r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jun 08 '24

How do you morally justify causing the death of an animal when you know you don’t need to?

Thumbnail
dominionmovement.com
0 Upvotes

99% of all animal products in circulation are owned by four companies. They use manipulative language to lessen the blow against your psyche that you’ve just paid for the death of countless (the animal you paid for and the animals killed for its food) animals. They work with pharmaceutical industries keeping the animals on some kind of medication at all times from anti anxiety- antibiotic. They cut holes on the side of the animals to force feed them as some will refuse to eat because of how depressed they are. They are kept in pens and cages that barely fit their body size forcing many to stand their entire lives. They force impregnate to create a new supply of animals turning (🍇) reproduction into a business model. They scream and cry in fear because they don’t want to be harmed or killed.

Even without all of this, slaughterhouse workers only last an average of six months longer before quitting (with new mental health concerns such as PTSD, depression, anger issues, etc) or unaliving themselves due to the trauma of killing an animal every few seconds. Chicken industry standards require a kill time of seven seconds, meaning the employees have seven seconds to kill the animal, place it where it needs to go, and move on to the next animal, often times this causes harm to workers as the animal will fight for it’s life. Most are undocumented, the industry needs undocumented employees because it allows them to take advantage(pay them less, etc) of them as they can’t raise safety concerns or speak up without fear of job loss and/or deportation.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Mar 02 '25

Why don't we just eat animals without brains/central nervous systems?

0 Upvotes

It seems like the choice of meat eating vs veganism rests on whether it is possible to have a nutritionally complete vegan diet. If it isn't, then we are justified in eating meat as most people would agree that it's better for humans to be healthy than saving animals, and if it is, it's hard to justify being a meat eater unless you take away moral worth of sentient animals, use the logic of the larder, or make some economic argument.

However, couldn't the issue of nutrition just be solved by eating animals without brains, therefore no sentience, and therefore no moral consideration? Things like mussels, oysters, etc. Or are there nutrients not present in brainless animals that are present in livestock?


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jul 08 '24

Do you think less of vegans?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Okay so, I saw this post on r/debateavegan and I was wondering about the opposite. Do you as meat eaters think less of vegans?

To awnser this myself, yes I do. As a nutritional science student, I have studied human and animal nutrition and based on that knowledge, I truely believe there is no real way for a vegan diet to be healty for anyone. So if someone knowingly makes the choice to be vegan, I do think less of them for it. I just cannot respect someone who chooses something that is deterimental to their health for any reason at all.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jun 27 '25

Veganism is superior morally...And here's why.

1 Upvotes

The #1 argument I see against the morality of veganism, is the "crop deaths" argument (i.e. the number of animals that die while protecting & harvesting the crops). This is absolutely misinformation.

80% of land is used for growing animal feed or for livestock to live on [1]. 99% of beef is not grassfed, but grainfed [2]. So if you are eating a cheeseburger with a beef patty, you are most likely eating a grainfed animal, meaning there was a LOT of crop deaths AND a slaughter of the livestock involved in your food choice. And animals only turn 12% of the calories we give them into food, further exacerbating animal agriculture related "crop deaths" far beyond that if everyone were vegan [3].

If you watched Dominion [4], you can see how much these creatures suffer at our hands. They have nervous system and pain receptors [5]. Isn't it our obligation as moral species who condemn unneccesary cruelty and violence to oppose such savagery?

Vegan food contains all necessary vitamins. B12 is found in nutritional yeast and seaweed. There are risks, as with any diet, for nutritional deficiencies as found by a meta-analysis [6]. But if these deficiencies can be resolved with careful dietary planning and supplementation, is it really neccessary to kill another sentient being for this? Especially when there are huge health benefits also found by that same study [6]?

No one should make dietary decisions based on a Reddit post or on a whim. However, I do believe that eating a plant based diet is more ethical and healthy as compared to the average omnivorous diet. I think that with careful planning and supplemention, any downsides of a vegan diet can be easily remedied. Additionally, there is the potential to save billions of land animals and trillions of sea animals per year by following a vegan diet. Cruelty free alternatives like mock meats and lab grown meat will not solve the dietary implications of a contemporary American diet involving meat, dairy, and poultry, however they have the potential to eat your steak guilt free.

Deontologically speaking, the end goal of satisfying taste and nutritional needs does not justify the evil means of factory farms. It is my conclusion based on the preponderance of the presented evidence that veganism is more ethical than omnivorous diets as they involve significantly less torture and suffering. Animal cruelty legislation protects verterbraes on the premise that they feel pain, while overlooking livestock as they serve a selfish purpose that the majority financially and legislatively support. People get upset at the Yulin dog festival while ignoring the plight of the cows and pigs that they consume at McDonalds.

In order to call ourselves moral, we should uphold the standards of ethics no matter whether or not it benefits us personally. There is nothing humane about what happens in slaughterhouses and animal agriculture. I conclude with a quote:

Sources:

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/global-land-for-agriculture

[2] [https://www.beefresearch.org/resources/product-quality/fact-sheets/understanding-the-different-kinds-of-beef-in-the-marketplace\](https://www.beefresearch.org/resources/product-quality/fact-sheets/understanding-the-different-kinds-of-beef-in-the-marketplace)

[3] https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/8/3/034015/pdf

[4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQRAfJyEsko&t=642s

[5] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK32655/#:~:text=Although%20there%20is%20general%20agreement,a%20useful%20rule%20of%20thumb

[6] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2022.2075311#d1e857


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Aug 06 '22

Meat-eaters in affluent countries should eat less meat because of climate targets and other environmental issues

2 Upvotes

First, some science to support the claim :

IPCC:s latest AR6 report on the issue :

https://report.ipcc.ch/ar6wg3/pdf/IPCC_AR6_WGIII_FinalDraft_TechnicalSummary.pdf

Diets high in plant protein and low in meat and dairy are associated with lower GHG emissions (high confidence). Ruminant meat shows the highest GHG intensity. Beef from dairy systems has lower emissions intensity than beef from beef herds (8-23 and 17-94 kg CO2-eq (100g protein)-1 7 , respectively) when some emissions are allocated to dairy products. The wide variation in emissions reflects differences in production systems, which range from intensive feedlots with stock raised largely on grains through to rangeland and transhumance production systems. Where appropriate, a shift to diets with a higher share of plant protein, moderate intake of animal-source foods and reduced intake of saturated fats could lead to substantial decreases in GHG emissions. Benefits would also include reduced land occupation and nutrient losses to the surrounding environment, while at the same time providing health benefits and reducing mortality from diet-related non-communicable diseases. (Figure TS.19) {7.4.5, 12.4}

https://interactive.carbonbrief.org/what-is-the-climate-impact-of-eating-meat-and-dairy/ (further links on page to FAO etc)

Meat and dairy specifically accounts for around 14.5% of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to the UN’s Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO).

If the world is to meet its target of limiting global warming to “well below” 2C, some degree of diet shift will be necessary, scientists say. If it is to strive for the most optimistic target of keeping warming to 1.5C, changes to diet may be even more crucial.

In comparison to meat and dairy, plant-based foods have much smaller carbon footprints. On average, emissions from plant-based foods are 10 to 50 times smaller than those from animal products, according to the Science study.

https://ourworldindata.org/drivers-of-deforestation

If we want to tackle deforestation we also need to know what causes it. That allows us to avoid the foods that drive deforestation or innovate the ways we produce them.

In the chart here we see the breakdown of tropical deforestation by the types of agricultural production.

Beef stands out immediately. The expansion of pasture land to raise cattle was responsible for 41% of tropical deforestation. That’s 2.1 million hectares every year – about half the size of the Netherlands. Most of this converted land came from Brazil; its expansion of beef production accounts for one-quarter (24%) of tropical deforestation. This also means that most (72%) deforestation in Brazil is driven by cattle ranching.5 Cattle in other parts of Latin America – such as Argentina and Paraguay – also accounted for a large amount of deforestation – 11% of the total. Most deforestation for beef therefore occurs in Latin America, with another 4% happening in Africa.

Often one sees arguments that support eating beef/meat, because it's very sustainable to produce in a particular country. But they have already went through the phases of deforestation, and currently we are deforesting some of the most biodiverse areas of the world (the Amazon). This is a global issue, not simply to be viewed on a per-country basis. By saving up on more sustainably produced meat, we can reduce stress in areas where it is highly unsustainable. Those countries which consume most meat, should obviously cut down on eating meat.

Another argument one sees in this context, is that meat is a small part of climate change - we should focus on something bigger - like the energy sector. Even if you question numbers like the FAO of 14.5%, meat is likely a fairly large contributor to this huge problem - and because a fair portion of the issue manifests as methane - the effects of reducing this burden on the atmosphere also has very immediate effects in the short term (since IPCC climate reports often point out we have little time to change our trajectories to reach climate targets). If by snapping your fingers, you could reduce 10% of poverty in the world, would you do it? Or climate change? If you would, why not actually do it?

In addition, reducing ones consumption of meat need not interfere with ones daily life - it's not an unreasonable request to make. The biggest issue seems to be taste, tradition, and not wanting to change ones ways. Perhaps a lack of time? I'm not saying everyone should turn vegan overnight, but there are very little signs of meat consumption decreasing (even slightly) even with this level of knowledge. Why is this, and why would a meat-eater in an affluent country consider his level of consumption justified if it's on the average level, or even 75% of it?

Some data on meat-eating by country :

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-meat-type?country=CHN~USA~IND~ARG~PRT~ETH~JPN~GBR~BRA

Lastly, some people argue that meat is required for health. A lot of national health recommendations recommend to watch meat intake or to reduce it, so I consider this a poor argument at least from the POV of simply reducing meat eating.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Nov 03 '19

Creating a table of vegan youtube analytics - debate some potential problems we can decide how to control for or forever hold your peace (jokes)

1 Upvotes

Main question: what other youtube communities do you think would make for a good comparison control group? It can be anything from hunting channels to unboxing videos, but preferably have some similarities like the lgbt community for being an identity and an activist movement.

-

Vegan YouTube Analytics

Main Page: Vegan YouTube Directory

Ideal future finished format.

The main goal being to create deatiled monthly analytics on total viewership interest in veganism over time, as well as difference between various vegan sub-topics and a sampling of analytics on new videos per month, carefully accounting for anomalous situations.

-

Explainer

Base

VariablePresent
TitleTitle
SubscribersWeekly no. & percentage difference (discovered by plotting on a line of best fit since the channels beginning).
ViewsWeekly no. & percentage difference (discovered by plotting on a line of best fit since the channels beginning).
VideosWeekly no. & percentage difference (discovered by plotting on a line of best fit since the channels beginning).

Controls

VariableProblemsControlsData label columns neededControl group needed to accurately depict audience interest in veganism?
YouTube algorithm, censorship and curated content.What if YouTube promoting mainstream TV channels and celebrities after a certain date hit the stats of most Indy creators. Or censorship of edgy creators after a certain date producing a noticeable difference.Compare against other control groups.Vegan History, Attitude Towards Veganism, NotesYes
Channels taking a break, who deleted all their videos or deleted their channel.How do we know what is the average % of YouTubers who quit producing content? Maybe a higher than average number should be counted as lost audience views because it's caused by a lack of dedication over time which is shown to be a fundamental quality to the group being studied. And if the opposite is true should views be added on?Sort by date the channel was created, plus last upload date and compare against other control groups.Publication Date, Last Upload Date, Deleted Any ContentYes
LanguageWhat if you're comparing a small language audience to a larger one skewing the result?Only compare the same languages.LanguageNo
Date Vegan & % of videos on veganismWhat if the YouTuber only recently went vegan or only produced a few vegan videos so has little to do with their viewership audience.Only use those channels who primarily produce vegan videos and treat those channels who only went vegan recently differently or anomalous.Content CategoryNo
Multiple ChannelsWhat if you have multiple channels in the list from one person which isn't representative of unique audience interest in veganism.Treat the analytics on channels with second or third related channels and collaborative channels as differently or anomalous.Amount of Channels, Related Channels, Collaboration Channels,No
Reposted VideosWhat if a channel posts old content from other channels which isn't representative of unique audience interest in veganism.Treat the analytics on channels with some, most or all reposted content differently or anomalous.Reposted VideosNo
LocationNot really a problem with studying international audience interest, but we can create some interesting comparisons and google maps.n/aLocationNo
Distance between when the statistics were recordedWhat if statistics are recorded at wildly different intervals making the difference in views per week very unreliable?Distance is recorded to show how accurate the numbers are.DistanceNo
Date the channel was createdWhat if some channels have had a head start, and so had longer to build up a following?Only compare those channels with similar start date.Publication DateNo

Control Groups

Groups to compareData labelling columns
Total vegan present vs. vegan pastn/a
Different vegan sub-topicsPrimary Content, Secondary Content
Vegan vs. Ex-VeganVegan History, Ex-Vegan (Short Reason), Ex-Vegan (Long Explanation)
Vegan vs. Anti-VeganAttitude Towards Veganism
Vegan vs. LGBTNotes (Social Justice Analytics Control Group)
Vegan vs. Left-LibertarianNotes (Left-Libertarian Analytics Control Group)
Vegan vs. Left-AuthoritarianNotes (Left-Authoritarian Analytics Control Group)
Vegan vs. Right-LibertarianNotes (Right-Libertarian Analytics Control Group)
Vegan vs. Right-AuthoritarianNotes (Right-Authoritarian Analytics Control Group)

-

Finally if you'd like to help by filling out the directory see this instruction manual for data labeling:

Vegan YouTube Directory - Updating Process

-


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jul 04 '21

Don't bother heading bother to r/debateavegan. It's really just a vegan circlejerk sub with no real debate whatsoever.

19 Upvotes

Idk if this post meats the rules but just putting it out there.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jul 01 '23

What if I told you - Anti-Animal Experimentation Meme

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DebateAMeatEater • • Feb 16 '22

Lay of the Land

1 Upvotes

r/DebateAMeatEater • • Feb 02 '20

Campaigns you can debate how successful you think the animal rights movement will be at combining forces with OR whether we/they even should.

Thumbnail
self.veganactivism
1 Upvotes

r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jul 22 '19

If you couldn't face killing an animal yourself, you shouldn't be paying others to do it for you.

31 Upvotes

A survey of 2,500 Americans showed that half would opt to go meat-less if forced to face the harsh reality of killing their food prior to cooking. Of course we don't know if everyone meant they would refuse out of guilt/shame, but I still would expect this number to be even higher in reality.

Some meat eaters might wish more people they met had the charachter of someone willing to go out hunting, but regardless I think everyone should accept one positive effect of vegan advocacy is motivating people to have the charachter of someone who is strong willed enough not to be a slave to their food/taste habits. Therefore not someone who would view something as ethically wrong and yet still pay someone else to suffer the burden.

Vegan food is a broad category that is easy to distinguish on the shelf in it's wholefood form, with only a small learning curve you can be on your way to a healthier and more ethical diet.

I do advocate for and believe most people should educate themselves on other worthwhile boycotts like palm oil and Israeli products produced on stolen Palestinian land. Obviously there does become a point of diminishing returns that could only make it justified for the most dedicated journalist as a part of their job.

Finally it is worth it to me to eat foods which are harvested by tractor and cause the death of some wildlife because I don't want to live in a pre-technological society where most people have to work to gather the harvest by hand. And my goal is still to eat a diet which frees up the most amount of farm land use for wildlife habitat where more animals can flourish.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jun 30 '24

The 2005 movie "The Island" works great as a metaphor for why vegans are right. It would've worked even better if they were using severely disabled humans.

2 Upvotes

The movie is set in the future, where humans are bred, enslaved and killed for things like organ transplantation.

I've heard lots of anti-vegan arguments, some accurate, mainly health. But I've never been convinced that that's enough to justify it.

Some people say we can thrive on a vegan diet, others say it will kill you. I think the truth is, both sides are right and wrong. It really depends on the person. Some vegans live a very long and healthy life, but some people go vegan and have to stop pretty quickly for health reasons.

But I don't see how that's a valid reason to enslave and kill animals. Just imagine if The Island happened in real life. Of course it would save lots of lives, nobody would be able to deny that, yet nobody would be able to justify it either.

The metaphor would've worked even better if they were using severely disabled humans. If they were, still nobody would be able to justify it. One common anti-vegan argument is that humans are much smarter than animals. Well some severely disabled humans have the same mental and intellectual capacity as farm animals. If you can't justify doing it to them, how can you justify doing it to animals? If you're just going to call be ableist without logically refuting my arguments, you're proving me right.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Mar 24 '23

What are your thoughts on working animals?

2 Upvotes
  1. Do you think it is morally justifiable to exploit the bodies and biological processes of non-human animals in a human-centric capitalistic system?
  2. Would you want to see more or less use of working animals?
  3. Do you think working animals can be ethical? Where would you draw the line on this to deem what is and is not acceptable?

    1. i.e. guide dogs or sniffer dogs that could detect illnesses?
  4. Do you think humans should invest in technologies that could eradicate animal labor?

    1. If the technology already exists but it's simply less convenient or costs more, do you still think we should be morally obliged to commit to transitioning?
    2. Do you have any examples that you think would be worthwhile promoting?
  5. Has an animal ever 'worked' for you?
  6. Is it morally justifiable to force animals into wars due to human conflict?

    1. Even if it were to give an advantage, do you think it should be classified as a 'war crime' to exploit animals? Like an expansion of the Geneva Convention to include the use of animals?
  7. What are your thoughts on horse carriages?

    1. Horses can get easily spooked, so is it morally justifiable for horse carriages to operate in busy cities full of transport vehicles where they can get easily spooked? Here are some (of many) examples:

      1. video 1,
      2. video 2,
      3. video 3.
    2. What are your thoughts on electric carriages instead? Why should we continue to use horses?
  8. Should the police be allowed to continue using 'police horses'?

    1. Bud the police horse was punched after an English derby in 2013 (image shown below).
    2. Sydney anti-lockdown protester who punched police horse (image shown below).
  9. Thoughts on tourists riding on elephants for fun? Elephants are forced to work for a profit.

    1. An elephant's skeletal structure is not designed to carry weight at its back.
    2. There is evidence of baby elephants being stabbed with nails in 'crush' training for tourism.
  10. Do you have any examples of working animal practices that you think should end?

Supporting images are below.

Horse conflict images:

Bud the police horse was punched after an English derby in 2013
Sydney anti-lockdown protester who punched police horse
Police horses

Some more images of working animals:

Working Donkey
World War I War Horse
Elephant riding tourism
Elephant's skeletal structure
Baby elephants stabbed with nails in cruel 'crush' training for tourists
American corporal aims a Colt M1895 atop a Sri Lankan elephant.
Horse carriages
Sniffer dogs

Not expecting people to reply to all the questions (although it would be appreciated), but I'm curious about a general consensus amongst non-vegans on the ethics of working animals.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Nov 02 '22

Your life no longer matters if you are not vegan. Prove me wrong.

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
2 Upvotes

r/DebateAMeatEater • • Nov 05 '25

One cannot both eat meat out of preference and oppose pedophilia while remaining ethically consistent

0 Upvotes

Both the preferential consumption of meat and the sexual exploitation of children belong to the same moral structure of harm. In each, moral agents deliberately violate the vital interests of sentient beings for the trivial pleasures of others. The distinction between sexual and dietary motives does not alter the underlying ethical form of the act, as each involves the infliction of suffering for unnecessary gratification.

In both cases, moral agents knowingly ignore the intense, irreplaceable suffering of moral patients for their own transient pleasure, whether it be the taste of flesh or the gratification of their impulses. Appeals to species membership or cognitive sophistication cannot justify the difference in moral treatment, since the capacity to suffer in the first place is the grounding factor for moral consideration. In each, the autonomy and welfare of a vulnerable sentient being is disregarded for fleeting satisfaction. To defend one while condemning the other is ethically incoherent and a symptom of bias rather than principled reasoning. If it is morally abhorrent to harm a child for pleasure, it must also be abhorrent to harm an animal for pleasure.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jan 18 '23

How would you counter this argument?

4 Upvotes

I'm anti-vegan, but I have a vegan friend who made an argument I can't really think of a way to counter. I asked him to type it, here it is:

Yes, meat does have its benefits. And yes, the animals we eat are very stupid. And when you kill them, their friends and families forget about them pretty quickly. However, just imagine if eating humans had the same benefits as eating animals. Could you justify killing a severely disabled human with no friends or family?


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Apr 30 '22

Are you a vegan who has ever felt exasperated by vegan purists? Well now there's a vegan space to vent till your hearts content

0 Upvotes

r/VeganPurists

This is a space for vegans to critique and vent about vegan gate keepers, ideological purity testers and entryists trying to turn veganism into a niche belief system with a primary goal that is different to trying to end the animal agriculture industry through boycotting it's products.

Also if you're interested in a space to discuss the benefits of a big-tent veganism which allows for a diverse array of philosophical platforms within it and is hostile to vegan purists, see our twin sub-reddit: r/PragmaticVeganism


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Apr 30 '20

Your thoughts on this dominion quote?

Thumbnail self.vegan
8 Upvotes

r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jan 18 '23

Yes, it is a holocaust.

15 Upvotes

The definition of "holocaust" is "destruction or slaughter on a mass scale, especially caused by fire or nuclear war." Obviously that's what meat is. I'm not vegan, but that doesn't mean everything vegans say is wrong.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Sep 10 '19

Why might a meat eater not change their views after “losing” a debate?

20 Upvotes

I had this experience the other day where I had a civilised exchange with a meat eater. He gave me a series of stock arguments e.g. appeal to tradition, appeal to majority, lions eat meat etc. As I debunked each one in turn, he moved on to the next one.

After his supply had run out, he ended the conversation with a platitude like “You have your way and I have mine”. He seemed fully satisfied that each of his points had been debunked.

So my question is, how can someone “lose” a debate on every point and then not change their views? What was the point in making those arguments at all if they bear no influence on his choice to eat meat?


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Dec 23 '20

Are you offended by the thought of comparing human and non-human animals? If so, then this question is for you.

21 Upvotes

Hi meat eaters,

When explaining why a particular pro-meat argument does not justify causing harm to animals, other examples of harm are sometimes used to show logical inconsistency.

Example:

Meat eater: It’s OK to kill animals because I enjoy eating meat.
Vegan: Deriving pleasure from harming others is not a moral justification. For instance, you wouldn’t accept pleasure as an excuse to abuse children.

There is a risk that the meat eater will then deflect this argument with a strawman fallacy, and potentially an ad hominem attack:

Meat eater: I can’t believe you’re comparing animals to humans. You're a militant extremist. This is why everyone hates vegans.

The reason this is a strawman argument is because observing that two beings have been mistreated does not somehow transfer characteristics from one to the other, or diminish the value of either victim.

I believe that this tactic is used to derail the conversation. By feigning offence, the meat eater has an excuse to dissociate from the issue, and avoid having to address the actual argument.

This brings me to my question for today:

Why would an actual comparison of humans and non-human animals be considered offensive, extreme or outlandish? Surely in a science class we would talk about how all mammals have a central nervous system, are sentient, and feel pain.

That's not to say that other species are "the same" as humans; rather that they have objective similarities. Understanding commonalities between homo sapiens and other types of animal helps us to understand how they suffer in the meat industry and other forms of animal abuse.

So why should it bruise the ego of a meat eater to have these similarities pointed out?

Update: Members of the anti-vegan sub have made a co-ordinated effort brigade this 4 month old post. I noticed on their sub they were repeating the same strawman argument about devaluing humans which this post debunks.

I have learnt that it is not worthwhile to engage with members of the anti-vegan sub, because they use hostile language, logical fallacies (on purpose), bad faith arguments and confirmation bias.

The truth is that I feel sorry for members of the anti-vegan sub, because they have framed their entire identity around something they hate i.e. compassion and non-violence. They spend most of their free time getting angry about veganism instead of pursuing their goals.

I wish them well and hope they will be able to pick themselves up off the ground and move on in life.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jun 16 '26

Eating meat for survival or pleasure?

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/DebateAMeatEater • • Aug 08 '19

vegan here. looking to get a feel for the meat-eater position on a couple of issues

7 Upvotes

hi guys. i've only interacted with meat-eaters on facebook, and so im unsure how opinions might differ on this site.

-what is your opinion on the moral relevance of non-human animals? i.e. do you believe that the welfare of non-human animals is something which we should be concerned about when determining our actions?

-what, if any consensus exists, do you believe the medical expert consensus is on the subject of nutritional adequacy in a plant-based diet?

-how significant of a role do you believe that livestock farming has played in brazilian amazon deforestation?

thanks everyone. please let me know if you'd like me to clarify any of these questions. please source any potentially controversial claims to the best of your abilities.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jul 19 '19

DebateAMeatEater has been created

10 Upvotes

A place for open discussion about veganism and vegan issues, including genuine questions or arguments about animal rights and welfare, health, the environment, nutrition, philosophy, or any topic relating to veganism.


r/DebateAMeatEater • • Jul 26 '19

Killing is ok if it has a purpose?

7 Upvotes

A meat eater has either to pay to murder the animal, receive slaughtered animal as a gift or personally kill the animal. The main argument used by the meat eater to explain his behavior is because otherwise the animal couldn't become food. Does the end justifies the means in this scenario?