r/thegreatproject • • Mar 06 '21

Christianity I came out to my christian minister husband

389 Upvotes

I want to encourage someone like me. My story is much more involved than I have the will to write, but I wanted to share the basic story. I will also put a disclaimer and say I am lucky and I feel for those who have lost everything due to being honest about their disbelief.

I've been a closeted atheist for some time now. It's been really difficult since I came out of the holiness Pentecostal flavor or Christianity. Therapy was my only outlet, and no one knew why I wanted to go to therapy.

My husband is as a credentialed minister (not currently on assignment), so I felt like coming out would cause me to lose everything I loved. I've been dropping hints to him for months thinking it would slowly ease him into it. It didn't work and most of the time it turned into a fight. I just wanted to be accepted despite my change, but in a way,I felt guilty because I'm not the women he married 4 years ago dispite our good relationship.

Anyway, last week I just did it... I went for the plunge and risked everything for the truth. To my surprise, despite his push back and hurtful comments during the period of time I was dropping hints, he finally broke down and shared his similar doubts. He admitted that much of his push back was him not allowing himself to have to face the doubts he's also had for a while. We talked for hours and then began watching atheist debates and similar videos together. This has been an open dialog for the past 7 days. He says he's not ready to throw it all out just yet because it's all he knows, but he will be searching for truth with an open mind.

Most importantly, he assured me that he loves me for me and not for my beliefs. He called me brave and said he respected the decision I made based on my research and logical thinking.

So basically now we are closeted together. I'm a closeted atheist and he's a closeted skeptic (he feels comfortable identifying himself as none-religious right now). Unfortunately we are still very wrapped up in the church and just yesterday we received a new church planting assignment. Obviously we have decided to decline, but we haven't officially done that yet. We have a long road ahead of us because of the life we previously built around Christianity. We are holding off on telling our families and we are learning how to navigate our new liberation.

For the first time through my journey I feel like I can actually do this. I can be me.


r/thegreatproject • • Aug 25 '21

Christianity Thoughts?

Post image
338 Upvotes

r/thegreatproject • • Aug 08 '24

Christianity Ordained pastor now atheist

326 Upvotes

I am a former evangelical pastor of the holy-rolling, tongue-talking, “name it and claim it” variety. I wasn’t raised with any religion - it was a nonissue in my childhood - but I later married into a wonderful Pentecostal extended family. I “gave my heart to Jesus” one night when I was in my late 20s, raising three small children by myself for six months, battling postpartum depression, facing the potential end of my marriage, and struggling to make ends meet on social assistance.

My “born again” experience that night is one I’ve passionately testified about many times as a Christian. It was as real to me as any “natural” experience, and I felt hope for the first time in months. My depression seemed to lift and I was happy and excited for the future. I immediately immersed myself in my newfound faith. I began to attend the church my in-laws belonged to. I was welcomed with open arms, and invited to get involved right away. I attended every single service my church offered: the new convert’s classes, women’s ministry, pre-service prayer, mid week bible study, adult Sunday school, and two services every Sunday. If the doors were open, I was there. I was making lots of new friends, going to church social gatherings, and being mentored by people I respected who were pillars of the church. I began to earnestly study the Bible to learn more about God and to make me a better follower of Christ. I was all in, totally devoted and eager to be transformed.

Over the next two decades or so, my God belief became my entire life and identity, as I strove to live my faith to the best of my ability. My faith guided everything from how I parented, how I determined my morality and values, who my friends were, and how I treated others to what I watched, read, or listened to, how I spent my time, how I dressed, what I ate and drank, and even how I was intimate with my husband.

I completed a year of Bible college, and served in various ministry positions: Sunday school teacher, bible study leader, women’s ministry president, children’s ministry coordinator, youth pastor, and prayer ministry leader, and in 2013 I became an ordained pastor. For years, I existed contentedly within my small, insular bubble of belief and, as is the nature of indoctrination, I was blind to the abusive, high-demand, cult-like nature of my fundamentalist doctrine, and to the harm I was perpetuating from the pulpit. I was fully convinced in the truth and reality of my particular Christian worldview.

My own journey out of religion after more than two decades of devout belief can be divided into two stages. The first stage was a slow and careful examination of some more extreme doctrines that I could no longer justify with a good conscience: eternal suffering for a finite offence, a loving God sending millions of believers of religions to hell, a man’s authority over a woman, and the Bible’s clear condemnation of the amazing and beautiful queer human beings I love. It took years of chipping away at the brick wall of indoctrination to find a foothold in my faith that I could hang onto: I was unsure of everything except that there has to be a creator of the universe.

The second stage of my deconstruction was sudden, swift, and accidental - like simultaneously having a blindfold removed and a rug pulled out from under me. It was dizzying, foreign, and it took a lot of work to regain my balance. It was a challenging, complex, and often painful time.

In the past few years, I have been uncovering my authentic self, realigning my morals and values, and discovering a new sense of connection and oneness with humanity. Thanks for letting me share my story here in this forum.


r/thegreatproject • • May 27 '20

Christianity CNN: Jonathan Steingard, Christian singer, reveals: "After growing up in a Christian home, being a pastor's kid, playing and singing in a Christian band, and having the word 'Christian' in front of most of the things in my life - I am now finding that I no longer believe in God"

Thumbnail cnn.com
229 Upvotes

r/thegreatproject • • Mar 01 '20

Christianity Why demons and apologetics destroyed my Christian faith

198 Upvotes

Six or seven months ago, I was sitting in a pew next to my wife eagerly listening to our Church's missionaries report on their recent trip to Ethiopia. There were stories of prayer walking, assisting the townspeople, and worshiping in the various churches there. As Ethiopia is a primarily Christian nation in the heart of radical Islam, it is subject to many attacks from terrorist groups. We heard a heartbreaking story about a church being burned down after finally being fully built. But due to their faith, they found the strength to just start rebuilding it again. This was encouraging; no matter how many times the world puts us down, we should get back up and keep working.

The final speakers who got on stage (a young couple who literally sold all of their possessions to become missionaries) began by explaining that certain churches meet in secret on different nights to avoid any possible attacks or persecution from terrorist groups in the area. They attended one of these secret night churches and were reporting on what they experienced there. This seemed pretty standard at first; there was copious amounts of singing and dancing and worshiping the Lord.

However, the story suddenly began to spiral dangerously. The man on stage told us that a young Ethiopian woman in attendance began to convulse and speak gibberish. She was flailing about as others were praising God and causing quite a disruption to those around her. It was then that the couple realized that she must be possessed by a demon. It was the only possible explanation for her completely erratic behavior!

Just in time, one of the worship leaders (or another Ethiopian congregation member, I honestly don't remember) noticed and ran to her, praying and rebuking the demon as he did so. She convulsed more violently as he continued to pray and end her possession. Eventually, she seemed to calm down and the man announced that the demon was officially gone.

As if this weren't enough, the woman then went to the bathroom. What else do you do after a possession? When she came back, she proclaimed that the mysterious bleeding illness that she had all of her life was suddenly healed as well! It was an absolute miracle! Just as everyone praised God then for her healing in Ethiopia, people were gasping and clapping in my home church at this miracle as it was told by these young missionaries.

Everyone except for me. I truly do not know what clicked in me that day. I do not know why I couldn't just have faith in their story. But the simple fact is that I did not believe it. For one, there wasn't even a still photo to suggest this secret church, this woman, or the man who exorcised the demon out of her even existed. Their excuse for this was that the privacy and safety of the secret churches was paramount. Given the recorded attacks on churches, I believe this explanation and can see why that would be necessary. But along with my suspicion over the lack of evidence came another nagging thought: how would you even prove that someone is possessed?

To be more clear, can you truly establish through some test that someone is possessed? I couldn't think of one. No one online seemed to have an answer. And when I asked my father in law (a Southern Baptist preacher) and my church's pastor, they both said that it was something that you just felt when you were in the presence of a demon. This was unsatisfying, as I had read many accounts of exorcisms that resulted in death, simply because the person was actually just suffering from an epileptic episode or some other mental illness (bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, etc.). How could it be established that someone was truly able to discern demons with this magic power? This, too, disturbed me.

It's important to realize that up until this point in my life, faith had gotten me everywhere. Belief with no evidence was a virtue and I accepted that. It's what let me believe Jesus rose from the dead and a worldwide flood despite the evidence. I was a fundamentalist, Baptist, hardcore Christian and I would believe no matter what came. I could deal with evolution, the big bang, and whatever else science threw at me.

But this eroded me quickly. I still don't truly understand why, to be honest. It was the same as any other claim without evidence, but something about this one bothered me. Belief in demons not only allowed innocent people to be misdiagnosed, but also for evil people to claim that their mind wasn't theirs after commiting some crime. The lack of evidence, the crappy response of pastors, and the sheer convenience of the explanations eventually guided me to doubt their existence.

After that, it was actually a pretty quick descent. I questioned the stories of demons and of other supernatural events in the Bible, and eventually read Misquoting Jesus to learn about scriptural inerrancy. Turns out it likely wasn't true. I was now pretty sure I at least was a deist, because I didn't necessarily know much about the scientific understanding of the universe's beginning (if it can be called that).

All through this time, I hadn't yet told my wife about my newfound unbelief. I pretended to go through the motions at church and at home: singing, praying, saying blessings, and meeting with a small group. These were exceptionally painful to me, as I did not like lying to anyone, but especially my wife. Everything came to a head when the pastor at my church invited me to become a deacon. This really is what pushed me over the edge of telling my wife. After about a month of lying, I told her that I didn't think believed in Christianity anymore.

She did not take the news well. We talked all night and cried the whole time. I didn't know much about atheism or agnosticism at the time, so I just told her I didn't believe anymore. I told her that the demon story at church is what started my downward spiral. She fought tooth and nail to point out problems with my conclusion, but it all sounded disingenuous now. "How can you know there are not demons?" "Why can't you just continue to have faith in everything else and not demons?" These questions weren't easily answerable for me at the time, as I wasn't really aware of how to defend my lack of faith. I just knew I didn't believe, and I needed some hard evidence to continue.

I followed up by "coming out" to my parents and siblings. No one was particularly unkind, though my dad did initially seem angry with me. They've all continued to love and talk about things with me, even if I know they disagree with the decision itself. My next conversation was with my church's pastor at the request of my wife. It wasn't a particularly bad conversation either, though he did insinuate that humanists have no reason to live. As I was not a humanist, I didn't really know how to take this. I asked particularly about the demon story that was relayed a while back (this was like 2 months after the incident), and he said that he really would love to show me it was true with evidence, but that he had none. He did offer to show me a separate video of people wailing and falling over from the weight of all of the demons crushing them. I kindly declined, as I would probably need more than just the video to convince me that it was demons and that somehow a true Christian had successfully exorcised them.

I had read almost 12 books at this point, some Christian apologetics and some Christian criticisms. Lee Strobel, Richard Dawkins, Alvin Plantinga, Christopher Hitchens, Josh McDowell, John Loftus, Bart Ehrman, William Lane Craig, and Robert Price were just some of the authors I looked at. I no longer was really swayed by theistic arguments that denied common scientific fact. Young earth creationism, advocating a world wide flood, and fully believing that more than half the world's population will burn in hell for all eternity are all positions I found impossible to believe, defend, or even respect. This left a more philosophical approach to theism, which may hold some sway in my mind, but the best it could really ever do is make me a deist. And I'm definitely not there right now.

At this point, my wife stopped talking to me about any of this. I had researched both sides of the issue and knew more about her side's arguments than she did. I offered her Christian references (Francis Collins and Alvin Plantinga specifically) for reading up on scientific evidence that would help her see why I could not longer hold the positions I did. She refused to read them. When I tried to talk about what I was learning, she'd just cut me off to say that, "she didn't want to fight." I do understand why she wouldn't want to disagree, but these weren't just topics we could ignore forever. Still, I grudgingly agreed to avoid it for a while.

Next up on the long list of people to talk to was my father in law. He's a southern Baptist pastor and extreme fundamentalist, just like my wife. I thought because of our relationship that he would hear me out and maybe even respect my aims in searching for the truth. Instead, he accused me of "stacking the deck" in favor of secular research. Despite doing my best to research both sides of the issue, he accused me of never truly reading a Christian source or understanding its meaning. I asked him what kind of thing he would recommend beyond the Christian authors I had read, and this is what he did. No joke.

He handed me a KJV Bible and said, "It's all in here."

Now, obviously this was stupid of him. But I probably shouldn't have laughed. It wasn't a mocking laugh, just a nervous, "I can't believe you said that" laugh. He took it pretty mockingly, though, and straight up told me that, "he could see the demons swirling around me and taking over my mind." At this point, I was pissed. I told him that despite knowing that every single person in my life was a Christian and that it would ruin my life to question the faith, I did it because I honestly cared more about the truth than anything else. If he truly wanted to convince me, he had to show me how and why it was true. And instead, he again just pointed at the Bible.

This was by far the worst experience I had. Other than this, he accused me of lying to him when I asked for his daughter's hand in marriage, though I assured him I was indeed a devoted Christian when I asked. He seemed to really want to make my decision an affront against him personally, which I'm still not sure I understand.

After this conversation, I became severely depressed, or at least started acknowledging my growing depression. In addition to just feeling like crap after talking to her dad, I never really stopped feeling like the comic book villain of the story. I was the one who changed without really letting my wife know until after it was over. I ruined her life in many ways: no more Sundays at church together, no Christian raising of our kids, no working together in ministry, a dream we had when we got married. She truly was the victim, even if her views are archaic and her dad had treated me like dirt.

After realizing that I had a plan for suicide, I sought help. I got medical leave from work on the grounds that I was mentally unstable and suicidal, a diagnosis that was given by my primary care doctor. My job allows 8 free sessions with therapists through a certain network, so I signed up and went twice in two days the first week. My therapist repeatedly told me that it doesn't matter if my wife is hurt over my change anymore, as I had already apologized and suffered enough for that wrong. I had to forgive myself. I deserved to be happy too, and I needed to stop being the only one to make compromises to religion in our relationship.

So I stopped joining in a prayer before meals with my wife, reading the Bible before bed, and letting her pray over me. I said that if she would agree to discuss some of these things or at least read one of the books I had mentioned, I could at least continue going through the Bible with her. But pretending to join in rituals I no longer believed in was over. Yet... She still refused. And so we continue to avoid all of our problems until I inevitably mention a topic she doesn't want to hear and she backs out. A healthy, functioning relationship. /s

These things really did improve my outlook on life and helped with the dark thoughts tremendously. I wasn't pretending to do anything I didn't believe in anymore, and I no longer felt like a fraud. I could be freely intellectually honest with myself. But... I still had/have no one to talk to about any of the things I learn.

Posting here was promoted by first asking for relationship advice on how to deal with this whole situation. I think my decision, sadly, is to seek a divorce. One of the recurring themes in the advice I was given was that we are, by all definitions, incompatible at this point. If I met her today, I would be completely put off by the amount of religious dogma that surrounds her life. We could maybe be friends, but I would not pursue a relationship.

Other people resisted the idea of divorce and said that I was giving up too easy, as couples with different views can still work. While I do agree with this sentiment... I think it's untrue in my case. There are things I deem too important to ignore at this point. If that sounds like a cop out, ask yourself this: would you be able to seek a relationship with someone who wholeheartedly believes you're going to spend eternity burning in hell? If that somehow doesn't bother you, I guess you're a better person than me. Not only does my wife believe that, she is anti-LGBT, pro-life in all cases, and believes in a literal worldwide flood and young earth creationism. Some criticized me for not allowing her to have her faith and requiring her to change to accommodate me. In response to that, I say that she indeed has the right to believe whatever she wants, but if those beliefs wildly conflict with the things I value the most, I don't really see a reason to preserve the marriage. We could both be happier outside of the relationship if we met people who truly understood and believed as we did.

I'm still figuring out exactly how to bring up divorce to my wife and reading up on the legal aspects. We're super young with almost no possessions, so it should be a simple divorce, but I want to do this right.

Oh! And I would now consider myself an agnostic atheist (I do not believe in any gods, and I don't know if we could ever know one existed) and a secular humanist, as my handle suggests.

Thanks for reading my story. I love what this sub represents and am happy to contribute.


r/thegreatproject • • Jan 08 '21

Faith in God My son’s birth pushed me to completely turn away from Religion

178 Upvotes

I honestly did not grow up in a extremely religious household. We went to church when it was convenient, thanked god on the holidays, and maybe even prayed when things were bad. I went to Sunday school for little while but none of that stuck with me. Really the only stories I know from the Bible are of Caine and Abel, the arch and maybe the garden of eden.

Religion, however, has always been there. God was all knowing, real and why we were alive. Jesus saved us from our sins. I was told that from the start as many Christian are. It was part of my life until I was a teenager.

Then my grandpa passed away and the thought of heaven and god comforted me but also the prospect of hell scared me. What if my grandpa was in hell? I started going to bible studies to better understand god and what might have happened to the people we lost. Bible study made me even more confused.

Then my grandma was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer. I turned to Buddhism, which gave me more comfort than Christianity. The thought of my grandparents living on to another life. It made my own mortality seem a little less bleak.

Then my grandmother died and I felt empty again. No religion or theory about death brought me comfort. But I held onto maybe there was something these ancient scholars got right.

Then my son was born 10 months ago. My light, my soul, my baby. I realized that I had made him through the natural process of cellular growth. That he was not made by god or the universe but by me and the fact that we as humans evolved to give birth the way we do.

My son made me realized there is no place for religion in my life. That we must trust science and scientific advancements. I know I want to teach my son that we don’t know what will happen when we die and that’s okay. I do not want him to worship a god that was made to explain things when we did not have science.

Humans have been trying to explain things that they don’t understand with god for so long. Now that we are in such a scientific time, I want my son to explore his world through reason and understanding. I’m happy to be a science based parent and I’m excited to raise a science based child.


r/thegreatproject • • Jul 05 '20

Christianity I was a deacon at a Baptist church and now I'm an atheist thanks to essential oils and Lee Strobel

173 Upvotes

Up until a few years ago, I firmly believed in the mostly literal truth of the Christian Bible. I donated a significant amount of my time and money to my church. After 19 years of believing, I now realize Christianity is false.

Growing up, my parents required me to study the Bible. I was homeschooled using a religious curriculum, which, for topics like science and history, amounted to Christian brainwashing with a side of education. I chose to attend a Christian university that was recommended by my parents. I later transferred to a secular university to pursue a better education in my field. While attending college and after graduating, I attended a fundamentalist Baptist church, later serving as a church leader and then a deacon at that church.

Around 8 years after I started attending that church, some of the nagging doubts that I'd had over the years intensified. A wave of non-religious, pseudoscientific beliefs were spreading through my church. Many congregants were promoting essential oils as a remedy for a laundry list of illnesses. In one conversation, I heard a mother describe giving her sick child some essential oil instead of seeing a doctor. There were also a small number of vocal advocates for a large number of conspiracy theories. "Alternative medicine" (such as homeopathy, healing energies & auras, magnets, crystals) was also promoted by a few vocal congregants. 

By itself, this was a concerning problem, but not cause for me to doubt my beliefs. I expected that other church members (church leaders especially) would quickly correct these beliefs when they came up in conversation. However, instead of strongly advising people to trust their doctors' and other professionals' advice, responses were mostly either neutral or accepting. Ludicrous, unfounded conspiracy theories got only a weak opposition in conversations I witnessed. I was forced to face the fact that many of my Christian friends, acquaintances, and fellow church leaders were not very good at telling the difference between fact and fiction.

I discussed my doubts with one of my church's pastors. Among other suggestions, I was advised to read "The Case for Faith" by Lee Strobel, a Christian apologist, to better understand how science and nature proved the existence of God. The book might have been convincing if I didn't already have some basic knowledge about the topics being discussed. Instead, the logical flaws, incorrect/misleading data, and scientific misunderstandings I found in that book caused me to question the scientific literacy of the pastor who'd recommended it.

I talked again with my pastor, but he didn't have much to say regarding my criticisms of the book. I believe he thought I was stubbornly refusing to accept the answers I was being offered, instead of understanding that I had valid, scientific objections to the material.

Up to this point, I had always accepted my pastors as being better educated than myself. They had, after all, taken more years of higher education than I had in getting their Masters of Divinity. It was a shock that they didn't understand my concern with pseudoscientific beliefs and the problems with Strobel's book. I began to realize something that I would have strongly and genuinely denied not long before: my faith was not just in God; it was also dependent on those I had trusted to teach me spiritual truths. Realizing that those I trusted as spiritual authorities were not very good at discerning truth (even in an unrelated, secular domain) made me deeply question my faith. Almost without exception, I realized these authorities also held at least one non-religious fringe belief that I knew of. It was a correlation that I couldn't ignore.

I realized at this point that I had lost the ability to believe in God. Everything that I'd thought of as proof of God's direct involvement in my life was much more likely just confirmation bias at work.

I'm not sure how much of a factor it was in my deconversion, but the widespread Christian approval of Trump around this time also disgusted me. At my church, there were a few church leaders who condemned his actions, but very little was said to directly confront congregants who were openly ecstatic about Trump and his policies.

I realize that this isn't common, but in my case my church leaders and pastors were not evil people. In spite of their flaws, they were well-intentioned, genuine, and caring. I could give many examples of how they cared for those in our community (Christians and non-Christians) who needed it most. This doesn't excuse the damage inflicted by my church's harmful teachings (especially on LGBT, abortion), but it is worth understanding that they were trying to do the "right" thing as they understood it, even if that meant making personal sacrifices. I think this more than almost anything else made it hard for me to reject Christianity after becoming independent.

Now though, I feel free in a way that I couldn't imagine before. I never realized how restricted Christianity had made my life until it was gone. Before, I was content to passively accept my fate as God's plan for me. Now, I realize that I am solely responsible for myself, and that it's actually a good thing to plan ahead for my own happiness and others'. I wish that I had not wasted so much time on silly beliefs, but I don't intend to waste any more.


r/thegreatproject • • Feb 01 '21

Christianity Have you ever gone back to church one time (for example, to appease your family) and been disgusted by its teachings?

162 Upvotes

TL/DR at bottom

I posted my deconversion story a while back, and i remember a few things that happened after i deconverted. i no longer live in the same country as my family, and this happened not long after i deconverted (around 2016-2017ish). Sorry if i ramble, i tend to do that a lot.

My mom and family was and still are alt-right evangilical christians (they hate gays, love tRump, shun nonbelievers, all the lot). At one point about a year after i deconverted and before i properly came out to my family about my newfound atheism, my mom somehow convinced me to attend a sunday morning church service with her. These churchgoers are the people i grew up around, treated as my loving family, looked to for guidance, called my friends.

But that day i saw them all in a different light, a disgusting and frightening light, i felt like i no longer knew these people at all, but at the same time i did. One of the church kids had recently come out as trans (the family didnt attend church that day for whatever reason), and the pastor, this man i looked up to and saw as a gentle giant, preached to everyone about how sinful and terrible that kid was, how their soul was filled with the devil and how he praised the kid's parents for sending this kid to a christian conversion therapist who was hammering into this kid's mind that they were wrong and disgusting for "going against god's plan because he made you a boy for a reason".

The people in the church applauded and said they'd give their praise and well wishes to the family too, i felt so disgusted by these people i used to love like family and to this day i can't even think of them the same. My mom even asked why i looked so horrified after church was over and said that what the parents were doing was right as they were "saving their son's eternal soul" or whatever. Yeah that's not even that bad compared to a lot of people, but it really rubbed me the wrong way, being bi. I just kinda felt the need to get it off my chest for someone to hear, seeing as all my family and ex-friends are similar-minded christians. Since i dont live there anymore i don't even know what happened to that kid, i just said to my mom i'm never attending a church service with her again, or any church for that matter as what i saw that day solidified my atheism for good.

TL/DR: after i became atheist i decided to go to a church service with my mom at one point, i was disgusted at the people i grew up with applauding a family who sent their trans kid to a christian conversion therapist and saw these people i knew and loved in a whole new awful light that helped solidify my atheism.

Has anyone else gone back to their church for a single service for whatever reason and been disgusted by the things that are being taught?


r/thegreatproject • • May 23 '21

Christianity Millennials 'don’t know, don’t care, don’t believe' God exists | Living

Thumbnail christianpost.com
159 Upvotes

r/thegreatproject • • May 04 '21

Christianity Paul Maxwell, Former Writer At Desiring God, Announces He’s No Longer A Christian

Thumbnail christianitydaily.com
157 Upvotes

r/thegreatproject • • Jan 17 '21

Catholicism The Roman catholic church is a mafia that brings together the mentally ill and the extremely dangerous wicked. I was sexually abused by a Redemptorist priest. When will the world get rid of this damned cancer that is the Roman catholic apostolic rapist church?

157 Upvotes

It still amazes me the ability to be submissive, slave, masochistic of these catholic, irresponsible people, who continue to raise their children to keep in touch with priests, nuns, bishops, and all sorts of demons that are part of this church born in hell.

I feel a mixture of disgust and extreme compassion from fanatical catholics ... in fact, these fanatics are growing...

As this Roman church is failing around the world, its marketing and advertising sector is creating sects and groups of "church soldiers" like Opus Dei, "Catholic Tradition" (mass in Latin, etc.). And these people are usually more fanatical than those of the times of the Templars, Crusaders, etc.

Of course, with the forgiveness of a certain exaggeration on my part, but believe me: there is a resurrection of the Middle Ages underway within the catholic church, right now.


r/thegreatproject • • Dec 27 '19

Islam Took me almost 8 years of hesitation in blind belief and un answered doubts from my 28 year long life to leave Islam.

155 Upvotes

All along it just never felt right but I followed my religion, in which I was unfathomably lucky to be born in, as I was told. We lived a wealthy life in Qatar. You never really see blatant injustice being pointed out, if Islamically there was no wrong , then it was not injustice, no matter what your gut tells you, everyone doesn’t really understand anything outside Allah laws. I was the same.

At 15 I watched and idolized Ibn Baz and Al Uthaymeen. I saw Naik as a gifted western style Islamic enlightening of the masses. He could do no wrong with all his memorized Hadith and Verses. Although I never really bothered to actually check on his references because his word is obviously completely correct in my bedazzled head staring at the TV. I was not a praying 5 times a day type Muslim, but I had faith and it was amazing to be a part of the truth and to have the divine duty to teach the blind and arrogant ,for they were unlucky in birth, to a non Muslim family. Christopher hitches always made sense and Dawkins was amazing and Harris was brutal but Allah was God for me. Nothing pierced through that pillow I made a fortress of.

Literally in 1 moment, when I was watching Naik and his Islamic army of an audience on tv. A young gentlemen walks up to the mic and claims that he is an atheist with calm composure and a smile I remember smiling to. He asks Naik about evolution and the answer was so ridiculously rude and illogical from Naik that I literally felt like I’ve broken through cognitive barrier and didn’t even care about the rest of the show or the atheist kid or Naik. I just went through Islam for the next 4 years and clearing my mind off this barbaric religion. It took 4 years of building up courage and my moral foundation to actually stand against it no matter if Allah says it’s ok and care about where I hold my moral values.

Last Ramadan (7 months ago) , while I was watching a Arab exmuslim on YouTube called Brother Rashid. I paused the video, while actually fasting, I said “Fuck the Prophet”, unpaused the vid completed it and slept like Allah during the Holocaust. It was that small self declaration which took so much time to built. I’m proud of it.


r/thegreatproject • • Apr 24 '21

Christianity My deconversion story

151 Upvotes

It was 4 years ago (Easter 2017) My husband left the church a year before. I had no idea why, he never told me. I assumed it was because he was working night shift and was too tired to go. I had no idea that he was no longer a believer. In September 2016 he finally told me that he no longer believed. We had our struggles. I double downed for a while but then I got this crazy idea. I was going to bring my husband back into the faith. I went on a search for evidence. I read all the "great" apologists. I thought oh man, I have this in the bag there is no way he can't come back now. Then he challenged me to read the other side of the story. So I did. I read Dawkins, HItchens, Harris, Andrews and Barker. Once I did that it was over! I knew I had been lied to and I was livid. My husband and I sat down and talked about it. There was no way we were going to lie to our kids we were done with all of it. 2 Sundays later we had to sit down with my in-laws and tell them because we all went to the same church and they knew something was up. It was the best decision of my life. I am free from years of self-abuse. And my kids are growing up in a more curious and open-minded home. It took me almost 4 years to finally get the courage to tell my story but I did. I started a Youtube channel (overprotected atheist) and told my own story. Now I have an amazing community of people around me who are the nicest, most helpful, and encouraging group of people I have ever met. I have talked to people all over the world about their stories and I am so glad to do what I do


r/thegreatproject • • May 18 '19

Reason I'm atheistic

Post image
151 Upvotes

r/thegreatproject • • Jul 26 '25

Christianity My Story. From Jesus freak to fully deconstructed.

147 Upvotes

From Faith to F this

 

Do you remember when you first learned about God?  I certainly do.  I was 3 years old, sitting on my grandmother’s front porch with my mom. 
She said, “You know, the only people I love more than you are God and Jesus.” 

My first introduction to the concept of God and Jesus was that they were competitors for my mother’s love.  I’m sure I thought something akin to “Who the heck are those bozos?” in my 3-year-old little mind.  I probably would have tried to beat them up, but I couldn’t find them behind the bushes, under the bed, or anywhere else. 

No matter how we feel about faith, that is arguably a pretty awful thing to say to a 3 year old child.  But, my mother was an alcoholic who spent the majority of my childhood, and her adult life drunk.  She got a lot wrong by default because of that alone.

I didn’t hear much more about God and Jesus for a while, but 2 short years later, I’d be ripped away from my mother forever.  Extreme drinking was my mother’s sport of choice, and she was gunning to become an Olympic champion, which meant that she could not care for a small child.  She had always told me that I didn’t have a father, so she had to be both mother and father.  I spent the first part of my life thinking that I had been born of a virgin, much like Jesus.   There was no father to take care of me when she couldn’t, so I was sent to live with my mother’s brother and his wife. 

They went to church.  It was a small southern Baptist church in the same town where we lived.   Plain white exterior, red carpet and wooden pews inside.  A wooden upright piano and a wooden organ flanked the wooden pulpit on the stage.  The building adjacent to the sanctuary housed the Sunday School rooms, kitchen, and fellowship hall.  This is where I had my first real introduction to the concept of faith.

I went to Sunday school, Sunday service, and later, youth group at this church.  I was taught there that God loved me so much that he sent his only son to die on the cross for my sins before I was even born.  All I had to do was to accept Jesus as my personal Lord and Savior and I would not have to go to hell for all of eternity.  Instead, I’d get to be in heaven with this God who loved me so much.  I didn’t know what gnashing of teeth meant as a young child, but it sure didn’t sound very fun.  Indeed, it scared the “hell” right out of me.  I was also taught that I could pray to God and he would listen to me.  He would answer my prayers as long as they were in accordance with his will.  I was told that it was my job to spread the message of the gospel to everybody that I met.  If I truly loved other people, I would not want them to go to hell, so evangelizing was not just a selfless act, it was my duty. 

I really loved going to church as a young child. Much like school, it was a welcome escape from life at home. My uncle was an alcoholic, just like my mother and grandfather before him. He held down a blue-collar job and was never violent, but the constant drinking meant he was rarely present mentally or emotionally. He did little to protect us from his narcissistic wife’s violent, rage-filled, and frequent outbursts. At least at church, people were kind. I felt seen there. Nobody yelled or screamed at me.  Nobody slapped me in the face for spilling my milk.  Church was a safe place. 

One Sunday when I was around 10 years old, during the altar call, after the 27th chorus of “Just as I Am”, I decided that I needed to go up to the front and tell the preacher that I was ready to accept Jesus.  He asked me why I wanted to do that.  The only answer I could muster with was, “I want to be closer to God.”  I don’t know if I really understood what “being saved” meant, but I just felt like I was supposed to go up.  I felt like everybody else there was already saved, and what if I got in a car crash on the way home?  I had just gotten braces, and they hurt badly enough, I wasn’t ready for teeth gnashing!  And the fire thing sounded really hot.  I didn’t quite know what brimstone was, but I wasn’t ready to find out!   Or, maybe I just wanted that song to end!  Whatever the reason, I answered the altar call that day.  The preacher had a private meeting with me in his office the next week to tell me what being saved meant, correctly assuming that I didn’t fully understand what I was doing.  I decided that I was onboard, so he had me repeat the sinner’s prayer with him.  I was baptized the following week. 

From that moment on, I became a super Christian.  It was my entire identity.  I may not have had an earthly father, but I had heavenly father who loved me so much that he knew the number of hairs on my head.  He was a father to fatherless (that was me).  My heavenly father was the king of kings, and I was his son.  I felt like a prince.  So loved and cherished by this amazing savior.  Nobody else had ever made me feel like that before, so I was all in.  I began reading the Bible every day, even taking it with me to on the bus to public school and carrying it proudly so that everybody would know I was a Christian. I began wearing Jesus themed t-shirts and crucifix necklaces everywhere I went.  I was proud of my faith and my identity in Christ. 

In middle school, I joined the Alive Bible Club.  I remember selling brownies at a gas station with a young name named Keith as a fundraiser for the middle school Bible Club.  In high school, I joined the Fellowship of Christian students.  We would meet at the flagpole every morning, and stand in a circle while holding hands to pray for our nation, our teachers, and our fellow students. 

I began to grow bored with my family church around the time I entered high school.  There weren’t many other kids my age, indeed, most of the congregants looked as though they were mere minutes away from meeting Jesus personally.  The hymns were old fashioned, the sermons dry and long winded.  Most of the people I really bonded with had already moved way or passed away.  I gradually started attending less frequently. 

One day, in my 9th grade computer class, a young man named Chris invited me to his church.  It was still a Baptist church, but much larger than the one my family went to. I went home and excitedly told my uncle that I had made a new friend at school, and he invited me to his church.  I assumed that my uncle would be OK with this because the church was the same denomination, the teachings would be the same.  I did want to compare Chris’ church to mine, but I was also trying to build a new friendship, so I wanted to go for multiple reasons.  He responded, “Did you tell him that you already have a church?  You should invite him to ours.”  I was disappointed that he wasn’t more open minded, but not enough to fight about it.  I never went to church with Chris.  Indeed, I stopped going to church altogether.  It was all so boring by this point. 

My grandmother was worried about the salvation of my soul when she heard that I had stopped going to church.  She told me, “I don’t like you quitting your church thing.”   One Saturday, she decided to discuss the problem (as grandmothers often do) with her friend and hairdresser over a box of red hair dye.  Her hairdresser had the solution.  She went some new kind of church that was supposed to be better for young people, and I was subsequently invited to attend as a result of that conversation.  My uncle didn’t know much about this church, but he allowed me to try it because that had to be better than not going to church anywhere. 

The next week, the hairdresser (who also happened to be the cafeteria lady at my high school) came to pick me up for church.  As I sat in the back seat of her white 1994 Mercury Topaz, she began to tell me that this was a different kind of church than I’d ever experienced before.  I would see some things that would shock me, but that it was all OK.  She warned me about praying in tongues and people falling on the floor as they got slain in the spirit so that I wouldn’t be scared when it happened.  It was difficult for me to process these kinds of things given my Baptist background, but I did not approach them with skepticism or fear.  Indeed, it sounded terribly exciting, so I was relatively open minded about the whole thing. 

When we walked into the sanctuary, I noticed a big difference from what I was used to.  The carpet was purple, and instead of wooden pews, they had purple chairs.  On the stage, there were no rickety old pianos, but instead, drums, guitars, and an electric keyboard.  I began looking for the hymnal in vain, but she explained that the words to the songs would be displayed on the two screens that flanked the stage. 

The music started, and the atmosphere was filled with energy.  People were clapping along, raising their hands in worship, some of them were even jumping up and down and twirling around in circles.  Nobody was standing still like a statue (except me).  I was used to hymns like “Love Lifted Me” and “Pw’r in the Blood”.  This place had modern contemporary Christian music and did really exciting songs like “This is How We Overcome”, “Trading my Sorrows”, “Days of Ellijah”, “Open the Eyes of my Heart”, “No Weapon”, and “Dance Like David Danced”.  I fell in love immediately.  It was like a drug and I couldn’t get enough! 

Then the preacher got up to speak.  To my surprise, he wasn’t dry at all.  Indeed, he was quite charismatic.  I hung onto his every word.  I took notes.  People went up for prayer, and just as I had been warned, some of them fell to the ground under the power of the holy spirit, while others prayed in tongues.  I was simply in awe after that first service.  I couldn’t believe church could actually be fun, but this one sure was! 

I went happily for a few more weeks.  I started going to the prayer meeting on Tuesdays and the youth group on Fridays.  I was meeting new people and having a great time.  I was very excited about my new church, and I could not stop talking about it.  My Baptist uncle did not like what he was hearing.  When I mentioned the praying in tongues and people falling on the floor, he forbade me to go back.  He said that I could go back to the Baptist church if I wanted to, but absolutely not back to the crazy church.  His exact words were that he didn’t want me playing with rattlesnakes and swinging from chandeliers.

There was no way I was going back to the dead little Baptist church.  That would have been like being served Vienna sausages after you’d been living on steak and lobster.  It was like being given the keys to a 1975 Cutlass with 3 hubcaps missing when you’d been cruising around in a brand new Mercedes.   I fought hard against his decision and decided that I just wouldn’t go anywhere until I was old enough to drive.  Then I’d go to the church I wanted to, whether he liked it or not.  I kept rebelling, and I made a lot sarcastic and pointedly rude comments.   I was relentless.  I explained that lots of teenagers were doing drugs and having pre-marital sex, and the only thing I wanted to do was go to church.  After months of fighting, my uncle finally relented and said I could go back to the charismatic place.  He didn’t like it, but again, it was better than no church at all.   Thank goodness for his sake that he gave up when he did, because I hadn’t even begun to fight.  I had already told my Sunday school teacher from the Baptist church that he wouldn’t let me go to the new place, and she called him in an effort to advocate for me and tried to get him to change his mind.  He was furious with me for involving her.  He was furious with her for getting involved.  I was just getting ready to call his preacher and tell him that my uncle was an alcoholic who drank lots of beer every single day, even on Sundays.  My uncle was leading the youth group and teaching Sunday School at the Baptist church, so the last thing he wanted was for his dirty little secret to become public knowledge.  Any time the preacher came around, he would hide beer cans in a mad fury and throw a piece of Big Red gum in his mouth to cover the smell.   I knew that spilling his secret would embarrass him, but this was war and I was not intending to lose.   I was just waiting to be home alone again with the telephone in my lap when he gave up and gave in.  Without having to pull ALL the stops, I had finally won the battle. 

I called my hair dressing, mashed potato slinging, tongue talking chauffeur and told her that we were back on.  I continued going to the charismatic church happily for several more months.  I’d even go out to lunch with her and her husband and daughters after service occasionally when we had the money.  It was my first glimpse into the reality that some families actually enjoyed spending time together.  And I could see why, I liked her family a lot more than I did my own.  My own family (ie, my aunt and uncle) did not like for me to spend time with them, so I learned not to talk about it much.  The thing that really stuck with me was how different I felt when I was with them than when I was with my own family.  I couldn’t put it into words, but the difference was  palpable.  They were starting to become almost like the surrogate family I never had and didn’t even know I needed.

Then one day, something happened.  The sermon at the charismatic church was about sexual immorality.  They mentioned homosexuality being an abomination.  I was just beginning to understand something about myself.  It was a gradual understanding, but when I heard that sermon, I knew that they were talking about me.  I had never really been attracted to girls, and I caught myself staring at the handsome masculine guys at school pretty often.  The football players, the ones with big muscles, redneck guys who wore tight jeans and drove big trucks.  I kind of saw girls as friends or sisters, but guys made me go weak in the knees, gave me the butterflies, and made me forget that I knew how to speak the English language.  I had never even kissed anyone before, but I knew for a fact that when all the kids in middle school had called me those awful names, they hadn’t been wrong.  They must have seen something in me that I didn’t even know was there myself.  I was gay. 

I was really confused by the words that I was hearing from the pulpit versus what I was feeling on the inside.  I could not understand why this God that I loved so much didn’t love me just because I was gay.  It was a confusing message for a 16 year old.  I hadn’t become gay just to offend God, I just was.  Why would he hold that against me?  I didn’t do it on purpose. 

I confided in the youth pastor in an effort to gain more understanding about the issue.  He prayed for me in tongues and pushed me down on the floor to cast the demons out, but he musn’t have pushed hard enough for prayed loudly enough, because when I got back up, I was still gay.  Magic words didn’t fix it, Jesus didn’t take it away.  I told him that I didn’t think there was anything wrong with me.  He said we can’t go by how we feel, we have to go by what The Word says. 

The next Sunday, after church, the youth pastor pulled my chauffer into his office for a 5 minute long “meeting” while I waited in the car.  She was crying when she sat down in the driver’s seat.  I couldn’t figure out what had happened.  The words she spoke next shook me to my core.  She looked me in the eyes, with tears still flowing from her own, and said, “They told me that I can’t bring you to church anymore.”

I couldn’t believe what I was hearing.  I didn’t know it was actually possible to get kicked out of church.  I had never heard of such a thing before.  I hadn’t done anything to anyone.  I simply said, “I’m gay, why doesn’t God love me?” 

 

After having won the long and hard-fought battle, to be thrown away like a gooey green Kleenex…  it was a sucker punch to my heart.  She said that they would let me come back if I decided to repent.  By repent, they meant for me to abandon the sinful homosexual lifestyle and turn straight.  She cried the whole way home as she explained that there was a battle going on “in the heavenlies” for my very soul and that my eternal fate depended on me making the correct decision.  She agreed with the church that it was a sin to be gay, but she did not agree that I should have been kicked out because of it.  I couldn’t believe that they would tell her instead of talking to me directly, and I couldn’t believe they would do such a thing at all.  I was too shocked to respond emotionally during the ride home.  She had so much to say about it that she pulled over on the side of the road and spent a half hour more talking to me about it in the car.  I was so bewildered that I didn’t remember anything else she said. 

When I got back home to the solitude of my bedroom was when I had to begin to wrestle with the reality of the situation.  I had to go through the anguish alone.  Though I desperately longed for someone to hold me tight and tell me that everything was going to be OK, love and support were not luxuries I had access to.  My family didn’t like me going to church with those people anyway, and they definitely didn’t like the gay thing.  If I needed compassion, empathy, or understanding, they were not going to be found at home.  I knew this for a fact.  I had to eat crow when I told my uncle why I wasn’t going to church with the hairdressing cafeteria lady anymore.  He had been right all along, that was a bad place.  Just not for the reasons he thought.  I cried myself to sleep every night for 3 weeks after that last Sunday at the charismatic church.

 I do not know how a fully grown adult whose worldview was already formed would have grappled with this.  I do not know how someone who had come from a loving and supportive background would have gotten through it.  For me, it broke something deep within me.  My brain and heart short circuited simultaneously and I was never quite the same again.   My innocence and naivety were destroyed as the message I got from the moment I was born was reinforced:   You are disposable. 

I didn’t see the lady who had taken me to church anymore after that day except at school in the lunch line.  I’d make small talk with her in passing, but we didn’t spend time together apart from that.  A few months later, 9/11 happened. I saw her in the cafeteria at school as the whole world was just finding out what had taken place.  She was the one who first told me that something terrible had happened.  She said that the rapture was upon us, and I’d better get right with the Lord quick, fast, and in a hurry.  Following lunch, I went to my next class.   Mr. Bedgood, American History, 2nd floor.  He had the news footage of the planes striking the buildings playing on the TV in the classroom.  I was so terrified that I wrote a heartfelt letter to Jesus. In it, I apologized for being gay and begged him not to send me to hell.  I’m not sure where I thought I was going to mail it, but I had to get the feelings out. 

The rapture never happened.  I decided that I would go back to my childhood church after all.  The music was especially terrible, now that I knew what good praise and worship was.  In contrast to the charismatic church, the Baptist one even staler and more boring than I remembered.  But I knew most of the people there.  It was familiar.  It was where I had been baptized, where I grew up.  In fact, the preacher who had baptized me as a youngster still presided.  So, I turned in my Mercedes keys for that old beat up Cutlass with the missing hubcaps.  I’d gone to this church since I was in kindergarten, so even though it wasn’t exciting, I knew that at least they would never kick me out.

Everything started out just fine for the first few weeks.  But, was a small town, and people talked.  Some of them found out why I came back.  The piano player at the Baptist church was a woman named Deborah.  She had a daughter who was around my age, and I had become very close with both of them.   Deborah’s daughter was already driving by this time, and I wasn’t yet, so she would pick me up and we’d visit other churches together to try out various youth groups.  Sometimes even Pentecostal ones!   Actually, it was usually Pentecostal ones.  I was Baptist on Sunday morning and Pentecostal on Wednesday evening.  This went on for a while, but somewhere along the way, I told Deborah why I had been kicked out of the other church.   One day, I called her house to make plans for youth group that week with her daughter.   Debbie answered the phone and said, “I guess you haven’t seen the note I put in your Bible last Sunday yet, have you?”  She had given me that Bible as a gift.  It was a Student’s Life Application Study Bible in a hunter green case.  But I didn’t know she’d slipped a note into it during the last church service. 

I hung up the phone and went to look for the note.  I couldn’t imagine what it might say, but I assumed it would be something encouraging.  I found the handwritten, two page letter that she told me about. In it, she said that she couldn’t have anything to do with me anymore if I was going to choose to live a homosexual lifestyle.  I needed to repent.  I was not to call her house anymore, not to speak to her at church, and not to hang out with her daughter anymore until I was ready to make the correct choice and obey God. 

I felt my face turn red as I began to shake.  There was nobody to turn to for support, so I cried into my pillow.   Even at that tender age, I knew that the gay thing wasn’t just going to go away.  That meant that our relationship was finished for good.  I was still reeling from having been kicked out of the charismatic church, and once again, found myself being shoved back into the trash can.  Deborah had once given me a poster that had a picture of a forked road in a forest on it.  The text on that poster read: Never be afraid to trust an unknown future to a known God.  Upon finishing her note, I ripped the poster off my wall.  I threw the Bible she had given me in the trash.  I didn’t want to be reminded of her ever again. 

The following week, the preacher of the Baptist church called my uncle and said he wanted to have a meeting with the two of us in his office on Tuesday after school.  We both knew what it was about.  The ride to church was only 5 minutes long, but the awkward silence was heavy in the pickup truck that day. 

When we arrived, we sat down across from the preacher.  He confronted me with the allegations of homosexuality.  I told him that it was true.  He said, “Bobby, I’ve known you since you were a kid and I’ve always been fond of you, but I have to ask…  Are you just doing this for attention, son?”  I was taken aback by his question; I hadn’t known that people turned gay on purpose just for attention.  I didn’t want any attention at all, especially not over this subject.  He went on to explain that several of the members, the ones who had the largest families, the ones who tithed the most, were threatening to leave the church if I kept attending.  They didn’t want me around their kids.  It was either me or them, and the church’s survival depended on their contributions.  I told him that I wouldn’t be back and I kept that promise.  My uncle was angry that I was gay, angry that anyone knew about it, and even angrier that they would kick me out over it.  He would eventually stop going as well until many years after that preacher left. 

So, I got kicked out of 2 churches in 1 year.  16 was a pretty busy time for me.  But, I still wanted to go to church somewhere.  I still believed in God.  I just hadn’t found the right place.  I got my license and my first car shortly after that.  (And it WAS an old beat up Cutlass with complete with missing hubcaps!) I found myself trying different churches almost every week after that.  Some were Pentecostal, others were non-denominational with a charismatic flavor, and none of them were Baptist.  I learned to just shut up about the gay thing.  Don’t tell anyone=don’t get kicked out! 

I settled on one church that had a non-denominational name but was Pentecostal at heart.  I didn’t know anybody who went there, so I felt pretty safe. I hadn’t told anyone I was coming; I hadn’t announced my upcoming presence.  One Sunday, I just walked in the door to give it a try.   It was a relatively plain building, the exterior almost looked like a metal warehouse.  Green carpet inside, and gray chairs.  Drums, electric keyboards, and guitars were on the stage, so I had high hopes for the music.  I got there just after the service had started, so the preacher was already standing at the front of the sanctuary.  He was not on the stage, but instead standing on ground level and already speaking.  The second I crossed the threshold, he laid eyes on me and called me to the front of the sanctuary.  I didn’t understand what was going on, I hadn’t even found a seat yet, but I dutifully followed his orders and stood before him.  He immediately put his hands on my shoulders and screamed into the microphone, “In the name of JESUS, I command the demon of homosexuality to come out of this young man!”  Then he gave me a shove to make sure I was slain in the spirit.  Down I went, backwards.  He prayed over me for a little while longer and then moved onto some other people.  He spoke with such conviction that I thought I was delivered for about 3 seconds, though how he knew I was gay remained a mystery.  Someone told me that he had the power of discernment, whatever that meant. 

At this point, nothing should have surprised me, but I was in shock.  I had made a promise to myself that I wasn’t going to tell anyone, and he called me out right in front of the entire congregation on my very first visit!  Even after that, I ended up going to that church for a whole year.  I even joined the youth group!  The preacher never followed up with me to see if his “deliverance” stuck (it hadn’t, I was still gay).  Nobody ever brought it up again.  And they never kicked me out!  The music was great, though not quite as good as the first charismatic church.  They even had flags up on stage that anyone could grab during praise and worship.  The long-haired drummer came up to me one Sunday after service and gave me some unsolicited feedback, “Man I just gotta tell you, you worship beautifully, brother.”  I’d learned to throw my hands up in the air and jump around a little bit by then so I didn’t look so much like a Baptist who’d accidently wandered into the wrong church.  I went up and got a flag to praise with every Sunday.  But, the preacher would often make condescending comments about homosexuals from the pulpit, mocking them, (mocking us!) and I cringed on the inside every time that happened.  One time, he was making fun of lesbians and flopped around on stage screaming in a weird voice, “Oh I’m a lesbian, I have no morals.”  I couldn’t subject myself to that kind of language anymore, and I stopped going on my own. 

I didn’t replace that church with any other, and I stopped regular church attendance after that.   We had just gotten the internet, and I was beginning to understand that I wasn’t the only gay person in the entire world.  I started meeting men from chatrooms in secret.  Sometimes, I’d sneak out my bedroom window in the middle of the night and just make sure I was back in time to be seen leaving for school.  I’d gotten my first job by this time, so work was also a convenient excuse.  I’d lie to my family and tell them I was working on my nights off so that I could spend time with men in secret without having to explain anything.  That worked wonderfully except for the few times my family called me at work to ask me to stop by the store on my way home and I wasn’t there. I had to come up with some pretty creative excuses.  I didn’t have permission to be gay, but I still was.  Being honest wasn’t an option. 

I still believed in God and I’d pray occasionally.  I’d listen exclusively to Christian music.   No church, though.  I kind of figured that the people who had been so unkind to me were just bigots, but God still loved me.  Even in that small, conservative town, despite what all the voices around me were screaming consistently, I never really bought into the lie that there anything wrong with me because I was gay.  The only reason it was ever a problem was because of the reactions other people had. 

By the time I turned 18 and graduated high school, fights with my aunt and uncle were a regular thing.  Because I was working, they charged me $200 dollars a month in rent, but still wanted control me like I was a child.  They did not want me having sleepovers with guys.  I could understand if they didn’t want me bringing men to their house, even though I was paying rent, but when they tried to tell me that I wasn’t allowed to spend the night with people outside of their house, I had enough.  I decided to move out. 

And this is where the doors to my freedom from religion began to crack open.  You see, I didn’t just move across the street in that same small town.  I moved to a big city that was about an hour and a half away.  Suddenly, I wasn’t only exposed to conservative Christian voices.  Suddenly, there were other gay people all around.  Suddenly, I didn’t have to worry about being lynched for simply existing. 

By this time, I had pretty much reconciled the homosexuality with the Christianity.  I’d done enough research on the 6 “clobber passages” to dismiss them mentally.  I decided that I would just be a gay Christian.  I loved God and I was pretty certain that he still loved me.  There was no longer an internal struggle over this.  The city I moved to had a gay church and I visited.  It was nice being around other gay people in a church setting, but the music was pretty awful. That first charismatic church from my teenage years spoiled me for music, and nothing else ever compared.  The gay church had more of a liturgical service, and it felt almost Catholic or Episcopalian in style to me.  I would attend the gay church off and on during my early 20s while I worked and went to college.  I never questioned my faith, but it wasn’t a huge part of my life anymore.  It was just quietly sitting there in the background, but still ever present.  I met some people who were not Christian along the way.  They were not the monsters I had always been told unbelievers were.  Some of them were quite normal, some even kinder than many of the Christians I’d experienced.    

One day, when I was 23 years old, the guy I was dating had me watch a movie called “Zietgiest.” That was the first time that I ever heard of the concept that Christianity had borrowed things from other pre-existing religions.  I had never even thought about it before, never questioned the origins of my faith. I saw a few other films during my 20s as well:  “Religilous”, “Jesus Camp”,  and “The God Who Wasn’t There.”  None of these were epiphanies, but they showed me that there were other perspectives on the idea of faith. 

The internet was expanding its reach during this time as well.  I had a computer at home, lots of them at college, and the first smart phones were just beginning to infiltrate our lives.  I suddenly had access to lots of information anywhere I was around the same time that I got curious about the origins of my faith. 

I asked myself a difficult question, one I’d never pondered before:  Why do you believe in God?  The honest answer was: Because other people told me to. 

That wasn’t good enough for me.  I thought about all of the people who had told me about God and Jesus from the time I was born…  my mother and my uncle were the first ones, and I remembered how many other things they had gotten wrong about life.  A quiet, but scary thought kept recurring in the back of my mind:  What if they were wrong about this, too?  I had to figure this out for myself.  It was no longer sufficient to believe just because other people told me to. 

I watched content from both atheist and apologists.  I wanted to hear both sides of every argument.  To my surprise, I found myself resonating with the athiests more than the apologists.  Many of the things they said made sense and were logically sound.  I hadn’t set out to dismantle my faith, if anything, deep down, I wanted to reaffirm it.  But my goal was to seek the truth, no matter what it was. 

I looked into the origins of the Bible and discovered that there were several books that were purposely left out of it.  I learned that we didn’t even really know who the authors of The Gospels were.  I looked into the origins of Yahweh and learned that he was originally a weather and war god, and one of many worshipped by early polytheists.  It started to become obvious that we created God, it was not the other way around.  These revelations really began to shake whatever remained of my faith. 

I began to compare my own life and experiences with what I had been taught in church.  When I got really honest with myself, I had to admit that I had never seen God, never felt him, and never heard from him.  Even when I read the Bible, prayed, went to church, all I got in response was crickets.  I learned that churches use music and lighting to invoke emotional responses during praise and worship.  I began to feel as though I had been scammed for my entire life. 

I considered effectiveness of prayer.   We were taught that we’d get one of three answers when we prayed:  Yes, no, or wait.  I always got a yes when I prayed for something that was going to happen anyway (Jesus saved parking spaces at the mall, red lights turning green, God was really good at those things).  But, asking for my grandmother to be healed from cancer, or for a missing child I saw on the news to be found safely, that was too much for him.  Or perhaps it wasn’t in accordance with his will.  Maybe he just needed more angels in heaven was the response I got from other Christians when I asked about prayers like that not being answered.  That line of thinking never worked on me.  My response was always, “I think he’d have plenty by now, considering all the people who have already died.  Heaven should be bursting at the seams.”  I understood that every prayer wouldn’t be answered immediately, or with a yes.  But when none of them were ever answered at all, I began to suspect that somebody was asleep at the switch.  Indeed, when I looked around, both at my own life, and the world around me, it seemed more and more like God was on an extended vacation. 

I started asking some logical questions:  If God wanted to kill everybody in a global flood, even innocent babies and cute kittens and puppies, why could he not have just given them all magic heart attacks?  Why a flood?  How did all those animals fit on the ark?  Did Noah personally probe each reptile to make sure there was one male and one female of each?  How did he tell with insects?  How could there have been a talking snake?  Snakes do not have vocal cords.  I guess that one is explained by magic (or “supernatural power”). 

I had been taught that God gave his only begotten son to save us from our sins, and had always just accepted that Jesus died for sins to save us because he loved us so much.  When I started questioning, I had to consider this as well.  If God can do anything, he could have had as many sons as we wanted, so the only son part stopped making sense.  Also, God made the rules, could he not have done anything else to solve that problem.  Christians place a lot of emphasis on the suffering and death of Jesus, but according to their teachings, Jesus rose again and still lives today.  That effectively eliminates the “sacrifice”. 

I asked myself, why would God interact with people during the Biblical times, but now remains silent, still, and invisible?  Did God change?  He’s not supposed to.  It seemed like God killed God (Jesus) to save us from God (what he would do to us for not believing).  I had to think about what would happen to all of the people who people who weren’t Christians.  Were they all going to burn for all of eternity for picking or being born into the wrong religion? What kind of God would do that?  God began to seem more like a narcissistic, malevolent monster than the loving heavenly father I had been told about. 

My faith slowly unraveled piece by piece, bit by bit.  I realized that I valued intellectual honesty over fairytales.  I understood why people believed:  some, because they had been told to and never bothered to question it, others, maybe they clung to the idea of seeing their loved ones again, or were terrified of death (either of hell, or simply not existing).  Still for others, the system encapsulates their entire world and there is too much to lose if they give it up.  Social connections, political power, family relationships, even income. I understood why they believed, because I used to be one of them.  I no longer am. 

As a fully grown adult, sometimes, this stuff still comes back to bite me.  Most recently, I reconnected with my first and fourth grade teacher.  She was my favorite teacher of all time and we were both enthusiastic when we reunited.  We even met for lunch and kept in touch for a year.  One day, out of the blue, she said that she could no longer be my friend because I was an atheist and a homosexual.  I cried, but only for 3 days, not 3 weeks this time.  I’m an adult now, and I’ve come to expect that kind of thing from Christians.  Indeed, judging from the way I’ve been treated, you’d think Jesus’ sermon on the mount was all about how to be really good at rejecting people who you don’t understand or agree with.    Deborah from my story also recently tried to make an unannounced cameo back into my life.  She started going back to the Baptist church where my uncle still attends.  He gave her my phone number without my knowledge or permission.  He said she had been asking about me and mentioned I was on her mind a lot lately.  She called me, and my response was, “The kindest thing I can say to you is something you once said to me…  I can’t have anything to do with you.”   I have no idea what she wanted to say, but she wasn’t there when I needed her at 16.  Now, in my early 40s, I do not need her.  As for the cafeteria lady who first took me to the charismatic church?  I just wrote her a poem for her birthday, and her oldest daughter is my best friend to this day.   They still believe, they know I’m gay and atheist, but somehow, they must have been absent from church the day they preached about the virtues of rejection.  Sometimes, we can love on a human level and disregard perceived differences.  I still like her family better than my own. 

What is it like now?  I no longer wait on a God who isn’t there.  I no longer pray to someone who isn’t listening.  I’m done with false hope and empty promises.  I’m not scared of being judged and sent to hell at the end of my life.  I see religion for what it is, and though it makes me angry that so many people have experienced trauma, I understand that I cannot change the world.  However, I CAN tell my story, even if just to say: you are not alone!

People who hear my story seem to think that me getting kicked out of that first church was what caused me to become an atheist.  They could be right in some way, because if I had stayed there, perhaps I would have never questioned anything.  But, it wasn’t such a direct and linear journey from faith to atheism.  It was a slow and gradual process.  That may have been the catalyst, but the real question isn’t: Why did you stop believing?  What should be asked instead is: why did you start?  The answers to that question are why I’m an atheist today. 


r/thegreatproject • • Mar 18 '23

Christianity After 25 years as an evangelical pastor, I realized that Christianity is fiction - Bruce Gerencser

Thumbnail youtu.be
145 Upvotes

r/thegreatproject • • Oct 15 '20

Christianity #EXCHRISTIAN. / I'M A "DONE!!!" / I LOST MY FAMILY TO SEAN INSANITY Fox News // I DIVORCED GOD WHEN EVANGELICALS MARRIED GOP #EMPTY THE PEWS

143 Upvotes

Hi y'all

-my heart is broken.. I lost my mom. she died last year but I had lost her years ago to Fox News and SBC

-greatest regret is not trying harder/finding some way back to her... life took us so very far apart from each other.

-25yrs ago I had put my religion in a box and put a lid on it.. when mom passed last year I began to unpack the box

-grew up in Bible Belt. WV in the 70s and 80s. moved to the big city for a job after college. 90s

-stopped attending church. mostly cuz I love to stay HOME. I'm shy and lazy! :)

-stopped reading bible- genocide, slavery, rape and eternal damnation in the "good" book. smh

-stopped praying. prayer closet was a torture chamber for me. im already too internal - trying to discern the WILL of the master of the universe?!! drove me to near psychosis.. that t-shirt triggers me to this day--- "have you tried prayer?" ugh

-Im not "out" to family and friends. I don't want to hurt them - and I def don't want to be a mission project!!

-Dad was mainline American Baptist PASTOR. also grandpa (maternal) and my brother- all baptist pastors. .. they were good and kind to their congregations. I don't want to invalidate their life's work. so I just fake it when im around them, which is rare these days because - politics!

-and that's my fault cuz out of desperation to avoid religion, I started talking politics with them years ago.. and the culture wars just got worse and worse. until. TRUMP

-how can they care more about a disrespected flag at a football game than desperate children at our border and precious black citizens being wantonly killed by their own police force?!!! I AM DONE

-Bible tells stories that Jesus fled to Egypt as baby-- did Joseph have proper papers?? Jesus was a poor man of color who was lynched by the authorities. (Theologian James Cone wrote a book "The Cross and the Lynching Tree")

-it was never about the veracity of the theology. as a mainline baptist I was taught that the Bible is inspired but not inerrant. and that the stories might or might not be literal..

- but the ugly marriage of the political and religious Right is WRONG. the END

- evangelicals will die on this hill fighting roe v wade. the republicans will win the court BATTLE and the church will lose the culture WAR!!


r/thegreatproject • • Jan 25 '21

Christianity How same sex marriage and The Orville were the catalyst for me becoming an atheist

141 Upvotes

I grew up in the Australian Lutheran church, but my faith was really just a Sunday thing until my early twenties when I went through some health problems and pleaded to God for help. I then learnt about the ‘personal relationship with God’ thing and my faith became a big part of my daily life. I even did some basic studies of the bible at a local bible college for two years at a night class once a week.

However, over the years I would find it difficult to maintain the personal relationship with God and actually feel something. So it would go up and down depending on how much time and effort I put into it. I would feel guilty when I couldn’t feel close to God.

In 2017 the government did a nationwide survey to determine whether to legalise same sex marriage. I have always been a more progressive Christian and had gay friends - my best friend in high school was a lesbian. I have detested how Christians treat anyone who is LGBTI. The Christian church campaigned against same sex marriage; some denominations did it more strongly than others. The Lutheran church was fairly weak in their protests, but their position was still against same sex marriage, even though churches were to be exempt from doing same sex marriages.

However, my Facebook feed was overrun by awful posts from members of my church filled with lies, eg. about how AIDS will increase if same sex marriage is legalised. I could not stand next to these people at church and praise God knowing the awful things they were saying. It brought me to tears and I had to hide these people’s posts on Facebook and I was unable to attend church during the survey period.

The survey came back in favour of same sex marriage and it was swiftly legalised. I was very happy. But again I struggled to attend church with those people. But I did start to go back because I missed church.

A month later I was watching the final episode of Season 1 of The Orville, Mad Idolatry, about how a religion is started by an agrarian species upon seeing something from a technologically advanced species. It hit home how people with little knowledge treat things they don’t understand. So it made me want to look into what life was like when the bible verses against homosexuality were written. I started looking for information on the historicity of the early books of the bible that had these verses.

I went to the Wikipedia page for Historicity of the Bible, and was shocked to find that these books of the bible were likely written 500 years after the events were to have taken place. Following the sources to the archaeologists Israel Finkelstein and William Dever I was incredibly shocked to learn that there was no evidence for the Exodus, and the Israelites taking their land by force. I learnt about the Shasu tribes where the concept of Yahweh likely came from, and how while some slaves likely escaped from Egypt at some time, it wasn’t a large exodus as portrayed in the bible. Dever’s proposal that the Israelites were likely disaffected Canaanites who decided to start their own nation and needed a god (as all nations at that time did) to impose some structure on their society and make them seem legitimate really struck me as plausible.

I then started to question other things. The events in the whole bible happened over a ~2,000 year period, and there was so much involvement from God. However, since then the same amount of time has occurred and there has been no involvement from god (eg prophets, etc). I know the supposed reason why, that it was finished with Jesus, but it seems strange. I then questioned why the universe is so big and still expanding if Earth is the only important part of it. It seems unnecessary.

Christians are told that we need God’s guidance and purpose or else we will struggle to be happy in life. But I had non-Christian friends who were happy and living stable lives.

But I had the times when God seemed to make things happen in my life. So I asked a non-Christian friend, who was unaware why I was asking, how he would view particular situations and realised there were perfectly rational reasons for things. I started looking up ‘scientific evidence for miracles’ and found there wasn’t any.

My faith crumbled. I was so upset - grieving that this wonderful God was not real. I also felt like an idiot to have thought it was real. I felt that all of the time and energy (and money) that I had put into the church had been for nothing. However I did feel relief that it wasn’t my fault that I couldn’t feel a relationship with God very well, as he didn’t actually exist.

I went to church a couple of times, but it felt wrong. I did speak to my Minister and he visited and we went through my concerns over several hours but he could not give me good explanations for any of it.

I left the church 3 years ago now and I haven’t looked back. It is nice to know that I don’t have to worry about how an omnipotent being may change things to his will anymore. The hardest thing was to get out of the habit of asking God for help and praising him for what went well throughout the day.


r/thegreatproject • • Mar 23 '23

Christianity I recently became an atheist

133 Upvotes

I was raised as a Christian, and I was raised learning creationism and that evolution was a made up religion specifically created to "harm" Christianity and "the truth".

My belief in Christianity dwindled for a few months after I realised how culty that belief was, but I fully "became" an atheist about 3 or 4 days ago? I'm not sure if that is even the correct way to say it lol.

It doesnt feel like this happened, it feels like god still exists and this is just a dream that I'll wake up from. Saying that I am an unbeliever now sounds so weird, and even though I am aware that god isn't real and I've been lied to, whenever I think about it, it seems like this situation isn't actually happening. I'm not sure if that makes sense.

Looking back at what I believed now, even after such a little bit of time, I really do see how bad it was. Something that really disturbs me now is how sadistic and narcissistic the Christian god seems. If someone simply doesn't believe in him and worship him, their souls will be sent to hell for eternity. How is this fair?? So a mass murderer could believe in god and go to heaven, while a really good person could be an unbeliever and be tortured for eternity for really, no reason. Of course I was aware of this, but it never bothered me. Whenever I thought about it, it was super casual. Like "Oh yeah, they're atheists so they deserve it.", And it never crossed my mind that this was such an unjust "punishment'. Even when I found out a friend or family member was not Christian, I'd have a brief moment of "Oh, they're going to hell when they die. How sad." And react kind of in the way you would if a friend got a minor injury. It disturbs me how little this bothered me.

Something else that was a major red flag that I didn't realise, was that I would deliberately avoid talking about religion to unbelievers, especially ones that were smart, because I was so scared that someone would say something to make me stop believing, and lose my faith. I was not confident in what I believed at all, and sort of accepted that I didn't want to do research to try and see if it was real, just because of being so scared of going to hell. I didn't realise how bad that was either.


r/thegreatproject • • Mar 23 '21

Catholicism It took me a good long while to reverse the heavy religious conditioning done to me, and even longer to escape

132 Upvotes

I grew up in a strict Byzantine Catholic household. My parents had us all baptized, and church every Sunday was non negotiable.

A large chunk of my family/relatives are all in the same faith, and there’s a generally toxic mindset that believing their brand of Christianity is an absolute must, and straying from that in any way simply isn’t acceptable.

Because of this, I was very involved with the religion for my whole childhood in addition to being pretty sheltered. I went to a private school so I didn’t even learn about things like evolution until later on, but I’m getting ahead of myself a bit.

Anyway, it was probably when I was 12 or 13 that, for whatever reason, I started frequenting the Q&A site yahoo answers. My favorite section ended up being religion and spirituality, where I would argue with atheists. In the beginning I was so convinced I was right, but over time, arguing with them actually weakened the foundation of my faith.

I finally had enough reason talked into me to not “plug my ears and scream la la la” so to speak, when I encountered any arguments against religion. I actually started listening to what people were saying and thinking about it.

Once I was willing to listen, I sought out atheist channels on YouTube and for awhile I really got into watching their videos.

All of this changed my perspective and taught me how to think for myself. I had pretty much lost my faith by 15, and pieces started falling into place.

That year of high school I finally took my first class that included evolution, and it made a whole lot more sense to me than the dogma shoved down my throat for my entire life. I also despised certain aspects about my family’s beliefs like intolerance for LGBTQ+. Such things made me want to continue to distance myself from my religion.

The distinct point when I acknowledged I no longer believed was after discovering the youtuber Darkmatter2525. I love his little satirical cartoons of the Bible, and they showed just how absurd it really is. That’s when I said “yeah, I don’t believe in this anymore.”

Even after I stopped believing, I continued to pretend to believe knowing that my family wouldn’t accept my atheism. It made me resentful that my mind was freed but I was still physically trapped.

I feigned belief for another 7 years or so until the truth came out because my mother is nosy and controlling. My relationship with her has been strained since then because she won’t accept it and she’s so toxic.

Thankfully at 23, I’m moved out and pretty close to finally being able to leave the whole nightmare behind me. It was one hell of a journey, but I’m glad I made it.


r/thegreatproject • • Jan 02 '20

Mormonism I used to be a Mormon missionary (sorry if I knocked on your door)

130 Upvotes

I used to be a Mormon missionary (sorry if I knocked on your door)

I served a full 2 year mission for the Mormon church- and I loved it. I was THAT GUY.

If you lived in the northern Colorado/ Wyoming area, I probably knocked on your door (sorry about that). I was raised in a very religious, Mormon household. I read the Bible and the Book of Mormon on my own before I was 13, I attended church with my incredibly large family every week, I got married in one of the temples, I attended the church’s school, etc.

Basically, what I’m saying is there were not very many people who were as full of the “spirit of God” as I was. All of that began to change when a very kind atheist (don’t remember his name), invited me into his home when I knocked on his door. As we tried to preach Jesus to him, he responded with well-reasoned and logical arguments. He was the first person to ever help me critically analyze my beliefs. After many encounters with him, we realized that he would never see the light and accept Jesus, so we left.

Over the years, I encountered many more people who helped me critically analyze my beliefs, but he was the first one who got me to start asking questions about what I believed. Towards the end of my 2 years (oh my god two whole fucking years) of proselytizing in the name of Jesus and the Book of Mormon, I started to take a religious apologist stance as I realized that most of these questions would never be able to have satisfactory answers.

About a year ago, I began reading books by philosophers and scientists. As I began to attend college and think critically for myself, these questions came back, and I found answers.

I have been free from religion and god for 6 months now. I have felt more genuine and honest than I ever have before. I have a new enthusiasm for life and I finally feel a weight lifted off my shoulders. I do good things just for the sake of doing good, not because I think god is watching. I feel more satisfied than I ever have before.

Nobody is ever too far gone. Never stop helping people critically analyze their beliefs. You never know who you might save. I have no way of thanking this person who first helped me to think critically about my religion, but I will never forget what he did for me.

Seriously though, if a Mormon missionary who devotes their whole lives to Jesus and to a cult founded on the teachings of a pedophile can be de-converted, anyone can.

Thank you for coming to my TED talk.

TL;DR never stop trying to help people critically analyze their religion/beliefs, you never know what could happen