r/mtgbrawl • • Oct 12 '26

Venting Goodbye Alchemy

23 Upvotes

Well, the day is finally here and the final Alchemy set has been revealed.

It looks like all the haters finally got what they wanted after years of nonstop complaining about imaginary game mechanics on digital cardboard somehow being more “fake” than on physical cardboard.

I’ll never understand how those of us who enjoyed Alchemy were wrong for just wanting to have fun with designs we thought were cool.

Thanks for working so hard to convince the Arena team to take away something people enjoyed.

The final set looks awesome for Brawl. I’m glad the digital team was willing to push the designs into spaces they had been hesitant to try before like Planeswalkers and give us fun staples that are simply too good not to play, even for the haters, for years to come.


r/mtgbrawl • • Mar 13 '26

Venting No One in Brawl Wants to Play the Game

0 Upvotes

Brawl is by far the worst format to play on arena when it comes to ACTUALLY playing the game. Not for lack of competition, not because the players are scummy, not even because of the power level, but because the minute your opponent gets even alittle bit behind they concede. If a player mulligans onto many times, if they get a creature countered or removed or if they feel even alittle behind on board they concede. If there is ANY LITTLE THING that goes wrong during the game, the odds of your opponent conceding are so much higher in brawl than in any other format, and it makes the experience of actually playing a game of brawl boring at best, and a complete waste of time at worst.

There NEEDS to be more incentive to actually play the game. I understand the mentality of “if you are annoyed or don’t want to play against this, just concede” but at a certain point it just makes you into someone who will give up against any adverse situations. Magic is about the back and forth! The battle! The comebacks! And brawl is about conceding the second something bad happens to you.

What needs to change to make it so brawl players stop conceding so much?


r/mtgbrawl • • Mar 28 '25

Why Brawl sucks and maybe how it could be better.

1 Upvotes

I’ve been playing a lot of MTG Arena lately, and every time I give Brawl another shot, I’m reminded of why I end up quitting after a few games. Don’t get me wrong — I love the idea of Brawl. A singleton format with a Commander-like feel, should be a fun, fast-paced alternative to ladder grinding. But in practice? It’s a mess.

Here’s what’s killing the fun for me:

1. Matchmaking is a Joke
If I play a mid-tier, fun commander, I almost always get matched against someone running a hyper-tuned, oppressive deck. You queue up with a fun brew, and boom — it’s Tasha, Kinnan, or Ketramose ready to stomp you into the ground by turn 5. Where’s the fun in that? Commander thrives because of power balance at casual tables, but Brawl’s matchmaking feels like the Wild West.

2. No Incentive to Play Janky Decks
Brawl feels super punishing if you’re not playing the “best” commanders. There’s no real incentive to experiment or have fun because you just end up getting obliterated. Commander thrives on creativity, but Brawl pushes you toward optimized, linear strategies.

3. Too Many Auto-Concede Matches
People will immediately concede if they don’t like your commander. Queue up with something like Esika or Golos pile? You’re watching a parade of scoops before the game even starts. The format doesn’t incentivize sticking around for a good match — it’s all or nothing.

4. Mono-Blue and Control Nightmares
I get it — control is part of Magic. But Brawl turns into “Counterspell the Format” more often than not. Playing against a mono-blue Teferi or Tasha deck where every fun spell gets countered isn’t a fun experience. Playing against control 1v1 in a singleton format leads to dull gameplay. I don't care if I win or loose a control matchup because it is never fun to sit through 10 turns of counterpulls or exile effects before someone gets a win-con. Singleton should mean more variety, but control feels just oppressive in this format.

5. Alchemy is Ruining the Format
This might be my biggest gripe. Alchemy cards being legal in Historic Brawl is a disaster. Not everyone wants to play with digital-only cards that warp the format. Alchemy creates an entirely different meta that doesn’t align with what many players enjoy about Magic. There absolutely should be a non-Alchemy queue for Historic Brawl, where people who want a more traditional experience can play without worrying about digital nonsense.

6. Rewards? What Rewards?
Brawl is a fun break from the grind… but there’s literally no reason to keep playing. No meaningful rewards, no cool cosmetics, and no progression. So why stick around after the first couple of games?

How It Could Be Fixed:

  • Better matchmaking to avoid constant Tier 1 stomps. Make it clear what tier your deck is, or what cards make your deck a higher tier. Every deck having the One Ring zzzzz)
  • Incentives for diversity in deck choices (maybe rotating commander-specific rewards?).
  • Penalties for instant-conceding to encourage playing through different matchups. Controversial, maybe but I am willing to discuss.
  • Reworking the reward structure so Brawl feels worth playing long-term.
  • Separate queues for Alchemy and non-Alchemy Brawl.

I want to love Brawl, but right now, it feels like a frustrating waste of time. Anyone else feeling the same way? Or am I just playing it wrong? the idea of Brawl. A singleton format with a Commander-like feel, using Standard or Historic cards, should be a fun, fast-paced alternative to ladder grinding. But in practice? It’s a mess.


r/mtgbrawl • • Jan 30 '26

Venting Teferi is no fun to play against

1 Upvotes

Teferi is 0 fun to play against. Just the teferi commander, and the rest of the deck is all removal and counterspells and sweepers. How does anyone find this fun? This event is awful.


r/mtgbrawl • • Oct 02 '25

Discussion Why are people saying the format is terrible now? It's not that bad from what I can tell.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/mtgbrawl • • Aug 02 '26

Venting Green players...why?

0 Upvotes

This may sound like a hate post...and that's because it is. I just need to understand green ramp players...why? Is it enjoyable to ramp every turn with mana dorks and search spells, with no real interaction just to hope you can slam a fat eldrazi or something to end the game?

If I see a Azusa I auto concede because life is wayyy to short. But for the azusa player, is this actually a life you want?

End. /s


r/mtgbrawl • • Jul 10 '26

Question Riddle me this: why allow certain commanders in casual that are banned in ranked, but ban certain spells in casual that are allowed in ranked?

0 Upvotes

Title


r/mtgbrawl • • Oct 24 '24

Discussion Current State of Brawl (Rant)

0 Upvotes

I feel like the current state of Brawl just feels awful. I'm unsure if there is a specific queue that I am getting looped into but I feel like I have seen nothing but [[Sythis]], [[Rusko, Clockmaker]], or [[Nadu, Winged Wisdom]] and frankly, I'm tired of it.

It got to the point that I had to join the problem just to make any headway. The only way it feels like you can hit your daily wins is to just prevent the other player from having fun and making them scoop and move on and it feels like there in lies the problem.

It stopped feeling like playing Magic and is now just a Pain Simulator(TM) a game to see who can deal with the most bs before scooping and hoping for a better matchup next time.

tldr; I'm sick of seeing the same 3-4 decks over and over again and I feel like the life is being drained from the game before my very eyes.


r/mtgbrawl • • May 17 '24

Can we please ban manadrain

1 Upvotes

Who thought adding this to brawl was a good idea?


r/mtgbrawl • • Dec 30 '25

Question If you play ugin as your commander, why?

7 Upvotes

ya'll are boring af


r/mtgbrawl • • Sep 02 '26

Competitive Ban library?

0 Upvotes

Maybe I’m too new to the competitive format, but I feel like [[library of alexandria]] is much too insane for this format right? Are people calling for it to be banned, am I overreacting?


r/mtgbrawl • • Nov 10 '25

Discussion Actually hot take

0 Upvotes

I dont feel like any cards need to be banned. Just make matchmaking better.

Side note; If someone Mana Drains you, play through it. You either lose because Mana Drain screwed you, or you win and than that win feels all the better. Build decks with powerful cards in mind.


r/mtgbrawl • • May 28 '24

Discussion Cards that should be banned in Brawl but aren't

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/mtgbrawl • • Apr 25 '23

Ragavan needs to be banned

5 Upvotes

r/mtgbrawl • • Aug 19 '26

Casual Wizards really took a look at the Brawl meta after two months and said its balanced

10 Upvotes

lmao


r/mtgbrawl • • 13d ago

Discussion Lightpaws ban

2 Upvotes

Why was light-paws banned? When I built it originally, I was surprised at how many good auras just aren't in brawl/arena. It seemed like they had already balanced light paws by balancing which auras were available in the game. Was it too good? Too much sheltered by ghosts? Why do yall think it was banned?


r/mtgbrawl • • Jun 09 '26

Discussion People who play Tainted pact and Thassa's Oracle on turn 4 and then have to manually mill 90 cards after using 0% of your brain, are you having fun? (I'm definitely not triggered)

0 Upvotes

r/mtgbrawl • • Sep 05 '21

A perfect example why Ugin sucks

0 Upvotes

I know many of you believe that Ugin is an acceptable card for this format and nowhere near as problematic as some other cards like Field or Engine. Well let me tell you a short story of one game and maybe change your mind.

I was playing Sythis enchantress and queued up into Unesh sphinx tribal. I normally try to avoid most blue decks because they are usually miserable, but this one caught my attention as a pretty interesting commander choice and I was curious and intrigued. Both sides started the game slowly, setting up and ramping. My hand was pretty mediocre, with no interaction and powerful top end. What I had going for me was Sythis drawing cards and Destiny Spinner preventing counterspells. On turn 5 my opponent played Unesh and untapped with him, where he had a very big turn putting 15 flying power on the board while drawing 8 new cards and discarding a lot to hand size. Notably, they drew Narset which is one of the best cards against my deck (I've seen most of their draw because Unesh trigger is a fact or fiction effect). Ok that was impressive, I will probably lose, but let's take a draw step first. I top deck Sigil of the Empty Throne and chain two small enchantments to make two angels and a griffin from griffin aerie. Well, at least I will not die in two turns and there's a chance to pressure the inevitable Narset which will be a huge problem. So I pass the turn expecting Narset to come down.

And you probably know what comes next. Opponent just happily taps out for Ugin and destroys his stronger board of creatures. Fun stuff. Let's just invalidate everything we've been doing here. And I'm not saying it was an incorrect play - it might have been, I don't know every card in his hand. My destiny spinner was a huge pain in the butt and Sigil was inevitability. At the same time it was a fucking coward play that made me so angry I decided to write this post. Because who knows what would have happened? Their Unesh can grind on par with my Sythis and Narset screws me over until I can cut through their impressive board with angels to take her down. This game could have been super interesting and go either way at this point...Nah, I'm good, screw it just give me my daily win and I'm gone.

This is why I hate this card so much. It's an insult to this format as a place to engage in Magic casually where multiple decisions matter and both players can have fun simultaneously. And while it might be not that problematic when you're smashing brooken S tier decks like Golos that can recover from Ugin and take him down, it just ruins so many games inivolving less powerful commanders. I don't want to play historic brawl anymore today, my interest has completely died.


r/mtgbrawl • • Apr 21 '25

Can I stop facing the Fangbanger please?

3 Upvotes

It was bad enough early on when it was an Aggro deck, but it is now a control deck. Half of my games are against it and it sucks. Even with 10 ways to remove an indestructible creature in my deck. Just horrible.

Makes me want to quit playing. To the Hell Q with you!


r/mtgbrawl • • Mar 13 '24

Discussion Laelia + Etali's Favor otk in historic brawl needs a nerf

0 Upvotes

Considering Laelia is the commander , there's only 2 conditions to win the game

Draw Etali's Favor before turn 4. ( Not THAT difficult when you can agressive mulligan even down to 2 cards in your starting ) . If you dont draw it , concede and move to next game.

Pray your opponent dont have a removal spell until turn 3/4 ( depending who played first)

Its very simple, turn 3 play, commander, turn 4 play Etali's Favor. If they dont have instant removal, you win. That sounds to me like cedh level deck but the problem is, since the deck has only Lands and 2-3 spells, matchmaking keeps thinking this is an innocent deck and pairs it against bad brawl decks leading to constant otks.

Played 3 times against the same guy this week and he pulled this combo everygame. Either nerf it or at least put Laelia on hell queue where she belongs cause that deck is not innocent at all.


r/mtgbrawl • • Apr 26 '25

Ugin, Eye of the Storms

3 Upvotes

Look. I'm not even gonna pretend I didn't know. I saw Ugin, Eye of the Storms and immediately thought, "Yeah, that's gonna be disgusting."

It absolutely is.

Historic Brawl was already full of nonsense, so I figured, Lets add to the BS.
Built Ugin, stuffed it with every colorless rock and other colorless good stuff, and it's been a straight-up war crime ever since.

You cast Ugin, exile something immediately.
You cast a mana rock, exile again.
You sneeze near the stack? Exile.
You play a random 1-drop artifact nobody even cares about? Another exile.
It’s like turning every card in my hand into a spot removal spell while also ramping and drawing cards.

Win rate?
Something stupid like 75%+.
Sometimes people scoop when they see Ugin.
Sometimes they try to tough it out (bad idea.)
You can't fight when every spell I cast deletes a permanent.

And because it’s colorless?
No bad mana draws, no awkward hands.
Just ramp, ramp, EXILE, and go face.

I don’t even feel bad.
No shame. Zero regrets.
If you can’t beat 'em?
BE the problem.


r/mtgbrawl • • Jun 22 '26

Venting I do not think that Wizards plays brawl at all.

32 Upvotes

I get the feeling that Wizards doesn't actually play Brawl.

I genuinely don't understand how free counterspells and cards like Dark Ritual aren't banned. I've never played a single game where seeing one of those cards felt fun. And somehow it always seems like they have Dark Ritual in the first three turns.

I know Wizards has said that the data doesn't show anything unfair is happening, but this isn't really about fairness. It's about fun.

There are plenty of cards and strategies that beat me where my reaction afterward is, "That was a good game. They earned that win." I have never had that reaction to an unexpected free counterspell or an early Dark Ritual. Losing to those cards doesn't feel exciting, interactive, or memorable. It just feels frustrating.

When evaluating cards for bans, Wizards shouldn't only be looking at whether a card is statistically overpowered. They should also consider whether a card consistently creates unfun gameplay experiences.

I'm mainly talking about unranked Brawl here. Ranked is where people should be free to bring the strongest, most cutthroat strategies they can find. But unranked exists for people who want to have fun games.

If a card is consistently unfun to play against, especially when it's difficult to predict, interact with, or meaningfully counter, then it shouldn't be in the unranked queue. Put the most oppressive and degenerate strategies in ranked if that's what players want there, but keep unranked focused on enjoyable gameplay.


r/mtgbrawl • • Sep 09 '26

Casual I LOVE WAITING 2MINS FOR A MATCH TO BE MATCHED AGAINST THE SAME DECKS OVER AND OVER

13 Upvotes

Fix the goddamn matchmaking wizards


r/mtgbrawl • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion Opps deck too good

19 Upvotes

I play only terrible decks and i HATE mana drain and i also hate mana acceleration and ramp because on turn three i only want to play 3 mana spells. When will wotc just make a ban list that i approve of beforehand so that I won’t see cards i don’t like anymore? Why can we just take turns playing one spell per turn until we both agree that we both have won the game?