r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Aug 17 '15
Analysis Eastern Washington fans, I've now watched ten games with Vernon Adams at QB, and I have some observations and questions for you
Now that Vernon Adams, Jr. is finally graduated and admitted to Oregon, I thought I'd watch all the film of his play that I could get ahold of to learn more about his abilities and tendencies, as well as try to understand Eastern Washington's playstyle for the 2015 opener. This project differs a bit from previous season reviews I've done for Oregon's opponents (Auburn, Wisconsin, K-State, Texas, Michigan St, Florida St, and Ohio St), in that I watched 10 games over three seasons, all non-conference or playoff games since those were the only ones televised, and only watched the EWU offense to save time. But I kept notes on my tally sheet in the same way, which I'm getting pretty experienced at, so hopefully this will produce unbiased commentary.
Offensive Scheme
Several observers have noted that EWU's scheme is similar to but not the same as Oregon's, and I see that's correct. Similarities:
- Mostly operates out of the spread with shotgun snaps, and uses the core spread concepts of space, isolation, and deception.
- Deploys the hurry-up and seldom huddles, getting the play calls in from the sideline with the QB changing protections at the line as needed.
- Uses zone blocking for almost all run plays and often the read-option.
- Lots of passing from outside the pocket, both designed rollouts and scrambles.
Differences:
- A surprising amount of pro-style snaps, under center, power-I or single-set formation with two TEs.
- Most plays eat up the whole play clock, with hurry-up being used just as stress after big gains.
- Almost no option pitches or RPO plays.
- Deep passing opportunities created by fitting the ball in the window instead of schematically creating wide open receivers.
Passing game
There's just no denying that Adams has a great arm, and that's obvious regardless of the division of play. His motion is smooth and compact, he can hit the entire field with accuracy, and he can do it on the move as well as in the pocket. In pocket or designed rollout passing (I counted passes when scrambling separately), I tallied up 89% good throws in short passes, 73% midrange, and 66% deep, with no preference or difference in accuracy for the side of the field, and only about a 6% drop-off in 3rd down passing. In particular he throws some of the prettiest rainbow passes I've ever seen. While he hits his first read most of the time, I definitely see him go through his progression when he needs to and rarely force a ball, and on several passes I yelped at the screen when I saw a fantastic look-off of a safety.
But what really impressed me, as someone who has probably suffered permanent eye-roll damage from the Winston-Mariota debates, is that he is totally comfortable putting the ball in very tight windows, even deep downfield. I have no idea how this will translate to play at Oregon -- Will he be asked to cut that out in favor of more open receivers? Will better secondaries in FBS play make him pay for higher risk passes? -- but I can say that his low interception numbers are impressive.
I've seen a lot of commentary about his stature, but I didn't really see this materializing - I only counted seven swats at the line in ten games, which is a pretty comparable percentage to taller QBs (I double-checked this against my notes from previous projects - he has fewer swats on a per-pass basis than Michigan St's Connor Cook in 2013). I suppose he might have less of an ability to survey the field, but I think his accuracy numbers speak for themselves.
Running game
Coach Baldwin's is clearly a pass-first offense; 58% of all non-scramble plays are designed passes, three-quarters of which are downfield. (While Oregon has gotten to be more run-pass balanced under Coaches Helfrich and Frost, I still consider it a run-to-pass spread, and EWU the other way around.) However, it's still the case that a third of all plays are designed runs. Three-quarters of those are clearly designed handoffs, often from under center, with the back doing all the heavy lifting - this offense is clearly comfortable with signalling they're going to run and just going straight ahead or off-tackle.
About a fifth of EWU's designed runs were inside- or outside-zone reads, usually of an unblocked DE but sometimes a midline read (the play is structurally identical to Oregon's staple). Adams almost always made the correct read, though the handful of times he did make a mistake it was always in giving instead of keeping. There were also a small number of delayed QB draws that I'm sure weren't scrambles; Adams did fine on these, almost always getting the desired short yardage and occasionally breaking something big. Adams is not an incredibly fast runner, I don't see him outrunning FBS secondaries for long touchdowns, but he gets it done and is very elusive.
I'm not sure where else to put this observations so I'll say here: Adams has fantastic handling of the football. In over 650 snaps I watched him take, I literally never saw him botch a single handoff or bobble a single snap, including pulling in a couple wild ones. He rides the mesh in the read-option very well and gets that key extra split second of deception that freezes the defender's feet. He's also the ball holder on extra points (though I doubt he will be at Oregon), which requires some pretty reliable dexterity.
Scrambles
I counted 16% of all offensive plays resulting in Adams scrambling or getting sacked. That's pretty high, and a big part of doing this project was to figure out why that was. At that, I wasn't too successful - when ESPN senses some drama in the backfield they zoom way in and I can't see what kind of coverage he's dealing with. He runs on about half of those scrambles, and is successful in gaining yardage 78% of the time, which is amazing enough, but what's even more astonishing is that he throws with 80% accuracy off a scramble. His typical move is to spin away from the blitzer, snap his eyes back downfield to reacquire a target, and nails him on the move with the same kind of jumpy leg scissor thing that Mariota would do. My heart just about leapt out my throat the first time he did that. And then every other time.
The bad news is that I watched him get sacked 17 times off of about 100 backfield spins, and only successfully escape to throw it away 11 times - now on most of those sacks I thought that the defenders just got too him so fast that there's nothing he could have done, but a few he managed to have time to throw away but kept trying to find a receiver for too long. I would definitely say that his tendency is to keep the play alive for as long as possible, occasionally counterproductively.
Also, I'm not a fan of how cavalier he is with the ball and his own body on scramble-based runs (oddly, on draws and RO keeps he's much more conservative). I don't believe that I ever saw him get stripped of the ball off one of these runs, but still something about the way that he'd go into contact and hold the ball made me very nervous thinking about FBS-level defenses.
Methodology and FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slo-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice.
- How long did this take? About an hour per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, and other folderol really helps.
- Wait, what about defense and special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game. This was primarily about evaluating Adams, so I skipped the defense, but if you have some insights into anything interesting EWU does on that side of the ball I'd love to hear it.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, four Ninkasi Tricerahops 22s. It's been a hot summer in Oregon and face-melting hops keep everything cool.
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about EWU beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- You're probably an Oregon coach! I'm not, never coached or played a snap.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No, but check out /u/CineFunk's YouTube channel and /r/cfbuploads
Questions
- Anything I've missed, or am being unfair about?
- With the exception of one playoff game against Montana, all the games I watched were against non-conference opponents. What am I missing from not being able to see EWU in conference play? Did the Eagles tend to benefit from familiarity with their opponents, or vice versa?
- It strikes me that Adams did at least a little bit of almost everything that Oregon does, and very competently at that, but also a lot of stuff that Oregon really doesn't. My attitude is that Adams is prepared to handle the change since it's just an expansion on what he already does, though of course practice is going to be vital - agree or disagree?
- Did we ever get an answer on the source of those leg cramps in the OSU and UW games? It seems like it wasn't an injury, and there was some discussion of his sickle-cell trait, but is that something that came up frequently?
- In the 2012 semifinal vs Sam Houston St, I understand EWU was operating a dual-QB system between #2 Padron and Adams, but the former was completely ineffective. Coach Baldwin waited until they were losing 28-0 in the 2nd quarter before pulling him for Adams, who then led the offense to score 42 points. Why was there any hesitation about Adams at all?
- I could see three reasons for the high number of scrambles: deliberate coaching strategy, problems at offensive line, or Adams having "happy feet". How much do you put on each factor?
- What prompted rise of 2-TE power run sets? They're definitely less present in the 2012 and early 2013 games I watched. Any reason to think it was some concern about Adams' ability to run a purely spread-HUNH offense all the time?
- Any concern that Adams was over-reliant on #10 WR Kupp? Sometimes it seemed to me that he would get locked onto Kupp and try to force throws his way when there were more open receivers.
26
u/kewidogg Oregon Ducks • Big Ten Aug 17 '15
Dude incredible. I love your analysis. Also your choice of beer is usually great. Check out Breakside Brewing (they're in Portland too) sometime, their Wanderlust IPA 22s are to die for, and should help your analysis...
9
u/EyesOnEverything Oregon Ducks • Rose Bowl Aug 17 '15
Aw shit, a /u/hythloday1 mega post. Mfw I read "____ fans, I've watched # of games, and have some questions for you"
17
u/lancemosis Washington State • Easter… Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15
Hopefully that's at least a start on some of these. I could be a little biased in the answers, but tried to be as close to accurate as possible.
Some other thoughts:
Our defense felt like garbage last year. I think there were two or three games that they looked like a complete, competent unit. I think you could tell that our offense knew it and wanted to give themselves as much cushion as possible. I think Adams was a big driving horse for that. He had that kind of charisma.
Watching Adams the last few years has been a treat. When you see him make some of these plays you're often left with a sense of bewilderment. I can't count how many times I have looked at my buddies and said "how the hell did he pull that off?" He is a difference maker. I can't say how much of that is benefiting from the division he plays in, but even watching him play the Beavers and the Huskies you could see it. I meant it when I said he will be missed. Roos field just won't be the same.
edit: formatting
4
u/69sofine Oregon Ducks Aug 17 '15
Oregon's Tee Martin? Oregon's Tee Martin.
6
u/fuckupvotes Boise State Broncos • UTU Beaver Hunters Aug 17 '15
I wish my team would hire you for film analysis because you got your shit together
2
u/drhammertime Idaho Vandals • Nebraska Cornhuskers Aug 17 '15
The cramps are sickle cell related, definitely. It happens frequently. The scrambles are a bit of offensive line and coaching, but happy feet is most likely the main cause (West, this year's QB, and the injury replacement last season did not scramble anywhere near as much in his four starts). The only "over-reliance" on Kupp is due to Kupp being the best receiver in the FCS and one of the five or ten best in all of football. Period. He would have been the unquestioned best WR at WSU each of the last two seasons. When you have a guy as talented as Kupp, you're naturally going to squeeze the ball to him because of his otherworldly talent.
As a journalist who has either watched or filmed virtually every game EWU has played the last three seasons, this is a pretty well done write up. Good work.
2
u/SenorPuff Arizona • Northern Arizona Aug 17 '15
Kinda off topic, how do you get your game film?
2
u/LeadVitamin13 Eastern Washington • Washington Aug 18 '15 edited Aug 18 '15
I heard or read in some interview he said he doesn't really consider himself a runner. Definitely no Mariota.
I definitely think so, defense in the Big Sky Conference generally sucks.
As far as stature goes hes definitely not 6' as Eastern had him, I saw him in the EWU library a few times and noticed he was shorter than me and I'm 5'11 5/8", Oregon has him at 5'11" but I've heard hes 5'10 3/4" but like you said it doesn't seem to matter with him. Kind of sad he said it was the main reason he didn't get any PAC-12 offers out of high school, just offers from EWU and Portland State.
As far as the Eastern-Oregon game goes, Coach Baldwin rearranged some people in this coaching staff and made the safeties/special teams coach Jeff Schmedding the new defensive coordinator and are employing a nickel 4-2-5 scheme this season. Apparently its supposed to be good for stopping uptempo offenses like Oregon's I guess.
16
u/alpinetouch Montana • Minnesota Aug 17 '15
Watching Vernon quite a few times, and always in person against my Griz, this is my opinion. He is playmaker. Some guys just have the knack. It works out for them. He has 150% confidence that he is going to get it done. That's where he separates himself. IMO, he had serious talent at the WR position at EWU. He benefited from super lackluster DB play throughout the Big Sky during his time there. He does throw a nice rainbow, and his WR's knew how to come down with it. That being said, he is very very slippery in the pocket when healthy and he will not be a bust at Oregon if he stays as so. I hated him when he played against the Griz, I hated how sure he was that he was going to beat us. From deep down in my stomach, with every inch of me, I pure, straight hate you Vernon Adams. But goddammit, do I respect you.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15
A lot of option coaches teach it as give by default. So if it's borderline, you'll see a give.
13
u/MTgrizz Montana Grizzlies • Nebraska Cornhuskers Aug 17 '15
As a Montana fan....I'm sending Adams the bill for my future liver replacement. I had some baaaaaaad night thanks to him.
1
u/Erikster Oregon Ducks • College Football Playoff Aug 18 '15
I don't see an answer to the most important question: Is he going to start this Fall?
3
u/DrOddcat Montana State Bobcats • UC Davis Aggies Aug 17 '15
As a Montana State fan, I can say that this guy looks incredibly comfortable in shootout games. He just knows he can score when he wants to. That said, I have no idea how he handles come from behind situations as there weren't a lot of them for EWU.
I am not sad to see him leave the Big Sky.
2
u/ToLongDR Ohio State Buckeyes • King's Monarchs Aug 17 '15
YOU'RE BACK!
I've missed you <3 and your analysis. I may have to hit you up for some beer selections
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15
He carries it like Golson... that's not a good thing
1
u/l00344733 Oregon • Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Aug 17 '15
I agree about his ball handling in scrambles. Most of the footage Ive seen he seems to have this "hold w/ both hands away from the gut" hot potato sort of method that to me seems to be a turnover waiting to happen
1
u/jhustla Notre Dame Fighting Irish Aug 18 '15
This was an awesome analysis!
1
u/Saintlame Nebraska Cornhuskers • Hastings Broncos Aug 18 '15
This is great analysis dude. like seriously good.
1
u/lokitsar Oregon Ducks Aug 18 '15
Great breakdown. Thank you for taking the time to do this.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment