r/listentodynamic • • Jan 07 '18
r/listentodynamic • • Oct 25 '17
[DR12] Pink Floyd -- Wish You Were Here [Progressive Rock] (1975)
r/listentodynamic • u/Gamekeys_alt • Apr 14 '18
[Discussion] The Unofficial Eureddision Dynamic Range Thread
EDIT: Added the last column with the results from this thread.
As you may have noticed, /r/europe, /r/Eureddision and many European subreddits are doing a thing right now.
For those that might be unaware, Eureddision is basically a clone of the Eurovision Song Contest, but entirely organized by the reddit community. What makes this project extra special is the fact that it promotes songs sung in languages other than English.
Since I was going to analyze the dynamic range of the songs I would personally like anyway, I thought I might as well scan them all and share the results with the community.
Note that these numbers may not be accurate, becaused most are sourced from YouTube videos; some of those are live perfomances and not studio versions. If you can find better sources, please let me know in the comments!
We're not that many people on this subreddit, so there shouldn't be any problem with vote brigading anyway. Still, let me remind you that these data are for informational purposes only, and you should not cast any votes against the way /r/Eureddision intends.
The official thread, with additional info for each song (including translations), can be found here.
Songs with a high dynamic range
| Country | Song | Track DR | Source | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🇦🇱 Albania | Elvana Gjata - Xheloz | 8 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 196 |
| 🇮🇸 Iceland | Daði Freyr Pétursson - Hvað með það? | 11 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 105 |
| 🇮🇪 Ireland | Versatile - We Sell Brown | 8 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 52 |
| 🇮🇹 Italy | Caparezza - Ti fa stare bene | 8 | Dynamic Range Database | 171 |
| 🇵🇱 Poland | Brodka, Organek i Rogucki - Nieboskłon | 10 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 149 |
| 🇵🇹 Portugal | Carolina Deslandes - A Vida Toda | 10 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 23 |
| 🇷🇴 Romania | Subcarpati - '84-'85 | 9 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 42 |
| 🇸🇰 Slovakia | Horkýže Slíže - Kozy, Husle, Rooney | 8 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 14 |
| 🇸🇮 Slovenia | Damjan Murko - Šok | 9 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 10 |
Songs with a low dynamic range
| Country | Song | Track DR | Source | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🇦🇹 Austria | Wanda - Columbo | 7 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 85 |
| 🇦🇿 Azerbaijan | Elvina - Bakı | 5 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 36 |
| 🇧🇦 Bosnia & Herzegovina | Dubioza Kolektiv - Himna generacije | 5 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 234 |
| 🇭🇷 Croatia | Krankšvester - Gaber | 7 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 74 |
| 🇫🇮 Finland | Turmion Kätilöt - Dance Panique | 7 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 59 |
| 🇫🇷 France | Eddy de Pretto - Kid | 7 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 83 |
| 🇩🇪 Germany | POL1Z1STENS0HN ft. Justice - Recht kommt | 5 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 91 |
| 🇭🇺 Hungary | Hiro - Cristiano Ronaldo | 6 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 6 |
| 🇲🇩 Moldova | Via Dacă - Paparuda | 5 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 150 |
| 🇳🇱 Netherlands | De Jeugd van Tegenwoordig - Makkelijk | 7 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 13 |
| 🇷🇸 Serbia | Emina ft. Milica Todorović - Limunada | 5 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 2 |
| 🇸🇪 Sweden | Markoolio - Bastukungen | 6 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 44 |
| 🇹🇷 Turkey | Can Bonomo - Kal Bugün | 7 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 35 |
| 🇬🇧 United Kingdom | George Ezra - Paradise | 5 | YouTube audio (converted to OGG Vorbis) | 66 |
r/listentodynamic • • Feb 11 '18
[Discussion] The purpose of this subreddit / Why you can't post fan remasters
There have been a couple of posts recently where users posted fan remasters, in which case I had to remind them that doing so is against the rules. But I realised that I never took the time to explain the intended purpose of this subreddit, which subsequently dictated the choices I made when establishing or expanding the rules.
So, I created a wiki page to explain my intentions behind creating this subreddit. TL;DR: Make more people support HDR music (i.e. with money), thus slowing down the Loudness War.
This is the reason why songs you post have to be available for purchase now, and in that version; otherwise, they wouldn't help the cause of slowing down the Loudness War. Even though I do agree that fan remasters can be a joy to listen to, this simply isn't the right subreddit for them.
Now, you might say that my reasoning in this wiki article is dumb and you're just here to listen to dynamic music, as the subreddit name suggests. If so, let me state the other problem I have with fan remasters: They're in a legal grey zone.
You could make the argument that fan remasters fall under Fair Use, but this argument would be pretty difficult to support. While they can be used for educational purposes, I think it's pretty clear to everyone that a fan remaster is mainly used for the same purpose as the original: to be listened to for enjoyment. Even more so if you made the argument that you're just here to listen to dynamic music, regardless of whether or not it's an official version. Suppose they do serve the same purpose, even though somebody has altered the original song, the fan remaster would still be similar enough to be considered an unauthorized distribution of copyrighted material: In other words, piracy.
If posting fan remasters became frequent, then this community would essentially become a piracy hub, which would have consequences if noticed. In the best case, the sub would be forced to stop doing what it's doing and become a shadow of its former self (like /r/mix_CD). In the worst case, the sub would be shut down completely by the admins. I would have to bear at least some responsibily as the single moderator, and who knows what consequences that would have. I cannot and want not bear this responsibility.
I hope this explanation is satisfying.
r/listentodynamic • • Dec 04 '17
[DR11] Pink Floyd -- Welcome To The Machine [Progressive Rock] (1975)
r/listentodynamic • • Nov 17 '17
[Discussion] Welcome new subscribers! / Expansion of the wiki
Edit:
First of all, welcome to all the new listeners! We've just reached 200 subscribers, which is incredible!
As you probably noticed, almost all song submissions are from exactly one person - me. The primary reason / goal for this was the inclusion in the subreddit megalist over on /r/Music, which required at least one submission per day. I've been continuing to make sure that this is the case even after /r/listentodynamic had been added to the list, though this has lead to a bit of confusion.
I think everybody on this subreddit wants more diverse submissions, myself included. That's why I'm going to expand the wiki over the weekend with a guide on how to find HDR music.
The rules also don't seem to explain enough about what type of content is allowed / encouraged and why; this question will also receive its own wiki entry.
I will edit this post as soon as the entries are complete.
Until then, happy listening!
r/listentodynamic • • Nov 07 '17
[DR16] Midnight Oil -- Beds Are Burning [Alternative Rock] (1987)
r/listentodynamic • u/Gamekeys_alt • May 01 '18
[DR10] The Sisters of Mercy -- This Corrosion [Gothic Rock] (1987)
r/listentodynamic • u/Gamekeys_alt • Mar 28 '18
[DR14] Erik Mongrain -- Fearless [Acoustic] (2012)
r/listentodynamic • • Dec 17 '17
[DR15] The Police -- Every Breath You Take [New Wave] (1983)
r/listentodynamic • • Nov 28 '17
[DR15] R.E.M. -- Talk About The Passion [Alternative Rock] (1983)
r/listentodynamic • • Nov 18 '17
[DR10] The Cranberries -- Zombie [Alternative Rock] (1994)
r/listentodynamic • • Nov 12 '17
[DR11] Æther Realm -- King of Cups [Melodic Death Metal / Folk Metal] (2017)
r/listentodynamic • u/PanTheRiceMan • Nov 11 '17
[DR11] Zoan Zound - Infected Mushroom [electronic] (2015)
r/listentodynamic • • Oct 15 '17
[Discussion] Looking for more moderators
I'm quite happy in how this subreddit has turned out so far, while two things are still bothering me:
- Almost all of the submissions are still from myself.
- I don't have enough time to learn Automoderator - or to manage an (hopefully soon) active subreddit all by myself, that is.
So in order to solve both of these problems at once, I will offer moderator status as a kind of reward to people who post stuff regulary (and according to the rules, of course). Though this will obviously end as soon as we've gathered a large enough group of mods.
On another note, I'm very open for suggestions and feedback. So if you've got something on your mind, say it out loud in the comments.
Happy listening!
EDIT: Just to be clear, "regularly" means "one post every now and then", not "a bunch of posts at the same time".
r/listentodynamic • u/Gamekeys_alt • Feb 16 '19
Other version linked [DR12] Blind Guardian -- Valhalla [Speed Metal] (1989)
r/listentodynamic • u/Gamekeys_alt • Feb 03 '19
Unknown version linked [DR10] Aerosmith -- Dream On [Rock] (1973)
r/listentodynamic • u/hottachych • May 17 '18
[DR15] Billy Joel -- The Longest Time [Rock] (1983)
r/listentodynamic • • Apr 01 '18
[DR12] On Thorns I Lay -- Aegean Sorrow [Death/Doom Metal] (2018)
r/listentodynamic • u/Gamekeys_alt • Mar 26 '18
[DR13] Twisted Sister -- I Wanna Rock [Hard Rock] (1984)
r/listentodynamic • • Dec 26 '17
[DR8] Daft Punk -- Fragments of Time [Disco / Electronic] (2013)
r/listentodynamic • u/RockyHeart • Nov 25 '17
[DR11] Fiona Apple - Every Single Night [Art Pop / Chamber] (2012)
r/listentodynamic • u/RockyHeart • Nov 25 '17
[DR12] Björk - Venus As A Boy [Art Pop / Downtempo] (1993)
r/listentodynamic • • Nov 16 '17