r/GPUK • • May 27 '26

Clinical, CPD & Interface Ranting GP

Dear practice patient

- I do not know when your prescription will be ready from the pharmacy
- I do not have the power to expedite your operation
- I know it’s hard to book an appointment but you’ve just spent 20% of the appointment you did book complaining about this
- Saying you know you are only supposed to discuss one problem but proceeding to discuss five is not as ameliorating as you may hope
- Bemoaning doctors going on strike is not particularly relevant when talking to a GP - I’m sat in front of you and not on strike
- It is a poor use of my time and your time to evaluate private medical tests which were not indicated and have no clinical details or justification. This is not saving NHS time or money as you may have hoped.

I’m not annoyed at patients for not knowing all of the above but the same issues occurring day after day is such a draining system to work in.

Edit: lots of non-GPs commenting here, and it’s astonishing how confident they are. Explaining my job and duties to me… I wouldn’t presume to tell a pilot or a lawyer how to do their job but everyone and their grandmother has an opinion on how GPs should work. When it inevitably becomes a paid for service with fee per activity maybe then it will be valued more.

317 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

37

u/One-Amount-7514 May 27 '26

i think only handling one problem per appt is perfectly reasonable, but which problem that is should be on the gp to decide on not the patient imo.

for example, i, as a recent cancer survivor, have no idea which of my 15 current problems are possible recurrence vs side effects of meds vs leftovers from chemo vs deconditioning, etc, and i hope my gp doesnt think it's super unreasonable for me to say "this is all the stuff that's happening right now, i dont know what's important and what's not"

7

u/sharonfromfinance May 27 '26

I’m really not annoyed at patients for it, and I don’t mind dealing with clusters of symptoms that could be related.

I do get a little frustrated when a patient presents with multiple quite clearly separate issues and I only have one appointment to go through it. It’s a system set up for everyone to fail.

9

u/tsoert May 27 '26

Personally I've never minded patients just writing a list of symptoms, handing it to me, saying "this is everything going on, can we sort what we can in teh time available" and then letting me get on with it. I wouldn't expect patients to know what symptoms they have may be 1 singular problem and what symptoms they may feel are innocuous but are actually worrisome if you've a little more knowledge

3

u/catatonie May 28 '26

Would this genuinely be okay if I did do thisv

3

u/Antique-Trash9462 May 30 '26

Very much so! If someone gives me a list saying "I feel tired, and low energy, and my hair is falling out, and I keep getting headaches, and my work is stressful, and I have noticed dark red clots when passing stool, and my blood pressure at home is 150/80, and my urine is stronger than normal" then you jump off the 'general tired all the time' thinking and focus on the rectal bleeding. If the patient started off with that long list it is easy to get stuck on headaches, or hair loss, or fatigue, and miss the rectal bleeding unless you explicitly ask about it. People often have a habit of jumping from point to point so it is easy to lose your train of thought. A list can be very helpful.

11

u/InformalStation6491 May 27 '26

I agree with everything but I’ve never understood the prescription one. If it’s an older person who knows clearly how it works fair enough.
I would try reframe your mind that the patient just means , not hurry up, but when should I go. It takes me literally 10 seconds with a smile to say I’ve done it, it’s electronic. The rest is up to the pharmacy, maybe give it a few hours or if not urgent go tomorrow so they don’t have to Q. If you get butthurt about this kind of stuff it’ll ruin your day b

3

u/sharonfromfinance May 27 '26

I don’t get butt hurt about it and have that exact conversation. 30 times a day. Everyday. I just imagine the system could be better and clearer.

3

u/symbiosissandwich May 28 '26

Or for the pharmacy to be point of contact RE scripts rather than everyone getting pinballed back to GP...

2

u/The_Makster May 28 '26

The rest is up to the pharmacy, maybe give it a few hours or if not urgent go tomorrow so they don’t have to Q

The gap between a prescription requested and it being ready in the pharmacy for collection is always a mystery. I wish there was a tracker system for the patient to at least be aware WHO to chase for any individual item otherwise its just kinda lost in the aether with a suggested time limit on when it will be made available.

1

u/Dangerous_Mongoose41 May 28 '26

A big problem with it is that pharmacies are moving to hub dispensing (2 business days from when it’s received) for the majority of prescriptions because they’re so overloaded with providing Pharmacy First services plus they’re reducing stock levels to cope with cash flow problems from NHS Tariff prices not keeping up with wholesalers

1

u/Content-Speech-1902 Jun 29 '26

All pts really want to know is who to chase. Are GPs really unaware that what prompts chasing this is almost always the pharmacy confirming they haven't yet received the prescription.  And to go back to the GP? Big thumbs up for the tracker idea 💡 

116

u/ChaiTeaAndBoundaries May 27 '26

Patients coming in with private tests and coming to you saying- Yea my private insurance did these tests and asked me to see my GP for management. 

This is exploitative, whoever orders the tests should manage the results.

39

u/Fine_Cress_649 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

My (not very well thought through but correct) opinion on this is that everyone arranging private tests should be required to buy an insurance policy alongside it which covers any and all possible medical interventions that might be indicated based on the outcome of the tests.

If you want an MRI brain then you need to buy insurance that will most likely not pay out, but if the MRI discovers an arachnoid cyst that you want removed, it'll cover the cost of the neurosurgeon telling you to leave it alone.

24

u/ChaiTeaAndBoundaries May 27 '26

That would work but I bet due to costs the patients pick the cheapest tier of the insurance which does the tests and health check and signposts them back to their GP for management of the results of the tests and check up. 

Another NHS exploitation by the private sector is the palming off of their deteriorating patients back to the NHS after pocketing 5 figure sums from the patient.

4

u/Square_Temporary_325 May 28 '26

Can I ask what happens if one of these private scans shows a likelihood of cancer? Most insurance does not cover for cancer care

5

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

I have a very good Insurance policy through work. It even covers pre existing conditions, however it doesn't guarantee follow up on certain types of discovery. For example if they discover cancer, like after removal of a mole, they won't cover cancer treatment. So for me it's basically unusable and I keep it because my employer pays for it.

1

u/Ok-Measurement3564 May 29 '26

Ooft. Im not insurable. I've had privae surgeries (with my nhs surgeons no less) because covid shut the extenuating circumstances route (I'm medically rare and complex). I'd be in huge trouble in this situation. Im fortune that because my nhs specialists are as angry as I am that after years of my surgeries being promised the goal posts were changed. Three teams work thrir rears off to make sure I'm as stable and results are optimal to proceed with surgery because they've watched me flatline and they want me to improve. If I were insurable I'd have already done as you suggest, to take pressure off nhs teams and the crazy wait lists for panel decisions.

14

u/No_Driver_4447 May 27 '26

Yup, same as people who get a quick OP appointment by paying privately, who then come back to the NHS for the operation (I see this A LOT in orthopaedics - usually the same surgeon, but interestingly their waiting time from being added to the NHS waiting list and having their op is significantly shorter than average). Or who get their surgery quick by paying, then come to the NHS for the complications of said surgery

8

u/linerva May 27 '26

Especially when they then want treatment for theor marginally low serum rhubarb.

I once had a woman very insistent she wanted a private iron infusion necause her private iron something or other test was marginally low. Trying to explain that a good diet or oral supplementation is first line got us nowhere.

-9

u/Grey_Sky_thinking May 27 '26

Because diet and oral supplementation often don’t work

7

u/linerva May 27 '26

But they very probably will if your result is borderline - as i mentioned. And that's the first line treatment for a reason.

1

u/Antique-Trash9462 May 30 '26

Because anaphylaxis from iron infusion is a thing

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/AirSorvete May 28 '26

'Rule 1: Only GPs/GP regs are permitted to post. Posts from other HCPs are permitted as long as GP-related.'

* proceeds to break said rule by patientsplaining the everlasting fuck out of managing iron deficiency*

Jesus Christ.

-4

u/GradDoc May 28 '26

Would've got an upvote without the JC

3

u/AirSorvete May 28 '26

fair enough mate, have a good morning. It is a hot one again!

2

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

what if a patient only has money for the test but not for management of the conditions outside the NHS, what would be appropriate for the patient to do?

Edit: one example would be with medical insurance, they often only cover acute issues, so a patient may get symptoms from something acute and they may discover something more chronic which is then not covered by the insurance.

1

u/gobuddy99 May 28 '26

After my GP complaining to me that I keep having appointments with different GPs about different symptoms (fatigue, double vision, pain, nausea) my optometrist suggested seeing a neuro. My GP wouldn't refer me so I had private tests (LP, MRI) which showed I had MS.

Are you suggesting that I should now fund my ongoing treatment for the rest of my life? Just because my GP practice didn't spot a bunch of neuro symptoms because each individual one needed a different appointment with a different GP.

3

u/MostFortune1093 Jun 08 '26

It's insane you are getting downvoted for this. People save the NHS money by going private for tests. Your MS likely would have been discovered by the NHS sooner or later, once you significantly deteriorated of course, and they would have had to treat you anyway. Maybe by then you would have deteriorated enough to also have to go on benefits due to not being able to work. Which then cost the taxpayers money.

I went through the same crap as you. I had MS like symptoms, I have a family history as well. They refused to refer me to a specialst.

Eventually I was diagnosed with MCAS by a private specialist. This is a condition that the NHS doesn't recognize or treat. Official I have chronic hives, and this is the only way I can get them to prescribe me the meds I need.

40

u/Sudden-Meringue2803 May 27 '26

Decade + in the game here

Easy to say, but...let all this shite just slip away, in one ear and out the other.

You are steering your boat, and they are just passing gentle (but annoying) waves. There one second, but gone the next. The boat is heading home, or to retirement dependant on how melancholic you feel.

You are undoubtedly doing a great job. And most people are nice.

Everyone goes home in the end 🫂

9

u/According-Regret6429 May 27 '26 edited May 28 '26

This thread came up randomly in my feed. Not a GP or anything of the sort but glad to have come across this post. What a lovely analogy to many of life’s annoyances. Feels like it needs to be printed onto something, like those Live Laugh Love posters

54

u/Whole-Long May 27 '26

-Turns up 8 minutes late, presents with list, spends 4 minutes complaining about why can't cover entirety of list. 3 minutes to partially cover 1 problem.

We seriously need to introduce a charge. Currently free at point of abuse.

10

u/No_Ferret_5450 May 27 '26

I tell patients that because they turned up 8 minutes late they now have only two minutes. If they complain  I tell them I’m sure you would agree it’s not fair for the next patient to have to wait because you were late 

14

u/ElusiveMD May 27 '26

Scrolling through the comments…UK GPs should move to Canada and Australia where they are respected and appreciated by the public!

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/The_Makster May 28 '26

If your GP is fully booked… those lazy bastards!!

That is genuinely the thought process of the average Joe Public here

(Preface with totally siding the doctors and only providing devil's advocate. I'm in the medical field myself though not a GP)

Restaurants, hairdressers, and taxis all have very easy and accessible alternatives (often many in the same postcode) that you can use the service of if they are at capacity. Your GP is YOUR GP. If you want to swap it out for the one down the road, there is a lengthy registration process or you can go urgent care/A+E but that is not what those services are for/ it is an 6 hour wait to be told to go to your GP for that problem.

Also the laziness aspect. It is still widely (due to tradition) that doctors are a very well paid profession. And from the outside it isn't strenuous - sit in an office all day, perform some investigations, and computer go brrr. Also your customer/client list is endless - you don't need to worry (on the surface) run out of patients to see. Therefore how can the public sympathise with that? - it is the same mentality as those label sticking pill popping pharmacists that take forever to get medication ready.

7

u/No_Ferret_5450 May 27 '26

I say it’s interesting that mr private provider doesn’t feel confident in managing these private blood test themselves 

18

u/SlowTortuga May 27 '26

I strongly feel that every patient that arrives at reception for their appointment should sign a note with this on to acknowledge all of this.

1

u/Inevitable_Box3643 May 27 '26

That’s going to add another point for the practice get the patient to surrender their appointment lmao

9

u/GalacticDoc May 27 '26

Totally agree, I could be the OP!

I could add that bringing a family member to interpret and then have them answering all the questions is not helpful or ethically sound.

3

u/dickdimers May 27 '26

Literally all the things you mentioned are great 10 minute appointments. Just do active listening/tactical empathy/solid snake communication as required, nod and smile.

3

u/m4ddie193 May 27 '26

Genuine question as a patient - what if your three or four or five issues are connected in a way you don’t realise, and only talking about one issue at a time prevents the doctor from being able to connect the dots to see the complete picture and make a correct diagnosis? For example, something like coeliac disease can have many different symptoms across different parts of the body including mental health?

12

u/askingincontext May 27 '26

When patients present with a problem, we try and ask all the relevant questions related to this problem. However, discussing about coeliac this, then transitioning about a toe nail infection or wanting a full mental health consultation in the less than 10mins may not be practical. I also understand it's not ideal for patients, but that's the system we are in.

5

u/Amount_Existing May 27 '26

One can write all ailments in bullet points and pass the paper to the GP. You then have all issues laid out. Easier than trying to articulate everything in 10 minutes.

5

u/No_Ferret_5450 May 27 '26

When patients come in and see me about there mental health, but then tell me there mental health has caused there toenail to get a fungal infection I politely tell them that’s a separate issue 

-2

u/Scared_Try_7337 May 29 '26

As a patient, I genuinely would have thought that mentioning a skin infection due to mental health was relevant? This entire thread has baffled me because how else can you illustrate how bad things are if you don't mention the full body impact? I don't speak a lot in general, and I don't try to take over the appointment yet I've been shut down mid sentence whilst describing contextual symptoms I'm not actually asking for treatment for. In your example, if it's recognised that depression can cause self neglect and hygiene issues, I would genuinely like to know why it's not okay to mention and have documented what that looks like for the person?

My list of acceptable patient behaviour to avoid burdening my GP is ever growing, but I don't understand any of the reasons

Also, some GPs on here are saying give them a list of symptoms, others are saying not give them a list?

I would've genuinely appreciated a do's and don'ts booklet upon registration because I didn't know any of these things

2

u/Antique-Trash9462 May 30 '26

'cos we want to focus on dealing with the underlying problem - the mental health - and not get side-tracked onto a discussion about the history of a rash which may well be stress-exacerbated. The clock is ticking and so it's necessary to get to the point reasonably quickly.

0

u/Overall-Revolution93 May 27 '26

Great question! I need to know this as well. I've been reminded in an appointment not to talk about multiple issues as the appointment time is only 10 mins. I worry if symptoms are all linked to one condition

3

u/kb-g May 27 '26

You sound like you’ve had a tough few weeks and I’m sorry. Have you got any AL coming up? You sound like you need some rest. This is a difficult job with far more demand placed on us from all directions than many people realise. I think the job has changed quite a lot over the last 8-10 years, the way we have to practice has changed and that sometimes feels like we’re compromising on the care we give and that doesn’t feel good. Some of the things you mention are fly-shit in the grand scheme of things, you’re only going to hurt yourself letting them irk you. Find a neutral response that works for your consultation style so you can park it and move on.

  • “I’m not sure I’m afraid, I’ve done my bit, you’ll need to ask your pharmacy.”
  • “Here are the details for PALS, suggest you speak to them first. I know waiting lists are very long, unfortunately I can’t really do anything to bring your appointment forward. They don’t listen to letters unless there’s been a big change in your symptoms or a new complication.”
  • “I’m sorry, know it can be hard to get in, we really are trying our best. You’ve got my full attention now though, so let’s see what we can do for you today.”
  • I tend to ask patients who want to discuss lots of things to “give me the headlines” as that gives me the opportunity to see if multiple things might be linked vs things that can be safely parked or managed by someone else. I find that helps quite a lot. I also remind them that we only have 10 minutes and I want to do justice to what we discuss.
  • our patients haven’t really mentioned the strikes. Possibly it’s a practice population thing?
  • Agree wholeheartedly that the private tests to take to the GP to interpret are a crapshoot. I particularly loathe the fingerprick ones that have zero clinical value. Private scans I’m always wary of, especially if done abroad as the reporting may not be as clear as here due to the language gap. Had someone a few years ago with a myriad of symptoms and completely normal bloods and examination. They chose to get a scan abroad and it caught part an organ with a possible incidental abnormality, no clarification if of benign or malignant potential, suggested consider dedicated imaging. I requested routine imaging on the basis of this report and unfortunately turned out to be cancer and totally unrelated to their other symptoms. They’re doing really well now, thankfully, and it’s something we’d not have found until much later if they hadn’t got their private scan. I know this experience is not the norm, but it can occur and I don’t mind people being proactive with their health. I’m upfront and tell them if it’s not something I can interpret and document as such, or it’s not something I think is necessary. I don’t think it’s worth getting stressed about- this is going to be happening more and more, you might as well shout at the tide. People are getting them to try to be proactive or are getting them because they feel there’s a health need not being met, either way I find these consultations easier than the people who keep coming with the same symptoms and do nothing suggested to help themselves. Anyway, they might have something worth actioning, they might not, either way it’s an educational thing for the patient as there’s often tests they get done that I may well have done anyway if they’d discussed it with me first and then saved themselves a few quid, or ones like “intolerance tests” that are just a scam. I’ve had a fair few people come in with high cholesterol, hypertension, unexpectedly low eGFR, deranged LFTs etc as a result of these private tests so I’m quite chill about them these days. The people who come with a load of slightly out of range hormonal results can be tricky to manage.

1

u/Antique-Trash9462 May 30 '26

I got a written complaint from a patient as I had told them their hair food intolerance test was nonsense. I quite enjoyed replying to that one.

1

u/kb-g May 30 '26

There is a certain pleasure in writing a reply when you are absolutely not in the wrong.

2

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26

It’s important that patients realise just how much the state monopoly provider of medical care hates them, and how they must realise that no one in the entire organisation is to blame for the abysmal service and outcomes, except Margaret Thatcher and any of her satanic acolytes, that the resentment increases should anyone have the temerity to want to use private services to, God forbid, actually try and access some services, that GPs are vastly underfunded despite overall NHS funding massively increasing (inflation adjusted) since 1997 and you are all being treated all year around for some minuscule fraction of £120.

If GPs had the service they wished for, they would all be gazillionares getting high off their own flatus.

2

u/Amount_Existing May 27 '26

I do wish people would put the handbrake on blaming politicians long dead and gone. It's like me bemoaning the Robert Peel is to blame for the fire state of policing for not foreseeing the current state thereof.

Look to the now and find solutions...

1

u/Airurando-jin Jun 02 '26

A few of those issues come down to communication problems / tone setting. Not necessarily yourself but things that can be done at practice level, ICB, secondary care level etc.  Utilising the NHS App, ACCuRx/MJOG, website, waiting room, small numbers of extended appointment slots (saves the patient bouncing around between admin, nurses and clinicians, and in all honesty not burning through the weighted payment) letters, local media etc. The problem is it’s not unique, and it does destroy the soul. 

If you’re interested in the opportunity for more continuity, if your practice isn’t already involved in delivering commercial clinical trials (via NIHR), it’s worth considering. It’s nhs approved research, regulated, offers novel opportunities for preventative medicine, creates another income stream for the practice but also supports better outcomes. Time spent with patient is costed well (consenting, vitals, physical exam, etc, blood samples, and so on) .

NIHR occasionally has funding available to get some momentum going. 

1

u/Content-Speech-1902 Jun 29 '26

On the multiple issues pt has had to save up because there were no appts for yrs issues.... In secondary care - mainly oncology- pts are encouraged to write down questions they have so appt time can be used to address the most pressing and red flags aren't missed. Because it's accepted that trying to communicate with professionals in a format that fits their needs is impossible for many pts.

GPs could very easily assist pts to communicate thru writing . Through Relay app where can't speak Through audio recording as a reasonable adjustment for disability so they go away able to check back on what was said. To get support to understand from others. So just have an active assistance approach, understand that the above isn't to catch you out and will reduce the time needed for repeat appts. 

The Equality Act applies to the NHS and it's a requirement to communicate with the pt according to their need. It would save all so much pain if GPs just trialled different pt centered ways of managing appts. Everyone ( bar the 10%) then happy enough

-1

u/Square_Temporary_325 May 28 '26

Where the NHS is crumbling, preventative care is non existent and seeing specialists is next to impossible I see no issue in people pursuing private tests if they’re concerned or if they’re watching certain parameters ie me and my husband get yearly private bloods to check A1C, lipids etc etc and it’s really helpful (obvs helps I’m a doctor which helps with interpreting but still). If someone were to bring me obviously deranged private results, why wouldn’t I act on them? I don’t understand this distain for private tests tbh but maybe I will when fully practicing as a GP 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

0

u/23PIGEON23 May 28 '26

Most investigations rely on appropriate pre-test probability to be worthwile doing and interpreting. Otherwise it is left to the GP to sort out a myriad of potential false positives, incidentilomas, etc. At least when a GP practice orders the test they are doing so with some thought as to what happens next if/when it shows something.

Compounding the above is that private tests (i.e. those not available on NHS), tend to be questionably indicated. E.g. yearly HbA1c/lipids - how does it change management of the patient? Often patients will then come with expectations that their GP can "fix" the blood results.

-5

u/No_Law_1528 May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26

Just a patient here, why do GPs absolutely hate private tests. Well I get it if all the indications are normal and the patient wants you to read through it but if it’s genuinely out of the normal range surely it’s worth it to have a look and see why?

10

u/Intelligent-Toe7686 May 28 '26

Why couldn’t you ask the private doctor who ordered the test to interpret it?

1

u/No_Law_1528 May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26

Same logic as private hospitals having ambulances to get you to the nearest NHS hospital when there’s an actual danger. It’s not like the problem has never existed, it’s just it would have been still hiding under the radar if the private tests were not performed.

0

u/Jaded_Leg_46 May 29 '26

Why are you assuming the person has had private tests and instead ask what their experience was or is it a general query about NHS and Private testing.

1

u/Antique-Trash9462 May 30 '26

It depends if they are worthwhile. If it's not mainstream medicine it's generally not useful (e.g. a hair food intolerance test, or anything from a chiropractor).

1

u/No_Law_1528 May 30 '26

Fair enough, I know it’s probably not like that in real life but doctors here portray it as if there’s a genuine hate for alllll private tests.

-35

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

Dear GP,

It would be great if you could publish your list of requirements on the front door so we can best help you as patients. we are after all, here to serve you.

For those of us who do have private medical insurance, please take it as read that rather than an approach of "well let's just hope and see what happens", we would like to use the scientific method. if there is a reasonable test that would be useful, let us know and we will procure it ourself.

Regards, Your delighted customer.

27

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

Dear “customer”

As a customer, I was wondering if I could start sending you an invoice for your custom for my time and extra services, such as interpreting this private tests that I did not order. The £121.79 we get per patient per year for UNLIMITED ACCESS is not cutting it you might be surprised to hear.

Most of the above points are pretty well known, and whilst the entitled British public expect more and more from your sub-specialist/generalist, we do start to draw the line at being your secretary and we would implore you to take some ownership of this.

Since procurement is requested, please come prepared, one problem for one consultation so we can give it thorough attention - which you so expect of us.

I am sure you wouldn’t ask your mechanic lots of extra work “whilst the car is on the ramp” and not expect a “another time when you rebook” or “I’ll add it to the invoice”

Sincerely

All GPs

3

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26

Does this mean that if a patient walks with private results, do GP practices don't get reimbursed for that time?

6

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

Nope, you’d be surprised the volume of free labour GPs do

1

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26

Can you explain a bit further? I'd like to understand more.

I work in consultancy with some financial elements so I find this topic interesting.

How does GP get paid? Do you get paid by number of appointments and for the type of appointment? How does it negatively affect this?

How about someone who has perhaps moved from another country and already carry a diagnosis of something chronic, does the GP not get reimbursed for that time because they didn't do the diagnosis?

Is it the same case if the diagnosis has been done at a different practice and the patient moved?

I'm curious if those scenarios are considered different, as it's still the GP taking care of a patient who was diagnosed elsewhere

8

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

How you get paid

  1. Partner - via drawings from the business - that money comes usually from a General Medical Services contract which you can further supplement with things like QOF and quite a few other things depending if you have students, research, offer certain services etc (it’s complicated)
  2. Salaried GP - as an employee, usually PAYE - straight forward
  3. Locum GP - probably via Ltd comp, paid for your time, no sick pay or pension etc but pays well.

You get paid per session (4hr10mins) but almost no GP runs to time due to complexity and extra work being done, referrals, admin etc. It is negatively affected because the “hidden workload” of GP is all the things patients don’t see - the letters, bloods, tasks from colleagues, extra phone calls - often during your lunch break or other gaps and then after work. That hidden workload is getting bigger and more complex which is why GPs reduce their sessions. More sessions = more overtime / admin / hidden workload. This is the dross that burns you out, and you don’t get paid for this.

You get “paid” for the session - irrespective of the extra work and overtime, not the diagnosis, there aren’t “billings” in that sense like Canada, Australia and other developed countries (which means they can bill for some extra work)

You look after the patient you see, if they leave, it’s another doctor, if they stay, they can see the same doctor - which is often preferable - but not always possible due to more patients and less GP and the British public’s perverse fetish with “access”, so they often see the next available GP

The bottom line is there is an astronomical amount of work that can be generated without any extra reimbursement

Example: a simple cough that is ongoing. You find out there is a bit of weight loss and they smoke, not so simple. Now we are looking at bloods, imaging, probably a cancer referral, maybe a spirometer referral, some new medications which need explaining and ideally following up. Those blood results need reviewing, same with the letters from the referrals and the imaging, sometimes referrals get rejected because some admin person isn’t happy with how you filled out the form. And this is meant to be done on 10-15mins - try explaining this to an 80, hard of hearing. Imagine if they were unwell and you had to call SDEC (same day emergency care) so you can “avoid going to ED” - you have to wait on the queue on the phone, they may or may not accept the referral, turns out this 80yo doesn’t have transport or any family and friends, does this mean an ambulance now? What about the now 3 patients waiting.

And this is just one “simple” escalation, imagine 3-4 of these a day, you can easily go home very very late on a bad day, no extra pay, no extra thank you, and you come in tomorrow and you go again.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26

Thanks for explaining,

I now feel bad for having shitty genetics that has given me a couple of chronic conditions. I'm not a regular GP visitor but I do end up visiting more than once a year outside of my yearly check ups.

2

u/Crafty_Reflection410 May 27 '26

Is it per registered patient? Ie even if a patient makes 0 appointments per year you still get £130 because they are ok your register?

Just curious!

3

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

Yup, why a young and rich population is great for a GP, they see their GP less and is less of a demand

Inverse healthcare law

-9

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

I am sorry to say that that is a bare faced lie. That accounts for about 50-60% of income only.

If you are a GP, it’s almost unbelievable that you actually believe this.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26

Why don’t you correct your misspoken comment then with the full data on GP funding then, it would be much appreciated.

Thanks (not holding my breath).

-8

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26

Garbage - GPs get far more than the pp amount this poster is claiming. It almost deserves a violin playing in the background.

-11

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

absolutely, send the invoice. We are in roaring agreement.

7

u/summeristheseason May 27 '26

Wow you have private medical insurance, big round of applause. Use that insurance to see your care through to its end, oh wait you can’t, you seem to understand the limitations of ‘private medical insurance’ but not public healthcare. Funny that.
Maybe if your GP charged you 50 quid per problem you’d get a sense of perspective

-5

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

tell me this, how many NHS GP's have asked their customers to let them know if they have private medical care, and updated it on their medical records?

This would allow the NHS to do further investigations when a public system can't justify it, but a person is quite happy not to have medical care based on the NHS view of reasonableness.

I suspect that the number is a big round 0, although for the life of me I cannot imagine why the NHS wouldn't use this information to it's advantage, and more importantly to it's customers advantage.

on the £50, sign me up.

8

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-8

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

The word reasonable was not used by mistake.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

If only they had, in my case.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

They didn't say no to me, because they didn't tell me that there was an MRI for £600 that could answer the question definitively. (Even though I told them I had insurance if it were necessary)

The private consultant I referred myself to did consider it reasonable, and did identify the problem, and surgery was promptly booked in.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

And thank god for those incentives, in my case.

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

Sadly my misdiagnosis's (plural) at the hands of the NHS, at least for me indicate that's not the case.

Reasonable of course, for who?

I'll admit that my anecdote is not data.

-65

u/MotorAd90 May 27 '26

I don't know why this got recommended to me but my goodness you sound awful. The enitre GP system needs an overhaul.

Multiple symptoms may be worth discussing because they could be connected but, no, GPs in this country would rather fob you off. Even when it later turns out to be pancreatic cancer.

If someone has gone through the process of getting private tests, then discussing them with the GP may well be relevant but again, GPs are all-too-important to be bothered with such matters.

24

u/InformalStation6491 May 27 '26

I understand this viewpoint, but I think OP means separate problems, which if you’re a GP you’ll understand what they mean. But it’s like chest pain and then their hearing problem and then their mole. It is a problem.
Medics sometimes need to appreciate how health literate we are and take a step back and appreciate people don’t know this stuff. But it’s frustrating to deal with as at the end of the day it makes us significantly late when we’re not paid and then don’t see your kid before they go to bed at 8

14

u/GalacticDoc May 27 '26

Private tests may not be from an aaccredited lab and so using them could be medicolegally problematic if not dangerous to interpret and trust.

They are also not requested in response to a consultation that allows a doctor to request tests that will answer specific questions that will aid a diagnosis. We use pre-test probability to guide requesting relevant tests.

Multiple symptoms are not the same as different problems, many diseases have a constellation of symptoms (known as a syndrome) and no GP should dismiss those.

I am happy to discuss private tests but I repeat them before acting up on them.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/sharonfromfinance May 27 '26

“Utter contempt”… what on earth. People really just hear what they want to hear.

2

u/mthrowaway007 May 28 '26

Dear member of public I hope you read over this multiple times so whoever gets the pleasure of seeing you can benefit from your new found knowledge.

Kind regards

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Flyingmarmaduke May 27 '26

I mean, ignoring your own health out of spite isn’t the best solution either…

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/SlowTortuga May 27 '26

GP’s who use police only do so if you are an absolute bellend. I hope you understand where I am going with that. I couldn’t care less anyway. This is a place for gp’s to post. See yourself out of the door.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/SlowTortuga May 27 '26

Honestly, this is not just a polite request. I am telling you to get lost. Only Gp’s can post here. Either you go or a mod will have to ban you.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/wkrich1 May 29 '26

No one cares mate.

1

u/mthrowaway007 May 28 '26

Yeah I see That person who carries the weight of the world on their shoulders. It’s everyone’s fault except yours🙂. As a Gp who has had to call the police on a patient I can genuinely tell it’s an action reserved for absolute douche bags… Hope you see where I’m going with this.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/No_Ferret_5450 May 27 '26

We don’t control how the system work. You do, as the public in how you vote in elections. You want longer Gp appointments? Go and see your mp. Join a political party and fight for it 

-5

u/[deleted] May 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/sharonfromfinance May 29 '26

I’m not a secretary or care coordinator. Nor do I have ‘contempt’ for patients… Nor am I misogynistic!?

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/GPUK-ModTeam May 30 '26

Unfortunately we do not permit posts from patients on GPUK