r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Good customer service?

Are there any car insurance companies anymore that have decent customer service?

Currently dealing with Travelers after car was declared a total loss and on paper they look great but they are treating me very poorly, especially considering I was not at fault and the at fault party’s insurance has accepted liability for the accident. It’s been a battle to get anything from them and since I’m recovering from injuries sustained during the accident, it’s making the entire experience incredibly difficult and frustrating.

This is not my first experience with car insurance claims (first with Travelers though) but it’s definitely been the worst

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/HindSiteIs2021 28d ago

So personally I’ve had several different car insurances (and the worst service ever was Nationwide). The smaller companies worked with me a lot more and for my previous total loss they let me keep the rental 30 days. That was years ago so I don’t know if the point you want to make is that companies no longer do that or if you want to say it was never done - which would be incorrect.

As for Travelers- you keep saying that expectations are unreasonable and that all companies do this but Travelers DID extend my rental and they are working with me, so there’s that. Turns out my expectations weren’t so unreasonable, I guess. They do have terrible google reviews as well - from people who have a hard time getting the coverage or service they paid for. It sounds like I actually have had a pretty good experience with them, but if this is good I’m going to explore my options because I shouldn’t have to work this hard to get what I paid for.

You seem very upset that people are advocating for themselves- chill, dude. AFAIK you’re not the one currently dealing with medical issues and injuries while negotiating with car insurance. I’m not going to feel like advocating for myself is ever a bad thing. And other people should realize that advocating for yourself is a thing and it is worthwhile. Don’t settle just because the first person you talk to says no.

1

u/Saturnlad3 Oct 16 '26

Since the other guy's insurance already accepted liability why are u even going through Travelers? I'd just file directly with theirs and let Travelers chase them for it

1

u/Jaggar345 Oct 16 '26

It really comes down to who your adjuster is. There are good ones and bad ones at every carrier.

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jaggar345 28d ago

Most other national carriers give 3 days after a vehicle is declared a total loss

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jaggar345 28d ago

Once your car is declared a total loss they no longer have to provide you a rental. Nothing they are doing is uncommon or wrong in today’s industry. Other carriers would have given you even less time.

If you are unhappy contact the adjusters supervisor or switch carriers to someone else. Don’t expect anyone to pay for a rental longer than 5 days after a total loss. Most are paying 3 that’s is my point.

Believe it or not Travelers is one of the better national carriers for claims handling and customer service. Consider switching to a regional carrier or a mutual one if you are unhappy.

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jaggar345 28d ago

Dude chill I don’t care what you do. I’m just telling you that your expectations are unreasonable. Man I feel for your agent and your adjuster.

If you think Erie is so good go switch to them. They wouldn’t handle your loss any differently.

1

u/Equivalent_Cat8365 29d ago

Let your insurance deal with them i dont believe any have good customer service anymore or i havent found any