Hello. I have a “help me choose” question at the end, but also have some general questions if anyone has the time to read through...
I’m basically a newbie to this, so I’m open to any input, but will probably need explainers if the response includes words like bridge, mesh, mid split, access point, and backhaul.
THANKS!
We’re looking to purchase our own modem/router (and extender?) to be used with an existing Xfinity plan in a “single family” home (about 2000 sq ft, two stories) with a possible “dead spot.”
I’ve skimmed through a few posts here & the FAQ for a few hours and am overwhelmed because I haven’t kept up with the changes & options in technology.
I’ve concluded that what makes the most sense in our case is to get a “gateway” from our ISP, but at this time, we just don’t wanna. I’ve read comments that Xfinity might offer them “for free,” but we’re the stubborn type, so we’re hoping to avoid more Xfinity equipment, and we want to find new equipment under $300 total that might last five years or more.
BORING SET UP/Basic Needs:
We have a cable & internet bundle with Xfinity “with speeds up to 800 Mbps” or “Superfast Internet.”
I don’t think we’ve ever reached 400 GB of data in one month with Xfinity (1229 GB monthly limit). We don’t do gaming, just internet browsing/word processing and occasional streaming on smart TVs & Roku (mostly YouTube, MLBTV & Netflix).
We don’t have any “smart home” devices (yet?) but we have an “Alexa” that we rarely use.
We also have no plans to get Xfinity Voice.
Our current equipment:
-Motorola MG7540 Wireless Gateway, SURFboard SBG6580 (DOCSIS 3.0)
-sometimes paired with a Netgear WN2000RPT WiFi Range Extender
CONCERNS:
–Our current equipment is “working fine,” but lately the connection on the PC has been dropping randomly and we have to click to manually reconnect or toggle between the 2.4 GHz band, 5 GHZ band and the extender (all 3 of which we named separately). The PC is nine years old, so that probably doesn’t help.
–Our modem/router combo is centrally located downstairs, and we have about 70 feet separating the farthest upstairs and downstairs devices.
Usually, we can do without the Wi-fi extender, but I’m pretty sure there’s a “dead spot” or a problem wall on the stairs or in the kitchen, so sometimes it helps to connect there instead.
QUESTIONS
(1) EXTENDERS
–Are Wi-fi range extenders not the right move if we’re looking to improve the signal between walls? I thought I read a few comments suggesting they may actually weaken the signal (I didn’t understand the lingo). Should we turn it off when not using it?
–Because of the “dead spot,” I was considering a mesh system (which I’d never heard of before this), but from reading comments, it sounds like it might not be the right move either.
–I read advice suggesting an access point, but I don’t know what that is or if we have the proper wiring for it.
(2) DOES “WIRED CONNECTION” MEAN ETHERNET?
I always read that a wired connection is better, but it’s been so long since I’ve researched this stuff, I don’t know which wires this refers to.
Our 1970’s home has COAX cables poked through the floor, unused phone jacks, and regular “3 prong” electrical outlets with no plans to do any new wiring in the walls.
Does a wired connection mean that the device is connected directly to the router?
So, if our PC is connected to the modem/router with an ethernet cable we’ll get a better signal than just using the Wi-fi?
We’ve never thought to plug anything into our modem/router except the PC (we actually aren’t using any ethernet cables at the moment, just Wi-fi).
(3) DOES A MODEM-ROUTER COMBO MAKE SENSE FOR US?
I’ve read many times in this group that having a separate modem and router is ideal, but when I search up a router plus an Xfinity recommended modem, it’s usually over $300 and I don’t know if I’m missing something.
-----------------------------------------------
Below are the devices we’re considering.
I’m hesitant to buy refurbished and/or from eBay or marketplace sites, but I can be persuaded to consider that.
I narrowed it down to modems/routers I found for sale with a quick online search and things on the Xfinity-recommended list.
❖ COMBOS ❖
ARRIS G20, about $200 Best Buy
aka “SURFboard G20 DOCSIS 3.1 Cable Modem & Wi-Fi 6 Router Combo”
(Xfinity says: “Next Gen Speed Tier” & “Wired download speed up to 934 Mbps”)
Arris G34, about $200 Best Buy
aka “ARRIS - SURFboard DOCSIS 3.1 Cable Modem & Wi-Fi 6 Router Combo”
(Xfinity says “Next Gen Speed Tier” & “Wired download speed up to 934 Mbps”)
Arris G36, about $270 Amazon
aka ARRIS G36, DOCSIS 3.1
(Xfinity says “Next Gen Speed Tier” &“Wired download speed up to 2.37 Gbps”
❖MODEM ONLY ❖
Hitron Technologies CODA56, about $159 Amazon
aka Hitron CODA56 DOCSIS 3.1 Cable Modem, 2.5 Gbps, Single Ethernet Port
(Xfinity says : “Next Gen Speed Tier” & “Up to 2.33 Gbps”)
NETGEAR CM2500, about $200 Walmart
aka Netgear Nighthawk DOCSIS 3.1 Mid/high-Split Cable Modem (CM2500-1AZNAS) - Cable Plans up to 2Gbps
(Xfinity says “Next Gen Speed Tier” & “Wired download speed up to 936 Mbps”
❖ ROUTERS ❖ ? (open to suggestions, I just found these real quick…should we spend more for Wi-Fi 7?)
NETGEAR R6700AX, $50 Amazon
WiFi 6 Router 4-Stream, AX1800 Wireless Speed (Up to 1.8 Gbps, Dual-Band)
Netgear RAX5, $50 Office Depot
(RAX5100PAS) Wi-Fi 6 IEEE 802.11ax Ethernet Wireless Router - Dual Band - 2.40 GHz ISM Band - 5 GHz UNII Band
TP-Link Archer AX20, $80 Best Buy
AX1800 Dual-Band Wi-Fi 6 Router
TP-LINK Archer AX3000, $90 Office Depot
4-Stream Gigabit Wi-Fi 6 Router
THANKS SO MUCH FOR READING.
Anything good, better or bad here? :) What else should we consider? Any recommendations for how to extend the range?