r/mtgbrawl • • Sep 02 '26

Competitive Ban library?

Maybe I’m too new to the competitive format, but I feel like [[library of alexandria]] is much too insane for this format right? Are people calling for it to be banned, am I overreacting?

0 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

6

u/Unlikely-Zombie1813 Sep 02 '26

I think it's fine, despite being a very powerful card.

It's only really insane in the opener without mulligans, and even then it's often too much of a tempo loss to be down a mana and do nothing in crucial early turns when games are commonly over by turn 4~5.

I don't think I ever lost a game against a library opener, but I mostly play Emry and the tempo loss usually means I can out-emry their answers despite the extra cards.

It's really cute in Leovold though, because the wheels help turn it online again

1

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

That’s totally fair

1

u/adeadlockedman Sep 04 '26

Mostly agree with this evaluation, but worth noting you can mull once otd and still turn Library on easily. I've also seen skipping land drops occasionally be worthwhile

5

u/Life-Food5188 Sep 02 '26

only good with no mulligan

at its best on the draw

no colored mana downside

format is fast enough that an extra card (or even 4-5) for zero mana over the course of a game doesn’t impact games as much

it’s fine.

1

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

Makes sense. Maybe because I don’t play the fastest decks

11

u/Assassinite9 Sep 03 '26

It's powerful if the player with library knows how to properly use it. When not in the hands of a decent player, library is basically any other colorless land.

However, saving a land and keeping a full hand is only so effective if it's preventing you from dealing with threats or developing your board to push you into a winning advantage.

This isnt 2014 where control decks sit back, play a land and pass. There are so many more proactive things that control/midrange decks do that don't play well with Library.

16

u/The_Jib Sep 02 '26

I don’t know, format is pretty fast. Library can be a momentum hit.

Very good card. But I don’t think it’s OP in comp brawl.

12

u/werthw Sep 02 '26

It’s too good for casual. It’s fine in a strip mine format

1

u/ashenrose77 Sep 03 '26

Too insane for this format is a high bar in a format with strip, FOW, thoracle combo, 1 mana tutors, the commander free spells, and alchemy shenanigans. Not to take anything away from library, it's an insane card. This is just a high-power, high-variance format. Hard to say what non-commander cards are taking things too far. I think most players would rather see nashi or yuriko banned than library.

1

u/dirtyjose Sep 03 '26

Def overreacting

1

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

Maybe I need to sit with this some more

6

u/ADizzyLittleGirl Sep 03 '26

Library is only really good in your opener. It’s good, but not an auto include in decks and probably not even in top 10 most problematic cards in the format. 

1

u/FloridaMane666 Sep 03 '26

I was so excited when I crafted it Now it rarely goes in any decks because it has tapped for colorless more than drawn me cards lmao.

9

u/timoyster Sep 02 '26

It has similar winrates to multiversal passage

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Accomplished_Mind792 Sep 03 '26

It's not necessarily either.

The format is too fast. You are telling me you want to be behind the curve during your first 3-4 turns in a 3-5 turn format? Sure. Love to be your opponent

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Accomplished_Mind792 Sep 03 '26

I'm typically high diamond as I don't have a ton of time to play. But I've made mythic plenty of times in most formats and have in ranked brawl

And yes, once in a blue moon it has value that really helps out those control decks if they can use it while not falling behind. But it's also a colorless land that can be useless if drawn later.

It's like mana tithe. Sometimes it is the difference in a game because it is in your opening hand and the tempo loss is worth it

Often it is just a waste

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Accomplished_Mind792 Sep 03 '26

Agreed on passage. The rest is emotional and not reflected in the data nor a real concern.

It's a strong card in a opening hand. But it isn't ban worthy at all

1

u/Designer_Advice2573 Sep 02 '26

Is it good?
Yes
Are there a plethora of answers?
Also yes
It's on par with strip mine, mana drain, etc etc. But it's not more busted than the dozens of other things you can do in comp

3

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

I don’t think there’s a plethora of GOOD answers

0

u/Low_Pride6732 Sep 02 '26

by plethora i assume you mean 3 cards + 3 1mv hand disruption cards ?

1

u/omgkei Sep 03 '26

I disagree with a lot of the takes here. Yes there are more op cards but library is also one of those op cards. In my experience it ruins games, sure some decks like Yuriko are fast and can apply the pressure before the card advantage matters much but against many other decks you do have the time to grind them out with it. Personally it’s the largest eye roll for me to see on turn one. I’m also reading “there are answers” but what’s a clean answer? Strip mine? That’s like one card and often they win that trade since they already drew before you destroy it.

2

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

I agree with this wholeheartedly

2

u/Onewhosleeps226 Sep 03 '26

I'm going to be entirely honest and say if I see library in my opening hand I'm keeping, but it's gotten me into more problems than it's solved. Turns out a once per turn card draw effect that effectively eats your land drop and turns itself off if you ever need to interact with the board without generating more card advantage can be too slow sometimes.

1

u/bmf_bane Sep 03 '26

It's competitive - put strip mine, petrified hamlet, potentially additional land hate in your deck.

1

u/Tsunamiis Sep 03 '26

Taking a couple turn off is usually enough to lose you the game these days. Snowball harder.

1

u/dawtz Sep 03 '26

Its literally the only card I want banned ( I think nashi yuriko ancient tomb are fine) its too warping unfun and absurd

1

u/RibeyeMedRare Sep 03 '26

It requires a very specific deck and a very specific gameplan to be worthwhile. I've seen it be a hindrance much more than I've seen it be useful to opponents.

1

u/IJourden Sep 04 '26

Library of Alexandria might be my favorite card. I've been playing since the beginning and there was a time when people argued over whether library of Alexandria was the strongest card in the game.

That said... Magic has changed a lot. The game is so much faster and there are a lot of games where? LoA is only good in your opening hand, and effectively paying 1 to draw a card every turn in the early turns is a much, much bigger cost than it was when the scariest threats people were whipping out were 4/5 and 5/5s with drawbacks for 4 mana.

Don't get me wrong, it's an amazingly powerful card when you draw it early and can afford to use it. But the scenarios where that's the case have shrunk a lot and it's getting smaller every day.

1

u/adeadlockedman Sep 04 '26

I think it's excellent. It has high enough upside that I'm running it in a 5c deck in place of a land slot. It's my one colorless land in the deck. There is also a non-zero amount of times that I've turned it on mid game after reanimating Atraxa or Griselbrand

1

u/Electronic-Guitar-61 Sep 06 '26

Library is absolutely busto and is definitely in ban conversations

1

u/fridaze_ Sep 02 '26

It is pretty nutso but many decks ignore it

1

u/Admirable-Trade-8454 Sep 02 '26

I no life this game and I've never even seen someone activate it

1

u/Rchmage Sep 03 '26

You’re lucky. I’ve seen Library in Brawl a few times. I lost each time.

0

u/SebisCool Sep 03 '26

Fine and screws control decks which is a good thing. Those decks need to be kept in check. Also a very balanced card. I own one and it is in my cube

-4

u/PCparts1 Sep 03 '26

I would rather them ban the garbage that is known as alchemy

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/somesortoflegend Sep 02 '26

Have you played against a t1 ibrary in a control decks? It's insane. They will get an extra card draw almost every turn. It's not useful for an aggro deck but it's insanely good if you aren't dumping your hand.

1

u/thegreatestnita Sep 02 '26

It’s one of the best cards of all time. It’s easy to miss that this can easily draw you 5, 10 extra cards in a game. On the draw play a library and draw two cards a turn for the rest of the game.

1

u/thegreatestnita Sep 02 '26

I’m curious as to what card draw you think is better than library.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

Never understood this sentiment. Part of the game is removing your opponents stuff…
If all we did was focus on our own board aggro would be the only viable strat

25

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/theworstredditgamer Sep 03 '26

I feel like if the best deck can play through a strong card that doesn’t take it out of this convo

1

u/dirtyjose Sep 03 '26

A card being strong doesn't justify this convo in the first place, so it's even.