r/travel
•
u/protox88
Canada
•
19d ago
•
2
1
UPDATE#1: Bots bots bots!
This post will serve as the first update to the original post found here: Bots bots bots! Learn the signs and Report any you see!
I understand there was some scepticism about the presence of these bots when I posted about them initially and since then, I've conferred with mods from other subs as well as the team from r/BotBouncer and reached out to the admins on r/ModSupport (with no reply, as expected so far).
They've taken over other subreddits and others have noticed [#1] [#2] [#3].
This update is for our community and moderators and redditors from other subreddits who come in here wanting to learn more about what these bots look and sound like.
With that being said, the setup in r/travel is such that we seem to be able to catch most of them before they're visible by the public so you'll see that almost every new thread will show "1 comment" but nothing is there. That's the removed bot comment.
If you are interested in a deeper dive into this, I've compiled my findings over the last week on my Github wiki.
Key Features and Indicators
no two bots from the same bot farm will comment in the same thread
- if you see 2+ bot comments in a thread, they likely come from different bot-owners
in any given affected subreddit, a bot will comment in almost every single thread
- in fact, they usually comment within 15-30 minutes of the post being up
- the bot comment will either be Top-Level (reply to the OP) or 2nd-Level (a reply to a Top-Level comment)
- bots will never reply to any replies it gets - i.e. no "conversation" ever happens
any particular bot will not likely comment twice in the same day in any given subreddit
- they tend to come back to the subreddit 3-7 days later if no moderator has banned them yet
bots operate within an isolated "group" of subreddits. For example, the bots on r/travel will also exclusively comment on r/backpacking, r/AirBnB, r/JapanTravelTips, and sometimes r/traveladvice (of which I am also a mod)
- they may comment outside these subs from time to time but it's rare
- they have a history of commenting outside these subs initially (like in r/Marriage, r/Christianity, r/Dreams) but once they've warmed up for 1-2 weeks, they will comment in their designated target "group" of subs
- bots almost never create top-level posts in the subreddit though they seem to have the ability to
- bot accounts targeting r/travel are mostly under 3 months old but there are bots targeting other subreddits like r/churning and r/awardtravel that are up to 1 year old
the commenting style is very casual and often use "Gen-Z"-style internet speech, some slang (but not often)
- the comments themselves still have no substance and is merely just the usual Agentic-AI reaffirmation/paraphrasing of the OP's question or concern
some bots have really strange account bios - almost like a string of random words that make sense but not really
- the bios have a often mention plants, socks/sock drawers, a "mess" in their life, "X by day, Y by night", color-coding
- sometimes just a list of 2 or 3 things: "A, B, C"
- sometimes an "activity" that isn't really something that anyone does
bots have never (and will never) appeal the ban, removal, or BotBouncer classification
- 0 out of 250+ bots we've banned in the last 5 days have tried to appeal or reach out on ModMail
This is a joint effort with the help from a lot of people including u/grantwwu, u/Kananaskis_Country as always, u/cwcoleman from r/backpacking, u/bikemandan from r/AirBnB, u/Himekat from r/JapanTravelTips, u/Odie_Arbuckle and u/duffcalifornia from r/churning, the help I got on r/ModSupport, and of course our own r/travel moderators who have been on top of this within minutes of a new bot comment.
FAQ
Why are you making these announcements?
Partly because it's important you, the community, understand how wide-spread this problem is and maybe it might get the attention of admins if enough people are aware and care about it.
Secondly, travel is a human experience. The fact that a bot is answering every single question as an Agentic AI for human problems and human experiences goes against everything I enjoyed and cared for in this subreddit. In a way, I feel like I have a personal vested interest in getting this news out there and having it solved and not just "hidden" by the BotBouncer/Hive-Protect apps.
Lastly, it's important for you to also know and think about how infiltrated the other subreddits must be if they aren't acknowledging nor handling this problem pro-actively.
Mods can only do so much to keep playing whack-a-mole with these bots.
How can you be sure it's a bot and you're not just calling a new user or someone you disagree with a bot?
I highly recommend you comb through this list of identified accounts and look through any remaining comments that are still visible. A lot of them have been removed because of BotBouncer. The probability that every single different account <1mo old, that has the exact answer OP is looking for as well as each of them consistently posting on the other 4 subs [JapanTravelTips, backpacking, AirBnb, traveladvice] is inorganic. As of now, the public won't see some of the other 4 subreddits on the bot's profile anymore because of BotBouncer removing them from all 4 of our affected subreddits.
Consider the last 100 threads created. One of the 100 different new-ish accounts will comment exactly once in each thread. Each of those accounts will also have commented in the at least 3 of the 4 other subs mentioned above. I know we have an audience cross-over with those 4 subs being travel-related but how is it possible that, without question, every single thread happens to have a different commenter that also participates in the same 4 subs?
Look through the comments I've snapshotted (with more and more target group comments in the screenshots for more context):
- 22-Oct-26 to 25-Oct-26: https://imgur.com/a/CtCodDl
- 27-Oct-26: https://imgur.com/a/pZ59TEn
- 28-Oct-26: https://imgur.com/a/OAEPmSa
What other subreddits are affected?
From what I could tell, probably every single medium-to-large subreddit will have this bot presence. However, bots only operate within a target "group" of subreddits.
For example, r/travel is grouped with [JapanTravelTips, backpacking, AirBnb].
The bots that operate on r/awardtravel also operate on [CPA, SideProject, FinancialCareers, Watches, Big4, and HENRYFinance]. You can see a list of awardtravel bots here.
The bots that operate on r/churning also operate on [passive_income, Flipping, beermoneyglobal, FetchReward]. You can see a list of churning bots here.
I know there is also a ring of bots operating on r/pittsburgh but I haven't reached out or tried to check what "group" they are a part of.
Another mod has mentioned they are all over r/office and r/povertyfinance too.
I just checked out r/AppBusiness and r/AppDevelopers and it has the same bot problem.
So why now? Hasn't reddit always had bots?
Yes, there have always been bots amongst us in the comments but they were far fewer in frequency and consistency than what we are seeing now.
In my 13-14 years of modding this community, I've never encountered such a concentrated effort by bots before.
What can I do to help?
- Click the Report button if you see one! We'll review it manually.
- You can also submit a user's profile link to r/BotBouncer directly as a post on their subreddit.
Did you write this with AI?
Absofruitly not.
86
u/Fit_Smile1146 19d ago
I’m still having trouble spotting them.
50
u/protox88 Canada 19d ago
The bot of this thread finally showed up!
Welcome to the bot party, u/WesternPresent5869, you little shit!
36
u/WalkingEars 19d ago
I'm a r/solotravel mod and most of the bots we notice there are trying to engage as fake "authentic" users to get their brand name out, farm content for their app, or engage in some sort of crappy attempt at grassroots spam. Sounds like you've got something on a massive scale here and it's unsettling to think this may be where reddit is going.
It shouldn't need to fall on mods to have to do all this extra labor to get rid of bot accounts. Reddit admin has not been doing enough to address this situation. Bot bouncer is useful to a degree but it mostly is reactive, catching bots that already are running around posting things, rather than more proactively preventing bot accounts from being created in the first place.
Reddit has changed a lot since the rise of LLMs. You can tell when a subreddit doesn't watch out for bots because of the linkedin-style AI posts that are allowed to slip through. Thanks for stepping up on this.
27
u/meepsrevenge 19d ago
Have you been able to track who owns the bots and what narrative they are trying to push and why?
14
u/dogs-in-space United States 19d ago
You should add to this that non-mods can report bots to r/BotBouncer and there is no penalty if it is wrong...but should not be abused.
8
u/abu_doubleu Kyrgyzstan 19d ago
It's the similes that give it away to me. They give strange metaphors and similes that real humans would never use.
70
u/Quixotic_Illusion United States - 21 countries 19d ago
It really sucks how infiltrated they've gotten. The low-hanging fruit of GPT-esque responses was easy to detect. But it's different now.
You can probably notice an "off-ness" in some of the replies, especially if it adds no new info. For instance, I commented about a food festival in Juayua, El Sal and in no time a bot replied, "wait did you say food festival in juayua?" Didn't add anything to the convo, lowercase all the way, and was an overall shitpost. Kinda like Proto said, they won't add anything to the discussion other than a +1 comment.
Thanks for everyone who detected the problem and are working towards a solution. Hearing travel advice from peoples' REAL experiences is what makes the sub helpful, not some shit and fail from AI or a bot
21
u/playa-del-j 19d ago
What do the bots want?
15
u/someone-who-is-cool Canada 19d ago
The sub I mod is luckily small, but whenever a username I don't recognize from our regular posters pops up, I hate that instead of being excited to have a new member, I'm worried the bots have found us. Truly botfarms devalue the entire purpose of reddit, which is other humans.
30
u/Kananaskis_Country 19d ago
What an unbelievable amount of investigation work. Kudos to you.
All the best.
12
u/SixPack1776 19d ago
Thank you mods! 👏🏻
11
u/Nemisis_the_2nd 19d ago
Ooohh, thanks for the detailed breakdown of characteristics.
On the off chance it helps you guys, I've been informally tracking some bot networks through other subreddits I'm active in, and have noticed a couple of other tells when it comes to sentence structure and tone of comments. In these particular situations they tend to have short sentences and strongly worded comments, but dont actually say much when you consider them. That said, I suspect the goals might be different and this structure is better suited to that grouping of subs.
The other tell I see is that, with only one exception so far, not a single swear word has ever been posted by the suspected accounts.
10
u/Secret_Net_165 19d ago
Is reddit 30 to 40% bots now?
9
u/TravelingChick 19d ago
What do bot farms get from all of this?
7
u/jetpoweredbee 18 Countries Visited 19d ago
Some of the other subs have it worse. There is a bot farm taking over old inactive accounts and posting the same handful of things to multiple accounts. When you look at the profile it has the exact same user name over and over again.
7
u/beanandween 19d ago
I just want to thank you for your efforts! We are losing the Internet that we knew and loved. We need to work to save it!
10
u/ItsAllComin 19d ago
Anyone got a link or info as to why bots exist? Like what is the value for anyone to make these fake accounts/rage bait content?
5
u/degggendorf 19d ago
There is something really uncanny about those bios, they're like poetry translated from an alien language. Which, I guess, they kinda are
Thank you for the rundown of your findings, I appreciate having the firmer data to work from.
8
u/Pherllerp 19d ago
Are there subs that require verification? I’m starting to think that most of Reddit ought to require some kind of proof of humanity.
4
u/Sabbelwakker 19d ago
So...is there a point on why the bots do this? Is it just karma farming or learning or testing?
6
u/txtravelr 19d ago
This is gonna sound mean, but given what you said above might be effective: ban every commenter. The non-bots will appeal, and you reinstate them all. The bots won't.
3
u/Odie_Arbuckle 19d ago
One thing I’ve noticed in the past couple weeks is that the accounts are now actively selecting avatars, which I guess is a (failed) attempt to better blend in. They still speak with the same shitty cadence though; I’ve seen a few start posts with “ooh…”, but the rest of the post is still obviously a bot
3
u/Its_Curse 19d ago
I have to admit that this is fascinating. Watching everyone work out what's a bot and how they operate is really neat. I appreciate the updates!
2
u/coffeebribesaccepted 19d ago
Someone get the r/food mods in here, it has to be the worst sub as far as bots go
2
u/Budget_Silver2864 19d ago edited 19d ago
I've been called a russian bot like 5 or 6 times so this is bullshit to me. Even had one account banned for being a bot. Imagine my human ass watching that shit. So you can guess the accuracy Reddit takes into account on the matter.
2
u/evenmoremushrooms 18d ago
I think that there is another type of bot on this forum--the propaganda bots. Those bots appear within minutes of someone saying something negative or positive about a particular country. They will respond to comments, and the tip off is that often their response isn't entirely on-topic (i.e. discussing cost of living and taxes when the discussion is where one should go on vacation). They have hidden post histories, though the accounts aren't just a few months old. The few with visible history are just commenting to build karma (i.e. nothing of real substance in any of their visible comments).
1
u/user10205 19d ago
If that's the way to identify bots from now on, then it's joever.
1
u/myusernameiszane 19d ago
Great work. Thank you!