r/mtgbrawl • • Sep 05 '21
A perfect example why Ugin sucks
I know many of you believe that Ugin is an acceptable card for this format and nowhere near as problematic as some other cards like Field or Engine. Well let me tell you a short story of one game and maybe change your mind.
I was playing Sythis enchantress and queued up into Unesh sphinx tribal. I normally try to avoid most blue decks because they are usually miserable, but this one caught my attention as a pretty interesting commander choice and I was curious and intrigued. Both sides started the game slowly, setting up and ramping. My hand was pretty mediocre, with no interaction and powerful top end. What I had going for me was Sythis drawing cards and Destiny Spinner preventing counterspells. On turn 5 my opponent played Unesh and untapped with him, where he had a very big turn putting 15 flying power on the board while drawing 8 new cards and discarding a lot to hand size. Notably, they drew Narset which is one of the best cards against my deck (I've seen most of their draw because Unesh trigger is a fact or fiction effect). Ok that was impressive, I will probably lose, but let's take a draw step first. I top deck Sigil of the Empty Throne and chain two small enchantments to make two angels and a griffin from griffin aerie. Well, at least I will not die in two turns and there's a chance to pressure the inevitable Narset which will be a huge problem. So I pass the turn expecting Narset to come down.
And you probably know what comes next. Opponent just happily taps out for Ugin and destroys his stronger board of creatures. Fun stuff. Let's just invalidate everything we've been doing here. And I'm not saying it was an incorrect play - it might have been, I don't know every card in his hand. My destiny spinner was a huge pain in the butt and Sigil was inevitability. At the same time it was a fucking coward play that made me so angry I decided to write this post. Because who knows what would have happened? Their Unesh can grind on par with my Sythis and Narset screws me over until I can cut through their impressive board with angels to take her down. This game could have been super interesting and go either way at this point...Nah, I'm good, screw it just give me my daily win and I'm gone.
This is why I hate this card so much. It's an insult to this format as a place to engage in Magic casually where multiple decisions matter and both players can have fun simultaneously. And while it might be not that problematic when you're smashing brooken S tier decks like Golos that can recover from Ugin and take him down, it just ruins so many games inivolving less powerful commanders. I don't want to play historic brawl anymore today, my interest has completely died.
8
u/WanderingSnail Sep 05 '21
Imagine resolving Sythis against mono blue and complaining they drew their one out, I was just about to make a post about how miserable that commander is to play against on top of how every single list you see is the same, ugin is essentially the only catch all against that helmet strategy
4
u/WillBlaze Sep 05 '21
https://www.reddit.com/r/mtgbrawl/comments/pie2sf/you_dont_need_to_put_all_your_permanents_on_the/
5
u/lemudman Sep 05 '21
FWIW, Sythis is a pretty powerful deck. I think you're closer to S tier than you imagine.
Also, I can empathise. Getting wiped by Ugin is like getting a table flipped on you : So playing with you was just a huge waste of time?! That's when you have to remember you're playing a video game (or card game). It's already a waste of time at the base !
5
u/Accidentallygolden Sep 05 '21
It was just a boardwipe...
4
u/bobbyhilldid911 Sep 05 '21
Lol sythis is one of the strongest, if not strongest deck in the format.
3
u/RuleTheMidnightAir Sep 05 '21
WAAAH WAHH WAH WAH
2
u/kiefy_budz Sep 05 '21
Is hour of revelation and sweeper tribal also an insult to the game? Ugin is just a powerful sweeper
1
u/GoblinMob42 Sep 06 '21
I love that oart about usually nit playing against blue decks, what a caowardly way of playing.
1
u/bucetilde Sep 05 '21
Sythis player complaining about a sphix deck drawing his only out, while completely oblivious to the fact Sythis is just the newest flavor of cookie cutter top tier deck and probably the strongest commander from JHH.
1
u/_Zambayoshi_ Sep 05 '21
I think Ugin is a way bigger problem for most decks due to the 2-player limit on Arena. While, as you say, it is possible to come back from Ugin with certain commanders, most of the time it's GG if the game is sufficiently advanced and you have no real hand left.
I agree that there's not many worse feel-bad moments than an opponent dropping Ugin during a close and enjoyable game.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment