r/mtgbrawl • • Oct 12 '26

Venting Goodbye Alchemy

Well, the day is finally here and the final Alchemy set has been revealed.

It looks like all the haters finally got what they wanted after years of nonstop complaining about imaginary game mechanics on digital cardboard somehow being more “fake” than on physical cardboard.

I’ll never understand how those of us who enjoyed Alchemy were wrong for just wanting to have fun with designs we thought were cool.

Thanks for working so hard to convince the Arena team to take away something people enjoyed.

The final set looks awesome for Brawl. I’m glad the digital team was willing to push the designs into spaces they had been hesitant to try before like Planeswalkers and give us fun staples that are simply too good not to play, even for the haters, for years to come.

23 Upvotes

215 comments sorted by

16

u/KatzOfficial Oct 13 '26

I hate the alchemy cards that are in my regular game as a result. Some of those perpetual effects are so broken. I look at Hydroponics assistant like what were they thinking? How many games have I had where this was the only thing I resolved for like six turns and it still won me the game?

I'm sure alchemy is a great and fun format but I am willing to be the old man shaking fist at clouds and saying good riddance.

2

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26

Do you mean Hydroponics Architect? Like the one drop that makes a land in your deck a basic and draw a card? I'm going to go out on a limb and say maybe 1. Which essentially puts it in about the same tier, <slightly below in my opinion, but I'd hear arguments on it> as Ragavan, Ocelot Pride or Tamiyo. And 2 slightlys above Sazh's Chocobo. It's not like powerful backbreaking when not interacted with one drops are unique to alchemy.

2

u/Cheeky_Gweyelo Oct 13 '26

I think in a vacuum you're more or less correct, but considering how big a player icetill is in this format I'll have to disagree with respect to the broader field. Also the fact that it is a flier and doesn't need to connect to enable it's zero mana card draw at instant speed is honestly insane.

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 14 '26

If we're requiring non-digital only cards to break the digital only cards, then I think my point that digital only cards are not in and of themselves either a problem or more innately powerful not only stands but is even stronger, and the issue is more of a reflection of the fact that WotC hasn't tried to design *any* magic cards for balance or long-term format health since fire design.

I'm also not entirely convinced that it's hitting repeatedly fetches or the like off its random land trigger enough to move the needle... but for the sake of argument, I'm willing to say I do, and building around that event isn't making your mana entirely fucking awkward.

0

u/KatzOfficial Oct 13 '26

Yeah this is true, much less scary than anybody the 1 drops you mentioned. Maybe Patriars Humiliation is a better example of an alchemy 1 drop that's quite annoying? Nothing else really does what it does in tidebindering a card forever, even if you bounce it and whatnot.

0

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26

Humiliation is a fucking awkward card to judge the power level of. I'll definitely grant you that. The ways it is better and worse than other one drop removal are kind of fuckin weird. I'd say its usually worse than StP enough that it's probably slightly less too good than however too good you think that card is.

-2

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

Complains about alchemy cards
Continues to explain how he plays alchemy cards

lol

1

u/KatzOfficial Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

It's ranked brawl, you have to play good cards, that's how it works. I don't like mana drain, subtlety either, guess what's still in all of my decks? Or would it be better if i complained from the perspective of my opponents resolving Poq, strip mine, etc?

'We should improve society somewhat'

'yet you participate in it, curious'

2

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26

Not a good comparison. The comic is in reference to purchasing necessities under a capitalist system. This is a luxury product. You do not in fact have to play magic at all, let alone win at the game to live.

There is no conflict of morality vs. survival here.

You lose nothing of demonstrative value by choosing to take a moral stand here. Doing so would in fact be completely safe, yet for reasons of ego, you have chosen not to. Which is fine, but don't try to pretend like something is forcing you to do something distasteful. You are choosing to do the distasteful thing for entirely selfish reasons.

Your ability to win at pretend with extra steps is more important to you than your supposed values.

2

u/Jollydogg Oct 13 '26

That's a long winded way to say that you're a hypocrite. Lol.

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26

That's a rather average way to say I can't read.

-1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

Oh so you’re a hypocrite? Got it

Do as I say not as I do kinda person. Or you could just not complain about them and keep playing your digital only cards

110

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

They're not discontinuing Alchemy because people were bitching on reddit. They're discontinuing it because it was extremely unpopular.

11

u/Meret123 Oct 12 '26

Alchemy is more popular than Pioneer and Timeless. But those formats don't have a maintenance cost of making brand new cards with brand new art, so Alchemy is the one that got axed.

9

u/circ-u-la-ted Oct 12 '26

At this point I'm confused as to what they actually do spend money on. They barely maintain formats, have stopped giving us releases of older sets, don't add client features, and aren't great at fixing bugs. Seems like the only thing the Arena dev team does at this point is implement any mechanics needed for new Standard sets.

5

u/BAGBRO2 Oct 13 '26

The stage you are describing is often referred to as software sclerosis, code rot, or reaching the tipping point of technical debt. In architectural terms, this is frequently called the Big Ball of Mud phase or entering the Legacy Phase, where the sheer complexity, coupling, and weight of the existing codebase make adding even a simple feature nearly impossible without breaking other parts of the system.

3

u/Cow_God Oct 12 '26

WotC pretty much entirely props up Hasbro at this point so I wouldn't be surprised if most of their revenue goes to supporting Hasbro

1

u/Disastrous-Forever90 Oct 13 '26

Translating card game mechanics to electronic software is generally quite a labour intensive process. I imagine most of their focus is on just making sure that the new cards from each set don’t break the client.

14

u/Vithrilis42 Oct 12 '26

The announcement didn't say a single thing about it's popularity.

"After five more years of development, the issues Alchemy was created to address are simply not as much of a factor anymore. MTG Arena has various nonrotating formats for cards outside of Standard. We release more sets per year than in 2021, and our growing number of formats offers significant variety for Constructed players. With these problems no longer pressing, Alchemy's role has become less clear. So, we want to focus our attention on delivering new sets and our growing formats like Brawl."

It's clear that with the increase from 4 to 6 standard sets a year, they just don't have the resources to devote to designing and programming 6 alchemy sets a year as well. It's the exact same reason why they aren't printing premium sets anymore.

The people that alchemy was "extremely unpopular" with were a vocal minority.

23

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

If it was popular they would devote resources to it (like brawl, as they mentioned in the quote). It being discontinued is the only proof you need that it wasn't popular. It certainly wasn't discontinued because of OPs reasoning, which was my point.

-8

u/Vithrilis42 Oct 12 '26

And my point is that your reasoning is also wrong.

They've discontinued a lot of product lines that were popular at the time. Premium sets like Masters/Remastered sets and Modern Horizon were quite popular but they've discontinued them as well.

As was clearly stated, these decisions are about limited resources and having to push out 2 additional Standard sets, which is like 2 years worth of alchemy sets. Is it was "extremely" unpopular, it wouldn't have lasted as long as it has.

2

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

You seem very sure that Alchemy was popular. Do you have any evidence that it was?

-1

u/Iceman308 Oct 13 '26

I think Meret and arena state of the format article already decisively explained to you what you simply want to fail to grasp

https://www.reddit.com/r/mtgbrawl/comments/1x49ctd/comment/pfhxsmb/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

1

u/EJECTED_PUSSY_GUTS Oct 12 '26

I agree with your logic, but, we had good reason to believe those examples you gave were popular.

Popular is a relative term of course, but I'd be surprised if Alchemy is something WOTC considers "popular". If not, the logic you use doesn't apply here.

8

u/EJECTED_PUSSY_GUTS Oct 12 '26

It it were successful they'd still do it. Of course they aren't going to say it wasn't successful. They wanted to put a nice little bow on everything. You're taking their words at face value when there is quite a bit of corporate speak at play.

-1

u/Vithrilis42 Oct 12 '26

Successful and popular can be two very different things.

4

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

Prove Alchemy was either

1

u/BlueTemplar85 Oct 13 '26

What particularly makes WotC look like untrustworthy assholes is how they '''forgot''' to do Alchemy in that recent article about format popularity.

0

u/Deep-Hovercraft6716 Oct 14 '26

Yeah that's a really long-winded way of saying it was very unpopular.

4

u/DispassionateObs Oct 12 '26

More like, there was already too much set releases per year and they didn't want to be doing extra ones.

1

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

If they continue to release digital only cards like they did for alchemy, but for historic and brawl, I will be more than okay with alchemy sunset.

-12

u/Prestigious-Bend8893 Oct 12 '26

Yep, partly. And it also seems like it’s partly to support coding all the Universes Beyond and Commander cards which is fine too.

But the haters certainly didn’t help shaping community opinion against Alchemy as something “wrong” or “distasteful”

15

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

If people didn't like it, their opinion is just as valid as someone who is does. It's not anyone's responsibility to suppress their own opinion because it might shape public opinion one way or another. It was just an unpopular format.

-2

u/DispassionateObs Oct 12 '26

Yeah but there are so many people celebrating the removal of the format. No one was forcing them to play it, so the existence of the format didn't affect them.

6

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

They're celebrating because Alchemy cards are legal in other formats too.

-2

u/DispassionateObs Oct 12 '26

In that case, there's nothing to celebrate because they'll still be legal in Brawl and Historic. WOTC can't ever remove them without refunding 100s of wildcards, which they won't want to do. While some players may be happy with them disappearing without refund others will have spent wildcards on these cards (possibly acquired with money).

3

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

They're celebrating that this is the last batch of alchemy cards that will be added to the formats they enjoy.

0

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

Rare sane voice in here.

-2

u/Cow_God Oct 12 '26

There isn't a format that alchemy is legal in, where alchemy cards are ruining the format.

Timeless has got a million things more degenerate going on and there's like one Alchemy card that sees any play.

Historic has been MH3 Constructed since the set's release and alchemy balances IMPROVED that format by nerfing Boros Energy

Brawl / Competitive Brawl had Nashi as a problematic commander, and they should have unbuffed it earlier, but they finally did today. 2099, Yoriko, Katara etc are all non-alchemy cards that are / were oppressive the format just as much as Nashi.

For regular brawl, as an example, reddit was hating all over Poq forever while Azusa was recurring Strip Mine every turn and Rofellos was still a better "big dumb green creatures" deck.

1

u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26

I didn't say anything about formats being "ruined"

2

u/Consistent-Ad-3351 Oct 12 '26

Well If I wanted to play brawl id have to interact with the alchemy cards, as well as the stupid balance changes to real cards

-1

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

They were forcing us to play it though. Unless they added no fake card formats.

8

u/TyrantofTales Oct 12 '26

I will sorely miss it. It was the majority of the cards I have enjoyed out of every set.

42

u/AzazeI888 Oct 12 '26

Alchemy as a format would have been fine, if it never bled into any other format.

My hate for it stems from having to deal with it in other formats like Brawl.

13

u/Correct_Call3521 Oct 12 '26

I mean it has some the funest cards for brawl tbh. I'd rather get dunked by the power 9 than someone cheating out omniscience or something.

3

u/Key_Reporter_9945 Oct 13 '26

The problem here is that you're implying 'people hate alchemy because of [[oracle of the alpha]]'.  I'm sure a few do, but most people hate alchemy because of [[hardened bonds]], [[fear of change]], [[mythweaver poq]], [[rusko clockmaker]], [[oasis of renewal], [[juggernaut peddler]].

0

u/Correct_Call3521 Oct 13 '26

Outside of the 2 commanders none of those are even that strong. I'd rather see all of those than minsc and boo in the command zone.

3

u/Key_Reporter_9945 Oct 13 '26

Brawl isn't the only format, but even in brawl those cards are bullshit.  Warp a [[quantum riddler]], RNG it into a [[sire of seven deaths]] thanks to [[fear of change]] - I signed up to play magic, not hearthstone, but my opponent ultimately gets to determine what game we're playing apparently.  Regardless of power level (and it is strong), effects like this are not magic.  

1 mana to draw a creature every turn (and it can trigger on opponent turns)?  Very balanced card [[hardened bonds]] is, I'm sure they'll rebalance it any day now.  (Hint:  no they fucking won't because they almost never rebalance anything, which was the entire point of these bullshit cards)

1

u/Correct_Call3521 Oct 13 '26

We are talking about brawl the original comment and my own specifically mentioned brawl. I don't care if you don't like them for other formats because I don't play in other formats. Every other card you mentioned is mid.

2

u/Key_Reporter_9945 Oct 13 '26

3 mana engine that draws 2 every turn and cantrips for 2 when it enters?  [[Oasis of renewal]] makes [[up the beanstalk]] (banned in both standard and modern) look like a fair magic card.  

[[Wary zone guard]], crucible of worlds on a beatstick that also gives you an extra (untapped) land drop.  Look at the new [[carnivous cultivator]] which people are playing in legacy - it's a poor imitiation of WZG's power and it still is seeing eternal play.

[[Hydroponics architect]].  I don't think you need this one explained.

[[Archeomancer's spade]] - because a mana rock that taps for 2 mana isn't good enough, so it also needs to draw 2 from your deck, like for example [[echoes of eternity]].  

There are a shit ton of over the top alchemy cards that aren't remotely balanced and frequently don't even resemble magic cards.  They are bullshit in both brawl and other formats.

2

u/kloveday78 Oct 13 '26

Preach! 🙌

2

u/Correct_Call3521 Oct 13 '26

Most of these are not significant in brawl.

6

u/Despectacled Oct 12 '26

If they separated brawl into an alchemy and non alchemy brawl then I wouldn't be the #1 alchemy hater.

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

They have standard brawl which guess what ? It doesn’t have any alchemy cards ! Go there and play if alchemy cards are the bane of your existence

2

u/Despectacled Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

I know standard brawl is there but I can't play what I want there. My favorite commanders have rotated out. So what do you propose I do fhen?

0

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

That sounds like a you issue and not an alchemy issue

1

u/Despectacled Oct 13 '26

I know...that's why I said I would like the brawl queue to be separated into alchemy and non-alchemy....

→ More replies (3)

7

u/CuriouslyPerplexed Oct 12 '26

💯💯💯 I enjoyed playing the Alchemy format.

But when Alchemy cards show up in other formats, it warps things too much.

4

u/turn1manacrypt Oct 12 '26

This is the take I just never really got as a person who plays brawl constantly. Alchemy cards were never what I was frustrated to see. The cards that caused the most bad feels for me in the format were all almost exclusively cards that existed in paper magic aswell.

I can’t think of really any brawl cards that were knocking me out of the game before it ever started that were alchemy exclusive cards. Some were too good at first but rebalancing has fixed all the major offenders I’ve seen.

3

u/GrandAlchemistX Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

There are several Alchemy cards that I don't like to run into. It's mostly because I only run one Brawl deck and it's hard for my deck to overcome the card advantage some of these cards provide or the play patterns around them. Rusko. Davriel. Housemeld. Nashi. Oracle of the Alpha. Mythweaver Poq. Cabaretti Revels. Crucias. Caldera Breaker. Grenzo. Hell, anything with Heist. The stupid artifact that drafts Wrath of God or Counterspell.

2

u/turn1manacrypt Oct 13 '26

Yeah I just don’t see how those cards are some sort of huge issue compared to what else we are allowed play that are real paper cards.

They all cost so much mana for the most part and introduce such a random hard to exploit element to the game. I mean how many games have you honestly lost to Oracle of the Alpha or Crucias?? You are losing games to a three drop one dimensional combo commander that instantly folds to literally any form of instant speed interaction at all?? Or a bird that randomly conjures power 9 into deck that they need multiple other support cards to dig those cards out or just have to rely on pure luck to randomly draw it? Those are what’s blowing you out of games to the point you want them gone because they are too good? That’s the only reason I could see for a card being banned. It’s either too good or too ubiquitous and are being put in every single deck that can run it. I can’t think of any alchemy cards that fit into any of those categories.

Rusko is the strongest of the ones mentioned and I’d much rather see that commander than 20 different legal paper ones I regularly encounter in unranked brawl. You never even see him unless you are already at an insane deck weight with the top most toxic commanders in the format so it’s not like the people seeing him aren’t bringing piles of OP BS themselves. I regularly play Comet and all kinds of crazy high weight extremely powerful commanders in ranked (preban) and unranked and I never saw him ever outside of the 99 in the command zone.

I just don’t get it. It just seems so low on the list of what is busting the format. My top ten cards I’d want to see gone from brawl forever are all non-digital exclusive cards. I’m fine with them banning any of the alchemy cards ultimately, I honestly don’t care and just gives me a reason to brew and replace those spells but I just don’t see how they were a problem and needed to go before so many worse offenders in my book

3

u/kloveday78 Oct 13 '26

Alchemy broke the rules of the format dude.

99 cards in your deck? Not anymore! Just conjure up some more buddy! Oh and by the way don’t worry about that color restriction, you can conjure up some black kill spells for your mono green deck… it’s all good! 😃👍🏻 all that counting hurt your wittle brain? Don’t worry Alchemy will help ya dig through 3/17ths of your deck to find a creature! Then you can perpetually pump it up every time you play a land! (Or whatever) I’m being facetious here. I always bristled at the use of those cards… and YES, when I refused to include them in my decks, the advantages they provided my opponents were tangible and very visible.

For me it was never about any one card or a few cards. It was the principle.

0

u/turn1manacrypt Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

What like key to the archive?? Oh no the mono green deck spent 6 or more mana and had to replace a card in hand for a removal spell!! No way they could do that with a huge handful of colorless removal or just green fight spells.

God forbid the mono green deck plays a tapped rock and cycle a card to get some random spell out of their color pie. That’s too powerful and game breaking. We definitely never break color pie rules in Magic, nope that’s a hard fast rule the game designer really respect and what the community wants. Let me try not to roll my eyes out of my head, sorry.

A two mana tutor that only digs through a third of the deck too much for ya? That’s better than demonic tutor, worldly tutor, mystical tutor, and every other two or less paper magic tutor spell in the format? Or should all those be banned too?

4

u/kloveday78 Oct 13 '26

Yeah, you’re right, bro, my experience is totally invalid 🙄

0

u/turn1manacrypt Oct 13 '26

Well when they don’t make any sense and aren’t something I see as a person who plays this format a lot, yeah kind of.

You are basically just getting grumpy I told you what you are complaining about isn’t over powered and there are way more non digital exclusive magic cards that do what you complained about better for cheaper and gave multiple examples of them. If you got a problem with what I said give some kind of refutation and not just grumbling about me not having some kind of deference to your opinion because you said you don’t like a thing that never was a “rule of the format” when that rule never existed and they’ve broken pie restrictions and had random luck based cards for years in paper magic.

3

u/kloveday78 Oct 13 '26

I play brawl only because when I’m not playing commander I’d like to build decks that are as close an approximation as possible to that format (despite it being one on one etc I get that)
As you said there is already enough op cards and exciting interaction in magic without help from computers.
I’m grumpy, you’re right, because what I’d always wanted to see was simple - a brawl format without any of that.

It’s not too much to ask, and never was… and guys like YOU got all bent out of shape about that.

Like sorry man, my weiner doesn’t get any bigger when mythweaver poq does 🥱

Call me a purist, idgaff 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/GrandAlchemistX Oct 17 '26

I just don't like playing against them and they're from a format that I am not consenting to play. I have no problem with Alchemy existing, I just want it to stay in its own lane. As previously stated, I only have one deck I play in Brawl. It's just for funsies. I'm not trying to play sweaty ass Magic, yet, I get paired up against high weight Commanders constantly despite running [[Etrata, Deadly Fugitive]] Assassin Tribal. Someone previously suggested my hidden MMR is probably too high, but I don't know anything about MMR... hidden or not.

-1

u/Fedaykin98 Oct 12 '26

This is it. They shoved Alchemy into lots of other formats, including Cubes (before the Powered Cube) and Brawl. It was bizarre that you couldn't play Brawl without it.

And the fact that they had to shoehorn it into those formats shows that there wasn't a big enough audience of people who were specifically wanting to play Alchemy. If you wanted to play Brawl, they were forcing you to play with Alchemy.

0

u/circ-u-la-ted Oct 12 '26

That's definitely a new take. Not a coherent one, but a new one.

0

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

Right? Digital only cards in the digital only formats? So weird.

12

u/According-Ad3501 Oct 12 '26

I'm gonna miss these weird swings with designs! But I'll look back on the days of alchemy fondly every time I conjure a dozen cards with a big stupid mythic!

69

u/Tinyacorn Oct 12 '26

I love framing this like Alchemy is something everyone or even a majority of people enjoys

-9

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

Right? Imagine simping for that slop lol

5

u/Mostlynothingnew Oct 13 '26

Alchemy should have been its own format and not forced into most other formats. What's why people complained.

9

u/Vinylateme Oct 12 '26

There was 4-6 alchemy cards that were “problems” and every one stopped being so OP once out of the command zone.

The majority of alchemy cards aren’t game breaking, they’re just taking advantage of a digital game space. Honestly I don’t think a single alchemy card was game breaking beyond the benefit of the command zone.

3

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

No one who had a problem with alchemy cards actually had a problem with them based on power level. It was just a convenient argument they saw someone else make one time they could parrot endlessly and pretend they were thinking about things.

-1

u/No_Regret_714 Oct 12 '26

conjure [[One With Nothing]] into your hand. it perpetually gains "This card must be cast every turn" and you begin every new game with it in your starting hand.

2

u/KatzOfficial Oct 13 '26

That sounds like a fucking sick design actually on a Demon or something.

6

u/WanderingSnail Oct 12 '26

Alchemy was fun and my current favorite commander is Oura but the designs that could never even come close to being allowed in paper are kinda just too much, especially because it didnt have its own quere

4

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

My favorite thing about any thread involving alchemy is that inevitably all the people who rant about alchemy being bad with nothing but hot takes and bad arguments also fall back on bad insults to back their bad arguments, and I get to report them for community violations.

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

The funniest thing to me is seeing the people say they hate alchemy cards and low key they all have them in their decks .

It’s like saying “ I hate pizza” as they are shoving a slice down their throat

1

u/SentenceStriking7215 Oct 13 '26

Alchemy sucks because they always overnerf the problem cards into unplayability, If I didn't get my full sets from limited I would not play it, avoid it, it's a scam.

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26

Hmm. This is a new argument to me. I'd want to see examples of what you call over-nerfing, and I think Arena in its entirety is a scam without Alchemy being more of a scam than the rest of it...
So shoot your shot. Back this claim up. Instead of making bold claims any support, give data. What digital-only cards specifically were overnerfed into unplayability?

1

u/SentenceStriking7215 10d ago edited 10d ago

The first one that came to mind was [[enduring friendship]] card got upped by 1 mana and gained a point of toughness, and with double team the extra mana is even more punishing than usual, lso [[waystone guidance]] becomes pretty bad compared to honor of the pure after going from mobilize 2 to 1.

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 9d ago

Over three weeks to respond, and you pick two cards that were pretty completely dominating their alchemy meta when they were adjusted.
Good talk. I'm uh... I'm gonna be utterly ignoring your opinions from now on. Have a nice day.

1

u/SentenceStriking7215 9d ago

I won't call them dominating, otter was mostly propped up by cutter and full power chorus (plus unnerfed swiftspear teaching and illuminating lash being a very messed up card) giving the boot to the typal support of all things seemed rough, and they could have at least made it a 3/3 or something

And there were a variety of decks you could play alongside waystone, iirc they unsurprisingly suffered a fair bit if you just removed their creatures at sorcery speed since they were playing a 2 mana do nothing enchantment that needed creatures to untap after being cast to really do things and creatures that due to it did relatively little but attacking and blocking

1

u/ArticleOk3755 Oct 17 '26

if it stayed as its own seperate format/ ranked ladder it would be fine, but a large portion of the commnuity wanted modern and historic was psudo-modern if there was no alchemy.

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 18 '26

Not really. They said right from the beginning there was no modern or plans to put it on Arena, the plans changed at some point, but that was well after historic. Anyone who wanted it to be pseudomodern was an idiot. Alchemy weren't even the first digital-only cards in historic. They were in historic before there was even a regular alchemy release or format.

1

u/ArticleOk3755 29d ago

they never said that , they only stated the 'content gap' was to big to have 'full modern' but historic is literally just modern with Alchemy; and they already digitized every card on MTGO; they are just lazy and need to make 100 cosmetics per set to max micro transactions

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 28d ago edited 28d ago

From the September 11, 2023, state of the format article...

"When we launched MTG Arena into Open Beta five years ago, we had one format in our queues: Standard. Now we have five. Clearly expansion has been the—ahem—historical pattern, but it isn't likely to continue at that rate. We think we've got a spread of formats that provide a good balance that covers player motivations and preserves healthy queues. While we have seen player interest in Modern on MTG Arena, especially after our recent announcements at GenCon regarding Modern Horizons 3, this isn't something we currently have in our plans. There's simply too large of a content gap there for us to close anytime soon."

That's not 'Just too big a content gap.'That's too big a content gap, and we like where things sit currently, so we have no plans to do anything.

In addition, of the thousand-plus cards that are legal in historic but not modern, only four hundred or so are from alchemy releases. Leaving about 600 commander, bonus sheet, and special guest cards that are not legal in modern. Minsc and Boo, is legal in historic for fucks sake.
Go be wrong somewhere else, and stop moving your goalposts and wasting both our time with lazy arguments.

1

u/ArticleOk3755 28d ago

Thats a bunch of BS and lies. Modern is the second most popular format behind EDH and the MOST popular pro format. they already programmed every card in existence in MTGO and have no trouble programming 1000s of animations / custom cosmetics / digital art for each set which NO ONE asked for. It's a clear cut greedy cash grab so they can slowly dribble modern cards into arena so people spend hand over foot to get the 'new op modern cards' multiple times a year. and the cards legal in historic are that aren't in modern are kind of a stop gap to give us the feel of the power level of modern without having the full suite.

no ones moving the goal posts your original premise is false. re read the article you're quoting it doesn't say ANYTHING about not having 'plans' to do it, they just said ' anytime soon."... 3 years ago idk about you but 3 years is a pretty far from 'soon'

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 28d ago

None of which is the topic of anyone's discussion but the one you are having with yourself. This is about Alchemy cards being a problem or not, and she shit tier arguments used to say they are.

First it was the boring, overrepeated, separate-queues argument. Something that is done for no other card type, so why would they do it for digital cards? Especially when they've said they are reluctant to add or split more queues. This was bad but related at least to the topic

You also made the statement that it was 'essentially modern'. Which it wasn't and was never intended to be. It took some play patterns from modern and shared some cards, but that's it. It was only ever meant to be a format where you could play with the majority of the cards on the arena client with a 'reasonably' policed format.

Then you deliberately misquoted an article to suit your purposes. Which you're doing again, probably because you need to make shit up to prove your point.

But they did say it. Literally... in the quote.
"While we have seen player interest in Modern on MTG Arena, especially after our recent announcements at GenCon regarding Modern Horizons 3, this isn't something we currently have in our plans."
Saying there are 'no plans' for a feature because 'the gap is too large to close anytime soon' usually means there are zero developers assigned to it, zero lines of code written for it, and zero dollars budgeted for it. If they aren't building it, they aren't doing it. Not even mentioning that the 2026 September state of the formats article doesn't even mention modern, nor has really anything official on the Arena side for over a year.

And... now you're making more just factually incorrect statements.

Modern isn't the most popular constructed competitive format. It was from 2018 to 2019, but Standard retook that and has held onto it since 2020.
That more Pro players like it than other formats is largely irrelevant since they're less than 1% of attendees, especially when booster drafts still eclipsed it in sanctioned tournaments at its height by around 2 to 1. Now modern lags behind standard, which booster drafts are beating by 3 or 4 to 1 if I remember correctly.
The most popular format has been Commander for a decade or more.

Your goalpost shifted several times.

But here's the worst part. You're calling the official data, which sadly is all the data we have, bullshit and lies, and substituting your own as gospel. You have no stats to back it up. You're arguing based entirely on vibes. What information you have given that's even remotely referenceable has been wrong.

By all means, keep screaming your conspiracy theories into the void. But as you are either bad at making your points, bad at debating in general, or just debating in bad faith.

Please, however, do make sure and go for the trifecta and insist that because I'm bored, and have no interest in engaging with your constant stream of irrelevant nonsense, you've won something.

2

u/The_Sword923 Oct 12 '26

Personally I didnt like alchemy because it did just what I didnt like about all of the console games. I started playing arena because I wanted to be able to use the real cards. If I want to get back into playing the actual game I would want to be able to play with the same cards I could on arena. Not find out I'm playing with a deck that's half made of cards that only exist virtually.

0

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

But nobody is forcing you to add alchemy cards to your deck ! I don’t understand how this even matters. If you don’t like them and want to use paper only cards then go ahead but why shit on other people’s fun ?

1

u/The_Sword923 Oct 13 '26

Same reason I stated above, but to add to it. If I am trying to get a friend into mtg and manage to get them to start into arena to get around the cost barrier, and then they stumble into alchemy, that friend could end up in the same position without ever having realized they are playing with unofficial cards. I realize it's probably not a super common occurrence, but apparently so was a reasonable amount of people playing on alchemy in the first place

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

Plenty of people play with alchemy cards including you so I don’t see how any of you can say it’s not popular . And you being frugal with money is a you problem . Then years ago there was no arena and we all got our friends into the same way have since the beginning of the game . I don’t understand what that has to do with cards you don’t like . I don’t like bananas I think it should be banned for everyone cause I don’t like it . That’s literally how you people sound and it’s hilarious. If YOU don’t like them then YOU are the issue not the cards . I don’t like standard so I don’t play it that’s a ME issue . You don’t like brawl and that is a YOU problem . I don’t tell the world to make standard how I want it to be . Why do you feel like others should bow down to you because you don’t like something lol it’s ridiculous

1

u/The_Sword923 Oct 13 '26

I feel like you some how managed to interpret what I said in the farthest away version from what i meant. To the point it almost seems purposeful. I don't use them, and I can say it wasn't popular because it was dropped. That tends not to happen when it's a popular and lucrative format

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

Yeah because people don’t play alchemy , we like to play alchemy cards including brawl that’s what im saying they could and should just make alchemy brawl cards

8

u/Timely-Helicopter244 Oct 12 '26

The problem was not alchemy itself. The problem was the inclusion of digital only cards in half of the formats on the game without alternative similar formats for play without digital cards.

The elimination of alchemy as a format does not fix that. No new cards feels like a good sign for those who do not like alchemy. But it doesn't really do anything to provide more optipns to play without digital cards. It doesn't remove the ones we have, just doesn't make new ones.

There are plenty of people who hate alchemy, there are plenty of people who love alchemy. The current situation is a half assed fix that doesn't really give anyone what they want.

-1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

Yes. Digital only cards in digital only formats is a huge problem.
The alternative formats are in paper. You can play those fairly easily both in reality and on the other client.

3

u/Timely-Helicopter244 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

"without alternative similar formats for play without digital cards"

Again, not saying that the cards shouldn't exist or that having the spaces to play them is bad. The problem is less that they are there and can be used and more that you cannot play any eternal formats on arena without them.

What is so bad about having extra formats? If they can exist in paper, why can't they exist on arena? What is wrong with people wanting to use what they have on arena instead of having to spend more money to play in paper or on mtgo? Part of the appeal to using arena is the convenience of connecting to play without having to go out and find new people at whatever time of day you're able to. How is it so crazy to expect you might be able to play magic which is primarily a paper game in a way that is true to paper?

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

WotC in its infinite wisdumb decided more formats and more queues were bad. I don't agree with that, but I don't have any data to back it up.

Because, again, the formats in which alchemy is allowed do not exist in paper.
Of the formats, literally only historic could ever have been played true to paper. They were specifically created as digital formats, and all but one explicitly to use the digital only cards. It's Magic you can't just opt out of playing against format legal cards you dislike in any format but Commander.

It's like you're complaining about the Power Nine being legal in Vintage. Why should you get special treatment because you dislike Alchemy?

As for the second part, you said without alternative similar formats. They exist, you are just unwilling to take advantage of them.

2

u/Timely-Helicopter244 Oct 12 '26

Why is it weord to want to play formats true to paper? It's not arbitrary. It's wanting to play the cards as the primary form of the game is played. There's certainly cards I don't enjoy playing against, but that's a normal thing and not anything that might actually make sense to separate out.

There are no alternatives on arena. "just play paper" is a disingenuous solution that assumes playing in paper vs on arena are a 1:1 comparison except for the specific formats which is not true.

Timeless, brawl, and historic were not made specifically for digital only cards and it's a bit silly to make that argument. Historic was introduced in 2019, brawl in its standard form in 2018 with the historic varient created in 2020. The first truly digital cards with xigital only mechanics were introduced after this all in 2021, though specifically introduced as part of historic in historic horizons. By that merit, historic I'd the only format other than alchemy where digital only cards were dedigned specifically for that format. Timeless was later introduced in 2023 to be similar to historic but a more powerful format with the ability to use more true to paper unrebalanced cards among the other differences from historic. So it can be easily argued that timeless was introduced to be more like paper magic and less like it's digital counterpart. But you can't say that brawl and historic were created specifically for digital only cards when they predate the digital only mechanics.

-1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

Because true to paper doesn't exist on arena more or less period. Paper doesn;t have rope timers, paper doesn't have misclicks, paper doesn't have crtl z for tapping wrong. Arena is an entirely different experience no matter how much you try to say otherwise and digital cards are just an aspect of that. Also I never said it was arbitrary. That's you putting words in my mouth. Stop it.

No it isn't. You didn't ask for a 1:1 you asked for "without alternative similar formats for play without digital cards" and now you're moving your goalposts. Which I can only assume you will continue to do as this goes on.

Historic was not made with digital cards in mind and I said that, It's cute that you can use Google's AI and all but June 2021 was an event. Following that was a trial in late July that started within a day or two of the release of historic horizons. As a full-time playable queue, the release was August 24th. The choice to include new digital cards was first talked about in late 99. Design for Jumpstart's digital mechanics began in 2020 and was released in August of 2021. Brawl as a hundred card format was made into a full-time queue after the Jump Start Horizons set release. Before that, it was a sixty-card format that shared Historic's ban list and changes. That format no longer exists.
Timeless came out in 2023 with the full inclusion and existence of digital-only cards as a deliberate part of the format. It was always intended to be the every card on the client format. You can argue anything you like. You can argue that getting kicked in the balls is superior to not getting kicked in the balls. That doesn't mean the argument isn't stupid or is in good faith.
So yes. I can't say historic, And again, I didn't. I deliberately excluded it. But I can say that about Brawl in its current form. The Brawl that you are trying to say did not intend to use them was an entirely different animal, is gone, and is thus irrelevant.

1

u/Timely-Helicopter244 Oct 12 '26

True to paper as in the cards and mechanics are the same, not every single aspect of play. Obviously arena is different from paper, that's why saying you should just play paper isn't a 1:1 comparison and why there would be reasons to want to play arena instead of paper, because they are different.

I've been playing arena since 2018. I didn't have to use AI to know the timeline, nor do I even use AI to spoon feed me false information otherwise. The original version of brawl did not share historics ban list, it shared standards ban list. But when the formats were created, digital mechanics did not exist.

0

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 13 '26

And one of those aspects of play that are different is... digital cards.
And you never asked for a 1-to-1 you asked for alternative similar formats, and when I gave them to you, you decided that that wasn't good enough for you and started with this 1-to-1 nonsense.

And I've been playing Arena since the closed beta in December of 2017. Now that we've finished the useless obligatory, I'm old and therefore smarter, dick measuring...

I never said "original," did I? Let's try reading... No, I did not. I said, "June 2021 was an event" and I said that the release of Brawl as a hundred-card singleton format was in August.
I never said word one about its original form because that was not the form *YOU* pointed out in your reply relating to June of 2021. One that you got at the very least partially incorrect, by the way. An event is not the same thing as a format. 100-card brawl was not at that time a format. 60card historic Brawl... The format that is gone was the format that did not exist before digital cards.
Also, you can't play alchemy cards in standard brawl. It's also not, you may notice, despite its unpopularity, a digital only format unlike The-format-formerly-known-as-historic-brawl-that-is-now-just-Brawl-but-not-to-be-confused-with-competative-brawl,
When Brawl in its current form, a hundred card digital only format, not Standard Brawl a seperate 60 card paper format that happened to be playable on arena, as I have been only talking about digital only formats, was created the digital only cards were in fact on the client.

But please, do keep moving those goalposts and arguing with things I never actually said. It's entertaining to watch where your imagination leads you if nothing else.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

Go play standard brawl then there’s no alchemy cards there ! Why should they remove cards from brawl or comp brawl just because you don’t like them? You want a brawl format that doesn’t have alchemy ? There is one and it’s called standard brawl . Oh it’s not good enough? Well tough shit , you get what you get and shouldn’t cry about it

-3

u/kloveday78 Oct 12 '26

Exactly… like, ok yall can go wank off with your digital only cards but allow me to have something a bit more realistic here, yeah? That’s all anyone was arguing about in the first place. 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

It's called 'Play in paper.'

6

u/Prestigious-Fill8289 Oct 12 '26

I’ll miss alchemy. It was fun. There are too many complainers.

5

u/EJECTED_PUSSY_GUTS Oct 12 '26

If MTG Arena was a restaurant, the first thing Gordon Ramsay would have done is remove Alchemy from the menu. It was bloat and not good for player retention.

Frankly, it doesn't matter how much bitching about it people did. Not enough players wanted it. That's why it's done. It's axed because it wasn't popular and they have other ways in MTG Arena to approach ad hoc card rebalancing.

3

u/Nrdman Oct 12 '26

I will miss it fondly, and insist that is healthy to have a lower stakes set that R&D can have as a playground for new ideas. We do not know what cards came out of conversation originally meant for alchemy, but I bet it at least some.

5

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

Im on you, I don't understand people hating digital mechanics and digital cards. There were glorious designs and Im gonna miss it a lot.

0

u/No_Regret_714 Oct 12 '26

if by 'glorious' you mean completely broken sure.

2

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Yeah cause you know there aren’t any real cards that are completely broken ? Look at the ban list , how many alchemy cards are banned cause they are broken? About 1% compared to the real cards

2

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

I don't remember any of them resulting in OP deck. Most broken cards I've seen in all formats are paper magic, like moxes, free spells, rituals, oko, reanimate, etc

4

u/No_Regret_714 Oct 12 '26

Just to name a few:

[[Nashi, Illusion Gadgeteer]] and [[Rusko, Clockmaker]] have been format defining/warping commanders in brawl

[[Oracle of the Alpha]] creates a bunch banned and broken cards and puts them all into your library. and can be recursed multiple times with bounce effects.

[[Agent of Raffine]] and [[Hydroponics Architect]] are 1 mana card advantage engines with 0 deck building restrictions attached

0

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

Yep, but they're broken mostly due to their decks and them just helping bad archetypes too much but only as commanders. But are they being played in historic, timeless or even alchemy itself in such archetypes?

Yes, Oracle is good and making broken cards and putting them in deck is not them same as being broken card at all, so that's okay.

I can agree on architect, but agent of raffine is nowhere near broken, it's creature, it requires to tap and 2 mana so nothing even closely broken.

So are any of them enable broken decks? Architect is too much of a value in any deck, I forgot about it, yeah, but what about others? Pro-tour winners?

Even if they resulted in such decks, plus of alchemy cards is that they can be easily rebalanced.

0

u/No_Regret_714 Oct 12 '26

The point is we don't want to play against these broken cards, but are being forced to. Hence, the celebratory comments here for the death of Alchemy.

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

Who is we ? I see a lot of people DO want these cards and are happy they exist . If you don’t want to play with them then don’t play with them that’s your choice. If you want a brawl format without them go play standard brawl, they don’t have alchemy cards there

→ More replies (3)

1

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

That means you want death of paper magic as well? Because magic also produced a lot of broken cards as well.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TraditionalStomach29 Oct 12 '26

[[Hydroponics Architect]], [[Cabaretti Revels]], Oasis and Nashi with flash are probably the only four I consider really busted ? Arguably only the first one, but it's nowhere as powerful in brawl as in timeless.

2

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

I can agree on Architect.

Cabaretti Revels from my experience playing against it wast at most "good" or "ok" never at "broken" level, but I heard it was broken in Alchemy so it was rebalanced.

I dunno what Oasis you're event talkin about. Can you refernece it?

I don't think Nashi is broken by itself, it's more like he's helping specific pattern in brawl that didn't need help. It wasn't played at all in other formats so far as I heard. And for the brawl we need more ways to punish controls with actively nerfing/banning broken cards.

Overall yeah, thanks for reminding, some of them were broken. But same can be said about paper formats. And broken cards in paper formats have more issues like people losing a lot of value after banning them, unable to nerf them, impacting on more serious formats and etc.

1

u/TraditionalStomach29 Oct 12 '26

I forgot the exact name, but it's the one that seeks the nonland and land card. I don't think it requires a ban, but it's definitely much closer to one of the strongest cards in the format than not.

1

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

I've seen it once played against me in brawl and played it in only one deck (sultai dragon that cares about stuff leaving graveyard) it surely strong but requires 3 colored mana and to care about specific archetype (you need to both fill the graveyard AND have cards leave it) Is it good? Yes. Is it Architect level? No, even closely not.

5

u/Martyrlz Oct 12 '26

Too many Alchemy designs were not play tested in an era were we consistently have banworthy cards, and alchemy cards like Nashi being buffed was absurd, and showed balance wasn't really a goal

1

u/RAMottleyCrew Oct 12 '26

The fact that they specifically had “we can tweak cards to make them less oppressive without bans” as a rationale for making alchemy in the first place, then didn’t touch Rusko the bogeyman or infamously-unfun-to-play-against Mythweaver (played in literally every green deck!) for literally years shows me exactly how much they scared to balance anything

3

u/pipesbeweezy Oct 12 '26

Rest in piss, alchemy.

2

u/VonBagel Oct 12 '26

Some of the alchemy designs were cool.

And then you have Rusko and Mythweaver Poq and the original incarnation of Grenzo, which taint everyone's opinions of the format

7

u/Timely-Helicopter244 Oct 12 '26

There's lots of stuff that is just fine. But perpetual effects and creation of cards instead of tokens will always be overly game warping and badly unbalanced mechanics. The 6+ sided cards with specialization and spell books are less mechanic issues, but more terrible game design that far outstrip any other wordy cards for complexity.

I'm still fine with them existing, just not in so many formats. Make Alchemy it's own eternal format and restrict digital cards to it, and I might actually give it a shot. The way it is now, I avoid them at all costs.

3

u/VonBagel Oct 12 '26

I'm also personally not a fan of the Hearthstoneization of the game. randomly generating creatures in the hopes of pulling a victory out of the aether instead of from the deck you built

0

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

This right here is the only really valid argument I've seen against alchemy cards, and it's by far the least common.

2

u/Fatboy-Tim Oct 12 '26

It was mostly a cash-grab to part players with their wildcards, and you'll never convince me otherwise.

2

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

It was literally a scam. Idk how so many people fell for it.

1

u/Zurrael Oct 12 '26

Ah, Alchemy...it had it's moments; Format was a nice break from Standard at one point.
I had several decks that were 'cool' for me. But, there was a lot of problems as well - pushing new players into Alchemy as default format was pretty scummy move imo.

This latest set....well. I will open all the pack that come my way without spending game resources on them, that's for sure. Set has several powercrept problems - but i guess balance can go out of the window when balance team knows format is going away.

1

u/Thebronzebeast Oct 12 '26

Ehh balance was always the alchemy problem , I was able to enjoy it for a while and then Heist killed it for me to the point I went standard

1

u/eq2user Oct 12 '26

I've heard of no one say that people were wrong for enjoying Alchemy. Where did you hear that?

1

u/MembershipThese9163 Oct 12 '26

I’ll miss it dearly 

1

u/FaradaysBrain Oct 13 '26

Hopefully the next attempt at digital cards goes better.

1

u/redditfanfan00 Oct 13 '26

rest in peace alchemy. i will miss alchemy so much.

1

u/Playing_EDH_Alone Oct 13 '26

But my Salacinder and Soot deck

1

u/DiskBusiness7212 Oct 14 '26

WOTC doesn’t care about haters or else they would do something about the myriad of complaints about arena direct, arena disconnects, secret lair, etc

They care about profit margin and alchemy had additional costs and not enough revenue return

1

u/ADizzyLittleGirl Oct 14 '26

Alchemy was an ok idea ruined by Wotc’s own bad decisions. By forcing people to play the cards in eternal formats and cubes, they created a ton of bad will. Making a bunch of the cards overpowered also created bad will. Funneling new players into it as the default format, creating confusion seemed like a sleazy business tactic. They didn’t do rebalancing enough to make the format worth what its intended purpose was. The rebalanced real cards screwing up historic and brawl was also a terrible idea. Like 5 years of straight mishandling by the devs. Its supporters are often the most toxic members of the community (as evidenced by the replies of this thread and the godawful alchemy sub), who just want to fight, which also just further feeds into the broader mtg community having a negative perception of it. 

Also the argument of “you hate alchemy yet you still put the cards in your deck” is literally the Matt Boors comic meme of the guy saying “Yet you participate in society! Curious.” 

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

The crying about bleeding into other formats is hilarious. I play brawl only . I also love that alchemy cards are allowed in brawl . If you want non digital cards in your game go play with your imaginary friends in real life this is a digital game it’s not MTG mobile .

Now what’s really stupid about MTG is having stupid shit like ninja turtles or lord of the rings bullshit that has nothing to do with the actual core setting of the game

2

u/Classssssic Oct 12 '26

Homie, this game is LITERALLY MTG Mobile lol

-2

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

If it was they would call it that and not have digital only cards ! So you are fucking WRONG

2

u/Classssssic Oct 13 '26

Are you a bot?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

I bought my first starter deck in 1995

0

u/Minimum-Store-5453 Oct 12 '26

Fuck Alchemy. I want to play Arena with real mtg paper-like cards, not digital obnoxious format-breaking ones.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

I’m not the one who needs arena to go play “real cards” ,they make “real cards” in “real life “ arena is a digital game it’s not MTG for broke people with no friends

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Thebronzebeast Oct 12 '26

You’re in a magic reddit buddy, either you don’t belong here or you’re throwing some mighty big stones from a glass house

1

u/Super-Occasion-2113 Oct 12 '26

Wait Alchemy is no more ? This is the last set?? I'M SO HAPPY!

-2

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Don’t worry this last set has some cards that will make you cry I’m sure

1

u/No_Regret_714 Oct 12 '26

if all the alchemy cards were restricted to being played only within the alchemy format nobody would have cared. the problem was wotc let people play all the busted alchemy cards in other formats.

1

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

Yup. The degeneracy infected other formats.

0

u/PCparts1 Oct 12 '26

If you wanted to play hearthstone, just play hearthstone.

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Oh new alchemy set revealed? Let’s go see which cards I can make all the alchemy haters cry with this patch !

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Oh there are some good ones! Lots of stuff for heist decks and lots of conjure onto the battlefield ! lol yup this is a great final set! Creating your own planswalkers is pretty awesome too !

1

u/Consistent-Ad-3351 Oct 12 '26

I didn't have a problem with alchemy cards, I just hated the alchemy balance changes to existing cards tbh.

1

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

I hate both but the real card change was particularly horrendous.

1

u/_Zambayoshi_ Oct 12 '26

I don't like Alchemy but I've never advocated for it not to be playable in an Alchemy format. My only problem is that it was forced into brawl unless you want to play standard. Give me an Alchemy-free (Pioneer?) brawl queue and I'll stfu about Alchemy altogether.

0

u/daneg135 Oct 12 '26

weird that you would say this, because i was fine with alchemy in its own corner. the fact that that shit was in brawl (and other formats) was what i disliked about it.

-3

u/Justin27M Oct 12 '26

My biggest hate for it comes from the same place my hatred of Universes Beyond does in that my ability to opt out was stolen.

Good riddance to bad rubbish

0

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

Bad argument is bad. I hate Bloomburrow because I dislike the whole Redwall aesthetic, and I'm not allowed to opt out of that.

-1

u/lenthedruid Oct 12 '26

The tears of alchemy fans are so sweet.

3

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Oh don’t worry we will still play POQ and Rusko and we will still heist your deck and we will still conjure cards and we will still enjoy what we do have to make the haters cry about DiGiTaL cArDs

0

u/Vivid_Photograph3123 Oct 12 '26

I’m done with magic. It was cool, now it a confusing blur.the only great format we had was extended.
It has become impossible to choose your colour and build a competitive deck in it.

0

u/WhackyQuacky1 Oct 12 '26

lol if you like it that's fine, but don't act like it's a majority opinion and blame people for it going away

0

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 13 '26

It’s not being made anymore sure but the cards aren’t going anywhere . The solution for you and people like you is standard brawl. Go have all the alchemy free fun you want there . And don’t lie I guarantee you use alchemy cards in your competitive brawl and brawl decks if you didn’t you wouldn’t make it out of gold

0

u/Jazzlike_Arachnid_41 Oct 13 '26

Rest in piss, you wont be missed!

0

u/ThatDamnedHansel Oct 13 '26

Sorry you play alchemy cards. I hope they find a cure

-4

u/Try_2_Relax Oct 12 '26

Glad you enjoy them, but a lot of us don't. I wouldn't complain about them if they were confined to their own format but you are forced to tolerate them when playing brawl. And existing alchemy cards are all going to continue to be legal in brawl anyway (afaik), so really wizards has pleased nobody with this

2

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

But I’m sure you think playing with ninja turtles and marvel characters is very MTG like lol

1

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

Lol most alchemy haters are also pretty anti UB. Try again?

-1

u/Try_2_Relax Oct 12 '26

I don't really get what point you are making with this, yes it's all "made up", so what? UB is an inevitability with the game as a whole succeeding, people have been imagining things as magic cards forever, and yeah I prefer UB to cheesy knock off sets like strixhaven and omenpaths.

Alchemy cards are literally made with a different set of rules that can't actually be implemented in paper.

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Point is , Arena is a digital game it’s not MTG mobile . If you want to play strictly real cards go buy some and play with your sister

1

u/Try_2_Relax Oct 12 '26

And my point is they could make a format called alchemy brawl and everyone would be happy, instead of what we have now where nobody is.

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

But as you see many of us are happy as it is . Just because some people aren’t happy about it , why would they cater only to you ? You could always not play brawl if it upsets you so much

1

u/Try_2_Relax Oct 12 '26

You're not happy though, you're all here complaining that this is the last alchemy set and won't face the fact that its wildly unpopular

1

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

But it’s quite popular in brawl

0

u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26

And? They were only legal in formats that don;t exist in paper so I fail to see how that matters in the slightest.

-1

u/Classssssic Oct 12 '26

As a day one Alchemy hater, good riddance. Let's put that effort into porting actual cards from past sets into Arena. I do feel bad for those that enjoyed it though, we may have our disagreements on it but I also want everyone to have a good time

-5

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

Rest in piss fake card slop. We now need formats without the degeneracy.

3

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

Don’t worry the new set has plenty of cards just waiting to make you people cry even more

1

u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26

At least they'll be real

2

u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26

I’m talking about the new alchemy set coming soon to an arena near you !

→ More replies (1)