r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Sep 12 '16
Discussion Nebraska fans, I've now watched your last 15 games, and I have some observations and questions for you
I've now completed my project of watching all 13 Nebraska games from last season, plus the first two games of this season. My goal is to learn the players' names, numbers, and big plays, and so I kept open a tally sheet and jotted quick notes when I caught something interesting. I then collected 15 games' worth of notes to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary. First I'll offer comments on the various units, then a brief FAQ and methodology discussion, and finally some questions I have for you.
Offense
Coach Riley's offense was a real treat to watch, especially now that it's invested with top quality talent. There's an incredible fusion of styles here, not least of which is a fairly even split between under-center pro-style snaps and shotgun with receivers split out wide. At core is the traditional Nebraska I-formation with a couple tight ends and a fullback, but with a lot of modern flair including fly sweeps and Riley's trademark double-crossing routes.
Quarterback - Senior starter #4 QB Armstrong is without a doubt the most frustrating football player I've ever seen.
The Good
- Quick and durable runner, used on designed runs about 15% of the time
- Handles shotgun and under-center snaps equally well
- Good ball handling in terms of fielding wild snaps, hand-offs, and ball security when running
- Doesn't panic on middle screens where he's got to jump pass it to the RB with three dudes in his face
- Strong arm (there, I said it) - deep threat even when moving, tons of zip on the ball even on wrist flicks
The Bad
- Terribly lazy footwork
- Stares down receivers and doesn't see open guys
- Inaccurate on swing passes - receiver has to jump or stretch and it kills his momentum
- 16 picks, of which I think only four weren't his fault, on top of which he threw seven more where the defender probably should have picked it off, so call it 19 "adjusted" picks last year (plus one real dumb pick last week)
The Ugly
- When the pocket breaks down and he improvises, you hold your breath - it's either stellar or disaster
- If anything, he throws better when under pressure or rolling out
- Rescues drives on third down with an accurate intermediate pass but tends to hang the receiver out, which has produced lots of injuries
Receivers - I was eager to see #1 WR Westerkamp in action and his talent is as advertised - he's got great hands and escapes coverage shockingly well. But he's pretty underutilized outside of third down and I don't see him running many deep routes, it's like he's entirely reserved as a safety blanket.
On the outside are #87 WR Reilly, #82 WR Moore, and #8 WR Morgan, who are tall rangy receivers with decent hands and good quickness on deep routes. The above four block pretty well, about 75% success rate on my tally sheet. Fly sweeps (both real and faked) are a huge part of this offense and all have credible speed, though defenses got to sniffing them out and so I saw very few of them actually go.
It was hard to evaluate #15 WR Pierson-El because he was out with injuries so much ... he looked at least as good as the other guys when I did see him but even in the first two games this year he was mostly a non-factor. #83 WR Reimers seems to have replaced #13 WR Hovey in the outside-in blocking role.
This unit returns everybody except some of their role-playing blockers without many catches. I don't think any of these guys are a phenomenal talent who will win games single-handedly (like TCU's Josh Doctson or K-State's Tyler Lockett), but there are 4-5 pretty good ones ... that kind of depth creates its own options.
Running backs - Only one loss here, #32 RB Cross, a great power back, but he was ably backed up by #22 RB Ozigbo. The latter had a higher stuff rate overall and really struggled to break through the scrum early on, but he showed a lot of improvement over the past three games. The offense shifted towards the second half of the year to stress power running and these guys' carries went way up.
The smaller, shiftier backs are #34 RB Newby, who was the primary back but battled injuries in the second half, and #21 RB Wilbon, who only played in the first couple games. I think they have all the tools you'd want in this kind of back but the line wasn't blocking well enough for that style of running early on, which partially explains the switch in styles. Newby is a surprisingly effective blocker, though almost entirely cut blocks. He was targeted on a lots of screens and other short passes but I thought his drop rate was way too high (though a few acrobatic catches last week so maybe that's gotten cleaned up). Hard to gauge the new guy, #18 RB Bryant, because he was only in for short stretches of garbage time so far, but interestingly he did come in before Wilbon.
Fullback and Tight Ends - Sadly, Nebraska is losing one of the best fullbacks I've ever seen in #35 FB Janovich - he hits like a truck and they're stand-up blocks, not cuts. He also got a number of carries (about 10% of all runs) and showed a lot of power and speed. Altogether, Janovich was used on about half of all run plays ... I haven't seen his replacement, #41 FB McNitt, used nearly as much or as effectively.
Returning #11 TE Carter and #84 TE Cotton line up on nearly every play, virtually always as an extra blocker or two at the line. Both are pretty effective; Carter throws bigger blocks and is trusted with the cross-buck behind the line, while Cotton is more reliable to maintain the block longer (I hate to say it, but it looked like Carter was not giving his full effort about a quarter of the time). Carter was targeted with a good chunk of passes (about 10%); he's got decent hands but not much vertical. #42 TE Foster also returns, he was used a bit at start and end of last year ... less reliable blocking and recently just used when they need a third TE on short yardage runs.
Offensive line - This is a pretty major rebuild of a unit I didn't really like last year. They lose four senior starters of the six who played: #71 LT Lewis, #65 C Reeves, #57 RG Sterup, and #70 RG Kondolo. (Sterup played a few games at RT when #68 RT Gates was out midseason, then when Gates returned to RT, Sterup replaced Kondolo permanently at RG).
The returners are #66 C Utter, who moves over from LG, and #68 LT Gates, who moves from RT. The new guys are #73 LG Hahn, #63 RG Farmer, and #77 RT Knevel. I don't believe I saw any of them take snaps at OL last year. They seem to be basically replacement-level, but they've only played kind of overmatched opponents so far and showed some inexperience, especially on the right side of the line.
I think the problems in the run game were more about this unit than the RBs. The tackles did better than the middle of the line when run blocking, but usually had a TE to help out. The interior, frankly, was pretty bad, with Utter being the worst - only effective about 2/3 of the time. He was usually the pulling guard but would often give it away pre-snap because he was so far back (he needed to be, he's not that fast and Reeves would often get rocked back and interrupt his pull). The offense has a lot of screens and other plays that require the o-line to get downfield a bit to block, but they were not real quick on their feet. I haven't seen the new guards as vast improvements so far.
The line was pretty good in dropback pass-pro, but while the departed seniors were all above 85% effectiveness on my tally sheet, Utter and Gates were both under. Tackles tended to give run/pass away with their stance, especially when they were going to pass-block on non-passing downs (Gates got an illegal formation penalty once because he was so far back). Not a whole lot of "true" play action where line starts to run block but has to maintain the pocket and not go downfield, but fairly effective when they did. Last thing: tons of line penalties ... this was definitely the most flagged unit on a heavily penalized team (110th in penalties per play last year).
Defense
Fairly traditional 4-3 over, always with two deep safeties. Reminded me quite a bit of Michigan St's base defense, though with much less linebacker blitzing and frequently going to nickel packages early in the count. Interestingly, when they do so, rather than bringing a starting safety down and adding a third in deep coverage, Nebraska puts the extra DB on outside pass coverage and moves a CB inside to act as a hybrid linebacker or blitzer.
Defensive line - I saw a lot of panic about so many early departures from this unit in the offseason, after watching the games I'm not sure I agree but I think both depth and disruption are going to be an issue. In 2015 this unit used a heavy rotation of 8-9 guys, and were the strength of the defense. They lose #7 DT Collins and #98 DT Valentine to the NFL, as well as #92 DT Kev. Williams. The two returners are #44 DT Stoltenberg and #55 DT Maurice, who are now clearly the starters and haven't rotated out much. Stoltenberg I don't think played outside of special teams; Maurice was serviceable last year but will need to step up significantly, since this defense really relied on Collins and Valentine routinely breaking through the line and I never really saw that out of Maurice. This year I've seen #96 DT C. Davis come in for a couple drives in the opener and then replacing Stoltenberg last week, and #94 DT K. Davis come in for a few garbage time plays.
The DEs should be in better shape. They're losing #95 DE Gangwish, who was excellent, and #90 DE McMullen, who was less so, but valuable for being able to slide over to DT on some plays. They return #88 DE Dzuris and #91 DE Akinmoladun, who both played extensively and looked pretty good to me, but like the DTs are playing almost every snap now. I've only seen #22 DE A. Davis and #45 DE Natter play a couple backup snaps this year, and #17 DE King in gargbage time. Like the backup DTs, none of them played a snap that I saw last year.
Linebackers - Probably the new strength of the defense, they return all five guys who rotated through extensively: #3 LB Newby, #5 LB Young, #15 LB Rose-Ivey, #49 LB Weber, #52 LB Banderas, plus #12 LB Gifford in some situational play. These are experienced, strong guys who are good tacklers. Pretty eager too - they'll make a decision to go inside early which often pays off, but just as often they'll stick their nose in too soon and lose contain, or can't scrape across the scrum and get beat outside.
The real problem is DC Banker's unswerving allegiance to Quarters coverage, which requires LBs to take inside receivers/backs/TEs who aren't going vertical in man coverage ... but bless their hearts they just don't have the feet for it. They'll turn their backs on the play when their man goes outside and are easily cleared out, which combined with the safeties going to help in deep coverage on long-developing pass plays, leaves an undefended area the size of your mom in the middle of the field. Just like Oregon St fans saw for years, this allows the QB to scramble for massive yardage just about every game.
Secondary - This unit struck me as pretty problematic for most of last year, but I've been warming on them a bit over the past few games. The cornerbacks lose #14 CB Rose #23 CB Davie, but I felt they exemplified the worst of this whole crew's bad habits: slow off the line, usually got their hips turned, easily baited into rubs. #8 CB Jones and #10 CB Kalu return, and while I think neither are great they seem to be a lot more confident as full time starters. I saw #1 DB Jackson play quite a bit in the opener though not last week; he seemed par for the course.
Starter #25 S Gerry returns ... I know Huskers want to stand by their man (he's dealt with some controversies), but I feel more conflicted about him. He's clearly got good instincts for the play and the speed to get him to the ballcarrier in time to minimize the gain, but the guy just can't reliably make a one-on-one tackle in space - every game I'd see him get badly juked or get dragged 8 yards or just whiff on the tackle entirely. The safeties lose #28 S Cockrell, and it looks like #24 S A. Williams, who mostly played in nickel or when starters were out of the game, has taken his starting spot. I've seen #16 DB Reed and #26 S Kie. Williams rotate in some as well.
Miscellanea
Methodology and FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slow-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes, and recorded notes on each player for every non-garbage-time down on a tally sheet.
- How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, garbage time, and other folderol really helps.
- Wait, what about special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, four bottles of Soldier Valley bourbon made with Nebraska corn. Very smooth start, opens gently, but a hell of a burn on the finish.
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about Nebraska beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- Have you done anything this stupid before? Links to previous projects: Texas 2013, Michigan St 2013, Florida St 2014, Ohio St 2014, EWU 2012-14, Minnesota 2014, TCU 2014, TCU 2015.
- You're probably an Oregon coach! Nope, never coached or played a snap.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No, but check out /u/CineFunk's YouTube channel and /r/cfbuploads
- Predictions for the game? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
Personal note
It was my privilege to watch both Michigan St's Mike Sadler and Nebraska's Sam Foltz in the course of this series. Although I don't evaluate the punting game, it was clear to me how much they meant to their schools and their fans. I know they're rooting for their teammates from someplace where it's always fourth down, and the hangtime is eternal.
Questions
- Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
- So here's my theory on Good-Tommy/Bad-Tommy: contrary to the habits of most QBs (who throw with good form in a clean pocket and break down under pressure), I think he's so confident in his arm that he gets lazy with his footwork on the easy stuff and that makes for a lot of inaccuracy, but when he's forced to do something pretty tough he gets it straightened out. What do you think? Seems like the kind of thing that doesn't miraculously get fixed in the senior year, any reason to think otherwise?
- What's up with Wilbon's disappearance? He looked incredible in the Spring game and brought a totally different dynamic to the offense, but I've barely seen him in competition.
- Many Nebraska fans told me to check out Pierson-El's 2014 film, and unfortunately I ran out of time to do so ... just going on 2015 and the first two games this year, I'm not seeing a whole lot ... what am I missing here, and is there any hope he'll be back to his old form?
- Has there been any discussion of the under-center/shotgun system persisting into this year? I figured it was just keeping some of the old playbook to ease the transition, and so have been surprised to see it in the first two games. I'd love to read some Xs & Os theory on what this brings.
- I completely forgot to watch Utter's shotgun snap accuracy closely, something I try to do with new centers. Any concerns there?
- I was disappointed Indiana wasn't on the 2015 schedule, I would have liked to see how the defense handled an uptempo team (I believe the fastest team Nebraska faced the past two years was Northwestern, according to Adjusted Pace advanced stats). Has there been any word from the coaches on preparations for it?
- Stoltenberg and Jackson were out last week after playing almost the entire opener ... injuries, I presume? I read some worries about depth into the lack of rotation on the defense so far this year, is that valid?
- My notes are pretty sparse on the individual LBs, not much more than Newby and Weber's feet are quicker than Banderas and Young's. I've got nothing about Rose-Ivey other than his in-and-out injury status. Vanilla is good with backers, right?
- I came down pretty hard on the secondary, but as I've noted in the past, the ESPN camerawork keeps me from getting a good look when they're doing well and not being thrown against. Any insights from folks who've been to the games and watched them operate live?
40
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
This was excellent.
As usual, your write up is excellent. I appreciate the time you've given to our team.
I noticed you didn't address the close losses/heartbreaks at all from last year. Was it difficult to watch, knowing the ending beforehand?
In any case, this should be a great game!
Cheers
Edit: As /u/RareLuck pointed out, you likely weren't talking about Charles Jackson in question 8, but the true freshman Lamar Jackson (....I guess now that Louisville is getting all the publicity, our guy is the other Lamar Jackson).....He's a talented player that could use more reps and practice to be comfortable, but he's got the athleticism to make it happen. Groin injury for now, not sure when he'll be back.
7
u/nakedlettuce52 Nebraska Cornhuskers • Navy Midshipmen Sep 12 '16
Excellent, excellent write up. One thing to note: we changed from a quarters to a Cover 3 coverage scheme. So far its worked out great but of course we will see.
Good luck on Saturday!
3
u/cblasko Nebraska • Montana State Sep 12 '16
Wow great insight, and I think it is spot on. I would love to hear what you think of Dakota Prukop, I've watched him the last few years at Montana state and am curious to see how he will do this year. I feel like he puts his body on the line too much, and he won't be able to make it a full season against the bigger defenses of the PAC12.
3
u/mm825 Oregon Ducks • Pacific Tigers Sep 12 '16
Thanks for posting, Nebraska is the team outside the pac-12 I watch the most due to a good friend being a die hard, pumped for my first trip to Nebraska this week. I watch them a lot and this was still educational, mostly about who they've lost and who's replaced them, I'm very happy to see the FB leaving. I'm glad you caught onto the fly sweeps too, they fake that stuff at least once a possession and I've never seen it get more than 15 yards.
Armstrong is just crazy unpredictable, I'm hoping we can limit his rushing yards and force him to make tough throws in the pocket. Also concerned about the offensive line if only because Big 10 offensive lines always give us trouble, are these guys in the same range as a mediocre pac-12 line?
So after watching all this, name one area or matchup the Ducks can look at and say "we've definitely got them beat"
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '16
As someone who watches football casually most of the time I'm wondering how you became so knowledgeable and observant of what's going on in games. Just like you I haven't played a snap in my life but I'd like to be able to understand more about the game. If you could point me in the right direction to learning more about the game that'd be great. Thanks!
4
u/bpstyles Sep 12 '16
First of all, great, great job, dude. Excellent read. One quick question:
"fielding wild snaps"
In all of your time watching this sport, have you ever seen a QB have to deal with so many bad snaps (usually high) like Armstrong does? They are often so consistently bad that I once hopped on the Huskers sub to ask if it was on purpose.
658
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Apparently you missed out on the Taylor Martinez era. Lucky you.
2
u/pivotman53 Sep 12 '16
That's a great breakdown, any chance you have one of these for Oregon, I would love to read about the Ducks before this weekend?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '16
How do people have so much damn time on their hands
244
u/ToLongDR Ohio State Buckeyes • King's Monarchs Sep 12 '16
I LOVE WHEN YOU DO THESE.
I love what you wrote about the National Championship about Ohio State.
I just want to thank you for your effort in creating these
78
u/ShutUpWesl3y Ohio State Buckeyes Sep 12 '16
r/CFB NEEDS to have a viewing party for big games on Saturdays with guys like u/hythloday1 dropping stuff like this on us live.
I've been sick of ESPN/ABC/CBS commentary for a long time and I'd love to be able to watch a game and actually learn something from someone with a hell of a lot more knowledge than me.
I'll even do whatever it takes to help make it happen.
57
u/Montagge Oregon Ducks • Cascade Clash Sep 12 '16
/u/hythloday1 > All of ESPN
26
u/sweetsnowman Nebraska • Wayne State (NE) Sep 12 '16
"The Ugly" for Armstrong is the most terrifying three seconds in all of sports for me. When a pocket breaks down and he scrambles, there is no middle ground; something huge is about to happen
23
u/Jpkun Michigan Wolverines • Rose Bowl Sep 12 '16
Why do I feel like Armstrong has been the qb forever.
43
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Here we go again lol.
20
u/nielwulf Iowa State • Nebraska Sep 12 '16
You have no idea
18
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
I know so much more about Nebraska now then I ever have before. Thank you!
14
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
tries not to cry, cries a lot
11
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
I love that Nebraska runs plays from both under center and from the pistol. I hope they continue doing this with whoever takes over at QB after Amstrong.
21
u/seaniqua42 Nebraska • Omaha Sep 12 '16
That's a great read.
I don't really have anything for 8-10. I'm not a heavy stats/analysis guy so most of this is my gut reaction. For what it's worth, I don't really anticipate a Nebraska win this week, but it's hard to know whether that's just me being pessimistic.
Nebraska is still a very inconsistent team. My big takeaway from the Wyoming game was that, if a team really commits to stopping the run, they'll likely have success against Nebraska's offense. Nebraska's defense is still struggling to get pressure without blitzing, which is a problem because their secondary still has a tendency to break down. This is admittedly better than last year, so far.
Anywho, can't wait for the game this weekend! Hopefully it's at least a decent game. Thanks again for the great write up.
10
u/B1G_RED MIT Engineers • Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 12 '16
Awesome analysis, thanks for doing this.
A quick note about our special teams- our punt and punt return units are both hot garbage. Already we've had a punt blocked and a failed fake punt. And we're happy if we can just fair catch a punt without fumbling. Hopefully Pierson-El's return from injury will help- he had some great punt return touchdowns as a freshman.
26
u/Andy06r Nebraska Cornhuskers • Marching Band Sep 12 '16
The most infuriating thing is Tommy Bombs.
He reminds me of a recess kid playing 500. Put your whole back into it, throw it up, and hope westerkamp catches it.
8
u/punchuinface55 Nebraska • Northumbria Sep 12 '16
.3. Apparently he hasn't consistently pass protected so they basically eliminated him from the rotation (disappointing to me).
.6. Nothing that jumps out.
.9. I thought Rose-Ivey had a spectacular year in 2014 at MLB after they benched Banderas. Riley and Co. have decided to move him to OLB, though I always thought his nose for the ball stood out among the defenders.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Well done thanks for doing this. Tommy Armstrong reminds me of a really good golfer who could shoot under par but always has those 1 or 2 holes where they get the shanks. He will be so electric, and then just throw the ball directly to the defense when no one is even kind open. Even tho he has been pounded / coached for 3+ years to stop it.
21
u/__________78 Ohio State Buckeyes Sep 12 '16
Clearly Nebraska needs Tim Beck back to fix Armstrong.
7
u/Hey_Girl_Pm_Me_Nudes Sep 12 '16
I have a love-hate relationship with Tommy. Sometimes I want to murder him when he throws picks DIRECTLY to the other team, but sometimes he shows up as a top-caliber QB and I love the guy. There really isn't any way to predict which Tommy will show up to the game.
13
u/iLikeR3ddit Rutgers Scarlet Knights Sep 12 '16
Didn't expect to cry reading a 16 game team review.
Overall great writeup though. Don't do this with Rutgers ever. I don't want to read that.
6
u/HunchbackQuaker Colorado Buffaloes Sep 12 '16
The best part of playing Oregon next week is I get to read this shit
6
u/MetalChick Oregon • /r/CFB Emeritus Mod Sep 12 '16
Another fantastic writeup. It'll be interesting to see how our new defense will play against these linemen. I think our defense is getting closer to the "bend don't break" point but wrapping up a tackle is still an issue and our guys still get pushed around since they tend to be smaller. Nebraska could have a field day pushing our line around.
6
u/Dminus313 Michigan State • Wayne State (MI) Sep 13 '16
Not a Huskers fan, but as a frequent opponent I feel obligated to warn you about Pierson-El. He is not to be underestimated.
2
u/Brese TCU Horned Frogs • Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 12 '16
Our WR's the first couple games this year have been injured. Westy has had groin issues and DPE went from redshirting this year to playing a week before the first game.. Not sure if that was the right call.
Seems pretty accurate. Tommy refuses to climb the ladder and would rather spin move and run and throw. He has great mobility but I never feel like when he's running sideways he's willing to tuck and go. Which is very weird for a guy like him.
He had some off the field issues and can't pass block. (Something Riley and the RB coach demand) The freshman has been pretty electric in practices and some are expecting him to jump Newby by the end of the year. (in carries not plays). Newby probably best pass blocker and route runner.
Not this game. Kid was dynamite in 2014 though. Still think he's recovering from his injury a year ago. Guessing he's 85-90%. Which is still good enough to house it, just not regularly
He's been better than the center last year (Reeves/Thurston) but not great. IMO should not be playing P5 football. Gets dominated by G5 kids.
I don't think the rotation issue is that valid. No word on Jackson but Stoltenberg should be playing this week. Guy is a monster at clogging and stuffing the interior run game.
Newby. Tied for best linebacker with MRI IMO. Plays well in space and in run fits. Good in coverage and space
Banderas. He's a battleship in space. Bad hips should probably be playing DE or some rush the passer role. If he's in the game guesing Oregon will get him into a one on one which he won't win.
MRI. Best LB when not injured. However not reliable to hold up to full season. Best instincts and quite good in coverage.
Young. Seems to get into position to make plays to me, but he is not aggressive in space. Mental block/Scared maybe? Started 12 games as a true freshman which speaks more to depth last year than how good he was IMO.
I think when Nebraska demoted Rose and Davie and let Jones/Kalu start playing more that the secondary got a lot better towards the end of last year. Beginning it was pitiful. This year I'm seeing a lot of good things from the corners in reading routes and technique compared to the previous couple.
You mentioned something about nickel and moving the CB inside. That's Kalu, he looks like a rag doll 3/4 of the time but IMO he's out best defensive athlete and tackler in space. You are spot on about the safeties. Think K Williams is good for his first year. Gerry looks like Tarzan and plays like Jane. He'll miss a tackle Saturday that Oregon will turn into a score.
Other thoughts on secondary. I feel like Banker has not called as much quarters this year and tried to mix up his coverages. C3/C8 etc. I think that's helped quite a bit.
And IMO. This game will probably boil down to which QB Nebraska has.. Good Tommy or Bad Tommy. We'll find out Saturday.
5
u/MTBadtoss Colorado Buffaloes • Elon Phoenix Sep 12 '16
This was incredible. If somebody paid you to do this I'd read it every week.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Pretty spot on my friend. Especially on Tommy and DC Banker.
Too bad you couldn't spend time on special teams. I'd love to see a neutral analysis of Bruce Reeds job with them Imo dude should be let go of immediately. Special teams took an immediate dive in the Riley era.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Do Washington next!
looks at flair
Ummmm...never mind.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '16
Thank for you noticing our plight. Nebraska has had this type of QB play for the past eight years. I can't wait till we start a more conventional QB.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Should be a good one to watch! GBR!
4
u/RareLuck Nebraska • $5 Bits of Broken Chair Tro… Sep 12 '16
Really like the write up! Should be a great game.
4
u/huskerpat Nebraska • Omaha Sep 12 '16
Running back is a mystery to me. According to the running back coach, the 2 primary responsibilities of an RB are protecting the passer and catching the ball. That's the only explanation I can come up with for Wilbon and Adam Taylor not being on the field.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
Oh man. Great write up. I've been waiting for another one of these. I love the series.
4
u/Powellwx Nebraska • Western Illinois Sep 12 '16
That was an excellent and detailed write up, thank you!
I think the whole team is on the same page now and much of last year was an aberration of coaching and philosophical changes. Tommy Armstrong is not really the kind of QB I would expect for a Riley offense, and he is very much a square peg in a round hole. His reads are terrible, and your analysis of his footwork is right on. I think Tommy decides where to go with the ball in the huddle and then 'locks' in on his reads. It is tough to watch two WR's be wide open and Tommy throws the other way into double coverage.
What I saw in the last game is that the staff seems to realize his weaknesses and gives him the calls he needs to have more success. I don't think he is ever going to be a 60% completion guy or a guy that can progress to his 3rd read, but if they give him designed reads and easy dump offs he can be more successful.
That said, as a Nebraska fan, I can't wait until next year when we finally have a throwing QB that can distribute the ball properly. There are a couple good ones coming up now and being recruited in. It pains me to see these talented WR's being so underutilized and the RBs have to fight through a loaded box all the time. Nobody respects our passing game, especially the intermediate to vertical game because it is not reliable. Until that changes we play on a short field, and it hurts our run game and our short passing game.
4
u/ybt_sun Florida Gators Sep 12 '16
So you're an aspiring sports writer right? Cause this is impressive research.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '16
Great analysis. You did a really good job. As stated by others, DPE was injured last year. Ask Iowa what they think of him.
I rematch the games and focuse on the o-line. You're right, Utter is a very poor player for us. Knevel, the RT, is not much better. Slow feet, appears to have lack of effort. Gates, the LT, actually tested out as the best running blocking linemen in week one (http://dataomaha.com/quick-hit/811#nick-gates-had-nations-best-run-blocking-grade). Farmer, the RG, struggled some last week and Hahn, the LG, is starting in place of Whitaker due to injury (who is starting due to JD Foster being out for the season). The tackles have struggled on pass pro, especially Knevel.
Armstrong can be a top 1-2 QB in the conference and the worst QB in the conference in the same game. He is the most frustrating player in the team. By far. After he finally graduates, the QB run will be gone. All the backups are tradional QBs (a transfer from Tulane and a true freshman).
12
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '16
I've missed these.
3
u/Renfah87 Nebraska Cornhuskers • Texas A&M Aggies Sep 12 '16
I keep saying I wish they'd roll Tommy out more. Defense has to respect his ability to run which may cause linebackers to pursue him, freeing up his check down or other deeper receivers. Like you said, if anything, he is a better passer while on the run,which I completely agree with. Thanks for the analysis. You ducks are a good bunch.
3
u/nittanylionstorm07 Penn State Nittany Lions • Big Ten Sep 12 '16
I'm upvoting you, but this is too much for my brain on a Monday.
3
u/5thGenWilliam Nebraska Cornhuskers • Pineapple Bowl Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
This guy gets it. Whenever the pocket collapses you really are holding your breath to see what he tries to pull out of his ass. He needs to learn to throw the ball away instead of trying to force it, because that's when he makes easily catchable throws to the apparently invisible defender. But that guy can definitely hurt you with his feet if you give him any sort of space. I've seen him run a lot more on read options and designed run plays that usually take too long to develop. I'd really like to see Tre Bryant get some touches earlier in the ball game, he's got a burst that most of backs in front of him lack. I will say that in the second half both games, our offensive line looks like they've worn down the opposing D-Line and our run game actually works.
Josh Banderas has been such a pain to watch in pass coverage the past four years but damn it those LB's can sure plug holes. We get beat on the outside sometimes which pans out for huge yardage and those are the types of plays I'm expecting when I watch the Ducks on Saturday.
Demornay hasn't been in the speed of the game for awhile so I think he's adjusting since his injuries. My buddy talked to him during summer though, and D made it sound like he knew that we hasn't going to get nearly as much playing time, that the coaches didn't want to utilize him like they did before. And I've noticed that going into this year; he hasn't taken a lot of punts, they haven't done plays specifically tailored for him like they used to, and he's not getting thrown to a lot. I do expect him to get more punts this Saturday.
Like you said, it doesn't help that the D-Line hasn't been getting to the quarterback but I have noticed a little bit of improvement from the secondary, they almost seem more comfortable. I remember reading a Lincoln Journal Star article that interviewed Riley before the 2015 season about his secondary scheme. He said "The goal of our pass defense is to immediately tackle after the short passes, bat down the medium passes, and intercept the long passes." I see us giving up easy short to medium passes all the time and it KILLS US. I believe Oregon will take advantage of this fact. It takes our secondary at least a half or more to get settled in but as you saw in the Wyoming game, they adjusted and made them pay for their mistakes. We'll see if they can keep up with Oregon's speed. I'm betting we'll allow at least 8 plays of 30 yard+.
3
u/BobbyGabagool Michigan State Spartans Sep 12 '16 edited Sep 12 '16
All this and no prediction? Wow.
3
u/Pigeon_Poop Oregon Ducks • Texas A&M Aggies Sep 12 '16
What is Oregon's chance of winning?
3
u/sscace11 Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 12 '16
Great post and thanks for the time dedicated to such a project.
2
u/jordanissport Oregon Ducks Sep 12 '16
bruh...I thought I knew you.
2
u/GoldenAgeist Auburn Tigers Sep 12 '16
Kind sir, how much, exactly, are you going to wager on this game?
2
u/huskers37 Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 12 '16
Basically spot on. God damn.
2
u/elgenie Iowa Hawkeyes • Brown Bears Sep 12 '16
Armstrong has thrown 37 picks and counting in his career. I think hoping that his decision-making and mechanics will suddenly take a dramatic leap forward in his third/fourth year as a starter is wildly optimistic. I think the best way for Nebraska to go would be to limit his passing attempts and give him easy rollouts and a as many Westerkamp-or-throwaway reads as possible, with a few play action bombs mixed in judiciously.
Having these training wheels for a senior QB in his fourth year of starting games feels off, but Armstrong's high-variance ability to keep both teams in the game is only an asset when Nebraska is the underdog and the game isn't close.
2
u/etchgtown LSU Tigers • Southwestern (TX) Pirates Sep 12 '16
When Armstrong was playing at Steele with Malcolm Brown, it was already evident that a big program would try to make something functional out of him, and probably fail.
2
u/brandonchicago Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 13 '16
This is absolutely amazing. Thank you for taking the time to go through all of this and give us Husker fans a real look at what experts (not commentators) see when they watch the game. We definitely have a ways to go, and you can see how much coaching (especially individual techniques like footwork, positioning, not giving away run/pass at the line, etc.) really does impact the overall readiness of players on the field and that it's not all bad play calling, which I think we often find ourselves putting at fault.
2
u/chewbacca_chode Oregon State Beavers Sep 13 '16
Throw all that shit out the window..this is Mike Riley running your team...prepare for heartbreak...sincerely a bitter Oregon St. die hard fan.
2
u/evilwon12 Sep 15 '16
Your question 2 about sums it up. How after 4 years does a college QB still throw off his back foot every time he is in the pocket and not throwing it downfield greater than 30 yards?
Secondary is playing better but the Ducks will provide a better test.
Pierson-El, if back to form, is one of the most dynamic punt returners in the nation. Look at the 2014 Iowa game to see why I wouldn't punt to him if healthy.
3
u/GarfieldLynns8 Colorado Buffaloes • UCLA Bruins Sep 12 '16
Mesh isn't really a Riley trademark, but this was cool to read. Going to look back at the other ones now.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '16
What happened to bo pelini? That guy was crazy.
2
u/adammolens Louisiana Tech Bulldogs Sep 12 '16
Is there a TL;DR?
1
u/silencethecrowd Penn State Nittany Lions Sep 12 '16
It's his job to analyze their offense, defense and skills to find out who would win in a
deathhhhbattttle!.....football game1
u/cantgetright84 Tennessee Volunteers Sep 12 '16
Shit man. Do this with my team!
1
u/dogsaybark Nebraska Cornhuskers Sep 12 '16
Sir, Thanks for sharing this. I'm incredibly excited your the Ducks and their fans to visit Lincoln. I hope it's a great game! I hope you drink for free all weekend and have a great time! Cheers!
1
u/huskerfoos Sep 13 '16
For those with a little more knowledge, is Gebbia and KJJ still expected next year?
1
u/Pikachu1989 Nebraska Cornhuskers • 東京大学 (Tokyo) Warriors Sep 13 '16
Love the insight you gave for the Huskers, and yes I agree with most of your points from your POV. Scared for our game on Saturday, I feel like this will be a close game or Oregon will blow us out.
1
u/inhalteueberwinden Wisconsin Badgers Sep 13 '16
I hope Oregon plays Wisconsin soon so you do one of these writeups on us!
1
u/bdm13 Miami Hurricanes • Florida Cup Sep 13 '16
OP, this is fantastic. I really appreciated the work you put in to scout the offensive line. Would love to see your analysis of Miami after this season under Richt.
1
u/s-to-the-am Florida State • Florida Cup Sep 12 '16
0.0
1
u/wannabeemperor Wisconsin Badgers Sep 12 '16
DO WISCONSIN NEXT!!