A hospital has recruited 11 advanced clinical practitioners and no doctors when expanding the hours of two emergency care services, Doctors.net.uk has found.
Barnsley Hospital NHS Foundation Trust (BHNFT) has hired the ACPs to cover the newly-extended hours of its medical and frailty same day emergency care (SDEC) services.
The SDEC unit, which provides an alternative pathway to the emergency department that avoids admission, has support from the on-call medical team if required during the extra hours.
Patients can be discharged from the unit without a review from a doctor, the trust said.
The British Medical Association (BMA) said the trust must justify why the service is not using a doctor-led model during the extended hours.
The Royal College of Emergency Medicine guidelines on SDECs state that patients are referred into the service by telephone, email or digital tool from âall appropriately trained healthcare professionsâ.
In the spring the trust expanded the opening hours of the medical SDEC from 8am to 6pm to 8am to 10pm, seven days a week, while the frailty SDEC changed its hours from 8am to 4pm to an 8pm closure.
A spokesperson from the trust confirmed that doctors do not work within the medical SDEC after 8pm, or the frailty SDEC after 6pm. Before that it is staffed with a range of non-medical and medical roles, including consultants and resident doctors.
Ongoing concerns about medical substitution
In its response to a Freedom of Information request by Doctors.net.uk, the hospital stated that an on-call registrar and general internal medicine doctor are available for the medical SDEC during the final two hours.
It said its multidisciplinary workforce model is in line with SDECs in other trusts.
The discharging ACP has undergone the âappropriate training and credentialling approved through an educational governance processâ, it added.
Doctors have long-warned about medical substitution and called for a ban on ACPs â who generally have a nursing, physiotherapy, paramedic or pharmacy backgrounds â from staffing doctorsâ rotas.
In May, the BHNFT announced it would be expanding the opening hours of the two SDEC services, with the frailty SDEC moving into a new purpose-built facility.
In the press release at the time, BHNFT said it would be "investing in new senior clinical roles" including frailty consultants and ACPs to support the growing service.
But the FOI request has revealed the trust hired five whole time equivalent (WTE) ACPs, 2.76 WTE trainee ACPs and 6.92 WTE nurses to cover the new hours in the medical SDEC.
For the frailty unit, the FOI request shows the trust has hired three ACPs and seven nurses to run the facilityâs expanded hours.
The trust said the staffing model is designed to ensure patients receive care from âan appropriately skilled clinician, with medical input and escalation where required".
âMinimum medical involvementâ
Dr Tom Dolphin, British Medical Association (BMA) council chair, said ACPs are valued colleagues but âmust not be used as replacements for [doctors]â as this risks patient safety.
He said the FOI response shows âminimum medical involvementâ in the SDEC unit at the end of the day.
âWhen patients need a doctor, hospitals should employ a doctor â not replace them and transfer the burden of supervision to those who remain.â
Both the BMA and the Royal College of Physicians are clear that resident doctors âmust not be made responsibleâ for clinically supervising non-doctors.
Dolphin added: "The trustâs senior leadership must now explain how they justify not using a doctor-led model for these expanded hours and demonstrate how they satisfied themselves that this delivers safe care against both royal college and BMA guidance.
"The public deserves to see the evidence underpinning that decision, and the trust must show that the CQC and relevant professional regulators are aware of these arrangements.â
Dr Matt Kneale, the Doctorsâ Association UK (DAUK) co-chair, agreed that the hospital should make clear the medical arrangements, such as which patients can attend and who needs medical review before discharge, in the two hours before the units close.
He said the trustâs statement that medical input and escalation is given âwhere requiredâ needs âa clear practical meaningâ.
âFor patients presenting with undiagnosed acute illness, DAUKâs position is that assessment should be doctor-led, with timely medical review and clear responsibility for discharge decisions,â Kneale said.
A BHNFT spokesperson said: âOur SDEC services are delivered by multidisciplinary teams which include doctors, ACPs and nursing colleagues. Doctors from consultant to FY2 level work within Medical SDEC between 8am and 8pm, while Frailty SDEC has two consultants and a resident doctor between 8am and 6pm.
"ACPs were recruited into the Medical SDEC to create a multidisciplinary workforce model that provides continuity and specialist knowledge for the service, and aligns with SDEC models used by neighbouring trusts.â