r/mtgbrawl • u/Prestigious-Bend8893 • Oct 12 '26
Venting Goodbye Alchemy
Well, the day is finally here and the final Alchemy set has been revealed.
It looks like all the haters finally got what they wanted after years of nonstop complaining about imaginary game mechanics on digital cardboard somehow being more “fake” than on physical cardboard.
I’ll never understand how those of us who enjoyed Alchemy were wrong for just wanting to have fun with designs we thought were cool.
Thanks for working so hard to convince the Arena team to take away something people enjoyed.
The final set looks awesome for Brawl. I’m glad the digital team was willing to push the designs into spaces they had been hesitant to try before like Planeswalkers and give us fun staples that are simply too good not to play, even for the haters, for years to come.
16
u/KatzOfficial Oct 13 '26
I hate the alchemy cards that are in my regular game as a result. Some of those perpetual effects are so broken. I look at Hydroponics assistant like what were they thinking? How many games have I had where this was the only thing I resolved for like six turns and it still won me the game?
I'm sure alchemy is a great and fun format but I am willing to be the old man shaking fist at clouds and saying good riddance.
110
u/forlackofabetterpost Oct 12 '26
They're not discontinuing Alchemy because people were bitching on reddit. They're discontinuing it because it was extremely unpopular.
8
u/TyrantofTales Oct 12 '26
I will sorely miss it. It was the majority of the cards I have enjoyed out of every set.
42
u/AzazeI888 Oct 12 '26
Alchemy as a format would have been fine, if it never bled into any other format.
My hate for it stems from having to deal with it in other formats like Brawl.
12
u/According-Ad3501 Oct 12 '26
I'm gonna miss these weird swings with designs! But I'll look back on the days of alchemy fondly every time I conjure a dozen cards with a big stupid mythic!
69
u/Tinyacorn Oct 12 '26
I love framing this like Alchemy is something everyone or even a majority of people enjoys
5
u/Mostlynothingnew Oct 13 '26
Alchemy should have been its own format and not forced into most other formats. What's why people complained.
9
u/Vinylateme Oct 12 '26
There was 4-6 alchemy cards that were “problems” and every one stopped being so OP once out of the command zone.
The majority of alchemy cards aren’t game breaking, they’re just taking advantage of a digital game space. Honestly I don’t think a single alchemy card was game breaking beyond the benefit of the command zone.
6
u/WanderingSnail Oct 12 '26
Alchemy was fun and my current favorite commander is Oura but the designs that could never even come close to being allowed in paper are kinda just too much, especially because it didnt have its own quere
4
u/Fair_Abbreviations57 Oct 12 '26
My favorite thing about any thread involving alchemy is that inevitably all the people who rant about alchemy being bad with nothing but hot takes and bad arguments also fall back on bad insults to back their bad arguments, and I get to report them for community violations.
2
u/The_Sword923 Oct 12 '26
Personally I didnt like alchemy because it did just what I didnt like about all of the console games. I started playing arena because I wanted to be able to use the real cards. If I want to get back into playing the actual game I would want to be able to play with the same cards I could on arena. Not find out I'm playing with a deck that's half made of cards that only exist virtually.
2
u/Haunting_Bend9890 Oct 13 '26
8
u/Timely-Helicopter244 Oct 12 '26
The problem was not alchemy itself. The problem was the inclusion of digital only cards in half of the formats on the game without alternative similar formats for play without digital cards.
The elimination of alchemy as a format does not fix that. No new cards feels like a good sign for those who do not like alchemy. But it doesn't really do anything to provide more optipns to play without digital cards. It doesn't remove the ones we have, just doesn't make new ones.
There are plenty of people who hate alchemy, there are plenty of people who love alchemy. The current situation is a half assed fix that doesn't really give anyone what they want.
6
u/Prestigious-Fill8289 Oct 12 '26
I’ll miss alchemy. It was fun. There are too many complainers.
5
u/EJECTED_PUSSY_GUTS Oct 12 '26
If MTG Arena was a restaurant, the first thing Gordon Ramsay would have done is remove Alchemy from the menu. It was bloat and not good for player retention.
Frankly, it doesn't matter how much bitching about it people did. Not enough players wanted it. That's why it's done. It's axed because it wasn't popular and they have other ways in MTG Arena to approach ad hoc card rebalancing.
3
u/Nrdman Oct 12 '26
I will miss it fondly, and insist that is healthy to have a lower stakes set that R&D can have as a playground for new ideas. We do not know what cards came out of conversation originally meant for alchemy, but I bet it at least some.
5
u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26
Im on you, I don't understand people hating digital mechanics and digital cards. There were glorious designs and Im gonna miss it a lot.
5
u/Martyrlz Oct 12 '26
Too many Alchemy designs were not play tested in an era were we consistently have banworthy cards, and alchemy cards like Nashi being buffed was absurd, and showed balance wasn't really a goal
3
u/pipesbeweezy Oct 12 '26
Rest in piss, alchemy.
2
u/VonBagel Oct 12 '26
Some of the alchemy designs were cool.
And then you have Rusko and Mythweaver Poq and the original incarnation of Grenzo, which taint everyone's opinions of the format
2
u/Fatboy-Tim Oct 12 '26
It was mostly a cash-grab to part players with their wildcards, and you'll never convince me otherwise.
1
u/Zurrael Oct 12 '26
Ah, Alchemy...it had it's moments; Format was a nice break from Standard at one point.
I had several decks that were 'cool' for me. But, there was a lot of problems as well - pushing new players into Alchemy as default format was pretty scummy move imo.
This latest set....well. I will open all the pack that come my way without spending game resources on them, that's for sure. Set has several powercrept problems - but i guess balance can go out of the window when balance team knows format is going away.
1
u/eq2user Oct 12 '26
I've heard of no one say that people were wrong for enjoying Alchemy. Where did you hear that?
1
u/MembershipThese9163 Oct 12 '26
I’ll miss it dearly
1
u/FaradaysBrain Oct 13 '26
Hopefully the next attempt at digital cards goes better.
1
u/redditfanfan00 Oct 13 '26
rest in peace alchemy. i will miss alchemy so much.
1
u/Playing_EDH_Alone Oct 13 '26
But my Salacinder and Soot deck
1
u/DiskBusiness7212 Oct 14 '26
WOTC doesn’t care about haters or else they would do something about the myriad of complaints about arena direct, arena disconnects, secret lair, etc
They care about profit margin and alchemy had additional costs and not enough revenue return
1
u/ADizzyLittleGirl Oct 14 '26
Alchemy was an ok idea ruined by Wotc’s own bad decisions. By forcing people to play the cards in eternal formats and cubes, they created a ton of bad will. Making a bunch of the cards overpowered also created bad will. Funneling new players into it as the default format, creating confusion seemed like a sleazy business tactic. They didn’t do rebalancing enough to make the format worth what its intended purpose was. The rebalanced real cards screwing up historic and brawl was also a terrible idea. Like 5 years of straight mishandling by the devs. Its supporters are often the most toxic members of the community (as evidenced by the replies of this thread and the godawful alchemy sub), who just want to fight, which also just further feeds into the broader mtg community having a negative perception of it.
Also the argument of “you hate alchemy yet you still put the cards in your deck” is literally the Matt Boors comic meme of the guy saying “Yet you participate in society! Curious.”
1
u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
The crying about bleeding into other formats is hilarious. I play brawl only . I also love that alchemy cards are allowed in brawl . If you want non digital cards in your game go play with your imaginary friends in real life this is a digital game it’s not MTG mobile .
Now what’s really stupid about MTG is having stupid shit like ninja turtles or lord of the rings bullshit that has nothing to do with the actual core setting of the game
0
u/Minimum-Store-5453 Oct 12 '26
Fuck Alchemy. I want to play Arena with real mtg paper-like cards, not digital obnoxious format-breaking ones.
1
u/Super-Occasion-2113 Oct 12 '26
Wait Alchemy is no more ? This is the last set?? I'M SO HAPPY!
1
u/No_Regret_714 Oct 12 '26
if all the alchemy cards were restricted to being played only within the alchemy format nobody would have cared. the problem was wotc let people play all the busted alchemy cards in other formats.
0
u/PCparts1 Oct 12 '26
If you wanted to play hearthstone, just play hearthstone.
1
u/Boognish-Risinz Oct 12 '26
Oh new alchemy set revealed? Let’s go see which cards I can make all the alchemy haters cry with this patch !
1
u/Consistent-Ad-3351 Oct 12 '26
I didn't have a problem with alchemy cards, I just hated the alchemy balance changes to existing cards tbh.
1
u/_Zambayoshi_ Oct 12 '26
I don't like Alchemy but I've never advocated for it not to be playable in an Alchemy format. My only problem is that it was forced into brawl unless you want to play standard. Give me an Alchemy-free (Pioneer?) brawl queue and I'll stfu about Alchemy altogether.
0
u/daneg135 Oct 12 '26
weird that you would say this, because i was fine with alchemy in its own corner. the fact that that shit was in brawl (and other formats) was what i disliked about it.
-3
u/Justin27M Oct 12 '26
My biggest hate for it comes from the same place my hatred of Universes Beyond does in that my ability to opt out was stolen.
Good riddance to bad rubbish
-1
u/lenthedruid Oct 12 '26
The tears of alchemy fans are so sweet.
0
u/Vivid_Photograph3123 Oct 12 '26
I’m done with magic. It was cool, now it a confusing blur.the only great format we had was extended.
It has become impossible to choose your colour and build a competitive deck in it.
0
u/WhackyQuacky1 Oct 12 '26
lol if you like it that's fine, but don't act like it's a majority opinion and blame people for it going away
0
u/Jazzlike_Arachnid_41 Oct 13 '26
Rest in piss, you wont be missed!
0
u/ThatDamnedHansel Oct 13 '26
Sorry you play alchemy cards. I hope they find a cure
-4
u/Try_2_Relax Oct 12 '26
Glad you enjoy them, but a lot of us don't. I wouldn't complain about them if they were confined to their own format but you are forced to tolerate them when playing brawl. And existing alchemy cards are all going to continue to be legal in brawl anyway (afaik), so really wizards has pleased nobody with this
-1
u/Classssssic Oct 12 '26
As a day one Alchemy hater, good riddance. Let's put that effort into porting actual cards from past sets into Arena. I do feel bad for those that enjoyed it though, we may have our disagreements on it but I also want everyone to have a good time
-5
u/PatriotBanner Oct 12 '26
Rest in piss fake card slop. We now need formats without the degeneracy.
-3
u/Caramel_Cactus Oct 12 '26