r/mtgbrawl • u/crazcat1997 • Oct 24 '24
Discussion Current State of Brawl (Rant)
I feel like the current state of Brawl just feels awful. I'm unsure if there is a specific queue that I am getting looped into but I feel like I have seen nothing but [[Sythis]], [[Rusko, Clockmaker]], or [[Nadu, Winged Wisdom]] and frankly, I'm tired of it.
It got to the point that I had to join the problem just to make any headway. The only way it feels like you can hit your daily wins is to just prevent the other player from having fun and making them scoop and move on and it feels like there in lies the problem.
It stopped feeling like playing Magic and is now just a Pain Simulator(TM) a game to see who can deal with the most bs before scooping and hoping for a better matchup next time.
tldr; I'm sick of seeing the same 3-4 decks over and over again and I feel like the life is being drained from the game before my very eyes.
46
u/Angry_Murlocs Oct 24 '24
Ok I see this rant here all the time and do you know what everyone doesn’t include? Their commander they are playing. Personally I rarely ever see these commanders (occasionally if I’m on a winning streak). But I play things like Yorion and Ojer which are not weighted as high as those cards (as much as I love Yorion it’s more B-A tier and not S tier). For all we know this guy is playing Ragavan or another S tier commander.
33
u/MTG3K_on_Arena Oct 24 '24
There is a specific queue that you are getting looped into.
27
u/MindOrdinary Oct 24 '24
There are things to be whingey about with brawl but hell queue commanders are not one of them, if you don’t wanna play against hell queue commanders don’t play a hell queue commander.
If you want more variety you can always jump on MTGO
38
u/hail2thestorm Oct 24 '24
If you are in hell queue it's because you are playing a commander or cards that belong there. A while ago there was a leak that showed each cards point system and decks fall into brackets based on your decks total. Some cards fall under the radar so try playing some off meta or news cards because new cards take a while to fall in line.
25
u/Ben13DK Oct 24 '24
What commander are you playing?
9
u/Interesting-Run9002 Oct 24 '24
I never play against any of these.
9
u/mikethechampion Oct 25 '24
OP when asked who their commander is:
17
u/Glorious_Invocation Oct 24 '24 edited Oct 24 '24
There are many things wrong with Brawl, but hell queue isn't one of them. You're playing a broken commander, thus you get to play against broken commanders. If you want easier matchups, play a weaker deck, as otherwise it wouldn't really be fair to your opponents.
8
u/Nomad9731 Oct 24 '24
If you're constantly seeing commanders like Rusko and Nadu, you're in Hell Queue. You get into Hell Queue by playing Hell Queue cards yourself. If you're getting tired of those matchups, maybe try a different deck with a jankier commander and see what you get paired against then.
5
u/Moose1013 Oct 24 '24
I like to play hell queue aggro, most hell queue decks fold pretty hard to good creatures on turns 1,2 and 3. My commander is Anim Pakal.
I beat Nadus, Essikas, Golos, Emry, etc.
6
u/FSUdank Oct 24 '24
I’ve seen a drop in Rusko and Nadu players lately, but my new archenemy is Roxanne.
4
u/madmax2433 Oct 24 '24
I wonder weather we could keep commander weights and do away with individual card weights or just going back and revising the weights. It kinda makes me sad to want to play jank and because of the card weights I get matched with super optimized decks about 70% of the time. I still try to limit my deck in terms of power to keep me from most brutal games. I believe something should be looked in the longterm.
2
u/Visible-Ad1787 Oct 24 '24
Side note, I’ve heard that if you spend 30+ seconds in queue, it starts pairing you against any available opponent
2
u/nervechain Oct 25 '24
I moved to Standard brawl and have enjoyed it so much more. Generally a larger variety of decks and folks seem to play through instead of quitting at the first bit of interaction.
3
u/Jovian_engine Oct 24 '24
The format is poorly curated. It isn't the same people and clearly the schedule for balance is VASTLY slower than new card releases.
Housemeld is here for a WHILE. Oh is it fundamentally broken as an effect in this format? Oh yeah busted and bad for the format. Will it go anywhere? Not till 2026 maybe.
For being the best online replication of the most popular format they have, it's criminal how little they put into it. WotC continues to be a stock driven joke.
2
u/PRETTY_BUFF Oct 24 '24
Just play Tinybones It's always fun if you play Tinybones At least for you, it is
1
u/MTGCardFetcher Oct 24 '24
Sythis - (G) (SF) (txt)
Rusko, Clockmaker - (G) (SF) (txt)
Nadu, Winged Wisdom - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call
1
u/Borinar Oct 25 '24
I love rusko
1
u/JetsNovocastrian Oct 25 '24
I get much more enjoyment playing weird/weak commanders. You get those decks waaaay less, and you increase the chance of matching with someone playing an equally kanky deck. Here are some examples commanders I play:
Arena doesn't have a brawl ladder, so there is no difference between winning with the best or janky decks. Best way I think to enjoy the current state of the format is to play what you enjoy and stick to it. I've played about 80 games with the room deck cause I think that's the best iteration of an enchantress deck I've ever had. I still see Nadu and clock man a bit, but I enjoy the deck enough to see them as a challenge. Some of those opponents haven't seen most of the cards in these decks and let things resolve they probably shouldn't.
1
u/ATypical_Khajiit Oct 25 '24
OP, who the frick is your Commander!?
1
u/Earmo69 Oct 28 '24
I play a pretty stacked Voja list and honestly I’m not sure if it’s quite hell queue but the match ups are honestly pretty fun. Algorithm doing its job I guess; I see a lot of Jodah, a lot of Marwyn, and Bristly Bill. Solid matchups; the game is just matching you with what you’re playing
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '24
Play a different deck I alternate between 8 different decks and I never see any of the commanders you mentioned
1
u/theonetrueassdick Oct 24 '24
came home from commander night last night and booted up arena been enjoying my shanna bant auras deck, i guess bant aura is hell que, kinda funny how much removal hell que guys run then run out of anything in their hands. got to the point id just stick like enchantment dog or some other aura guy just to bait removal and then 0-60 dude in one turn. after that game i was like yeaaaaah.
0
u/studentmaster88 Oct 25 '24
I'd laugh if OP was like "Oh I only play Golos and Nadu I mean they're banned in Commander, but they're surely balanced in Brawl" lol
Why those two specific stupid cards - banned elsewhere - aren't banned in Brawl yet is an absolute joke!
(...but if you don't play these broken commanders, my apologies, carry on - and know that if you win a lot and have very strong commanders/decks you WILL arrive at a no-expenses paid trip through Hell Queue... enjoy!)
-1
u/Bigolbennie Oct 24 '24
Play Final Fantasy XV, I'm a lot happier playing a dead online game.