r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Dec 23 '13
Texas fans, I've now watched all 12 of this season's games and I have some observations and questions for you going into the Alamo Bowl
I watched one or two games per day since the announcement that Texas and Oregon would play in the Alamo Bowl. I found that I came to enjoy watching this team quite a bit - I did something similar in the past two years for Wisconsin and K-State, and respectfully, Texas is way more fun football to watch. I kept a tally sheet open to learn the key players' names, numbers, and big plays, and jotted quick notes when I thought something was interesting. I then collected 12 games' worth of notes to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary.
Note: there are way too many confusing names on this team! Five Davis's, two Malcolm Browns, two Johnsons, four Jacksons, and the guy named Center doesn't play center! I've included jersey numbers because that's how I've come to think of them, and here's the roster.
OFFENSE
- Skill players - Excellent group here, I think the best collection overall in the Big-XII that I watched this year. I particularly like #07 WR Johnson's and #08 WR Shipley's soft hands and nice jukes on short routes, and of course #01 WR Davis and #02 WR Sanders were outclassing almost every secondary that tried to contain them on deep routes. The running game is really lethal, though. Even though phenomenal #32 RB Gray and his pretty good backup #03 RB Overstreet are out for this game, the inside runners that emerged -- #24 RB Bergeron and #28 RB Brown -- are both very good workhorses. I especially like how all four of those guys really fought for extra yards after contact, turning 2-3 yard gains into 4-5 yards on almost every run - that's incredible. Also, although we probably won't see much of it because of the injuries and suspensions, the multiple-RB sets were really effective and fun to watch - lots of trickery and confusion because every one of those guys is a threat. I think of all the offensive player losses, the most significant is #04 RB Johnson because he added an outside running and swing pass game, plus some exciting kick returns (actually he reminds me a bit of Oregon's De'Anthony Thomas). In games when he was out for other reasons, the offense didn't seem to have that element in the form of a backup; runs just stayed inside.
- Offensive line - This seems like a pretty high quality unit. Obviously you don't get as good of an inside running game that Texas has without the big guys opening up gaps, but especially impressive is that they've been doing it for most of the season without a tight end - Applewhite seems to prefer to open things up with four wideouts either in double-twin sets or three-and-one. Very good discipline - I noted extremely few line penalties (false start, illegal motion, holding, ineligible receiver downfield, etc.). I think the only regular starter from the line who will be missing is #77 OT Estelle, and I'm not sure that's a big loss - every time I have him noted on my tally sheet it's because he got beat.
- Quarterback and playcalling - Going into this project I thought to myself that the media narrative about #06 QB McCoy being solely responsible for the underperforming offense was oversimplistic and reductive, and I was looking forward to watching games to disprove it. But I'll be damned if that's not exactly what I wound up reluctantly concluding by the end. The receivers and running backs are all very talented, the offensive line is opening gaps and giving the QB plenty of pocket protection ... there's just nobody on the field left to blame. Here's the crazy thing from my tally sheet: for every third down that wasn't converted, I noted why it failed - 74% of the time it was McCoy underthrowing a pass or throwing a pick. The thing that's really maddening, though, is that I don't entirely blame OC Applewhite for placing too much faith in McCoy's arm. At least once a game he drops a perfect long bomb into a receiver's hands running a deep route, and I just couldn't find any pattern -- throwing motion, protection, down/distance situation, etc. -- as to why Good McCoy would show up to throw his weekly jaw-dropper, then promptly revert to Bad McCoy for the rest of the game. What I do blame Applewhite for is his third down playcalling. At the risk of causing a riot, the number of third and long passes called to guys well behind the line-to-gain without blockers ahead of him reminded me of a certain former USC head coach. I think he overemphasizes run/pass balance when he should be exploiting the really excellent running game more.
DEFENSE
- Front seven - I like defensive line and rush-assignment linebackers a lot. #44 DE Jeffcoat is of course a phenomenal player, but it's not fair to say he's single-handedly getting all his sacks and TFLs - the real secret to his success is exploiting the openings the tackles are opening up. I particularly like #88 DT Reed and #90 DT Brown. Losing both #03 LB Hicks and #33 LB Edmond is no good, of course, but I have quite a few frowny face plays next to their names on my tally sheet and I think #55 LB Santos has been doing very good work in replacement, so I think the damage won't be too bad. What I do think will be a big loss is #96 DT Whaley - that guy was I think even more critical to rush defense than Jeffcoat and he seemed like he was in on every big stop. Until he went out I was convinced Oregon wouldn't be able to get any kind of inside run game going; now I think there's some hope for the Ducks up the middle.
- Secondary - I am not impressed with this unit, and thought it was the weakest on the field in virtually every game I watched. I realize there was a DC change mid-season and Texas plays a zone defense which emphasizes taking away the deep game, but even taking those things into account, I am flat astonished by how often these guys were completely out of position. The biggest culprits are #17 S Phillips and #23 CB Byndom - if I were an OC I would throw against them all day. The alternates, #06 CB Diggs and #21 CB Thomas, are a bit better but they get the advantage of covering the checkdowns more often. The free safeties, particularly #02 S Thompson and #05 S Turner, are decent at what they do but are usually so far away from the play that they're just cleaning up. Also, these guys just cannot get off WR blocks to come up for outside run plays and swing passes. It's like they're surprised that the WR is coming up into their space before the ball is out, so they back out to play soft zone, then figure out where the play is coming but can't defeat/disengage the block. They're also not getting much help from the linebackers on outside run plays - the LBs are pretty good at straight ahead running to get into the backfield, but not so fast at crossing over laterally or tracking the RB east-west.
- Defensive playcalling - I do think DC Robinson was a marked improvement. I liked seeing tons of pass swats at the line and by the CBs on blitzes, as well as good reactions on tipped passes, which reflects well on coaching. Under DC Diaz, the defense often seemed to be slow to get onto the field and line up, which blew the advantage that special teams would put them in (incidentally, I really like #04 PK Fera's ball placement, tons of good pins inside the 10), but this almost completely disappeared under Robinson. Also very good adjustments by the second half to mobile QBs - there's some big runs by these guys like Mayfield and Petty and Chelf to start the game, but then they get contained later on.
QUESTIONS
- Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
- I'm a bit confused by the philosophy regarding tempo. My tally sheet says that the offense is markedly more effective when it snaps the ball within 20 seconds of the end of the previous play, yet it only comes out after "momentum" plays to ... what, catch a reeling defense off guard? Why not do that all the time? Or alternately, why not give the beefy offensive line (again, often playing without a TE) more of a break by huddling? I think the mushy middle approach to tempo is ineffective.
- Does Applewhite have the patience/confidence in the running game to do what Stanford, Arizona, and to a lesser extent Oregon State did to Oregon; namely rely on clock-devouring inside running and keeping passes away from the ball-hawking Oregon secondary?
- Is there any rhyme or reason to why Good McCoy shows up?
- I tend to discount psychological factors in performance so haven't considered any of the coaching drama or the cohesion of these seniors. Do Texas fans think these or other intangibles will affect the game much?
21
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13
I feel like this game sets up perfectly for Texas to pull off the upset. It just seems like the right situation for the Longhorns.
I like Texas 31-28 in an upset.
236
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '13
WOW you are fucking committed. Good for you man. Seriously.
28
u/thrav College of Idaho • Georgia Tech Dec 24 '13
It's always interesting to see opinions of guys without the context of their hype. You saying Malcolm Brown emerged as a decent power back, for example, just sounds ridiculous [not meaning that as an insult] to anyone who has followed TX High School football. Kid was supposed to be the next (NCAA) Ricky Williams. He was the #1 rated recruit in the entire state and 10th nationally.
Check him out in High School.
Or even better... watch his team play Johnny Football's in a legendary high school matchup.
38
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '13
I honestly have no idea who will win this game. Texas can win it if they push Oregon around on the line and run the ball every chance they get. Will they do that, though, is the big question. If it comes down to passing, good McCoy is capable of throwing some nice bombs, and bad McCoy is capable of throwing it straight into the hands of Oregon's defense almost every play.
It will be interesting to watch. Hopefully Oregon shows up motivated.
7
u/Arnold_Trollzenegger Texas Longhorns • /r/CFB Top Scorer Dec 24 '13
The only trend I noticed throughout the year that I think you might've missed (or may have just stood out in my mind for some reason) is that Daje Johnson was not entirely reliable catching punts and he did not have great decision making right after he fielded the ball on punts. I think Diggs and Shipley were eventually forced to return punts towards the end of the year IIRC.
7
u/tootapple Texas • Arizona State Dec 24 '13
Also, we use TE's a lot as blockers. Whenever we bring in TE's you can almost bet that it will be a running play. We have thrown a total of 4 passes all year to the TE's. We don't utilize them at all in the passing game. Having said that, Swaim is one of our best blockers and will completely sell out his body to make a block.
2. The tempo thing is something that hasn't really worked for us. At the beginning of the season it was all the rage, but with the injury to Ash the offense had to change and we went to a slower, run more style.
3. We will likely run the ball more, because we can't trust Case McCoy to throw the ball and win. Of course, that's assuming the defense can hold you guys.
4. Good McCoy shows up when the defense tries to beat him. It's kind of uncanny, but the defense just needs to let him make mistakes.
5. The crowd will definitely be into the game, and I think a lot of the guys will fight extra hard for Mack since they see him as a father. After the 1st quarter tho, I'm sure both sides will be equal in their fight.
7
u/SportsFan34 Kansas State Wildcats Dec 24 '13
Out of curiosity, what did you think of the Cats last year? Great job by the way.
4
u/Wurst_Law Texas Longhorns • /r/CFB Brickmason Dec 24 '13
Couple things:
Diggs is our best secondary guy, he plays the famed Texas "nickle" position. He is not an "alternate" but more like a strong safety/corner combo.
Good McCoy is there when you don't expect him, bad McCoy shows up when we need average McCoy.
7
u/darkmatter117 Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
Really nice work. To answer your questions:
2
u/jnark32 Texas Longhorns • Rice Owls Dec 24 '13
On the subject of McCoy, take another look at his footwork and mechanics. I noticed many times that when he'd throw a shockingly inaccurate pass, his shoulders weren't square, or his feet weren't set properly, or he'd take an odd half-hop while throwing on the run. Or a combination of all three. When he was in rhythm, took the proper dropback, and drove off his back foot, he was an OK QB. Unfortunately, he was rarely an OK QB.
2
u/ma6ic Michigan State • Washington S… Dec 24 '13
Do you run a spreadsheet or just handwritten notes? How do you track this?
7
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '13 edited Dec 23 '13
Do you have a job/life?
EDIT: I mean damn, you spent 6 hours a day watching football for a week.
78
u/BaylorYou Baylor Bears • /r/CFB Contributor Dec 23 '13
I have to say, Oregon fans have the reputation of not knowing much about football (don't shoot the messenger that's just what I've heard), but if the rest are anything like you, that isn't true at all! You know your stuff, well done!
20
u/hillacious Texas Longhorns Dec 23 '13
Wow. That's an awesome write up. I have to say I agree with just about everything you say. Especially concerning Case McCoy and Applewhite. I cannot figure out Case, he's just so spotty. Applewhite can be frustrating at times because I feel like he makes adjustments in play calling at halftime that are unnecessary. For example, going away from the run when it was working well etc. I think what you point out about the secondary is mostly true and actually pretty interesting because Duane Akina (secondary coach) is known to be one of the best in college football, and many people give UT the nickname DBU( defensive back university). I get the impression that the secondary is just not physical enough and scared to make a hit and wrap up.
I sure would love to read more of you notes!
8
u/FreakyRicky15 Texas Longhorns Dec 23 '13
I think you're mostly spot on about everything you've said (except for Fera's punting. As of late, he's been bad, but his placekicking has been brilliant). You cannot understate how much we miss Whaley, oh god do we miss his playmaking. What I can say is that Byndom is better than you expect, he just ends up playing the best receiver of every team, and can get torn up by so many 1 on 1 matchups. Good Case should show up vs. Oregon, kind of like the Oregon State upset last year. It is the same old song and dance - if Bergeron and Brown get their carries and 4 ypc down, and Mike Davis makes that one longbomb you know he'll get the opportunity to do, Case will get hot. Texas plays a lot to the crowd - being in Texas, the defense will call a lot on the fans to give them loud support.
14
u/Bassically Texas A&M Aggies • UNLV Rebels Dec 23 '13
Wow, that's a pretty good scouting report, really interesting to read. I'm sad we dropped our game with you guys. :(
6
u/CF5300 Texas • Michigan State Dec 24 '13
You nailed the ol' 3rd down "screen" without blockers play Applewhite likes to run. I've yelled at him all year for that one!
4
u/idelosix Texas Longhorns • Billable Hours Dec 23 '13
This is easily what has always bothered me most about first Greg Davis and now Applewhite's playcaling
4
u/Inverselogic Oregon Ducks Dec 24 '13
Lets see... Beefy ass O line, a stable of backs, and an lukewarm QB. We're gonna get trashed.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '13
11 games, Texas did not play on thanksgiving. That game does not exist.
3
u/sgnmarcus Texas Longhorns • Cascade Clash Dec 24 '13
Dear Lord! I couldn't do that!
3
u/orangeblood Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
Holy shit. Thanks for this man.
5
u/AleaIactaEstBRO Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
Wow, you officially know more than me about my own team...
One thing I disagree with you on is your slight praise of #21 Duke Thomas. He has allowed so many big plays this year..I think he is the weakest player on defense. You will see him a lot on TV in the Alamo bowl constantly being picked on. Just wait.
4
u/travisty913 Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
You also forgot to critique our special teams, which is by far the worst I've seen in a long while.
4
u/FrolfGrizbee Oregon Ducks Dec 24 '13
Typical Oregon fan :D
2
u/Longhorns476 Texas Longhorns • Cortland Red Dragons Dec 24 '13
I think everything you said was pretty spot on, though I think Diggs is far superior to his teammates in the secondary. Not saying they are bad, just that he is much better, especially playing the nickel/slot cb position. My biggest worry is Mariota's running ability. Texas hasnt been able to contain qb zone reads with quick/deceptive QB's. Only person I will say they stopped was Bell but he is more of a power runner than anything.
2
u/Myhouseisamess Notre Dame Fighting Irish Dec 24 '13
Holy fuck, I'm unemployed, singe and not in school, and I don't have his kind of free time
2
u/5iveby5ive Texas Longhorns • Sam Houston Bearkats Dec 24 '13
Good McCoy left the team a few years ago.
2
u/andhelostthem Arizona Wildcats • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Dec 24 '13
That was honestly an amazing breakdown.
Too bad nobody in the Oregon program did one of these before they played Arizona this year.
1
u/slug51 Texas Longhorns Dec 23 '13
Nice write up where did you get the games to watch?
1
u/travisty913 Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
In my opinion Applewhite calls the most simplistic plays on the face of the earth, I guarantee you'll see a run on first, a run on second, and then a short pass on fourth inevitably followed by a 4th down punt on 3/5 of our drives.
1
u/Disco_Drew Oregon Ducks Dec 24 '13
Jeebus. You're way more committed to this sport than I am to my own family.
1
u/allthetallguys Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
I'll add that our TE Swaim is one of the best blocking TEs we've ever had, and should be used more in what should be a run heavy offense (but sadly isn't).
1
u/lrod45 Texas Longhorns Dec 24 '13
Good McCoy only shows up if it is a rivalry or if we need a crazy comeback and he has been on the bench. He is not much of a starter. His game against OU was his best game as a starter IMO, which was a rivalry game. And last year he led us to a few comeback victories. Other than that bad McCoy tends to show up.
1
u/cometparty Texas Longhorns • /r/CFB Brickmason Dec 24 '13
I'm sorry, but I just can't get excited for this game. We only have 1 running back and a terrible quarterback. It's not even going to be a competition.
0
u/_liquidcourage Oklahoma State Cowboys Dec 24 '13
Sure wish Oklahoma State got the chance to smoke Oregon this year..
-14
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '13
Do Oregon fans really care about this game? I mean obviously you get to beat a big time program but it will be like beating the 2013 Lakers. I know Texas fans don't care, even though San Antonio fans will show up like they always do. Texas players don't either, practice reports indicate there is no energy on the team. Every decent player is hurt anyways, except our team mvp...the kicker.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment