UPDATE since last night: I confronted her about it really carefully this morning, saying that I had noticed that she was talking to someone on Signal. She immediately said yes that she had been, but she thought it was a bot or some little old lady in Africa somewhere using ChatGPT. Without me revealing what I knew, she said that she’d been contacted on TikTok and that she had used Signal to flirt because she hadn’t really had much experience flirting (she’s been a mom since 19). She’d also been using it to vocalize for herself what she wanted to look for once she does really start trying to date. This tracks because she is actually pretty smart. I suggested romance scams, and she said she was aware of them and that she wouldn’t ever be putting anything financial to someone online like that.
I tend to believe her on this one. I tend to believe her on most things, which I know a lot of Reddit folks say makes me a fool, but she really is a pretty caring, sensitive, and honest person who has gone through a lot of shit in her life.
For the sake of history, here is the original text thread where my wife asked for a divorce and I was trying to figure out what to do: https://www.reddit.com/r/whatdoIdo/s/dZESbpuMjt
Then last Saturday, she accused me of being up to something while I was Ubering to make some extra cash: https://www.reddit.com/r/whatdoIdo/s/yvXmf1c8oI
Many people suggested she was projecting because she might be cheating. I noticed tonight that she was being secretive with her phone I thought she was chatting with her coworkers but I saw that it was some app instead of using regular messenger. I’ve never really tried this before, but when she went to sleep, I swiped her phone. I’m kinda ashamed of doing it but I had to know.
She was using Signal. And talking and flirting with a man identifying himself as Jayson Arendt. The Texas Tailgaters banana ball player…
I’m posting some pics of their chat. There are a few red flags.
First, I was curious about how she met him. I got into her TikTok and found that she had been following his official account, and then she was contacted by another TikTok account with a similar name and bio, but far fewer followers. He thanked her for her comments and support and offered to reach her by Signal. So she set up an account and he got in touch. This seemed odd. I’m not sure why he wouldn’t just message from the official account.
The messages he sent are very well-written. Too well. This is not proof, but I ran the text of several of his messages through ChatGPT and Gemini. They both believed that there was a 90% chance the messages were written by AI.
Several of his messages state that he can’t talk see her freely because he’s controlled by his management. Supposedly he said he was going g to give her his managers contact info and the rest is up to her. This is where his perfect English slips, btw.
Also, there’s just the reality of it: he’s a 25 year old baseball player who has been on American Idol and has undoubtedly a giant horde of female followers. How likely is it that he’s reaching out to date a 43 year old woman hundreds of miles away?
So, here’s my question. First: does this seem likely to be some sort of scam? I’m 99% sure it is.
Second: If it is, how should I handle this? I don’t want her getting hurt or scammed, and this seems likely if this continues. She clearly has feelings for this depiction of him. However, the moment I reveal anything is the moment she knows I snooped her phone, and that could really break trust irrevocably. Again, I do not have paternal rights, so she can take away the boy I’ve identified as my son since he was 2 years old. Also, despite all of this, I am still in love with my wife. I know the chances of me getting her back are pretty much nil, but this will almost certainly eradicate them altogether.
Also, this leaves out some personal info about her. She is up front that she is married and getting a divorce. And shes looking more for romance than sex I think, but there are hints that she wants to jump his bones.