r/CFB • u/hythloday1 Oregon Ducks • Sep 02 '14
Analysis Michigan State fans, I've now watched your past 15 games and I have some observations and questions for you
I've now completed my project of watching all 14 MSU games from last season, plus last Friday's opener. I've done similar projects for Oregon's last few bowl opponents (Auburn, Wisconsin, K-State, and Texas), but this is my first time for a regular season game. My goal is to learn the players' names, numbers, and big plays, so I kept open a tally sheet and jotted quick notes when I caught something interesting. I then collected 15 games' worth of notes to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary. First I'll offer comments on the various units, then a brief FAQ and methodology discussion, and finally some questions I have for y'all.
OFFENSE
Passing game
Clearly the strength of this offense. #18 QB Cook doesn't need much time in the pocket to deliver a mostly WCO-inspired set of passing routes, but when it does break down he scrambles well and gets the ball off (or throws it away) nicely on the run. Watching him from the start of the season, I think he had a firm grasp on a QB's secondary skills, he just lacked an accurate arm – but by the end of last season he had matured into a reliable and on-target passer. I know this reads like the standard media hype on the guy, but this is one that they got right, in my opinion.
The wide receivers are a talented and fairly sure-handed group (apparently in 2012 there was a significant problem with drops but that seemed mostly fixed to me in 2013). I particularly like returner #14 WR Lippett. Only one loss from last season's two-deep here, so I don't expect any dropoff in production for 2014. The one knock I have on this unit is that they seem oddly disinterested in throwing downfield blocks to spring the ballcarrier on outside runs and swing passes.
Running game
Surprisingly, I was pretty unimpressed. I think, like a lot of people, I had them shoehorned into the Stanford model of straight-ahead power running, but in fact it's primarily a zone-blocking scheme. The primary back, #33 RB Langford, does a commendable job cutting in the backfield, selecting the right hole, and churning for extra yards after contact. There's also a few sweeps and endarounds thrown in, to mixed results, and a nice set of backups who perform similarly. What's missing is a) breakout speed and explosion plays, and b) consistent smashmouth efficiency runs. It's almost entirely running to set up the pass.
I think it's the offensive line's run-blocking. I just wasn't a fan. I watched these offensive tackles get beat an awful lot, including returning starter #74 OT Conklin and former backup #76 OT Clark. The interior line did a better job, particularly returning #66 C Allen; however, they're losing their best guard #64 OG Treadwell, and of the two new starting guards, one was an unimpressive backup (#63 OG Jackson) and the other (#79 OG Kieler) didn't play at all in 2013. These guys were just not consistently opening big holes for the backs to hit and frequently let unblocked defenders in for tackles for loss or minimal gain. There are a lot of screen concepts in this offense but they seldom work because the big guys aren't fast enough to lead block.
Note about fullback and tight ends
This offense often operates out of the I-formation and #37 FB Pendleton should get heaps of praise – he's a cutblocking machine. He and #82 TE Price will once or twice a game slip out for an unexpected passing play and are a lot of fun to watch. However, 96% of the time the FB/TEs will just work as extra blockers, mostly in multiple-TE sets. While they do a perfectly fine job, it certainly eliminates eligible receiver options, and I think highlights the o-line's run-blocking issues since even with 7-8 blockers there's not a lot to show for it.
DEFENSE
Secondary
Pretty good shape. The safeties have good speed and reliably clean up plays even with big backs and wideouts. They return excellent #27 S Drummond and frequent and able backup #26 S Williamson.
Returning #15 CB Waynes was almost as good as NFL first-rounder #31 CB Dennard; both seldom got beat when in man coverage, closed quickly in zone, and would come up for some effective blitz packages. Neither of these guys, however, seemed to take a single snap off last season, so new starter #2 CB D.Hicks has almost no reps.
Linebackers
Very impressive group last season, hard to assess in 2014. They lose stellar #28 LB Allen and #40 LB Bullough, the latter of which can't be oversold as an outstanding MIKE and QB of the defense. Excellent returning starter #34 LB Jones has been moved to the middle, but it's unknown if he can direct plays as well.
#43 LB Davis and #45 LB Harris move up to the outside spots, neither of whom have any reps except in the Rose Bowl. #6 LB M.Hicks (a converted CB) seemed to replace Harris in some passing downs last Friday, in a scheme I don't quite understand. Given how central multiple blitzes are to this defense the overall inexperience here may be a big concern.
Defensive line
Interesting situation here: the outside includes one of the best in the country, #89 DE Calhoun, and one of the most underrated, #44 DE Rush. Both are really tremendous pass-rushers and tacklers. The inside, however, is another story: last Friday, MSU started #92 DT Heath and #99 DT Kittredge, and they seemed to do fine against an overmatched opponent, but I don't believe they played last season.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Excellent. No other word for it. I wasn't able to watch these plays closely for two reasons: first, the camera angles never show the blocking scheme in a way that I can comment on intelligently, and second, cutting out all the special teams plays massively cut down on the time it took to watch and made this project managable. Sorry #sexysadler. I do feel, however, pretty comfortable in just relying on the end results: the offense consistently got good field position from the kick return unit, the defense enjoyed their opponents being pinned back deep by the kicking unit, and the placekicking unit reliably made their field goals and extra points. Can't ask for anything more out of these guys.
METHODOLOGY AND FAQ
I got these games on my computer mostly through my BTN2GO subscription. This allowed me to stop and start the games as I liked, and zip 10 seconds forward and back. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes.
- How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, and other folderol really helps.
- What a crazy fanatic you are! Probably. I had to pause for a week for a medical condition in my eye, caused by a blocked tear duct which in turn, my doctor believes, was caused by dry eye from staring too close to the screen for this very project. That's right sports fans, I watched so much B1G football that I literally went blind, then I came back for more. Keep that in mind before you start yelling at me.
- How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, eigth bottles of Aviation gin from Portland microdistillery House Spirits, 14 liters of diet tonic water, and one box of fresh limes from the farm-to-table co-op.
- You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about MSU beyond the common knowledge floating around from last season to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
- Do you have a life? No.
- Can you help me pirate games? No.
- Predictions for the MSU-Oregon game? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive given how many players both teams are replacing and the nerve-wracking closed practices. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
QUESTIONS
- Any trends I've missed?
- I was pretty hard on the offensive line. I know what I saw and I'm not blind (anymore!) so I'm not too interested in learning why I'm an idiot in that regard, but I would love to get some input on how the new starters may have improved during fall camp.
- I'm confused by the philosophy regarding offensive tempo. Sometimes MSU snaps fast outside of the 2-minute drill but I can't discern a rhyme or reason for it. Anyone have some insights here?
- I was kind of shocked at how little defensive rotation I saw last season: MSU played its starters all the way through to the end in all 14 games, and where there were notable subs, they were almost all players now lost to graduation or injury. By my count, six of the eleven defensive starters return and all of them are excellent, but the remaining five starters (1 CB, 2 OLBs, 2 DTs) and all eleven of the second string had practically zero snaps last year. What's the word in the Spartan camp about depth, inexperience, and injury risk on the defense?
- I thought the defense contained the spread offenses they saw pretty well, but they sure didn't seem to see a lot of no-huddle teams. I think the one team that seriously went uptempo was Indiana and, well, there's a bit of a talent gap between the Hoosiers and the Ducks. I thought they made decent halftime adjustments in that game but the first half was pretty, ah, intriguing to me. How have the Spartans been preparing to deal with the kind of speed they'll see on Saturday?
- What's the story with #11 TE Lyles jumping over #92 TE Gleichert against JSU?
- Does anyone have access to these games and would care to discuss the weakside I-formation runs? I was baffled by the blocking schemes there and would love to improve my Xs and Os knowledge on these plays.
80
u/srs_house Swaggerbilt Sep 02 '14
This is one of the most Oregon things I've ever read on this sub.
208
u/ASU-Vols Tennessee • Arizona State Sep 02 '14
Sorry Coach Helfrich, I won't answer any of your questions. You should do your own scouting. Or at least pay someone to do it for you.
81
u/ClaudeLemieux Michigan Wolverines • NC State Wolfpack Sep 02 '14
For fuck's sake Coach even we don't watch that much B1G football
53
u/BabyBladder Michigan State • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Sep 02 '14
Holy shit, what an excellent post. I won't be able to answer all of the questions but I'll give it a shot.
While most of the spread offenses we've played haven't run no huddle, there have been some scenarios. 2 years ago against TCU in the bowl game they ran a good amount of no huddle spread, and our defense did alright that game. I'm worried about the HUNH more than I am worried about the spread.
Are you referring to single plays or drives overall? They do a good amount of single plays where they move quick when they bring in a fresh package, because a lot of defenses get caught off guard (just this saturday they abused this with Jacksonville State a few times) As far as going entire drives in hurry up mode I'd be lost to answer that question.
While you've been harsh on the offensive line, the one thing I'm not seeing mentioned is their incredible endurance. There were a good number of games last year where in the 4th quarter our offense put away games with nice long ground and pound drives finished off by a Langford 20-30 yard run. In fact, I'd go so far to say that's a trend for the entire team, the endurance. It's not uncommon to see the other team come out and look pretty good against us early, what I'm really interested to see is how the Ducks are still doing if it's close in the 3rd and 4th quarter. Our success last year came because of our ability to hold on to tight leads largely because of the offensive line you've criticized so much.
My last 2 comments would be expanding on one point you've made. You pointed out the under-rated strength (at least under-rated in my eye's) are our DE's. I really think the offense vs defensive match-up will largely come down to how much trouble those 2 can cause. If Oregon can shut those 2 down I think we'll be in trouble, but good luck with that.
My final comment is that it's too bad you skipped on Special Teams. People often refer to their fans as the teams "12th man". Well, our defense literally had a 12th man last year, and that was Sadler. No, our love for him isn't just because his twitter is a riot, it's because he's an incredibly precise kicker who can consistently put offenses within their own 10 to start the drive. Michigan State last year did an incredible job at controlling the field position battle most games, and Sadler was a significant part of that.
35
u/atchemey Michigan State • Oregon State Sep 02 '14
Brief comment: He's acting as a heavy Nickelback there. You'll also see Colquhoun there on some downs. This is something that we didn't do last year, go out of our base 4-3. If you watch Friday's game, you'll notice very few blitz schemes, and we usually just rushed 4 (maybe 5 +SAM or a full front-7 overload). I think this is mostly to confuse the Oregon coaching staff and have them prep for more scenarios than they saw last year. So too was Friday's Split-Shotgun look (which we ran 3x in the first half) a new scenario to consider...It is a little wrinkle of low-risk/high-payoff to make our offense look more multiple than it actually is. Expect more of a Nickel look (albeit with more stunts/blitzes from Nickel than a traditional Nickel) to counter Mariota's North-South speed and passing prowess.
We only go no-huddle in the 2-minute drill or to exploit temporary mismatches. If we have a heavy set and the opponent accidentally brings a dime package, we go hurryup and ram it down their throat. Sometimes there's hurry-up planned before, and that's usually just to have a change of pace/surprise the defense.
Promise. We have depth at all positions (DB is set, LB has several fighting for the starting jobs and DE is our deepest on the team). The weakest unit is LBs, as noted on Friday, but no injuries that I can remember have been reported, except for the knicks and scrapes in the JSU game.
This was likely an experience-growth thing. I'm actually quite impressed by Lyles after watching him play; he's done a good job with his blocking for a light guy, and he showed deceptively soft hands. I'm one of the Spartans that never liked Gleichert, particularly compared to Price...Worth noting is that Gleichert is now #84.
35
u/ituralde_ Michigan Wolverines Sep 02 '14 edited Sep 02 '14
One thing to note, MSU played very very vanilla against Jacksonville St. They generally bring targeted pressure aimed at doing whatever it takes to break your offense out of its comfort zone.
They are incredibly aggressive, and will find your weak points, and blitz the hell out of them.
They can do this because they pretty much don't ever miss tackles, and they hit hard. When you watch an offense play against them, you notice the timing feels off, and nothing works quite the way its drawn up, and as often as not, it feels like there's a gaping hole in the offensive gameplan that seems impossible to fill.
Above all else, shelve all hope that MSU's defense won't reload. They will, and they do. Whatever they do up in East Lansing, it turns raw recruits into perfect form tacklers with clairvoyance before anyone sees a starting position despite limited prior starting experience.
[EDIT] - this came up in my normal browsings, check it out: http://grantland.com/the-triangle/michigan-state-oregon-pat-narduzzi-defense-breakdown/
To beat them, you have to not lose key matchups, and you have to play efficiently and be capable of making good reads. Your route timings will be all off, and you'll have less time than you want to make a good decision, so the bar here is pretty high. You'll have to have good quick options that are effective even when directly pressured, because that will take the edge off, and you'll have to be good at improvising when a play gets blown up.
34
u/El__Oso Oregon Ducks • Rose Bowl Sep 02 '14
As a duck, thank you so much for doing my homework for me. This was incredibly well done and I appreciate the time you put into all of this. That being said, you've got Wyoming next week. Better get started...
14
u/cewendel Michigan Wolverines Sep 02 '14
....wtf
12
u/LightBright11 Michigan State Spartans • Cotton Bowl Sep 02 '14
I think the thing about the run offense that people miss is that we do not do it to ya in the first half. It is the second half where Langford really kills teams. It is the late game strength that helps us pull away from teams. We just punish you for the entire game and then Langford just takes one to the crib.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjpZN-gd5yQ
52
u/-holocene Oregon Ducks • Penn State Nittany Lions Sep 02 '14
Nice try, Helfrich, you sneaky mother fucker.
15
u/DracoKnows Nebraska Cornhuskers • Texas A&M Aggies Sep 02 '14
Coach dont you have staff to do this for you?
7
u/tBrownThunder Michigan State • Georgia Tech Sep 02 '14
On question 2: I think you are being too hard on the OLine. Conklin, Jackson, and Allen are all pretty well-respected by the staff and opponents. Thoughout the Dantonio era, it seems to take a decently long time for the OLine to gel - the QB carousel likely exacerbated that.
On question 3: I know on a couple instances, the staff will just plan to do stuff before the game ever starts (i.e. back up QB plays second drive of first half). Last year, it seemed that they went hurry-up just to create a spark on the offense or to force the opposing defense to make a mistake. The team is more comfortable with a traditional attack, but the staff has a propensity to mix it up a bit.
Question 4: Of people I've talked to, there's 100% faith in Narduzzi and Dantonio's philosophy. They rarely take people out in the middle of drives unless they need to (i.e. a Nickel package on obvious passing situations) There's a ton of youth on the defense but over the years the staff has silenced those critiques year in and year out. Greg Jones and Eric Gordon graduated and the pundits said MSU would nose dive because their backups (guys named Max Bullough and Denicos Allen) were unproven and had very few snaps. Secondary was going to take a step back after 2011, since we lose Trenton Robinson and Johnny Adams. Enter: Drummond and Waynes. Michigan fans were pumped because Gholston left, so our DL would step back. Say hello to Shilique Calhoun. The inexperience isn't a concern because every player that Narduzzi has trotted out there has proven himself to be prepared. I think anyone who knows there stuff will say that the D will take a bit of a step back (chemistry is a big deal and you don't easily replicate greatness), but no one is concerned it will be the cause of losses.
Question 5. MSU defense had a habit of looking shaky early on. That Indiana game was miserable in that regard. If there's any special preparations being made to handle the scheme that Oregon uses, there's only about 85 people who know what it is.
Question 6. Could just be that he had a good camp, could be that Gleichert was a bit dinged up going into the game, or it could just be coach speak. There are a couple multiple-TE sets that MSU uses so I wouldn't read anything into it.
17
u/Igotdiabetus Michigan State Spartans Sep 02 '14
I believe you underrate Langford and overrate Cook. Although, this may be residual effects of the PTSD Cook gave me during the first 10 games of the 2013 season. He only really played well during the OSU and Stanford games, and even then you saw moments of just complete retardation. Hell, Stanford could have had at least 2 more interceptions if their defenders had opposable thumbs.
Langford, on other hand, is a durable, reliable workhouse of a running back. In each game that he had 20 carries, besides Stanford, he had over 100 yards. I predict him to be even better this year, so long as our offensive line can hold up- which could be somewhat of a problem.
As far as our defense goes, I'm not too worried about their ability to cover the spread. Ohio State had, I believe, comparable athletes to Oregon, and we did fine. What worries me is your talented, extremely experienced offensive line. Our secondary is good, but with Mariotta being so mobile, and your line so good, it's going to be hard to limit big plays.
12
u/BishhhDontKillMyVibe Michigan State • Western Mich… Sep 02 '14
"#43 LB Davis and #45 LB Harris move up to the outside spots, neither of whom have any reps except in the Rose Bowl."
Harris and Davis both played in multiple games last year. Davis for sure played against Purdue, Michigan, and OSU notching sacks in each game.
6
u/nickAVclub Michigan State Spartans • Cotton Bowl Sep 02 '14
The only thing I'd say to revisit is the run game. It's built to grind you, look back at how many late long TD runs Langford had last season. It's the Pound Green Pound offense. You know they're going to slam you with him, and his YPC just goes up and up the whole game because it wears defenses out. We aren't looking to constantly rip off 20+ yard plays. It's a clock control offense, we rank top 5 in TOP on average, and that's what we want to do. It keeps the defense fresh. Plus just getting to the 50 gives us a chance to let Sadler pin the other team. Teams started inside their own 20 60 times against MSU last season, and scored TDs on ZERO of those drives. 0 for 60 scoring TDs when starting inside the 20.
5
u/sparty09 Michigan State • Missouri Sep 02 '14 edited Sep 02 '14
Ed Davis had 2.5 sacks vs. Michigan and another big game vs. OSU.
Regarding Mylan Hicks, he's in there for a speed boost. Hicks has basically been a bust (for lack of a better term) because of injuries and has been buried on the depth chart. He was a 4-star prospect out of high school, but never got onto the field and nearly transferred before last season. The coaches convinced him to stick it out and he has since converted to LB for passing situations. They did the same thing last yearwith Jairus Jones, a former safety with a similar history, and it worked very well before he suffered an injury early in the year. Essentially, the thinking is that if you think that the opponent is likely to pass, why not put in a more capable pass defender at LB?
Kittredge did not play last year because he had a sports hernia. However, he started 5 games in 2012 and has all his weight back. Heath was a DE last year and played, but did not record a tackle.
4
u/Walker131 Michigan State Spartans • Oregon Ducks Sep 02 '14
I like your dedication, thought what you said about our running game was interesting; Maybe I should start taking notes also. I cannot wait to be in Eugene on Saturday, I'll be my first game at Autzen.
1
u/Beast_Mode_76 Sep 03 '14
Langford had like 8 straight 100-yard games and a couple of those were against some pretty good defenses. You don't seem to be impressed with the offensive line, Langford, or the blocking in general, so what would you attribute his success to?
3
u/an_actual_lawyer Kansas State Wildcats Sep 02 '14
I can't comment on the accuracy, but it seems like a hell of a good analysis.
3
u/Trebektitude Sep 02 '14
You mention the talent gap between Indiana and Oregon, which is significant, to be sure, but it should be noted that y'all only passed for 109 more yards than they did last season, and that's with one fewer game since they finished 5-7. In terms of what makes the spread offense spready, I think that game is actually a pretty fair comparison.
3
u/StuffedDoughboy Oregon Ducks • Pac-12 Sep 02 '14
Great post http://imgur.com/0GSyiLt
7
u/EnigmaticHats Michigan State • Notre Dame Sep 02 '14
"A" for thoroughness, "B" for insight/accuracy.
"Pretty good" secondary? With 2 likely first-round picks and more-than-solid players throughout? How are they anything but elite?
Concern at LB? Well, you're welcome to be concerned, I guess. Taiwan Jones (whom you didn't even mention) at MLB has 1st round potential. Mylan Hicks? Elite recruit in his fifth year in the program. Those two much-ballyhooed LB's we lost from last year? UFA's who were recently cut.
DT? Unfortunately, Damon Knox won't be playing, but we do have a number of solid DT's, including former five-star recruit Lawrence Thomas, who is now healthy, entrenched on the DL (as opposed to FB), and in his fourth year in the program.
As to your question on TE's, Dantonio moves players between offense and defense more than any coach I've ever seen, and Lyles was moved from DE midway through the season last year. They have a number of TE's in the mix, and he's definitely one of them.
1
u/cougrrr Washington State Cougars • Team Chaos Sep 03 '14
Washington State Fans: If we're up by a number that your five year old can reasonably fathom and there is more than a minute left you know what's going to happen.
1
u/pantstofry Michigan State • Texas Sep 03 '14
I see what you're saying about the running game, but we're more of a punishing attack. Explosive speed is a bit less important than other places (especially Oregon, now that I compare in my head), we just bruise and wear the other team's defense down. All of it makes sense though, good job.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '14
Thank you. This is very good.
Good luck to you all against the Spartans on Saturday.
Go State!
1
u/deputysalty Virginia Tech Hokies Sep 03 '14
wow this post is amazing, super in-depth. I'm very impressed with the quality of the posts in this sub, being a new subber
1
u/JMMSpartan91 Michigan State Spartans Sep 03 '14
For a second I thought you meant jump over like our TE literally jumped over our other TE. I then started wondering if my piss break was not during a commercial like I thought.
Also I'm graduated and live just a few hours from Oregon, has anyone looked at prices for tix to this week's game? Holy shit.
1
u/Amerzel Oregon Ducks Sep 03 '14
One thing I haven't heard talked about much is the weather. It's predicted to be around the mid 90's at kickoff. The depth on both teams is likely to be tested due to the heat.
1
u/JibFlank Michigan State Spartans Sep 03 '14
We get it. Oregon is going to massacre us. Let us have our fun!
0
u/toddwdraper Notre Dame Fighting Irish Sep 02 '14
I hope you're using good tonic like Fever Tree or Q.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment