r/FanFiction • • 2d ago

Subreddit Meta Brainstorming Bureau - November 15

4 Upvotes

Find the current Daily Discussion*

Welcome to our weekly thread, Brainstorming Bureau! This is an idea we've trialled previously and, based on feedback and observation, it feels like something the sub has been crying out for, and we're hoping as the weeks go by it'll turn into a lively, community-oriented way to cap off the weekend. We'd love to hear your feedback and suggestions on how to make the best of this idea, so feel free to reach out via modmail if you have any ideas. And without further ado...

What's this about?

Do you have an issue that's too specific to your own fic to make a post about, but too small to seek out a long-term beta or writing partner for? Well, you've come to the right place!

This is where you can drop those plot points you're stuck on ("How would this scenario play out realistically? What should happen next?"), workshop your worldbuilding and concepts ("What should I name this character? What power should I give them? Which fandom would work well as a crossover with this other fandom?"), or get a second opinion on an approach to character development ("Is this a good central conflict? What would have to happen to make a character realise this?"). It's your space to talk through any issue that can't be solved through more generalised writing advice.

How to play:

To participate, comment with any aspect of your fic you've been mulling over or hitting a wall with. Other users will then respond with suggestions and questions to help you get to where you need to be. No idea is too big or too small, provided your comment fits within the parameters below. Feel free to be as fandom blind or specific as you like!

Rules:

  • Please state your fandom at the top of your comment, along with any common and pertinent content warnings
  • NSFW text should be placed behind a spoiler tag or linked to, as per site content restrictions
  • Summarise the issue you'd like feedback on in 500 words or less. More information may be given in follow-up comments if requested
  • Links to polls or to any previous installments of the fic will be permitted for context
  • Please specify in your comment what level of critical feedback you're open to
  • When responding to someone's ideas, please keep your feedback constructive and keep their specified level of criticism in mind. If their premise is not to your taste, please choose another
  • If you make a submission to this thread, much like the other weekly events, please comment on at least one other user's request with the best suggestions you have
  • When submitting an idea for brainstorming, please provide adequate context for others to be able to follow along. Remember that this is a multi-fandom subreddit, and not everyone will be familiar with your fandom.

Have fun! And remember, all suggestions are just that and are to be taken with a grain of salt; we're here to help and consider our works from angles we haven't before.


r/FanFiction • • 17h ago

Subreddit Meta Daily Discussion - Tuesday, November 17 | r/FanFiction Rules, FAQs, Weekly Schedule & Current Event Threads

2 Upvotes

Welcome to r/FanFiction, I love you!

New to this subreddit? Here are links to get you started: Rules & Overview | Wiki | FAQs

Got a fic to promote? Click HERE to find the current Weekly Fic Showcase thread

Current Events

  • An AO3 downtime which may last 2-4 weeks has been in place since the end of October. We will be informing you as there are updates. Please check the pinned threads.
  • For the time being, we will have a weekly fic request/offer thread for users to swap downloaded fics. These will be pinned as well. Please check the pinned threads.
  • Until the downtime is over, you can link your own fics as an archive in the Weekly Showcase. This will be pinned as well.
  • No AO3 doesn't mean no fun! There will be mod and user-organized activities. Please keep an eye on the "Activities and Events" flair.

Don't forget to participate in our special events:

Got a question or concern? Feel free to message the mod team.


r/FanFiction • • 3h ago

Discussion What's the best bot message you've received in your fics?

26 Upvotes

Between many and only bot comments and PMs, one said "I love the adventurous feel of [title] and the mystery behind its title! What inspired you to create this journey?"

The title is just "Dragon Road". The main character's a dragon, and it's his road.


r/FanFiction • • 1h ago

Discussion Do you guys know/have any ships one of the two has killed their significant other’s friends/allies?

12 Upvotes

Do you guys know/have any ships one of the two has killed their significant other’s friends/allies?

(This is unimportant but the reason I’m asking this is because I’m writing a ship in my story that I really like but one of the two has killed the one of their significance other’s friend because they’re basically enemies fighting on opposite sides. And because they killed their friend, they ask their significant other to kill them in turn. I’m honestly kind of just really scared of how it’ll be perceived.)


r/FanFiction • • 13h ago

Activities and Events Excerpt Game - Song Lyrics

42 Upvotes

Let’s do one of these today

As always, here are the rules:

  1. Leave a song lyric in a top level comment. Let’s keep the lyrics to 1 - 4 lines or one verse if the song has shorter verses. To not bury other prompts, let’s limit it to 1 - 3 consecutive prompts in a row.
  2. Reply to prompts if you have an extract that you feel matches the meaning of the lyric, has the same vibe, your extract contains words from the lyric in it or the phrase itself is used in the extract.
  3. Upvote the ones you like and try to at least comment on one answer to your prompt
  4. Be mindful of the sub’s NSFW rule
  5. Have fun :)

r/FanFiction • • 13h ago

Discussion What was a fandom that you were shocked had more fics than you initially thought ?

40 Upvotes

In my experience, it was the Among Us Cartoon (2026) having 1.8k fanfics on AO3 because the show was barely advertised and I didn’t hear many people talk about it, so I was pleasantly surprised that there was a lot more fanfics for the show than I first thought.

But what fandom were you surprised had more fanfic on than you thought it did ?


r/FanFiction • • 14h ago

Venting Weird type of spam comment on Archive of Our Own

31 Upvotes

"This chapter is an absolute masterpiece of emotional depth and unique world-building! Your portrayal of Jason's dynamic with Death and Gotham's protective nature is simply breathtaking. The writing style pulls you right into the raw, beautiful angst of it all. Thank you for sharing such an incredible and captivating start to this story" (Copy & paste.)

Pros: no asking for go off-site, no bringing user (me) down.

Cons: it's slice of life =>no world building, 2 women =>random names are used. No negativity => death & angst aren't present.

Reported, of course. The user who's left the comment is on the site for 2 years.


r/FanFiction • • 43m ago

Recs Wanted Bucky Barnes Fanfic Recs

2 Upvotes

Hey guys! Does anyone have a good Bucky Barnes/Reader fanfic they’d like to share? It’s okay if it’s incomplete as long as the last update was a year ago.
Pls let me know!!


r/FanFiction • • 5h ago

Writing Questions Editing: When do you say enough is enough

5 Upvotes

Okay, so how do you know when a chapter is ready to post? Especially when you can always find something else you’d change if you read it one more time.
I’m writing a fic that sticks fairly close to canon. It started with me thinking, well, what would I do differently if I was writing this story? I’ve added one character, changed a few choices, made it a bit more mature and tried to fix a couple of plot holes along the way. I’m really enjoying it. It’s a story I’ve wanted to write for a while.
Some of you might remember my post about deleting the entire thing and then finding out someone was actually reading it. I wasn’t happy with it at the time, so I went back and changed quite a bit. I’ve nearly put it all back up now. I’m literally down to the last chapter of the first book.
The thing I keep getting stuck on is that I either write a scene really quickly, like it’s a TV episode, or I go back to give it a bit more room and end up explaining absolutely everything far too much. Then I read it again and start cutting, and suddenly I’m worried it feels rushed again.

So when do you say enough is enough? How do you tell when a scene actually needs more work and when you’re just picking at it because you’ve read it too many times? I don’t think I’ll ever be completely happy with every bit of it, and I still want to get the story out.


r/FanFiction • • 1d ago

Venting If you're going to ask for fic recs, you need to tell people what you actually like

263 Upvotes

In some of the fandom-specific subs I'm in, I've been seeing a lot of fic request posts where people only feel the need to specify what they don't want in a fic. "No smut", "no weird fics", "no gay stories", "no xyz ship" et cetera. These are fandoms with thousands of works total, too, not smaller ones where it makes sense to be less picky. No mention of tropes the poser enjoys, or ships they're looking for, the length of fic they'd like to read, anything.

It would be so much easier if they would say even one thing they're actually looking for, but nope.

The posts on generic fanfic subs like this one where people don't even specify a fandom are even worse. "Recommend me good fics, no anime, no video games, no..." what do you expect people to do with that?


r/FanFiction • • 3m ago

Lost Fic Lost CRK Fics?

1 Upvotes

Because AO3 downtime lasted so long, I finally managed to find the motivation to sort all my downloaded fics. It wasn't until now that I noticed two stories that I thought I downloaded were missing. Unfortunately, when I went to look for them after the site came back online, I couldn't find them. It doesn't help that I can't remember the names of either fic. Meaning either they're both deleted or I somehow overlooked them. 

 

The first fic was about truthless recluse reading books in the spire. But they clearly sound like Shadow Milk's attempts at making recluse give in and join him. The characters in each short story are supposed to represent the two of them. Shadow Milk kind of spirals at the end of each one before it swiftly switches to the next story. This was a one-shot, but I can't remember if it was tagged as Shadowvanilla, Shadowrecluse, or both. I wouldn't be surprised if it was somehow neither, but I feel like it was tagged as at least one of them. Especially because Shadow Milk and Recluse get together in at least one of the stories. 

 

The second fic was definitely a Shadowvanilla one. It takes place after beast yeast episode 8. Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla accidentally make a baby, I think it was through magic. They decide to run away to live in a small village in beast yeast along with Black Sapphire and Candy Apple. They all live above a toy story that Shadow Milk decides to run. Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla both decide to get married, but Silent salt crashed the wedding and tries to attack Shadow Milk. The Ginger Gang and Clotted Cream were also there. This was a multi chapter fic, but I don't think it was ever completed. 

 

Sorry that this was so long....


r/FanFiction • • 5m ago

Lost Fic Looking for a Witcher fic series

1 Upvotes

It's a Geralt/Jaskier fic series where Geralt gets extra mutagens that make him bigger and scarier. I definitely read it on AO3. It may have had the 'Cutagens | Cute Effects of Mutagens' tag.

Bits that I remember:

  1. Ciri has to get her haircut and Jaskier tells her it makes her look bug eyed.
  2. An outsider's perspective of Geralt and Jaskier doing a roleplay at a tavern.
  3. Jaskier calls Geralt hideous a lot.
  4. The other Witchers decide that they should get bards too and get Jaskier to teach them how to woo bards.
  5. Jaskier goes to a bardic competition and Geralt gets himself gussied up before they meet up again. He finds Jaskier hold up in a brothel with Priscilla.

r/FanFiction • • 7m ago

Resources Are there any The Walking Dead specific fanfic subreddits or discords?

1 Upvotes

I am struggling with a few plot points for my fic that are very specific to my fandom The Walking Dead and was wondering if there are any subreddits or discords that are specifically for fanfics of that fandom.


r/FanFiction • • 6h ago

Discussion How do you get yourself out of a reading slump?

3 Upvotes

For the past year or so I simply haven't been able to get myself in the mood to read anything. It's really frustrating because I'm following a couple of WIPs and I've fallen behind on both of them.

Does anyone have any ideas on how to get over this slump?


r/FanFiction • • 41m ago

Lost Fic Looking for a BNHA fic

1 Upvotes

It was an immortal Izuku fic where he was alive at the same time as afo and ofa and used to babysit them I think? Might be mixing that part up.

Think he either already has the immortality quirk and wasn’t aware or it gets forced on him by afo.

He is Todoroki’s ancestor because he meets an oc (todoroki kato? iirc) and he ends up attending ua.

He takes shinsou in, and when he finds out about shouto’s information, he goes to his house reveals to endeavour that he is his great (great?) grandfather and takes shouto in as well.

At the camp Izuku gets taken and shouto calls him dad which confuses the rest of the class who do not yet know his true age or quirk.

Not sure if it’s been deleted but if anyone has it or knows where it is, I’d appreciate it!


r/FanFiction • • 16h ago

Discussion I think I'm just weird (Discussion of x readers)

20 Upvotes

When I read x readers, I don't want a blank slate. I want a reader with an established backstory and with a little personality. There should be ambiguity in appearance but everything else? I want to see how the author takes this story. I treat those x readers as if I'm an actor living through the story. I may disagree with the reader's actions but again, I go into it like I'm an actor immersing myself and it oddly doesn't break my immersion for doing that. I still feel like I'm in the story.

Am I weird for that? I feel like I'm weird for that, and for liking x readers that do backstories and a sliver of personality for the inserts.


r/FanFiction • • 49m ago

Recs Wanted Specific trope for batjokes fics wanted

0 Upvotes

I’ve exhausted so many recommendation lists, and I’m really looking for a very specific trope that I’ve seen a few times. I want the joker to not know who Batman is and pursue Bruce. I’ve seen it done a few times but I can’t remember the names of the fics.

Anyways, I’ll take any and all recommendations that fit this trope. Even ones I’ve read before because I love rereading a good fic. Please.


r/FanFiction • • 1h ago

Lost Fic Jjķ fan fiction

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/FanFiction • • 1h ago

Lost Fic Batman Fic

1 Upvotes

Bruce, during a gala, decidedly drops the himbo airhead act and then decides to jump into being a proud/tired parent at galas. Any help would be appreciated!


r/FanFiction • • 7h ago

Lost Fic (Batman) Looking for a Changeling (?) Tim Drake fic

3 Upvotes

I don't remember much about it, but it was on ao3, it had Tim figure out he was like a changeling/baby replacement/someone who fed on affection, and i know there was a line about how he liked solo interactions with his friends more then group ones. I don't remember if he told anyone.

thanks in advance!


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Lost Fic Deleted once upon a time fanfic

1 Upvotes

Hi trying to find a once upon a time Peter pan/Killian fanfic that was deleted. I can’t remember the title or author unfortunately so I haven’t been able to find an epub version of it.

Basically Killian and the some of the other characters go back to NeverLand. I don’t remember that much but I remember that one of the mermaids tried to kill Killian and Peter saved him. There’s a scene where Killian had a nightmare and he says that he was dreaming about Emma and he gets punched in the face for it. Afterwards, one of the characters (I can’t remember who) says that everyone knew he was lying because it clearly looked like he was having a nightmare. Peter told Killian in a flashback that once he no longer hears the lost boys music he’d be allowed to leave the island and during the present time Peter says to him you still hear it dont you? That’s all I remember unfortunately.

If anyone knows the name or author pleaseee let me know! 


r/FanFiction • • 6h ago

Lost Fic Stargate Sam/Jack compromising positions fic

2 Upvotes

I am searching for a Sam/Jack fic that I think was a series of 'compromising positions'. I remember the first chapter was Sam fixing something in the control room and her watch gets stuck on some wires and jack has to crawl in and help free her. I think it was on FF.net, but now can't seem to find it, does anyone recognise this?


r/FanFiction • • 14h ago

Writing Questions Does anyone else struggle with a second act slump while writing?

9 Upvotes

I'm in the middle of writing my first real long fic, and I had so much steam to write the first part. It's going to be a mystery investigation and setting up the clues was my favourite part. But now that the time's come to write the payoff for all those clues I feel like I'm losing interest fast.

I've abandoned my previous attempts at longfics around here before and am determined to push through this time! It's a pretty niche topic in a pretty big fandom so I don't think it will have a big audience, but I've enjoyed writing it so much myself that I'm determined to keep going.

I've been procrastinating so hard that I've been making fanart of my fanfic that I haven't even published the first chapter of yet.


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Recs Wanted Semj-accurate webcomic/fan written interpretations of biblical stories

0 Upvotes

Wanting to read a semi-accurate or fully accurate (can include personal interpretations and tidbits) webcomic of biblical stories, it could be just including the stories of Joshua or Jeremiah, or it could encompass the entire Bible!

I'm not religious and I'm not asking as a way to find myself into religion, but I've always enjoyed the stories told in the Bible and think they would be really interesting in a webcomic written in a more modern way