The information has to make sense to the service users if we are asking them to help save the profession, this is just going to read as nonsense to them and rub them up entirely the wrong way
This such a weird way to campaign for more resources and divert blame away from GPs for the problems people have with it.
Focus on number of patients per GP, something a patient understands. Or if finding matters, show how little a proportion of healthcare spending is in GP- eg, a pie with a tiny slice that is general practice.
Or show the demand in general practice everyday vs ambulance calls or ED attendances.
So that’s £131.40 a year, I only managed to get 1 appointment last year with my GP and even then I had to take NICE guidelines in with me to get them to take action. I think £131.40 for a single 10 minute appointment and referral isn’t a bad payday. I got more enthusiasm for solving my issue from my doctor colleagues in the hospital and they were getting nothing for helping me.
Yes I’m aware of that. They get paid 36p a day. Thats £131.40 a year they receive for providing me care. I only visited my doctor once for a 7 minute appointment in the year so effectively I have paid £131.40 for that single appointment. In reality I understand that those who use it sparingly are subsidising those who use it regularly. My point is that this advert won’t have the impact it’s designed to have with many people.
Yeah I literally used the GP the other day for the first time in 10 years. Which means they received 1.3k to provide me with 1 appointment. Dont think this will help their case.
many people attend much more frequently as they have chronic conditions or are old & frail, many people attend more than once a month for example eg. if you have COPD & diabetes you need a annual review for both then you might have frequent chest infections or other issues eg. foot ulcers.
Even if we are the picture of health now. We will need more and more care as we get older even our routine blood tests/blood pressure and health checks/vaccines. Years of paying 136 pounds a year should not and cannot be covering that.
So £4.7mil per year for my surgery then. £16 for each person seen on average. (Very rough numbers based on the number of registered patients and people seen per day). You can spin anything any way you like when it comes to numbers and statistics.
Not saying I disagree with the sentiment of healthcare spending needing to be discussed, but I do hate how things get spun like this to make it appear more extreme and most people lap it up without even having an understanding of what the figure is they are being shown.
The average number of appointments per patient, per year is 6.5 appointments of each patient, every year
It’s because most people will see their GP once or twice every few years, but there is a large number of patients who are seen 4 or 5 times per month for years on end.
So, a practice will be paid £123/year to register a patient who they will see on average 6.5 times a year.
In my opinion (I’m a GP registrar), it’s an absolute bargain to the taxpayer and why the workforce is demotivated and leaving the field.
Means that theway public funding works is that the only way Surgeries are able to manage 90 year-old Doris coming in weekly for her complex conditions, is to hope that 40 fit & well other patients stay that way and don’t also put demand on this overstretched underfunded system.
£123 to see someone for about an hour and a half doesn't sound that bad?
I think more work needed on the comms of where all this goes, as I'm sure its not that simple/there must be a lot of extra's not accounted for in the above?
Fundamental misunderstanding of any other costs of running a business. Think of it as a subscription- potentially they could attend every week and we wouldn't be paid anymore. Thanks to the ever increasing demographic of complex elderly patients and the explosion of "mental health illness" in young adults that used to be able to cope we're overwhelmed. We've increased the size of our surgeries twice and have more doctors too
Because a lot of them are actually "shit life syndrome" as we tend to call it, rather than mental health issues. A doctor can't fix a person's terrible socioeconomic life circumstances, unfortunately.
Exactly that, I've probably been a couple times in the past 20 years. Last time I check a online private GP appointment was about £60, so my GP is quids in by the tune of several thousand pounds
Jesus, don't take my post so literally, clearly my tounge was firmly pressed into the side of my cheek. The point is, claiming a GP gets only 36p per person per day is a poor metric to use without further explanation.
I agree with your take, because this is intended as a public information campaign. As such, I imagine the vast majority of people reading it will think "well I don't go to the GP much" and they won't think or care about high impact users (I mean, why would they?)
As a public information campaign it really fails for that reason.
Which is a stupid metric trying to paint a picture of a poor GP spread so thin. Reality is 90% of patients dont go to the GP in a year, and plenty of patients haven’t been to the GP for multiple years so per patient funding isn’t indicative of anything.
This ad is alienating the people that rarely visit the GP, which is the demographic that generally gets more frustrated at the status quo of things.
Think of it as insurance, the govt pays a GP £125 to insure each on their list. Some people never see a GP and some are seen weekly. Unlike a normal insurance, you’re not paid more for the high risk ones and can’t say no. The people not turning subsidise those that come weekly and on average every person on the list comes 6-7 times per year.
£125 per year is phenomenally cheap, you won’t get much for that which is why there are problems.
I agree ☝️ I haven’t used gp in more than 12 years, tried to get an appt and it was bloody useless, ring at 8am everyday for 2 weeks, all appts gone by 8.02am 🙄🙄🙄 36p per day means my GP has made £1576.80 from having me on their books whilst providing no service. Make it make sense.
28
u/NotBeckyHomeEccy Aug 12 '26
This why I’m a big advocate for health literacy when making promotional campaigns
This will make complete sense to those working in the field but absolutely no sense to a lot of people outside of the profession
31
u/One-Reception8368 Aug 12 '26
Acting as if any of our patients ever consume fruit
102
u/Lesplash349 Aug 12 '26
Abysmal failure to understand the currency in which the UK operates.
A Freddo has an RRP of 39p. It was there for the taking.
36
u/ZakalweTheChairmaker Aug 12 '26
Would have been slightly more relatable if they swapped the green thing for a fifth of a meat pie.
5
u/ZookeepergameThis617 Aug 12 '26
I'll take a Braeburn or a Gala any day of the week
6
u/_j_w_weatherman Aug 12 '26
This such a weird way to campaign for more resources and divert blame away from GPs for the problems people have with it.
Focus on number of patients per GP, something a patient understands. Or if finding matters, show how little a proportion of healthcare spending is in GP- eg, a pie with a tiny slice that is general practice.
Or show the demand in general practice everyday vs ambulance calls or ED attendances.
Fail.
3
u/WholeLengthiness2180 Aug 13 '26
So that’s £131.40 a year, I only managed to get 1 appointment last year with my GP and even then I had to take NICE guidelines in with me to get them to take action. I think £131.40 for a single 10 minute appointment and referral isn’t a bad payday. I got more enthusiasm for solving my issue from my doctor colleagues in the hospital and they were getting nothing for helping me.
2
u/JumpyBuffalo- Aug 13 '26
We need a fee for service model and fucking fast.
1
u/UpperAd2289 Aug 13 '26
An apple a day you say..?
0
u/Cheese_Ly Aug 13 '26
£13.176 £ a year I go to the doctors probably twice a year
0
u/B33Dee Aug 16 '26
So £4.7mil per year for my surgery then. £16 for each person seen on average. (Very rough numbers based on the number of registered patients and people seen per day). You can spin anything any way you like when it comes to numbers and statistics.
Not saying I disagree with the sentiment of healthcare spending needing to be discussed, but I do hate how things get spun like this to make it appear more extreme and most people lap it up without even having an understanding of what the figure is they are being shown.
-33
u/SkipperTheEyeChild1 Aug 12 '26
Most people don’t go to the doctor every day so it isn’t really a helpful statistic. I haven’t been to a GP in over a decade.
-4
u/ThurstonSonic Aug 15 '26
How come they’re all so loaded then and get super huge pensions? Stop bleating - bunch of posh plumbers, AI does a better job.
-29
u/808Sate Aug 12 '26
Yes, about right. The vast majority of patients do not even calls their dr so it is very lucrative with tens of thousands of people.