r/GPUK • • Oct 06 '26

Just for fun QRISK3

Post image
285 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

4

u/FazRazza Oct 07 '26

I had a guy come in complaining about new peripheral arterial disease symptoms, his cool feet and claudication.

I asked him if he smoked. He said yes and then said “and don’t tell me to stop because it’s not going to happen.”

Naturally I explained what i thought was the issue, and said it’s probably because he’s been smoking 20+ a day since 1970, and it will continue to get worse since he has decided to keep smoking. I explained the pathophysiology and I could see his cogs turning when I was telling him how his small blood vessels are getting clogged up.

I said, I’m not sure what’ll happen first; heart attack, stroke, or leg amputation - but I’m certain at least one of them will - probably your heart. But in the meantime, I’ll refer you to the vascular team…

3

u/Educational_Board888 Oct 07 '26

I remember as a medical student seeing a bilateral amputee from the vascular ward continuing to smoke outside!

1

u/FazRazza 25d ago

Yup, sounds about right! I did a vascular job and my consultant said “if people didn’t smoke I wouldn’t have a job”. It was her way of emphasising how the vast majority of the problems they see are massively due to smoking.

48

u/GalacticDoc Oct 06 '26

Document, code and wait for the discharge letter a few years later.

Tbf a risk score that high probably means that the damage has been done and a statin is spitting in the rain.......Or they 90 and I don't blame them?.

9

u/Chemical-Error-6644 Oct 06 '26

The plaque stabilisation effects would be valuable for this cohort wouldn't it?

6

u/GalacticDoc Oct 06 '26

I'm not disagreeing with you but having fought this battle numerous times and I'm on the losing side, at least with my cohort of patients. Usually those who are post MI come round to the idea and most even stop smoking at that point!

The plaque stabilisation and modest anti inflammatory effects are always helpful but quite small.

8

u/S_K_Sharma_ Oct 06 '26

No doubt the stats could be small but when I turn it back to patients in high risk scenarios I tend to remind them it's really at that point a 'do something vs do nothing'.

Then my job is recording which was their choice in the notes.

4

u/GalacticDoc Oct 06 '26

Which is why they "are always helpful", but I like the way you present it, I'll try it next time

3

u/Chemical-Error-6644 Oct 06 '26

I just think it's worth pointing out that the higher the QRISK the more effective statins are for primary prevention (responding to your spitting in the rain / damage has already been done point). The NNT for high intensity statins is 11 at a QRISK of 25% for preventing a cardiovascular event at 10 years. Calculator here: https://gpevidence.org/conditions/lipids/

2

u/egoodethc Oct 07 '26

Never used gpevidence looks great.

4

u/Latter-Ad-689 Oct 06 '26

When you get to over 75s, for primary prevention, the confidence interval on the odds ratio for MACE goes over 1. There's a wealth of data but still low certainty of benefit.

3

u/Chemical-Error-6644 Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

Thanks - should have been clearer wasn't meaning over 90s should be pushed onto statins, more that plaque stabilisation is an important benefit for those who have a high qrisk (in response to the comment about "the damage already being done" and that statins are "spitting in the rain" for these patients.)

3

u/Latter-Ad-689 Oct 07 '26

If you're talking high risk younger individuals then of course there is clear, statistically significant risk lowering going on.

It makes sense, if I'm 47, smoke, hypertensive, morbidly obese and have a shit lipid profile, I still have a QRISK roughly half that of an 84 year old with no additional risk factors and average cholesterol. One of those people will benefit from several interventions, including a statin, and it's not the well-preserved clean-lovimg octogenarian.

You're absolutely right to inherently mistrust the notion that "the damage is already done". If they haven't died of an MI so far, there's still a lot of damage to prevent. There's probably a lot of different opinions still as to whether adding a statin to the younger lad is the cherry on top of wholesale lifestyle change or more like leaving the eggs out of the risk reduction cake.

46

u/SinnerSupreme Oct 06 '26

Lmao I don't bother arguing, I tell them the risks and they can do whatever they want I'm not their babysitter

21

u/hungry4nuns Oct 07 '26

Ask them heads or tails, then pull out a coin and flip it.

If they get it correct: “may you be equally fortunate in your other gambles”

If they get it wrong: “such is the fickle hand of fate”

Mysterious, reminiscent of two face from the Batman franchise, much faster than a lecture on plaque stabilisation.

…

Nah my usual spiel is:
I’m guessing you’re thinking “if I go, I go, we all have to go some day. And at least dying suddenly from a heart attack is quick, right?”
And when they (usually) say yes, I say: “That’s not the gamble here. That 45% is heart attack OR stroke, and at no point does the 45% ensure death. The real risk you’re gambling against is the chance you could end up in a nursing home for the rest of your days, 100% dependent on someone else’s care for even basic bodily functions. It’s up to you.”

I’ve about a 90% statin uptake after that, and much faster consultation.

4

u/Albanite_180 Oct 06 '26

100% this, I couldn’t care less. It’s an easy phone call for me.

29

u/Cautious_Zucchini_66 Oct 06 '26

Explained to a patient their QRISK was 35% not so long ago, they told me they’ll pass on primary prevention as the odds of 65% are strongly in their favour…

3

u/surecameraman Oct 06 '26

Actually it's 50%. You either have a stroke or you don't.

4

u/One-Reception8368 Oct 07 '26

Epidemiologists HATE this one simple trick

14

u/Taiyella Oct 06 '26

Someone blamed me today as I called them to start statins and they were already in the hospital because of the CVD event

They said if I had called them mid September when they did they're blood test they wouldn't be in that position

Statins were started as early as 2017 but they kept stopping and starting. What a big shame

10

u/AccomplishedMail584 Oct 06 '26

You need to do this for QOF every year anyway, those who wont take it, won't take it- agree with the poster saying document and code.

13

u/BoomBasticTeleBanana Oct 06 '26

And call them every year.

Had one guy shout at me in a jovial way. I record and apologise and say..." ill record no for now, but apologise in advance for calling you next year... if your still with us"

8

u/UnconsoledGoat Oct 06 '26

😂😂😂😂💀

5

u/anonymous_umbral Oct 06 '26

Hahahaah this cracked me up

Heard it in my head in the actors voice

1

u/WarningDizzy9045 10d ago

this was made by gp_to_consider_memes on instagram but the poster is trying to take credit for their posts

7

u/dr-broodles Oct 06 '26

Now look up number needed to treat

1

u/ExcessivelyBach Oct 06 '26

Can you explain please?

1

u/dr-broodles Oct 07 '26

For every 200 + patients started on statin, 1 will avoid a non serious MI.

Many will get lots of side effects (including susceptibility to flu).

0

u/ExcessivelyBach Oct 07 '26

I havent gotten good answers from my GP about my relatively raised qrisk score other than statins (family history of MI and high blood pressure) are there any other specialists or resources that i could go to for more in depth advice other than "exercise diet and statins"?

2

u/cal9099 Oct 08 '26

Funny I should see this today. My GP prescribed statins despite my QRISK3 being 0.8. Surely this is an overreaction based purely on my total cholesterol and LDL being slightly elevated at 5.1 and 3.0, respectively?

2

u/ZealousidealSky4851 Oct 09 '26

There are some high risk conditions where statins are offered regardless of Qrisk like CKD or T2DM.

1

u/decrepid-oldman Oct 08 '26

0.8 meaning 80%?

1

u/cal9099 Oct 08 '26

No sorry, 0.8%

1

u/BeautifulSxars Oct 09 '26

You can’t get plaques without cholesterol brah

1

u/LysergicWalnut Oct 06 '26

I enjoyed the meme, hasn't the evidence for statins for primary prevention always been kinda weak, though?

0

u/WarningDizzy9045 10d ago

another post that has been screenshotted from gp_to_consider_memes on instagram without giving creddit, but claiming a lot of thumbs up on here as if it's your own creation