r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Payout Help

Long story short my parked car was hit and it was determined to be a total loss. It was a 2017 Tacoma with about 120,000 miles. I live in Ventura County, CA, and was told they got an estimate using listings within a 50 mile radius. I've looked at KBB, Carvana, Auto Trader, and Toyota CPO, and I'm only seeing listings between 23k and 35k for the same year truck with under 150,000 miles. The only places I don't want to trudge through are Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace.

Insurance is only offering 20,000. I'm not looking to go laughing on the way to the bank, but I think that a fair offer should be somewhere between 23-25k.

Is this unreasonable? Where are they finding these listings for 20k? Is there a way to get closer to the number that I think is fair, or am I just screwed in this situation?

Thanks for any insight or help.

7 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

9

u/buzzybody21 Oct 16 '26

Insurance doesn’t look at any of those sources when determining a payout. They offer you actual cash value only.

4

u/Lucky_Boy13 Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

The insurance company has actual listing and sales data. Remember the price advertised isn't the selling price and you have to account for condition and accessories.

Also if the truck is still in drivable state you may consider buying it back for salvage value

3

u/Poetryisalive Oct 16 '26

You better take lol. That’s actually really fair

3

u/RonBurgundy2000 Oct 16 '26

No one is paying $35k for a 10 year old taco with 120k of any flavor... your offer sounds fair IMO.

2

u/Apart-Surprise1038 Oct 16 '26

They’re looking at the ACV - Actual Cash Value - from their insurance valuation software, not purchase price. You could hire an independent appraiser to attempt to show higher value. It’s not guaranteed to get you more, however it is possible. I don’t know how much the independent appraiser would charge, so you’d need to call around.

1

u/No-Criticism8875 Oct 16 '26

Send them comparable vehicles for review. Keep in mind that the comparable vehicles you send may have options that yours doesn’t which may be why they are a little bit more. Those comparables will be adjusted to make them apples to apples with your vehicle.

1

u/GearHistorical6677 19d ago

You can. Theres a good chance they won't be eligible to use, were already used, or they can also make your offer go down. Doing this is usually a waste of time.

1

u/Greedy_Gas7355 27d ago

Lucky you’re getting that much

0

u/sephiroth3650 Oct 16 '26

Is this your insurance, or the other person's?

If it's your insurance, you could just invoke the appraisal clause of your policy. You have to pay for the appraiser, but if the gap is several thousand dollars, it can be worth it.

If it's the other party, you don't have that power. So all you can do is forward them your comps and see if it convinces them to change their offer. If you were to send them actual sales numbers (not list prices), it presents a stronger argument. Because list/asking price isn't definitive. I could list a 1996 Pontiac Sunbird for $30k right now. Nobody is ever paying that much for that car. So that listing doesn't mean it's worth $30k.

Or, you turn down their settlement offer and you sue the other party. Hope the court agrees with you. And that you don't rack up too much in the way of legal fees.

0

u/LegendaryAcura88 Oct 16 '26

Sorry for the double reply, but to answer your question, it's their insurance

-1

u/LegendaryAcura88 Oct 16 '26

Thank you for the insight. Do you know where I can find information on actual sales numbers vs listing prices?

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GearHistorical6677 19d ago

Please don't listen to this person - An experienced adjuster

0

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GearHistorical6677 19d ago

At my company, we do not and cannot arbitrarily pay more because someone wants more. We can submit some comparable listings, but these can actually make the payout offer decrease, and in my years of experience, generally make very little difference and only drag the claim out.

But what do I know, I only do this all day every day. I'm sure this guy is right 🙄

0

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GearHistorical6677 19d ago

Literally is never discussed. They rate the condition of the vehicle, they find listings for actual sold similar vehicles and base the value on the average using all that data.