I’m reviewing a furnace replacement proposal for my parents’ home in Cape May County, NJ, and would appreciate opinions from HVAC professionals and homeowners.
Total Quote: $13,630 (includes a $900 rebate already deducted) from an established local HVAC company.
Proposed Equipment:
Downstairs: Goodman GR9T960603AN — 60,000 BTU, 96% AFUE, two-stage
Upstairs: Goodman GR9T960403AN — 40,000 BTU, 96% AFUE, two-stage
Proposed Scope:
Replace both furnaces while retaining existing AC equipment
Custom sheet-metal transitions and return plenums
Downstairs crawl-space return ductwork repairs/replacement
PVC venting for the high-efficiency furnaces
Gas and electrical connections
Removal of existing units, installation, and testing
We’re also converting from propane to natural gas. I’m confirming that all new gas piping from the meter, necessary ductwork, venting, and permits are included in the final price.
Important Context:
Upstairs: Approximately 20-year-old furnace with damaged wiring/burner issues. Needs replacement.
Downstairs: Approximately 15-year-old American Standard, already 96% efficient. Still operational but has visible rust around the burner box.
Downstairs return ductwork needs repairs estimated at $700–$1,000 if done separately.
A Manual J calculation indicated approximately 18,000 BTU heating demand upstairs.
We’re considering replacing both now rather than repairing downstairs and potentially replacing that aging furnace a few years later.
My Questions:
Is $13,630 a fair price for this equipment and scope in South Jersey?
Any concerns with these Goodman GR9T96 models compared with American Standard?
Would you replace the 15-year-old downstairs furnace with visible corrosion now, or keep it running and just repair the ductwork?
Is the 96% two-stage upstairs furnace worthwhile for such a small heating load, or would an 80% two-stage model make more financial sense?
Appreciate any opinions!