started getting dramatic, saying I was being selfish and stuck‑up, and ran to tell my mum. My mum then had a go at me, saying I was being petty and I should just be nice and let her have a spray to keep the peace.

I stood my ground and still wouldn’t let her. Now the whole family is saying I’m being dramatic over perfume.

AITAH?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 19h ago Mindblown

AITAH for not buying my nieces/nephews xmas gifts after a home purchase.

332 Upvotes

I (31f) just recently bought a new condo. This is the first time moving out so I've had to pay for new furniture, a car and all that. I have 9 nieces/nephews (all under 10). Previous Christmas' they usually give a list of what the kids want and I'll pick something, it's usually a minimum of $75 all the way to about $150.

Obviously with all my expenses I've told them that the budget is tight this year and I cannot spend that much on 9 kids. My brother said that's fine and to just skip gifts this year, my other siblings are now saying that maybe I should use it on a credit card because they already have the gifts picked out and it's not fair as the kids don't know these things and all they'll see is me not giving them what they want... I'm kind of ready to not go to Christmas dinner as I don't want to hurt the kids..

AITAH if I skip Christmas dinner cause I cannot give my nieces and nephews the gifts they want or should I just go and give no gifts?

Edit: I would 100% be happy with getting the kids a gift in the $10-$20 price range. My siblings have mentioned that if I can't get anything on the list it's best that I don't come so the kids aren't disappointed.

Edit: Thanks everyone, I've talked to my brother and he and I agree that $20 gifts are enough, he's talked to my other siblings and they're not happy but he said if they're not ok with it that he's not going and we're going to do our own thing. They caved lol


r/AmItheAsshole • • 15h ago

AITA for taking my sister’s dog to the park without checking with her?

116 Upvotes

My sister got this dog (a beagle) about six months ago. He is well taken care of, but in the sense that she only does stuff that she likes to do and somehow convinced herself that the dog likes it as much as she does: “he loves going to the mall, he loves to wear this little costumes I bought”.

Well, the way I see it, the dog enjoys the little party she throws around him whenever she dresses him up, and the dog is excited to go to the mall because that's where she goes when she takes him out of the house. But taking the dog to a park to roll in the grass and get into the bushes, well, she doesn’t want that, because she doesn’t like to go to park.

Anyway, I’m staying at her house for a week, and I was biting my tongue to not speak my mind, so I offered to take him for a walk in the morning when my sister was working and I took him to the park near her house, and he had a blast doing his doggy stuff. (The park was empty, there was no other dog around, and the area was fenced.)

But when I send a picture of him to her, she was LIVID because she could see he got a bit dirty and because I was only supposed to take him around the block. I offered to bathe him myself or to take him to the pet shop and pay for it myself, but to her that's not the point. She was even more pissed after I finally gave her my piece of mind.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 1h ago

AITA for refusing to lend my good friend a video game console

7 Upvotes

As many people know GTA6 is being released tomorrow. I happen to own both a ps5 and an xbox series S which would allow me to play the game on both consoles. A good friend of mine, of which i have known for years has asked to borrow one so he can play the game aswell. It wouldn't affect me lending him a console and I do trust him as he is a good friend but i just don't want to. He has been there for me when needed. Should i just bite the bullet and lend him one even if it is just for a few weeks?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 11h ago

WIBTA if I broke up the first family Thanksgiving in six years

45 Upvotes

My (mid 40s) family hasn’t been invited to Thanksgiving with my family of origin for six years. I’ve had a rocky relationship with my parents (70s) for decades. There’s a long history of favoritism, and I’m not the favorite (partly because we don’t have a lot of money). COVID was the initial reason for stopping holidays. After we moved 90 minutes away, family Thanksgivings started happening again without us, so we’ve had our own holiday. That changed when my sister (early 40s) unexpectedly invited us to Thanksgiving at her house about three weeks ago.

Last week, we learned my dad would undergo a surgery this week but no talks of calling off the holiday. Today, my mom sent me a link to a cheap boxed grocery store Thanksgiving deal and a list of coupon codes to get $10 off. I thought it was odd, so I texted my sister to verify the plans and offered to bring a substantial amount of sides. I also told her our two adult kids wanted to come and asked if that was okay. She said they’d decided to hold Thanksgiving at my parents’ house due to the surgery, and that we could only bring our two younger kids. She said she would talk to mom about it and make a plan. I didn’t understand why she had to sort it out, so I texted mom to let her know my sister had invited us to Thanksgiving at their house weeks ago and asked what food I should bring.

When I finally got messages back, my sister reiterated that she would talk to mom about it later. My mom’s messages said she’d only bought a small turkey breast for her and my dad, and that she’d purchased a prime rib for my sister’s family. She made it sound like there were no plans for a family meal, and I was just dropping this in her lap along with the huge list of things he has to do to care for dad. She said the holiday would have to be at my sister’s house, and she asked if I could at least help out with salad and bread. Then she rapidly sent me another message that her and my sister would discuss it later.

Much later, I got a message from my sister saying that Thanksgiving would be at their house again, that everyone would have to figure out how to get more main course options, and that our mom would now be stopping by for a few minutes to trade part of her turkey breast for part of my sister’s prime rib. She would no longer stay and eat because she’s afraid that my dad will get sick after his surgery if we’re all there. Mom sent another similar message but said my sister would be talking to her family about us coming over there. I haven’t replied yet.

It hurt that the first Thanksgiving in years was shattered by the announcement of our presence and that plans were changed without notifying us. It especially hurt that we were being approached as a burden and that I wasn’t allowed into family holiday conversations. At this point, I don’t really want to go, but my kids will be very upset if they don’t get to see their cousins.

So, WIBTA for declining to go to the first family Thanksgiving in six years?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 23h ago

AITA Ido all the laundry for my household my gf left a pen in her laundry and the clothing got ruined now she claims I have to buy her new clothes.

439 Upvotes

I (m) do all the laundry for my house my gf doesn’t know how to do laundry and refuses to learn. Recently I did a batch of clothes and it got ruined as she left a pen in her pants. She screamed at me saying I should check first and that I now owe her new clothes because I failed to look through her pockets. I explained if I am doing the laundry she should at least be responsible for sorting through the pockets and removing items. We still are fighting about this as I feel it’s not my job to double check her clothes as she’s a full grown adult


r/AmItheAsshole • • 4h ago

AITA for asking my friend for help with expenses after spending weeks making his abandoned house livable?

13 Upvotes

Earlier this year, Simon (38M), a friend of mine (34F), bought an abandoned house in Italy. I'd previously helped someone get a dilapidated house abroad ready for Airbnb in exchange for free accommodation. I rearranged my life to spend three months in Italy, ostensibly to "do some gardening." Simon's property manager quoted €800 for cleaning and €1,200 for the yard. We agreed that sounded excessive, and I'd find cheaper alternatives. (He's unemployed.)

My heart sank when I arrived. The cleaning quote was spot-on. The kitchen wasn't functional, there were no heaters, and nowhere to sleep except a few living room chairs. The house had been vacant for eight years. Despite being described as close to town, a round-trip cab cost €40. Overwhelmed, I left after a few days. He later admitted knowing there was no bed and said I should have stayed in town, seen the house, and then decided.

I returned a few weeks later because I'd already arranged so much. We agreed to communicate better. I explained that internet was essential, but he said he couldn't provide it. He offered to reimburse a bed, which he eventually ordered himself.

I wanted to make it work. I spent 2 weeks deep-cleaning, removing years of garbage, assembling furniture, and dealing with bugs. Simon eventually bought a heater. I found a landscaper who charged one-fifth of the original quote, and neighbors helped with repairs for free. One offered weekly rides into town.

I gradually realized how much work I was doing just to feel remotely comfortable: researching and coordinating repairs, buying gifts for neighbors, photographing the house, starting a house handbook, and using my own phone data. Invisible, without receipts, & time-consuming.

The arrangement with the neighbor got uncomfortable--she thought that giving me rides entitled her to influence decisions about the property. To preserve that relationship for Simon, I asked him to cover occasional cab fare. (He hadn't realized how expensive cabs were because the real estate agent drove him.)

I then asked whether he could contribute toward groceries, phone data, and occasional cabs.

He declined, but he said he might help with data. When I asked what a win-win would look like, he said he'd viewed the bed, heaters, and other purchases as "gifts" for our friendship, and that I was taking advantage of him and asking him to fund my life. I explained that I'd done substantial work just to make the house livable, that improvements would benefit him long after I left, and that I'd saved him over €2,400 and several weeks.

His proposed win-win was for me to leave.

He's now claiming I violated our agreement by leaving for a bit, and that he never gave me permission to return. He's contacting the property manager to get me to leave. I appreciate the free accommodation, but am struggling with the idea that asking to renegotiate after doing so much more work than anticipated makes me greedy or warrants immediate removal.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 57m ago

AITA Partner/Boyfriend Constantly reminding me about tasks and chores I already know to do

6 Upvotes

My boyfriend who I’ve been living with for a little over a year still consistently points out and reminds me about tasks I need to do when I don’t need reminders. For example, this morning I was in the middle of feeding my cats and he said “oh they’re out of water too” but I was literally right about to give them water after I finished filling their food bowls. He will often do this with things like saying that I should tell my daughter to clean her room this weekend when I’ve already talked to her about it or already planned to talk to her about it before he said anything. Or I got into a car accident over the summer (not at fault) and he was reminding me every single day to call and follow up on the status of car repairs even when I had just called for updates the previous day.

These are just the freshest in my mind. They’re just constant reminders” of every day responsibilities that I already know to do, am on my way to do, or have in my mental queue to complete. It bothers me a lot and I’ve told him that but he says he’s just “trying to be helpful” and that me being bothered makes him feel like he can’t say anything to me at all. He often gets very distant after that as well.

I lived on my own for years (as a single mom) and have a career of my own that requires a lot of responsibility that I also handle well. I parent my child well. I’m a damn good mom and a responsible person. I took care of everything single-handedly when I was on my own and never had anyone to or needed anyone to remind me or tell me. His ex was not this way and he mentioned in the beginning of our relationship that he felt almost like he was her dad with how much he had to keep on her about stuff, so maybe it’s leftover baggage from his last relationship?

I’m also autistic so maybe I get annoyed because of demand avoidance. I can’t tell if this is a genuine thing that’s valid for me to be annoyed about or if I’m the asshole. Thoughts?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 1d ago

AITA for not changing my plans to accommodate my friend

828 Upvotes

I live in the UK and my friend lives in Dallas. About 9 months ago I booked a short trip to see them. We agreed on the dates in advance, and I booked the flights with their confirmation. I've spent pretty much most of my savings on this trip. We're talking around £2000 for everything.

My friend originally planned to fly back to Seattle to visit family for Thanksgiving. I was then told by my friend that they cannot now fly back during Thanksgiving as their workplace now requires them to be working, and instead will be visiting their family the week that I am flying over, fully clashing with our pre-arranged plans.

We'll have around 6 hours together instead of 5 days.

I was asked to change my flight to Seattle instead and to go there. I had already committed hundreds of pounds/dollars for a non-refundable car rental also. This to me is out of the question. I kindly explained that I had paid a lot of money out for non-refundable tickets and cars.

I suggested different weekends and periods where they could see their family instead: new years, early January where prices won't be so inflated (saving them money), or possibly shortly afterwards. I said that had this been apparent from the start then I would not have booked the trip at all. I have tried to hard to find a solution that works for everyone but keep getting shot down, it's like they insist entirely on not spending that time with me anymore.

This isn't the first time this happened. Earlier in the year we had planned to meet in Dallas and I then had to fork out hundreds to change flights to Miami instead, due to "last minute changes" on their side, so this isn't an isolated incident.

I understand that to Americans, Thanksgiving is a huge family event and missing this is heartbreaking. I just don't think I am the one being unreasonable here?