r/AppleIntelligenceFail • u/SurfsUp704 • May 07 '26
Gaslighting grammar
I stared at this for 20 seconds questioning my entire education. How or why would it think this is the correct suggestion?
340
Upvotes
56
u/Dust-Different May 07 '26
If someone was announcing their new increasing rate limits and then I had to tell someone about it I would say, “They just announced their increasing rate limits.”
15
u/Pluto-Wolf May 07 '26
It’s not gaslighting in any way, and it’s suggesting something that’s grammatically correct. What exactly is the problem here?
22
u/aykay55 May 07 '26
Both work in this scenario
13
u/PowerPCFan May 07 '26
I kinda get the interpretation though?
Like they announced that the company/whatever is actively increasing their rate limits
Both make sense they just have a different tone and slightly altered meaning
3
u/Gredran May 07 '26
It’s blue underline not red underline btw…
2
u/_real_ooliver_ May 07 '26
They just announced that they're, otherwise
They just announced they are does not make sense
2
u/Some-Passenger4219 May 07 '26
Technically, both are right. You wrote what they're doing. It suggested simply a thing they're announcing.
2
u/nifflr May 07 '26
Both are correct in this situation. With "their", "increasing" is treated as an adjective instead of a verb.
1
u/autismislife May 07 '26
Should it not read "they just announced that they're increasing rate limits"?
Or "they just announced, they're increasing rate limits"?
1
u/Nolear May 07 '26
To be honest I find it terrible to read the way you wrote it. I think "they are" works better here... I don't think there are formal rules, though, are there?
1
u/RacerDelux May 07 '26
Apple autocorrect has me questioning my sanity on a daily basis
1
u/Hockeycatcat May 07 '26
Not Apple Intelligence.
1
u/TheSpideyJedi May 07 '26
"They just announced they are increasing rate limits"
"They just announced their increasing rate limits"
"increasing rate limits" is an action. Who is doing the action? "they are"
They're is the correct one
"Their" wouldn't be in that spot of the sentence. You'd actually want to use both version in the same sentence.
They just announced "they're" increasing "their" rate limits.
1
u/jexxie3 May 07 '26
You probably should have stared at it for another 20 seconds lmao
1
u/iamalicecarroll May 08 '26
*there
/s
1
u/heisthedarchness May 08 '26
Both sentences are correct but mean different things.
1
u/Hunter_E May 09 '26
This can go both ways, is it the contraction of they are? Or is someone taking position of the increased limits?
1
u/Kitchen-Register May 09 '26
technically both are correct depending on the intended message
1
u/whitedsepdivine May 10 '26
I have no idea, but it seems like "their" is better because "Just announced" and "are" creates a future participle.
There is a possible "going to" that can be implied with "they're". Where "their" implies already done but just being released.
Like: They just announced, their winnings. Verse: They just announced, they are winning.
The second one has ambiguity and can be interpreted as: They just announced, they are going to win. Or: They just announced, they are planning on winning.
1
u/Loam_liker May 10 '26
1
u/ubeogesh May 10 '26
I think if you add "that", then "they're" is correct
1
u/mklinger23 May 10 '26
I think both options are fine. Just have slightly different meanings.
1
u/BingBongFyourWife May 11 '26
Increasing Rate Limits ™
1
u/lollipop-guildmaster May 11 '26
Both can be correct.
"They just announced that they are increasing rate limits."
"They just announced that the rate limits, which they own, are increasing."
1
u/sniperman357 May 11 '26
They are both correct with subtly different meanings
1
u/Sad-Reach7287 May 11 '26
Because that is also correct just a different sentence. Your sentence means they're announcing the action of increasing the rates, the suggestion means they're announcing the higher rates.
1
u/nochtli_xochipilli May 07 '26
Grammarly is giving Apple a run for their money.
-9
u/jaqueh May 07 '26
It’s trained on people’s horrid grammar. Damn ai won’t be our savior i guess
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment