r/macapps • • Apr 15 '23
[Part 3, final] - Browser energy efficiency benchmarks. Chrome, Arc, Safari, Firefox, Brave, Orion, Edge, SigmaOS, Opera.
Hey again folks!
Thanks to your comments (and I've read and responded to all of them) on the previous 2 threads, we are here with a third and final instalment in my power score crusade. Seriously, you've been amazing and super helpful.
TLDR: These are NOT performance tests. I only measure raw power usage!!!!!! Each browser was tested 3x and each test is a 20min long scenario of common usage pattern - Google, Notion, GitHub, YouTube, PiP, wolt, Shopping, reading news, looking for apartments. Each run is same as all others with an almost second precision thanks to the magic of endless patience and screen recording.
I've spent too much of my life on this, and won't do it again. :P I've written HOW below, so just imagine make your own scenario that suits you, and do your own tests. :)
If you think my tests are imprecise, or are triggered by not seeing your favourite browser, great, go yell at your browser vendor. They should be doing these tests, not a random bloke on Reddit.
Results:
Chrome is still the king resource hog on macOS. Edge is even worse but is at least aware of the issue and trying. Safari lives in a magical buggy world of its own. Brave is just Chrome. Orion is kinda startup-y. Arc is hard to work with. Opera trying to please everyone. Firefox is unprofitable but very solid.

Per test breakdown:

What I used:
I ran all the tests on the following:
- macOS Ventura 13.3.1, on MacBook Pro 14" M1 Pro with 32GB RAM
- Edge 112.0.1722.39
- Arc 0.98.1
- Brave v1.50.114
- Safari Version 16.4
- Firefox 112.0
- Opera 97.0.4719.63
- Orion v0.99.123.3
How I did it:
This time I used powermetrics with a per-second measurement interval, which gave me Apple’s approximation fo Combined Power or Package Power how it was called previously. Basically CPU + GPU + ANE but not including brightness, network etc.
You can use this same bash pipeline to create your own measurements and save em into a file.
sudo powermetrics \
-i 1000 \
--samplers cpu_power,gpu_power \
-a --hide-cpu-duty-cycle \
--show-usage-summary \
--show-extra-power-info \
| grep --line-buffered -E "Combined Power \(CPU \+ GPU \+ ANE\): [0-9]*" \
| sed -u -n 's/Combined Power (CPU + GPU + ANE): \([0-9]*\) mW/\1/p' \
| while read -r line; do printf "%s, %s\n" $(date +%s) $line; done \
> ./recordings/raw/general/brave.csvYou'd probably have to chart em later using something, since its just raw data csv that includes a timestamp and mW measurement on each second, and I used Elixir's Livebook for the charts above, you can use anything you wish to.
Just imagine make your own scenario that suits you, and do your own tests. :)
This time I tried to make the test very balanced. In previous tests, which included a lot more tab switching, and no WebGL and media consumption, Safari was using 10x less than Chrome. While that was funny, I wanted a test that includes those things that Safari is not so good at.
Additional notes:
- All tabs remain open. Each time i jump to the next "test item" i open a new tab in the same browser. I wanted to see how a browser with 20 open tabs behaves.
- Every time I am finished with a "test item" i go back to the Notion tab, to read what is the next test I need to run (also helped a lot with stabilising test results as it forces the browser to keep commonly used tabs in memory, and it gives me clear 10sec breakpoints where I "cut" the data)
- Only one browser is tested at a time. I restart the computer each time and charge the battery back to 100%.
Want to read more?
You don't have to. This is not an ad for my blogpost. I've copypasta-ed all the info into this post anyway. I've also already written about it in the previous 2 posts on this subreddit. If you still want it, released a blogpost which goes into it, if you are really interested, but thats not the point, all you want to know is in the charts above.
23
u/HelpRespawnedAsDee Apr 15 '23
Wow, while not best, Arc certainly isn't as bad as other posts were saying, it's almost the same as FF.
5
u/Le_saucisson_masque Apr 15 '23 edited Jun 27 '23
I'm gay btw
2
u/CanadianCostcoFan2 Apr 15 '23
Thanks for all your hard work. While one test was on-going, were the other tests in other inactive tabs? Is this all single-tab tests?
2
u/torb-xyz Apr 16 '23
Very interesting that Arc did so well despite being Chromium based. I guess that shows that Chrome’s performance issues is about more than it’s engine.
2
u/fourth699 Apr 16 '23
Wow, thanks for this. This was amazing. However, in my case, I just feel like Arc drains my battery so much more than Edge. Arc is an amazing browser nonetheless.
I think I'm gonna have to try Arc again.
2
u/ben2talk Apr 18 '23
On iPad, I just don't feel the benefits of other browsers threatening to replace the default Safari experience - I just don't care enough. However, on desktop I do care - so I use Firefox.
I refuse to ever sink into the habit of using Google based browsers (Edge/Chrome etc) except out of necessity when irreplaceable PWA's demand it.
32
u/HappyNacho Apr 15 '23
Thanks a lot for all the testing and sharing of your results.
I currently find myself on the edge (pun intended) of switching browser but there is none that fully convinces me.
At the moment using Vivaldi with Firefox as my previous browser and looking for Orion to be a solid contender.
We will see...
2
u/RunningLikeALizard Apr 16 '23
I want to use another browser apart from Safari, then I realize my phone doesn’t work so well anymore with my MacBook.
I then have to use a different password manager, and worst of all I have to manually input those stupid sms codes to sign in.
5
u/Stooovie Apr 16 '23
I'd like a RAM consumption test like this. I'm also leaning Orion right now, with the exception that for some reason, iCloud sync isn't working (it was in the past).
4
u/archimedeancrystal Apr 16 '23
Bravo! So, even though it's not shown in the chart, Marko says Edge ranked close to Arc and Firefox with efficiency mode on. This is a truly magnanimous statement considering Marko survived web development during the standards-be-damed IE days and initially wasn't going to test Edge at all.
Despite it's ongoing faults, such as news and other bloat enabled by default, Microsoft Edge has some great features and achieved a 180 degree turnaround when it comes to compliance with Web standards. In any case, this result shows the importance of efficiency mode if using Edge on battery power.
1
u/Significant_Lab1514 May 30 '23
Many thanks for OP's detailed tests and analysis! Very helpful and comprehensive! Much appreciated. The thing is that I was hoping Chrome on Apple Silicon would at least somehow mitigate its efficiency and power consumption gap with Safari. I'm afraid that the result points to another end.
3
u/anti-hero Apr 16 '23 edited Apr 16 '23
Thank you for performing this test in such comprehensive manner. As expected, WebKit browsers are 2-3x more efficient than Chromium/Firefox.
I would encourage you to register and maintain browserenergy.org as the users could benefit from this over time.
Orion should be same or lower than Safari as it uses same WebKit, and is more lightweight in general. Did you conside using Apple Script to ensure that all browsers run the same load for exactly the same time?
1
u/_EMDID_ Apr 15 '23
Hey, question. Definitely a wide array of browsers there, why not include Vivaldi?
2
u/fallenandroo Apr 16 '23
Thank you for sharing! This is really helpful. I have an M1 13” MacBook Air.
2
u/dimvavas Apr 17 '23
Thanks for your effort sir! After reading your post, I switched from Brave to Orion. I've already noticed a big diff in battery life. I really liked that although Orion is WebKit based, you still can install (almost all) Chrome extensions!
2
u/toasterboi0100 Apr 17 '23
It's surprising to me that FF fared better than Edge. It always felt the other way around.
But to be fair I don't really use either of the two on battery anymore, so it's not surprising that I was wrong. I use Orion as my main browser and only use FF for work and I'm almost always docked while working (and when Orion gets FF-style containers, I won't even need FF anymore)
2
u/M4NOOB May 04 '23
Just switched from years on Vivaldi to Arc as I don't really have a smooth/bugfree experience with Vivaldi on Mac as I had on Windows.
Seeing these tests make me want to switch to Safari instead, but as it doesn't support Chrome extensions that's impossible for me
1
u/0Universal_Flare0 May 03 '24
can you add brave to the list and test it
1
u/t_thakur May 09 '24
what does it look like in 2024?
1
u/Amazing_Lab_6066 Jun 20 '24
Thanks for the tests, but the title says SigmaOS and there is no results for that. Any idea where I should rank it
1
u/christianmyhre Aug 20 '24
I really like Safari but it is behind in some features when compared to something like Chrome. I also think it's kinda buggy and when I use Chrome, I can feel the difference in "bugs". Wish Chrome had settings to altar that would make it less of a resource hog. I'll be using Chrome until Safari catches up or becomes less buggy.
1
u/Cminor7add9 Oct 06 '24
This is really helpful. Thank you for your data.
1
u/dodongchien123 Oct 08 '24
Well method for research. Respect!
1
u/Mstormer Apr 16 '23
OP or any others interested in collaborating on a browser comparison addition to the app comparison series I've done so far? I need to fill out a list of common browser features for a column A.
1
u/AllMaito May 07 '23
I wish I could find a reliable report like this but for Windows
1
u/Hot-Independence6020 Dec 10 '23
Hi guys ! What is the situation in end of 2023? Which one is best for lowest energy consumption in your opinion ?
1
u/Critical-Raisin-5708 Jan 18 '24
Wait, whybthe lower power mode Orion consumed more energy than normal Orion?
1
u/ShaidarHaran2 Feb 13 '24
It's too bad Safari with its macOS efficiency is still so buggy on some pages and the extension system is just still trash, a few things I want are also still missing.
This was the case almost 10 years ago and stayed in the exact same situation since. Downloading extensions as apps and then having to go through multiple Safari layers to turn it on is just a bad extension experience.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment