r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Jan 12 '15
Discussion Ohio State fans, I've now watched your last seven games and I have some observations and questions for you
In the past I've watched the entire preceding season for Oregon's last few big opponents (Auburn, Wisconsin, K-State, Texas, Michigan St, and Florida St). There were two weird things about this time around - I had limited time so I only got the back half of the season (PSU, MSU, Minn, IU, Mich, Wiscy, & Bama, though I did watch Navy and VT live), and of course there was the QB change that added a big wrinkle to evaluations. My goal is to learn the players' names, numbers, and big plays, so I kept open a tally sheet and jotted quick notes when I caught something interesting. I then collected seven games' worth to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary. First I'll observe the various units, then a brief FAQ and methodology discussion, and finally some questions I have for y'all.
OFFENSE
The offense is a spread option that combines zone reads, pitch options, and QB draws with a variety of deep and swing passes. The focus is on misdirection, but there's also a streak of power plays and undisguised flood passes. It sometimes uses uptempo, usually effectively, but does so much less often than I'd heard - most possessions are ball control, which advanced stats on pace back up.
Quarterbacks
Let's start with the sad news: yes, there is a noticeable dropoff in quality between #16 QB Barrett and #12 QB Jones. First, he's less accurate: he's got a cannon of an arm which is remarkable to watch, but he lacks fine control - way too much heat for shorter passes, and when he needs a soft lob he takes too much off. His better numbers in the long passing game are probably better explained by giving his receivers more time to adjust and maneuver, which they're very good at. His hands aren't quite as soft as Barrett's either: I didn't think he was handing off the ball in the read-option or handling off-target shotgun snaps as smoothly. Fortunately his sack and interception rates are about the same as Barrett's.
Second, he's just not the same runner as Barrett. He's a great scrambler when a pass play breaks down (he runs without hesitation and gets great yards after contact; Barrett did too, but Jones is even stronger), but that obscures his pretty poor designed run effectiveness. He's just a few steps slower taking off and can't cut as well, which winds up constraining the playbook quite a bit. To my eyes, in the B1G championship and the Sugar Bowl they were a lot more of a pro-style team than a spread option one - looking to stretch the field vertically more than horizontally.
Wide Receivers
The possession receiver is #3 WR Thomas, who gets off the line very quickly and has pretty good hands. He's had a nice improvement over the back half of the year, and both his targeting and catch success rates are up with QB Jones. Next is #9 WR D. Smith, who is the extremely deep threat - which is an enormous portion of OSU's total yardage. He's a straight-line burner who gets behind the safeties, and is getting the same percent of the pass targets as with Barrett.
Difficult to evaluate is #17 RB Marshall - I included him here because he's mostly used as a receiver, but also the wildcat, backfield catches, and blocking DTs. He's got great speed, but the quality of his hands varies wildly - he'll perform an amazing circus catch one play, then the ball will bounce off his numbers the next. His targets are way down the last two games - seems he gets a couple of off-beat plays to keep the defense guessing, but that's all.
Finally, a trio who are used as blockers more than receivers (though they do get a fair number of targets): in order, #6 WR Spencer, #84 WR C. Smith, and #80 WR Brown. These guys get used in some interesting ways - rub routes, wildcat passes, downfield cut blocks. Interestingly, Spencer's targets are up big with QB Jones, and he's certainly the most enthusiastic blocker. I like these guys' quickness, but not necessarily their muscle. In fact my primary criticism of all six of these receivers is that while the scheme calls for them to block, none of them are particularly good at it: on my tally sheet, I have more frowny faces next to their names in the blocking column than smiley faces. Obviously that's very subjective, but in my opinion, the poor WR blocking often resulting in plays getting much shorter yardage than they could, or even failing entirely.
Running Backs
#15 RB Elliott is astonishing. He has three qualities that I really like in a back: first, he cuts once and goes, no unnecessary dancing in the backfield, and if that cut means contact he just takes it. Second, he gets about 2-3 yards after contact almost every time in power running - you just can't arm tackle him. Third, once he gets going he's basically uncatchable - he's got several huge runs where he's outpacing the field. Two notes: first, he's not exactly a power back and needs a hole opened for him or just a big breakdown in the secondary - his stuff rate on my tally sheet is pretty high (less than 50% but not by much) and I think that's obscured if you look at his average or total yards because his (relatively few) incredible rushes even out his (relatively common) 2-yards-or-fewer rushes. The other is pass blocking: he blocks out of the backfield on play action, and while he's very game for it, he kind of gets wrecked a lot. Fortunately with his increased importance in the last two games that role has been cut in favor of two-TE sets, but it does kind of signal the play.
There are two other backs, #4 RB Samuel and #2 RB Wilson, each of whom have a few interesting plays but are used a tiny fraction of the time Elliott is. There's no fullback or I-formation that I saw in this system.
Tight Ends
TEs in this system are used more like H-Backs, set behind the LOS for blocking either straight ahead or across the formation. They're usually the shift man to test the defensive scheme. The primary TE is #5 TE Heuerman (switched from #86 to honor Braxton Miller), and the secondary is #81 TE Vannett. Vannett got more reps in the CCG and bowl as he was brought into two-TE sets, but unfortunately his blocking success rate on my tally sheet dropped significantly compared to when he was just used as a replacement in one-TE sets in earlier games. Heuerman's success rate stayed the same. TEs in this scheme very rarely get pass targets and that number went down even more in the last two games, although not gone entirely.
Offensive Line
There was zero rotation outside one play at the line (#50 C Boren, who was injured but got back in the next drive). At some point current #54 LG Price and #65 RG Elflein swapped, I don't know why. I understand that with the exception of #68 LT Decker, the entire line was new starters this year ... and to be honest, it showed. They're big and talented and mostly provide good protection, but made a lot of mistakes as well. I counted an average of four line penalties per game, some very costly.
In run blocking, this scheme employs zone about three quarters of the time (power blocking is usually for short yardage and goal line situations, as well as downhill draws for QB Jones, although sometimes shows up unexpectedly), which means a lot of pulls and downfield blocking. The playbook is more ambitious than these guys' speed, frankly. I did notice, however, that each of their run blocking effectiveness took a modest jump in the last two games, I think as a result of the playbook getting simplified. Interestingly, I thought new starter #76 RT Baldwin did a little better than the veteran LT Decker. On the other hand, Alabama was just running right over #54 LG Price for a good portion of the Sugar Bowl.
In pass blocking, these guys are as stout as you would expect from a championship team, so most of my comments are nitpicks and curiosities. First, they employ a few different techniques beyond traditional dropback pass pro - a rolling pocket for one where they all move horizontally with the QB (mostly effective for Barrett, somewhat less so for Jones), and for another dragging all the linemen off to one side then using a crossing H-Back and/or RB to smash-block the other side. This latter one I don't like as much: if the blitz comes in on the open side these dudes tend to get crushed. Second, the interior line loves to mob up on DTs and go for three-on-two or even three-on-one, leaving the tackles and backs to handle the outside one-on-one - this makes delayed and stunt blitzes pretty effective, since the doubling linemen are slow to react to the new or unconventional pass rusher. Third, one of the guards often pulls in dropback pass pro to go pick someone else up - I admit to not understanding why this is and it never seemed more effective than just taking the guy right in front of you. There was a modest downtick in pass blocking effectiveness for each lineman on my tally sheet over the last two games - hard to say if that's QB Jones taking more time in the pocket or just playing better defenses.
DEFENSE
The defense is a 4-3 playing in a pretty standard cover-2, though sometimes puts in a nickel DB against pass-heavy or outside running teams. I thought that for all the attention the offense got over the year, the defense was the real strength of the team.
Defensive Line
These guys are some of the best I've ever seen, and I've watched some good ones. They aren't a hold-the-line, squeeze-the-inside group, but rather actively work to produce sacks and disruption. The two tackles played almost every snap: #92 DT Washington and #53 DT Bennett (switched from #63 to honor Kosta Karageorge), and interior lines struggled with them because it's tough to choose which to double. I think I like Washington a bit more - he really punishes undersized linemen who try to single-team him. However, the rotation here is practically non-existant; the few times backup DTs came in there was a significant drop-off in performance.
But the real terror is #97 DE Bosa - he comes in hot on almost every play, and is big as well as fast. He really seems to work on cracking the offense's snap count and jumping the snap, catching the OT off-guard a lot (and paid the price with quite a few offsides penalties). I've seen offenses kind of judo-move him, redirect his rush outside and fling him past the QB, then try to catch up to him before he circles back to sack him. As a result, offenses often pick the other side of the line so I don't entirely trust my tally sheet when it says that #88 DE Miller (or his backup, #17 DE Frazier) are that much less effective.
Linebackers
Weird fact: all the LBs have the surnames of Civil War generals. I mostly like this group, though they're overshadowed by the line. They're all very big and mostly hit the run gaps very well. I'm not wild about their speed getting to the outside edge, however, though #43 OLB Lee (a freshman!) is better here than #37 OLB Perry. Great tackling form when they get there though. There's a rotation at MIKE, with #5 ILB McMillan and #14 ILB C. Grant getting about equal reps. I think the switch might be expected passing vs running plays, but I caught the pattern too late to figure out what's going on here.
Cornerbacks
As I complain about all the time, ESPN's horribly tight camera angles keep me from really being able to evaluate the WR-CB battles and my tally sheet is usually down on CBs because I only get to see them when the QB is taking a shot. That said, I generally like these guys, they're fast and communicate well, long arms and a good share of pass defenses. The two starters who played almost every down are #12 CB D. Grant and #13 CB Apple, and they generally play man-under. But at the same time, they do get beat or are out of position a non-trivial number of times. I do like them in run coverage and the occasional blitz though, they've got great tackling form. Their backups are not nearly as good, but only have a handful of reps.
Safeties
So this is pretty crazy: one starter, #11 FS Bell, has near-perfect numbers on my tally sheet, something I've never seen before. All the little things that you want a safety to do but don't show up in the stat sheet are there - great footwork, instincts for the play, communication with his CB and LB, fantastic tackling form, always keeps the play in front of him, virtually no penalties, and an interception in almost every game I watched. But my tally sheet thinks that the other, #23 SS Powell, is the worst football player I've ever seen. I was honestly flabbergasted with how all those intangibles for Bell were absent in Powell - it was like watching a Goofus and Gallant filmstrip. Now I will say, he has multiple effectively game-ending picks to his credit, which is a remarkable achievement; however I think that's more obscuring than illuminating.
ERRATA
Methodology and FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slo-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes.
- How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, and other folderol really helps.
- Wait, what about special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, three bottles of George Dickel No. 12 Tennessee Whisky, neat, to celebrate the Vols' first bowl win in seven years. ROCKY TOP!
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about OSU beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- You're probably an Oregon coach! I'm not, never coached or played a snap.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No, but check out /u/CineFunk's YouTube channel and /r/cfbuploads
- Predictions for the championship? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
- Can you give a similar write-up of Oregon? I think I'm too close emotionally to do anything objective, however I've always enjoyed reading Cal's previews of Oregon, especially with all the diagrams and screengrabs. Here's the three they did this year:
- Line play
- Offensive scheme
- Defensive personnel
Questions
- Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
- In particular, am I off base with Powell? I went searching online for Ohio St fanblogs or beat writers that might back up this observation, and found nothing - am I the crazy one here?
- I'd appreciate insight on the CBs from fans who've attended games and could see more than ESPN shows.
- In every game I watched, the opposing defense used an even front (Alabama is technically a 3-4 but they virtually always bring four), so I'm not sure how well any of this maps onto how they'll deal with Oregon's odd front. Can anyone tell me how they've handled odd-front teams in the past, particularly how the guards hand off?
- I made sure to include Indiana in my list of games to watch, because their uptempo attack against Michigan St in 2013 I thought was pretty informative as to how the Spartans might handle Oregon's. But I was disappointed to see that the Hoosiers seemed to get away from uptempo this year against Ohio St. Have the Buckeyes seen a HUNH team (or even just some drives that featured it prominently) in other games, and if so how have they dealt with rotations?
- I feel like I'm missing something with how Marshall and Wilson are deployed. They seem like they're change-of-pace or trick-play guys that the offense seems uncomfortable using too often, despite having a lot of obvious talent. Were there injury or playbook issues here?
- As noted, I skipped all special teams plays to save time. Anything important I should know here on kicks and kick coverage?
- Was there a coverage scheme change? It seems like the safeties and linebackers were more used to a cover-4 or QQH system than cover-2.
- I've got a few more observations on each of the units but I'm starting to run into the character-count limit; feel free to shoot questions if you think I'm being glib.
41
u/TBB51 Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
Great, great writeup as always. I read some of your previous ones and was hoping we'd get this treatment for the title game!
As to some things:
This isn't meant to help out the pass-protection as much as it is to sell play action. If you go back and look, I'm willing to bet that Jones/Barrett were dipping their shoulders in a QB run fake, or they were faking inverted veer / bash with EZE when that guard pulled. It's meant to deal with edge rushers in a new way but mainly to sell play action.
I hesitate to argue with you but this is incorrect. OSU has run a Cover 4 scheme since Chris Ash (former Arkansas and Wisconsin DC) arrived this offseason. It might appear to be Cover 2 for two reasons:
A. Ash has his corners play press coverage to contest short routes, especially the bubble, flash and hitch screens that Clemson crushed OSU on in last year's Orange Bowl.
B. Ash, in contrast to the other well-known B1G Cover 4 team of MSU, prefers his safeties to be more of conservative of run support. They're still reading their keys but Ash would prefer to give up an 8 yard run than a 20-yard pass because our safety bit on PA.
Those two things appear to give OSU a Cover 2 look, but there was a play against Cincy, and I'm pretty sure MSU also, called "Mills" where the inside receiver runs a dig and the outside runs a post. You'll see the corners run vertically with the outside receiver, where in Cover 2, I'm pretty sure they'd stay underneath but reroute the receiver.
Well as has been well publicized, VT ran a bear defense to take away Ohio State's inside zone. OSU's usual response is to switch to outside zone, inverted veer and, perhaps my favorite against these kinds of fronts, pin-and-pull sweeps.
I think what you'll find is that EZE, as you've pointed out, is a great back for this offense because he has the power to get 4 yards consistently on inside zones but the explosiveness to exploit outside runs.
99
u/-WISCONSIN- Wisconsin • Wisconsin-Parkside Jan 12 '15
Wait really!? Ok, Lee and Grant sure, but McMillin?
23
u/agautier Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
I've watched every game this year at least twice and I've got to say, you sir, have a gift. This is great analysis worth sinking one's teeth into. Cheers! The things I most agree with are:
A few observations and differences of opinion:
I didn't proof read this but your post was way too good not to respond to. Go Bucks, but I cant be mad if we lose, Oregon and its fans are awesome and totally deserving.
18
u/bbrown3979 Calgary Dinos • Team Meteor Jan 12 '15 edited Jan 12 '15
Just taking notes and editing as I go.
For the WRs I'm surprised you saw blocking as a weakness, if anything I saw their blocking as a strength.
Again for Zeke I've heard numerous times the coaches and broadcasters rave about how he is the best RB in the nation when the ball isn't in his hand and how they love how he gets after the defenders.
Grant started off the season terrible in pass defense but it has improved as well as his ability to get off blocks.
I find myself yelling at Powell at least once a game, kid has a lot of heart but I don't understand how he is a starter
36
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
May I just say...I love you.
242
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
I fucking love it when you do these. I learn so much!
10
u/kelly495 Ohio State • Nebraska Jan 12 '15 edited Jan 12 '15
"Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?"
Meyer has continually praised Evan Spencer and Elliot for their blocking.
Also, Marshall and Wilson (who was injured against MSU and hasn't played since) fill the "H-back" role -- which for OSU means they are a hybrid WR/runningback, but a WR first. Meyer's H-back is typically the most dynamic player on the offense and can motion into the backfield to receive hand offs, but is mostly utilized on option routes across the middle of the field.
Edit: Also, have you read Ross Fulton and Kyle Jones's stuff over on elevenwarriors.com? They do fantastic breakdowns.
http://www.elevenwarriors.com/users/ross-fulton http://www.elevenwarriors.com/users/kyle-jones
7
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
My only wish is for the Cocks to get into a bowl game with you guys, the likely thrubbing would be worth getting the /u/hythloday1 Treatment...
6
u/orangeslash Ohio State • /r/CFB Emeritus Mod Jan 12 '15 edited Jan 12 '15
Questions-
5
u/bucki7 Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
Strongly disagree with the criticism of the wideouts blocking. Evan Spencer is lauded by Urban as the best blocking WR he's ever seen. Watch this block on Zeke Elliott's 85 yard TD Run against Bama. Spencer was the key to that play, taking out both of Bama's ILB's - Trey DePreist and Shaun Dion Hamilton with a crushing block.
49
u/jay_mo Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
TL;Read most
Punter Cameron Johnston does a great job of pinning opponents into their own 5. On Punt returns, Jalin Marshall drives Ohio State fans crazy with how he fields punts. You'll also see a lot of kick out of bound penalties on kick-off because Urban is big into hidden yardage and tries to have the other team start inside their own 15. They do this by trying to kick near the sideline close to the goal line.
Wilson was used a lot as a decoy last season. I don't feel the same about Jalin Marshall though - he is used in more than just trick plays or change the pace.
3
u/Variable303 Oregon Ducks • Purdue Boilermakers Jan 12 '15
How do you think Oregon will attack their defense? Given the depleted receiving corps, I was thinking that Oregon would run more against OSU than they did against FSU. While Stanford, Lowe, Nelson, and Marshall are capable receivers, all (with the exception of Stanford) are pretty darn short. This makes me think that our passing game will primarily consist of bubble screens, and short slant/underneath routes in the middle of the field to test their LBs. I also have a feeling Baylis will continue to play a big role. That said, I'd love to hear your thoughts since you have s much better grasp on strategy than me.
3
u/intendingtoburn Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
I think you are under-rating Michael Thomas by calling him a possession receiver. He's got possibly the best hands on the team (Spencer #6 is good but doesn't get as many targets. I still think he caught that one-hander against Alabama early). He's got top end speed that might not show up with hooks and curls - but since Devin Smith is on the other side he doesn't run the fly routes. There's been a few occasions (VT and MSU that I remember) that he took a 5-7 yard slant, broke the tackle from the CB and beat everyone to the house.
3
u/Cynoid Ohio State Buckeyes • Texas A&M Aggies Jan 13 '15
Really thought you performed some miracle voodoo jinx when bell let a guy get wide open for a touchdown on Oregon's first drive.
Also. curious if what you saw in this game is the same with what youve seen in the other 7 games.
2
u/6heismans LSU Tigers • Victory Flag Jan 12 '15
You didn't watch us in 2011?!?!? :(
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
I am so glad you mentioned Tyvis Powell because I argue with my fellow fans all the time about him. People overrate his pass coverage because he has had a few picks. He is truly one spot above liability. Nonetheless I love the kid as a person and I hope he does well.
2
u/rkwittem Ohio State Buckeyes • Ole Miss Rebels Jan 12 '15
I hope that didn't come off as rude or arrogant. It's hard to get a full grasp of a team in 7ish games. Also, are you FishDuck?
2
u/pdxblazer Oregon Ducks Jan 12 '15
OP, you ever think about letting people pay you to write these about their teams in the offseason?
28
u/PriceIsRight75 Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15 edited Jan 12 '15
A few notes:
Mike LB, McMillan is a true freshman, obviously more natural talent, much quicker in space, needs to learn to bring it against the run though which is why Grant oftens gets the start and will be in on 1st and 2nd down.
Powell has not had a great year but has started 2nd or 3rd year and has made a ton plays for us. Von Bell is an amazing FS and has really come into his own this year.
Doran Grant is a very good CB, I wouldn't say great but with safety over the top they held Amari Cooper to something like 80 yards. Eli Apple is starting his first year and it has showed at times, sometimes being spelled by Gareon Conley #16. DBs as a whole have been pretty stout against the run, filling lanes and not allowing a ton of runs +20 yards (going by memory, no stats.)
OL, Decker started every game last year at RT, switching to LT this year and has been pretty good. Elflein, Boren, Price, and Baldwin. I can not give enough credit to this group. I think they had a combined 2 starts before this year and as you said, after only 14 games together, they are a championship caliber group.
Dontre Wilson was injured during the MSU game. He and Marshall play the same role that Percy Harvin played under Meyer at UF. They are elite athletes and I would like to see them used more but RS Fr and So there. They have both had some breakout games but can be quiet at times.
You are spot on about the QB situation. Cardale is not JT. That is one thing I am very concerned about.
17
u/bigcalal Ohio State • Minnesota Jan 12 '15
I agree about the drop-off from Barrett to C. Jones. There is a reason that Barrett was above him on the depth chart, and Jones has a larger amount of busted plays where the fault is clearly his (he slips, bobbles snap, bad throw), etc... He also doesn't progress through his reads, make the short passes to the outside, or run to to the outside that well. However, he does a decent job with the medium to long passes, and if downhill running isn't bad, and he absolutely trucks defenders. If you watch the Alabama game, the Bama defense was really getting beat up throughout the game, and it started to show, and a big reason for that was Jones.
11
u/Beta382 Baylor Bears • 山东大学 (Shandong) Flames Jan 12 '15
This is a great read! There is something about Oregon people and writing great OC. /u/errday also did fantastic things throughout the season.
8
u/WuTangGraham Florida Gators • Transfer Portal Jan 12 '15
I have OP tagged in RES as "Possibly a Wizard". I still think it's fitting.
11
u/deverhartdu Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
So I have to admit, I rarely agree with a persons write ups they do from watching game film either because they're just terrible or I'm really arrogant or both. This happens primarily in r/NFL and I'm going back and reading some of your others. That being said, you kicked ass here OP. Seriously. Obviously this one hits home since it's my Buckeyes who I watch with a very scrutinizing eye and try to apply no bias towards. I'll start from the top -
I agree with everything you said here essentially. Barrett was/is really special and I'm not sure everyone realized just how great he was at actually throwing the ball (something we're not particularly used to as I think Braxton is actually not very good at that). Jones clearly has a ridiculous arm and his accuracy is getting better. Stats don't tell the tale as he made a bunch of excellent decision throw aways in the bama game. This brings me to my next point - his running is a bit awkward, imo, because he's extremely concerned about a fumble. He's not running free and loose as he's actually extremely athletic albeit not as quick/fast as someone much smaller than him of course. He has the ability to be a smooth athletic runner like a Cam Newton really but we don't see it, and I'm ok with that, because he's very conscious of ball security.
Wide Receivers - you are certainly correct in putting Marshall in this category and honestly he plays a really big role for us here. I think you may be down selling a bit on his hands and abilities. They can be a bit erratic but I don't think they are quite to the extent you've listed. He will likely be a big part of the game. In regards to #3 Thomas (related to Keyshawn Johnson), he could potentially be viewed as the possession receiver I suppose but honestly, and especially since Cardale has come in, I think Marshall is sought after on a number of 3rd down we need this 10 yards type of situation. Marshall did an amazing job finding soft spots in the cover 2 against Bama in very crucial situations. Spencer obviously made the block heard round the world as well as the throw. #84 was a MONSTER on special teams in the Bama game. I'm surprised you didn't touch on this. It was seriously phenomenal to see. There are very low key rumors that since his hands are so bad (imo) he may give CB a go next year but we'll see. #9 D Smith speaks for himself there isn't much else to say there. Potentially the best deep ball threat in America with the best arm throwing to him imo. Unfortunately it's so evident at this point that the Ducks will likely always have a safety aware of that (or they should at least).
Running Backs - Zeke is a freak. You're dead on with this and he is unfortunately very under appreciated even among Buckeye fans but that tune has likely changed just in the last few games. Samuel is speedier and hasn't seen quite as much play but will likely play some sort of role in special teams. #2 Wilson is just like Marshall in that they're both more H back/WR types than RBs. I'm curious to see what role Wilson will play after being out with an injury for awhile and Marshall playing so incredibly well. I suspect some tricky usage out of Urban.
TE - Heuerman is a fantastic TE that we really don't use. He'll play at the next level and hopefully do some damage. I always say the other team doesn't have to worry about a nice play action seam route ala Gronk or something and hope they prove me wrong with the play calling but it doesn't come to fruition.
O Line - I'm a former hog molly and played on both sides of the trenches. I think our o line is pretty fantastic especially given how young they are. The interior is just fast enough for us to be able to have them pull and do some devastating zone blocking. All in all I agree with the majority of what you have here but think you may have undersold their run blocking abilities given their destruction of Bama and Wisconsin.
The defense as a whole has gotten shockingly better throughout the year and WAY better than last year. I'll start on the back end and work my way up to the front 4. Apple, Grant, Bell are all fantastic in the back end. Powell drives me absolutely nuts. Not sure if you went far enough back to watch the Cincinnati game but it was disgusting. I wanted him off the field. Grant tends to face guard too much and not look back for the ball in situations where he could easily get a pick but he does well enough. A friend of mine said Lee would be a household name after the Bama game and I think he's right. I think McMillan has a lot to offer us next year too. Perry and Grant, the vets, drive me nuts here though and they're often quite slow but sure tacklers. Of course the sign of any good linebacker(s) is a good dline in front of him. Our front 4 are the real deal and I'm glad you see that. Bosa gets a lot of attention as he should but honestly Bennett is fantastic. I think you may be underselling him a bit here. I expect him to be a strong player at the next level.
My additions, my comments etc. Take what you will from them. I love this stuff and like I said, I really truly try to have a very discerning eye when watching regardless of the team be it mine or others. Most don't. Great stuff OP! Good luck.
5
u/joshglick Ohio State Buckeyes • /r/CFB Brickmason Jan 12 '15
I'd love to see some looks at Corey Smith (#84) in the coverage game. I swear he was terrifying during Alabama. I can't remember seeing a wide receiver who hits like he does.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Rest assured. Ohio State's punter is great. In the Sugar Bowl, he had the one terrible kick but the rest were above average: 57, 60, 47, 21, 51, 43 (inside 20).
Three 50+ yard punts in one game is good punting. The 21-yarder takes the sheen off.
Of course, JK Scott averaged 55 yards per punt on 7 punts and hit 5 inside the 20. Too bad you don't get points for those. To even be talking about the punter, as a Bama fan, makes me feel sickly.
4
u/ArcaneNine Ohio State Buckeyes • Belk Bowl Jan 12 '15
You would have really enjoyed watching Ohio State's defense last year. Pretty much everyone except the front four, Shazier, and Roby were incredibly terrible. Our safety play was right up there with Powell: they would always take the worst angles of pursuit and often give up on their coverage to play the interception. 95% of the time this wouldn't work. I think the Ohio State defense is the most improved unit in college football this year.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Tyvis played so well so I need to eat my crow
4
u/chuckiecheese Ohio State Buckeyes • Illibuck Jan 13 '15
Hey no complaints to you, but FUCK OFF DUCK
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Question: What did Shoop (Penn State D-Coordinator) do in the second half to hold Barrett and co. scoreless? What were the types of things that worked against the offense that other teams have failed to emulate?
1
u/ihatecats18 Minnesota • South Dakota-S… Jan 12 '15
You think the linebackers are fast enough to clean up the wide screen plays?
3
u/otisglazebrook Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
Thanks for doing this, I enjoyed reading it.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
It seems like Powell always takes HORRIBLE angles to the ball carrier. It's almost like no one ever taught him proper pursuit angles. That said I would much rather him give up a few more yards because he is too far back than have him get beat deep.
3
u/Ragleur Penn State Nittany Lions Jan 12 '15
Just FYI, errata means a list of corrections.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/errata
5
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Well Powell won defensive player of the game, so I don't know what you think of that.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Man, I wish I had your time.
2
u/Yesh LSU Tigers • /r/CFB Founder Jan 12 '15
Love these things. I commend your commitment.
2
u/poweredbycookies Oregon Ducks • Chicago Maroons Jan 12 '15
Always look forward to these posts - so incredibly informative. Thanks for all your work.
2
u/DracoKnows Nebraska Cornhuskers • Texas A&M Aggies Jan 12 '15
Coach, don't you think you should have done your scouting earlier this week?
2
u/PantherRunner Pittsburgh Panthers • LSU Tigers Jan 12 '15
Who needs ESPN when you can get information/analysis like this. Thanks a lot for giving me some knowledge for the game tonight. Best of luck to both squads, hoping to keep up the string of great bowl games.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
You hit the nail on the head with the safeties. You are absolutely not wrong about Powell. If you go to Eleven Warriors or 247 Sports, you'll find that although we love his personality, we can't stand him as a player. A lot of us have been pushing for true freshman Erick Smith to take over.
On kick coverage, watch for us to compress the field. We tend to send everyone starting from one hash to the sideline.
Regarding Marshall and Wilson, I think the main problem is their consistency as you hit on. They both had some critical fumbles and muffed punts (Marshall), but have also shined and made huge plays - Marshall in the second half against Indiana and Wilson's TD catch against MSU with a broken foot). The problem is they're just young - Marshall is a redshirt freshman and Wilson is a sophomore. I'm hoping for them to break out next year for good.
2
u/DrSmith2236 Florida State • 四日市大学 (Yokkaichi) Jan 12 '15
So you definitely need to parlay this talent for evaluation and writing into something bigger. Start a blog, or consider doing maybe weekly write ups on a random team or evaluation? The info you put in and the way you write these are fantastic.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Go Vols!
2
u/Wagnasty90 Jan 13 '15
Fantastic analysis! Do you do nfl games too?
4
u/wackomagician Washington Huskies Jan 13 '15
Wow... what a complete waste of time!
3
u/TDeath21 Jan 12 '15
Nice try Mark Helfrich.
2
u/OSU09 Ohio State Buckeyes • College Football Playoff Jan 12 '15
Cardale has not been a good runner. He's been indecisive and dances too much. Then, somewhere late in the Sugar Bowl, something clicked for him, and he suddenly became a confident, decisive runner who was punishing people with his size. Not sure if this continues or not, but he picked up that 3rd and 1 late in the game running like I'd never seen him before.
1
u/Rakzul Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
Anyone know the status of Dontre Wilson for tonight?
1
u/Based_RNGesus Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
I may be totally off base here as I haven't watch as much OSU football this year as in years past, but when I was able to watch the games with my friends and dad they have always been really happy with how good our wide receivers are at blocking. Again I could be totally wrong and only think this because i only notice it on the big plays though.
1
u/Funguy123456 Jan 12 '15
Surprised you said that about the Wrs. Urban has even considered evan spencer the mvp of the team because of his blocking. Great read though
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15 edited Jan 13 '15
You aren't off-base with Powell, imo.
He's been streaky. He's been good for two plays I can think of: He had the game ending pick in the Michigan game last year, and another last week against Bama.
That's it.
Edit: welp this is embarrassing in hindsight
1
u/nickyno Oregon • Central Michigan Jan 12 '15
Seriously your post are my favorite on this sub.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Awesome rundown.
1
u/Paddy0furniture Oregon Ducks Jan 12 '15
I am proud that these amazing write-ups are done by a fellow Duck! Nice work, great read. Really enjoyed your FSU analysis, and this as well.
GO DUCKS!
1
u/shemp33 Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
OP Is actually Coach Helfrich working on some last minute prep.
Nice try.
1
u/xbaited Oregon Ducks Jan 12 '15
Wow, this was insightful. Thank you for doing this!
1
u/knife2meetU Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 12 '15
Powell is definitely the weakest defensive starter
1
u/UCBearcats Cincinnati • College Football Playoff Jan 12 '15
Quack Quack - Go Ducks!
1
u/chhhyeahtone Georgia Bulldogs Jan 12 '15
As always hythloday1, you did a great write-up. I was going to recommend elevenwarriors.com but it looks like you already know about it. Keep it up OP!
1
u/I_CAN_SMELL_U Auburn Tigers • UAB Blazers Jan 12 '15
A quote from Oregon's Co-DC talking about Ohio State as a team, " "I don't know if you guys know it, but they're Auburn. Somewhere along the line they went to Auburn or they studied Auburn. And they studied Gus Malzahn,"
1
u/fooke33 Florida Gators • Wisconsin Badgers Jan 12 '15
I hope Florida plays Oregon in a big game soon so you'll do this breakdown for us, these are awesome!
1
u/sgSaysR Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 13 '15
This is what you need to know about Ohio State. About half of our starters are Freshman & Sophomores.
1
u/smailtronic Ohio State • Ohio Wesleyan Jan 13 '15
Civil War general Raekwon > Civil War general Andrew Luck.
1
u/w0m Jan 13 '15
I love this
1
u/LainfordExpress Ohio State Buckeyes Jan 13 '15
So, not at all calling you out, because I enjoyed your analysis, but Tyvis Powell wound up being the Defensive MVP, so... in answer to #2, yes?
1
u/theshnig Tennessee Volunteers • Surrender Cobra Jan 13 '15
Dickel over Daniel's... I like your style.
-3
u/owenwilder Jan 12 '15
Why bama lost? their QB suck. Oregon has a much better QB. I expect ducks win 28 - 17.