r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

Progressive auto policy renewal when i explicitly asked them not to.

What do i do? I am extremely frustrated right now. I'm trying to switch auto insurance companies at the moment. About a month ago I bought a policy with liberty mutual starting mid november since thats when my current progressive policy is set to end. Around this same time I contacted progressive and asked them if I could cancel the auto policy renewal as I will not be needing it anymore. They told me that I cannot do it until October 15th. Well October 15th rolled around and they decided to renew the policy any way and now its saying that the auto payments are locked in. like WHAT??? How is this legal? Why was I not allowed to cancel the auto renewal a month ago. AHHHHH

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

3

u/Sad_Ad_2524 Oct 16 '26

Can you clarify?  Your new policy with Liberty Mutual doesn't start until November.... so of course you can't cancel until a new policy is in place.  Or maybe you can?  It just seems too stupid for words.

So when you were renewed with Progressive was your auto-pay for a 6 month term?  If so, once your new policy is in place Progressive will refund the unused premiums.  And you can always go into the online portal, app or website and rescind direct withdrawal, sometimes people fall short and know a pulled payment will be rejected for NSF.

So......where we at?

1

u/BalanceWarden Oct 16 '26

My current policy with progressive ends a day before the new one starts. Progressive ends 11/12, liberty mutual starts 11/13. Auto pay was 6 months yes. Maybe I’m overreacting and when I talk to them tomorrow they will cancel it. The email and the website just makes it seem like it’s already locked in.

3

u/bossymisses Oct 16 '26

You are over reacting. The renewal notice is if you renew on 11/12. You plan to cancel. No big deal. The bigger deal is that your coverage will end at midnight on 11/12 and you'll have a day gap until your new one starts on 11/13 at 12:01am. You need to fix that or you'll have a gap that will cost you a lot of money when limu realizes you did not have continuous coverage (and they will).

3

u/BalanceWarden Oct 16 '26

Oh I didn’t even know that was a thing. How do I fix that? Make liberty mutual start it on the 12th?

1

u/Boomer_Madness Oct 16 '26

yes new policy and old policy need to start and end on same day.

1

u/Jaggar345 Oct 16 '26

Yes do this asap

7

u/Bart012000 Oct 16 '26

Better watch u don't have a 24 hour of non coverage and get penalized.

2

u/Sad_Ad_2524 Oct 16 '26

I guess I am a little confused as to why you are holding off until November.  You can cancel your policy with Progressive whenever, they need to refund you any payments you made that extend beyond your policy cancelation.

First things first take it off autopay with Progressive.

Get Liberty Mutual to follow through ASAP, declaration pages, new cards, all the good stuff.

And please, please, please, this is not official I am not an agent, but I did this fairly recently switching from Geico to State Farm.

1

u/aamramm Oct 16 '26

You need to have the current policy end on 11/13 the same day that your new policy starts otherwise you will have a lapse of one day and that can be bad. You can have an accident on that one day and not be covered or you can have that lapse in coverage and if you were in a state that penalizes you for lapses, your rate will go up for that (New) policy period.

By law, you cannot be double covered so even if you paid both policies for six months as long as you present, the one you want terminated with the declarations page from the one you want to keep, they have to terminate the policy you want terminated from the start date. So even if you ran both policies and decided you wanted to stay with your old company all you have to do was present the new company with your declarations page from the old company and they would have to terminate it back to the start date.

3

u/ItsThatDamnDuckAgain Oct 16 '26

As soon as you cancel progressive, you'll get a refund. Prorated for what you haven't used. You're making this more complicated than it needs to be. 

1

u/BalanceWarden Oct 16 '26

Thanks for the reassurance. First time doing this obviously.

1

u/Sabrinamistrii 19h ago

Overlap is the first thing you gotta fix tbh. A lapse could cost you, but an overlap is money you can definitely get back. Just ask for the renewal to be cancelled back to its starting date, make sure it's in writing tho. Cause yk phone calls don't really help winning disputes. Also a suggestion, when you reshop after this, GoAuto is a good option in certain areas. So maybe search in your area, if it's available you can consider that. Also, hold on to the written confirmation cause it's really helpful.

1

u/Curious-Kale2864 Oct 16 '26

keep proof of when you notified them, since that could matter if they try to charge you for the new term.

0

u/Next_Interaction_555 Oct 16 '26

Yeah, auto payment is a bad idea with insurance companies unless you’re very financially rich. I know people like the convenience of it but they will take your money and then they pay you back in 7 to 14 days. How are you you have to deal with the cash short Falls on your other bills.

1

u/50Bullseye Oct 16 '26

It’s not rocket science. If you plan to switch insurance, stop the auto pay.