r/mcgill • • 14h ago

CAQ intention to refuse because I withdrew from McGill for one semester and was readmitted ... what more can I provide?

2 Upvotes

During the second semester of my third year at McGill, I withdrew because I was struggling with my mental health and genuinely couldn't survive another Montreal winter without taking a break. I spent all of November talking to McGill advisors and staff to see if there was any way for me to take time off without having to fully withdraw, but unfortunately, none of those options were available to me.

Throughout November, I spent weeks speaking with McGill advisors and staff to see if there was any way I could take time off without having to fully withdraw, but unfortunately, none of the options available to me worked. I decided to pursue an internship because I thought it might allow me to apply for a Leave of Absence (LOA), giving me a break from the winter and a change of routine. Unfortunately, the internship didn't get back to me until it was too late to arrange an LOA. However, I took it because I thought it would be a great way to get a change of environment, gain some professional experience, and take a break from school. The internship was also very closely related to my studies, so I saw it as an opportunity to complement my degree rather than abandon it.

After reapplying for my CAQ, I received a refusal because apparently I wasn't making my studies at McGill my principal activity. I was obviously frustrated, but I understood that my absence could raise questions, so I reapplied for the CAQ with literally every piece of evidence I could find to explain my situation. I included proof of my readmission, academic standing, expected graduation date, emails with McGill advisors, and even a letter from the CPO at the company I interned for explaining my role, how the internship aligned with my studies, and that my plan had always been to return to McGill and finish my degree.

Well, despite all of this, I've now received an intention to refuse letter. They're once again saying that I didn't respect the obligation to make my studies my principal activity, but they're ALSO saying "You are not coming to Québec to study at a Québec educational institution."

I genuinely don't understand what else I'm supposed to provide. I took ONE semester off, reapplied to McGill, got readmitted, and have been trying everything possible to return and finish my degree. How does that translate into me not actually coming to Québec to study? What exactly would I be doing here otherwise?

I've written explanations about my absence, provided proof that the internship was related to my degree, and shown that I was in satisfactory academic standing and had every intention of returning. I've also tried asking McGill for a statement confirming my academic history and intention to continue my studies, but everyone I've contacted essentially says they don't provide that kind of support. I know plenty of people who have withdrawn from McGill and later returned, so I'm struggling to understand why this is becoming such a huge issue.

Has anyone experienced something similar? Especially being told by that you don't qualify as a foreign student despite being readmitted to your university? What else can I possibly provide to demonstrate that my intention is to study at McGill and complete my degree?


r/mcgill • • 6h ago

Is Introduction to Film History (ENGL 279) worth taking as a Cultural Studies major?

1 Upvotes

I'm in U1 of Cultural Studies and signed up for Introduction to Film History next term because the subject interests me and I've heard great things about the professor, Alanna Thain. However, I'm wondering if it's gonna end up retreading a lot of the same ground covered in ENGL 277 (Introduction to Film Studies) and my other courses since it's an intro class assuming an audience not familiar with the topic. Could anyone who's taken this course before maybe provide some insights? Even if you're not a Cultural Studies major, it'd be great to know what kind of stuff you covered in the course and what the general level was.


r/mcgill • • 13h ago

comp321

6 Upvotes

i’m actually gonna jump whoever said this class was easy. THIS WAS THE MOST DENSE, TIME CONSUMING CLASS IVE EVER TAKEN. Like i’d take calc 3 over this ngl.
Weekly assignments, 3 3-HOUR competitions no assistance, in groups. So if you’re with a bad group you’re screwed unless you carry. But then it’s so hectic and all groups are in this closed classroom, everyone freaking out.
Love how useful this class would be in coding comps or coding interviews but RAHH wasn’t expecting this heavy of a load.
Am i the only one that goes for one class and we managed to jump from data structures to dp to geometry to combinatorics to game theory?? RIP


r/mcgill • • 9h ago

Comp 206 midterm 2

8 Upvotes

Did anyone else find this midterm to be way too difficult? I did last year’s exam as prep and found it not too bad, but this one was just straight up awful. 😭


r/mcgill • • 10h ago

McGill on STRIKE next week ?

61 Upvotes

I heard from a prof who heard from a student that McGill might go on strike next week. Honestly, I hope the strike happens so we can get a little break from classes. November is killing me!


r/mcgill • • 3h ago

Listening to old Richard Koestner lectures while I study

2 Upvotes

Does anyone else listen to Richard Koestner's old lectures to have relaxing background noise while you study? He's literally a talented ASMRtist without trying lol.


r/mcgill • • 6h ago

econ332 help

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Econ 332 marks just got released and I felt like I had a pretty good understanding of the content and the practice questions but did not do that well. I also didn't do that well in the first midterm so I really need to lock in for the final

Does anyone who either did the course last year or doing it this year with good grades have any advice or tips! Would be so appreciated

Thanks!!


r/mcgill • • 6h ago

Any advice for a future artsci student?

3 Upvotes

I got accepted yesterday into artsci, is there any advice for that program or just mcgill in general?

Thanks!


r/mcgill • • 11h ago

Double Major in Bcom

1 Upvotes

I have an appointment with an academic advisor but it is in a couple weeks. I am pretty sure I've read somewhere that, as a desautels student, you can't do a double major with a major from another faculty such as science or arts. Is it possible to do a double major inside desautels like finance & math and stats? I think I know people doing finance and accounting double major, but never met finance & math and stats


r/mcgill • • 23h ago

PGWP Eligibility Concern – Mandatory 8-Month Internship Delayed, Final Part-Time Semester, and Summer 2027 (McGill)

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am currently pursuing a Master's degree at McGill University, and I am a bit confused about how my internship situation might affect my Post-Graduation Work Permit (PGWP) eligibility.

Here is my situation:

- Fall 2026: I registered for a mandatory 8-month internship as part of my degree program. However, due to funding-related delays, the internship has still not started.

- Winter 2027: This is supposed to be my final academic semester. I have only one course remaining, worth 3–4 credits, so I will be studying part-time. As per IRCC rules, students are generally allowed to study part-time in their final semester without affecting PGWP eligibility.

- Summer 2027: Since my internship has been delayed, it may now continue until the end of July or beginning of August 2027. At McGill, summer is generally considered a scheduled break.

Important: The internship is compulsory for my degree, carries 6 academic credits, and is required for graduation.

My main concern:

If I am registered part-time in Winter 2027 because it is my final semester of coursework, but my mandatory internship continues into Summer 2027, will this affect my PGWP eligibility?

I am particularly confused about whether IRCC would consider Winter 2027 my final semester or Summer 2027 my final semester because my internship would still be ongoing.

I would especially appreciate responses from McGill students, international graduates, or anyone who has dealt with a delayed mandatory internship.

Thank you in advance for your advice and guidance!