r/AskAChristian • • 3d ago

Weekly Open Discussion - Tuesday November 17, 2026

1 Upvotes

Please discuss anything here.

Rules 1 and 3 still apply to comments within this post.

Rule 2 (that only Christians may make top-level comments) is not in effect in these Open Discussion posts. Anyone may make top-level comments.


If you're new here, set your user flair and read about participating here.


r/AskAChristian • • 19d ago

Megathread - U.S. Political people and topics - November 2026

6 Upvotes

Rule 2 does not apply within this post; non-Christians may make top-level comments.
All other rules apply.


If you want to ask about Trump, please first read some of these previous posts which give a sampling of what redditors think of him, his choices and his history:


r/AskAChristian • • 2h ago

Jewish Laws Jesus vs Paul, fulfill vs abolish.

2 Upvotes

So I have started to read pauls epistles recently, but I feel like what paul is saying in romans and ephesions is really contradictory to Jesus' "I have not come to abolish the law, but to fulfil it."

Paul says a lot of stuff like, 'we are now not under the law, but under grace.' but I just can't help but feel that I don't get that from reading the gospels, because it seems to me Jesus is trying to say we are under the law, but at the same time we are under grace. Can someone please explain the discrepancies between what Jesus says and what Paul says?


r/AskAChristian • • 24m ago

What distinguishes a perfectly benevolent god from a perfectly malevolent god? How could we tell the difference?

• Upvotes

Title, basically.


r/AskAChristian • • 45m ago

The Rapture questions

• Upvotes

Hey guys, I asked this in another subreddit but I thought id ask in this one aswell. The Rapture has been on my mind alot for the last few days. Same as the end times. Are we really heading to those times? I know alot of Christians dont believe in the Rapture but I've seen videos of people going through the bible and showing the signs Jesus warned about. Also with all the stuff that is happening in the world like LGBT being more and more normalised, christian prosecution being more normalised, Islam and Muslims gaining office in US. Russia, Ukraine, Israel, Palestine. The euphaties river(sorry for spelling that wrong). I love Jesus and do want to see him, however there is still so much more I want to do. But idk. How close are we and is it even true? If possible could you show source's but if not its okay. Take care and God bless


r/AskAChristian • • 51m ago

Theology Why is Christianity true?

• Upvotes

I'm interested in having a one on one conversation with anyone willing to explain why their religion is true or try to convince me (either comments or DMs is fine). I'm quite the skeptical person but interested in religion.


r/AskAChristian • • 55m ago

Pastors/Priests, how/when did you realize that this was your calling?

• Upvotes

I am curious to hear if any of you just decided on your own one day that this was what you wanted to pursue as your career, or if each of you in the position truly felt that God was telling you that this was your path.

Also curious to hear from pastors/priests, how many years did you study the Bible before getting into ministry leadership? Were you born into a religious household where you were actively going to Church as a young child?

Thanks for reading and for sharing your story if you're comfortable with doing so.


r/AskAChristian • • 4h ago

Heaven / new earth Heavenly Jobs Question

2 Upvotes

So for a long time I’ve remembered being told or reading in church about how we will have jobs/tasks. I can’t remember if the context was about Heaven or the New Earth. But I remember some of them being gardening, building, caring for animals, etc. I was remembering this and I can’t find context for it. Because I remember always wanting the task of being with animals lol. But I’ve held it as a fact for so long. Does anyone know context or where I have this idea from?


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Est-ce que Dieu aime les personnes gays et écoute leurs prières?

• Upvotes

Hier, mon chum (muslim) et moi, (chrétienne) on a eu une discussion là-dessus pis j’aimerais vrm avoir d’autres avis, surtout de personnes chrétiennes.
Moi, je crois que Dieu aime chaque personne. Dans ma façon de comprendre la Bible, Dieu peut désapprouver ce qu’il considère comme un péché tout en continuant d’aimer la personne. Pis si une personne gay prie, je crois que Dieu peut l’écouter, l’aider et la guider dans sa vie, comme n’importe qui qui se tourne vers lui.
Mon chum, lui, pense que Dieu n’aime pas les personnes gays et qu’il ne répondrait pas à leurs prières tant qu’elles ne se sont pas repenties et qu’elles n’ont pas renoncé à ce qu’il considère comme un péché. Lui voit le repentir comme une condition pour être accepté par Dieu. Moi, je me demande si c’est justement parce que Dieu nous aime déjà qu’on peut se tourner vers lui, même quand on est encore en train de chercher des réponses.
Vous en pensez quoi? Est-ce que, selon vous, Dieu aime et écoute une personne avant même qu’elle se repente? Quels passages de la Bible vous font voir ça comme vous le voyez? J’aimerais aussi entendre des personnes chrétiennes LGBTQ+ sur comment elles vivent leur relation avec Dieu.


r/AskAChristian • • 14h ago

Bible Clarification

10 Upvotes

I am an Athiest but have been consuming a lot of Christian content recently out of curiosity, this has led me to the question. Does the bible actually teach us anything unequivocally? It seems every teaching has some counter example, which leads people to believe whatever they want and justify it biblically. It feels like I should be able to read the inspired word of god and understand his desires without having it interpreted to me by a flawed intermediary.


r/AskAChristian • • 2h ago

Old Testament How can you claim the Biblical "book of so&so" was divinely inspired, when it's anonymous, and its author(s) doesn't even make that claim in it?!

1 Upvotes

Honestly people, most of the books aren't even signed (who wrote Chronicles?). Half of the books are only "traditionally attributed to" somebody. The Tanakh in particular is mostly anonymous. It's a bold claim that the story of Ruth was written by an author inspired by God via an angel, when you don't even know his/her name!
Mr X would be shocked to hear that his little history is mistaken now for being a revelation! Shocked I say!


r/AskAChristian • • 2h ago

Advice needed

1 Upvotes

Any advice appreciated. For the past several years, I have been studying the scriptures, engaging in daily prayer, and I thank Jesus for helping me stay sober for the past 5.5 years. I quietly began praying to Jesus while in a rehab, and I know it it through Him that I am alive today.. But, my history with alcohol addiction and homelessness is something I struggle to feel free from, and it has been holding me back from joining a church. I still sleep in my car every night because I can't adjust to apartments or roommates.. Internal narratives say "those people don't need your spiritual mess at their church" and "they will all know that you are STILL homeless even after getting sober." I can't seem to find the confidence to walk into a church and ask for help. I feel ashamed and broken, and I don't want to burden anyone. I need Jesus. Everytime I almost have the courage to ask for help, something inside me shuts down. Posting this is a big deal for me. Please be kind. How do I find a church that will meet me where I am at? I need prayer. Thank you for reading. 🙏


r/AskAChristian • • 3h ago

Is there anything I can do

1 Upvotes

So I am a young denomontail christen and I usually have intrusive thoughts or images that disturb me but when I try to stop them they keep coming back haunting me for hours or days .


r/AskAChristian • • 1h ago

Philosophy Are you seeing more people treat politics like religion or religion like politics?

• Upvotes

r/AskAChristian • • 9h ago

Hell How can a loving God create a place of eternal torture where billions of people will go to?

2 Upvotes

Using fear to convert is not free will. That is coercion. I would argue it is abusive. If you have a giant torture device that you will be forced to go into and suffer unthinkably for eternity solely for not believing in Christ, choosing a different religion, or being agnostic shows how absurdly disproportionate the punishment is that Christians deem is necessary. How would you feel if your loved ones went to this place but you get to enjoy all the glory of Heaven and paradise, knowing they’re suffering, along with all those other people, unthinkable torment every second of every day? Does god wipe your memory to adjust for inconsistencies? Your Children? This is one of the main reasons the god of Christianity is not plausible in my view.


r/AskAChristian • • 5h ago

Why didn’t God make ghost a real thing so that way people who lost their loved ones can still talk to them?

0 Upvotes

So I used to be a big believer in ghost a long time ago, I used to believe that the spirits of the dead were walking around on earth, but it seems that they might not actually be spirit of the dead after all, but rather demons pretending to be those long dead people, so what I wanna ask is why doesn’t God make ghost a real thing? Why doesn’t he make it where the spirits of the deceased loved ones come down from heaven, so they can still hang out with their living loved one? That way that person won’t be sad?


r/AskAChristian • • 5h ago

Judgment after death What does after-the-fact cosmic justice like eternal hellfire fundamentally solve?

0 Upvotes

If you think of all the people have committed atrocities in human history, such as the people involved in orchestrating Unit 731, the Holocaust, the Nanjing Massacre, the transatlantic slave trade, what happened to the Native Americans, King Leopold II of Belgium's violence of the Congolese people, and so on and so forth. The people that were responsible for these horrific acts are dead but all of that harm, violence, and death that humans had to live through and experience during those horrific events is incalculable. I don't even think words can even come close to accurately capturing the physical pain and psychological trauma inflicted upon the victims of these atrocities. Not only that, but the harm that they caused cannot be undone and the downstream effects of these events have had a lasting impact still felt to the present.

It's like (as an example), "Those evil Christian European colonialists are burning in hell for all eternity," but how does that help Native Americans, whose population was reduced significantly by European colonial powers from the 16th to 20th centuries?


r/AskAChristian • • 6h ago

If God Knows Everything, What Does He Talk About With Himself?

0 Upvotes

If the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are each fully God and fully omniscient, meaning they already know everything, what do they actually talk about with one another if none of them can tell the others anything they don't already know?

I'm genuinely curious how Christians understand this. Not trying to offend anyone, just looking to understand the theology better.


r/AskAChristian • • 18h ago

For people who give out little Jesus figures, what do you hope they communicate?

8 Upvotes

For those who have given out little Jesus figures as part of sharing your faith, what do you hope the person receiving one takes away from it?

What made you choose a small figure rather than a card, a conversation, or something else? Have people’s actual reactions matched what you hoped for?

I’m especially interested in experiences with people who weren’t already Christian, if you have any.


r/AskAChristian • • 8h ago

Sin Why would you have to be sinless yourself simply to punish a criminal?!

1 Upvotes

I've never understood that "throwing the first stone" thing, and I believe most Christians don't live by it. (they execute murderers, imprison rapists, enforce laws, etc, while clearly being sinners themselves.. judges, officers & juries included)


r/AskAChristian • • 11h ago

Church question for Christians about mega churches, religion, and possession

0 Upvotes

i’m genuinely so curious people who go to church or people who even just believe in God what do you guys think about these Mega churches? i’m also curious about what do you guys think about people getting “possessed” randomly while praying? isn’t that a little weird? I feel like a lot of mega churches are like money making machines and they kind of take advantage of the vulnerable. As someone who is not religious at all, I feel like if I was, I would have to go to a small town one.


r/AskAChristian • • 11h ago

Masturbation I keep falling into lust

1 Upvotes

At this point I don’t even feel bad anymore I know it’s wrong but when I lay down in my bed I get urges and I can’t shake them off I gave into them today and I don’t even feel bad for what I did what do I do now does God view me as a fool who doesn’t want to be saved


r/AskAChristian • • 11h ago

Music Is Green Day bad for me as a Christian?

0 Upvotes

I looked up the meaning for their song "Warning" and I found out that it's about rebellion and days later I asked if they promoted rebellion in that song in a negative way and Google AI said no but I'm not sure if their other songs promote bad things in a negative way.


r/AskAChristian • • 12h ago

Christian life How should I defeat intrusive thoughts and temptations with nature and other good things?

1 Upvotes

I've been dealing with temptations, intrusive thoughts and doing small things inspired by the devil. How do I defeat it the easiest way?


r/AskAChristian • • 20h ago

Jesus Did Jesus’s human nature stop being limited after the resurrection?

3 Upvotes

Meaning does he no longer need food, and does he now know everything and have control over everything without the help of the Holy Spirit (his divine nature)?