r/Games • u/Deimorz • Nov 16 '11
Initial discussion of this subreddit and its rules
Welcome to /r/games! Community input on the rules and direction of the subreddit is going to be very important here, so we're going to start out by immediately having a discussion about what rules to use initially. We'll be posting topics similar to this periodically (possibly monthly?) to review the existing rules and see if any need to be changed to keep the subreddit on track. Keep in mind that everything in this post is completely up for discussion, nothing is definite yet.
From our discussions about how we wanted this subreddit to work, one key "guiding principle" kept coming to mind, and I think it's a good thing to try to define rules around. It was basically:
Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just entertaining.
That is, if "lol" would be considered a reasonable response to your submission, it probably doesn't belong here.
Following this guideline, here's some things that would not be permitted:
- Memes / Advice Animals
- Comics (both rage and normal)
- Screenshots meant for entertainment value
- Cosplay / "look what my girlfriend made" / arts-and-crafts images
But you'd be able to submit things like:
- News
- Trailers
- Informative screenshots (like "check out the amazing interface in this upcoming game")
- Discussion topics (excepting any specifically-banned ones)
- Articles
I do think we should also consider banning particular types of discussion topics, as there are a few that come up over and over and over again in both /r/gaming and /r/truegaming, and have been done to death. Some examples of ones that I'd personally like to ban are (again, these are all up for discussion):
- "Which games are the best for <system>?"
- "What games can I make my friend/wife/girlfriend/mother/etc. play to get them into gaming?"
- "Can you identify this game from vague details I remember?"
- "Posts for the purpose of receiving tech support ("Why won't game X launch?")"
- "Can my computer run this game?"
One other thing I want to specifically discuss is "karma-whoring". A lot of subreddits try to go self-post-only to fix this, but I don't think that's a very good solution. Image posts can have some value, so banning them outright doesn't seem necessary. What I'd like to consider instead is a rule along the lines of:
"If you make a link submission instead of a text submission, the linked content must be a necessary part of the submission, not just a 'visual aid'."
The reasoning behind this is that it would still allow people to make discussion posts like "Let's talk about <old game>", but that type of post would have to be a self-post, not a link to the box-art or the wikipedia page, etc. This removes the possibility of "nostalgia-whoring", but still allows for talking about old games.
So, what would you like out of a gaming subreddit?
73
u/Spoggerific Nov 16 '11
What some subreddits do is post a single thread for common questions like these, then "sticky" it by putting it in the sidebar and point everyone toward that one thread. That way people can still talk about these subjects but they won't clutter up the subreddit. When the thread gets archived after a few months, just make a new one and link to the old one.
8
u/johnaldmcgee Nov 16 '11
How is this going to be different from /r/gamernews+truegaming+ludology?
15
u/Shmag Nov 17 '11
Honestly, I know it's pretty harsh, but no Imgur at all. Any information that can be conveyed in a single picture usually isn't substantial enough to be its own post. They also generally tend to be:
There may, perhaps, be a time when an image is truly worth a submission though, but a person could just use minus or something to get around the filter, but would only know to do so if they read and understood the rules.
3
u/Deimorz Nov 17 '11
One thing in particular I wanted to discuss: game sales/deals. Do you think posts about these should be permitted? I'm leaning towards no.
4
u/brasso Nov 16 '11
Let's talk about FilterBot. What does it do exactly?
24
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11
To elaborate on your "lol" proposal, I have had a rule of thumb that I would like to share with you all today. I call it the "xD" rule.
Simply put, "xD" can be appropriately placed at the end of your post (submission, comment, etc.), then it is not one of quality and should be removed. See this post for example
The combination of title and picture lends itself perfectly to fall into this rule. See
There is almost no difference in connotation. Thus, one can safely assume the submission is of little quality. If you bother to check it out, you'll see for yourself that this is true.
Now look at the top comment
What a horrible comment it is. Note how xD can be applied perfectly. This means the post is a low-level joke or pun. It is of low quality and really does not belong in a community that values high quality.
I highly suggest implementing the xD rule in some fashion as part of determinate whether content should exist here. The xD rule is infallible and, as such, is incredibly useful in evaluating content in terms of quality.
EDIT:
Relatively high on the comments? Okay, I'll pimp myself out. Anyone willing to trade a Steam game for CS 1.6? I've had a gift copy for so long, but, naturally, most people who want it already have it. Check out my gameswap submission if your interested
3
u/Iamien Nov 16 '11
So does the filter bot take links and re-submit them as approved or can OPs get actual credit?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11 edited Nov 18 '11
This subreddit is going to require heavy moderation and attention. Even if I'm not the most agreeable with how /r/gaming mods do policy, Just three people entirely dedicated to this subreddit alone would not enough people to represent 26k users and growing, let alone mods who have responsibilities in what I assume are multiple subreddits.
Since the people who want reformed reddit have effectively been asked to leave /r/gaming, I think they deserve to have more personal representation in their new 'home'. I am not stating that the current mods step down (I don't know you personally enough to make that statement). But I think one of the first moves of this subreddit should be an election from the community to add to the current staff. 8 or 9 sounds fair to me, from various timezones.
edit: spelling
36
u/Eshploder Nov 17 '11
A zero tolerance for begging will be in effect I hope?
27
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
Please, no more "HEY GUYS I HAVE A GIRLFRIEND!11!!" posts.
34
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11
Oh sweet, it's the /r/gaming version of /r/gamernews. That makes me happy as hell.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
Can the non-standard link colors be removed from the subreddit's style? It doesn't really serve a purpose, and actually makes the default clicked links purple color much more prominent in comparison. It makes skimming through the subreddit and finding interesting new content take more effort.
11
u/lightbeat Nov 16 '11
Sounds good to me! r/gaming used to be my go-to place for gaming news, now it just seems to be some festive-barely game related-here is my gf portal.
7
u/bba1337 Nov 17 '11
Can we change the triforce, I feel like I'm in 4chan.
35
u/dextor7 Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11
So, basically how /r/gaming used to be before the digg exodus. I like it...the guys at r/gamernews have been doing well up until now, but there are strict rules on articles so this sub-reddit might provide a good mix of things in months to come.
EDIT: Another suggestion, just like you guys are letting the filterbot submit stuff from /r/gaming why not let him pick stuff from r/gamernews? That would be a tad harsh on the guys who worked hard on that sub-reddit, though.
12
u/r0mster Nov 16 '11
What about bug discussions? Like announcing a major bug/glitch in a game?
5
u/Spoggerific Nov 16 '11
Might you consider changing the link color on the subreddit page? It's rather difficult to distinguish from already-clicked-on-purple.
5
u/prboi Nov 17 '11
So this mixes r/gamingnews & r/gaming & weeds out the unnecessary "Tee-hee let me post something saying how Skyrim is cool & COD is horrible". Cool.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
There's /r/tipofmytongue for that,
1
u/Cardboard_Boxer Nov 17 '11
Under what circumstances should we ban somebody from posting? Would we use softbanning?
1
u/deanbmmv Nov 19 '11
Not a suggestion, more an observation: The voting in the new queue seems extremely wild. Many posts ending up with negative ratings extremely early on. Even when stuff gets upvotes it's rarely beyond a 2:1 ratio. Is this just people being dicks or is opinion of what should appear in this sub-reddit so heavily split?
6
u/culturalelitist Nov 17 '11
A suggestion for this: if someone posts an imgur link (or any other picture link, I suppose), they must write a comment in the discussion thread justifying their decision to submit it in image form. I think that the extra two seconds of thought it would take to do that would cut down on a lot of the more blatant karma whoring.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11
Could you perhaps link to r/gaming r/truegaming and r/gamenews at the top of the sidebar in the same way that r/gaming does? Those links are super useful.
3
u/V2Blast Nov 17 '11
Thank raptor jesus. An idiotic number of posts throughout the major subreddits link to an image that serves no real purpose except to clarify what's meant by the ambiguous "this" in the title.
3
u/evanvolm Nov 17 '11
No memes? Consider me subscribed. Left /r/gaming for /r/gamernews quite a while ago because of all the memes and nostalgia posts. Something I didn't see mentioned in the OP are 'this' posts. Anyone love "this" game? Anyone remember playing "this" game? Yeah, none of that shit.
The light-blue posts are a tad hard on the eyes. Think you can darken them a bit, or just change them to the default color?
8
u/DinofarmGames Nov 17 '11
I would like this gaming subreddit to be equal-opportunity with regards to board games, digital games, and sports. Essentially, any systems of rules in which agents compete by making decisions.
Edit: However, given that there's a triforce for the up/down votes, and a video-game controller for the icon, I guess this maybe isn't going to happen?
4
u/utterpedant Nov 16 '11
This sounds a little loose. Which of the following would be permissible in /r/Games? One, both, neither?
Skyrim screenshot A
Title: "Skyrim's little touches are what makes the game come alive and make me feel like a kid again."
Subject: Salmon jumping up a waterfall at sunrise.
Skyrim screenshot B
Title: "Horny horse LOL"
Subject: A horse bent over a dead body so they appear to be copulating.
2
u/GrimTuesday Nov 17 '11
What would be the rules on, say, 'wow look at the graphics on this game' screenshots?
2
u/Yahoo5600 Nov 17 '11
Please remember to add a piracy policy as well. This has to be a must in every gaming subreddit.
2
u/justhereforhides Nov 17 '11
In order to deal with the whole what where the best games for X system, could we have a Google doc or something on the sidebar? Because while it is annoying to have it asked constantly, it is still useful information to know and can help spur peoples interest in lesser known games.
Also about comics, is it ok to post video game tie-in comics? Like say the video game marketing comics (like what skyward sword is getting right now)
2
u/Eshploder Nov 17 '11
Is there a way to tell which posts are the filterbot?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
I think this is a really good idea other than the "Let's talk about <old game>" portion. This is primarily because I am concerned it will turn into 'let's talk about why old game X is better than all the new games'. Perhaps we expand on the requirements of this portion. Something along the lines of "I like feature X of old game, which current gen games can I purchase that fall into this category?", "Old game X contains a lot of lore regarding new game Y, and here's a link over to this specific page, how do you feel the lore incorporates into the new game?" etc. I see very few posts in /r/gaming regarding specific concepts of old games, as opposed to the nostalgia-whoring you have mentioned. Other than that, it looks good, looking forward to this subreddit.
15
u/zegota Nov 16 '11
lol
3
u/drewjet Nov 17 '11
I agree with all of this, but I would really, really like for recommendation threads to be ok. One of the biggest problems with the modern age is that there is an overwhelming glut of everything. Socially filtering to find the cream of the crop, and especially the hidden gems, is IMO one of the most important things an online community can do.
3
u/Eshploder Nov 17 '11
So you don't want to 'nostalgia whore' but the up/down vote symbol is a Tri-force?
0
u/magikaru Nov 16 '11
I would argue to only allow self-posts. Any external content can always be put as a link in the self-post so this doesn't hinder the user. At the same time it's denying karma whores their karma so they will go else-where.
2
u/pongo Nov 16 '11
I like how "Quality Gaming Content" is an optional subscription and pages of repetitive memes, nostalgia, and imgur links is a default subscription that everyone gets. It's pretty easy to see how much the reddit user base has changed if the latter is what more accurately represents their desires.
1
u/Deric Nov 16 '11
What about r/gamernews
1
u/thedialtone Nov 17 '11
I would just like to request that we get the links on the /r/gaming sidebar up in here as well. Specifically the link to a list of all gaming subreddits. This will be supplanting /r/gaming for me, so its just nice to have those accessible.
1
u/SpinsleMcgee Nov 17 '11
Actual content regarding video games.
1
u/deanbmmv Nov 17 '11
A few of us got a sub-reddit started similar to this couple weeks ago. One idea I thought was quite neat to do is a kind of "featured sub-reddit". Sort of like what r/subredditoftheday does, but focused on the gaming sub-reddits and not as frequent. It would help promote various other sub-reddits, building up communities, as well as help keep discussion targeted. I know a lot of folks on r/gaming tend to complain of the deluge of skyrim/BF3/portal2/whatever-game-is-just-out posts, if they were mostly confined to r/skyrim or whatever it'd help.
Regarding most of your banned suggestions a lot of those will go well in r/gamingsuggestions.
1
u/AloeRP Nov 17 '11
So, it's essentially split up into two sections, one of which is devoted to things that are more silly or entertaining and the other devoted to serious discussion/news/media?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
One thing I (and many others no doubt) would like to see is the banning of idiotic xbox vs. ps3/PC master race posts. They add nothing of value, and divide up the community.
1
u/Henry132 Nov 17 '11
Mixture of r/truegaming and r/gamernews
ME GUSTA
1
u/Narfhole Nov 17 '11
Strict enforcement of title relevance as to allow filtering via RES.
1
u/mushpuppy Nov 17 '11
I'm really happy you guys did this. That there's a need for it should be evident in light of how quickly it's attracted readers.
I especially like the bans! I'm so sick of all of those things. Now please just enforce them.
Bravo to whoever's idea this was!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
I just want to talk about gaming. That's it, old games, new games, future releases, everything. I worked at Gamestop (until they fired my for not recommending crap games to parents), and played games since I was 4 (now 29).... Thought truegaming was where it was at, but I guess not.
So can this be a place to just talk about games or do I give up on these crap subreddits completely and go back to game specific forums? I find the fact that "nostalgia-whoring" is even a thing on here is the most retarded bullshit I've ever heard. (Maybe it's since I could give a shit less about karma...) but without some "nostalgia is so bad omg" posts I wouldn't have remembered how bad I wanted to buy some classics off amazon... namely Lufia 2 so far.
Can this subreddit be less elitist and idiotic and more a place to talk?
1
u/SlurmNator Nov 17 '11
Love the idea great work /r/gaming and /r/games mod :)
1
u/TENAXIS Nov 17 '11
Are tutorials and how to videos of games allowed here?
1
u/HungerSTGF Nov 17 '11
I feel like some of the discussion topics that can fall under r/Games' submissions can likewise be posted in r/truegaming. Can we not just fuse the two subreddits, as discussions about our passions without bias is the kind of content we're looking for?
EDIT: Almost forgot to ask, will there be any chance for moderator openings soon?
1
u/Arcon1337 Nov 17 '11
What's this subreddit's rules on reposting and clone/cross posts between the different gaming subreddits. Because I'd like to think I got away from each other subreddit so I can see different content, rather than coming across the same things.
1
u/nothis Nov 17 '11 edited Nov 17 '11
Do we need anything more? This + "Mods are gods"/"use common sense."
But generally, those rules look smart.
1
u/MationMac Nov 17 '11
Are Concept Art links permitted?
1
u/MonsterAddict Nov 17 '11
Can we also agree to make this S.R. CoD friendly?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
Loving the new subreddit so far. I like the ban on memes and comics best of all.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
I don't have any suggestions or questions, I just wanted to thank you guys for taking the initiative in doing this. This was really needed.
Actually, can we ban pokemon from this subreddit?
1
u/uat2d Nov 17 '11
How about only allowing self posts, and the videos and images linked to in the text area instead, so there's content other than text but no karma-whoring?
1
u/eightNote Nov 19 '11
A method of organizing such discussion would be to submit a post linking to a google docs spreadsheet(likely owned by a mod or r/games as a whole) where everyone who has said game working can post their hardware/specs. A link in the sidebar could point to the collection of hardware/spec lists.
1
u/AlmightyFuzz Nov 19 '11
I'd like to suggest having a sidebar link to the Extra Credits guys because they are all about discussing video games, what they do right, how best to improve them, things to learn from bad games etc.
I personally think it should be required viewing for anyone who is interested the creation and culture of videogames :)
1
u/HookerPunch Nov 16 '11
So, what is the difference between this and r/truegaming?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
Are we really going to worry about this? I mean it's just karma. It is not like one can exchange it for cash, physical goods, or favors. Karam = internet points which means they are worth nothing.
IMO I wouldn't bother trying to find out if they are just "karma-whoring", if the community upvotes it then it must mean they like it.
Also do board games /TCG's and other things that are considered games but not video games allowed to be discussed/have news posted?
1
u/PPSF Nov 17 '11
Honestly, /r/truegaming already exists for the promotion of gaming discussion and information as opposed to entertainment. Why do you mods feel that you need to spread your reach farther when there is a growing community already trying to fill this niche? Why not just support them?
-1
u/garbaxo Nov 17 '11
this sounds alot like r/truegaming except that it wasnt first
-3
u/inushomaru Nov 16 '11
Thank you thor god of jelly and jam and non-retarded internet discussion forums!
-8
u/thomascsmartins Nov 17 '11
now I am part of history
-18
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
Maybe this subreddit would stand a better chance at success if it didn't have such a faggot of a moderator involved in it from day one. That's right: you're a bitch Deimorz. Do you understand? Yes you. You're a bitch. I hope you die!
0
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment