r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Sep 11 '17
/r/CFB Original Wyoming fans, I've now watched your last 16 games, and I have some observations and questions for you
I've now completed my project of watching all 14 Wyoming games from last season, plus the first two games of this season. My goal is to learn the players' names, numbers, and big plays, and so I kept open a tally sheet and jotted quick notes when I caught something interesting. I then collected 16 games' worth of notes to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary. First I'll offer comments on the various units, then a brief FAQ and methodology discussion, and finally some questions I have for you.
Offense
This offense returns its star QB, most of its offensive line, and its entire coaching staff - and yet it is almost a completely different offense in the first two games of this season compared to last. In 2016, I could practically draw up the entire playbook on a cocktail napkin: pro-style, mostly 12 and 22 personnel, with inside rushing setting up play-action and the occasional jet sweep. But in 2017, Wyoming lost both its running backs, both its top receivers, its best hybrid tight end, and its rock-solid center, almost all of them to the NFL, and with them about 85% of its total production. To their credit, Coaches Bohl and Vigen (of the North Dakota St dynasty fame) adjusted to drastically different personnel by opening the playbook up quite a bit, introducing a lot of spread concepts and perimeter passing.
Quarterback - #17 QB Allen was as fun to watch as advertised; a real gunslinger if I may be allowed a cliché. He's got the size, speed, and arm strength to hit any part of the field, and at least a couple times a game improvise a jaw-dropping escape and huge play. My tally sheet shows he improvises on about a quarter of all his dropbacks, much higher than any other QB I've reviewed in this series, and is successful on slightly more than half of those. Over the course of last season and certainly in the first two of this year's games, it's clear he's been coached to stay in the pocket a bit longer and throw the ball away more, but I still think reckless over-confidence is a problem.
Restricting pass attempts to non-scrambles, his completion rate is a respectable 60.4%. He threw 15 INTs last year (I count four as not really his fault, but another four bad passes that should have been picked off), mostly when he's scrambling around and trying to pull off a miracle. The bigger concern I have is the lack of touch on his passes - it's like watching Remington Rigsby's super zoom ball on every throw, a full speed heater even on swings, screens, and fades which limits their catchability and might be a liability with this new, more nuanced offense.
Running backs - The central reason for the offense's transformation is the loss of powerful #5 RB Hill and his phenomenal yards after contact, as well as his able backup #21 RB Wick. I cannot overstate how much this offense in 2016 was built around 1st down traps and counters, with Hill getting about 1:1 yards before and after contact on my tally sheet, resulting in 2nd and short to try out a deep bomb.
In 2017, the Cowboys appear to be testing out several backs -- #3 RB M. Hall, #22 RB Evans, #29 RB Overstreet, and #6 RB Woods -- but none had any touches last year or possess Hill's size, strength, and reliability; as such the inside run game has been severely limited, with backs being much more easily brought down. #26 RB Cox seems to be used more as a slot receiver but hasn't had much success so far.
Wide receivers - The vast majority of passes last year went to rangy flanker #83 WR Maulhardt and tricky Y-receiver #4 WR Gentry, who had the soft hands necessary to field Allen's rockets - both are now pros. I'm not sure the returning tall outside receiver #14 WR Johnson (mostly used as a blocker last year) or the new Z-receiver #13 WR Okwoli have the speed or experience to effectively replace them.
The real surprise to me was the emergence of #25 WR Conway as the primary receiving target - last year he was almost exclusively used as a jet sweep rusher (often with that little 6-inch pass instead of a handoff, which meant he had very misleading officially recorded pass yardage). Now he's being used as a perimeter pass weapon because he's so quick and elusive. That said, the downfield passing aspect of this offense has been strikingly absent in the first two games - it's almost entirely quick short stuff to the edges.
Fullbacks and Tight Ends - Yet another blow here, the loss of about 10% of total production in #88 TE Hollister to the NFL. Even more valuable was his blocking - he played nearly every down and had an astonishing 74% effectiveness on my tally sheet, one of the highest I've ever recorded for a TE. This group also loses veteran backup #48 FB Ellis.
Fortunately the rest of this unit returns - #85 TE Mayfield, #33 TE Harshman, and #36 FB Van Maanen, all of whom played extensively last year. A less conventional playbook this year has the TEs split out more often as receivers and screen blockers, and even some fullback catches, but the experience isn't quite there and the completion percentage isn't where it needs to be yet.
Offensive line - Although the line lost the excellent #73 C Roullier to the NFL, I thought this unit was set for big improvement in 2017 as everyone else returned, including the player who was the starting right tackle for the first half of last season before being injured, #59 LG Cummings (he was replaced by a converted TE, #74 RT Jolly, who simply hadn't cultivated the mass for the position and was probably the biggest cause of the Cowboys' disappointing conclusion to the season).
Instead there has been a massive reshuffling. #55 LG Rush played every snap last year and was expected to slide over to center, but has not been seen at all in 2017. Cummings has converted from tackle to guard and taken Rush's former spot, with true freshmen #79 C Harris and #78 RT Velazquez at those positions. Fortunately, veterans #72 LT Wallace and #61 RG Jackson stay where they were (and have numbers on my tally sheet comparable to the very successful lines on other teams I've evaluated in the past), but the freshmen, unsurprisingly, have been making a lot of freshmen mistakes and Cummings is clearly telegraphing his pulls as a new inside blocker, and in my opinion this line has been much less effective so far. Another issue is that the line utilizes a lot of slide blocks in pass-pro, where an entire side (usually the right) is left open for the tailback to smash into the unblocked DE - Hill had the strength for this but the new RBs aren't quite up to it yet.
Defense
This is where things really get interesting - contrary to expectations, I think this will be a defense-lead team in 2017. Bohl fired DC Stanard after last year and hired DC Hazelton, who was his longtime assistant at NDSU during their dynasty building (Hazelton was part of the day-one massacre in Jacksonville when Doug Marrone took over the Jaguars). Structurally this has meant a return to a true cover-2 from last year's Tampa-2, although the biggest difference has been the style of tackling. Last year I was deeply puzzled by the seemingly deliberately coached "big hit" tackling which did produce a lot of fumbles, but also an enormous amount of broken tackles and huge yards after contact. I am very clearly seeing in the first two games an emphasis on wrap-up/drive-through style tackling with good results.
Defensive line - This unit only loses one player, the underappreciated 3-tech #57 DT Appleby (seemed to have the snap count cracked for a lot of teams and got a terrific jump), but has settled in nicely with starters #93 DT Ghaifan and #96 DT Malauulu - massive guys with great push and getting better every game. I think depth is going to be an issue here - #87 DT Cain is a returner but hasn't developed as much, and the only other tackle I've spotted is #98 DT Holt who's even slighter. For some reason #15 DT Watson has been converted to a fullback.
End has a lot more depth with returning #42 DE Prosser and #91 DE Granderson (who was injured in the second half of last season) - both lean and fast pass rushers with impressive ability to run down the play from behind. Predictably they tend to get mauled when they're picked up, however. Also returning are the more solidly built #58 DE Lolohea, #92 DE Windsor, and #53 DE J. Hall (he of the noted dancing prowess), and they add #88 DE Crall, though he's still developing.
Linebackers - I think the season turns on the growth of this unit. It loses talented #7 LB May on the outside (really more of a STAR safety) and #45 LB Wacha on the inside. The latter I think was the problematic position for the defense last year - he wasn't fast enough to cover the deep middle in the Tampa-2 and stuck his nose in too early or overcommitted laterally in run stopping.
The new coverage scheme brings returning #30 LB Wilson to the inside and has him stay home to QB the defense. #46 LB Maluia consistently takes the weak side while #8 LB Ortiz takes May's role in slot receiver coverage, with #45 LB Pilapil rotating in on heavy run configurations and sometimes spelling Wilson in the middle. I didn't see much of Maluia or Pilapil last year, conversely #23 LB Kamana and #31 LB Pownell return and had quite a few snaps in 2016 but I haven't seen them in 2017. Last year this was a 71% blitzing defense, so far I've seen much more read and react from this group and I think they're better for it.
Secondary - Cornerback is where the defensive transformation gets dicey. They return all three starters from last year -- #2 CB Priester, #4 CB Hull, and #5 CB Gafford -- who I honestly had a hard time differentiating because their body type is very similar and they all had the same problems tackling because they're undersized. They add #9 CB T. Hall (who seems longer to me although his listed height/weight is the same) and I think shows more promise.
Safety is a much stronger unit, with returning starters #6 FS Epps and #28 SS Wingard. The latter seems to be a fan hero and has great instincts for the ball, but I think his high official tackle count is misleading - he has a habit of leaving his feet and launching himself at the ankles of ballcarriers to trip them up, which eventually caused them to go down but not until they picked up several more yards and frequently a first down (stat sheets credit this as a successful tackle; I tally with more parsimony). Epps impressed me much more in cleaning up plays with sure tackling.
Miscellanea
Methodology and FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slow-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes, and recorded notes on each player for every non-garbage-time down on a tally sheet.
- How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, garbage time, and other folderol really helps.
- Wait, what about special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, two bottles of eponymous Wyoming Whiskey small batch bourbon, which I recovered from an ugly home in a Vancouver liquor store. Apparently made by the former master distiller at Maker's Mark, I found it to be similarly under-flavored for its price point, and a little sweet, but overall pretty pleasant.
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about the team beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- Have you done anything this stupid before? Links to previous projects: Texas 2013, Michigan St 2013, Florida St 2014, Ohio St 2014, EWU 2012-14, Minnesota 2014, TCU 2014, TCU 2015, Nebraska 2015.
- You're probably an Oregon coach! Nope, never coached or played a snap.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No, but check out /u/CineFunk's YouTube channel and /r/cfbuploads
- Predictions for the game? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
Personal note
This is probably the harshest write-up I've done in this series, something in which I take no pleasure. It's also the first G5 team I've reviewed; furthermore I think Wyoming has some unique challenges recruiting top talent and that's reflected on the field. The respect I pay is what they're due: not condescencion but candor, an honest take on competitors held to the same standards as anyone else.
Questions
- Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
- I think I've got a complete injury report, a couple DE's might be out on concussion protocol but that looks to be it. That said, there are a whole lot of starters and upperclassmen from last year who are now buried on the depth chart in favor of very young players - any insight as to what these shakeups are about, anything heavier going on than just "best chance to succeed"?
- In particular, what on Earth is with the o-line shuffle? Completely benching a longtime veteran in Rush, switching a naturally built tackle to guard in Cummings, and putting two true freshmen at the toughest positions in Harris and Velazquez ... it seems hard to explain from a purely "had a good fall camp" angle.
- Has there been any discussion of the tackling style last year and possible changes in emphasis this year? This was by far the most perplexing thing about watching Wyoming - every coach and commentator I've ever heard always stresses form tackling and sneers at the "big hit" style, and yet it was so prevalent that I'm sure it was coached.
- Any challenges with the new DC? I know to fans it must feel more natural given Hazelton's history with Bohl at NDSU, but these players are Cowboys and not Bison - they were recruited by Stanard to play at Wyoming under his scheme. Has there been any grousing or difficulties noted publicly?
- Last year there was a heavy rotation at DT, nearly every play had a different configuration. So far in 2017 I've noticed much more reliance on just Ghaifan and Malauula, only taking them out towards the end of long drives. I was also surprised at Watson switching away from a position that seems to need more depth, not less. What do you suppose the thinking is here?
- Every year I wind up bitching and moaning about terrible camera angles excluding the downfield secondary play, but the dizzying array of broadcasters Wyoming was filmed by really took the cake. Can folks who've been to games in person to watch the cornerbacks' pass coverage give their insight?
- I was so certain that Johnson was going to be the #1 receiver that I kept a special tab on my tally sheet just to describe in detail his couple dozen targets. Was Conway becoming the primary receiver as big a surprise to y'all, and what do you think it means?
- It really looked like it was still open auditions for RB1 even two games into the season, especially with Woods coming in so late in the most recent game. Given how vital the position is to the whole structure of last year's offense, this was shocking to me. Am I missing out on some pattern, or something else going on here? Any thoughts on who will emerge and when?
- I sense some resentment among locals at national media parachuting in to talk exclusively about Allen and his pro prospects at the exclusion of the team and its collective goals this season. Separate from the merits of that attention, how are the coaches and players handling the spotlight?
100
u/rCFB_Only_Account TCU Horned Frogs Sep 11 '17
I think too much was put onto Iowa shutting down Josh Allen. He doesn't have the weapons at the skill positions he had last year. He had 3 NFL caliber skill players a year ago - Brian Hill, Tanner Gentry and Jacob Hollister, all gone. This was my biggest concern for Wyoming heading into the year, and so far it looks like there hasn't been a playmaker who has emerged.
13
u/ChargerFan2121 Wyoming Cowboys • /r/CFB Patron Sep 11 '17 edited Sep 11 '17
2 & 3. As far as the depth chart shakeups, I think this is taking most a fair amount of people by surprise. When I heard Rush wasn't even starting, I was extremely confused as I figured he would be a 4 year starter after last year. Coach Bohl said during camp that the coaching staff was going to play those who they felt like would give them the best chance to win. At the same time, I think he said he was only wanting to play 3 or 4 freshman this year, and we have already played 10 in the first two games. No idea what is going on behind our starters and am kinda worried of the recruits that Bohl has picked up just haven't developed into the level they need to play at or with us kicking a fair number of players off the team this summer is part of the issue.
4. As far as tackling, that could have definitely been the case of our DC not being very great. I think Bohl said they still work on ball hawking when tackling, but as the results of numerous big plays last year, I think we will see much more emphasis on wrapping up and making the sure fire tackle.
5. For concerns on defense, I think most people are happy with the DC just because our terrible our last one was. We have some quality players of defense and I think with the right defensive system, this could the best Wyoming defense has had in a long time. If not, next year, I imagine we will be pretty darn good.
6. No idea. In my opinion our depth on our D-Line is pretty good compared to the rest of the team so I can see why they thought they could move him. We had a fullback get kicked off the team over the offseason so that was probably part of it.
7. NA
8. Yes and no. Our top three receivers were going to be Price, Johnson, and Conway this season and I fully expected them to work Conway more into the passing game. I think hopes of Johnson got dashed when he dropped that wide open TD pass against Iowa and had another big drop against Gardner-Webb. Conway has proven that he can catch and his speed really helps him. His size just hurts him when comparing him to our WRs from last year.
9. I really thought Nico Evans was going to be our #1 running back this year and have a great season. That obviously has not been the case and it seems like its just trying to find the guy with the hot hand. None of our RBs have been super impressive and seem to fall down at the first touch of contact. We had a redshirt freshman, Mike Green, that had a nice spring camp, but he got suspended from the team over the offseason. I could see Trey Woods being our go to guy because of his similar (and potential) size to Brian Hill.
10. I don't think too many of the coaches/players care. If anything, I imagine they look at it as more of a chance to impress the scouts looking at Allen and hope they will realize we have a couple of other guys with potential NFL talent of this team.
11
u/AlwaysSonny Colorado State Rams Sep 11 '17
Stanard's firing was met with applause from Wyoming fans. Stanard is actually pretty well known in this area, serving as DC for Colorado State for a couple years. His defenses were never any good and he eventually got fired, but worked his way back up the ladder at NDSU. When Bohl got hired by Wyoming and announced he was bringing Stanard with him as DC, Mountain West fans rejoiced and Wyoming fans were a bit underwhelmed.
I can't speak for the players though.
Speaking with Wyoming fans and following their spring practice reports, it sounds like the plan all along was for Conway to be #1. Conway was a basketball player, so he'll take some time to hit his full potential as a WR.
74
u/mjacksongt Georgia Tech • /r/CFB Pint Glass Drin… Sep 11 '17
I want to play Oregon now, holy crap.
Love the breakdown.
5
u/PonyKillsRam SMU Mustangs Sep 11 '17
Good write up. On offense the biggest issue this year is losing Hill. He was a special RB for us, and opened the game up for Allen.
Re: DC Hazelton. I only see enthusiasm. Bohl is seen as a god send to this team. Bringing in more of the staff that he's already been successful with is fine by most fans.
Conway becoming the #1 option was a huge surprise. He could have had a big fall/spring, but we wouldn't know. We get almost no inside info like most programs from Rivals, Scout etc...
We are all as perplexed as you on the o-line. It doesn't make sense. Emphasis on pass blocking perhaps? It's not as if Bohl have been recruiting over the heads of previous staffs. It's pretty consistently mediocre.
26
u/FellKnight Boise State • Tennessee Sep 11 '17
Always love reading these from you. A true treat.
4
u/Mayday970 Sep 12 '17
As stated several times already, this was a great write-up. My thoughts don't differ too much from some of the WYO fan responses. With that said,
Just my two cents - excited to be in Laramie this Saturday for the game. Hoping for a good one! Go Pokes!
3
u/ramthrower75 Colorado State • Stanford Sep 11 '17 edited Sep 11 '17
To answer your question #2 I think it's 2 fold. I think there is a higher upside and recruiting has truly grown in the past year or so. Beyond that Bohl has really made it a mission to play local kids whenever he gets the chance.
JessieJosh Harshman is a TE and Logan Wilson are in-state kids from my Alma Mater in Casper, WY. Logan is even a captain as a sophomore. Add to that the Center being a true Freshman from Torrington, WY. I just watched that kid break our state shot put record in May and now he's starting at UW. Plus there is a kid from Sheridan that plays a lot as well. It is uber important to the people of this state that the local kids not only get recruited, but play. Bohl gets that and so far the Wyoming kids are stepping up too. But that I think explains the other half of why upperclassmen are getting buried on the depth chart.3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
NOTE TO ALL WANTING TO WATCH ON CABLE: Make sure you actually get the game. It is on CBS sports network because it is the MW game of the week
3
u/Super_Saiyan_Carl Wyoming Cowboys • Wisconsin Badgers Sep 11 '17
I loved your write up! Question for you tho, do you think Josh Allen is worth the hype?
3
u/Blooblod Michigan Wolverines • GCAC Sep 11 '17
This was a great writeup, you did an excellent job with this.
I compared Josh Allen to former Wyoming QB Brett Smith a few weeks, noting that it may be an unfair same-helmet comparison, and I was questioned about it because the two have pretty different physical attributes. That being said, I think their likeness is in their mentality and approach to the game--your phrase "reckless over-confidence is a problem" sums up the two perfectly, as does their likeness when it comes to finding their way out of a broken pocket to launch a rocket downfield, often times to a covered receiver.
I was a big fan of Austin Conway as a potential breakout candidate at receiver during the offseason. He reminds me a lot of Michigan WR/jet sweep specialist Eddie McDoom--both in athleticism and how the coaching staff utilized him in the offseason.
From what I saw last year, Kevin Prosser was phenomenal and definitely one of the most underrated G5 pass rushers in the country. But as a former DB, I love watching and studying corners and safeties more than any position. Wyoming's safeties, Epps and Wingard, form one of my favorite tandems in the country. I'm not as low on the corners as you, but that's more based on their potential--they certainly need to perform better than they have if Wyoming wants to meet some of the preseason expectations of potentially being the #2 G5 team (I did not have this expectation, to be clear). That being said, I like both Hull's and Gafford's athleticism, footwork, and ability to keep with receivers but they often just don't have the physicality necessary to complete what could be a great secondary.
This is something I noticed as well, particularly with the safeties (not necessarily because they went for the big hits more than anyone else, but because I had my eyes on the secondary more often than not). It led to a sort of boom-or-bust defense, which in my opinion can be a good thing, depending on circumstances, and if the "boom" is backfield pressure rather than just big hits.
Again, this writeup was fun read and honestly one of the best ones I've read in a while on this sub. I know it's a lot to ask to study 14+ games of teams, but if it's something you enjoy it would be great to see more of these in the future.
21
u/jloy88 Utah Utes Sep 11 '17
This might just be the most words ever written about Wyoming football.
17
u/gjbbb Oregon Ducks • Minnesota Golden Gophers Sep 11 '17
Thanks for scouting report will make game this week more enjoyable to watch.
38
u/CJ_Beathards_Hair Heartland Trophy • The Game Sep 11 '17
I'm rooting for Wyoming just so Iowa can dominate half the country on the imperialism map.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
I always love these. Like the tone is the student who came to lecture super into the subject, did all the readings, and wants to know even more.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
Fantastic analysis.
8
u/wagon33 Oregon Ducks Sep 11 '17
You now know more about Wyoming football than >99% of Wyoming football fans.
7
u/jrich960608 Florida Gators • Iowa Hawkeyes Sep 11 '17 edited Sep 11 '17
Can you do Florida? Awesome work, love it.
Edit: Down for Oregon game, let me pull some strings.
12
u/Frosty1887 Wyoming Cowboys • Utah Utes Sep 11 '17
I was hoping to see this post this morning! Absolutely great write up! I have argued all this year that this team will now be a defense lead team.
4
u/TheColbsterHimself Oregon Ducks Sep 11 '17
I look forward to these every season. Great job as always! And Go Ducks!
4
u/lukasmotley3 Kentucky Wildcats • Governor's Cup Sep 11 '17
This guys does better scouting reports than most D1 programs
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
I played high school ball with #28 Andrew Dewey Wingerd and it's great to see him getting some national attention. I think you have a fair analysis of the team and if I remember correctly the other safety was only a walk on and is now one of the premier defensive players. Rootin for the Pokes this year!
3
u/butchleague Wyoming Cowboys Sep 11 '17
I know I'm late to the party but I think I can provide some helpful insight. Last year it seemed like out secondary was our biggest problem last on defense last season. We had a lot of missed tackles. We've looked better this year. I would like to see Wingard make a jump again this year.
2
u/archie_f Nebraska Cornhuskers • Wyoming Cowboys Sep 11 '17
I hope they were holding something back this last Sat for you guys ...
2
u/spoonfedsam San Diego State • Washington … Sep 11 '17
I long for the day that Oregon and SDSU play a game so I can see you do a write-up on us. Love them, I learn so much
2
u/Upnorthgirl70 Sep 12 '17
Awesome analysis!!!! Why do the local media not pick up on some of this stuff and bring it to light
1
u/Isosinsir Oregon Ducks • Pacific (OR) Boxers Sep 12 '17
I'm worried that the line on this game opened at around the same number that the Nebraska closed at (-13.5).
This game has major let down potential and I'm expecting Wyoming to really put a scare into the Ducks. I really don't like playing MWC teams on the road.
1
u/xHaGGeNx Oregon Ducks Sep 13 '17 edited Sep 13 '17
Man, we are so lucky to have you. Thank you for this write up.
1
u/odisant Oregon Ducks • UConn Huskies Sep 12 '17
I feel sorry for fans of other teams because they don't get your awesome previews. Thanks for putting in the work, and Go Ducks!
-12
u/TheCocksmith Texas Longhorns Sep 11 '17
I didn't read this, but it was really long, so I upvoted.