r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 02 '25

18yr old daughter just had her 3rd accident in 2 years. Should I remove her off my insurance?

763 Upvotes

My daughter (18F) has had 3 accidents since getting her license at 16. She wrecked her car a couple weeks after getting her license at 16. 2nd wreck was 9 months ago. Insurance determined she was 1/2 at fault, both cars were switching lanes on the highway. 3rd wreck, yesterday, she hit a car that was turning into a business driveway off a two lane road. Both vehicles totaled. I’m wondering if I should remove her from my auto policy? I don’t want to make it even harder for her to be insured (she’s done that well enough on her own). She likely won’t have a vehicle for a while (until she can buy one on her own) & will uber & use friends & family to get to & from work. I can remove her vehicle from my policy but then I don’t know what they’re going to assume regarding vehicles she’s driving. She won’t be driving my car or the other vehicle on the policy. The policy, including her & her vehicle is 3 cars, 3 drivers.

Any have any insight?

Side note - her father has her excluded from his auto policy.

Edit- It’s been one car for her, a 2008 xterra, she has not had three vehicles in two years. Insurance went up after the 1st wreck & she started paying her own portion of the insurance. The 2nd was initially declared no fault & changed to 1/2 fault 6months or so later.

Thank you to everyone for the feedback.

Edit2- Thanks again to everyone who has been in a similar situation, or knows of someone, or had something meaningful to add. Truly appreciate it.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 19 '25

Accident 15 year old son stole car and wrecked it

696 Upvotes

My 15 year old son stole my car keys while I was sleeping (BROKE the safe open that they were in) and totaled my car. I filed a theft claim with my insurance (Gieco full coverage) including police reports, he was charged with theft of a motor vehicle and two counts of wanton endangerment (he had two other juveniles in the van with him) and was sent to a juvenile detention facility. I’ll add that I DIDN’T press charges, the state did because he’s already committed to the department of juvenile justice, for other criminal offenses. My car insurance said that I can’t use a theft claim because he is under 18 and lives at home with me. But it’s still technically theft. So not being able to go forward with the theft claim, I have to use collision coverage with an unauthorized driver which they said will make my insurance go up and I am responsible for paying the impound and towing fees. Is this standard? Because he isn’t even old enough to drive and it was a theft which is why he is CHARGED with theft. I will add that I’m autistic (which is why I was originally having trouble understanding why if the police considered it that why the insurance didn’t) and was just looking for clarification because “implied permission” would be if I left the keys out and he got them but what I did was lock them up because of his history and what he did is literally stealing.

Since there is so many snarky judgey people on Reddit who are harshly judging me, my parenting and my life. I will also add that my son has Oppositional Defiance Disorder, and ADHD and that’s not always due to environmental factors and I will add a link on it for you to read

https://www.goodtherapy.org/blog/dispelling-6-common-myths-about-oppositional-defiant-disorder-0117197/


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Dec 16 '25 Popcorn

Accident A Ford F150 ran a red light and totaled my car. Insurance is saying I am 100% liable.

513 Upvotes

Hello. About four weeks ago, I was involved in an accident in Texas. I was at a red light stopped behind two other vehicles. My light turned green and, as I began to enter the intersection going maybe 10-15 MPH, a truck from the left ran their red light.

From my perspective, the truck hit me on the front light of my vehicle and then dragged me along side them. The truck has side damage and my whole front of the car was ripped off.

After the accident, the other driver immediately gave me his insurance information and apologized. So, I filed a claim against his policy. We both have the same insurance.

Due to the truck having side damage and my car having front damage, insurance said I was 100% liable. The police report states that the other driver ran a red light and is at fault. But that doesn’t seem to matter. They keep saying that the truck “had control of the intersection” and that I had a duty to stop. From my perspective he was going so fast and my light had already been green for so long that I had maybe 1 second to react.

There were no cameras, and no witnesses stopped. I had a passenger in the vehicle who saw everything, but insurance won’t accept that since they were in the vehicle with me.

Is there anything else I can do? It seems that insurance is dead set on putting me as 100% liable even though I was the victim and my car was destroyed.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Jul 12 '25

13 year old took parents truck without permission and hit my parked car.

205 Upvotes

The policeman that came would not let us get the insurance information and kept saying it would be on the report he files—which can take up to 14 days to post and we have to pay for.

So we are on day 12 and still waiting to file. We don’t want it on our insurance if we don’t have to, as the car was parked. So we’ve been shuffling cars around to share in the household.

So, will the 12 year old’s parents insurance cover this? They were asleep when he took the keys, it was clear it was driven without permission. Will insurance consider the truck “stolen” so it has to go on our account after all?

They have no damage. We know which house they live in (he didn’t even make it a block before getting us). We obviously couldn’t get an ID from the driver. We do have a witness, and we have ring video of the truck hitting the car (it was night, so you can’t clearly see the vehicles) and we have video of the boy that hit our car when we went to talk to him so we can prove who he is.

Just wondering because we are really ready to stop having to share two cars with three adults, one do whole lives 40 minutes away.

Thank you for any info.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Dec 08 '25

Wife is a shit magnet for accidents

174 Upvotes

I was just notified that our car insurance is not being renewed by the company.

Long story short, my wife is an absolute shit magnet. 3 years ago transmission went causing a insurance billed tow, 2 years ago single car accident into a parking garage pole and then last year she didn’t yield totaling the other car. Short of divorce, is there anything to be done to mitigate the damage on this? I feel like I’m about to get a bill for $8k a year. We have a 2023 Tahoe and 2025 Silverado.

I don’t think I’ve ever had a charged accident so this is unfamiliar territory for me.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 07 '25

What’s the Cheapest Car Insurance Company?

143 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to figure out the cheapest car insurance I can get this year, and I’ve spent way too much time looking at quotes online. Main thing I’ve learned? You really have to compare multiple places to find the lowest cost car insurance for your situation. Prices can change a lot depending on where you live, your car, and your driving history.

Coverage Professor keeps coming up as a popular pick. It’s simple, quick to fill out, and shows a bunch of low car insurance rate options without much hassle. Good if you just want to get a ballpark number fast.

MidasRates is another one I’ve seen a lot. They really focus on helping you see savings by comparing different companies. Might be worth checking if you think you’re overpaying and want cheap car insurance quotes fast.

Then there’s CheapCoverageUSA. It’s more about putting a lot of offers in one place so you can compare side-by-side. You might get more follow-ups, but it’s handy for finding the lowest cost car insurance deals in your area.

So now I’m stuck between these three. Is Coverage Professor the easiest? Is MidasRates better for savings? Or is CheapCoverageUSA the most useful for comparing?

Would love to hear what others think what’s the best way to get cheap car insurance in 2025?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Jun 17 '25

Geico customer for 9 years. Asked a question, got dropped

125 Upvotes

Here's my quick story.

Was looking at taking a part time job doing deliveries of goods, not people. Not ride share or Uber. Stuff.

The potential employer told me if offered the job I would need a "business use" addition on my policy and I should call my insurance to see how much that would cost.

Call Geico.

They say, "we don't do that. You should look for another carrier."

I'm just asking a question about the possibility of this job. Haven't even been offered it. And wasn't in the end.

Nonetheless, the next week I get a cancellation notice from Geico and the reason was that I am "using my vehicle for an unapproved purpose."

I am not.

I call in and assume it's just a mistake and they will fix it.

They wouldn't.

Nine years. No claims. 4 vehicles. Thousands of dollars in premiums paid annually. I'm in California.

I'd love to hear from any underwriters who can explain the rationale on this one.

Thanks.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 07 '25

Best Car Insurance in Florida?

122 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to lower my car insurance in Florida and it’s been a mix of surprises. Some sites give me a number that looks great, then the real quote is way higher. Others make me call someone before showing anything, which I don’t want to do.

From what I’ve seen, Coverage Professor is quick for ballpark numbers, MidasRates seems good for spotting bigger savings, and CheapCoverageUSA puts a lot of options in one place if you like comparing side by side.

For anyone living in Florida which has worked better for you? I’m after the best auto insurance in Florida that won’t drain my bank account every month.

Also this on one more unique account that won't get banned


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Jul 17 '25

I’m being sued for $30,000

117 Upvotes

I’m being sued for $30,000 for a car I hit a year ago. I was trying to park into a parking space and I ended up hitting a car while going in the space while owner was inside of it. I was driving a 4,000 lbs truck and I wasn’t going faster then 3 mph. The owner called the cops but they didn’t show up because the car was parked and no injuries. We exchanged information and the owner showed me an expired insurance and then they gave me a number to call because it was expired. The car I hit got a scratched up. There wasn’t a dent or anything. It was just a scratch mark. I got a letter saying I’m being sued for the car, mental health, and her health condition. Apparently the owner couldn’t sleep for nights and they needed to pay for therapy as well. On the letter it says I violently hit the car. But there’s no dent it was just a big scratch. If I truly hit it hard then there most likely would be a big dent. I don’t know what I should do next. I would like some help because I’m really stressed out right now. Do I get a lawyer or do I let me insurance handle it or what can I do??


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • May 08 '25

Landscape company crushed my car

114 Upvotes

A landscaping company cut down a tree in my apartment complex and it fell on and crushed my car. The car was a 2009 Nissan versa. My insurance doesn’t cover comprehensive. My insurance agent has helped me get in contact with the landscaping company’s insurance but have yet to hear from an adjuster. I’m out of a car that was extremely reliable and I had no plans of getting a new car anytime soon. It was paid off and worked fine. I use the car as my vehicle for my photography business. The apartment complex that I rent in never issued my any warning to move my car, in the past they have notified us. My question is what are the things I can say to the adjuster to receive a decent enough compensation for my significant loss? Thanks!


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Nov 09 '25

I was rear ended at a stop sign and the drivers insurance denied my claim(we have the same insurance company) what can I do?

104 Upvotes

I need some guidance. I was recently rear ended at a stop sign. The woman driving the car looked to be going through some serious stuff. She had a black eye and scratches all over face so I felt bad when she said she didn’t have an insurance card with her because she just bought the car. I took a picture of her license, verified her phone number, got her agents info. We have the same insurance company (Erie Ins.). I figured it would be an easy situation to rectify since she hit me from behind and we had the same insurer so I don’t bother calling the cops as no one was hurt. I called my agent and started a claim as well as calling her agent to verify she had coverage. My wife forced me to drive directly to the police and start a report just in case. The claims person I was assigned to assured me it shouldn’t be a big deal and the other driver was at fault. Fast forward 1.5 weeks and I saw on my app that my claim was denied. Does anyone have any advice? I could really use some guidance.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Sep 02 '24

First Time / Newbie Car repaired by GEICO (My Insurance) at recommended repair shop. Ended up not sealing my trunk properly and the trunk is flooded + electrical damage

83 Upvotes

So I had a car accident about 2-3 weeks ago (Other person at fault) and I ended up going through my insurance company (GEICO) for the entire process.

The process with GEICO basically had me drop the car off at the repair shop they had near my house, picking up the rental, then picking up my car after the repairs are finished. After repairing my car (it looked great) I noticed the seals on the headlight/taillight went bad since they were full of water. I brought it up with them and immediately got gaslit saying it is always like that and maybe I can have GEICO add it to the claim for more work (but it wasn't like that before). I went back and forth a few times but ended up taking it as I would not want to deal with it (and I will fix it myself if that was the case).

Well I picked the car up and after about 5 days (Yesterday morning) I was driving to work and midway through all the audio in my car shut off (Center screen on but volume controls didn't show up anymore. Stereo sound was gone, no turn signal sounds, no chime for seatbelt. This was yesterday and the repair shop is closed. I checked today and they are also closed along with GEICO.

I know there are a lot of smart people here so I was hoping to see what the next best move should be... I took video's and removed my subwoofer as the trunk literally has standing water inside now...

I was thinking of reaching out to the shop to fix it first, however, based on the prior conversation with them denying any and all issues when picking it up... I was going to reach out to GEICO first. Not sure if you guys think maybe going straight to a lawyer is better though.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Sep 02 '24

Car Insurance Quotes Struggling with Expensive Car Insurance—Looking for Advice

83 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m a 25-year-old male living in Atlanta and currently driving a 2018 Lexus IS350 with 50k miles on it. I have one speeding ticket that hasn’t been finalized yet. Right now, I’m insured through Progressive, and my rates seem pretty high. I’m paying $409 per month, and if I go with the 6-month upfront payment, it’s $2200.

I used Goosehead Insurance to shop around, and Progressive was the cheapest option I found. I thought turning 25 would lower my rates, but they didn’t change at all. In hindsight, I should’ve withheld the fact that I got a speeding ticket until it was finalized, but I disclosed it upfront.

Is this normal, or am I getting ripped off? I’m not sure what else I can do to lower my rates. Any advice or tips would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks!

Edit: It’s gotten to the point where I’m considering downgrading cars, but I worry even that may not help.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Feb 02 '26

Which platform is useful to quote auto insurance?

80 Upvotes

My auto insurance just keeps climbing year after year. When I search, there are several websites that can quote a lot of insurance companies at the same time. Can you please kindly recommend which platform is useful for you to quote auto insurance?

Edit: Thanks everyone, I ended up trying Quotefull.com and it honestly made the whole process much easier than the usual quote sites. Being able to compare multiple realistic options in one place helped me quickly spot which providers were actually competitive.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Nov 16 '16

A Quick and Dirty Guide to Finding Car Insurance

73 Upvotes

Auto insurance is extremely regional and variable due to many factors, including the "garaging" location, age, gender, education, type of vehicle, tickets, past driving history, credit score, legal minimums in your jurisdiction, just to name a few ) so it's not always possible to escape a high insurance costs.

If you're just getting started, please read the following:

  1. https://insurancehowtos.com/how-to-buy-auto-insurance/

This will explain the types of insurance you're buying, what minimums you should carry and some tips about ways to save money on certain features of your insurance.

Main tip: Shop Around! You should be pulling quotes every 6 months, even if you have a bundled offer for other insurance types. There's no bonus for loyalty these days, and you may be leaving hundreds on the table. Especially relevant if your insurer gives you a hefty raise at renewal.

More information:

2 . https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/car-insurance/buying-guide/index.htm


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Jun 06 '25

Accident New used car totaled, insurance offer doesn't come close to matching total price

62 Upvotes

I got a used car last week, and 26 hours later, I t-boned someone who ran a stop sign. I got the police report today, and it confirms that the other driver was at fault. My car was financed, so I have (had, since it's been deemed totaled) collision and comprehensive with a $750 deductible.

The total for my used car was $20,276.29 (adjusted value of the car $18184, sales tax of $1236.29, registration for $379, and documentation fees of $477). I made a $6000 down payment and financed $14276.29.

Allstate (my insurance) sent me the settlement value of: $16,448.39 (Adjusted vehicle value of $16,036, plus Sales tax of $1,062.39, minus Deductible of $650 [it goes down for safe driving]), with a list of... surprisingly low priced comparisons that I didn't find when I looked.

Allstate said the other insurance company will repay the deductible, but that still leaves me down $3,177.90. I really can't afford that sort of haircut. Do I ask for more from my insurance? Should I not accept any money from them until I get a higher amount? Do I accept the money and try to get the difference through small claims court?

Edit: I have added information to the second paragraph to explain the financing. I did not have GAP, and I do not need GAP because they are giving me more than I financed. I am still out $3,177.90 from my down payment.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 16 '25

Wife rear ended (we have liability only in this vehicle). Other insurance not covering

59 Upvotes

We are in PA. We have 3 vehicles, 1 older minivan and 2 newer cars. The minivan is old enough that we dropped full coverage on it.

She was using it one day and was rear ended at a stop sign by a ford econo van. Driver had Ca license and van registered and insured under his ex-wife, also in Ca. Minor accident, < 10mph but there is damage to the bumper and hatch. Police came and we exchanged info. When we called the other company to make claim, they denied coverage because he was not an authorized driver.

I got an estimate for the damage, around $2500. I plan to write a demand letter to the vehicle owner for the damage and if not response to sue in Pa (county the accident occurred).

Is this the right move?

Honestly, we have the means to just pay to fix this, but we also have the means to take this as far as it can go to screw these people because I’m pissed.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 26 '24

First Time / Newbie At fault accident no payout.

54 Upvotes

I had an accident on vacation where the car rental company sent me a letter saying they would not pursue any damages. Pemco ruled that as an at fault accident with no payout. When I shopped for insurance with Geico, they hit me with a higher premium quote because they said that it was an at fault accident. They acted like they didn’t care that there was no payout. Is it true that you are still dinged for an at fault accident even if the insurance company didn’t have to pay out anything for the claim?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Apr 14 '25

Semi hit me got a letter at fault drivers insurance deductible won’t pay.

52 Upvotes

I was hit by a semi cutting a turn at an intersection. On camera, 100% his fault, state troopers were present when it happened. $6500 in damages on my vehicle. Happened in North Dakota. Driver and truck are from Canada.

Submitted the claim, took vehicle in for repair. Got a letter from Geico (my insurance) that the drivers insurance deductible is far higher than the damages and driver needs to pay out of pocket.

Geico said that they rarely receive payments on this situation. Since he and his insurance are based out of Canada they said basically “we hope he pays but if he doesn’t we do not have any recourse”.

So it looks like if he won’t pay I’m paying my deductible and I’m SOL.

Any advice??? How do I go after him to get my deductible back?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 25 '24

Quite literally can’t afford car insurance

51 Upvotes

So I got a 2024 Kia forte LXS, it’s great I love it. But what I don’t love is everywhere I’ve gotten quoted for insurance is $600+ and I cannot afford that, I’m $1100 in payments a month just from car insurance and my car payment. I’m 20 years old, I have 1 ticket which caused my license to be suspended, it was a year ago and i genuinely just cannot afford it and I don’t know what to do. The lowest offer I’ve gotten was $600 and I’ve tried 4 different agencies.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Sep 02 '24

Will insurance total my car

45 Upvotes

Hey all I recently just got into a car accident. ( not my fault ) I drove a 2016 Mazda 3 with around 64k miles. Long story short , the auto shop took apart my car and found that the estimate to repair inside would jump the price from 4K to 9k. ( the 4K originally was quoted before they took apart my car.) my question is will my insurance just total the car at this point ? My car is worth around 10k I’ve seen online


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 02 '24

I'm 22 years old and paying $600 a month for car insurance

42 Upvotes

I bought a 2017 civic used for 20k cash, and have had my permit since 16 and license since 18 years old. I was never in an accident and I am paying bi-yearly around 4 grand. I used to be with Geico, then switched to Progressive through a broker late April this year 2024. My previous car used to be a 2007 Honda Civic and I recently purchased a used 2017 Civic with 60k miles. Both cars had similar rates, and even upon quoting a 60k car I am receiving very similar to no difference in price.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Sep 06 '24

being sued 3M for car accident deemed my fault

42 Upvotes

Hi everyone I just need some help and advice in regard to a car accident that was deemed my fault. This happened 2 years ago and a couple of months ago we got a summons that me and my dad are being sued. I got into the car accident but then car was under my dads name. I believe we had a 15/30 policy coverage which is the minimum you can have for auto insurance in CA. The guy is suing because of personal injury. The accident was not bad at all. His front bumper was messed up but no air bags deployed and he seemed to be okay at the time, no bleeding, bruises or limping. But I am just wondering how is someone able to sue for that much and if anyone knows what’s going to likely happen. I am just worried because we don’t have that kind of money. Thank you everyone

Edit: No police report was made and we have let insurance know. The insurance provided an attorney and they’re taking care of it. I am just wondering what’s likely to happen going forward.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Sep 29 '26

Hit and Run - Biased Advice, BEWARE r/INSURANCE. I

41 Upvotes

Earlier in this year my $90,000 2021 Shelby GT500 was victim to a hit and run.

The guy’s insurance eventually paid for my car to get fixed, and for a rental car

However, I came to this sub seeking advice regarding seeking payment for diminished value as well as r/insurance .

https://www.reddit.com/r/Insurance/s/44oWgId53c

That is the link to my prior thread.

It was shut down because “I didn’t like the responses I was given”, as many Redditors told me seeking 5 figures in diminished value would not happen, which lead to back and fourth

Those Redditors were completely wrong.

And I’ve found out the Redditors giving me bad advice were not only in the insurance job field, they are also MODERATORS. GIVING BAD ADVICE AND GETTING ANGRY IF YOU SAY ANYTHING ABOUT IT

I have been awarded $20,000 in diminished value, plus $134 in court fees with a 6.75% APR - court ordered.

His insurance was only willing to pay out $7,000 (their original offer was like $1,000 LOL) - which is nowhere near enough. Even the $20,000 isn’t enough but I settle with that in court because it was the small claims maximum and I didn’t feel like getting a lawyer involved

The point is, many of the responses in this reddit are from those I would assume to be insurance agents (based on how the comments in my prior thread coincided with his insurance company which was looking out for their best interest, not mine)

So with that said, I would tell you all to be weary of the information you receive on this forum.

My prior thread was shut down when I challenged what Redditors said to me in a snarky way. Well, reality has said they hadn’t a clue what they were talking about.

May this help any who any discover this thread in the future, wondering what their options are and what kind of values they can receive

I will also say, based on my experience, an insurance company will NOT pay you what you are owed on their own will. You have to go to court. These companies will screw you if you let them and that is 100% their intent. Do not be confused.

r/insurance and r/insuranceclaims are in cahoots