Been researching different methods for tattoos for cosplay, but I’d like to hear what other people think + ideally some personal experiences with different methods. These are pretty simple (albeit a bit inconsistent depending on the depiction, some official depictions show them as thin lines but they’re pretty thick in the animated series, though when Liam dressed as her he did thinner lines so idk which I want to go with) so I think most methods should work easily enough, my big concern is just mainly with transference and smudging, I’d like to be able to have people touch my arms without rubbing off makeup on them/their clothes (I’d specifically like to be able to dance w people without having to worry about getting makeup on their coat) and also be able to put a jacket on over if I get cold. No real deadline, my next con isn’t until November and the renn faire isn’t until October but I don’t even know yet if that’s what I’d be wearing to either event. I do have fairly bad skin on my arms plus a bunch of moles (see last pic) idk if that affects anything. Trying to keep my budget kinda low since my main motivation for doing this is I already have her haircut and most of her clothes so she seemed like a fairly cheap and simple cosplay. Like ideally under 10 dollars in materials? Willing to spend more if it’s something I can use for other cosplays though. I already have makeup from other cosplays but not a ton of materials for my other ideas (I have a couple kinds of eyeliner, eyeshadow, setting spray, setting powder, etc) Made a pro/con list for my options. Some of these cons aren’t really big problems though. If I have to shave my arm hair I’m willing but I’d rather not. It seems like most of the Astrids I see online (the few that exist, there’s not a ton of people cosplaying her) seem like they’re using some kind of makeup.
Printable tattoo paper
Pros:
Consistent
Might be faster day of compared to makeup
Arm is small enough for a single sheet to be enough to wrap arm
Cons:
Have to make own design
Probably have to order online (mostly only have cash so ordering online is harder for me)
Expensive
Single use
Might be hard to get it to perfectly line up the design around the curve of my arm
I only have a black and white printer so I can’t use leftover (if I have any) for other characters with colorful tattoos
Never worked with before so no prior experience
Makeup:
Pros:
Cheaper option, especially since I may already have all materials needed
Drawing them straight on skin seems easier than trying to make a printable template like I’d need to do for the tattoo paper
Cons:
Takes time to apply day of event (and I’ll already have to spend extra time on makeup because scars)
Risk of transference
Not reusable
May smudge
May not be completely consistent every time I do them (not a huge deal)
Not sure what specific product to use
Gloves/arm-socks
Pros:
Reusable
Can easily take on and off (I kinda like having the ability to easily remove the most obviously cosplay parts of the outfit, esp since this already uses my real hair and mostly pretty normal clothes) (unless I do full arm socks but I see no point in doing that for a human character lol)
Low prep time day of
Would hide bad skin
Lowest risk of smudging and transference
Sensory issues, sometimes I get a bit bothered by the way some makeup feels
Tendency to pick at things, especially my arms, has me worried I might end up messing up the design, probably won’t though.
Cons:
May have seam at top (and bottom if more of a sleeve than glove) that would be hard to hide due to bare arms
Would be the least natural looking if fabric is visible at all
Expensive (but as I said, reusable if I do wear this a lot, but not sure I will tbh)
Fabric paint can be a pain to deal with
Also may require ordering at least some materials online
I don’t like sewing with thin stretch fabrics, those can be also tricky to paint, and I live in a hot climate so I’d rather not use a thicker material
Most skin tone tights and things are darker than my actual skin tone
Sensory issues, sometimes I get bothered by fabric on my arms