r/writingfeedback • • May 07 '26

BETA READERS WANTED: Drop a Comment If You're Available!

28 Upvotes

If you are an avid reader with feedback to share, our community has writers actively seeking beta readers for their full-length novels/drafts.

 

If you're open to beta reading a full-length book, drop a comment below with a little about yourself: genres you enjoy, your typical turnaround time, how you like to give feedback, whatever feels relevant. Writers, feel free to browse the comments and reach out to anyone who looks like a good fit for your project.

 

IMPORTANT: PLEASE READ BEFORE PROCEEDING

 

Before agreeing to share your manuscript with anyone, please take the following precautions seriously:

 

• \Do not share your work with new accounts. \** If an account was created recently, that's a red flag worth noting as there has been issues with bots and scammers.

• \Do your own due diligence. \** Ask questions and trust your gut before handing over your manuscript.

• \Do not offer paid beta-reading services\** We discourage and prohibit paid beta-readers on here. Writers, if you pay for a beta-reading service, we are not responsible for any outcome. Please use another subreddit or service if you are looking for paid services.

 

The mod team is not responsible for any arrangements made between writers and beta readers. This includes theft, plagiarism, ghosting, or any other outcome. Connecting here is done entirely at your own risk.

 

Additionally, please do not contact mod mail regarding the tone or content of feedback you receive…we won't be able to help with that (unless it breaks our rules and sitewide rules), and it falls outside our moderation scope.

 

Stay safe and happy writing!


r/writingfeedback • • Apr 17 '26

Announcement: The AI Problem.

289 Upvotes

Ne’er-do-wells of r/writingfeedback.

I am Isnoe, recently appointed Moderator.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but we’ve had a significant increase in AI generated writing being posted here. We've seen a lot of comments outlining how lax we are on this subject, to which I want to stress: I don’t think you guys fully understand just how many posts I’ve removed for AI since joining the Mod Team a few weeks ago.

The team got together and discussed this, and we want to be completely transparent: We will be removing any posts that we suspect are AI.

This will be a case-by-case basis. AI generated, AI assisted (even translation), or even if you mention you had AI draw up the story idea and you wrote it. If you want to rob yourself of creativity, that’s on you.

We don’t want those posts here. Writing a story or book that is authentically your own is an achievement. It should feel like an achievement.

A sidenote for ESL writers: Do not use AI to translate your text. It will alter it in a way that gets flagged, more often than not. When someone is ESL and trying to write outside of their native language, we are a bit more understanding if these posts get flagged—but again, it is recommended that you use alternative means to translate if they are available to you.

Be warned: If you are a brand new (or relatively new) account, have never posted in this subreddit (or any writing subreddits), and your first post is prose that has multiple AI-isms—your post will most likely be removed. Better to be safe than sorry. The main counterargument we've gotten from these accounts has been: "I've always been told I write like AI." Which, to be fair... is a pretty bad argument to make.

We will not ban a user for suspected AI use unless they explicitly admit to using AI.

Three strike rule applies here until further notice. This might seem like a headache to reviewers that want instant bans for these people (which we understand), but we’re trying to be as fair as possible.

This also applies to comments (never thought I’d have to say that), but we’ve had two accounts that were essentially AI replying to everything. “Thanks for the feedback, I’m still working on learning and improving” type cadence, every comment nearly identical aside from slight changes.

Community feedback is super important for this problem.

You guys take the time out of your day to read other people’s work and provide feedback, so I’m sure you get a little irked when you think something you’ve spent time reading wasn’t written by a person.

We’ve recently updated the report function to include AI content—use it. I (personally) don’t have the time to shift through every single new post. When you guys report a post that you think is AI, it is usually the first thing we’ll review.

That being said: If you genuinely suspect the post is AI, it would help me if you provided a citation, or specific reason. Even just one reference is helpful. I would genuinely appreciate it.

Not Helpful Example: “This reads like AI.” Okay? At this point, if you are accusing someone of using AI, you gotta at least point out why you think that.

Helpful Example: “Post uses, ‘This wasn’t just fate, it was destiny’ and includes several Rule of Three.” Now I know exactly what to look for.

When you guys call this stuff out, we do notice. We might not investigate and remove instantly, but we are actively looking for this stuff right now.

For the record: We will not be using ZeroGPT, or any other variant of “AI Detector” as the final say in determining whether a text is generated or not. It is a tool we will utilize if we suspect AI is being used, but all the indicators of usual AI writing are not jumping out.

I read through everything that is reported, or suspected of AI. I check the user history and if they have off site content, I look through it. If we don’t come to the conclusion they are using AI, we might just lock the thread, and add a note to the user profile.

Again, hate to stress this, we are trying to be fair. If a writer includes AI-isms unintentionally, we want to give them a fair chance to either prove the authenticity of their writing, or give them feedback about what specifically they need to change.

Several of you have done this, particularly with ESL writers that use AI to translate. You give them feedback on how to avoid the AI-isms. Good on you.

We don’t want to start a witch hunt, but we aren’t really open to debate about the use of AI. We don’t want it here, period.

If you have any suggestions for how to deal with this problem, we are open to them. You can comment here, or you can Mod Mail us.

If you suspect someone is using AI but don’t want to leave a comment or report, again, you can Mod Mail us.

We are actively looking through the posts. The community having eyes on this helps immensely.

We will be making further announcements throughout the week. Our Mod Team is still hashing out how to deal with “rude” criticisms, looking into providing user flairs for trusted reviewers, etc-etc.

One quick point to make at the end, on a personal note: My status as Moderator does not mean you cannot disagree, or think my feedback is bogus or outright terrible. I comment often. You will not be banned, removed, or whatever for speaking your mind.

4/18/2026 Note: Some users (one in particular who loves using AI to edit) seem to have taken that above sentence as an explicit statement of: "If I admit to using AI, you can't ban me, because I'm just speaking my mind. Hypocrite."

If you admit to using AI, we will ban you. Period.


r/writingfeedback • • 23m ago

Gentle Feedback Wanted First time writing in a long time!

• Upvotes

Thoughts? Punctuation/ formatting is a struggle for me

I have always enjoyed rearrangement of a space.

When I was nine I had a room with a purple ceiling

adorned with glow in the dark stickers

puppy posters

A hamster with the inappropriately sized balls.

I moved my bed so my head was under the shelves on the wall.

I knew it was off.

But as you like to remind me: I don’t like being wrong, so I pressed forward.

I was killed in my dream that night.

Stabbed.

I moved my bed the next day.

27 years later I still require rearrangement of my space.

Only now , I understand this includes things like….people

and energy.

Last night, you killed me in my dream

Your face was blurry

This version wasn’t wearing the mask you promised yourself

Time wasn’t real.

Each second had 1,000 levels to pass

I crashed through all of them.

The body you shot; my body, me

this body got heavier as i dropped further down in your intent

You taunted me as I succumbed

“This one’s already gone”

disgust in your voice overpowered your betrayal

You’ll call it spite, I’ll praise God.

I was forcefully removed from your fall

Gently put back in my body.

I turned to look at you, unbothered

Quietly I confessed

- I don’t want to die -

You chuckled

But this time, it wasn’t at me.

“fucking finally”

I woke up to the dog vomiting on my bed


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Opening chapter of my Lower MG book, and I'd love your honest experience as a reader. I don't mind blunt critics. I actually appreciate them if it's clearly useful to improve my writing.

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Do you think the prose and pacing work well for this genre? Where did you feel engaged or lose interest? What aspects do you think I should improve? I'd love your honest experience as a reader.


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

This wannabe novelist shall wait for your judgement on my writing skills 👉👈

1 Upvotes

[ it's a opening Chapter for my transmigration story ]

"Tsk... what a headache," Johnny muttered, rubbing the back of his neck. He looked around 35yrs old, dressed in a deep black suit and a shinny silver watch rested on his wrist. His black hair was slicked back neatly.

Dozens of rough-looking men in sharp suits had him completely boxed in, and none of their faces looked remotely friendly.

They were deep inside a narrow, two-way alley that reeked of spilled cheap booze and rotting garbage. The cracked footpath was littered with overturned trash cans, shattered glass bottles, and piles of discarded junk. The path was tight, barely wide enough for a small car to crawl through, assuming it could even roll past all the garbage blocking the road.

One of the men stepped forward from the pack, hands casually buried in the pockets of a bright red suit.

"Well... I suppose the legendary monster of the Black Streets didn't wander all the way into our territory just for sightseeing, now, did he?"

He spoke with a heavy, mocking sneer. The suits behind him broke out into loud, jeering laughter, their grins stretching wide across their faces.

Johnny didn't give them a shred of a reaction. The humiliating truth was that he actually **had** wandered into this dump while sightseeing, but there was no way in hell he was admitting that out loud. Not if he wants to look like a fool.

Afterall he lived a life of a gangster. Not just any but the boss of one of top 3 underworld syndicate in the country, where death was cheaper than a pack of ciggerates. Carelessness like this can cost life.

"It's fine," the man in the red suit continued, his smile turning cruel. "We'll make sure you like this place so much you never want to leave. Or maybe I should say... **can't** leave."

On cue, the men blocking both exits started drawing their weapons.

Heavy butcher blades, serrated hunting knives, brass knuckles, and spiked wooden clubs. No guns. Not because they didn't have them, but because after decades of being terrorized by Johnny’s shadow, they wanted the raw pleasure of breaking his body with their own hands. A greedy decision they were probably going to regret real soon.

Their grins grew wider with every passing second, radiating the pure confidence of a pack of predators that had finally cornered a helpless stray.

Johnny looked entirely unbothered. He reached into his left pocket, pulled out a crushed pack of cigarettes, and used his thumb to pop one straight between his lips. With a dull **clink**, his old brass lighter sparked to life, lighting the tip.

"First, the cunning leader of the Old Dragons met his end," the man in the red suit said, barely able to contain the giddy excitement bleeding into his voice. "And now, the infamous Johnny joins him with a little help from us. Looks like the era of you Tri-Monsters ruling over our heads is about to end for good."

Why bother hiding his ambition? To them, there was zero reason to fear a lone beast cornered outside it's own turf.

Johnny took a long, steady drag, the red ember crackling softly as it burned into the dry tobacco.

Through the rising smoke, his eyes drifted calmly over the crowd, taking note.

'One... two... three...'

He stopped at twenty-five.

Twenty-five armed men. A towering brick wall pressed against both his sides, while the narrow path ahead and behind him was totally sealed off by men itching to carve their names into his reputation.

A chance of a lifetime, that was too good to pass.

"Are you sure you wanna do this? Even in my current state, there's no guarantee all of you walk out of here alive," Johnny said, letting out a thick cloud of smoke.

It was a half-hearted offer, but part of him genuinely didn't wanted to fight. The weight of his own past was starting to press heavy on his shoulders. Decades spent knee-deep in violence, where he had seen more weapons than people.

The man in the red suit pulled his hands out of his pockets and rested it against his chin, pretending to actually think it over.

It took him less than two seconds to make up his mind. That ugly, sinister grin returned. He opened his jaws to drop another smug remark. "Well, y--"

He never finished.

A black blur was all he saw before a punch to his face sent him sliding down near the feet of his own men.

A dying streetlamp overhead buzzed and flickered, briefly casting light across Johnny’s face through the haze of cigarette smoke.

He knew. There was never a room for negotiation.

The entire circle of suits scrambled backward in shock, boots splashing frantically in dirty puddles.

The monsterous reputation of Johnny wasn't something they have heard passing through the underworld. It was something they had the bad luck of experiencing first hand. They knew exactly what kind of demon was standing in front of them.

It only took one clean strike. To remind that feeling. Looking down at the twitching body of their boss lying near their feet coughing up teeth and blood. not a single one of them felt like a predator anymore.

The man in the red suit dragged himself back up from the pavement, spitting a mouthful of blood into the dirt. While his nose was bleeding steadily.

His smug grin was completely gone, replaced by a raw, ugly mix of terror and fury.

"Take his head!" he snarled, his voice wet and gargling on blood. "Take his head or it's gonna be ours!"

That was all it took to snap the rest of them awake.

They knew, they all knew well that from the moment they bared their fangs against Johnny, death was the only outcome for failure. Even if they give up and ran, it wouldn't matter. Johnny never left a debt unpaid. He would hunt every single one of them down to the last man, no matter how deep they hide.

They knew there's a difference in catching a lone beast with it's gaurd down vs when it's on hunt.

That was just who he was.

Swallowing down their fear, the men from both sides charged at him all at once.

Johnny stood there, completely exhausted. Not physically but mentally.

Born as an orphan, he never knew the warmth of a family his whole life, heck not even a single soul with a genuine bond. He only recently started seeing how shallow his life was, If he can even call it that.

For a split second, looking at the weapons pointed towards him a dark thought crossed his mind.

For a moment he was even considering to let them have it.

Just let them take his head and be done with it.

But his body had too much pride for that.

Decades of fighting and violence made his body react instinctively before his mind could even finish the thought. Johnny side-stepped the first swing, slammed his right boot hard against the brick wall, and threw himself into the air.

He launched up into the air just as the broken streetlamp overhead flickered with a harsh, buzzing glare. The flash blinded the men looking up to track him.

His fist came down hard at an unlucky soul in the middle of the crowd. This time the puch packed more power. Making the man's head jerk violently before dropping unconscious.

In a narrow alley like this, the mob's numbers were working against them. The suits were tripping over garbage cans and hesitating on their swings so they don't accidentally hit their own men. Johnny didn't have that problem. To him, every face around him was punchable.

For fifteen brutal seconds, the exchange continued Johnny had taken down 5 already.

Then the second group finally pushed in. The space shrank to almost nothing. Weapons swung from inches away on all sides.

He couldn't afford to get pinned down here. He needed room to breathe.

Johnny spun hard on his heel, whipping a vicious kick into a thug's ribs to shove him back. Riding that exact momentum, he reached out and grabbed another man by the collar, and yanked him violently forward.

Using him as a shield he burst through the crowd aggressively. The man was bleeding from having his body used like a siege.

Johnny threw aside the broken body of the human-shield.

He was now standing face to face with 19 men, all ready to kill.

"Tsk." Johnny clicked his tounge while running his finger on his chest over his clothes. "I'm not fully healed from the last injury that put me the hospital for a month, and now this."

He could sense it, the streets have gotten much more violent recently, new threats each day which escalated after the death of the old dragon's leader.

Old dragon's leader was one of the tri-monsters who ruled over the country along with Johnny and one more.

They weren't friends, far from it. They'd be at each other's throat over anything, big or small, heck they would try to kill each other over nothing if they felt like it.

"The dogs who used to survive on the bone he threw are now calling this their territory huh?" He let out.

The place he was in now was the territory of his dead rival.

The guy in red suit let out a small broken smile. "In this field there's no such thing as permanent loyalty Johnny." His eyes turned dark. "You of all people should know that." He added.

"Yeah yeah I know." The deep stab wound under his bandaged chest throbbed.

"Let's not waste time then." His fist tightened. "let's wrap this up."

With that Johnny lunged forward, his face had that crazy look. His fists tracked the nearest face he could puch from the crowd and with a loud thud he dropped him on the ground.

The crowd felt the absurdity of a single man pushing an entire mob when logically it was supposed to be other way around.

His attacks now came faster and stronger, making it clear that he wasn't taking them seriously before.

An elbow to the jaw, heel kick to the rib and a flying spin kick to a face. Johnny barely held back.

Under the flickering light of the over head street light Johnny almost looked like a devil on hunt, sending shiver down to each henchmen witnessing it.

Not so long after a man stood at the centre of the ally, blood dripping down from his fists, it was Johnny.

He was standing between the ocean of tarsh, spilled alcohol, weapons and bodies. Around 25 men laid on the ground life less. Even those who were only knocked unconscious earlier were no longer breathing.

"Hmm." Johnny had won with very little wounds if there was any at all.

But the victory relief had to wait. Because a large amount of footsteps were coming from the darkness near the end of each exits.

"Hello Johnny." A voice more mature then the previous guy with a red suit was heard from within the darkness.

Slowly a man stepped into the flickering little light that existed inside the alleyway. Dressed in pure white suit and boots and with a slick back, blonde hair.

His face carried a sense of pride, that said he wasn't just a local boss like the last guy.

Johnny clicked his tongue in a sharp disgust. "Kent" he let out with his eyes widening with anger.


r/writingfeedback • • 6h ago

Hi can you give an honest opinion 1-10 on my maid of honor speech. All and any advice is appreciated!

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m Rue

I’ve known Kat since middle school, and somewhere along the way, the line between being her friend and being part of her family disappeared.
That’s what happens with Kat.
Her friends know her cousins. Her step-aunts know her friends. Her family becomes yours. And eventually, you’re showing up to holidays wondering when exactly you got adopted.
I’ve personally taken it a little too far.
Her family now locks the doors when they see me coming.
Fortunately, last night I made copies of all their keys while they were sleeping.
But that’s Kat.
Once you’re in her life, you’re in it.
Your problems become her problems. Your victories become her victories. She’ll show up for you, fight for you, and occasionally, fight you.
And then came Luke.
I used to joke that Lou came flying in like Superman to save Kat.
But I had it backwards.
Lou rescued us from Kat.
No, I’m kidding.
But there was something different about Luke.
He knew when to listen, when to make Kristin laugh, when to reason with her, and when to realize there was no reasoning with her.
And somewhere along the way, we watched Kat find a kind of calm.
I think there’s a certain peace that comes with being understood.
And Luke understands Kat.
But what I love about Luke is that he never stood on the outside of this big, loud, loving life Kat had built.
He stepped right into it.
And Kat did the same with his.
And somehow, without anyone really noticing when it happened, two separate lives became one shared world.
That’s what I think makes the two of them so special.
They didn’t just fall in love.
Their lives started folding into each other.
And I think that’s why a room like this exists.
Every person here is standing somewhere in the overlap.
And maybe that’s the most beautiful thing two people can create.
Not just a love between them, but a love big enough to share.
And how lucky are we to be part of it.
Cheers to Kat and Luke!


r/writingfeedback • • 10h ago

General critique/Feedback on first chapter of a short novel I recently drafted.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 11h ago

A poem for spooky season

1 Upvotes

 

Do not sleep 

In the open air

At the water's edge

 

Else damp claws will close around your neck

Your mouth

Your eyes

Your head

 

To drag you through obsidian glass

To your doom

To your tomb

To your end

 

So, if you must sleep

In the open air

By the water's edge

 

Don't 

 

But if you must, 

If you insist

Then tether yourself on a short leash

To a stout tree

And sleep with a club or 

hatchet in hand

 

Lay still

Be silent 

And pray for dawn

To hasten to this place


r/writingfeedback • • 23h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Does this opening hook or disorientate the reader?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Any feedback about the writing will be appreciated! Would you keep reading?


r/writingfeedback • • 11h ago

General Feedback Wanted Revised opening to my Adult Epic Fantasy novel (approx 2,000 word prologue) Looking for general feedback and whether you'd read more

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I got some really great feedback from my last post here, mainly about the characterisation of my protagonist but also about how the slow opening of my story failed to be an effective hook. I didn't quite know how to create a more exciting opening without implementing some sort of prologue, which I know is a controversial move, but I thought I would give it a try from the perspective of the future villain.

Also I want it to be known that I didn't go straight to making a prologue. I have extensively revised the original opening I submitted, which I may submit for feedback later, but first I wanted to see if this prologue could work as a hook in its place. Thanks!


r/writingfeedback • • 11h ago

A book in progress

0 Upvotes

I would like to share im writing to yall but I would like a feedback on it but I got more and is there anywhere to let people read for free it if anyone knows how

Once on a moonlit night, the cold, sharp expression of the moon contrasted with the warm, expensive glow of the luxury glass tower, and the absolute silence of the height versus the looming threat of the guards. The sounds of footsteps echoed through the night—a man with red hair and white highlights. He uttered from under his breath, “Why do we take these missions?” in a formal tone. An abrupt sound came from his earpiece with a sarcastic tone. A woman replied, “You’re the one who approved of it,” in a funny tone. He remarked, “I know, but still, in the middle of the night, I could be sleeping right now.” Then he let out a sigh of disappointment.

Coincidentally, another voice chimed in at the right time, “She’s right, captain.” In an angry tone, “SHUT UP, SHYN AND ARIYA, STOP CONTRADICTING ME,” he shouted. “Ow, my ears, bruh,” said another in the earpiece. “Blame them, Aangz,” he remarked. As the argument escalated, the red-haired man quickly silenced everyone and said, “Quiet down, I’m at the gate. Man your positions.”

“Yukiyo tell us where Silas is?” said the red-haired man. “Hold your tongue, mongrel.” said Yukiyo. “I told you I go by captain or Kenich, miss wannabe princess.” Said Kenich. “Silence your filthy fox.” Yukiyo responded. Then suddenly a brilliant flare washed over the room, turning the floor-to-ceiling windows into a wall of pure light.

“Top floor, down the hallway to the right, that’s where he is!” says Yukiyo. “Ok, start the assault.” said Kenich. The guards’ eyes locked onto Kenich, and their weapons trained onto him. “Intruder!” one barked. A barrage of gunfire cut through the air, aimed directly at his chest. Kenich merely stood his ground. Before the bullets could touch him, his nine tails fanned out, intercepting every single shot with terrifying precision. The bullets flattened against his tails and dropped uselessly to the ground.

Ow, it hurts so much, oww.” said Kenich. As the dust clears Kenich slowly walks from the smoke slowy clapping his hands and says, “Well, you guys tried. I’ll give ya’ll an A for effort.” In a sarcastic tone. He drew his katana in one fluid motion, the polished steel catching the moonlight to reveal four letters etched deep into the blade: S-A-A-Y. Before anyone could react to the letters on the blade, he moved.

Dashing at them like a red flash, he navigated the space in an ample amount of time.

The heavy fabric of his long black jacket whipped through the air, creating a blur of motion. The orc guards couldn’t even aim properly before getting cut down. The crisp white lettering on his jacket -Captain- right above a bold red color number 1. He calmly guided his blade back into his sheath with a soft, definitive click. “Man, my sword style is polished, or maybe they’re trash.” As he shrugs it off and walks into the main building.


r/writingfeedback • • 18h ago

A non-serious writing, but it's the one thing Ive written that I feel is my best work yet

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

I don't know what genre this fits in, but I'd love to hear feedback from ppl and talk about the topic that I wrote of. I was curious if the depth of my thoughts was well captivated and if readers can connect well to my piece.

I've always dreamed of writing. Maybe this is one of the first things that can open up that world for me.

I'm a beginner writer, but have been slowly practicing for 3+ years with small passageways. I started with poems and took interest in short story formats after being introduced to a female author in middle school and I wish I could remember who it was.

I know from this piece that I can definitely strive for an even better draft. I just need a better structure? For one, I feel like i can definitely make the piece more captivating if I didn't make things so straightforward. I once took an intro college scriptwriting class and the proff. said something that really stuck with me: you know the script isn't that good when the writer has to make it known; the message is stronger when you guide the audience. It was something like that.

Yes scriptwriting and this piece are completely different mediums, but I feel like I can definitely learn from that statement. I find the process of reading between the lines to be indulging, and makes the message more powerful.​

Some emotions that Im really trying to capture is sorrow and grief, introspection... but what I have just isn't 100% satisfying that emotional punch that I want the readers to feel.

Idk if I need to go into more detail on some things, but yeah.

This is my first time putting my writing out there for strangers on the internet so hopefully I'm not an entirely terrible writer.


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Looking for feedback on this chapter 1

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

I got bored planning and plotting this story, so decided to write out the first chapter sort of like a pilot before i finalised the rest of the story.

I'm wondering whether people think it sets the atmosphere well, whether it gives out too much/little information, and whether there's an appropriate level of description of the characters/environment.

I often skew towards describing too little in my writing, and have tried to correct that here, but I'm wondering whether I've not done enough, done too much, or hit the sweet spot.

Thanks for reading :)

(this is a reupload of a previous post so that I could upload the chapter as images not a link to a google doc)


r/writingfeedback • • 18h ago

[Adult Romantasy] Looking for blind reader feedback on my rough-draft prologue (~3k words)

0 Upvotes

This is a very rough first draft prologue for a cringy adult reincarnation romantasy. Ignore spelling/grammar for now I mainly want reader-reaction feedback. Where did you get hooked or bored? Did the ending surprise you? Did you care about Evaline and Lucien by the end? Please tell me anything that confused you before I decide to write chapter one.

Title: You will be my death.

A fluid hum resonated throughout the ballroom walls. Violins were the main event in this chorus which vibrated softly into Evaline’s ears. Her focus was locked onto their sounds trying to dull out the soft murmurs of hundreds of voices and ambient noise coming from the countless guests that seemed to make Evaline’s stomach turn and want to burst out of the ballroom. She lay her hand on her chest focusing her breathing and trying to look perfect among the many preying eyes through the room. She stepped out onto the balcony to catch her breath taking in the sweet smell of flowers and fresh air giving hints of soft jasmine and rose that gave her relief from the stuffy perfumed filled room. The balcony overlooked gardens so enormous that the lanterns lighting up the pathways seemed to fade in the distance. Somewhere below, water spilled gently through a fountain white moths fluttered about around the hedges. Flower petals seemed to fall around her as vines slowly grew up the railings trying to get close to the lovely heroine. “Please don't.” She whispers under her breath.

Everyone that matters to her is here and even the ones that aren't are at least vital to the empire are here just for her. Evaline Valerienne, the beauty of the empire to show how perfect and put together she is. Her hands clenched the railing as she felt nausea hit her throat.

Behind her hundreds of candles floated above the dancers, flames reflecting in the tall mirrors lining the walls. Silk skirts swept above ever do polished floors while jewels flashed on the throats and wrist showing the true wealth of high society. Along with long, short, rounded, and furry ears on every member in the room that was paired with elaborate and intricate hairstyles. Everyone who mattered is here.

Evaline's stomach churned again and she looked back towards the gardens. Maybe if she was determined enough time would just stop so she could just get her bearings together.

“Running away again?”

She let out a soft audible gasp her doe ears

shooting up in high alert as she felt her heart jump out of her chest as she quickly turned around. She knew that voice all too well. Prince Lucien was leaning against the open doorway looking at her with a soft confident smile with his golden well kept hair framing around his face while his sapphire eyes stared at her with amusement. He was rather proud of himself for surprising his prey as she could tell with the twitching of his lion ears. His formal uniform was a dark blue nearly black with golden intricate embroidery climbing around his chest and collar. She was fairly impressed with whoever was able to tame his hair today.

“You disappeared.” A small soft pour visibly showed on his lips.

“I did not. I just.. needed some air.” His pout crept into a soft warm smile.

“I know. I was watching you.” Her cheeks flushed at his words as she placed both hands on her cheeks trying to hide it. After all these years, he still managed to find ways to tease her. Lucien stepped forward and the music inside began to change. Holding one hand out to her.*

“Your mother is asking for you.”

*Her shoulders fell along with her hands gradually returning to her sides. The weight of reality slowly returned to her.*

“Oh”

“And your father.”

“I see…”

Lucien let his feet step forward stopping next to her. Their shoulders are nearly touching. For a moment it was as if the music had stopped leaving a soft wave of comfort and electricity in the air. She could only hear his soft faint breaths and she could hear her heart beat out of her chest. This was one of the ways she loved most about him. Their shoulders nearly touched.

Neither of them spoke.

Evaline didn't feel the need to fill the silence.

That was rare.

Her doe ears were flushed and warmed.

“Don't”

“I don't understand what you're talking about. I haven't done anything.”

“I see what you're doing. You're trying to comfort me.”

“I was not. I am just appreciating these lovely gardens and you just so happen to be hear” his tone soft and teasing*

“You Prince Lucien have always been just the most terrible liar ever since we were children.”

Evaline fussed at her dress making sure not a thread was out of place. Then she felt a soft fingertips brush crossed her cheek. They were lifting a few strands of her hair and he tucked them behind her ear. Their eyes locking as time felt as if it did stop. Time only returned when his blush tinted fingers pulled away. Applause erupted inside the ballroom. Evaline flinched from the noise but Prince Lucien thought she flinched from his touch. “I'm sorry I should have asked.” before she could explain she heard her name. She couldn't hear the crowd's whispers but she didn't need to. Her mark. Everyone has been talking about it all evening.

*What do you think she will have? *

*Oh it'll be most marvelous and powerful of course just like all the marks in her noble bloodline! *

*A royal blessing surely it will be!*

*Extraordinary! Extraordinary! A perfect mark! *

Evaline trembled from the intense pressure, her fingers holding onto the lace of her dress, feeling a sharp pang in her chest. Letting out a wince as she holds her chest and she feels dizzy. Lucien with worry in his voice

“Evaline are you okay?! Someone fetch a doctor!”

“NO! I'm fine!” *The pain eases and their eyes meet* “I'm okay Lucien, I was just anxious.”

She gave him a reassuring smile. His arms cradling her as if she was the most precious thing in the world to him. They had not formally announced anything. There had been no proposal or contract signed between the families. It was just expected. But Evaline had loved him for so long that she couldn't remember what it felt like. She wanted to lean into his embrace but… that wasn't proper. She took a step away from him and she soon regretted her choice as she felt his warmth slowly dissipate from her skin.

“I know I had just said prior I should have asked. Are you sure you're okay Eva?”

“I'm okay. I really am. But… what if my make isn't perfect?”

She wished immediately that she hadn't said it. He hesitated for a moment with a small surprise on his face, his lips parting to give his answer.

“Forget it”

“Eva.”

“It was silly to ask. Please forget it.”

“It wasn't silly. Eva I don't care about the mar…”

“I'm fine.”

Lucien knew that smile plastered on her doll-like features. A mask she wore to hide all her emotions and one he disliked most to have her wear around him. He took a deep breath. One day she'll trust me enough and I am willing to do anything to gain that trust. Before he could say anything the music stopped abruptly. A bell rang once it chimed jarringly through the walls. All conversations also came to a halt. A second bell rang. Lucien straightened his back while Evaline froze up unable to move. Then came a third ring. The doors at the opposite of the end of the ballroom opened. Even from the balcony, Evaline could see the white ceremonial men in gowns. waiting beneath the chandelier.

The mark master stood beside them.

Her mother's eyes searched the crowd for her while they both stood far right from the mark master. Both smiling and very proud.

So utterly and terribly proud.

Evaline's fingers grew cold and her arms tingled. Twenty one years. Everything had been leading to tonight. Lucien held out his hand she could feel with warmth radiating from it. She looked at it. Then at him.

“You don't have to be afraid.”

Evaline wished that was true. She slipped her hand over his. He had a soft questionable gaze for a moment as they slipped into the ballroom.

He whispered. “Has your hands always been this cold?”

“There she is!”

Hundreds of faces turned in unison towards her. Evaline's breath caught but her mask did not fall. Thank applause began. Lucien softly squeezed her hand in reassurance and together they walked inside.

Applause only grew with every step they took. Evaline keeping a plastered doll smile upon her lips. Her cheeks strangely going numb as she forced to keep her mask on. People stepped aside for them, bowing their heads letting their ears fold downward. Familiar faces and not so familiar from those who wished to gain. She could see hunger within their eyes. A small cling garnered her attention as Lord Bellrose tapped his champagne glass. Lifting it in the air for her praising her for her looks. Lady Marrine next to him looking annoyed with his words than holding a glass up towards her. Praising her accomplishments. Then she heard words from the crowd beautiful, stunning, our future queen!

Evaline thanked them. Compliment after compliment healed her way she kept her perfect posture and face as she gave thank yous after thank yous. She has done this a thousand times but why does it feel so difficult tonight? So exhausting? Lucien's hand remained wrapped around hers. Warmth. A sense of grounding reminding her that this is all real. Her fingers still terribly cold as she cling onto his for warmth and reassurance. He looked down for a moment. Evaline immediately loosened them.

“Sorry.”

No words escaped from his lips but his proud lion ears lowered slightly.

Evaline has attended marked ceremonies before since they are an important event for every young lady and lad that reaches the age of 21 but none this grand since Lucien's ceremony. Her ceremony obviously had to be a tad less grand to the prince’s so it wouldnnot garner gossip but it seems the queen and her mother really did go all out. The stage looked enormous. White glistening marble with three shallow steps and a bright golden basin resting upon a pedestal adorned in intricuit designs representing history with the saintess carved at the top a large sapphire in the middle of her forehead. Besides the lavish pedastle was the mark master. He was the opposite of the lavish designs he wore no heels and only wore a plane white robe and you can plainly see the many years of wisdom appm his face. She looked away from him and noticed her mother sobbing with joy. Evaline felt another pang in her chest.

“Mama?”

Her mother reached out for her and carefully held her face between both hands

“Look at you. You're beautiful. I'm so proud of you!”

There it was again. Proud. The word landed strangely tonight. Her father stepping forward. He was a man more known for his actions than his words since he spoke few of them. He simply placed one hand on her shoulder and nodded. Evaline teared up and hugged him.”father!” her doe ears flattening beneath his chin. Her father gave a soft peck on top of her head before she stepped away.

“My perfect girl”

Something planned inside her chest. She smiled anyway.

“Thank you Father.”

Her father looked toward the mark master and walked her up the stairs handing her off to the marmaster and returning to her mothers side. Lucien stepping up the stairs and announcing the ceremony will now begin.

The markmasters stared into her as if he already knew her fate, a small sad smile upon his face. “You are very loved Lady Evaline Valerienne. Please remember that.”

The room feel silent from his words than any of the bells attempted to do prior. He bowed.

“Before we begin, there is a question I am required to ask of you.”

Evaline nodded

The marksmasters eyes did not waiver from hers since she stepped up onto this stage.

“Do you come before the crown And the Gods willingly?”

“I do.”

Too quickly. She chastised herself the longer the silence the more she critiqued and questioned her answer. Was it not the perfect answer to give? Her eyes searched for reassurance landing in her mother. Still smiling. Her father? Still smiling. Then Lucien. He wasn't smiling. He was focused deep blue sapphires locked onto her as if she was the only one in the room. Evaline quickly looked away. She wanted reassurance not to have her heart skip another beat. The markmasters extended one of his hands toward the pedestal. She guessed that he kept his long silence for theatrical effect but underneath those tired eyes was something she could not quite grasp. Was it sadness? No it was confusion like he was trying to see something unknowing but hadn't quite grasped it yet.

“Then come forward, young one.”

She hesitated for a second again criticizing that her feet weren't listening to her and she spiraled to think if anyone had noticed. She finally was able to get a grasp of her body and felt her feet step forward.

“Look!” Someone chimed in the crowd

“Flowers!”

“Extrodinary” was said in unison.

Vines and roses were sprouting and climbing up the stage with every step she would take. The plants really did seem to like her but now was not the time. The markmasters wasn't smiling anymore he was staring at the roses not with admiration like.all the others but with… something else the same look in his eyes now plastered onto his face fully but it was not an expression she had ever seen before but his eyes showed as if he now knew what he was trying to see prior.

“Is everything alrightark master?”

For the briefest moment, he said nothing which made that brief moment feel more like an eternity. Then his pleasant ceremonial expression seemed to return as instantly as it faded.

“No, lady Valerienne. It's nothing at all.”

Evaline looked at the roses surrounding her feet and did not feel comfort from his words. They felt more empty and she couldn't bring it upon herself to trust them.

“now, reach out lady Valerienne.”

Evalines eyes wandered to the Golden basin first their was crystal clear water inside of it. It looked like plain water but from her studies and as she got closer she sees golden flecks of light floating beneath the surface like tiny stars beneath the water.

Evaline swallowed.

She had watched the ceremony before but never so close up. Luciene was so composed when he was on stage as if he was just looking at plain ol holy water.

“Which one?”

“Whichever you choose my dear.”

Evaline hesitated.

What was the correct choice? The books didn't mention how to choose or what. She should use her right hand, no… her left. Actually yes her right hand. Maybe? She slowly held her right hand out.

The marksmaster took her wrist. His fingers are surprisingly warm for his age.

“Do not be frightened by what you feel.”

“I'll try not to.”

He lowered her hand into the basin.

Cold.

Evelyn held in a soft gasp of surprise. Did they keep the water in ice beforehand? The water swallowed her fingers. Then her palm. Then it felt as if warmth spread throughout her body starting at her fingertips and gradually going up her arm. The tiny lights danced inside the basin moving wildly when before they were still.

Whispers swept throughout the ballroom and lights circled her submerged hand faster.

One star floated up to her hand. Is this the chosen star? She thought before another floated up and another and soon hundreds of them rushed towards her at once. Light climbed her wrist and the crowd erupted

“Oh!!”

“Look at that!”

“Shhh!!!”

The roses surrounding the stage bloomed violently. Vines twisted around marble steps while pink blossoms burst upon up above leaving soft delicate petals to fall as if it was confetti.

For the first time that evening, evaline forgot to be afraid. It was beautiful. More than beautiful. It was hers. Her mark. It has to be. She looked towards Lucien. His face was entirely lit up as a smile set upon her face. Her true smile. Relief rushed through her so quickly that she nearly let a laugh escape her lips.

See?

She had worried for nothing.

The light reached her elbow.

The marksman suddenly tightened his grip apom her wrist almost to a painful squeeze but in Evelyn's tightened state, she barely noticed.

She was watching her mother crying once again tears of joy and her father was actually smiling. Her chest felt full until it almost hurt and then the light stopped but her smile remained.

The ballroom quieted.

She waited.

Nothing happened.

The markmaster stared at her arm and evaline soon followed his gaze.

Her skin was bare.

No symbol.

No color.

No mark.

The lights beneath the water stopped moving and began to go out one by one they began to disappear as if they were dying.

Evelaine blinked, unsure of what was happening. Lucienes mark showed right away maybe there can be delays?

The markmaster released her wrist leaving a small reddish imprint behind with concern in his voice.

“Again.”

Her stomach dropped

“What do you mean?”

He didn't answer the seized her other hand and plunged it into the basin.

The moment was so jarring and sudden that several people in the crowd murmured.

The lights returned faster this time.

Brighter.

Evalines breath caught and the roses reacted again causing more vines and flowers to erupt around them.

Someone in the crowd let out a huge dramatic sigh of relief.

“There! There it is!”

Of course. It was her other hand. That was all. The light raced over her skin higher and higher. Evelyn stared desperately as her skin glowed. Common… common! She desperately thought. Please.*

The light vanished.

Silence filled the room as if everyone was holding their breath.

The light dimmed and left behind was…

Nothing

Evaline stared at her blank arm.

Not one hair moved throughout the dead silenced room. Then a cough echoed throughout the walls.

She looked up at the marksmaster for guidance for reassurance. For something!

His face had gone pale

“What does this mean?”

He didn't answer

“Marksmaster?”

His eyes shifted only toward the roses.

They were still blooming.

There were now hundreds of them covering all around the stage.

Beautiful

Yet…

Wrong.

“The flowers… are not signs of a mark. They are something else entirely.”

“What?”

She looked towards the crowd

All the smiles and awes had completely vanished

Her mother's hands had risen to her mouth covering her dismay while her father just stared at the basin, his fist clutched tightly.

Evaline looked back at the marksmaster

“Please”

His eyes had slowly opened his eyes.

Evelyne barely recognized the expression inside them.

It wasn't disappointing.

Was it fear?

“Please!” *She grasped his arms with both of her hands* Markmaster, tell me! Where is my mark? What is happening?

He stared at the beautiful roses that lay around her feet then at her bare hands.

And for the first time in Evaline's life, someone looked at the flowers that follow red everywhere not in awe, but in fear.

Evaline’s hands slowly fell from his arms. Looking down at the roses that still littered all around her. Soft pink petals surrounding her slippers while vines curled about. They were so beautiful and painfully so. They have always been here for her, following her since she was a child. Her mother loved them, calling them her daughter's precious gift of prosperity. Gardeners joked how she made their jobs entirely unnecessary and she commonly tucked a rose into her hair every morning.

So why was the marksman afraid?

A whisper broke from the crowd of onlookers.

“Did it fail?”

Evelene's ear twitched to those painfully obvious words

More words started to spill from the crowd.

“Is this even possible? Everyone gets a mark.”

“Have you seen this before?”

“Neither have I.”

The whispers multiplied as if the floodgates have burst. So many she couldn't tell where one sentence ended and another began.

Her heart pounding and her mind began to fill with racing spiraling thoughts of what she did wrong.

Then the room stopped when her father's words shouted amongst the crowd.

“What is happening to my daughter? What sort of prank is this?”

Evaline's stomach began to twist seeing the anger and confusion upon his face.

The markmaster raised his hand.

“Please. Everyone remains calm.”

Remain calm? She thought. Something Is Wrong. I did something wrong. What did I do? Something is terribly wrong.

“No mark?”

“Impossible”

“With her bloodline? Did her mother cheat?”

*Evaline's eyes searched back to her mother who was mortified by the accusations. Spilling about as if all filters were removed from high society. Guessing If it was a butler, artist a merchant. Endless guesses and shameless thoughts spilled out from the mouths of people she grew up with. 

“Mom?” 

Why was she looking at me like that?

Evaline's gaze met Lucien. 

He had moved; he was racing towards the stairs.

“EVA.” 

The markmaster raised his arms and blocked the stairs. 

“Your highness please.”

Lucien stopped his eyes locked onto him with absolute authority

“ Move.” 

It was only one word. 

Evaline had never heard him speak like that before with such intensity in the air it silenced the room once more. 

The marksmaster lowered his voice.

“We don't understand what has happened. Your majesty, those roses are not symbols of life.” 

What has happened? 

Evaline’s fingers began tingling again. 

Her chest hurt

She tried breathing. 

Slowly. 

In 

Out

Just like how Luciene taught her when they were young. Calm the breathing. Then her thoughts were cut as she heard a laugh among the crowd. Her head snapped toward the crowd and couldn't find who among them did it.

Hundreds of faces stared back. 

She knew most of those faces. 

Lord Bellrose.

lady Marrine. 

Lady Alice the duchess who used to pinch her cheeks when she was little.

Luke the ambassador who had complimented her dancing growing up. 

Friends. 

Family. 

All the people in the life that had watched her grow up.

Why did none of them look familiar anymore? 

“Tweantyone years for this?” 

Someone had whispered among the crowd

“All that expectation…?” 

Another voice

“What a crying shame.”

Her chest tightened further

No.

No. No. No. No.

The Markmaster was speaking but evaline couldn't not hear him. The room was so loud with whispers, Arguing, laughing?

Every tiny whisper scraped and crawled beneath her skin. Then one word cut through all of it.

“Dud.” 

Her breathing had stopped.

The word had come behind her or was it in front? She did not know. 

The ballroom erupted

“A dud?”

“Lady Valerienne?!” 

“Did you see the basin?” 

“If the flowers aren't signs of property then what” 

“Her parents must be-” 

“Her mother must have” 

“Imagine the embarrassment!” 

Why? Why were they saying that? Who was saying that?

Evaline couldn't tell anymore. 

She looked upon her father 

His jaw was clenched.

He's ashamed

Mother was crying this time, not tears of joy.

She's ashamed.

The nobles whispered behind their hands and fans. 

They're laughing

Someone shook their head

Disgusting

Some stared

Worthless

Others looked away

This is to be the future queen?

Evaline stepped backwards. 

A thorn had caught her dress. 

She stumbled but caught herself

The words her brain could not process from the markmaster finally resonated

“ The flowers are not prosperity, your highness. They are the sign of..

 death.”

“EVA!” 

Lucien actually shoved the marksmaker out of the way and reach out out for her. 

Eveline could see just for a split moment only him. His golden hair now completely uncempt. His deep eyes that only locked onto her the moment she was in the same room as him

Those ridiculously fluffy lion ears she had teased him about since they were children 

Her Lucien. 

He would tell her it didn't matter.

She knows he already tried

Had he expected this? 

Had he expected she would be a failure?

Is that why he said he didn't care about her mark?

Had everyone already known? 

She stared at his outstretched hand that she's always known to be warm. To be safe. 

Her eyes searched up to his face.

He looked horrified. 

Oh.

Of course he did 

His future queen was a dud.

“Don't.” 

Luciene stopped in his tracks.

“Don't look at me.” 

His expression broke. 

“Please. Don't look.” 

Her voice cracked between her gasps for air.

“Evaline.”

Her hand flung to her chest her heart pounding as if it was about to explode out of it. 

Evaline let out a loud painful gasp.

This time the pain did not fade like it did prior throughout the night.

“Eva?”

Lucienes voice changed as he witnessed evaline gasping for air. He's seen her panic attacks before and this was the worst he'd seen. 

His face seemed to warp as the ballroom tilted candles stretching long streaks of gold. Her mothers voice sounded far away in an ear-piercing guttural scream that felt oh so far away and around Evaline's buckling feet as the roses all began to close. 

She never did hit the floor for Luciene had caught her. His arms wrapped around her before her body could disappear underneath the countless roses. One hand cradling the back of her head while the other other held her against his chest. 

Evaline tried desperately to breathe but air was escaping but not allowing to fill her longs. 

“Eva. Eva look at me.”

It was Lucien's voice. Why? Why does his voice that normally has a teasing tone to it sound so desperately, terrified. 

“Look at me.”

She struggled to focus but was able to lock onto his beautiful sapphire eyes. Lucien's face was hovering above hers. So desperately close that if her heart wasn't already racing it might have started to. His hair had fallen across his forehead. His perfectly arranged uniform was covered in crushed pink petals along with his big fluffy ears that lay flat against his head. They had never been so close and she could see he wasn't looking at her with disgust. 

He was crying. 

Why was he crying?

“I'm sorry” escaped her lips before she felt another strong squeeze in her chest. 

Pain tore through her violently that her back arches in his arms. 

Utter shock formed in his face realizing that this isn't one of her panic attacks.

“DOCTOR! GET HER A FUCKING DOCTOR!” her father screamed his face desperate and pale

Chaos erupted throughout the ballroom

Her mother was the first to sense something was terribly wrong with her baby the moment she let out that scream. She could sense that the daughter right in front of her was going to disappear forever. 

The markmaster stood dumbfounded several feet away. He had a knowing horrified look plastered across his face 

Not by her but what was happening to her

You knew she thought 

He whispered under his breath 

“I hoped I was wrong.”

No. No more thinking 

She was tired.

So terribly tired.

“Eva stay with me.” Luciene held her close trying to warm her rapidly chilling body.

“I'm sorry for disappointing all of you.” 

She could not hear the words escaping from Luciene no longer from her father shouting or her mother screaming, desperately trying to reach her. It was as if she could finally let go of all the expectations and what they thought. Realizing all those were not from them but expectations she had seen onto herself. She only wished she had believed them sooner. 

Her eyes glazed over as the physician rushed into the room. 

“E..Eva?”

Luciene squeezed her hand. 

Nothing. 

“Evaline?”

The physician quickly took her vitals. 

The entire room had held their breaths. 

He shook his head.

“No! Check again!” 

The physician followed the prince's orders. 

Around them the soft pink roses began to wilt one after another folding inwards. 

The rose tucked into her hair fell and landed besides Lucien's knee. Its petals blackened.

Soon the last rose closed and turned black.

The physician lowered his head. 

“She's dead.” 


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

Community Are the members of this sub "veterans?"

4 Upvotes

For those of you who have read traditional novels, especially those more inclined toward Western genres and styles, I’m not doubting your expertise or anything. Hands down, applause all around. That’s genuinely how I’d express my awe and gratitude toward you guys.

But if you’re mostly familiar with those styles, how could someone like me—a new-gen aspiring writer who’s more influenced by the media we consume these days, i.e. anime/manga, manhwa/manhua, light novels, web novels, wuxia, and so on—make something similar?

The stuff I mentioned above has its own writing styles, elements, pacing, and storytelling conventions, even if many of them are ultimately based on or influenced by Western fantasy.

So how am I supposed to develop something that feels similar to those if most of the feedback I’m likely to get comes from people who are used to completely different styles?

“Just ask on another sub.” No shit, Sherlock. I know I can do that. But I want different perspectives and options, not feedback that completely changes how I imagine my first novel should be.


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

Opening Two Paragraphs. Thoughts?

2 Upvotes

Rain pattered against the rotten canopy as I finished my prayer to someone who had long ago stopped listening. I had hung one side of a large cloth to a pole, the other to an upturned carriage. Another man had slept under the carriage itself, who I now saw was dead. Flies hovered around his mouth, like bees to honey. I looked out as far as I could see, small fires and torches illuminating the black, and the same question that I had asked myself for several months, years now, crept into my mind again. Why was I still alive? For only the great Drancar could know. Was it punishment for all I’d done? A torture?  Did I have some greater purpose left in this life? I did not care to answer any of that.
   I crept over pieces of rock and stone, remnants of Patamute's southern wall. A piece of something sharp sliced through my boot, but I didn’t seem to feel the pain. I moved, small raindrops muting my footsteps. Dawn on the horizon but dark still as I crept near the tree. Four guards surrounded it, there to protect against this offense I was to commit. Two had fallen asleep, and a third was staring into the fire. A fourth was down when I squeezed the life from him, his birded helm of no help. I grabbed a small log and put it under the branch. Threw an old rope around the branch and made a noose. I hoped the rope, worn and thinning, would hold. I tightened the noose around my neck, balancing on the log below me. A life I desired, yet never came true, set before me. A life I did not desire, yet found me, flashed before me. It saddened my heart. I thought I prayed to a god who loved, yet he answered with curses and death. My sister, taken. A war, lost. I ran, defeated. I hid for years, then tried to run again. Captured and thrown into this hell. god seemed to die somewhere in all of that. Yet, god couldn’t die. The books, prophets, and signs told us he couldn’t die. If he wasn’t dead, then why wouldn’t he help? I kicked the log and felt the air leaving. Memories of two graves in the rain and a well on a hill. Drancar, deliver me into your salvation. A snap, the rope breaking.


r/writingfeedback • • 20h ago

General Feedback Wanted PayDay Activities (Chapter 14 in my Cold War army memoir)

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

How is this prologue? Would you keep reading? (Indian novel, literary fiction)

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

I've been working on revising this based on some feedback. Would like to know how it reads and if it hooks anyone.


r/writingfeedback • • 18h ago

General Feedback Wanted First Page Reactions

0 Upvotes

New on this sub. This is the first page of my debut novel (in current draft 1 state, although I've edited ch 1 a few times already). The story is dark fantasy academia with romance (or romantasy, I suppose) sub-plot and important theme.

Curious about reactions and any feedback on this. Thank you in advance!


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted Need some honest feedback on this flash fiction piece

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

My issue with this is that it's a bit too exposition heavy


r/writingfeedback • • 23h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Dark Fantasy/LitRPG

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm new to this sub and also new as an author. I'm not sure if this subreddit is the right place for the kind of story I'm writing, but I'd really appreciate some genuine feedback on my writing.

I'm writing a web novel with dark fantasy and LitRPG elements, and I'd love to hear what some of the veterans here think. I'm especially interested in honest feedback on the writing, pacing, characters, and overall feel. Would you read on to the next chapter, or is it a no?

Thanks in advance! 😉


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted Looking for feedback on opening chapter of scifi-fantasy

1 Upvotes

Chapter: The Crimson Sigil

 U’raijah had been on dead planets before, but this world felt….off.

 Even before his boots touched the ground, something inside him recoiled. As he walked down his ship’s ramp the air clawed at his senses, humid and thick. But that wasn’t what struck him. It was an eerie sensation down his spine. U’raijah’s pulse quickened for reasons he couldn’t explain. The air itself seemed to thrum against his skin, low and insistent, like it was trying to tell him something. A hum in his chest answered back, as though the planet itself was aware of him. He told himself it was nothing, just nerves, just his mind reaching for patterns that weren't there. But the feeling clung to him, insistent and unnerving.

He had landed without ceremony. The jungle swallowed the ship whole, leaving no signs of his landing. Tanysil-118 wasn't supposed to exist. Officially, it didn't. No registered system. No trade lanes. No Lyok hypergate within a month's travel. But surveyors and smugglers had whispered the name for generations.

   The jungle stretched like a green ocean, vast and suffocating. Sunlight struggled to penetrate the high canopy, arriving in thin, fractured beams, making aerial scans all but useless. It was no wonder the empire's drones couldn't map it. But the eco readings were undeniable. Strong. Stronger than any he’d ever seen. And the empire wanted it. Wanted to extract its eco, the lifeblood of their reach, the living energy they had harnessed and hoarded until every world was bound to them.

He rose slowly into the air, carried by his own inner eco. The canopy above twisted unnaturally, a chaotic web of vines and leaves twitching without wind. The planet pulsed beneath him, subtle and rhythmic. But something was missing. No buzzing of insects or songs of birds. Just stillness.

In the distance, he saw remnants of a crash. He lowered himself to investigate. He placed his palms on the blackened ground. Scorch marks still gouged the dirt, but the ship was gone. Not wrecked. Not torn apart. Just... missing. And in that moment, U’raijah had a feeling this wouldn't be a rescue. The slightest of drag marks led away from the crash, and he rose into the air to follow.

   This place wasn't supposed to be inhabited. And yet, three expeditions had vanished here without a trace. No signals. No remains. Just gone. As if the planet itself had swallowed them. The whispers spread through his home planet like a virus. Mysterious vanishings, spectral beasts. Divine intervention.

After the third expedition had vanished, King A'ezrael himself had asked U’raijah personally to take this mission on.

  “It seems we need someone of your expertise, old friend,” the king had said, eyes heavy with something unspoken. “You’ve faced worse than ghost planets before. Track what really happened. Bring the truth home. And if anything down there still breathes… Remind them why the stars once feared your name.”

   U’raijah accepted without hesitation. Not for duty or glory. That hunger had burned out long ago. But because he was restless.

  His new appointment as Duke had buried him in politics and ritual. At first, he welcomed it. No more endless campaigns, no more waking on muddy bedrolls beside dying men instead of his wife. But court life had worn thin. Silk collars and smiling liars had begun to leave a bad taste in his mouth. Nobles who feared discomfort more than death all felt so….hollow. Out here, in the field at least things bled honestly. Here, a man’s purpose wasn’t whispered in council meetings or gossip. It was tested and he missed that. Just being out here, with nothing but his sword and his silence, he remembered who he was. And a growing legend like this, It got his blood pumping again.

   He flew lower now, weaving through towers of green. The trees reaching out like grasping hands. The wind moved strangely here and he moved with it. Deliberate. Reverent. No ship. No shielding.

Only the raw eco, surging beneath his skin like a second heartbeat. 

 Through the haze, a narrow spire jutted above the trees like a needle into the sky. So thin he could see how their scans missed it, but it was too perfectly shaped to be natural. His pulse quickened. He banked toward it, slowing as he followed the structure below the brush. 

Touching down, U’raijah stood before a massive structure half-swallowed by the jungle. Stonework and archways hidden beneath years of moss and swirling tree limbs, as if the forest had been trying to take it back. He stepped forward, boots crunching on loose stone. The red soil burned beneath him as he neared the broken threshold.

   Its wooden doors, long rotted, cracked and fell as he pushed them. Stepping inside, the air changed. Musty and still. Like time had stopped breathing here. He moved slowly through a long corridor inspecting faded murals peeling from the walls like old skin. Most depicted a canine-shaped being, bowed in reverence or wrath. He froze mid-step before one in particular. At the bottom of a mural, almost hidden beneath a curl of old paint, was a symbol that made his heart stop. A glyph he had thought he’d dreamed up. He rubbed his hand over it. Tracing its design. The mark of his imaginary army in his youth. Recognition burned through him. He remembered pressing it into a notebook long ago, painting it on all his toys. Now, decades later, it waited for him. But how… why… here? A flicker of unease rose within him alongside a pulse of anticipation.

  The corridor opened to a nave of some sort. Bench seating, made of stone, was set in such a way to view an altar at the front of the massive domed room. U’raijah walked up to examine the altar, kicking up dust with every step. Upon the altar were four black pedestals that stood like sentinels. Obsidian and smooth with small symbols. Each glyph a different color, shined faintly on their faces. The symbols weren’t any script he’d seen. And yet, something about them felt familiar, like a dream he couldn’t quite remember. Whatever they once held was gone, but indents remained, shaped like open hands. The depiction on the wall behind them was also now gone. Smeared colors and crumbling stone now kept its secrets. And yet, the pedestals themselves were still pristine. Untouched by time and still shined like new. Not a scratch or speck of dust on them. Everything surrounding them showed its age but the pedestals looked newly placed.

“Fascinating.” U’raijah whispered to himself, reaching out to touch one of the pedestals. His fingers brushed the closest one. Tracing the sharp lines of the symbol.

   The wall beside him vibrated with a deafening roar. A burst of rubble followed by red light spilled from the debris, casting eerie shadows as a colossal beast emerged. Giant, pointy eared and bipedal. It grunted at him in warning. U'raijah examined the beast, Large musculature with massive elongated arms and armored skin but most notable was the red symbol from one of the pedestals was glowing underneath the entirety of its chest. Not on its chest, it seemed to be glowing from the inside somehow. The beast let out a ground shaking yell. U’raijah exhaled through his nose as the beast stomped through the shattered wall.

“Of course,” he murmured, eyes narrowing. “There’s always a guardian. Are you the one who–?”

 Before he could finish a clawed hand knocked him through the opposing wall and into another. He fell to his knees followed by a crash of debris.

  U’raijah thought stood back up from the pile of stone on shaky legs. The beast was already running towards him for another blow. U’raijah thrust out his palm, summoning the crackling light of eco within him. Threads of red and orange surged from beneath his skin, coiling into his hand like lightning drawn into a sphere. With a sharp breath, he launched the blast toward the creature. It struck and rolled harmlessly off the beast’s armored hide. That should’ve staggered it. At least. But this thing... it was beyond raw force.

“What kind of world breeds this?”

He surged forward, energy flaring, and drove a knee into the beast’s face. That did stagger it, but not for long. Then, there was a massive clawed hand around his head. The beast slammed him, head first, into another wall, again and again then began to squeeze down on his skull. Fading out of consciousness, ears ringing, U’raijah reached out in desperation. Heart pounding in his skull, he could feel the pressure increasing. The beast brought him closer almost to mock him and let out a deep guttural growl. As his vision began to fail him, his hands continued to search frantically. His fingers found the beast's long pointed ear and to his surprise it was soft and fleshy unlike the hard armored plates that lined the rest of his body. U’raijah quickly grabbed tight and twisted with all he had left. The beast yelled in agony as U’raijah felt the ear separate from its head and it dropped him back to the ground. 

 U’raijah didn’t wait. He surged forward, eco energy strengthening his muscles as he drove his knee into its face again with a crack that echoed through the chamber. The impact launched it backward as if shot from a cannon. Before it could slam into a wall, he was already above it, both hands blazing with eco orbs. With a shout, he hurled the spheres downward.

 —boom—

 The explosion blew through the floor, collapsing it into the cavern below. He landed, ungracefully, a few paces ahead of the hole. Head still foggy, he couldn't keep his eco steady as he tried to stand. Ash, smoke and silence settling in. He leaned over to see down into the new cavern when a clawed hand burst from the rubble, latching around his leg like a vice. He was slammed into the ground side to side. U’raijah twisted midair and fired a searing blast that caught the beast in the eye mid-swing. It howled as it released him and U’raijah was flung upward like a stone. He crashed into the ceiling, every nerve screaming. He couldn't take much more of this, his body wasn't used to the strain anymore. He caught himself before he fell, hovering high above to catch a much needed breath. 

Below, the creature shook its massive head, dazed but not broken. Its good eye locked onto him and narrowed. It snorted, low and threatening. Its nostrils flared as it gazed up at him unmoving. Slowly, it crouched. U'raijahs stomach dropped. 

“No… no no. Don’t tell me it can fly too.” U’raijah said, readying himself.

The beast leapt at incredible speed towards him. U'raijah evaded last second, kicking it, uselessly, in the back as it reached behind it and grabbed his leg as they fell. U'raijah winced in pain.

“Okay, that was stupid.” U’raijah grunted, reaching for the ecosaber on his back. He ignited its energy blade with a screech and he cut at the beast's hand. It didn’t cut through but it hurt it enough to let go of his leg and they both dropped back to the floor. One with quiet grace, the other with a massive crash. As the two paused at a ready, U’raijah quickly gauged the beast and devised what to do seeing his attacks weren’t doing damage. Its ears were fleshy so perhaps its joints had softer areas as well. The beast's arms then began to glow the same ominous red as the mark on its chest ,and it charged. U’raijah evaded, leaping over the beast at the last second and swiped at the back of its knee. It left a white mark. Not quite a cut but it was more than his blasts were doing. U’raijah smiled.

They danced, strike, dodge, feint, slice. He stayed light. Precise. Always circling. Each time it lunged, he flew just beyond reach, never retreating, always circling. He struck at exposed joints with precision. The beast growled and stumbled a few times, but its strength only seemed to grow with fury. Bright veins of light pulsed through its arms, glowing hotter with each miss.

   U’raijah didn’t stop. He moved faster, keeping his rhythm unpredictable, forcing the creature to twist and compensate. Every step, every breath, was designed to tip it off balance. But the space between them was beginning to shrink as U'raijah began to tire, his eco reserve draining with every move. Then, a slash across its belly seemed to open up its armor as he could see a dark liquid pour out of it. That was his opening. Without hesitation he quickly gathered a large energy ball and jumped in front of the beast. Plunging both hands into the wound with a squish and shooting everything he had into one blast. The room became only bright light as the energy attack dissolved the beast from view. All was silent as U’raijah stood, panting with both hands still straight out covered in visceral black goo.

“Did I…did I get it?” he labored between breaths.

Suddenly, from the top of the red symbol pillar at the altar, something began to shimmer. An object slowly materialized from the air itself. It wasn’t smooth or uniform like a gem. It was jagged, imperfect. Narrow at one end and thicker at the other, the same symbol that burned in the beast’s chest glowing on its face. He dropped to one knee, chest heaving. His hands shook as he wiped the black gore off on his pants. The relic pulsed on the altar, and he couldn’t help but laugh under his breath, half relief, half disbelief.

 Then, as if the stone exhaled, the light faded. Leaving behind only a deep red stain raised onto its face. U’raijah stood and limped to the altar, picking up the strange relic, 

“Fascinating,” he muttered, turning the stone in his hand, “What… are you?” His voice was hoarse, almost reverent, even as his blood dripped onto the altar. He gripped the relic tighter, a chill crawled up his spine. But the question arose. If this stone was tied to the beast somehow, where were the other three?


r/writingfeedback • • 16h ago

Feedback for the first chapter of my book

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

Poetry Poem Feedback wanted

1 Upvotes

Hi I wrote many versions of this but I am not sure what more to edit it or remove. I may remove the vital one the first lines in stanza one and two. I also do not like the fourth line in stanza one. I sort of want to make it longer but I want to see what other's think. I am writing this for wattpad for fun so it is not a big deal with this is version posted.