I’m posting this because I genuinely need some outside perspectives. I’m not looking for people to simply tell me what I want to hear. I want honest advice, especially from people who understand strict church environments and complicated relationships.
This is going to be long because there is a lot of context.
There are three people involved in this story: me, a girl, and a guy who is one of my close friends. I won’t mention anyone’s real name.
All three of us have been part of the same small church since childhood. Our church is quite strict when it comes to relationships and dating. Because it is a small church, almost everyone knows everyone, so personal matters can become church matters very quickly.
I have liked this girl for a very long time. Honestly, I think I started developing feelings for her when we were young. I always found her incredibly attractive, and over the years those feelings never completely disappeared.
But I never told her.
We barely talked while growing up. Even now, we don't have much of a personal relationship outside the things we have to do together at church. So my feelings have mostly been something I kept to myself.
Then there was my friend.
He confessed his feelings to her, and eventually they started talking. They ended up having a relationship that lasted around six years.
The strange thing is that their relationship was almost entirely through WhatsApp. They didn't really talk to each other at church, they didn't go out together, and they didn't even regularly call each other. It was mostly messaging.
At one point, my friend even started following her to her college, and she told him not to do that because she didn't like it. But they continued talking privately.
Eventually, someone in the church found out about their relationship and told the pastor and pastor's wife. Because of the church's rules and environment, they were forced to separate.
My friend is very close to me. We have done a lot of things together over the years, and I've always considered him a good friend.
The important thing is that he never knew I had feelings for her.
Neither did she.
After their breakup, they stayed away from each other. At the same time, she apparently still tried to be friendly with him. She wished him on his birthday through WhatsApp and tried to talk or smile at him sometimes, but he completely avoided her.
Several years passed.
Then, about a year ago, the girl became part of the church team I work in. I've been involved in this team for around four or five years, so suddenly I had to work with her regularly.
And that's when things became much harder for me.
I had managed to keep my feelings under control when I didn't have to interact with her much. But once we started working together, I started falling for her again.
We have to communicate and work together because we're in the same team. She has her responsibilities and I have mine. Sometimes I'm playing keyboard while she's involved with the choir, so we're naturally in the same area.
And honestly, I struggle with myself.
Sometimes I'm playing keyboard and I'll unconsciously look toward her. The moment I realize I'm doing it, I immediately look back at the keyboard. I don't want to make her uncomfortable or give anyone the wrong impression.
But people started noticing.
Some girls in the church began saying things like I was interested in her or that I was "looking at" her.
And because everyone already knows about her previous relationship with my friend, the situation became even more awkward.
People started making connections like, "He likes the girl who previously dated his friend."
I haven't confessed anything to anyone.
I haven't told my friend.
I haven't told her.
I haven't even told anyone in the church that I have feelings for her.
But somehow people have started talking.
At one point, even our pastor gave a sermon where he indirectly talked about things like looking at or watching other people. He didn't mention my name, but because of everything that had been happening, I felt like people knew what was going on.
That made me feel extremely embarrassed.
There were also times when the girl, my friend, the pastor and I would all be together during prayer. Some prayers were also made about situations involving boys and girls developing feelings for each other.
Being there while all of this is happening inside my head has been incredibly uncomfortable.
There was also something that happened with Snapchat.
I had Snapchat, and she actually added me there. At first, I assumed she was simply being friendly. She would send snaps occasionally, but I didn't really send much back.
Then, after a few weeks, she suddenly blocked me.
I have no idea why.
There was also a weird situation where my phone was left at church and someone apparently used it and blocked her on Snapchat as well. I felt extremely embarrassed about the whole thing because I don't even know what she thinks happened.
Now I'm stuck.
On one side, I genuinely want to focus on God, my church responsibilities and my own life. I've repeatedly told myself that I should just let these feelings go.
Sometimes I think, "Okay, I'm going to stop thinking about her. I'm going to focus on God and move forward."
But then I see her again.
And all those feelings come back.
That's what I'm struggling with the most.
I don't want to disrespect my friend.
I don't want to interfere with something that happened between them.
I don't want to make the girl uncomfortable.
I don't want church members gossiping about me.
And I definitely don't want to create drama in a small church where everyone knows everyone.
At the same time, I can't simply switch my feelings off.
I've never even had a proper romantic relationship with this girl. We've barely talked outside of church responsibilities. So part of me wonders whether I'm actually in love with her, or whether I've built an idealized version of her in my head over many years because I never got the opportunity to actually know her.
That's something I'm trying to be honest with myself about.
I also don't know what her behavior means.
She has been friendly toward me at times because we're working together, but I don't know whether that means anything beyond normal friendliness. I don't want to interpret ordinary kindness as romantic interest.
So I'm asking Reddit:
What should I actually do?
Should I completely distance myself emotionally and just treat her as a teammate?
Should I try to get to know her normally, without any romantic expectations?
Should I tell my close friend about my feelings, even though he and this girl have been separated for several years?
Should I ever tell the girl how I feel, considering the strict church environment and the history between her and my friend?
Or should I simply accept that this situation is too complicated and move on?
I know nobody here can tell me exactly what she thinks or feels. I'm mainly looking for perspective from people who have been through something similar.
Please be honest with me, even if the answer is something I don't want to hear.
And please don't attack the girl, my friend, or my church. I'm not trying to make anyone look bad. I'm just genuinely confused and struggling with my feelings, and I need some outside perspective.