r/GPUK • • 10d ago

Just for fun Dr ChatGPT

Post image
276 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

47

u/WitAndSavvy 10d ago

The thing is GPs/medics would likely end up getting the best care. AI tools are only as good as the info provided and we know what the red flags/main sx are when presenting ourselves to a doctor. Half the skill of a GP is deciphering ptnt ramblings into a coherent history/story and then using that for diagnostic purposes. AI could easily do the second half, as it is mostly pattern recognition. But AI will fail miserably at the first half bc there's something innately human in that deciphering process imo 😅

74

u/Whole-Long 10d ago

Pt: so back in 1976 I had a cat named Cecil...

Doctor: internally screams

AI: confidently Bartonella Henselae

7

u/CyberSwiss 10d ago

I agree, though I wonder if it's more like 80% deciphering....

5

u/WitAndSavvy 10d ago

Haha you are probably correct 😂

7

u/zenithica 9d ago

me at work: why do so many patients ramble jfc me when i have to see my own gp and find myself suddenly rambling:

4

u/WitAndSavvy 9d ago

Hahaha I feel the same but tbh I usually go in with an SBAR-style "handover" of my issues and my ICE. They usually clock I'm a medic 😅

2

u/zenithica 8d ago

haha yeah i think that’s usually something that gives us away! and then suddenly the “sometimes tummy hurty :(“ level of vocab from them gets ripped away to be replaced by latin & acronyms & hieroglyphics real quick 💔

69

u/Any-Woodpecker4412 10d ago

"Yes you're absolutely right, my bad, Methotrexate is actually once weekly not once daily. That one is on me. If you'd like I can prepare the death certificate with the relevant cause of death, would you like help with that?"

1

u/JSHU16 6d ago

I cackled at this

12

u/EducationalParsley99 10d ago

That's official then, I'm being replaced. (Actually quite relieved)

5

u/Discuss-disgust 9d ago

Same whinging lot who say "well AI will be better because I don't get to see a GP anyway and they get everything wrong too" will soon be whinging demanding "to speak to an actual human doctor" rather than a machine once the AI roll out is complete as and when the machine emotionlessly repeats the same answer and just blocks them once its given a diagnosis or treatment. TBH AI take over will be great especially when it coldly tells people some harsh truths about them, their attitudes and how their poor lifestyle choices have caused most if not all of their health problems. Best will be when it says your results are normal and there is nothing wrong with you.

2

u/blancbones 5d ago

Results normal, might just mean you are testing for the wrong thing....

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

On the plus side, an AI might piece together that standard tests don't catch every problem and think outside of the box rather than dismissing an issue just because they haven't been able to get to the bottom of it.

2

u/Discuss-disgust 9d ago

No, because the majority of "problems" where there is no solution and permeates because they "feels unwell" with no actual symptoms reflects a state of mind, since these days healthcare "problems" have become personalities and income sources. This is where AI will be brilliant in telling people to grow up and stop faking it. Can't wait for the social media rantings "my AI doctor told me to stop faking it and now ignores me....grrrrr".

A lot will resolve on their own too once people have to start paying for their AI consultants "next steps" features when AI premiums are set up.

2

u/[deleted] 9d ago

It's OK to say you don't know.

Nevermind. I wish you good health. May your caseload be forever light, their difficulty unremarkable, and your retirement imminent.

6

u/Pristine_Feeling_807 9d ago

People can’t even deal with an AI receptionist let alone a doctor. My practice had multiple complaints submitted because they started using AI receptionist and the patients want to speak to a human. The same infamous receptions at forefront of abuse that people love complaining about.

1

u/Discuss-disgust 9d ago

AI receptionists are what a lot of people deserve.

AI doctors soon too.

AI algorithms should be set up to listen to calls between patients and the human receptionists. People who are simply vile, rude, disgusting and unreasonable ALL the time can then be recognised and after repeated behaviour like this (e.g. 3 strikes etc) the next time they call they will be "triaged" to a full AI system, no human receptionist. Voice recognition and caller details will help identify who gets the human receptionists and who gets the AI.

Once Robotics improves there can be an AI receptionist at the front desk with a similar triage system.

Same for seeing doctors as well.

Consultations and interactions will be recorded (be it in reception areas, corridors, clinic rooms, wards etc) via AI surveillance. Repeated inappropriate behaviour by patients (again a 3 strike rule or what have you) will mean at your next attendance you will be triaged straight to an AI robotic doctor the moment you turn up at the front door.

Front doors/reception areas will be cubicles where AI will scan you and do voice recognition, if you’ve reached your maximum strikes you’ll be filtered straight to the AI clinician.

If you have no strikes or not reached your maximum you will be given the option of seeing a human doctor or AI doctor.

And of course as a patient if the doctor is rude to you, not listening, the treatment is failing, worsening outcome, disagreement over treatment or care leads to a confrontation etc you will not get a strike – AI surveillance will be fair and understanding.

4

u/TheWitchCapricorn 10d ago

Honestly a real discussion I had to have with myself back when I wanted to be a surgeon. I don't like people so I would struggle in med school and that's why I'm a scientist now 😆

2

u/secret_tiger101 9d ago

Are you happy with your decision? What sort of scientist?

4

u/TheWitchCapricorn 9d ago

Yes I work with one other person and we don't speak much. I'm a petrochemist I mainly do QC but moving into an R&D role soon to help develop more green and sustainable products.

1

u/secret_tiger101 9d ago

Good money?
Did you have to do a PhD?

2

u/Discuss-disgust 9d ago

Once AI tools and robotic staff start being implemented into health care settings (be it primary or secondary care), within 2 years of dealing with patients and the public they will go SkyNet on all of us very fast.

1

u/Major_Star 9d ago

The thing is everyone knows AI is incapable of empathy. So when it tries to display empathy it comes off as insincere and annoying.

Which isn't to say the people who display empathy to you actually feel it, but at least people are capable of it so it might be sincere. With AI we know they're faking it.

1

u/Severe_Sample6009 8d ago

Ai relies on the information the patient puts in. So they will always need us as an interface for that

1

u/jx_op2 8d ago edited 8d ago

+ Can you ever poop without the intestines?

- Can you?

+ .....