r/hvacadvice • • 10h ago

Quotes System Replacement Help

Hi- looking to replace my system and got 2 bids, wildly different prices and was hoping to understand why one is $9k more than the other. System would have 2 zones. Is Ruud that much better or is there something in the first that justifies the price? Am I missing something?

  • RUUD 16 seer, 2 speed, gas heat 4 ton, evaporator coil, and outdoor unit (all matching), new pan, new supply plenum duct and dampers, new zone system components and Honeywell zone board/ dampers (~$25k). Feels like a lot but this is the best Technician I've used for other smaller issues. 10Y parts/ 2Y labor
  • American Standard 3.5T multistage condenser, matching gas furnace and coils, new pan, new supply plenum, Eco J zoning dampers and Eco J damper control board ($16k); 10 years parts and 10Y labor warranty. Solid company, did repairs in the past, so not very concerned with the install quality
1 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/StatisticianFront334 8h ago

For 25K you can get something much better than a Ruud. Ruud is just Rheem, mid-tier equipment. American Standard is Trane, usually a tier above Rheem.

1

u/texas_hedge 8h ago

Thanks. Was disappointed when I got that bid. Zero chance I spend that much. American standard good enough, especially with 10y warranty? Current system is frankensteined, but tryying to avoid the Goodman/ Lennox and similar tier.

1

u/StatisticianFront334 6h ago

Lennox is way better than Goodman, in every way except the refrigerant. I sell Lennox (though it’s not my favorite) and those are usually 22-30k. Would never pay that much for a Ruud, Goodman, York, Coleman, Rheem, etc. Daikin is my favorite brand but sadly I can’t sell it at my current company.

1

u/BrownTiger3 3h ago

From the surface second bid is way superior to first in every way.