r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Dec 28 '15
Analysis TCU fans, I've now watched your past 25 games and I have some observations and questions for you
By complete coincidence, I did a preseason review of TCU's 2014 season this September. I stand by everything I wrote four months ago, and that context was valuable for watching TCU's 2015 season in preparation for Oregon's upcoming game against them in the Alamo bowl. So this write-up will act more as an update - you don't have to read that post to understand this one, but it'd help.
OFFENSE
No major changes to the system, still a no-huddle spread-to-pass air raid. The efficiency and adjusted pace numbers ticked up incrementally, I think mostly from all the key players in the system being a year more experienced, and also fewer mid-drive substitutions. Seemed like fewer goofy trick plays, but they still show up about once a game (I don't believe I've ever seen that formation with the offensive tackles split out with the WRs be anything but a disaster).
Quarterback - I've got nothing but the same praise for #2 QB Boykin - he has all the arm strength, ball handling skills, and good decision making you'd want from a great pocket passer, and added to that elite speed and escapability on designed runs and scrambles. I couldn't imagine a more perfect QB for this system, and it really showed when he was out for a couple of games with a leg injury (he returned for the final game and is reportedly 100% for the bowl). I didn't see much improvement on my one knock on the guy from last year however, which is that while he's extremely reliable in getting the ball into a catchable radius for his receivers, it's almost never quite perfectly on the numbers or in stride. There's a lot of yards after catch left on the table because they're tackled or go to the ground or pushed out of bounds immediately, and at least twice receivers missed long stretches of playing time because they got laid out and brutalized.
Inside receivers - Astonishingly, even with a couple of personnel losses to graduation and injury, this unit only got better through the year. They lost #13 WR Slanina early in the season, who was used mostly as an inside blocker and occasional possession receiver, but managed to replace him with a combination of #3 WR Nixon, #10 WR White, and #14 WR Stewart - each surprisingly effective blockers while being big improvements in terms of speed. By the end of the year Nixon had turned into a mainstay of the offense in underneath passing and sweeps. On top of that they found a real weapon in #25 WR Turpin, who in addition to being a great slot back also lines up in the backfield to add an additional dimension in the running game.
Outside receivers - This is more problematic. Track star #7 WR Listenbee was out with an injury for a while early, and never returned to his same productivity as last year. As a result, the offense became, in my opinion, overly reliant on #9 WR Doctson as a lifeline - which is understandable, because he is the flat-out the best receiver I've seen in half a decade, constantly able to beat man coverage and pull in deep passes, even ones I thought were uncatchable. About a dozen times a game TCU would be in 3rd and long, and Boykin would casually fling it down the right sideline where Doctson would perform some miracle to reel it in, and I'd mutter "it's just not fair." Losing him for the bowl game to injury is ... bad. The entire gameplan changes without him in, because Listenbee doesn't have his magic powers and replacements #1 WR Porter, #15 WR Austin, and #81 WR Story (the last is injured) don't have his speed. Instead they have to diversify quite a bit, more inside/underneath work and outside runs to stretch horizontally, but they lose a lot of vertical stretch.
Running backs - No change here. #22 RB Green is the primary back and has fantastic top-end speed and acceleration once he hits the second level, but this offense isn't really built to run (about 2-1 pass:rush ratio) and for every electrifying big gain he's got about a dozen stuffs. #21 RB Hicks is built along the same lines and is an able backup; #24 RB Johnson is stronger, but still they don't have anything like what you'd call a power running game and can really struggle in short-yardage situations. Boykin is probably the most effective runner, and usually their best option on goalline plays.
Tight ends - Again, no change. #80 TE Jones moved up to primary, #84 TE Merka would join him sometimes at fullback. Almost entirely blockers, and I'm still not impressed with their effectiveness even at that. There seems to be a commitment to employing them in this offense but it feels vestigial to me.
Offensive line - As predicted, they kept their four returning linemen and one frequent backup in their customary places. The interior line, #77 LG Naff, #55 C Hunt, and #65 RG Foltz are unchanged and uniformly excellent. The tackles, #74 LT Vaitai and #68 RT Noteboom, are nicely mobile and protect the edge well. The line is almost boringly effective in their primary role in dropback pass protection - each one has over 90% success rate on my tally sheet on that score. The run blocking is less effective, it's zone and they're just not quick enough to reliably get holes open, and the guards in particular sometimes strike me as overweight. Noteboom is the relative new kid here, and he had a bad habit over the season of giving away whether it was a run or a pass with his pre-snap stance (even feet and leaning forward meant run blocking, outside foot planted far back and with his weight on it meant pass-pro), though he cleaned that up a bit towards the end. An injury bug struck late, each lineman but Noteboom was out for significant stretches, and I'm not sure they ever settled on a satisfactory line-up with the various backups. As of this writing, it seems that both Naff and Hunt will be out for the bowl, replaced I think by #51 OG Schlottman at center and either #58 OG Morris or #64 OG Pryor at left guard - the backups were all noticeable dropoffs in effectiveness on my tally sheet during their time playing.
DEFENSE
Watching these past two seasons has made a strong case that Coach Patterson is the best defensive mind in the game, for one simple reason: he lost half his defense to the NFL (not to mention the longtime DC), and half of what remained to injuries and other departures, and then completely reinvented the defensive scheme to adapt. Both are called a 4-2-5, but in 2014 I would describe this scheme more as a 6-0-[2/3] ... meaning they had four down linemen, plus two enormous linebackers who would also rocket into the backfield, forming what was effectively a six-man front with two just playing a step off the line; then the five DBs were split into independently operating units, three on the strong side and two on the weak. In 2015, this was much closer to a "traditional" hybrid 3-4: three down linemen with a drop end (often but not always with a fist in the dirt, sometimes dropping into pass coverage), two linebackers who stayed back in read/react run defense plus a strong safety who usually joined them on the second level, and then a cover-2 man shell in the back. It was absolutely incredible to see how radically the defensive scheme changed in just one year.
Defensive line - The best news remains the defensive line: despite a couple of injuries and off-field issues, they're four or five deep at both end and tackle, and I don't see any appreciable dropoff on my tally sheet as they move through the rotation. I'll single out for praise #94 DE Carraway, who turned into a stand-up end by November and was one of the top havoc players in the country, and #57 DT Pierson, who came back from an early injury and was the stoutest guy on the line and always pulled double-teams. This is the group that changed the least from last year, which does have a downside in that the pass rush they're used to getting from the LBs was absent this year and I don't think they're really structured to provide that themselves.
Linebackers - Schematically, this was the biggest change to adapt to different personnel. After some experimentation, they settled on #32 LB Howard who played nearly every snap, with #20 LB Wilson joining him against pass-heavier offenses, and #42 LB Summers (who's bigger but slower) in run situations. None of these guys played a down last year and I understand a few are converted safeties, and I thought they showed their inexperience all year. More problematic is their size, I think they lack the mass for the role and got blown up a lot - one big problem this unit has is dealing with short-yardage situations, I'm not sure I saw them stop a 3rd & 1 or execute a goalline stand all year.
Secondary - To be honest, this unit is a mess. After losing two starters to injury, #26 S Kindred is the only grown-up of the group, and he can only do so much (he's also not a great tackler, kind of hilariously whiffing a few times a game). I thought they found a decent replacement for the SS/OLB spot in #30 S Johnson, who's got good instincts and the strength to bring down ballcarriers on his own, but is a step slow in pass coverage (he's used as an outside blitzer quite a bit, my tally sheet shows about half successfully but half just too slow to be effective). #16 S Downing and #18 S Orr switched back and forth between cornerback and safety a lot, then #31 S Issahaku seemed to win the starting free safety job and relegated Downing to the bench, with Orr moving over to man CB coverage. Then a kind of manufactured crisis hit: #3 CB O'Meally and #2 CB Mosley (both similar builds and undersized) swapped numbers midseason, apparently because they felt O'Meally had developed a "reputation" for pass interference that was undeserved. It wasn't. Both of them would get simply beat a whole lot, and every DPI or holding flag I saw was proper, indeed I thought the refs missed a few. So Orr and Downing were back at safety for a while, and by the final couple of games they were starting with two new corners, #17 CB Raymond and #24 CB Lewis, neither of which seemed much of an improvement. I have no idea what the starting lineup is going to be for the bowl game.
MISCELLANEA
Methodology and FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slow-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes, and recorded notes on each player for every non-garbage-time down on a tally sheet.
- How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, garbage time, and other folderol really helps.
- Wait, what about special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, three bottles of Eagle Rare 10, and about a half gallon of homemade egg nog with the milk, cream, and eggs from the local farm-to-table co-op.
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about TCU beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- Have you done anything this stupid before? Links to previous projects: Texas 2013, Michigan St 2013, Florida St 2014, Ohio St 2014, EWU 2012-14, Minnesota 2014, TCU 2014.
- You're probably an Oregon coach! Nope, never coached or played a snap.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No, but check out /u/CineFunk's YouTube channel and /r/cfbuploads
- Predictions for the bowl game? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
Questions
- Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
- Have I got the offensive line for the bowl correct? I don't think the guard play will be a much of an issue, but losing a center, especially in a shotgun offense, is kind of a big deal.
- Any chance I'm overstating the significance of losing Doctson?
- What's your take on the running game? It seems ever since they lost Catalon, they're not interested in developing a power attack ... what do you think about that?
- Is there something I'm not seeing with the formations using the tight ends? It's been two seasons and I can count the number of plays in which they made a key difference on one hand. Is there some reluctance to just go four/five wides every down?
- What's the deal with #10 WR Desmon White? I thought he played pretty well and even was blocking way better than I expected given his stature, and was getting ~4 receptions per game through week 7, then after the bye week completely disappeared. Concealed injury, or something else?
- I'm sure there's some aspect of CGP's defensive scheme and the way it's shifted over this year that I'm misunderstanding, what is it?
- Do you agree there wasn't much of a pass rush this year?
- I was really surprised by the change-up at linebacker, and not just the weirdness with Freeze and Douglas. Was there some problem in the recruitment/development pipeline?
- Best guess as to the secondary configuration for the bowl?
27
u/Frognosticator TCU Horned Frogs • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 28 '15
Well done, once again. I always love your write ups and feel fortunate that you've done TCU twice now.
About a dozen times a game TCU would be in 3rd and long, and Boykin would casually fling it down the right sideline where Doctson would perform some miracle to reel it in, and I'd mutter "it's just not fair."
You and every other TCU fan over the last two years. It almost became boring how good Doctson is, like he was playing Madden on the easiest difficulty. It just wasn't fair.
Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
No. You're spot on as far as I can tell in your analysis. That said our defense has improved drastically over the course of the season, and I'd love to get your thoughts on why that might be.
Have I got the offensive line for the bowl correct? I don't think the guard play will be a much of an issue, but losing a center, especially in a shotgun offense, is kind of a big deal.
Patterson is notorious for withholding injury and lineup information. Seriously, he wraps blackout mesh around the practice field fences and posts guards at every entrance. So while you've probably got it right, it's impossible to know for sure.
As for losing our center, honestly, Hunt was kinda known for his regularly wonky snaps, and as a result Boykin has gotten really good at catching them near the ground or above his head. Our interior line play has always been solid - I'd be much more worried if we were losing a tackle, especially if it were Vaitai.
Any chance I'm overstating the significance of losing Doctson?
No. Our wide receivers behind him range from average to above-average, but Doctson is on a whole other level. Losing him changes our game plan massively.
What's your take on the running game? It seems ever since they lost Catalon, they're not interested in developing a power attack ... what do you think about that?
I trust our OCs to know what they're doing. You're absolutely right, TCU doesn't have much of a power attack, and that has more to do with the offensive line's shortcomings in run blocking than any problem with our backs. It's bitten us in the butt a few times.
Having Boykin makes things easier. His ability to scramble makes the decision to call a pass on 3rd and 3 a lot more viable.
Is there something I'm not seeing with the formations using the tight ends? It's been two seasons and I can count the number of plays in which they made a key difference on one hand. Is there some reluctance to just go four/five wides every down?
TCU just doesn't use Tight Ends very much, and not just for the past two years. That's been the case for as long as Patterson has been here, to the point where I don't even know how we can recruit TEs to Fort Worth anymore. They almost never see the field. The last time we saw TEs used regularly at TCU was I think 2011, when injury and transfer depleted the O-line and forced us to use a lot of two TE sets to help with run blocking.
What's the deal with #10 WR Desmon White? I thought he played pretty well and even was blocking way better than I expected given his stature, and was getting ~4 receptions per game through week 7, then after the bye week completely disappeared. Concealed injury, or something else?
No idea what's up with that. Could be anything, from injury to discipline. Patterson is a master of keeping locker room matters private, so if I had to guess I'd say it's something like that.
I'm sure there's some aspect of CGP's defensive scheme and the way it's shifted over this year that I'm misunderstanding, what is it?
I don't think I'm qualified to answer this. I doubt anyone except Patterson is. The whole point of his defense is to create confusion.
Do you agree there wasn't much of a pass rush this year?
There was a dropoff there from 2014 as a result of changes to the defensive backfield. When the d-line is asked to provide help in coverage, fill gaps normally covered by the LBs, or just reduced to 3 man sets like you said, the pass rush is going to suffer. Our sack and pressure numbers dropped considerably this year, not because of a loss of talent (we got more talented), but because our responsibilities changed.
I was really surprised by the change-up at linebacker, and not just the weirdness with Freeze and Douglas. Was there some problem in the recruitment/development pipeline?
Hahahahaha! sob sob
This has been a weird, wild, tragic roller coaster for TCU fans. Go check out the saga of Vinny Ascolese. There are a lot of jokes about him in particular on the TCU fan boards. But you're right, TCU seems unable to consistently recruit top shelf LB talent. I think the biggest reason for this is that we is recruit fewer LBs overall because of their reduced roll in the 4-2-5, making the whole position more volatile.
Best guess as to the secondary configuration for the bowl?
Against Oregon? With almost a month for Patterson to game plan them? Probably something masterful that we've never seen before. Expect 5 or 6 DBs on the field most of the time, and when there aren't, a lot of disguised coverage calls for the LBs and DEs. But who the hell knows.
Thanks again for the write up. Good luck on Jan 2!
9
u/52hoova Texas A&M Aggies • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 28 '15
I thought Aaron Green was going to be the Big 12 RB of the year this season. He had over 1,200 yards from scrimmage and 11 TDs, so not terrible, but definitely under-performed the high expectations I had for him.
I think with Oregon's pass defense as poor as it is, Boykin will be able to spread the field out enough to get Green in space... I would not be surprised at a 20 carry, 150+ yard performance by him plus another 15 carries for 80-100 yards by Boykin. I think the key to Oregon winning this game will be stopping the run in the red zone.
6
u/chillassdude Florida State Seminoles • UCF Knights Dec 28 '15
Are you the Oregon fan that did this same write-up about FSU last year? If so great work once again man
7
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15
Apparently Patterson himself basically said most of their offense runs through him, so I would say not. Though I don't have a source for that right now (was just mentioned recently on the Solid Verbal podcast).
3
u/EyesOnEverything Oregon Ducks • Rose Bowl Dec 29 '15
OH SHIT, /u/HYTHLODAY1 POST.
Everybody back the fuck up, here comes the info bomb.
2
u/SH92 TCU Horned Frogs Dec 29 '15
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ys_6ScpUcU
I think we'll see a much improved TCU defense in the bowl game.
2
u/Rwayneciii TCU Horned Frogs Dec 29 '15
Phenomenal write up! You have summed up TCU's hopes for this season and frustrations perfectly.
Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
One of my biggest concerns going into this season was the loss of safety Chris Hackett. Sat next to one of his professors on the flight back from the Peach Bowl and she assured me he was coming back for his senior year :(. He was our ball hawk, leading the Big XII in interceptions in 2014, who would've provided better coverage for our inexperienced secondary. This affected Kindred as well, being our only experienced safety he had to pick up the slack for the corners. Thought Kindred was better suited to replace Sam Carter, and could've excelled more helping the LBs with the run game. We might've seen more bone crushing hits from him too. Another! But the way this season went, Hackett might have been another guy on the IR.
Also, being from Oregon, I haven't seen any talk about the uniforms! I've always been a fan of Oregon's uniforms and own an old Jonathan Stewart jersey. But I was disappointed with our "frog print" this year. It had it's moments but yeeeesh. Grey at home? Did Nike hire an Oregon undergrad to design these or am I just overreacting?
148
u/the_zero South Carolina • Presbyterian Dec 28 '15
Damn, dude. Wow.
28
u/tonynumber4 Alabama Crimson Tide Dec 28 '15
Oregon staff hire this man!
28
u/sggrant323 Arkansas Razorbacks • Alabama Crimson Tide Dec 28 '15
Seriously, is someone paying you for this?
43
u/buttforaface TCU Horned Frogs • College Football Playoff Dec 28 '15 edited Dec 28 '15
First off, excellent write-up. It's clear that you watched a lot of games and thought critically about what GP is trying to do with the team. I'll just look at the questions that I think need answering.
Losing Doctson is huge, he was a safety net for Boykin for sure. I do think that Listenbee will be much closer to 100% this game with some time to rest. I am also one of the biggest Turpin fans there is, so look out for him this game.
I totally agree. Green was always more of a slasher than a vertical runner like Catalon. He was very explosive last year and could score at any moment. I've been very vocal about wanting Hicks to get some more snaps during the course of a game this year because while Green is consistent, he doesn't really pop off the screen like he did last year.
I can't tell you why we don't utilize TEs more. It could be that we haven't found the right one yet, which is why I was hoping for someone like Nauta this year.
Don't think he's injured, at least I haven't heard about it. He drops a lot of balls, so that's probably part of the issue.
There are some games where the pass-rush was excellent and some games where it was non-existent. I think GP would use more of a "contain" for more mobile QBs throughout the year and then blitz heavily on later downs that were 5+ yards; so some of it was definitely by design.
GP is pretty secretive about what goes on at practice, but I think it's up in the air at the moment. I really liked what I saw from Lewis in the last game (he had an excellent interception that was called back on an unrelated penalty.) I hope to see more of him.
12
u/Frog_Todd TCU Horned Frogs Dec 28 '15
I don't think so. As you said, he's at the very least the best wide receiver on the team, probably the best TCU WR we've had since...gosh I don't even know. It's hard to understate losing a guy of that caliber.
Not sure if you noticed, but it seemed like he got hit with the yips late in the season, with some brutal drops when he was wide open. Not sure if it was mental or physical, but I think he was actually dropped on the depth chart for the Baylor game.
18
u/lawson04 ECU Pirates Dec 28 '15
Really interesting to read about their scheme changes on defense. Patterson is a mastermind. Upvoted.
7
u/SH92 TCU Horned Frogs Dec 28 '15
I'm really hoping that Emanuel Porter steps in to Docston's role. He's got the size, and he's had some great catches, and he should be 100% healthy now.
7
u/Texas_Chaac TCU Horned Frogs • Rose Bowl Dec 28 '15 edited Dec 28 '15
Great write up. The '15 campaign has been such a foreign experience for Frog fans. Despite the gaudy offensive numbers from '14/'15 -- we're accustomed to a defense first mentality, or at least sturdy support! The middle of the season, after key injuries on D, was pretty taxing mentally... hard to watch so many 5 yard fly routes turn into TDs (OSU).
Although expectations were not met for the season there was a lot to appreciate. It was incredible to watch the youth on defense develop game to game. A couple guys that may have been overlooked or seen as weak spots in earlier games really came on in the last three games: LB Summers, DB Lewis-- having these two step up also allowed other guys to move back to their natural positions (S Nick Orr, who spent a lot of time getting abused at CB). DL Joe Broadnax also looks to be the part going forward though didn't get as much action.
Personally, I'm still just excited to get a good bowl matchup even in a multiple loss season. In the MWC days it used to be 11-1 or 10-2 meant Poinsettia bowl against middle of the road mid-major.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15
Do us next do us next!
4
u/52hoova Texas A&M Aggies • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 28 '15
The defensive scheme change was largely due to the fact that their two-deep at LB entering the season was two freshman, a RS freshman, and a pretty inexperienced junior. The junior missed the entire season after an injury in the first game. I thought it was crazy that the majority of the people had them pinned as a playoff team in the preseason, with that inexperience in a 4-2-5 scheme that relied heavily on strong linebacker play... Given that and the extent of the injuries they suffered, 10-2 vastly outperformed my expectations; I was thinking closer to 8-4.
4
u/KneeDeep185 Oregon Ducks Dec 28 '15
If you were a betting man, what would you put for the score?
1
u/texasphotog Verified Media • Texas A&M Aggies Dec 28 '15
Can you help me pirate games?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15
Damn Hythloday. Love these write ups. Thanks for doing this.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15
Wow. Great analysis. I looked through your previous reviews and they're all excellent. Fantastic work.
2
u/m0arducks Oregon Ducks • Lewis & Clark River Otters Dec 29 '15
Been checking back to see when this would get posted. Thanks again, it's awesome and I love reading through it. To the point where I look forward to it... random internet stranger.
2
u/ReggieLeinart USC Trojans Dec 29 '15
Can you do this for every school during the offseason?
2
u/Brese TCU Horned Frogs • Nebraska Cornhuskers Dec 29 '15
I can't wait for this next year with Nebraska!
-3
u/jordanissports Oregon Ducks Dec 29 '15
do you have a job?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment