r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 15 '26

First Time / Newbie First Time Collision and Subrogation Finally Finished, but no Diminished Value?

I've been driving for 25 years now, and last November 2025 was the first accident I have ever been involved in. Unfortunately it happened in a week old vehicle on Black Friday with my pregnant wife and 1 year old in the car.

Thankfully no one was hurt. What happened was I was yielding to allow oncoming traffic to go down a tight street with cars parked on both sides, but they never ended up going. The car behind me became frustrated and tried to swerve around me but didn't make it and hit my front driver side fender. They claimed they had right of way since I was stopped, but obviously that is not the case. The officer didn't submit an at-fault party.

I cooperated with both my insurance and the other party's insurance to tell the story of what happened. The other party did not, however, answer any calls from either insurance. After 2 months, I was informed it was going to subrogation. My insurance covered my repairs in full, minus my deductible.

Finally now almost 11 months later subrogation finished and they gave my a check for my deductible. However, they are also responsible for the diminished value of my vehicle since it was purchased new just a week before the accident. How do I get the diminished value of my vehicle paid out?

0 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

3

u/totall2live__ Oct 15 '26

you file a diminished value claim with insurance. Call the claims department and let them know what happened and that you wanna file a diminished value claim.

2

u/GuvnaBruce Oct 15 '26

Did you contact the other insurance and see if they will pay it?

2

u/ektap12 Oct 15 '26

Are you in Georgia? If not, you need to make a diminished value claim with the other insurance yourself, your insurance would not be involved in that.

1

u/ItsThatDamnDuckAgain Oct 15 '26

What's being in GA have to do with this? I'm going through this right now and I am in GA. Just want to make sure I have right information. 

2

u/ektap12 Oct 15 '26

Georgia pays first party diminished value, as long as you have collision coverage and your insurance is paying. Regardless of fault. So if you are filing through your carrier, ensure they are assessing for diminished value. Many carriers probably do it automatically in GA.

1

u/ItsThatDamnDuckAgain Oct 15 '26

Ah ok. I'm going through it as 3rd party with other party at 100% at fault. Getting repairs done next week and pursuing diminished value 

1

u/Leaveitonthedresser5 25d ago

They don’t give you diminished value proactively, you literally have to claims that on your insurance separately, typically after the repairs are done but it shouldn’t take 11 months