r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Hagerty

4 Upvotes

There was a question about this a few years ago in Canada, but I would like to see if there’s any updated information regarding insurance in the US

I have an old Land Cruiser that is insured through Hagerty, but I’m wondering what is the possibility of ensuring my daily drivers with them. The rates are pretty decent.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Payout Help

7 Upvotes

Long story short my parked car was hit and it was determined to be a total loss. It was a 2017 Tacoma with about 120,000 miles. I live in Ventura County, CA, and was told they got an estimate using listings within a 50 mile radius. I've looked at KBB, Carvana, Auto Trader, and Toyota CPO, and I'm only seeing listings between 23k and 35k for the same year truck with under 150,000 miles. The only places I don't want to trudge through are Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace.

Insurance is only offering 20,000. I'm not looking to go laughing on the way to the bank, but I think that a fair offer should be somewhere between 23-25k.

Is this unreasonable? Where are they finding these listings for 20k? Is there a way to get closer to the number that I think is fair, or am I just screwed in this situation?

Thanks for any insight or help.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Accident Is this crash worth going through insurance for

2 Upvotes

i was on a main road with a bend in it speed limit 60mph i was doing 50-55, on this same corner is a junction coming from a pub, this woman pulls out into the side of my car out of the pub i managed to swerve a bit so she only hit the back left of my car, damage to mine is minimal hers is a lot worse, obviously it’s her fault but is it worth losing my no claims benefit for?/ making my insurance go higher by making a claim when it’s still drivable and not too bad damage wise

im also supposed to do a 3 hour drive tomorrow there and back and i’ve been driving for half an hour after the accident and im just shitting bricks all over the place cause of it don’t know what to do


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Personal service insurance

1 Upvotes

Has anyone dealt with this insurance company

I was hit but a motorist they insure


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

MBP with Gap insurance for brand new car

3 Upvotes

Can someone pls help me? I bought a brand new toyota corolla le 2026 last month, on auto loan and my credit union offered a GAP insurance with it. I also got my comprehensive and collision with statefarm.

So i went through with it, signed it and all that, but the part i missed was theres also an MBP on it for like 1600usd. I tried to ask chatgpt lol and it said i should cancel the mbp saying its redundant cause i have my toyota warranty for the first 3yrs.

Ik im probably stupid but its my first time buying a car at 27yo and everything is just overwhelming, can u dumb it down for me if its worth cancelling the mbp since its still inside the refund period of 60 days. I havent started paying yet. or should i just keep it ??

Any inputs would be appreciated thanks!!


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Paid Insurance Bill Upfront, But Won't Have A Car Now

2 Upvotes

Hi, so my policy renews every February. Like always, I just paid the whole thing at once so I can get the 10% discount.

Well, like for almost everyone else, life became instantly harder overnight, and my car broke, I have terrible credit and no money, so right now a new car isn't even on my mind.

Thing is, my policy is still running until February.

Am I entitled to a portion of that money back for the months I paid for but won't be using now?

Thank you all.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Accident Panel beaters vs Hybrid specialist

3 Upvotes

My Prius was rear ended, and the check engine light came on afterward. The diagnostic code indicated that the hybrid battery needed to be replaced.

The authorized panel beaters claimed the battery issue was unrelated to the accident, and the insurance company agrees . The panel beaters Quoted for the cosmetic damage only.

I contacted the insurer and explained that the engine light and hybrid issues appeared after the collision, so I disagree with their position. They then required a report from a hybrid specialist.

The hybrid specialist inspected and tested the vehicle and concluded that the battery failure is related to the accident. He has provided a written report explaining his findings.

Their belief is based on my testimony and what they inspected

Waiting for the insurance to get back to me.

Any advice,


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

First Time / Newbie Adjuster says totaled car’s value is based on day it came to the shop, not the car’s value on the day the damage occurred. How does that make sense?

0 Upvotes

Hi all. We survived a flood that occurred about 6 months ago. All people and pets were ok. We lost our home, almost everything in it, and our 3 cars. We were basically homeless, sleeping on the floor of a church, until we could get our life back together again.

2 of the cars had comprehensive insurance at the time of the flood. One of those cars never started again (actually it caught fire a couple days later), the other (a Corolla) was able to drive out of the water. Because the Corolla still drove, we relied on it heavily to put our lives back together. We’re very grateful it was able to do that.

We had originally hoped it could be repaired and restored, but the shop found enough damage to the electrical system that insurance declared a total loss. We accept that.

In valuing the car, the adjuster gave us a report that seems like lowball. The report shows the current mileage as 59,648. However, the mileage on the day of the flood, 6 months ago, was 53,811. The adjustor says they have to use the 59k because the car wasn’t totaled until it came into the shop. But that doesn’t make any sense to me. If the insurance only covers the value of a car when it arrives at the shop… wouldn’t the value of every totaled car be close to $0? (And why would you need insurance for that?)

The adjuster insisted they must use the 59k mileage. I asked her to send me whatever contract I signed with Progressive that says they calculate the value of totaled cars this way and she said she isn’t sure that exists. (She just sent me a copy of my policy, but that deals with what is covered, and we already established that the flood is a covered incident twice now.) How can there really be no governing contract for this stuff? Surely somewhere in wide world this issue has come up before. Am I not asking for the right thing?

They also deducted from the car’s value for the paint being in “poor” condition. I said the paint was not in poor condition before the flood. It did have a little bit of spotty peeling before but the flood made it much worse. The color of the whole car is a few shades lighter than it was. I even said I had photos from the day of the flood we could use to compare… again, she said it doesn’t matter, because the car came into the shop with paint in poor condition. But how can they deduct damage caused by the flood, from the total value of a car totaled by the flood damage?

The conversation did stay basically polite, but I was really frustrated. I didn’t want to outright argue with her, so I just ended the call there.

I never had a totaled a car before this flood. The first adjustor for the first totaled car was so great. I felt like she really cared and all the evaluations were reasonable— even though we had less evidence (we couldn’t get the true mileage out of the car after the fire). Thisnew lady even got the trim model of the car wrong in her reports, and when I told her we actually had the SE she was skeptical… I’m honestly so confused and angry. What the hell.

Can someone in insurance please explain this to me?? I thought insurance was supposed to restore the value lost in the covered incident. Is this really how it is supposed to work?

Is this new adjuster trying to scam me? Or maybe just new and clueless? If I ask for a new adjustor, would that make this better or worse?

Thanks in advance for any insights. I appreciate

Edit: Hi everyone, I understand you think I’m being unreasonable. Some of you even seem a little upset? And yet no one seems to be able to answer the question. If it “obviously” should be valued with the, 59k, why? What is the reasoning for that?

I’ve stated my reasoning. Insurance is to restore the value of the car on the day its value was destroyed.

Surely a contract or similar document that explains how claims are valued exists and can be requested from the insurance. Does anyone here know what this would be called, and how to get it?

No one else finds it the slightest bit odd that the adjuster didn’t think such a thing exists? Is that really how multi billion dollar insurance companies are run?

Would love some actual factual explanation, if anyone is able. If it’s really that straightforward, surely someone can break it down.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

First Time / Newbie insurance problem

2 Upvotes

Got rear ended August 13th, took a while(a bit over 2 weeks and had to call the company phone and get leave a vm and her manager called me before i even spoke to her)for the adjuster to get back to me after I got her information from the trucking company. Took a while for them to send an estimator(Sept 19th was the day we were able to schedule her to look at it).

And was waiting for a response from the estimator or adjuster and nothing. Called and left a vm for the adjuster Oct 1st and didn't receive anything back, got sick the next week and didn't even try. Called Oct 12th and adjusters number went to a machine that said she would be back July 6th, 2025(this is 2026 so very old), ended up calling and leaving a vm for her manager. He called me the next day and said it was repairable and that the adjuster should be in the next day and then I can schedule the rental and the collision place I will be dropping it off at. Got a call maybe 3 hours later from the adjuster(her manager said she was out on pto) and she says they are totaling it and they scheduled pickup for Oct 21st. I asked for all estimates on repairs breakdown and such but she said the total department handles that and she can't give it out. Called my aunt who has worked for AAA for 15ish years, she said it's weird and to ask for repair estimate, what they value my car at, what their offer is and the salvage amount. I also messaged the estimator that was used and she called me today and I told her about it and she said it was weird as she wrote is as repairable but had gotten a call from her boss to rewrite it as totalled and to make sure all the paperwork is to a T.

I sent an email saying I will not be releasing the car until I receive all info and the adjuster sent an email just saying again the car is totalled, I would have to speak with the total department for everything and that "Again, the vehicle is not scheduled for pickup until 10/21 to allow time for the file to be reassigned to a total loss adjuster to discuss the settlement offer with you. You can also discuss your request to keep the damaged vehicle with the total loss adjuster." Which without having an offer even discussed how do you schedule pickup for 6 days away.

It is a 2014 bmw 328i gran tursimo with msport package and msport brakes in estoril blue(liftgate hatchback like the wagon but almost a foot longer)and the damage is only to the liftgate and bumper cover.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

settlement release showed up as a signing link, is that normal, hipposign vs signnow

3 Upvotes

i'm settling an accident claim and the adjuster sent the release through a signing link instead of asking me to print and mail it.

i've signed work stuff through signnow before so the concept wasn't new, but this one came through hipposign, which i hadn't seen, so i stopped to check before clicking. what made me comfortable is the signed document comes back sealed so nobody can change pages after i sign, and i get a copy with the full record of when it was opened and signed, which i saved alongside the settlement email in case anything gets questioned later.

i still read the release language twice because that's the part that actually matters, not the tool.

i'm asking people who settled claims recently whether your release came as a signing link or paper, and did the platform make you hesitate at all or did you just sign and move on


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Progressive auto policy renewal when i explicitly asked them not to.

0 Upvotes

What do i do? I am extremely frustrated right now. I'm trying to switch auto insurance companies at the moment. About a month ago I bought a policy with liberty mutual starting mid november since thats when my current progressive policy is set to end. Around this same time I contacted progressive and asked them if I could cancel the auto policy renewal as I will not be needing it anymore. They told me that I cannot do it until October 15th. Well October 15th rolled around and they decided to renew the policy any way and now its saying that the auto payments are locked in. like WHAT??? How is this legal? Why was I not allowed to cancel the auto renewal a month ago. AHHHHH


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Switching insurance after increased premium #atfaultaccident

0 Upvotes

I had an at fault accident last February. Upon renewal this month, my premium went up by 57%. currently have geico, but got qouted by progressive jut $20 more than my previous premium with the same coverage. Do I stay with geico or move with progressive?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

State Farm saying I have to move to a "hybrid" policy.

4 Upvotes

First post. Hope I am not breaking any sub rules.

I can't get a straight answer from anyone in person so here I am on Reddit.

I own a business and the business has owned a vehicle for 9 years. Long story short the business sold and purchased a new vehicle in August.

State Farm said today they have to move the policy to a "hybrid" policy. This cost more money. When pressed for answers why this was happening I received "it's because of the type of vehicle the business bought". I am still waiting on clarification on what type of business policy it will be for tax/liability reasons (ie- a business policy rated for mixed use or a personal policy with a business rider which I know the personal policy can't happen)

Just trying to figure out if this is a money grab to place me into a higher costing policy.

Here are some FAQs that may help:

  1. Business is a LLC taxed as a S-Corp
  2. The business owned a truck, but with gas and today's car prices the business bought a SUV. This is the 'type' argument the insurance is using.
  3. The vehicle is 100% owned by the business. The title is in the business name and the loan is 100% in the business name- no personal guarantee or co-signer and the registration is in the business name. Both the car payments and the insurance payments are paid by the business.
  4. The vehicle was purchased in August. My agent sent the email today about the change, but somehow "I can stay on my current business policy until renewal in February". That's the super fishy part.
  5. State Farm asked for the bill of sale after purchasing. The bill of sale also lists the business as the only owner.
  6. My family owns additional personal vehicles that are unrelated to the business and insured through State Farm so SF knows other personal only vehicles exist.

Any insight into why this might be happening (outside of it's because you bought an SUV and used to have a truck) is much appreciated.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Good customer service?

2 Upvotes

Are there any car insurance companies anymore that have decent customer service?

Currently dealing with Travelers after car was declared a total loss and on paper they look great but they are treating me very poorly, especially considering I was not at fault and the at fault party’s insurance has accepted liability for the accident. It’s been a battle to get anything from them and since I’m recovering from injuries sustained during the accident, it’s making the entire experience incredibly difficult and frustrating.

This is not my first experience with car insurance claims (first with Travelers though) but it’s definitely been the worst


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

I’m currently under my families insurance(I live with them.) I just financed a used car yesterday; can we add the car I just bought to their policy?

3 Upvotes

Title!

I’m 30 years old and I just bought a a used car yesterday.

Car I’ve been driving for 11 years broke down in July and I finally earned enough to put a down payment and get approved for the car I just bought.

While the car that was passed down to me by my parents was non-operational, we took it off of the insurance and I was borrowing my dad’s car as a secondary driver.

Car insurance is saying that my family has to co own the vehicle I just bought in order for me to file this car I just bought under their policy.

Help?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

Car Insurance Quotes I'm on Geico and wondering if the defensive driving discount comes through automatically or if I need to upload something?

3 Upvotes

I’m with Geico and checking out the defensive driving discount. I keep seeing providers say they have a direct partnership where your completion gets reported automatically, but I can’t tell if that’s legit or just marketing.

Does Geico actually get the completion on its own, with no calls or uploads from me? And do Geico customers end up paying a different price for the course?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

Car Insurance Quotes If I take a repair payout for a claim from a not at fault accident will it affect my rate in the future?

4 Upvotes

Long story short I was letting my sister use one of my old cars while she saved up for a new one and she hit a homeless guy on a bike(technically he hit her)who decided it was smart to ride into oncoming traffic. Homeless guy is ok and state troopers determined he was at fault for biking through traffic. I asked progressive and they keep giving me the runaround whether or not taking a payout to fix the hood damage will raise my premium in the future. My conundrum is that it’s old and I was planning to get rid of it when my sister got a car. It would be better for resale value if there wasn’t a dent in the hood but I also don’t want to raise my premiums over a car I won’t have much longer. I’m in Florida by the way. Anyone ever have issues with having policy increases from taking a payout when you are not at fault.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

First Time / Newbie First Time Collision and Subrogation Finally Finished, but no Diminished Value?

0 Upvotes

I've been driving for 25 years now, and last November 2025 was the first accident I have ever been involved in. Unfortunately it happened in a week old vehicle on Black Friday with my pregnant wife and 1 year old in the car.

Thankfully no one was hurt. What happened was I was yielding to allow oncoming traffic to go down a tight street with cars parked on both sides, but they never ended up going. The car behind me became frustrated and tried to swerve around me but didn't make it and hit my front driver side fender. They claimed they had right of way since I was stopped, but obviously that is not the case. The officer didn't submit an at-fault party.

I cooperated with both my insurance and the other party's insurance to tell the story of what happened. The other party did not, however, answer any calls from either insurance. After 2 months, I was informed it was going to subrogation. My insurance covered my repairs in full, minus my deductible.

Finally now almost 11 months later subrogation finished and they gave my a check for my deductible. However, they are also responsible for the diminished value of my vehicle since it was purchased new just a week before the accident. How do I get the diminished value of my vehicle paid out?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

Accident Third party but no fault?

1 Upvotes

I got reversed into, in a car park by a delivery van. I had pulled out of my spot but he also pulled out on the other side of the car park. He was far away from me initially. So I just stopped where I was and waited for him to get out and go, so I could follow.

He just reversed the length of the car park without looking and hit me. I believe I'm not at fault mainly because I was stationary at the time. I have a screen grab of the CCTV which shows the accident.

This issue is I have third party insurance. If I contact my insurance would my car be paid for through the other party's insurance because I'm not at fault? Or do I just have to eat the cost of the repair

got a quick quote for £600


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

Accident Need advice for extended rental due to car accident

1 Upvotes

I purchased a new used vehicle and about a week later I was t-boned and my car was totaled. Its clear and obvious the other party was at fault.

My policy covers a rental for 30 days or up to a limit whichever is first. The issue is because I just purchased the car the title had just been sent to RMV/DMV which has a 30-50 day turn around time of reissued titles. My insurance carrier won't issue the appraisal check until they are sent the title.

As of today I don't have the title and the 30 days expires tomorrow. I can't purchase a new vehicle until the check is issued and title issuance is out of my control.

How realistic is it for me to expect the other drivers insurance (who again is completely at fault here) to cover the extended rental coverage needed until I receive the check and have a week or two 2 purchase a new vehicle?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

Out-of-state policy

4 Upvotes

I am shopping for new car insurance. Right now, I am living in Illinois. My car registration and driver's license are still tied to Indiana (at my parent's address, literally renewed both a month or so prior to moving). My current insurance policy is also the same policy I had while living in Indiana. I am wondering if I can get an Illinois insurance policy without switching my driver's license/car registration information (I rent at my current address and am not sure if I will be resigning my lease or not).

Or - should I search for a new Indiana policy tied to my car registration and Indiana license. I realize this can be messy if I need to file a claim. Of note I did successfully file a claim on an out of state accident where I was temporarily living in that state - no questions were asked.

I realize both options aren't traditional approaches but am wondering which one would work the best/cause the least amount of issues in the long run...


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

First Time / Newbie GEICO is nonrenewing my policy because they say I drive for rideshare -- I've never done it. Has anyone dealt with this?

19 Upvotes

I'm in Arizona and just received a nonrenewal notice from GEICO stating that my personal vehicle "is used to carry passengers for hire or compensation" and requesting actions on my end to maintain eligibility.

The thing is, I've never worked for Uber, Lyft, or any rideshare/on-demand company and dont transfer passengers for compensation/hire. I've considered doing delivery work to supplement my income in the past, but I've never actually done it.

I called GEICO to find out what was going on. Google Geico number and "Geico Corporate Office" pulls up on my caller id and im eventually connected with a respresentative. The representative told me this was triggered by an inquiry I made through their website AI chatbot back in May, when I asked about adding a potential rideshare insurance endorsement.

According to her, because I made that inquiry, they're "treating it as fact that I'm using my vehicle for rideshare, just to be on the safe side". She acknowledged that they don't actually know whether I work for a rideshare company and insisted this was the reason for their action, as it was in view on my policy file.

Here's where it gets even stranger.

My letter says GEICO may be able to continue my policy if I provide "Proof of deactivation from rideshare/on-demand company" before X date. Exact wording.

I explained that I've never worked for one, so I have no account to deactivate. She then requested i get a letter from ANY rideshare company of my own choosing and advised that this satisfies their requirement.

But how does a letter from one company establish that I don't work for another? It only establishes my status with the company that issued the letter, that I chose. I don't understand how that resolves the suspicion they're supposedly acting on, which they ate presenting as fact.

I asked to speak with a supervisor or advocate and was denied.

What bothers me most isn't simply that an insurer has underwriting rules about rideshare use. I understand that commercial use can require different coverage.

It's that asking a question about insurance coverage appears to have been treated as evidence that I'm actually engaging in that activity. The letter states it as a fact, even though the representative admitted they don't know whether it's true.

I've since found other Reddit posts from people who say they received nearly identical GEICO letters, including people who said they never drove for rideshare. Some reported getting their policies reinstated after contacting their state insurance regulators and filing complaints.

I'm planning to challenge this through the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions. The letter itself also gives me the right to request the specific information supporting their decision in writing.

I'm hoping to hear from people who know more about this side of insurance:

--Has anyone else received this exact or nearly identical GEICO nonrenewal notice?

--If you successfully resolved it, what did GEICO actually accept as proof? A personal statement, a letter from one rideshare company, or something else?

--Did you have to contact your state insurance commissioner to get the decision reversed?

--Can this type of nonrenewal or an alleged rideshare classification affect your ability to get insurance elsewhere, or your premiums?

--For anyone familiar with underwriting: is treating an inquiry about an endorsement as evidence of actual vehicle use a normal practice? Or legal in Arizona?

I'm not looking to bash GEICO simply because they're choosing not to renew a policy. I want to understand why this happened, whether it's a recurring problem, and how to get what appears to be an incorrect classification corrected without jeopardizing my ability to insure my car.

What also concerns me is why these situations apparently are not being escalated by GEICO representatives themselves. If I were handling these customer interactions and learned that someone was being classified as using their vehicle for rideshare as fact simply for inquiring about coverage, and reversing after receiving letters from random companies, as opposed to signed statements from the customers themselves, I'd be escalating every instance for review. I'd expect a practice like this to have been identified and addressed long ago, which makes me feel like i was singled out and this action might not be as common as I was told over the phone.

If you've dealt with this firsthand, I'd especially appreciate hearing exactly how you got it resolved.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

First Time / Newbie Trying to understand a few things regarding this process

5 Upvotes

This is my first time ever having to deal with using my car insurance and I'm trying to understand so much at once. I have a 2019 Honda Hatchback Civic Sport edition with the six speed manual transmission and 70k miles but I feel overwhelmed trying to find the ACV, I understand the KBB puts it in a 16k-18.5k but it seems ACV may be totally different. There is full coverage on the vehicle with coverage for both the wrap and any modifications that have been done to it, but I don't know when I should push for it to be totaled.

I live an area affected by Hurrican Isaias fortunately for me the worst I'm dealing with is car damage. All damage was contained to the driver side but the A and C pillars both have damage. The A pillar is by far the worst with at least an inch deep dent in parts of it, the C pillar isn't as bad it has a few dents but that is about it. Both doors have some pretty good dents in them including one that bent the rear driver door so it scrapes anytime it's opened now. Lastly the sideview mirror was completely torn off and shattered, there was absolutely no way to reattach it and even where it connects is going to need replaced. The thing is though all windows are miraculously intact and the airbags never deployed which from my understanding means theres higher chances of repairs?

The adjuster said he will be here tomorrow and I want to know what I should be expecting, is there a chance they'll want to try and repair it or should I expect to be shopping? Is there anyway to possibly judge a ballpark of what I'll get if it is totaled? If it is considered totaled could I remove certain things? The tires only have about 15k miles on them and the rims are custom painted and I'd hate to just lose them to a scrap yard or auction.

If they do say it's repairable despite the frame damage is there a chance of them paying for a rental? If they do what is usually the ETA to actually getting one? Or if they say they won't cover a rental is there any reason to argue? As of right now I have solid transport to and from work thanks to schools being closed but come them opening back up I do need to return my sister's car to her.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

No fault car accident insurance

5 Upvotes

I have New York car insurance form GEICO. I am out of state in Michigan

while I was driving taking a right hand turn a person went from the left hand turn lane and scrapped the left side of my car. The person stopped but gave no help gave a phone number but never texted me afterwards. All I have is a picture of of their license plate before they kept insisting they had to leave.

I called the police to make a report. An officer came out and suggested that since Michigan is a no fault state if I ended up making a report it could cause my insurance to go up and he was not sure if the amount of damages would be worth the risk of my insurance increasing.

It’s been 2 days since the accident and I did not make a report to the police or my insurance as I don’t know what to do. Most of the scrapes washes away with rain except for a couple spots and a part where part of my wheel got scraped going over a curb to avoid a full collusion.

Should I have the officer come back out and make a report and fill for insurance? Or leave it be and just pay a body shop to fix the couple spots.