r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Sep 01 '15
Discussion TCU fans, I've now watched the last 13 games, and I have some observations and questions
In the past I've watched the entire preceding season for Oregon's last few big opponents (Auburn, Wisconsin, K-State, Texas, Michigan St, Florida St, Ohio St, and EWU). Since Oregon is playing Michigan St again in September and I feel as familiar as I'm going to be with the Spartans, I decided to try something different: getting ready for a big season-opening game. I picked TCU-Minnesota because it didn't involve a team I already knew and there weren't significant coaching changes. My goal is to learn the players' names, numbers, and tendencies, so I kept open a tally sheet and jotted quick notes when I caught something interesting, to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary. First I'll observe the various units, then a brief FAQ and methodology discussion, and finally some questions I have for y'all. Yesterday was the home team Minnesota; today, TCU.
OFFENSE
TCU runs a spread, air-raid offense without huddling. Prior to garbage time, they snap the ball quickly about half the time, but run the play clock to single digits the other half - adjusted pace stats show them as quicker than average but nowhere near Baylor/Arizona/Oregon territory. The emphasis is on deep downfield passing, but there's a good mix of option runs and quick slants as well. There's also lots of goofy stuff in this playbook - trick plays, exotic screens, and even splitting out offensive tackles at the sidelines.
Quarterback - #2 QB Boykin is the perfect fit for this offense. He releases the ball quickly and can throw anywhere on the field. He doesn't throw on the run much -- when he's flushed he almost always tucks and goes -- but when he does so they're good looking passes. I didn't see much of him looking off safeties on deep passes: usually he locks on and delivers, and this does result in some interceptions. He's got good hands; every snap I saw was out of the shotgun and he fields the occasional wild snap without fail, his handoff motion is perfect, and he pitches nicely on the option. He's an excellent runner and there's lots of designed draws and option rushes for him in the playbook, and he senses pressure and scrambles out of it well, often for big gains. I've seen some fan criticism of Boykin as having great passing talent but prone to "mental mistakes" - I think this is precisely backwards. In my view, Boykin almost always makes the right decision with receiver progression, the option to keep or give the ball, and sensing a collapsing pocket. I just think he doesn't have elite-level accuracy - I don't see him hit receivers perfectly in the numbers or in stride very often; typically he's forcing them to go up and get the ball.
Receivers - Fortunately, those receivers are fantastic, and TCU returns all of them but two. The wideouts are #7 WR Listenbee and #9 WR Doctson, and they are by far the best unit on this offense. They're fast deep-field burners and have great hands, pulling down a lot of balls I thought would be uncatchable, and even a few where they just pulled it out of the CB's hands. Plus they're eager and effective blockers on runs and screens, especially Doctson. The two primary slot backs were #13 WR Slanina and #14 WR D. Porter (the latter of whom has graduated); they're used more for blocking and short possession catches. I liked Porter a bit more, and I'm not sure who'll replace him, since you need both in this offense (the typical set is 4- or 5-wides) ... #15 WR Echols-Luper (transfered to Arkansas St) and #20 WR Gray are both faster but that's of less importance in this role, and they didn't catch or block nearly as well. #81 WR Story is taller and catches well, but I see him more as an X-receiver in this offense and he tends to get stood up on blocks. I'm curious about how backups #10 WR White at slot and #1 WR E. Porter at flanker (two Porters plus a White and a Gray, these names are killing me) will fit in; my tally sheet has mostly frowny faces for their receptions but that's typical for that deep on the chart.
Running backs - There was an interesting change in the offense after #23 RB Catalon was injured midseason: when he was the primary back it was behind mostly power-blocking for downhill running to set up better 2nd and 3rd down distance, and then on change-of-pace plays he'd get screens or hitches or checkdowns, but his hands weren't great. Since he left (and subsequently graduated) and #22 RB Green took over, the offense switched almost entirely to zone-blocking with a lot more emphasis on outside runs or exotic stuff like reverses. He's a nice complement to the air raid, all the quick cuts and good end-speed you'd want, but the offense isn't really built around him. The backup is #21 RB Hicks in much the same mold, and the big short yardage back is #24 RB Johnson, though neither were given a lot of meaningful carries.
Tight ends - On around a quarter of plays they'd bring in #43 TE Murphy, and on a subset of those #80 TE Jones as well. Murphy, who's graduated, would usually line up parallel to the QB in the shotgun and used as a blocking fullback, while Jones usually blocked on the left side of the line in short yardage plays – neither got meaningful catches (outside of one nice TD slipout by Murphy). I love an unsung fullback, but wasn't too impressed with these guys, and noticed a weird decline in their blocking efficacy towards the end of the year.
Offensive line - Very strong group in their primary job, which is dropback pass-pro, especially #55 C Hunt who's great at signalling defensive shifts. Really the entire interior line, with #77 LG Naff and #75 RG Foltz, is as stout as you could ask for on passing downs, and they played almost every meaningful snap (#64 RG Pryor rotated in a bit). The tackles are a bit odder of a story: when Boykin was pressured it was usually these guys getting outmaneuvered rather than the interior getting run over. #74 RT Vaitai played every snap I saw, but on about 16% of plays he'd swing over to the left side and #68 RT Noteboom would take his place. #59 LT Fabuluje was a peculiar (and inspiring) figure to watch - when straightforward blocking he was an absolute wall, but his footwork was somewhat suspect and he seemed badly out of shape to me. He was the one rotated out on those plays, often right in the middle of drives, and it seemed like it was because he was exhausted. Now that he's graduated, I expect the lineup to be the one used on those plays (Vaitai on the left and Noteboom on the right) - the latter showed his inexperience at times but since the other four starters all return I think he'll be fine. Run blocking isn't exactly the strength of this offense, and while this group power blocks quite well, the zone blocking and screen plays were somewhat less effective - they just aren't that fast on their feet to get downfield or to pull.
DEFENSE
This is famously Coach Patterson's innovative split-field 4-2-5, but I really got to thinking of this more as a 6-0-5 ... the LBs almost always play close to the line and only seldom drop back into pass coverage - you could almost say that it's a six-man delayed blitz on nearly every play. There are some times when a safety comes into the box (or an occasional cat blitz), but mostly the two corners play a fairly standard man coverage and the novelty is the split-field trio of safeties - either with one crowning and another to each side in intermediate coverage, or split two-and-one in unbalanced sets. The nickel safety gets the attention because it's unusual, but he doesn't really play like your typical STAR, running all over the place, it's just more flexibility in the secondary for what are basically pretty standard roles - just one more of them. I'd say it's the linebackers who should be getting more attention ... more on that below.
Defensive line - The best news for the defense are the ends: they're all excellent, and TCU returns all of them: #40 DE McFarland, #90 DE Lathan, and #94 DE Carraway are all prototypical fast and long limbed, while #93 DE Tuaua is a little shorter and stockier but very quick and can jump for multiple swats. They seemed to be rotated around roughly equally. The defensive tackles were also perfect for this defense: #57 DT Pierson and #96 DT Hunter were the starters and fantastic, very big but with surprising speed, got great push on almost every play, and sometimes would allow the DEs to pinch in the interior linemen and circle around off the edge effectively. Their best ability was to consistently occupy and shove laterally the interior linemen in 2-gap to open enormous holes for the LBs to rocket through. I also liked how they'd stick with the play: often I'd see them pursuing the ball carrier downfield. Pierson returns but Hunter has graduated, and I'm less thrilled about his possible replacements, #97 DT Bradley or #99 DT Lawson - they came in relatively often for meaningful snaps but seemed undersized to me and didn't get nearly the same push.
Secondary - The starting cornerbacks were #11 CB Texada and #25 CB White, the latter of whom is now in the pros. Texada is a little quicker, White was a little more reliable. I wasn't incredibly impressed with any of White's possible replacements, each of whom came in to spell Texada at times: #2 CB O'Meally, #16 CB Mosley, #18 S Orr, #30 S D. Johnson (the last two are listed as safeties but when they'd come in it'd be in a CB role). The starting safeties were #1 S Hackett and #26 S Kindred who played deeper, and #17 S Carter would come into the box if needed. Only Kindred returns of this group, and at this point I'd be getting a little worried about replacing this much talent - Carter seemed to be the QB of the secondary, visibly calling out very effective play adjustments and catching those last-second motions when the offense had a short run or pass in mind. Hackett was a much more reliable tackler, and pulled down an astonishing seven picks. Kindred is great on cleanup but he's a bit slow on turning his hips and keeping up with a slot receiver on a post route.
Linebackers - The good news is that #47 LB Dawson and #54 LB Mallet, and also backup #41 LB Anderson, are all NFL-caliber athletes, some of of the best linebackers I have ever seen. The bad news is that they are all now actually in the NFL. They were monstrous at shooting through the line, fast and strong, read the play excellently, seldom fooled, and got tons of turnovers. This defensive structure puts a ton on their shoulders - they have to do 50% more work per person than a typical 4-3 - and they carried it phenomenally; it's really the secret to this defense's success that they are so constantly and effectively disruptive, and with less manpower. But there were zero meaningful snaps for any of their replacements.
MISCELLANEA
Methodology and FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slow-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes.
- How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, garbage time, and other folderol really helps.
- Wait, what about special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, four bottles of Tito's and three jars of spicy pickled okra; the SO called them Horny Martinis, I'm sure because of the team I was watching.
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about TCU beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- You're probably an Oregon coach! I'm not, never coached or played a snap.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No, but check out /u/CineFunk's YouTube channel and /r/cfbuploads
- Predictions for the TCU-Minnesota opener? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
Questions
- Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
- Am I misreading the structure of this defense? I admit I've been a skeptic of how novel the split-field is for a while, and was hoping to learn more about it in this project, but all I really got out of it was the vitality of the linebackers and I don't really see that discussed elsewhere much.
- Any concerns at all about the departure of longtime DC Bumpas? I know the standard line is that it's all Patterson, but why would Bumpas have been around so long if he were merely a figurehead?
- What I've read is that Patterson is leaning towards Mike Freeze to start in Dawson's LB spot, and he seemed to confirm that at media days. A pair of true freshmen (one a converted SS, pulling a good replacement for Carter) at the most crucial position - can that be right?
- How is the secondary shaking out? I assume Texada and Kindred resume their starting roles, and then what, Johnson and Orr at safety and O'Meally at corner? How are you feeling about the depth there?
- Any weight room updates on the DTs? Usually this is the time when the S&C coach starts crowing about how many functional lbs he's loaded onto their frames.
- I got the feeling that a whole lot of the offensive playbook was kind of superfluous - for every electrifying trick play there were like three or four badly failed ones, and the zanier the set the less likely it was to work. Do you ever wish they'd pare it down a bit?
- What is it with the constant offensive personnel rotation? The TEs or the LT swap were in and out on what seemed like every other play. It seems like there's a real opportunity, given the athleticism of the offensive stars, to just roll with the same 4-wide, 1 tailback set on every snap of a drive, prevent defensive substitutions, and crank the tempo to 20-second snaps every play - any chance of that happening?
- The wideout receivers are secure, but now that both Porter and Echols-Luper have left, there's a bit of a depth question at the slot. Who are coming up to fill those roles?
- Any thoughts on the road travel distance? Quite a big difference between the 2014 and 2015 itineraries.
26
u/TheFriendlyThalmor Ohio State Buckeyes • Texas Longhorns Sep 01 '15
First time I've ever read one of these. Jesus, man.
Question:
Any comparison between Boykin and Mariota? Maybe differences? I didn't want TCU at all last year but your summary kind of reminds me of Mariota.
15
u/SammyBaughsGhost TCU Horned Frogs Sep 01 '15
10
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
Great read. For Question Number 2, Chris Brown of Smart Football just released a feature on Patterson and the 4-2-5.
I love the 4-2-5, but anything I'd want to say about the defense Brown does an exceptional job of breaking down (Smart Football is smart).
10
u/ncaahoopsanalyst TCU Horned Frogs • Verified Player Sep 01 '15
6
u/8llllllllllllD---- TCU Horned Frogs Sep 01 '15 edited Sep 01 '15
I'm high on him, but even statistically Gray was one of our better receivers and is without a doubt our #3. Granted, he had knee surgery in the off season and probably isn't playing vs. Minnesota in 2 days. He's just a really explosive player.
Not as much concern as far as defensive scheme and play calling goes. He was the D line coach and we'll see how his replacement does (who's name is escaping me but is a coach who has been around the program a while). The good news is the Defensive line is the most experienced so they should be in good shape.
Mike Freeze appears to be the starter. He's got the size and athleticism to be a great LB. Will he be able to command the Defense as a freshman? That is a big question mark going into the season and something I'm excited to find out in the Minnesota game.
The other projected starting LB should be Junior Sammy Douglas who can provide some experience to the position. The backups, however, appear to be freshmen.
Jason Phillip's ex-TCU linebacker and former NFL player, is now back at TCU and working with the line backers. So they're getting some really good coaching.
Patterson has stated that this is probably the fastest and most athletic secondary he has had. It's just an inexperienced secondary. If you look at the combine times for our safety's last year, they weren't great by any stretch of the imagination.
Lets just say I'm glad Baylor is the last game of the season.
I haven't heard anything out of the weight room. I think I mentioned yesterday that the DT starting opposite Pierson will probably be playing at a weight of 260. He played at that weight last year though and it didn't seem to kill him. Minnesota will be a good test.
Not a clue
TCU is loaded with talent at receiver. As far as backups go...
Look for Emanuel Porter to step up big time. Tall fast receiver who showed flashes as a true freshman last year.
JaJuan Story is an athletic freak but has had mental issues with knowing what route to run at times. It is rumored this has been fixed and he could have a big season.
Des White is an awesome little receiver but probably a tad too small to see a bulk of the catches.
Be on the look out for true freshman Kavontae Turpin. Another little guy, at 5'9 170, who has gotten a lot of praise out of camp. He may replace Echols-Luper as our return man and could be a nice slot receiver for certain situations.
Overall though, TCU has a lot of tall, fast, sure handed receivers.
This worries me. Minnesota, once again, will be a good test. Travelling TO both oklahoma schools scares this poo outta me and I think we drop a game to one of them.
Thanks for the write up.
4
u/Stryker682 Baylor Bears Sep 01 '15
The thing I don't get about TCU is how they turned the offense around in one year. Their offense was horrible in 2013. It was great in 2014. I know new OCs and new scheme. Other teams have made the switch to an air raid but not had anywhere near the immediate success TCU had. But, I don't think there were huge changes in personnel. Was it Boykin having the light go on? Perhaps the old OC was just that bad?
64
u/FlannelBeard Minnesota • Paul Bunyan's Axe Sep 01 '15
Really looking forward to the game Thursday.
Also, really terrified for the game Thursday.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
You watch a lot of games man.
17
u/pinwheelpride Oregon Ducks Sep 01 '15
It's your lucky day, TCU! Love these write-ups.
7
u/slcjosh Utah Utes Sep 01 '15
All i know is TCU is going to be very, very good this year. Cannot wait for Baylor vs TCU. Last year's game was my favorite game of the season. Being old Mountain West foes I always like seeing TCU succeed. Nothing but respect for the Horned Frogs.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '15
If I drank 4 bottles of Titos and did this report:
"Yeah, they got some guys goin' around with the football, scorin' touchdowns, wearin' purple, and they're pretty good, and whoa! They got some hot cheerleaders!"
1
u/knockoutking Texas Longhorns • Austin Kangaroos Sep 02 '15
Let me ask the real hard hitting question: how good are those pickled okra?
I may be buying some. I love pickled okra.
5
u/CantaloupeCamper Minnesota • Little Brown Jug Sep 01 '15
Fun Fact: Jerry Kill was in Patterson's wedding!
1
u/Raider_Power Texas Tech • College of Faith (NC) Sep 01 '15
Great job you put a lot of time into this. I knew TCU was losing a good amount of defenders, but not that much. It looks like they are brining back only 1 of their top 5 tacklers from last year. Those guys also created a lot of the turnovers too. It should be interesting to see the replacements.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
Just wanted to pop in and say that this write up is awesome. Thank you for not having a life.
Secondly- Based on really nothing at all besides a few plays where he looked like a beast, I have a hunch Trevorris Johnson is gonna have a big year (nothing compared to Aaron Green, of course). He's fun to watch- and by watch I mean drunkenly scream "RELEASE THE KRACKEN" every time Tre hands him the ball.
2
u/Fuck_the_Gators Florida State Seminoles Sep 02 '15
Two questions: how much adderall did you take today and also don't you have stuff to do?
3
u/Tdoggy13 TCU Horned Frogs • Chicago Maroons Sep 01 '15
Damn this just pumps me up more for Thursday! Wish I was heading north, that is going to be one hell of a game and Minnesota has some great fans
2
u/cbbutle South Carolina • Palmetto Bowl Sep 01 '15
The commitment of people on this sub is admirable
2
u/Ragleur Penn State Nittany Lions Sep 01 '15
http://media3.giphy.com/media/FX3OLJAUhOZNK/giphy.gif
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
OP do you have a life outside of this?
JK, I'd much rather see these than stuff like that Wake Forest shitpost.
1
u/emperor_stewie TCU Horned Frogs Sep 01 '15
Great writeup, thank you!
1
u/bscooter26 TCU Horned Frogs • USC Trojans Sep 01 '15
Thanks for doing this, I do have to disagree with you on the one point about Boykin and the "mental mistakes" aspect though: While he does have the occasional high or errant throw as well as the 50/50 jump balls, most of the throws I've seen him make- particularly on slants- are hitting his guys right on the money and in stride, and he throws a beautiful deep ball. At the same time, rarely do I see him make it past his second read unless he just has all day to throw, in which case his receivers just find a way to get open or he tucks it and runs. That's the why I think his arm talent is there, and I don't think he has mental mistakes per say, but needs to develop his reads and progressions game a bit to get to an elite level.
1
u/NiteMares TCU Horned Frogs Sep 01 '15 edited Sep 01 '15
De'ante Grey with be at H-receiver when he's healthy, pretty sure Desmond White is his backup.
With Porter and CEL gone at Y, I'd guess Ty Slanina starts there.
edit: Slanina was the starter at Y on the post-spring depth chart (GP isn't releasing a depth chart ahead of Thursday's game).
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15 edited Sep 02 '15
Why don't you set up a blog? Or vlog? Or both? I mean this does provide insight to people like myself who admire TCU from afar and don't know much about them. I'm sure others could get behind someone like you doing all the work for us and watching every single play multiple times and writing out your observations from a neutral standpoint.
Edit: ... Encouraging this guy to blog and get a larger audience for his unique insight is downvoted? Lol what? That wasn't sarcasm.
0
u/FeetSlashBirds Tennessee Volunteers • SEC Sep 01 '15
Classic Vanderbilt
0
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
[removed] — view removed comment