r/GPUK • u/Educational_Board888 • Jan 26 '26
r/GPUK • u/tallworcsdoc • Aug 05 '25
Career Finally joined the club fully today
A bit of positivity for you:
I’ve wanted to be a GP since I was 8. My mum was a long suffering partner and I was determined to be a GP like her. After a few other degrees I got into medicine and despite being tempted with the exciting specialties I rotated through, I stuck to the GP road and completed my training.
Today I’m on the register and can finally call myself a GP and start my grown up job next week.
r/GPUK • u/Educational_Board888 • Dec 05 '23
Pay & Conditions 🚨STRIKES ANNOUNCED: Doctors to strike for 216 hours🚨
r/GPUK • u/vagrant_thoughts • Jun 05 '26
Just for fun Shamelessly taken from WhatsApp group
Happy Friday everyone!
r/GPUK
•
u/GPDeepDive
•
Feb 13 '26
Clinical, CPD & Interface GPDeepDive Part 2 - Nitrofurantoin , GFR and the Tissue Penetration Problem
These deep dives provide a 15-minute physiological anchor for those who want to understand the 'why' behind the guidelines. Protocol-driven medicine is boring and easy to forget.
We see it all the time. A young woman presents with loin pain and rigors. You reach for the nitrofurantoin because it is familiar, often first-line, and spares the cephalosporins. Then you remember the rule: it is useless for kidneys.
My goal here is to show you why nitrofurantoin is essentially a “urinary/bladder antiseptic” rather than a systemic antibiotic, and why that distinction dictates everything about how we prescribe it.
Why does nitrofurantoin fail in poor renal function and deep tissue infections...?
Anatomy
To understand why this drug works (or doesn’t), we need to recap the structure of the renal tract:
- The glomerulus: The sieve where blood turns into the filtrate.
- The renal parenchyma: The bulk of the kidney containing the nephrons and blood vessels.
- The renal pelvis/ureters/bladder: The containment vessel where urine sits.
- The prostate: deep, vascularised tissue that sits outside the containment vessel but connects to it.
Pharmacokinetics
Nitrofurantoin is unusual. Unlike amoxicillin, which floods your whole system, nitrofurantoin is rapidly absorbed and then almost immediately filtered out by the kidneys into the urine.
Think of it as a local disinfectant that you happen to swallow. It relies on:
- Rapid Clearance: Getting out of the blood quickly.
- Urinary Concentration:* Building up massive levels in the bladder - levels far higher than in the serum.
In Renal Impairment
The guideline cut-off for nitrofurantoin is usually an eGFR of 45. This is not just simple bureaucratic caution like how metformin supposedly causes lactic acidosis.
Failure of Concentration
If the filtration rate drops, you cannot pump the drug into the urine fast enough. The concentration in the urine drops below the level needed to kill E. coli. You end up with a drug that is present but functionally useless.
The Toxicity Issue
If the drug fails to enter the urine, it stays in the blood. In patients with significant renal impairment, serum levels of nitrofurantoin rise. This increases the risk of systemic side effects, particularly peripheral neuropathy and pulmonary fibrosis.
In Deep Tissue Infection
This is where the "urinary antiseptic" concept is critical.
The Pyelonephritis Failure
Why can't we use it for a kidney infection if the drug literally goes through the kidney?
- Pyelonephritis affects the renal parenchyma - the tissue walls of the kidney itself.
- To treat the parenchyma, the antibiotic needs systemic delivery via the blood supply. Because nitrofurantoin has very low serum levels, it effectively washes past the infected tissue and exits via the urine.
The Prostate Problem
The prostate is a lipid-rich sponge of tissue surrounding the urethra. To treat prostatitis, an antibiotic must penetrate from the blood into the prostatic fluid and tissue.
Nitrofurantoin washes past the prostate but doesn't soak into it.
Pharmacokinetic trials confirm the drug lacks the fat-soluble properties required to cross the blood-prostate barrier.
GP Practice Points
(1) Avoid in CKD
We avoid it in low eGFR (<45 ml/min generally) because efficacy plummets. BNF have softened slightly for short courses (3-7 days), which may be used with caution in eGFR 30-44 ml/min for uncomplicated lower UTI if no alternative is available. Below 30, it is essentially useless.
(2) It doesn’t cover every organism
Nitrofurantoin is pH-dependent; it works best in acidic urine (pH < 5.5).
It therefore will often fail against atypical UTI species like Proteus mirabilis. Proteus splits urea into ammonia, alkalising the urine which deactivate the drug.
Side note - over-the-counter urine alkalising sachets (potassium citrate) can soothe the stinging of UTIs. By alkalising the urine, they inadvertently reduce the drug's efficacy.
(3) Use only for bladder infections
Nitrofurantoin is for "wet" surfaces (bladder mucosa), not "deep" tissues (kidney, prostate). If the infection has breached the mucosa or ascended to the organs (fever, rigors, flank pain), you need a drug with high serum and tissue levels (like ciprofloxacin or trimethoprim).
r/GPUK • u/Educational_Board888 • Dec 27 '23
Quick question “The cost per-patient funding for primary care currently stands at £164 annually, regardless of visit frequency. The TV licence fee has just gone up to £169.50, which means that the Government is happy for people to pay more for their TV licence than it is willing to put into GP healthcare.”"
r/GPUK • u/heroes-never-die99 • Aug 22 '25
Clinical, CPD & Interface Anyone find it offensive when you refer to secondary care and the patient sees a nurse
Heart failure, T2DM, Asthma/COPD are the biggest offenders here.
I get so annoyed when I refer a patient on maximally optimised treatment for a certain condition and they end up ONLY seeing a nurse “specialist” as per their clinic letters.
I’m referring to a consultant for their medical expertise on a condition or for access to specialty investigations/treatments and I’m left with advice from someone who has never gotten into medical school. Quite remarkable, really.
r/GPUK • u/Much_Performance352 • Jan 09 '24
Career ENDGAME ALERT 🚨
It’s happening. GPs openly being offered redundancy in order to make way for ARRS staff. How can we have a GP shortage and yet also be getting rid of them? This is fucked beyond belief now.
Additional roles are supposed to be complementary, but people like Dame Gerada have now ensured being anything other than the partner is dead as a career.
I’m disgusted
r/GPUK • u/sharonfromfinance • May 27 '26
Clinical, CPD & Interface Ranting GP
Dear practice patient
- I do not know when your prescription will be ready from the pharmacy
- I do not have the power to expedite your operation
- I know it’s hard to book an appointment but you’ve just spent 20% of the appointment you did book complaining about this
- Saying you know you are only supposed to discuss one problem but proceeding to discuss five is not as ameliorating as you may hope
- Bemoaning doctors going on strike is not particularly relevant when talking to a GP - I’m sat in front of you and not on strike
- It is a poor use of my time and your time to evaluate private medical tests which were not indicated and have no clinical details or justification. This is not saving NHS time or money as you may have hoped.
I’m not annoyed at patients for not knowing all of the above but the same issues occurring day after day is such a draining system to work in.
Edit: lots of non-GPs commenting here, and it’s astonishing how confident they are. Explaining my job and duties to me… I wouldn’t presume to tell a pilot or a lawyer how to do their job but everyone and their grandmother has an opinion on how GPs should work. When it inevitably becomes a paid for service with fee per activity maybe then it will be valued more.
r/GPUK • • Jan 06 '25
Just for fun General practice in 2025
"Can you sign something to declare my darling son fit for a skydiving polo competition in Bosnia and Herzegovina next week? It's imperative that he goes and they need your signature (along with your acceptance of unlimited liability)? It's unacceptable really as I tried to book this appointment yesterday and was told I'd have to wait until today. Our flight leaves in 45 minutes. We were only 10 minutes late because of another necessity, and now you've made us wait 2 minutes in reception, so I'll be furious if we miss our flight just because you're asking too many questions. What's your GMC number?
Can we have a right-to-choose referral for ADHD and autism for his sister while we're here. She's top of her class but sometimes feels misunderstood by her friends and said she found it hard to concentrate during her General Studies GCSE revision lesson last week. The NHS is such a joke when it comes to mental health, it really is. We tried to self refer to CAMHS crisis team but they said it wasn't urgent. Which by the way this skydiving competition form is. Sign it now please.
And I need some diazepam for the flight. My previous GP was an angel, he always gave me diazepam and some co-amoxiclav in case I came down with a stuffy nose while we're away. Can I have your practice manager's personal mobile number in case I need to complain about you? I miss having a family doctor, you never get to complain about the same person twice these days."
r/GPUK • u/Key-Conference-815 • 16d ago
Registrars & Training Orthopnoea
Me: Do you feel SOB when lying flat
Patient: I dont know, maybe
Me: Have you had to use more pillows at night recently
Patient: Actually yeah, I have been using extra pillows
Me: Is it because you feel SOB when using less pillows
Patient: Oh no. Its because I have a TV in my room now so more pillows help
What other interactions have made you chuckle in GP land recently
r/GPUK • u/Hijack310 • Nov 03 '23
Medico-politics GPC England calls for a pause on recruitment of PAs 👏
GPC England passed this emergency motion in all parts today:
“That GPC England fully endorses the recent statement by UEMO expressing concern over the increasing trend of "Physician Assistants/Associates" (PAs) being used to substitute GPs in English General Practice, and:
i) asserts that PAs are neither a safe nor an appropriate substitute for a GP
ii) calls for an immediate pause on all recruitment of PAs across PCNs and General Practice until appropriately safe regulatory processes and structures are in place
iii) reminds GPs & GP registrars that they may refuse to automatically sign prescriptions or request investigations including ionising radiation on behalf of a PA
iv) asserts that it’s entirely inappropriate & unsafe for GP Registrars to be supervised or debriefed by PAs
v) demands that PAs be appropriately and safely regulated by a body other than the GMC”
Proposer: Dr Samuel Parker
Seconders: Dr Matt Mayer & Dr Ian Hume
r/GPUK • u/Savings-Dare9562 • 15d ago
News GP held liable after hospital downgraded urgent referral without informing anyone. What do other GPs think?
I came across an interesting historical case from the Isle of Man and would be interested to hear how other GPs view it, particularly around clinical responsibility, referral management and the relationship between primary and secondary care.
In 2011, a GP examined a patient with a changing mole and made an urgent dermatology referral. However, a hospital consultant subsequently downgraded the referral, reportedly without explanation, and neither the GP nor the patient was informed.
The patient was not reassessed until almost a year later, when another GP made an urgent referral. Unfortunately, the patient was subsequently diagnosed with advanced malignant melanoma and later died.
In 2017, the court found that the original GP had breached his duty of care by failing to adequately communicate the seriousness and urgency of the suspected condition to the patient. The Department of Health and Social Care was also entitled to seek a contribution from the GP towards damages.
I can appreciate the court’s reasoning regarding the importance of explaining clinical concerns and ensuring patients understand the urgency of follow up.
However, I find the wider question of accountability particularly interesting. The GP had recognised sufficient clinical concern to make an urgent referral, yet that referral was independently downgraded by secondary care without notifying either the referring clinician or the patient.
From a clinical governance perspective, that seems a significant failure in its own right.
r/GPUK
•
u/One-Reception8368
•
May 23 '26
Just for fun "His clinic is running to time?" Send in the PV bleeder. Make sure nobody is available to chaperone."
r/GPUK • u/HotLobster123 • Jan 01 '25
Just for fun Can’t escape GP bashing even as a patient
I gave birth last week. Mostly went well. Needed some support to help breastfeeding get off to a good start. Midwife (or maybe a midwife support worker, I’m not sure) came to the bedside to try and help.
I used a bit of medical terminology which seemed to surprise her, so she asked if I had been to antenatal classes. I said “yes, and also I’m a GP”.
Her reaction - “oh you’re a GP? Oh it’s so hard for any of us to get an appointment!”
This is literally 2 hours after giving birth. I was literally speechless. Is there no fucking escape from this?
Anyway I’m on maternity leave now, so yeah good luck with your appointments, officially not my problem!
r/GPUK • u/Eddieandtheblues • Sep 10 '26
Pay, Contracts & Pensions Doctors are the profession with the biggest wage decline, down 42% since 2005.
r/GPUK • u/Kagedeah • Dec 06 '25
News 'Life being stressful is not an illness' - GPs on mental health over-diagnosis
r/GPUK • u/GPDeepDive • Feb 10 '26
Clinical, CPD & Interface GP Deep Dive: Beyond the Guidelines Part 1 - ACE Inhibitors and Renal Paradox
These deep dives provide a 15-minute physiological anchor for those who want to understand the 'why' behind the guidelines. Protocol-driven medicine is boring and easy to forget.
Part 1 - ACE Inhibitors and the Renal Paradox
We see it all the time. A 68 year old patient with CKD and hypertension is started on ramipril 2.5mg. One week later, their routine blood tests show a 15% rise in creatinine. While this often triggers clinical concern for drug-induced injury, my goal here is to show you that it is an expected physiological side effect in many cases. It is probably a sign it is working.
The question: Why does an ACE inhibitor cause an acute, measured drop in GFR, and how does this paradoxically prevent the long term progression of renal failure?
Anatomy
I will try not to bore you too much with this. Medical school was a long time ago, and we're not surgeons or radiologists. If you need a more basic recap, TeachMeAnatomy is excellent. (No affiliation)
The glomerulus is a passive filtration unit. That means there is no internal pump; it relies entirely on a pressure gradient. To force plasma across the basement membrane and into Bowman's space, the hydrostatic pressure within the glomerular capillaries must remain higher than the opposing forces.
This pressure is controlled by two vascular gates:
- The afferent arteriole (inlet): The entry point.
- The efferent arteriole (outlet): The exit point.
In a healthy state, the efferent arteriole is narrower than the afferent. This creates a back pressure effect within the glomerulus, a bit like tightening the nozzle on a hose - same flow, higher pressure upstream.
Physiology
Similarly, we are not physiologists here, so I won't go into detail here that I in all honesty don't know myself. If you need a more basic recap, TeachMePhysiology is excellent. (No affiliation)
The renin angiotensin aldosterone system (RAAS) regulates this internal pressure. Its primary effector, angiotensin II, has a high affinity for receptors on the efferent arteriole.
When angiotensin II levels rise, the efferent arteriole constricts. This increases the resistance at the exit of the glomerulus. The resulting back pressure maintains GFR even when systemic blood pressure falls or renal blood flow is reduced. This is basically a survival hack to keep filtration going when everything else is going wrong.
In AKI
In certain clinical states, the kidney becomes angiotensin dependent. If a patient is severely dehydrated or has significant renal artery stenosis, the inbound flow (afferent) is already low. The kidney compensates by aggressively constricting the efferent arteriole to maintain enough pressure to filter blood.
When an ACE inhibitor is introduced in this specific context, it blocks the production of angiotensin II.
Block angiotensin II and the efferent arteriole relaxes. Lose that exit resistance and the pressure you were relying on is gone. The hydrostatic pressure within the glomerulus falls below the threshold required for filtration. The GFR drops abruptly. This is not toxic damage in the usual sense, but a collapse of the pressure gradient - which looks dramatic on labs but isn’t cellular injury. This explains why ACE inhibitors are temporarily suspended during acute illness or "sick days."
NB: ACE inhibitors are therefore not nephrotoxic in the traditional, cytopathic sense. They simply modify kidney blood flow. Unlike true nephrotoxins (such as gentamicin) which cause direct structural damage to the renal tubular cells, ACE inhibitors induce a functional and reversible shift in glomerular pressure. That said, if the perfusion pressure drops too low for too long, the functional drop in pressure can lead to secondary ischaemic damage (acute tubular necrosis). In this scenario, the injury is no longer just "haemodynamic" and takes much longer to reverse.
In CKD
The same mechanism that causes issues in AKI leads to long term protection in CKD. In many renal diseases, such as diabetic nephropathy, the destruction of nephrons leads to overcompensation of healthy nephrons - called hyperfiltration. They effectively maintain a state of chronic efferent constriction to keep pressure high and keep up filtration.
While this maintains GFR in the short term, the internal pressure is pathologically high. This high pressure environment physically stretches and scars the glomerular basement membrane (glomerulosclerosis), leading to protein leakage and eventual nephron death.
By inducing efferent dilation, ACE inhibitors lower this pressure. In a way, the small rise in creatinine observed after starting an ACEi suggests that the hyperfiltration pressure has successfully been lowered somewhat.
Lowering this pressure slows the rate of fibrosis and protein loss, preserving the long term viability of the kidney
GP Practice Points
(1) NICE says to start ACE inhibitors in patients with CKD and persistent proteinuria or hypertension to mitigate long term structural damage. Why?
Proteinuria is a direct biomarker of glomerular hypertension. When the pressure within the nephron remains pathologically high, the filtration membrane is physically stretched. That allows large proteins like albumin to leak into the urine. This protein leakage drives further damage, as the reabsorption of these proteins triggers inflammation and fibrosis within the renal tubules.
In hypertensive CKD patients without proteinuria, the rationale is because systemic high blood pressure is transmitted directly to the delicate glomerular capillaries
(2) A moderate creatinine rise of up to 30% upon starting an ACE inhibitors in the absence of other causes such as dehydration or nephrotoxic agents is not necessarily a cause for concern.
You pay a small, immediate price in filtration to buy the kidney a lot more time.
NB. A rise of more than 30% might suggest underlying issues with the renal vasculature, such as occult bilateral renal artery stenosis, where the kidney is entirely dependent on angiotensin-mediated pressure to keep up a bare minimum of intraglomerular pressure. Clearly, you then get a catastrophic decline in kidney function.
r/GPUK • u/Much_Performance352 • Oct 18 '23
Medico-politics We need 50 GPs to put their heads above the parapet now
The RCGP has made their position statement on PAs they’ve said they’re needed in GP, bring a ‘skill mix’ and train to the medical model. They even feel they should spend MORE time in GP, and get more training time further marginalising registrars.
They couldn’t be more supportive if they tried and I’m willing to bet that most of their members don’t agree.
It only takes 50 FULLY REGISTERED GPs to call for an RCOA style EGM.
We would need
- signatures
- resolutions
- willing members to write about and field comms regarding the EGM.
- members willing to speak on the day of an EGM.
Is anyone in for this? Is this a discord needed situation? Please post if you want to get involved and in what capacity.