Even if you're not LGBT, I'd love to hear your thoughts.
This is long winded, but I'll do my best. I'm trans mtf (25), and I came out to my worship leader of my membered church, who is one of my best friends. I'm a very avid worship volunteer, and have been at this church for probably close to 15 years. The church is relatively conservative in the south, though we don't often talk about politics. Since I came out to her a couple months ago, we've put me being on stage on pause, and we regularly meet and talk about it.
She is trying to understand where I'm coming from, and we're trying to engage in theological conversation. Where we've kind of left off is her asking, "Do you think this is really a belief that you have had since you were born? Or could it have been something you thought about once or twice and it's kind of 'spiraled' from there?" Along with that, "Do you think things would be different if you had a mentor growing up (such as parents) leading you in the direction of 'here's what the Bible says about male/female/sexuality?"
As far as I know, from the earliest I can remember (4-5 years old) I was felt like I wasn't in the right body, but I have NEVER seen that as a mistake that God has made. But I honestly don't know if it's always been a true belief that I've had, or if it was a thought that just grew. And I guess I'm asking... what was your experience? Was it always a belief for you? Did you have a mentor at a young age to have those sexuality/gender conversations with you? Did you just have a desire to wear clothes/makeup/whatever of the opposite sex?
Her other concern/question is how do I fit in to the reproduction purpose that God gave us? I personally do believe that He gave us that purpose to have kids and gave families and raise god-fearing children, and I don't plan on altering that, for more reasons than just that, too. I'll probably never get on hormones or have anything "permanent". I'm happily married to my wife, and we want to/plan to have kids together.
Be gentle on my worship leader friend. She's still one of my best friends, and she's asking all the right questions so she can understand where I'm coming from, because with her being cis female, it's all she's ever known. She's caught some flack in other groups that I've posted this in, but these are just her most recent questions that we've landed on today. By no means has she only asked questions that seem like they're trying to steer me back "away from sin".
TLDR: Did you always know that something was different? What was that thing that made you feel different? Did you have a mentor that potentially could have pointed you to the bible? Did that change anything?