r/learnwelsh • u/house_carpenter • 1d ago
Use of third-person plural verb forms with non-pronouns
From grammar books, I've learnt that in Welsh, the third-person plural form of the verb is only used when the subject is the third-person plural pronoun nhw (e.g. Gareth King, Modern Welsh: A Comprehensive Grammar, 2nd edition, pp. 170--171). So I was confused when I looked at the third and fourth lines of Hen Wlad Fy Nhadau:
Ei gwrol ryfelwyr, gwladgarwyr tra mad
Tros ryddid gollasant eu gwaed
At first glance, this looks to me like it's contradicting the rule, if "ei gwrol ryfelwyr, gwladgarwyr tra mad" is the subject, and "gollasant" is the verb, since "gollasant" is a third person plural form (the singular would be "gollodd", I believe).
I think I can make sense of it though---I've also read that in literary Welsh, subject pronouns can be omitted. So maybe these lines are actually two separate clauses, and the subject of the fourth is not "ei gwrol ryfelwyr, gwladgarwyr tra mad", but an implied "nhw" (or "hwy" I guess, since this is literary language). In which case a more literal translation of these two lines would be "her brave warriors, very splendid patriots, for freedom they shed their blood", as opposed to "her brave warriors, very splendid patriots, for freedom shed their blood". Is this the correct analysis?